The guys kick things off with a little history lesson on Hallmark's Christmas in July—from its beginnings with a single weekend in 2012 and how it evolved, to the very first original July Christmas movie in 2015 (yes, it's a Lacey Chabert classic), where the event stands today, and the highest-rated Christmas in July originals of all time.

Then it's on to Christmas in July 2026 – Week 2 as Kat Barrell (The Christmas Baby) and Stephen Huszar (Melt My Heart This Christmas) star in O Little Christmas Market. The script feels like a classic Hallmark movie from a decade ago—formulaic? Sure. Creative? Absolutely.

This movie has a little bit of everything: miniature Christmas displays, shipping containers, a lonely Christmas tree in a train station, a charming holiday market... and, naturally, developers threatening to tear it all down.

And, of course, we ask the important questions. Rich can't figure out why Grayson doesn't hop the next train home—or where he found that tuxedo in town. Meanwhile, Rene investigates the cost of moving shipping containers and isn't afraid to question Zoey's wardrobe choices.

As always, we cover:

• Behind-the-scenes movie fun facts.
 • Our favorite moments.
 • Scenes we’d rewrite.
 • The best supporting characters.
 • “Are We Sure?” — our ultimate Hallmark logic check.
 • Will Grayson and Olivia last as a couple?
 • The Mistletoe Meter – How good of a final kiss did Olivia and Grayson give us? We’ll give it a letter grade.
 • Who (or what) truly won the movie.
 • We rate the film and talk about what movie is coming up next!

For the love of Hallmark!

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

Email: [email protected]

*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media. 

Hallmark’s Christmas in July 2026 kicks off with Christmas Under Construction, a movie that first debuted on Hulu two years earlier. Fan favorites Daniel Lissing and Jessica Lowndes reunite a decade after Hallmark’s beloved December Bride. But after ten years, is the chemistry still there?

For a movie with only eight speaking roles, there’s a surprising amount going on. There’s a couples therapist who moonlights as a home renovation host, her boyfriend who’s obsessed with every grooming trend imaginable, a man determined to preserve his grandfather’s cozy cabin, and a girlfriend eager to knock down walls, modernize it, and flip it for a profit. Add an uptight media executive and an ambitious gossip columnist, and you’ve got... quite the mix.

As always, we keep it real. Beyond the romance and renovations, we tackle the big question: Does Christmas Under Construction actually feel like a Hallmark movie? Let the friendly debate begin.

As always, we cover:

• Behind-the-scenes movie fun facts.
 • Our favorite moments.
 • Scenes we’d rewrite.
 • The best supporting characters.
 • “Are We Sure?” — our ultimate Hallmark logic check.
 • Cooper and Chelsea… will their relationship last?
 • The Mistletoe Meter – Chelsea and Cooper give us two kisses towards the end of the film. We’ll give them both a letter grade.
 • Who (or what) truly won the movie.
 • We rate the film and talk about what movie is coming up next!

For the love of Hallmark!

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

Email: [email protected]

*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media. 

Evergreen… Part Three! This time we’re heading back to Hallmark’s beloved Christmas town for Christmas in Evergreen: Tidings of Joy (2019), featuring a star-studded cast led by Maggie Lawson and Paul Greene in their second Hallmark movie together. Joining them are Ashley Williams, Jill Wagner, Holly Robinson Peete, and Barbara Niven.

A 50-year-old time capsule takes center stage, Evergreen’s magical snow globe suffers an unexpected mishap, and three intertwined romances keep the Christmas spirit alive as the town once again works its holiday magic.

Hallmark writer Zac Hug was finding his stride with the network, delivering an ambitious script packed with memorable characters, multiple storylines, and plenty of star power—yet somehow making it all come together very nicely.

In this episode, we cover:

• Behind-the-scenes movie fun facts.
 • Our favorite moments.
 • Scenes we’d rewrite.
 • The best supporting characters.
 • “Are We Sure?” — our ultimate Hallmark logic check. And we’ve got a bunch.
 • Ben and Katie… will their relationship last?
 • The Mistletoe Meter – Katie and Ben with FIVE kisses… which might be a record! We’ll give them a letter grade.
 • Who (or what) truly won the movie.
 • We rate the film and talk about what movies are coming up next!

For the love of Hallmark!

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

Email: [email protected]

*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media. 

Rich and Rene join forces with Amy and Garry from Pour the Wine, It's Romcom Time (so grab a glass of vino) to celebrate Hallmark's landmark 2022 film, A Holiday Spectacular.

Then we hit the Hallmark lottery.

Writer Julie Sherman Wolfe joins us for an incredible behind-the-scenes look at one of Hallmark's most ambitious projects ever: a period piece set in 1958 and centered around the legendary Radio City Rockettes.

Think you know this movie? Think again.

In this episode:

• How a conversation between Rich and director John Putch led to Julie joining the podcast.

• Julie's journey from stand-up comedy to sitcom writing, Disney Channel projects, and a five-year road to her first Hallmark movie, Hello, It's Me.

• How a family connection to the Rockettes sparked the original meeting that eventually became A Holiday Spectacular.

• The writing process behind one of Hallmark's most ambitious productions—and how it differed from her other films.

• What it was like attending the film's premiere inside Radio City Music Hall—including the celebrity who left her star-struck and the musical performance she'll never forget.

• The late-night conversation at the premier with two Hallmark actresses that ultimately inspired a couple of 2025 Hallmark films (think… Spain).

• The movie's original title (and no, it wasn't A Holiday Spectacular).

• Why 1958 was the perfect setting for the story and how the Rockettes' sisterhood reminded Julie of her own friendships with two fellow Hallmark writers.

• How Hallmark keeps pairing her scripts with incredible Broadway talent, including Ginna Claire Mason and Derek Klena leading the way in this film.

• The Hallmark destinations she still hopes to write about someday.

And of course, Julie joins us for rapid-fire questions:

Eggnog: yay or nay?
 Classic or modern Christmas music?
 Real or artificial tree?
 Ugly Christmas sweaters?

(Spoiler: Julie has quite the collection.)

Bottom line: fire up Hallmark+, watch (or rewatch) the extended cut with 18 additional minutes of Hallmark magic, then settle in for 75 minutes of stories, insights, and behind-the-scenes details that will make you appreciate this movie more than ever.

For the love of Hallmark!

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

Email: [email protected]

Follow Amy and Garry: www.instagram.com/pourthewineitsromcomtime

Follow Julie: www.instagram.com/julie_sherman_wolfe

*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media. 

Kimberley Sustad’s first Hallmark movie. Andrew Walker’s Hallmark debut. Arielle Kebbel’s first turn with the network too. With an average age of just 28, our three leads bring plenty of youthful energy - but don’t expect perfection. This movie is packed with wonderfully flawed characters!

In A Bride for Christmas (2012) - Writer Barbara Kymlicka delivers a clever, sharp script that borrows a few elements from the 2003 movie How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days and somehow turns them into pure Hallmark magic. Bonkers, ridiculous, outrageous... and completely impossible to stop watching.

And the "dog shelter kiss" in this movie is considered one of the best in Hallmark history… will it pass the Mistletoe Meter grading criteria? 

In this episode, we cover:

• Behind-the-scenes movie fun facts
 • The best moment
 • What we’d rewrite in 2026
 • Those supporting characters who deserved more screen time
 • “Are We Sure?” — much needed Hallmark logic checks
 • We know Aiden and Jessie get married – but would their relationship have lasted if the movie ended with them only engaged?
 • The multiple kisses (four in all!)… and the letter grades they earned – one was steamy!!!
 • The MVP of the movie
 • Our personal — and completely meaningless — final rating

For the love of Hallmark!

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

Email: [email protected]

*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media. 

Kimberley Sustad's first Hallmark starring role. Brandon Routh fresh off a career that includes playing Superman. Firefighters. Cats. A terrific Nancey Silvers script. And one of the most delightfully unlikeable characters Hallmark has ever given us.

That's the recipe for the 2014 fan favorite The Nine Lives of Christmas. And Hallmark fans clearly agree—when Entertainment Weekly ranked the best all-time Hallmark Christmas movies back in 2025, Nine Lives landed at #2, second only to A Biltmore Christmas.

In this episode, we cover:

• Behind-the-scenes movie fun facts
 • Our favorite moments
 • Scenes we’d rewrite
 • The best supporting characters
 • “Are We Sure?” — our ultimate Hallmark logic check
 • Whether Marilee and Zach would actually last as a couple
 • The multiple kisses… and the letter grades they earned
 • Who (or what) truly won the movie
 • Our personal — and unbiased — final rating

For the love of Hallmark!

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

Email: [email protected]

*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media. 

Erin Cahill (Megan) may be one of Hallmark’s most charming leading ladies. And Rich and Rene are confident enough to admit it: Ryan Paevey (Charles) is one remarkably handsome dude.

Things get delightfully complicated when Charles travels from 1903 to 2020 and must convince Megan—a historian who has spent years studying his life—that he’s actually the man she’s written about.

This beloved 2020 Hallmark favorite was written and directed by Hallmark legend Ron Oliver (Christmas at the Plaza, The Christmas Train), and he provides us with incredible behind-the-scenes stories about how the movie came to life. SPOILER: It almost didn’t.

Featuring a magical Christmas clock, a time-travel twist, a stellar supporting cast, and some of the most heartfelt conversations ever seen in a Hallmark Christmas movie, this one gives us plenty to discuss.

In this episode:
 • Behind-the-scenes stories from Ron Oliver
 • Our favorite moments—and Ron’s favorites, too
 • Scenes we'd rewrite
 • The MVP supporting characters
 • “Are We Sure?” — our Hallmark logic check
 • Will Charles and Megan actually make it?
 • The final kiss
 • Who (or what) really won the movie
 • Our completely objective and totally unbiased final rating

For the love of Hallmark!

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

Email: [email protected]

*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media. 

Bethany Joy Lenz (Emily) may be the best actress Hallmark has ever seen. Tyler Hynes (Jamie) is arguably the most popular leading man in Hallmark history. And Paul Campbell — already beloved as a Hallmark leading man — has also become one of the network’s most talented writers.

Put them all together and you get the 2021 Hallmark Christmas favorite: An Unexpected Christmas.

When Variety released its 2025 list, “The 25 Best Hallmark Christmas Movies, Ranked,” the Hallmark world exploded with debate… and their #1 pick was none other than An Unexpected Christmas! 

In this episode, we cover:

• Behind-the-scenes movie fun facts
 • Our favorite moments
 • Scenes we’d rewrite
 • The best supporting characters
 • “Are We Sure?” — our ultimate Hallmark logic check
 • Whether Emily and Jamie would actually last as a couple
 • The multiple kisses… and the letter grades they earned
 • Who (or what) truly won the movie
 • Our personal — and unbiased — final rating

For the love of Hallmark!

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

Email: [email protected]

*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media. 

Hallmark Christmas in July gets a little hotter with Crashing Through the Snow! Starring Amy Acker as Maggie - a divorced mom invited to spend Christmas in Aspen with her ex and his soon-to-be fiancée Kate - the movie takes off when Kate’s charming brother Sam (Warren Christie) unexpectedly arrives home from Japan. The chemistry between Maggie and Sam? Off the charts… and not exactly your typical Hallmark romance.

Rich and Rene rave about the sharp script from Tamar Laddy, heartfelt conversations, gorgeous Christmas décor, and Maggie’s endless ability to trip over absolutely everything. Rene wonders why everyone in this town is so unbelievably nice - and why nobody seems more excited that Sam is finally home. Rich, meanwhile, has questions about Maggie’s miraculous ice-skating improvement… and whether Gremlins really belongs on a “best Christmas movie” list.

The guys also break down the unforgettable hot springs scene, debate the movie MVP, and react to a final kiss that may rank among Hallmark’s all-time best.

Bottom line: this might be one of the steamiest, funniest, and most emotionally honest Christmas movies Hallmark has ever made.

For the love of Hallmark!

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

Email: [email protected]

*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media. 

It’s Christmas in Evergreen… round two! In Letters to Santa, Jill Wagner and Mark Deklin lead the second installment in Hallmark’s beloved Evergreen franchise. Since the original Christmas in Evergreen earned a pretty strong grade in one of our very first podcast reviews, the big question is: does the sequel deliver the same holiday magic?

Rich is thrilled to see Allie — and her iconic red truck — return, loves the movie’s three “almost kisses,” and still considers Evergreen one of Hallmark’s all-time coziest Christmas towns. Rene falls hard for the flashback scenes, the story behind the Christmas letter, and of course… a top-tier cookie decorating montage.

But not everything sleighs. Rich wonders if the movie juggles one too many storylines and can’t stop doing the math on Kevin supposedly writing the letter 25 years earlier at age seven. Rene thinks the couple’s first big conflict feels forced and wishes Lisa and Oliver’s relationship had been defined more clearly.

The guys also debate the best supporting character, question Evergreen’s apparent shortage of contractors, and wonder why the inn lobby looks ready to host a symphony orchestra. Rene raises an eyebrow at Lisa’s mechanic skills, while Rich nitpicks the final kiss enough to keep it from earning an A-grade.

Add in an emotional reveal, a strong ice skating scene, an MVP disagreement, and one of the biggest score splits of the year… and you’ve got another festive Evergreen debate you won’t want to miss.

We keep it fun, keep it real, and always… keep it Hallmark Christmas.

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

Email: [email protected]

*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media.