Everything Mailbag

Everything Mailbag

Download on the App Store

Everything Mailbag episodes

  • VIP AUDIO 8/11 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Suddenly Susan x Hollywood Hogan, Joe Tessitore in NXT, Zaslav job security, Lucha Bros in WWE chances of success, more (94 min.)
    SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

    SHOW SUMMARY: This week, after a quick chat about the Olympics, WWE, and AEW, Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio talk about:

    • “Suddenly Susan” Off the Beaten Path
    • Last week’s hot takes revisited
    • Whether Hulk Hogan will receive more screen time due to his Gawker movie in 2025
    • Joe Tessitore’s chances as announcer
    • Zaslav’s job and AEW
    • Lucha Bros chances of success in WWE
    • Will NXT leave PC permanently in the CW era
    • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

      NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

      freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
      THANK YOU FOR VISITING
      1 hr 35 min
    • VIP AUDIO 8/1 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Mark Henry as talent scout, Regal back on TV, Josh’s thoughts on AEW TV vs. CBS/SEC, more (79 min.)
      SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

      SHOW SUMMARY: This week on the Everything Mailbag, Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio tackle the following:

      • Finale of the wrestlers in movies assignment
      • Thoughts on Cornette and Russo surviving a Stephanie Led WWE
      • Regal as an on-air talent again
      • What would a world without Nick Khan in WWE look like
      • NXT returning to Levesque’s roots/Levesque’s possible return of WCW
      • Mark Henry as a talent scout
      • Montez Ford or Angelo as the singles guy in Street Profits
      • Josh’s thoughts on the AEW television rights and the CBS-SEC situation
      • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

        NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

        freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
        THANK YOU FOR VISITING
        1 hr 19 min
      • VIP AUDIO 7/13 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Bo Jackson/Derrick Rose wrestling analogies, Film Off the Beaten Path, Pat Patterson Monday Night Wars, more (76 min.)
        SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

        SHOW SUMMARY: This week, Josh Mustacchio and Rich Fann kick off the Mailbag with the announcement of Joe Tessitore finale of the Bryan Alston mega email, then jump into:

        • Off the Beaten Path film edition, where Josh and Rich insert wrestlers into key Hollywood movie roles
        • Wrestlers that had a Bo Jackson or Derrick Rose impact/experience
        • Dijak and his role in WWE, and opportunities elsewhere
        • Dustin’s hot takes on who won the Monday Night War
        • “What if” scenario on Vince Russo being fired
        • Was Ron Simmons a good choice at the time of his title win?
        • Bruce Pritchard’s continued presence in WWE
        • WWE Network on Netflix
        • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

          NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

          freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
          THANK YOU FOR VISITING
          1 hr 17 min
        • VIP AUDIO 6/30 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Hypocrisy of authority figure decisions, Teddy Long’s legacy, Jesse Ventura on “Small Wonder,” more (100 min.)
          SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

          SHOW SUMMARY: This week’s Everything Mailbag kicks off with some “Small Wonder” chat off the beaten path, then focuses on:

          • Authority figures being arbitrary with rules and regulations and their hypocrisy with regard to fines and punishment
          • Casting wrestlers into iconic movies, part I
          • Hot takes on Ethan Page, Daniel Garcia, and “3rd Rock from the Sun”???
          • Wrestling origins and PWTorch origins in the “key of Terry”
          • Raw/Netflix moves and how that’ll affect their viewing
          • The legacy of Teddy Long
          • WWE’s global localization plan and how Netflix affects it
          • C.M. Punk, booker?
          • Comparing AEW’s women’s division to WWE and Stardom using University of Colorado
          • Angel Reese and Caitlin Clark as Magic and Bird?
          • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

            NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

            freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
            THANK YOU FOR VISITING
            1 hr 41 min
          • VIP AUDIO 6/16 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: All Hollywood Wrestling roster draft, Triple H and Punk getting along, Logan Paul and Trump, more (86 min.)
            SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

            SHOW SUMMARY: This week on a special Father’s Day edition of the Everything Mailbag, Josh and Rich cover the following topics:

            • WWE and NOAH relationships
            • Is Vince McMahon’s pariah status permanent
            • Off the Beaten Path of an all Hollywood Wrestling promotion draft for Rich and Josh
            • Pushback on Saudi comments in last ep
            • Triple H and C.M. Punk getting along
            • What it takes to get fans to attend shows
            • Would Pittsburgh support an NBA team
            • Logan Paul and Donald Trump
            • And more!
            • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

              NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

              freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
              THANK YOU FOR VISITING
              1 hr 27 min
            • VIP AUDIO 6/2 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: “Surely You Joust” ep of Family Matters, Jericho retirement tour on hold, post-Netflix WWE must-watch events, more (65 min.)
              SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

              SHOW SUMMARY: This episode of the Everything Mailbag kicks off with Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio discussing the “Surely You Joust” Season 4, Episode 1 of Family Matters as their Off the Beaten Path, and then jump into questions from listeners that cover:

              • What it would take for Nick Khan to pull WWE out of Saudi Arabia?
              • Should Jericho remain in AEW, or start a retirement tour in WWE?
              • Will TNT and TBS now become the wrestling networks in the same way that CBS was maligned from October 1960 to March of 1971 when CBS was known for airing rural sitcoms
              • What Josh and Rich are looking forward to watching when WWE moves to Netflix
              • And a phenomenal game of “Stump Josh Jeopardy”
              • Best wrestling retirements (real or fake)
              • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

                NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

                freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
                THANK YOU FOR VISITING
                1 hr 6 min
              • VIP AUDIO 5/19 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Dusty’s legacy, HHH vs. Michaels booking, Hockey vs. AEW ratings, more (59 min.)
                SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

                SHOW SUMMARY: They’re back! Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio return after a Mother’s Day hiatus to chat about:

                • Updates on the last few weeks
                • A wrestling “home and away” fantasy tag tournament;
                • Dusty’s overall legacy pre-and-post NXT vs. prior to it;
                • Comcast rights fees going up and whether it’s a determinant of WWE’s departure
                • What it would take for WWE to depart KSA deal
                • Teddy Long’s legacy in wrestling
                • Hockey and AEW ratings
                • The Triple H/Shawn Michaels booking comparison we never saw coming
                • HOF order of interest between wrestling, and the major four North American sports
                • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

                  NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

                  freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
                  THANK YOU FOR VISITING
                  59 min
                • VIP AUDIO 4/28 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Wrestling games draft, NFL draft thoughts from Josh regarding Tony’s appearance, AEW defections to WWE, more (66 min.)
                  SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

                  SHOW SUMMARY: This week, Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio open with puppy travel madness, hot weather, a few kind words on Craig, and listener email roundup featuring:

                  • A video game draft, regardless of system
                  • Thoughts on the NFL Draft from the weekend
                  • Who returns from AEW to WWE first, and Josh’s thoughts on Mercedes’ run so far
                  • Known booking flaws of Paul Levesque
                  • New Japan’s current booking struggles and how they can return to glory
                  • Stephanie McMahon, co-CEO again?
                  • Jesse Ventura chances in modern WWE
                  • Freddie Prinze, Jr’s wrestling promotion and its chances in the current scene
                  • Hot Takes speed round featuring MLW, NWA, television shows and more
                  • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

                    NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

                    freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
                    THANK YOU FOR VISITING
                    1 hr 7 min
                  • VIP AUDIO 4/14 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Paul Heyman’s HOF Speech, Mania thoughts, Cody Rhodes’ future feuds, Family Matters “Off the Beaten Path,” more (68 min.)
                    SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

                    SHOW SUMMARY: This week on the Everything Mailbag, Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio cover the following topics:

                    • Podcasting history of the pair (continued from last episode)
                    • Off the Beaten Path Family Matters Episode
                    • Ricky Stanicky review by Josh and his thoughts on Hulk Hogan, The Rock, and John Cena as actors
                    • Cody Rhodes’ potential options for a longer-term feud
                    • Rossy Ogawa’s new promotion and its potential tie to WWE/NXT Japan
                    • Netflix’s attempt to organize WWE events
                    • Paul Heyman’s WWE HOF speech and potential to book in company longer term
                    • Odds of Stephanie returning to a WWE role
                    • Future of a Brand Split
                    • Josh’s son’s thoughts on Mania, and Josh’s thoughts on this week’s AEW happenings
                    • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

                      NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

                      freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
                      THANK YOU FOR VISITING
                      1 hr 9 min
                    • VIP AUDIO 4/1 – Everything Mailbag w/Fann & Mustacchio: Mania Week madness, Mercedes’ evolution, GCW on Peacock, more (65 min.)
                      SPOTLIGHTED PODCAST ALERT (YOUR ARTICLE BEGINS A FEW INCHES DOWN)...

                      SHOW SUMMARY: This week, Rich Fann and Josh Mustacchio open with the Mania Week craziness, Mercedes’ booking leading into this week, Josh’s thoughts on WWE Speed on Twitter, and listener email roundup featuring:

                      • Nick Khan’s potential to be let go given his alleged involvement in the Grant case
                      • Kevin Kelly’s potential to be signed to WWE
                      • GCW on Peacock
                      • Martha Hart allowing Owen into WWE HOF
                      • Motor City Machine Guns and their best landing spot
                      • Ranking Mania Celebs during 80s
                      • Ronda Rousey’s treatment in her second stint in WWE
                      • Hardy’s potential return to WWE
                      • Inspirations to podcast, and podcasts outside of wrestling they listen to
                      • DIRECT LINK:  VIP AUDIO LINK

                        NOT VIP? NO PROBLEM… CLICK HERE FOR VIP SIGN UP INFO

                        freestar.config.enabled_slots.push({ placementName: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3", slotId: "pwtorchcom_medrec_3" });
                        THANK YOU FOR VISITING
                        1 hr 6 min