Blind Abilities

From the Pocket: The Confusing World of Service Dogs


Listen Later

From the Mother Nature Network website

The confusing world of service dogs

mnn.com
The term “service dog” is used a lot in public these days. What was once an assistance animal for blind or deaf individuals, highly trained service dogs are now helping people with a wide range of disabilities, acting as seizure alert dogs, PTSD service dogs, alerting a handler with diabetes to when his blood sugar dips, and so much more.

However, as an understanding of the broadened range of what a trained service animal can do

reaches the general public, and with the important work the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) has done to increase public accessibility and privacy for people with service animals, it has become common for people to call their pets service animals even when they don’t meet the legal definition.

Related reading: 11 things that humans do that dogs hate

A lot of people are interested in calling their pet dogs service animals for reasons that have little to do with mitigating the effects of a disability. Maybe it’s so they can bring their pet along on shopping trips, bring them on the plane with them during vacation, or get around housing restrictions for pets. Whatever the reason, claiming your dog is a service animal is no small thing. Those who want to have a dog as a constant companion or a working animal need to be aware of everything that claim entails legally — not to mention how it can effect the reputation of trained service animals everywhere.

Service dog versus therapy dog versus emotional support animal

There can be a lot of confusion about the different titles for dogs, particularly when it comes to public access. However, as Please Don’t Pet Me points out, “Differentiating between service dogs, therapy dogs and emotional support animals is not a matter of splitting hairs or political correctness. Each of these dogs has a very different job from the others and the terms are not interchangeable.”

Service dogs have been trained to perform specific tasks that help mitigate a handler’s disability.

A therapy dog provides comfort to people, particularly in hospitals, nursing homes and schools. While therapy dogs receive training on how to handle themselves in public and around the people they’re comforting, they are not trained to do specific tasks to help with a disability.

Emotional support animals (ESAs) are pets that provide a high level of comfort to the owner and do not have to have any training.

The only animal that legally can go to any public place the handler goes is a service dog.

ESAs have some additional legal protection under the Fair Housing Act; a person whose doctor has recommended they have an ESA can have their pet living with them, even in housing that has pet restrictions. They also have some protection under the Air Carrier Access Act, which allows a person with documentation to have their pet travel with them. However, an ESA is still a pet, not a service animal, and does not have the same public access as a service animal. In other words, while you can have your ESA living with you in a no-pet apartment, you can’t bring your ESA to the grocery store or coffee shop.

The American with Disabilities Act has an excellent FAQ that helps clarify the differences among service dogs, therapy dogs and ESAs. It can be a bit confusing even for those familiar with the territory, so it’s easy to imagine the confusion and frustration of business owners or other service providers who have to deal with people who claim a therapy dog or ESA is a service animal.

A working dog helps a vision-impaired handler. (Photo: Cylonphoto/Shutterstock)

So how do you know if a dog is legally considered a service animal? Ultimately,
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Blind AbilitiesBy Blind Abilities Team

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

50 ratings


More shows like Blind Abilities

View all
Stuff You Should Know by iHeartPodcasts

Stuff You Should Know

78,688 Listeners

Hidden Brain by Hidden Brain, Shankar Vedantam

Hidden Brain

43,687 Listeners

The Ramsey Show by Ramsey Network

The Ramsey Show

39,228 Listeners

Freedom Scientific FSCast by Freedom Scientific

Freedom Scientific FSCast

22 Listeners

Eyes On Success with hosts Peter and Nancy Torpey by Eyes On Success with hosts Peter and Nancy Torpey

Eyes On Success with hosts Peter and Nancy Torpey

21 Listeners

Mystic Access Podcast by Chris Nova, Kim Nova

Mystic Access Podcast

12 Listeners

Twenty Thousand Hertz by Dallas Taylor

Twenty Thousand Hertz

4,203 Listeners

RNIB Tech Talk by RNIB Connect Radio

RNIB Tech Talk

1 Listeners

Double Tap by Double Tap Productions Inc.

Double Tap

32 Listeners

Tek Talk by Accessible World

Tek Talk

4 Listeners

Freedom Scientific Training Podcast by Freedom Scientific Training Department

Freedom Scientific Training Podcast

28 Listeners

That Real Blind Tech Show by Brian Fischler, Ed Plumacher, and Allison Meloy

That Real Blind Tech Show

17 Listeners

Huberman Lab by Scicomm Media

Huberman Lab

29,272 Listeners

Double Tap Extra by Double Tap Productions, Inc.

Double Tap Extra

0 Listeners