The Mob Mentality Show

From the Birth of XP to the Death of Scrum with Tobias Mayer


Listen Later

In this thought-provoking episode, we sit down with Tobias Mayer—author, coach, and longtime voice in the Agile world—to explore the journey from his early discovery of XP (Extreme Programming) in 1997 all the way to today’s debate around the death of Scrum.

Tobias shares his personal transformation from developer to Scrum Master, his resistance to early XP, and how he learned great practices from developers he managed. We unpack his reflections on Agile’s semantic drift, the role of Scrum Masters as change agents vs. bean counters, and what happens when teams do Agile without even knowing the Agile Manifesto.

🔍 Topics we dive deep into:

  • Discovering XP through a paper against it 😅

  • When “Scrum” became a buzzword and what was lost in translation

  • What it really means to live the values of the Agile Manifesto

  • XP coaches, grassroots change, and learning from your team

  • The difference between top-down control and emergent discovery

  • Misused metaphors in tech: “firefighting,” “war rooms,” “soldiers,” and more

  • Are software teams more like engineers, artisans, or ensembles?

  • Can DORA metrics (DevOps Research and Assessment) prove or disprove Agile’s effectiveness?

  • We also dig into mob programming (aka mobbing)—what it means, why the name matters, and whether or not new metaphors like “ensemble programming” or “teaming” (à la Amy Edmondson) better reflect how high-performing teams really work.

    💡 Plus:

    • The problem with the Product Owner (PO) role in Scrum

    • Why language in IT shapes behavior—for better or worse

    • Applying Artful Making to modern product development

    • Rethinking business through the lens of theatre, philosophy, and cooperative economics

    • The importance of psychological safety, dissent, and experimentation in creating real agility

    • Tobias brings rich context from classics, theology, and history—yes, even turning a conference t-shirt into fashion—to challenge how we think about building products, teams, and businesses.

      🛠️ Whether you're into XP, Scrum, Mob Programming, Lean, or simply want to rethink your metaphors and language at work, this episode delivers grounded insight, sharp critique, and fresh perspectives.

      👉 Subscribe for more conversations at the intersection of agile thinking, real teamwork, and modern product development.


      Video and show notes: https://youtu.be/ZFoY-De91BE   

      ...more
      View all episodesView all episodes
      Download on the App Store

      The Mob Mentality ShowBy The Mob Mentality Show

      • 5
      • 5
      • 5
      • 5
      • 5

      5

      7 ratings


      More shows like The Mob Mentality Show

      View all
      Freakonomics Radio by Freakonomics Radio + Stitcher

      Freakonomics Radio

      32,120 Listeners

      Odd Lots by Bloomberg

      Odd Lots

      1,866 Listeners

      Software Engineering Radio by se-radio@computer.org

      Software Engineering Radio

      273 Listeners

      Hanselminutes with Scott Hanselman by Scott Hanselman

      Hanselminutes with Scott Hanselman

      380 Listeners

      Software Engineering Daily by Software Engineering Daily

      Software Engineering Daily

      625 Listeners

      Soft Skills Engineering by Jamison Dance and Dave Smith

      Soft Skills Engineering

      284 Listeners

      Thoughtworks Technology Podcast by Thoughtworks

      Thoughtworks Technology Podcast

      42 Listeners

      The TWIML AI Podcast (formerly This Week in Machine Learning & Artificial Intelligence) by Sam Charrington

      The TWIML AI Podcast (formerly This Week in Machine Learning & Artificial Intelligence)

      434 Listeners

      The Daily by The New York Times

      The Daily

      112,394 Listeners

      Badass Agile by Fuse Chamber, Inc

      Badass Agile

      24 Listeners

      Troubleshooting Agile by A weekly problem-solving session for all things agile

      Troubleshooting Agile

      12 Listeners

      .NET Rocks! by Carl Franklin and Richard Campbell

      .NET Rocks!

      244 Listeners

      The Journal. by The Wall Street Journal & Spotify Studios

      The Journal.

      6,062 Listeners

      The Rest Is Politics by Goalhanger

      The Rest Is Politics

      3,085 Listeners

      The Rest Is Politics: US by Goalhanger

      The Rest Is Politics: US

      2,201 Listeners