Finding Santa (2017) proves that not every Hallmark Christmas movie needs to be overly deep and complex — sometimes a cozy holiday romcom is exactly what the season ordered. Rich and Rene don’t quite see eye-to-eye on Ben and Grace’s chemistry, debate the best supporting character, and — like the seasoned professionals we are — assign letter grades to two kissing scenes with four overall kisses (with “Professor” Rich nearly handing out a failing grade to one of them). And that public proposal? Let’s just say one of us was swooning… the other was not. Plus: Is Santa school actually a thing, or just classic Hallmark magic? And who (or what) was the Christmas MVP of the movie? Listen now and find out! And if you love Hallmark Christmas as much as we do, hit follow so you don’t miss a single cozy breakdown.

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

*** The Forever Hallmark Christmas Podcast is not affiliated with Hallmark Media. Image courtesy of Hallmark Media.

In this episode, we’re reviewing Christmas in Evergreen, and we’re convinced writer Rick Garman must have had a checklist: How many incredible Christmas vibes can we pack into one movie? From a puppy-filled opening scene to a final kiss that Rene analyzes in impressive detail, this one keeps the holiday energy rolling. Along the way we tackle the big questions: Was Spencer too nice? Do Allie and Ryan last as a couple? Should Zoe have gone on the cruise? And which member of the incredible (and it was incredible!) supporting cast deserved more screen time? As always, we keep it real, we keep it fun, and we keep it Christmas.

Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas

*** The Forever Hallmark Christmas Podcast is not affiliated with Hallmark Media. Image courtesy of Hallmark Media. 

The Most Wonderful Time of the Year tries to convince us that complete opposites really can make it work. Along the way, we get a few things we’re not sure Hallmark would show in 2026 - one of our stars stepping on someone’s throat outside a bar, our female lead making a memorable post-shower entrance, and… did our male lead really bash someone with a trash can lid? And hey, we’re okay with all of it. At its heart, this movie is about bonds—mother to son, uncle to niece, and even stranger to stranger… and it all works. We debate the MVP of the movie, whether that final kiss gets a passing grade, and why we’d both rewrite the final two minutes if given the chance. And if you need one last reason to watch… two words: The Fonz.

*** The Forever Hallmark Christmas Podcast is not affiliated with Hallmark Media. Image courtesy of Hallmark Media.