Nearly half of all households in the United States have at least one dog. Many have multiple dogs. All of those dogs were bred somehow and somewhere. This episode is to increase awareness of where your puppies and dogs may have come from. In particular, I will be focusing on commercial dog breeders known as puppy mills. Specifically, those located in the state of Ohio, even though they exist worldwide.
Puppy mills are not the reputable breeders your friends or family may have recommended you get your puppy from. Commonly, they are unsanitary and have inadequate veterinary care. Their dogs are overbred and ill-bred, live in crowded undersized crates, and are provided insufficient socialization time, if any at all. There is no limit to how many dogs can be in one building. It can be hundreds. It is doubtful that there are enough people to properly care for the dogs housed in one location.
Puppy mill owners typically use brokers who act as “middlemen” between the puppy mills and pet stores, breeders and online sales. However, they can also sell directly from their kennels to prospective customers like us. Many customers may not realize that they are dealing with a large-scale commercial breeder. The facilities, which can house hundreds of puppies, are often located at a distance from the point of sale and may not be visible to buyers. These breeders frequently transport animals across state lines. Puppies raised in such conditions may experience significant stress, potentially leading to behavioral challenges such as fearfulness or aggression.
There are puppy mills who relinquish breeder dogs, and sometimes puppies to rescue groups and shelters. They also call rescue groups to let them know that they have a certain amount of puppies or dogs they need to move out of their facility within hours. Some of the reasons could be:
* an upcoming inspection
* not adhering to size requirements of crates per dog
* dogs can no longer produce puppies for health reasons
* shoddy veterinary procedures
* cost of euthanasia
For this episode, I introduce two women from Columbus who are passionate in their advocacy for dogs and decided to do something about it. Stefanie Mowrey, seated next to me in the studio, and Zaron Van Meter, have tirelessly volunteered their spare time for many years by fostering, rescuing, and adopting dogs.
Stefanie is a registered nurse whose passion for animals has endured since childhood. She was heavily influenced by a “60 Minutes” episode decades ago which depicted the unsavory conditions of puppy mills. It captivated her attention to take action when she became an adult. She started fostering, adopting and then volunteering at the local Humane Society, and for the Ohio state chapter of Bailing Out Benji., where she met Zaron. Bailing Out Benji is a national non-profit organization which advocates for dogs in puppy mills and also provides research and education about them.
While volunteering, Stefanie became more aware of the increasing number of dogs and puppies from mills and backyard breeders ending up in shelters and rescues. All too often, the shelters were already at capacity. Therefore, they have to rely heavily on fosters to take in dogs, especially puppies.
Stefanie uses the example in our podcast of the shelter she volunteers for. This shelter will only adopt “puppy mill breeder dogs” out to a home that already has a resident dog in order to help the mill dog become less anxious and learn how to actually be a dog. Some puppy mill dogs do not know how to play. They don’t know how to socialize with people or other dogs.
As a dog trainer, I know that the best teacher for dogs like this are other patient, gentle dogs. Dogs learn quickest and most effectively from other dogs, but it has to be the right type of dog. Dogs also want to know where they fit in their pack. A dominant and/or guard dog in this situation with a fearful newcomer can cause havoc. It is also up to the humans in the pack to ensure the safety of those involved.
Zaron Van Meter is a business owner and has been an advocate for dogs for over 25 years. Through her involvement as the founder of SK9 Scottish Terrier Rescue, she organized presentations by well-known devoted companion animal advocates, such as Cesar Millan, Dr. Jean Dodds, Temple Grandin, and Dave Hunt(an expert on dog fighting).
In 2012, Zaron was instrumental as an activist in getting an anti-puppy mill law passed included in Senate Bill 130 (Ohio Revised Code 956.20)1️⃣ which mandates better living spaces, regular vet exams, and health certificates for every dog that is sold to a vendor, like a retail pet store. Violations to this code is a misdemeanor.
Zaron and Stefanie wanted to do even more to help out by reducing the amount of dogs coming from puppy mills, with the ultimate goal of eliminating them. They became involved in educating the public and informing Ohio legislators of the need to close loopholes in the current laws to protect dogs who come from all commercial breeders.
In my opinion, there is not enough attention and priority given to puppy mills by the public and the government agencies that oversee them. More regulations need to be passed and current regulations need to be enforced more effectively. A light needs to be shined on these factories of sadness for the benefit of the dogs and the customers who unknowingly purchase them.
There are laws and agencies to oversee and enforce existing regulations against the breeders. On a state level, there is the Ohio Department of Agriculture. On a federal level, it is the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA). Existing laws preventing abuse are rarely enforced. If they are, often the penalty is simply a fine. Breeders who have received many violations have been known to change their name and operate under a different licensed name.
Even the mission statement of the Ohio Department of Agriculture, which oversees the high volume commercial dog breeder kennels, gives no mention to dogs. It reads:
“To protect Ohio citizens by ensuring food supply safety, maintaining the health of plants and animals, and creating economic opportunities for the state’s farmers, food processors, and agribusinesses, all while preserving resources and supporting the state’s largest industry.”2️⃣
In Ohio, dogs are currently similarly classified as livestock. We all know and love our dogs as loving companions that share our homes and are members of our families. To think that dogs are also viewed as property and can be discarded at the whim of these commercial breeders is beyond sad. Their well-being is not at the forefront of their business plan. It all comes down to money. If a breeder dog can no longer have puppies for health reasons or overbreeding, they cease to be a moneymaker. They are discarded or euthanized. Their best chance for survival is to be transported to rescue groups or shelters and eventually adopted by a loving family.
Laws in Ohio need to be passed to change the classification of our beloved dogs to be recognized as companion animals, not livestock. Examples of states that consider dogs’ welfare and best interest are New York, California, and New Hampshire. More states are updating their regulations and classification concerning dogs. Within the past two years, Pennsylvania joined suit. Ohio can too with your support!
The Ohio Department of Agriculture(ODA) inspects high volume commercial dog breeders. However, there are only 5 inspectors in the entire state to cover the approximately 475 that exist.3️⃣ In 2025, Ohio was designated once again, the second worst state in the nation, with 16 commercial breeders committing major egregious violations. 4️⃣ This is according to the Humane Society of the United States’ (now known as The Humane World for Animals) list called “The Horrible Hundred”. These mills are sometimes documented repeat offenders that should be shut down.
Currently, ODA inspections are announced. This is why puppy mills will dump numerous puppies/dogs at a time at a shelter or elsewhere before the inspection date. Mill breeders know they will be fined because of the health conditions of certain puppies or because they lack required paperwork.
Legislation in Ohio needs to return to the original code stating inspections be unannounced. This way the proprietors would not be able to hide the true conditions of the living quarters for the puppies and dogs. More inspectors need to be hired, trained and protected from zoonotic diseases that can pass from puppies to humans.
One disease that is becoming more prevalent in puppy mills is brucellosis. According to Dr. Felicia Nonnenmacher at Animal Clinic Northview, there is a simple blood test to screen for brucellosis. Most reputable breeders have their breeder dogs tested annually to make sure they do not expose positively tested dogs to people and other dogs. If a dog tests positive, antibiotics can be attempted, but unfortunately do not always lead to a cure. Euthanasia is recommended. Fortunately, Dr. Nonnenmacher has not seen a case of brucellosis in her practice. Zaron describes in our recording an experience a woman had in Canada with a dog she added to her existing pack that had brucellosis. It did not end well for her and her own dogs.
Under the current Ohio law (code 956.20), when puppy mills sell to pet stores, the pet stores must provide paperwork to prospective buyers which include:
* puppy’s date of birth
* puppy’s breed including color, gender, and identifying marks
* name and address of the breeder or kennel
* health info, including vaccinations signed by a licensed vet
* when the pet store took possession of the puppy
* breeder’s USDA license number and inspection report (if applicable)
Shady breeders hope that people won’t do their homework and research. Their website may look professional and inviting. They may say all the right things on the phone, but they are sourcing their puppies from puppy mills.
Questionable breeders depend on impulse buyers. They advertise online and post pictures of adorable puppies. They count on prospective customers falling in love at the sight of these posing puppies. It is not difficult to hook them into a deal to buy them. The puppies in the picture below had Parvo - a potentially fatal and highly contagious virus that causes diarrhea and severe vomiting. One did not survive. They look cute, but their disease can easily be hidden.
These puppies are not cheap. They are the same puppies that are sold for thousands of dollars at pet stores. On top of that, if puppies are not bred for their genes and temperament, they can cost thousands more dollars to correct health and behavioral issues. They could have been traumatized in their living quarters at the puppy mill, which can trigger fear or aggression issues. In some cases, these issues cannot be “trained out”. More often than not, some dog trainers do not want to take on or rehab severe fear or aggression cases. Shelters will not take them in if they have a bite history. Their future is grim.
Guilt falls on the humans running these operations, all in the name of greed. It is up to the customer, and prospective pet parent, to be aware and do the hard work of researching and verifying their breeder of choice. The tricky thing about getting a puppy or dog from a breeder is you may think they are reputable. They may say all the right things to make you purchase a puppy or dog from them, but they really are part of a bigger network that gets their dogs from puppy mill breeders.
Classic signs that the breeder your puppy or dog was sourced from a puppy mill include:
* lack of transparency about the mother and father of the puppy
* health certificates and papers not accompanied with puppy
* puppy is delivered to your doorstep or at a neutral location away from the kennel
* reluctance and resistance to answering your questions
* urgency to sell puppies - puppies must be sold right away
* injuries and diseases not disclosed
* poorly docked tails or clipped ears
* malnourished appearance
* many different breeds bred on premises
As Stefanie explains, shelters are overwhelmed. They already have enough dogs to take care of that come from the general population who either don’t want or can no longer take care of their dog. On top of that, they get litters coming from puppy mills. Space and funding for some of these shelters depend on donations. Volunteers help feed and walk these dogs. Vets give their valuable time to provide as much veterinary care as possible. Resources and volunteers are limited. Shelters are overcrowded. Puppies and dogs suffer from the overtaxed system.
Stefanie and Zaron experienced puppy mill dogs through their rescue and volunteer work. As a practice, Zaron did not adopt or foster puppy mill dogs. However, while volunteering for the Scottish Terrier Rescue, they received notification that Scottish Terriers needed to find homes ASAP. This is referred to as a puppy mill bust. Zaron took in three Scottish Terriers that day. She happened to be having a fundraising garage sale for her rescue group. She decided to display the pups in a pen at her garage sale to see if they could be adopted.
More importantly, Zaron wanted to educate the passersby on what puppy mill puppies looked like fresh out of the mill. She found homes for two of them. Zaron ended up keeping the third puppy because this puppy was so terrified of the world. Zaron named her McKenzie. Zaron knew she could end up with an owner lacking knowledge on how to properly deal with a fearful dog. McKenzie was an added incentive for Zaron to fight even harder for better conditions, more inspections, and more regulations on breeder dogs.
Recounting Stefanie’s story about a foster “win” illustrates an all too common occurrence with puppy mill puppies. Late one night, three years ago, while laying in bed and scrolling through her messages from the Humane Society she volunteers for, Stefanie received notification of an emergency foster plea. There were female breeder dogs and Rottweiler puppies from a different mother, that were 9 weeks old. The puppy mill kept the Rottweiler puppies’ mother to breed again. Either she or the stud had structural issues that were passed down to at least one of the puppies, as you will discover in detail below. Reputable breeders would never rebreed a female or male with health, behavioral or structural issues.
The Rottweiler puppies and breeder dogs had already been purchased to be sold to a particular pet store. However, when the broker arrived at the puppy mill, he/she did not want them because the puppies were too small to be successfully sold at a pet store. Therefore, time was of the essence, and the Humane Society needed to find fosters for these pups, or else their fate would be doomed.
Stefanie and her husband fostered one of the Rottweiler puppies and unintentionally fell in love. They named him Mac. Right away, Stefanie noticed that Mac would whine whenever she would pick him up and support his rear end with her hand. She thought it was because his tail had been freshly docked. Little did she ever imagine that it was because he had a broken hip! Stefanie and her husband didn’t find this out until he started limping about a year later. Mac had already been diagnosed with bilateral elbow dysplasia. Surgery would have cost $11,000 to fix it with no guarantee of success.
Additional x-rays revealed that Mac had a severely broken hip that had healed incorrectly. After consulting with one of the best orthopedic surgeons in the nation at The Ohio State University, it was determined that Mac did not appear to be in any pain from this horrific injury he sustained as a puppy. The total hip replacement surgery would have cost $8,000. Instead, the vet determined that Mac’s condition could be maintained with medication and lead a normal life, and that’s exactly what has happened. He currently lives happily with his 3 pack mates in Stefanie’s home.
It’s one thing to know that the puppy or dog you are getting is from a puppy mill and you are willing to take on possible health and behavioral issues stemming from those conditions. It’s another thing when you are led to believe that your puppy came from a reputable breeder, but you were deceived. This is only discovered if you start researching why your dog has health or behavioral issues and the breeder is not forthcoming with the truth. These dogs still need loving homes even though they come from a business that you believe is not an ethical one. The more we support the puppy mill breeders, the longer they will stay in business.
Abuse should never be tolerated. It should always be reported. What makes animal abuse unique is they don’t have a voice to report their abuse. We have to be their voice.
More action is needed by the general public to put pressure on our legislators. No longer can we sit back and remain silent while our loving companions are being mistreated in so many ways. If you believe that your puppy came from a puppy mill and you were deceived, please write a letter to your legislator.
You can also send Zaron and Stefanie an email which will be hand delivered and read to representatives in Columbus. Time is of the essence. Zaron and Stefanie will find out days before the committee hearings are scheduled for oral or written testimony on a current and pending legislation SB232. This piece of legislation, supported by Senator Casey Weinstein will involve stricter regulations ensuring the welfare of dogs in puppy mills. This will be explained in more detail in my next episode to be aired on January 20.
Dogs deserve better and we are the only ones who can speak up for them.
1️⃣. “Ohio Laws Legislative Service Commission”, http://codes.ohio.gov
2️⃣. “Ohio Department of Agriculture”, http://agri.ohio.gov, “last updated January 2018.
3️⃣. “Ohio Department of Agriculture”, http://agri.ohio.gov, “last updated January 2018.
4️⃣. “Humane World for Animals”, http://humaneworld.org, “last modified 2025”
Thanks for reading From A Dog’s Eye View! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Thanks for reading From A Dog’s Eye View! This post is public so feel free to share it.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit canineconcierge.substack.com