Extinguished

As the haunting melody of hope and heartbreak crescendos, we reach the poignant finale of Ariana Fitts's story in our latest Extinguished episode.We unravel the chilling turns in the search for the missing toddler and the quest for justice for her slain mother, Nicole "Nicky" Fitts. The fervor is reignited with a staggering $250,000 reward offer and the release of an age-progressed image by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, shedding light on the possibility that little Arianna might still be drawing breath in a world that's kept her hidden for too long.

The final chapter of our series calls upon you, our listeners, to join a vigilant collective, poised to share Arianna's image far and wide, transforming every listener into a beacon of hope. We dig into the crucial roles of the community, the FBI's widening search net, and the enigmatic babysitter Helena Martin, her husband David, and her sister—key figures in the days leading up to Nicky's tragic death and Arianna's vanishing. In an appeal to the collective conscience, we remind you that your eyes and ears could be the catalyst for a breakthrough. Your action can help write an ending to this story—one we hope brings Ariana home.

To read more about the case, visit the Charley Project HERE

Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE

Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.

Unravel the chilling narrative of Nicole and Ariana Fitts as we continue our compelling investigation. In our latest installment, the perplexing details emerge from the shadows, including Helena Martin's ominous past and the staggering 30,000 pieces of evidence yet to crack the case. We're left grappling with a haunting question: Could the Martins, shrouded in their silence, hold the key to unlocking the fate of little Ariana and solving Nicole's brutal murder?

With hearts heavy and minds resolute, we recount Nicole's unwavering dedication as a mother and the wrenching void left by her tragic end and Ariana's unresolved disappearance. We dissect the dark theories that swirl around Ariana's fate and the vital six-week period when mother and daughter were painfully parted. From possible family entanglements to the sinister underbelly of child trafficking, each theory is explored with the hope that forensic science might finally illuminate the path to answers. As the mystery unfolds, we honor Nicole's memory and rally our listeners: your voice could be the catalyst for justice in the haunting search for Arianna

To read more about the case, visit the Charley Project HERE

Get you tickets for True CrimeFest HERE

Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.

A dark past surfaces as we peel back the layers of a mother's trust gone tragically wrong. Amidst the heartbreak of Nicole Fitts's murder and her daughter Ariannas mysterious disappearance, we reveal the disturbing history of Helena Martin—one of the last to see Arianna and a figure with a former murder charge haunting her narrative. The threads of misplaced trust weave a perplexing web as we discuss Nicole's dire situation as a vulnerable, single, homeless mother and the fateful decisions that led to her untimely death.

The search for clarity intensifies when examining the peculiar actions of the Martins and their dubious Disneyland alibi, contrasted against the backdrop of Nicole's desperate fight to reclaim her daughter. As Goyette Williams recounts the final days before Nicole's disappearance, a cryptic text and a symbol-laden plywood board at the crime scene emerge as enigmatic clues. We scrutinize every angle, from the shaky stories to the chilling possibility that Arianna's vanishing was no accident. Join us for a meticulous analysis as we strive to piece together the harrowing events that have left a young girl missing and a family in anguish.

To read more about the case, visit the Charley Project HERE

Get you tickets for True CrimeFest HERE

Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr

Uncover the heartache and mystery shrouding Nicole Fitts's tragic end and her daughter Arianna 's disappearance in our latest episode of Extinguished. As we recount the grim discovery in McLaren Park that marked only the beginning of this saga, the unsettling details of their story emerge—from Nicole's battle with poverty and homelessness to the murky figures that entered her life in its final chapters. We pay tribute to their memory, piecing together the fragments left behind, and hope to spark the conversations that could bring answers to a family still searching for closure.

Listen as we navigate the complexities surrounding Nicole's relationships, including her involvement with a "street pastor" who may have been more foe than friend. We scrutinize the distressing signals that arose after Nicole's demise: cryptic text messages, a suspicious Facebook status, and the haunting realization that her daughter Arianna 's whereabouts remain an enigma. With every word, we aim to honor Nicole and Arianna Fitts, and through this narrative, we invite you to join us in seeking the truth behind a loss that reverberates to this day.


To read more about the case, visit the Charley Project HERE

Get you tickets for True CrimeFest HERE

Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr

As the curtain falls on our deep dive into the chilling case of Melissa Witt, we're left grappling with the weight of unsolved mysteries and the shadows they cast. Join us for our final installment, where LaDonna unveils her conviction that Melissa's killer was no stranger, but someone within her inner circle, buried in the pages of her diary. Our discussion traverses the delicate intricacies of the FBI's killer profile and why suspects such as Larry Swearingen still linger in the periphery of possibility—highlighting the enigma that has endured nearly three decades.

The triumph over adversity is palpable as we recount the odyssey behind our independent documentary's creation, celebrating its resonance with audiences at Crime Con and on platforms like YouTube and Amazon Prime. The unexpected success has not only ushered in a stream of crucial tips but also amplified public intrigue. Accompanying this surge, LaDonna's book "The Girl I Never Knew," has woven a tapestry of financial support and connections that extend far beyond the pages, fostering a community deeply invested in justice for Melissa.

Amidst the breakthroughs, the personal toll of such a pursuit can't be overlooked. Reflecting on the impact writing "Strangled" has had on LaDonna's life, She navigates the dichotomy of contributing meaningfully to a cause while safeguarding her privacy and well-being. Yet even as we battle darkness, we find light in the form of solidarity against death fetishism and the anticipation of a third book that promises to unravel more mysteries of Melissa's case. Our conversation is a testament to the power of collaboration and shared passion, affirming that even in the most tragic stories, connection and purpose can be found.

TIME LINE
(00:01) Extinguished
(09:48) Documentary Success and Writing Books
(25:40) Writing Books and Fighting Death Fetish
(33:18) Connection and Collaboration


Get you tickets for True CrimeFest HERE

Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr

Unlock the shadowy maze of suspects surrounding the haunting case of Melissa Witt's unsolved murder with us, LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam. This episode peels back the layers of deceit and confessions, leading us through a chilling gallery of individuals whose past actions cast a long, dark shadow over the investigation. As we share our personal encounters and exclusive interviews, you'll feel the icy grip of possibility that one of these men could hold the key to a decades-long mystery.

With each story, we reveal the intricate web of evidence and alibis that have both hindered and propelled the case forward. Extensive conversations with these individuals, including a 40-hour deep dive with a suspect, will leave you pondering the true nature of innocence and guilt. And when we explore the unsettling ties to the Baptist Vista Church Camp, the proximity to the crime scene sends a shiver down the spine of the community's collective memory.

As the year comes to a close, join us in a heartfelt tribute to the victims and the stories that continue to echo in the silence of unresolved tragedies. This episode serves as a poignant reminder of the lives that have been altered by such crimes, and our commitment to seeking truth and justice. We share a solemn farewell, but not goodbye, as we promise to return with more untold stories of the missing and murdered. Stay vigilant, stay informed, and may the new year bring renewed hope and answers.

TIME LINE
(00:01) Unsolved Murders and Suspects
(09:44) Suspects in Melissa Witt Investigation
(19:46) Church Camp and Travis as Suspect
(29:15) True Crime Podcast


Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr

A Christmas Eve celebration turns into a scene straight out of a horror film when a man clad as Santa Claus knocks on the Ortega family's door, unleashing terror beyond imagination. Listen as we, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey, unravel the Covina Massacre—a night that turned the joyous holiday into a nightmare of gunfire and flames, claiming nine innocent lives.

As we recount the story in a complete single episode, we shed light on the devastating actions of Bruce Jeffrey Pardo, the family member whose malicious intent was disguised under the veil of a festive costume. Through eyewitness accounts and a detailed investigation, we expose the darkness that lurked behind Pardo's eyes and the calculated vengeance that led to an unfathomable tragedy.

Join us for a poignant episode that serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of life and the sometimes hidden perils that can shatter the peace of the holiday season.

Listen to the other Collaborators on Santa Maybe a Criminal. Click Here

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr

Join us, David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey, on Extinguished, as we peel back the layers of the haunting, unsolved 1994 murder case of Melissa Witt from Fort Smith, Arkansas. Listen in as we share how a rookie reporter, Marcus Blair, made an unexpected connection between Witt's murder and another chilling case in Texas. We discuss the eerie similarities between these two cases and the chilling evidence that pointed investigators towards a suspect named Larry Swearingen. Unravel with us, the complex web of clues that linked Swearingen to the Witt case, including his mysterious presence in Arkansas just days before Witt's murder.

In the second part of the episode, we explore the dark and disturbing history of Larry Swearingen, a man whose violent past makes him a prime suspect. Swearingen, who was convicted and executed for another murder, maintained a disturbing silence about the Witt case, even going as far as sending threatening letters to one of the hosts. We also look into the case of Melissa Trotter, another young woman who was tragically murdered, and discuss the potential links between her case and Melissa Witt's. Tune in to uncover the mystery of these interconnected murder cases and the shadowy figure at their center.

TIME LINE
(00:01) Suspects in Melissa Witt Murder
(16:57) Larry Swearingen's Dangerous Crimes
(25:35) Melissa Witt Case


Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr

Today, we're turning back the clock to 1994; the year a vibrant, young woman, Melissa Ann Witt, was tragically ripped from her loving family and community in Fort Smith, Arkansas. Embarking on an emotionally charged journey with us is Ladonna Humphrey, a seasoned investigator who has been wrapped up in Melissa's unsolved murder for the past eight years. LaDonna, also an acclaimed author and filmmaker, will walk us through the heartbreaking events of that fateful December day, the ongoing investigation, and Melissa's life that was cut short in the blink of an eye.

We're also illuminating the relentless dedication of a retired detective, Jay C. Rider, who has committed years to uncovering the truth behind Melissa's case. Discover a touching story of his steadfast promise to Melissa's mother, a story that gives a whole new meaning to the phrase "above and beyond". Prepare to dive into the chilling details of Melissa's murder, which suggest the unthinkable; her killer might have been someone she knew.

In the final chapter of our journey, we focus on the impact of LaDonna Humphrey's work in the realm of true crime. Hear about her plans for future projects, including two tantalizing new documentaries, and her optimism about the imminent issuance of an arrest warrant in the case. We'll also explore the success of the award-winning documentary "Uneven Ground: The Melissa Witt Story", a film that has given a voice to a young woman whose life was cruelly silenced. Join us for this compelling and heart-rending discussion; it's not one to be missed.

TIME LINE
(00:01) Unsolved Murder of Melissa Ann Witt
(11:29) Jay C. Rider
(19:58) Unsolved Murder and Advocacy
(35:04) Melissa Witt Case and Book Series
(45:32) "Uneven Ground" Documentary
(51:05) Successes in True Crime Advocacy


About LaDonna Humphrey

LaDonna Humphrey is a writer, documentarian, investigative journalist, private investigator, Podcast host and an advocate for victims of crime. And for the past seven years, LaDonna has found herself passionately entangled in seeking justice for 19-year-old murder victim, Melissa Ann Witt.

LaDonna Humphrey lives in Cave Springs, Arkansas with her husband and five of her seven children.

LaDonna Humphrey Website Click Here


Facebook Click Here
https://www.facebook.com/whokilledmissywitt

Purchase The Girl I never knew who killed Melissa Witt:

Genius books

Amazon


Purchase Strangled

Genuis Books

Amazon


Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam

Prepare for a spine-chilling ride, as we unearth the heinous mysteries surrounding the unsolved murder of young JonBenet Ramsey. Join us, your hosts Ladonna Humphrey and David McClam, as we navigate the intricacies of the relentless investigation conducted by the Boulder Police Department and the Colorado Governor. We leave no stone unturned, discussing startling theories about the identity of the murderer and presenting a chilling encounter shared by a family friend of the Ramseys.

Then, brace yourself as we scrutinize eerie connections between JonBenet's case and other unresolved murders. The stakes rise as we ponder the horrifying possibility of a serial killer, lurking in the shadows of the pageant circuit, preying on young girls. Could there be two culprits involved, complicating the already baffling scenario? Join our quest for truth, as we strive to keep the pursuit of justice alive for JonBenet Ramsey, a young life tragically snuffed out, yet continuing to reverberate globally.

Time Line

(00:01) The JonBenet Ramsey Murder Investigation

(14:30) Connections in JonBenet Ramsey's Murder

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr