Everything Mailbag

Everything Mailbag

Download on the App Store

Everything Mailbag episodes

  • VIP PODCAST 3/10 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: TNA TV deal upgrade, ROH in WWE instead of AEW, Okada as Baba Yaga, more (82 min.)
    SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

    SHOW SUMMARY: This week, Josh Mustacchio and Rich Fann are springing forward to discuss the AEW title featured in a basketball conference win, an Off the Beaten Path review of Boy Meets World “for Love and Apartments,” and questions answered to the following:

    • Talent that was recently released likely to go to WWE from AEW
    • TNA television deal upgrade in USA
    • Should ROH have been bought by WWE instead
    • Whether WWE is “not wrestling anymore” per Michael Cole after Elimination Chamber
    • Should Tony Khan have relinquished control to Shane McMahon and given as stake as allegedly requested
    • Relationship between Rock and Triple H
    • Okada as Baba Yaga
    • Wrestlers on the “Rashford path”
    • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

      NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

      freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
      THANK YOU FOR VISITING
      1 hr 23 min
    • VIP PODCAST 2/9 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Top ten opening themes, sports teams WWE and AEW resemble, Pentagon Jr., Evolve, Joe Tess, more (66 min.)
      SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

      SHOW SUMMARY: This week, Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio return for a “super” mailbag where they discuss:

      • Top ten opening themes for shows
      • What sports teams, historical or otherwise, the WWE or AEW resemble
      • Age profiles of both promotions and what it bodes in the future
      • AEW as an analogue to ‘99 WCW?
      • International compliments for Pentagon Jr.
      • Should WWE scrap opening promos?
      • Thoughts on what Evolve should (and shouldn’t) be
      • Joe Tess as this generation’s J.R.
      • Bray Wyatt in AEW theories
      • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

        NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

        freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
        THANK YOU FOR VISITING
        1 hr 6 min
      • VIP PODCAST 1/25 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Top 2024 WWE matches, John Cena’s legacy, Netflix expansion of WWE products, more (56 min.)
        SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

        SHOW SUMMARY: This month’s Everything Mailbag with Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio opens with a little sports talk, thoughts on the Saturday Night’s Main Event, and the pair answer questions regarding:

        • Top Matches of 2024 for WWE
        • John Cena’s legacy
        • NXT and Smackdown moving to Netflix
        • Gabe Sapolski and C.M. Punk as a booking duo, Evolve, William Regal and WWE ID
        • Jim Smallman as William Regal’s mentee
        • Netflix early extension of Raw possibilities
        • Eric Bischoff hypothetical under Ari Emmanuel
        • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

          NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

          freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
          THANK YOU FOR VISITING
          57 min
        • VIP AUDIO 12/15 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Data-driven vs. data-justified wrestling decisions, Je’Von Evans vs. Kyle Fletcher, Mr. T in Diff’rent Strokes, more (98 min.)
          SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

          SHOW SUMMARY: This week, Josh Mustacchio and Rich Fann return to discuss:

          • Off the Beaten Path featuring Gary Coleman and Mr. T
          • WrestleMania VII show re-mix
          • Data-driven vs. data-justified decisions in wrestling
          • Women’s IC and US title thoughts
          • New Day turn segment thoughts
          • Could SNME become a weekly show late in the NBC/Universal contract?
          • Star potential of Je’Von Evans and Kyle Fletcher
          • Tony Khan booking questions
          • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

            NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

            freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
            THANK YOU FOR VISITING
            1 hr 39 min
          • VIP AUDIO 11/16 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Less is more in wrestling, Netflix Raw’s first segment, Co-Kane, more (84 min.)
            SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

            SHOW SUMMARY: Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio are back for the Everything Mailbag. In this month’s haul, they discuss:

            • Less is more in wrestling – cursing, Kevin Owens’ piledriver and where on the card to have it
            • What the first segment should be on Netflix’s Raw
            • Pricing out fans for events and where AEW can overtake WWE
            • Nostalgia of ECW in 2024
            • Balancing age profiles of main eventers in wrestling
            • Folks like “Co-Kane” on the indies and can those roles help towards a national product?
            • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

              NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

              freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
              THANK YOU FOR VISITING
              1 hr 25 min
            • VIP AUDIO 10/20 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Saturday Night’s Main Event booking thoughts, Undertaker and Kane’s unnecessary spat with Batista, CM Punk vs. Cody as booker, more (76 min.)
              SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

              SHOW SUMMARY: This week, Josh Mustacchio and Rich Fann discuss the following topics:

              • Latest NFL game musings, including the Vikings-Lions NFC face-off
              • Hot takes on the booking prowess of C.M. Punk vs. Cody Rhodes
              • More on Paul Levesque’s booking and bias
              • Hulk Hogan, Undertaker, and their standoff with Batista
              • Saturday Night’s Main Event booking ideas
              • Off the Beaten Path review of Kylin’s Boy Meets World episode – “Sixteen Candles and Four-Hundred-Pound Men”
              • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

                NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

                freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
                THANK YOU FOR VISITING
                1 hr 17 min
              • VIP AUDIO 10/13 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Upside between Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed, Rock’s final four matches wish list, wrestlers with biggest acting upside, more (61 min.)
                SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

                SHOW SUMMARY: This week, Josh Mustacchio and Rich Fann discuss the following topics:

                • What they’re looking forward to with regard to Raw’s presentation on Netflix
                • Wrestlers with the biggest acting upside
                • Upside comparison between Bronson Reed and Bron Breakker
                • Rock’s final four matches speculation
                • Off the Beaten Path Futurama Episode, “Raging Bender”
                • AEW critique and why folks may believe media to be biased
                • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

                  NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

                  freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
                  THANK YOU FOR VISITING
                  1 hr 2 min
                • VIP AUDIO 9/29 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Miro or Keith Lee return to WWE, Trick Williams and Melo better together, Foley comments, more (83 min.)
                  SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

                  SHOW SUMMARY: This week, Josh Mustacchio and Rich Fann discuss the following topics:

                  • Latest NFL game musings
                  • Josh’s thoughts on Wade’s appearance with Conrad Thompson and Eric Bischoff
                  • Off the Beaten Path Review of Kylin’s Boy Meets World Episode
                  • Wrestlers who would be great commentators
                  • Celebrities that listen and how crazy that is
                  • Miro or Keith Lee returning to WWE
                  • Lessons learned from WWE Vince doc
                  • Mick Foley’s McMahon commentary and RAINN
                  • Trick Williams and Melo better together?
                  • Rikishi as patriarch of a wrestling dynasty
                  • College Football Playoff Hot Takes
                  • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

                    NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

                    freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
                    THANK YOU FOR VISITING
                    1 hr 24 min
                  • VIP AUDIO 9/15 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: McMahon documentary, best “win or retire” matches, selling listeners on a new promotion to watch, more (81 min.)
                    SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

                    SHOW SUMMARY: This week, Josh Mustacchio and Rich Fann talk about the following fun topics:

                    • Selling listeners on a new promotion to watch
                    • Best “win title or retire” matches
                    • Shows that had a better episode that should have served as a finale vs the actual finale
                    • Bo Dallas’ impersonation of Bray on Monday
                    • Two hour raw and thoughts on that
                    • Continued follow up on Rich’s thoughts on AEW/WWE talent exchanges
                    • Bret Hart and his continued anger – is it justified?
                    • Thoughts on McMahon documentary
                    • Will WWE survive with a move to a limited house show schedule?
                    • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

                      NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

                      freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
                      THANK YOU FOR VISITING
                      1 hr 22 min
                    • VIP AUDIO 9/2 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Hogan and McMahon back in the news, Joe T commentary hype, Silver Spoons with Mr. T, more (112 min.)
                      SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

                      SHOW SUMMARY: Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio are back this week and chatting up on:

                      • Vince McMahon’s potential watching of WWE product
                      • Ronda Rousey’s second run and why it went wrong
                      • Contracts and fan reactions AEW vs. WWE
                      • Mauro Ranallo return possibilities
                      • Paul Heyman ECW booking and where it went right/wrong
                      • Off the Beaten Path “Silver Spoons” featuring Mr. T
                      • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

                        NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

                        freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
                        THANK YOU FOR VISITING
                        1 hr 53 min