Send us Fan Mail

Jehovah’s Witnesses are told to trust the elders. But most Witnesses have never seen the manual elders use behind closed doors.

In this video, JT, a former Jehovah’s Witness elder, discusses Shepherd the Flock of God — the confidential elders’ manual used when judicial matters, discipline, accusations, and congregation decisions are being handled.

This is not just about a book.

It is about what happens when ordinary men are placed in positions of authority over people’s lives, reputations, families, friendships, and standing in the congregation — while the people most affected are not allowed to see the rules being used.

We also discuss why serious accusations and possible crimes should never be handled through a religious chain of command. Real crimes belong in the hands of proper authorities — not in a back room with three elders and a confidential handbook.


Topics covered:
Jehovah’s Witness elders
Shepherd the Flock of God book
Judicial committees
Disfellowshipping
Religious control
Watchtower secrecy
Why proper authorities should be contacted when crimes may be involved


Join us behind the scenes on Patreon - https://www.patreon.com/exjwcriticalthinker 

Support the show

Send us Fan Mail

This conversation goes deeper than one question.

We’re looking at the full picture—
how policies, interpretations, and real-life decisions all intersect when it comes to blood.

From blood fractions…
to storing your own blood…
to the realities people are facing right now—
this isn’t just theory.

These are real situations.
Real families.
Real consequences.

This follow-up builds on the discussion and connects the dots in a way that deserves a closer look.

🔍 Resources Mentioned:

📄 Australasian Anaesthesia (Jehovah’s Witness patient care):

📄 Management of Jehovah’s Witnesses in Anaesthesia:

💭 Join the Conversation

What are your thoughts on these changes?

🔔 Stay Connected

www.CriticalThinker.com

Support the show

Send us Fan Mail

For many Jehovah’s Witnesses, 1975 was more than just a date.

It was a period that shaped life decisions, family relationships, education, careers, and personal identity for decades to come.

In this interview, Gail Kelly shares her personal experience growing up during the buildup to 1975 — a time when many Jehovah’s Witnesses believed Armageddon was very near.

Her family sold their home, moved across the country, and reorganized their lives around those beliefs.

But when 1975 came and went, the emotional and psychological impact did not disappear.

This conversation explores:

• the pressure surrounding 1975
• the “human cost” of end-times expectations
• shunning and family separation
• conditional relationships inside high-control religion
• and the lasting emotional consequences that followed for many former Jehovah’s Witnesses

This story eventually came full circle through:

a heartbreaking deathbed confession from Gail’s father
and later, learning of her mother’s passing through a Facebook obituary
Related Videos

▶️ An Elder’s Regret Deathbed Confession (Facing Mortality)

▶️ Elder's Deathbed Confession & Facebook Obituary

Thank you for watching EXJW Critical Thinker.

If this video resonated with you, please like, comment, and subscribe to support the channel.

Join us behind the scenes on Patreon  

Support the show

Send us Fan Mail

When the former Prime Minister of Japan was assassinated in 2022, the investigation uncovered deep ties between the attacker and a high-control religious group known as the Moonies. That tragedy set off a chain reaction in Japan—one that now has the spotlight turning toward Jehovah’s Witnesses.

In this video, JT breaks down:

Why the Governing Body suddenly shifted on higher education

How Japan’s new laws are classifying forced religious acts as child abuse

The “second generation” issue and why it hits home for ex-JWs

The role of money, lawsuits, and government scrutiny in Watchtower’s recent changes

We’ll also unpack Watchtower’s so-called “independent study” in Japan—and why it may not be as independent as they claim.

👇🏼 Download the Japan study here:

https://culteducation.com/group/1277-unification-church/38412-second-gen-of-unification-church-members-in-japan-sue-for-320-million-yen-in-damages.html

https://jwj-qs.jp/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/JWJ-QS-Study-Report-sec1-2-v1.0.pdf

https://jw-japan.org/en/jehovahs-witnesses-in-japan-a-quantitative-study

Blue Envelope    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35ok3hNgNLk

https://apnews.com/article/japan-unification-church-dissolution-d5e1fdf3cb671d6ffeb45d75620ef8b2

👉 Watch our livestream on JW education here: https://youtube.com/live/ZAnTAEw-9ig?feature=share

As always, we encourage critical thinking, honest discussion, and remembering that you’re not alone if you’re rebuilding after leaving a high-control group.

Join us behind the scenes on Patreon - https://www.patreon.com/exjwcriticalthinker

Check out our videos on why we left the Why We Left the Jehovah's Witnesses

https://youtu.be/rqYUCV4FHI4
https://youtu.be/bLaSB9P2MEE
 
Visit us on the Web at http://www.exjwcriticalthinker.com 
 
SUBSCRIBE to us on YouTube http://bit.ly/2p9RTSC 
 
Subscribe to Our Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ex-jehovahs-witnesses-critical-thinkers-critical-thought/id967813520
 
Follow us on:
     Twitter https://twitter.com/ExJWsThink
     Instagram https://www.instagram.com/exjwcriticalthinker/
     Facebook https://www.facebook.com/Ex-Jehovahs-Witnesses-Critical-Thinkers-529293183758131/ 
 
Check out our t-shirt designs: https://exjwcriticalthinker.myspreadshop.com/all 
 
How to Contact Us
We appreciate hearing from our viewers; however, we do not have enough staff or resources to communicate with everyone. We rarely check messages in our social media platforms (i.e., Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.), therefore, if you want to reach us, email us directly at the email address listed below:
 
✰✰ EMAIL: 
[email protected]

Support the show

Send us Fan Mail

What happens when a religion tells millions of people that higher education is “dangerous”?

For decades, Jehovah’s Witnesses were discouraged from going to college. It wasn’t a written ban, but elders, conventions, and Watchtower publications reinforced the message until it became a cultural rule. Careers, scholarships, and futures were lost.

In this panel discussion, JT and Lady Cee sit down with fellow former Jehovah’s Witnesses to share how this teaching shaped their lives. Together we’ll cover:

• The talks, articles, and letters used to discourage education.
• How elders enforced it in local congregations.
• Real stories from EXJWs who lost opportunities, scholarships, or careers.
• The sudden shift: why the Watchtower now calls it a “matter of conscience.”
• The lasting impact on finances, self-worth, and family life.
🎓 Whether you grew up as a Witness, left recently, or are just curious how doctrine controls life choices, this panel pulls back the curtain on how one religion controlled education for generations.
 
👉 Subscribe and join the conversation in the comments — your story matters too.

Want to create live streams like this? Check out StreamYard: https://streamyard.com/pal/d/4781897218785280

00:00 Introduction
03:35 Wes' Story
10:58 Ra'Shuna & Terrance
19:13 Fran & Joe
32:48 Daria
45:44 Collin
57:57 Efrain
01:15:02 Jack
01:29:31 Koco & Totally Awake
01:36:51 Closing Comments

Support the show

Send us Fan Mail

Laura X Timber 
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@lauraxtimber
Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/people/Laura-X-Timber/61566000317102/
TikTok - https://www.tiktok.com/@lauraxtimber
Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/lauraxtimber/

In this heartfelt conversation, Lady Cee and JT sit down with Laura X Timber, a powerful content creator who offers her platform as a soft place to land for those unpacking life after high-control religion.

This isn't just an interview — it's a reminder that healing doesn’t have to be loud to be life-changing. Sometimes, it starts with a safe space and an honest conversation.

🎙️ Featuring: Lady Cee & JT | EXJW Critical Thinker
🎥 Guest Host: Laura X Timber

Topics we explore:
• Sharing your truth without fear
• Creating safe space after spiritual harm
• Why stories like ours still matter

Join us behind the scenes on Patreon

Check out our videos on why we left the Why We Left the Jehovah's Witnesses

https://youtu.be/rqYUCV4FHI4
https://youtu.be/bLaSB9P2MEE

Visit us on the Web

SUBSCRIBE to us on YouTube

Subscribe to Our Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ex-jehovahs-witnesses-critical-thinkers-critical-thought/id967813520

Follow us on:
     X
     Instagram
     Facebook

Check out our t-shirt designs:  
 
How to Contact Us
We appreciate hearing from our viewers; however, we do not have enough staff or resources to communicate with everyone. We rarely check messages in our social media platforms (i.e., Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.), therefore, if you want to reach us, email us directly at the email address listed below:
 
✰✰ EMAIL: 
[email protected]

Support the show

Support the show

Send us Fan Mail

May is Mental Health Awareness Month, and in this powerful episode, we revisit the story of Tony — a former elder and third-generation Jehovah’s Witness — as he opens up about the emotional and psychological impact of growing up in the organization.
Tony shares how guilt, fear, and pressure to “perform spiritually” affected his mental health over time — and why so many others may be suffering in silence today.
If you’ve ever felt overwhelmed, isolated, or like your struggles were dismissed as “spiritual weakness,” this conversation is for you.
👇 If you're struggling or know someone who is:
📞 Call or text 988 (U.S.)
🌐 Global resources: 
🔔 Subscribe for more interviews and resources for those leaving high-control religions.
💬 Share your thoughts in the comments — your story matters.

Join us behind the scenes on Patreon

Check out our videos on why we left the Why We Left the Jehovah's Witnesses

https://youtu.be/rqYUCV4FHI4
https://youtu.be/bLaSB9P2MEE

Visit us on the Web

SUBSCRIBE to us on YouTube

Subscribe to Our Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ex-jehovahs-witnesses-critical-thinkers-critical-thought/id967813520

Follow us on:
     X
     Instagram
     Facebook

Check out our t-shirt designs:  
 
How to Contact Us
We appreciate hearing from our viewers; however, we do not have enough staff or resources to communicate with everyone. We rarely check messages in our social media platforms (i.e., Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.), therefore, if you want to reach us, email us directly at the email address listed below:
 
✰✰ EMAIL: 
[email protected]

Support the show

Support the show

Send us Fan Mail

🔁 Throwback Thursday – Back by RequestA viewer recently commented:“I’m not sure why I’m just now seeing this video in 2025. I really enjoyed it.” ❤️
That reminded us why this conversation with Gary Alt is still one of the most powerful interviews we’ve shared.

In this episode, Gary — a former elder, Bethelite, and now a life coach — opens up about his journey of leaving the Jehovah’s Witnesses, what he discovered about “the brotherhood,” and how he found healing on the other side.

👉 If this resonates, share your thoughts in the comments. We’re listening.


How to reach Gary Alt Resources:

Coaching

YouTube

Spotify

Join us behind the scenes on Patreon

Check out our videos on why we left the Why We Left the Jehovah's Witnesses

https://youtu.be/rqYUCV4FHI4
https://youtu.be/bLaSB9P2MEE

Visit us on the Web at http://www.exjwcriticalthinker.com

SUBSCRIBE to us on YouTube  
 
Subscribe to Our Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ex-jehovahs-witnesses-critical-thinkers-critical-thought/id967813520
 
Follow us on:
     Twitter https://twitter.com/ExJWsThink
     Instagram https://www.instagram.com/exjwcriticalthinker/
     Facebook https://www.facebook.com/Ex-Jehovahs-Witnesses-Critical-Thinkers-529293183758131/ 
 
Check out our t-shirt designs: https://exjwcriticalthinker.myspreadshop.com/all 
 
How to Contact Us
We appreciate hearing from our viewers; however, we do not have enough staff or resources to communicate with everyone. We rarely check messages in our social media platforms (i.e., Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.), therefore, if you want to reach us, email us directly at the email address listed below:
 
✰✰ EMAIL: 
[email protected]

Support the show

Send us Fan Mail

Episode uploaded from April 18, 2025

This week, millions of Christians reflect on Jesus — especially during the Easter season. But for Jehovah’s Witnesses, that relationship is framed in a very different way.

In this episode of The Critical Thought, we illustrate how that belief system actually works — through a unique skit, a real-life experience from a former elder, and some critical questions every Jehovah’s Witness should be asking.

🎭 Featuring our skit: "1-800-HEAVENN™ — Where Some Calls Get Through™

📌 Want to go deeper?
Watch our earlier videos on this topic:
► Jesus Is Not Your Mediator – Part 1
► Jesus Is Not Your Mediator – Part 2

❓ 8 Questions to Ask Any Jehovah’s Witness:
1) If Jesus isn’t your mediator… who is?

2) Why do you pray in his name?

3) How are your sins forgiven if his sacrifice doesn’t apply to you?

4) Why does the Bible say he intercedes for all who come to God through him?

5) Are you in the new covenant — or just observing it from the outside?

6) Why does the Insight book define a mediator as a go-between, yet deny you that access?

7) How did you miss this doctrine if you’ve studied the Bible for years?

8) What else haven’t they told you?

Join us behind the scenes on Patreon

Check out our videos on why we left the Why We Left the Jehovah's Witnesses

https://youtu.be/rqYUCV4FHI4
https://youtu.be/bLaSB9P2MEE

Visit us on the Web

SUBSCRIBE to us on YouTube

Subscribe to Our Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ex-jehovahs-witnesses-critical-thinkers-critical-thought/id967813520

Follow us on:
     X
     Instagram
     Facebook

Check out our t-shirt designs:  
 
How to Contact Us
We appreciate hearing from our viewers; however, we do not have enough staff or resources to communicate with everyone. We rarely check messages in our social media platforms (i.e., Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.), therefore, if you want to reach us, email us directly at the email address listed below:
 
✰✰ EMAIL: 
[email protected]

Support the show

Support the show

Send us Fan Mail

This week, millions of Christians reflect on Jesus — especially during the Easter season. But for Jehovah’s Witnesses, that relationship is framed in a very different way.

In this episode of The Critical Thought, we illustrate how that belief system actually works — through a unique skit, a real-life experience from a former elder, and some critical questions every Jehovah’s Witness should be asking.

🎭 Featuring our skit: "1-800-HEAVENN™ — Where Some Calls Get Through™

📌 Want to go deeper?
Watch our earlier videos on this topic:
► Jesus Is Not Your Mediator – Part 1
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=svX3onqO2ls
► Jesus Is Not Your Mediator – Part 2
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpymBCrvAiE

❓ 8 Questions to Ask Any Jehovah’s Witness:
1) If Jesus isn’t your mediator… who is?

2) Why do you pray in his name?

3) How are your sins forgiven if his sacrifice doesn’t apply to you?

4) Why does the Bible say he intercedes for all who come to God through him?

5) Are you in the new covenant — or just observing it from the outside?

6) Why does the Insight book define a mediator as a go-between, yet deny you that access?

7) How did you miss this doctrine if you’ve studied the Bible for years?

8) What else haven’t they told you?

Join us behind the scenes on Patreon - https://www.patreon.com/exjwcriticalthinker 

Support the show