This episode details the cold case investigation into the 1981 murder of Lieutenant Ray Joe Clark, who was shot in his home. After 33 years, authorities identified former deputy Mitchell Rubble as the killer, revealing a motive rooted in a personal vendetta after Clark fired him for misconduct. The narrative describes a tense police interrogation where Rubble unknowingly provides incriminating details regarding his vehicle and the specific ammunition used in the crime. Key evidence emerged when a former associate, Bob Smithberger, broke his decades-long silence to confess his role as an unwilling getaway driver. Despite his persistent denials, Rubble was eventually convicted and sentenced to life in prison. He ultimately died in custody shortly after his sentencing, bringing a final conclusion to the decades-old mystery.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

This episode documents the resolution of a fifty-year-old cold case involving the 1974 murder of Mary Kathleen Schlice in Wisconsin. Investigators utilized modern investigative genetic genealogy to identify John Keith Miller, an 84-year-old man living in an assisted living facility, as the perpetrator. During a recorded interrogation, Miller initially feigned ignorance before eventually confessing to the killing, though he attempted to minimize his actions by claiming it was an accident. Despite his claims of a single stabbing, forensic evidence proved Mary suffered multiple wounds and fought for her life. The case was ultimately solved through DNA samples provided by Miller’s biological relatives and his own daughter. Miller pleaded no contest to first-degree murder and was sentenced to life in prison, finally bringing closure to the victim’s family after half a century.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

The episode details the investigation and interrogation of Gene Stuller, who was arrested in 2025 for the 1991 murder of Julia Sue Willbanks. After the case remained cold for over three decades, advanced genealogical DNA testing linked Stuller’s blood to a pair of shorts found on the victim. During a lengthy police interview, detectives confront Stuller with the overwhelming 1.6 trillion-to-one DNA match, contrasting his calm demeanor with the brutality of the 17 stab wounds inflicted on the victim. Stuller repeatedly denies any knowledge of the crime or the woman, even as investigators highlight his history of substance abuse and blackouts during that era. Despite his claims of innocence and lack of memory, the interrogation concludes with his arrest based on a judge-signed warrant. The source ultimately illustrates how modern forensic science can eventually resolve decades-old cold cases by uncovering undeniable physical evidence.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

A former forensic scientist for the Colorado Bureau of Investigation, Missy Woods, was recently sentenced to prison after admitting to falsifying DNA evidence over several decades. In response to her misconduct, the Denver Police Department launched a comprehensive retesting initiative to ensure the integrity of affected criminal cases. Their investigation identified dozens of sexual assault cases in Denver that required urgent review due to her involvement. Recent lab results from these efforts successfully generated new DNA profiles suitable for the FBI’s national database, leading to fresh investigative leads. While many findings have been forwarded to the District Attorney's Office, specific details remain confidential as these criminal proceedings are still ongoing.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

Law enforcement in Greenville County, South Carolina, recently announced a significant breakthrough in the 1986 homicide of eighteen-year-old Chelsie Yvonne Moss. Following the reopening of the case in 2023, forensic DNA testing successfully linked the victim to Ronnie Lee Williams, a sixty-four-year-old man currently imprisoned for a separate murder. This decades-old mystery was originally centered on a discovery in a wooded area where the victim suffered fatal blunt force trauma. While this scientific advancement has led to a formal murder charge, investigators are still appealing to the public for historical details regarding the suspect's past associations. The sheriff's office emphasized that this arrest aims to provide long-awaited closure for the family and demonstrates their persistence in solving cold cases.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

Authorities in Lexington, Kentucky, recently announced the resolution of a homicide case involving the 1998 death of Linda Marie Rutledge. After nearly three decades, investigators utilized ballistic evidence and DNA technology to link the crime to Robert Eugene Brashers, a man who died in 1999. A critical breakthrough occurred when a shell casing found at the local crime scene matched evidence from an infamous cold case in Austin, Texas. Forensic testing confirmed that Brashers' genetic profile was present in both locations, providing definitive proof of his involvement. This development highlights the successful collaboration between multiple law enforcement agencies and the impact of modern forensic advancements. While the suspect cannot be prosecuted, the findings offer long-awaited closure for a case that had remained a mystery for twenty-seven years.



This episode includes AI-generated content.

The episode examines the unsolved abduction of Nancy Guthrie, the elderly mother of news anchor Savannah Guthrie, who was taken from her Arizona home in early 2026. Investigators face significant hurdles, including the extremely dark conditions and rugged geography of the Catalina Foothills which may have helped the kidnappers evade security cameras. Tensions have mounted between local and federal authorities over the handling of evidence, while experts suggest that missteps at the crime scene further compromised the search. Despite the recovery of cryptic ransom notes claiming the victim may have died, no suspects have been named and the family continues to plea for information. Overall, the episode highlights how a combination of difficult terrain, bureaucratic infighting, and high-profile media attention has caused the trail to go cold.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

Unsolved investigations often stall for decades due to limited technology, shifting police priorities, and the loss of institutional memory. However, the passage of time can also become an investigative asset as personal loyalties fade and guilty consciences lead to late-life confessions. Modern breakthroughs are frequently driven by forensic genetic genealogy, a process that uses DNA databases to build family trees and identify suspects or victims. While these scientific tools are revolutionary, their success is often restricted by high costs and departmental budget constraints. New legislation and the use of artificial intelligence are being explored to help navigate the massive backlog of hundreds of thousands of cold cases. Ultimately, solving these mysteries provides families with long-awaited resolution, proving that time can eventually transform a stagnant file into a closed case.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

This episode details the upcoming Idaho Missing Persons Day event, which coincides with the 25th anniversary of the disappearance of Amber Hoopes. Local officials and family members will gather at the Bonneville County Courthouse to honor Hoopes and over 180 other individuals who remain missing throughout the state. The text explains that Hoopes was abducted in 2001, and while a suspect was eventually identified and died during a police confrontation, her remains have never been located. By officially proclaiming this day of remembrance, the community aims to foster public awareness, education, and support for families still seeking answers. The source serves as both a tribute to victims and a call for any anonymous tips that might help solve these cold cases.

This episode includes AI-generated content.

Following a search by a volunteer dive crew, a vehicle was discovered submerged in a Leawood retention pond using specialized sonar equipment. Authorities confirmed that the car’s license plate corresponds with a vehicle involved in an active missing persons investigation. Local law enforcement, including an underwater recovery team from Overland Park, worked together to extract the car from the water on Saturday afternoon. While the vehicle is tied to a specific case, officials have not yet publicly disclosed the identity of the individual involved. Police are currently in the process of contacting the family of the missing person to provide updates on the discovery. This investigation remains ongoing as investigators examine the evidence found at the Norwood Street location.

This episode includes AI-generated content.