Evan & Tiki

The 4th and final hour of Evan & Tiki brings classic WFAN chaos, sports debates, and plenty of laughs. The show opens with reaction to Nick Castellanos being released by the Philadelphia Phillies and whether he makes any sense for the New York Mets. The guys break down why signing him would directly impact Mark Vientos, and whether Mets fans should trust the young slugger or chase a revenge storyline against Philly.

The guys try to wrap their heads around the NBA All Star Game’s new format and quickly realize it is way more confusing than expected. Team World vs USA Stars vs USA Stripes, short games, round robin rules, and age based rosters all get debated. They question whether splitting Team USA actually makes sense, why some players feel old already, and whether fake allegiances can create real intensity.

Kevin Durant’s comments about effort spark a bigger discussion about whether this year’s game might actually matter, especially with international stars being called out. Add in the NBA’s return to NBC, mixed feelings on the dunk and three point contests, and a classic Friday segment of Idiots With Idioms, and the conversation goes everywhere in the best possible way.

Nick Castellanos is suddenly available, and some Mets fans are intrigued by the idea of adding a proven bat on the cheap, especially one who might terrorize the Phillies out of spite. But does that actually make sense for this roster? The guys break down why Castellanos’ declining offense, brutal defense, and age raise real concerns, and why any move for him would directly eat into Mark Vientos’ at bats. It comes down to a simple question: do you believe in Vientos enough to give him a clean shot, or are you ready to pull the plug? Plus, why signing players out of fear of division rivals is a dangerous way to build a team.

It’s a Valentine’s Day edition of Cinco De Luncho, and the gloves are off. The guys count down the top five most useless Valentine’s Day gestures, from sending nudes and buying chocolates to flowers that die, corny Instagram posts, and overpriced prix fixe dinners that rush you out the door. Along the way, the list completely derails into classic show chaos with real relationship confessions, unsolicited advice, and stories that probably should not have been told on the air. Equal parts comedy, honesty, and bad ideas you should absolutely avoid.

Spring training brings the kind of Yankees update that always raises eyebrows as Cam Schlittler is pulled off the mound with back tightness. The guys break down why any pitching issue, even a “no big deal” one, feels different than it would for a position player, especially with the rotation already shorthanded. Is this something that simply pushes Schlittler back a turn or two, or a warning sign that keeps him off the Opening Day roster entirely? Plus, a bigger discussion on how minor setbacks for young pitchers can quietly snowball once the calendar starts moving.

A brand new weekly segment is born: “Are You Kidding Me?” where the show rounds up the dumbest sports opinions from around the station and crowns a winner. The inaugural list comes in hot.

It starts with Boomer’s take on an Olympic athlete feeling conflicted about representing Team USA, and a bigger debate about whether fans can say “keep politics out of sports” while still celebrating icons like Muhammad Ali.

From there it gets even more ridiculous: Keith McPherson going after Luke Weaver for showing up to Mets camp with Yankees gear, Tommy’s “Aaron Judge is the best right fielder in New York sports” line, and Craig Carton going full scorched earth by calling for LeBron James to be suspended for sitting out.

Then it turns into a full-blown trial about what actually counts as a “real sports opinion” when Sean Morash’s Brian Cashman wardrobe rant becomes the lightning rod. The crew argues, votes get disputed, and callers jump in to break the tie as the segment goes off the rails in the best way.

The conversation flips to the NFL announcing a Week 1 game in Australia between the 49ers and Rams, and the idea that the season could start on a Wednesday or Thursday before the traditional defending champ opener. Tiki breaks down the brutal travel angle as a former player, while Evan argues the fan side and why the opener tradition matters.

The segment wraps with Jets talk: is the job more attractive if you build a real roster and stay competitive, or do you embrace the tank for a potentially loaded QB draft? Plenty of caller fuel, Giants comparisons, and a classic argument about what actually makes a franchise desirable for a coach.

The guys dive into why “more quarterbacks in the draft” is actually good news for the Jets, even when names like Dante Moore and Trinidad Chambliss choosing to return to school feel like a gut punch. They unpack the bizarre NCAA eligibility circus surrounding Chambliss, including the court injunction letting him play a sixth year and why an appeal could keep the story alive.

From there, the conversation turns into a full-blown debate about what the Jets should do at quarterback, with calls ranging from “swing big” trade ideas to realistic veteran targets. Evan also announces a new Jets QB “big board” reveal coming next week, because of course he does.

Plus: Joe Judge’s strange comments making the rounds, the show tees up a new weekly “worst take” segment for WFAN, and Tom Brady catches heat for taking an unnecessary swipe at Jets fans while narrating AMC’s 49ers documentary.

The segment closes on a heavier note with reaction to the Steve Tisch and Jeffrey Epstein document disclosures, what the Giants should do next, and why fans are furious even without any new allegations of criminal conduct being made in the reporting.

A scary Friday the 13th story kicks things off before the conversation turns into full Jets chaos. The guys break down how whispers about Derek Carr coming out of retirement to play for the New York Jets went from sounding obvious to suddenly feeling unrealistic. After revisiting Carr’s December comments and his latest clarification, the debate shifts to what he really wants, which teams actually make sense, and why the Jets keep finding themselves stuck in quarterback limbo. Plus, concern over Yankees injuries, early thoughts on a new weekly “worst take” segment, and the exhausting reality of chasing veteran QB solutions with no clear answer in sight.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Is the Mets roster a given, especially now with the news of Francisco Lindor having hand surgery. Evan and Hoff give their predictions on the 2026 opening day roster.

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices