Evan & Tiki

Steve Cohen shut the door on the idea of a New York Mets captain, but comments from Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto about last year’s clubhouse raise even bigger questions. Is there truly no need for a captain… or is it exactly what this team lacks?

Lindor insists the clubhouse was united and focused on winning, while Soto’s blunt remarks about “drama” suggest something very different may have been happening behind the scenes. From chemistry questions to roster turnover to lingering rumors about tension, the conversation dives into what really went wrong and whether it actually mattered on the field.

Was the Mets’ disappointing season about pitching and performance… or something deeper inside the room?

As spring training opens, Mets owner Steve Cohen delivers a candid, revealing message about the 2026 season and his growing frustration with the franchise’s long World Series drought. He says the vibe around this year’s team feels different, more optimistic, more energized, despite major departures like Pete Alonso and Edwin Díaz. But should fans buy it?

We break down Cohen’s most important comments, including his admission that missing the playoffs again would be unacceptable, why he believes sustained contention matters more than one magical run, and whether ownership truly understands what fans are feeling.

Plus, Cohen drops a bombshell on team leadership: as long as he owns the Mets, there will be NO team captain. Is that a smart clubhouse strategy or a missed opportunity for identity and accountability?

From roster turnover and offseason anxiety to the realities of building a championship team in today’s MLB, this conversation gets to the heart of where the Mets stand and where they must go next.

Is this finally the year the Mets become a perennial powerhouse… or are fans being asked to stay patient yet again?

The NBA tried something completely different… and it might have saved All-Star Weekend. From the early start time designed for a global audience to the fast, tournament-style format that turned every possession into crunch time, this year’s game delivered something fans haven’t felt in years: real competition.

But not everything landed. Why did the championship game fall flat? Did splitting Team USA into “young” and “old” backfire? And why did some stars seem way more invested than others?

The conversation then shifts to the bigger picture. Commissioner Adam Silver is openly searching for ways to eliminate tanking, and the proposed solutions range from intriguing to absolutely insane. A postseason tournament for lottery teams? Guaranteeing playoff spots AND top picks? Or blowing up the entire system by abolishing the draft altogether?

Plus, the crew reacts to LeBron’s comments on the USA vs. World format, debates whether All-Star Games are really just for kids now, and explores why fans crave entertainment in the moment but quickly forget the results.

If you care about where the NBA is heading, this one’s packed with ideas, arguments, and a few takes that could reshape the future of pro sports.

Evan & Tiki discuss the possibility of Derek Carr as the Jets’ next quarterback. Plus, ranking the top five veteran QB choices (14:09); Carton trolls Patriots fans saying the Jets are better run (33:09); Boomer asks ChatGPT about the Jets QB situation (49:44) and discusses with Gio who the Jets best QB options are (59:04); Carton on his plan for the Jets (1:05:36).

This week's Knicks highlights include praising the team's dismantling of the Sixers to enter the All-Star break on a high note. Plus, Evan and Tiki compare the Mike Brown Knicks to last year's group under Tom Thibodeau, and marvel at the fanbase invading Philadelphia for a road game.

Francisco Lindor is heading for hand surgery, and the Evan and Tiki crew debate if the star shortstop can be ready for Opening Day. Plus, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle wonder how long it will take Lindor to get his power stroke back, and more reactions to Juan Soto moving to left field.

Derek Carr walks back Jet hops, NBA All Star Weekend is here, Valentine's Day surprise from Tiki, and much more

The Derek Carr rumor cycle takes a hard turn as new comments force Evan to rethink everything he thought he heard in December. Is Carr actually open to coming back, or is he quietly ruling the Jets out unless they magically become contenders overnight? The guys break down what Carr really means by “the perfect situation,” which teams actually fit that description, and why the Jets may already be on the outside looking in.

The quarterback discussion spirals into full Jets chaos, from Malik Willis to Kyler Murray, Tua, Cousins, Rodgers rumors, draft options, and the reality that there is no clean answer. Evan announces an upcoming Jets QB Big Board, callers argue over upside vs. desperation, and the debate over winning now versus setting up 2027 heats up.

Plus, Tom Brady somehow narrates a 49ers documentary and still finds a way to take a cheap shot at Jets fans, sparking a classic Evan rant. The hour also introduces the idea of a weekly “worst take of the week” segment, with more than a few WFAN personalities already lobbying their case.

The Knicks made a move that barely made a ripple, but it could matter way more than people realize, and we explain why. Plus, a brand-new weekly segment launches at 11:30am: “Are You Kidding Me?” where we crown the dumbest sports opinion from the station, including some absolutely unhinged nominees.

Then we pivot to the NFL’s plan to kick off Week 1 with Rams vs. 49ers in Australia and possibly start the season on a Wednesday or Thursday, and what that does to the tradition of the defending champ opening the year. We also get into the Jets debate: is it better to tank for a top pick or build a real roster even if it lands you in draft purgatory?

Featuring caller heat, host arguments, and a full “who had the worst take” showdown.

Evan and Tiki react to the Knicks' latest roster addition, Jeremy Sochan. After being waived by the Spurs, is the young defensive agitator the perfect "dog" for the Knicks' stretch run? The guys also settle a bet regarding Knicks fans taking over Philly with the "Jose" chant for Jose Alvarado.

Then, concern grows in Yankees camp as Cam Schlittler is scratched from throwing off a mound due to back tightness. Evan and Tiki debate if the young right-hander will make the Opening Day roster and if fans would sign up for a guaranteed 94-win season.

Plus:

A shocking email from a Giants fan who defected to the Jets.

Shaun Morash’s "Cinco de Lunch Show": The Top 5 Most Useless Valentine's Day Gestures.

Presidential trivia ahead of the long weekend.