“Some people stand togetherMeanwhile, I stand apart” - A Strange Loop Final SongAs I start my quest to find my own “Stephen Sodheim,” collaborator, and composer, I am focusing on seeing as much theater as possible. Rodeo’s libretto is about 80% and I just started character development on the second musical (more to come). Considering writing a musical is an endeavor I only started two years ago, the move to New York was meant to immerse myself in the community of theater makers. I want Color & Light to be about the process and inspiration, so my audience can learn along with me. And like great writers do, they read great writing. And great theater makers, they see great theater. In the last two months, I have seen A Strange Loop three times. The musical won the 2020 Pulitzer Prize for Drama and recently won Best Musical and Best Book at the Tony Awards in June 2022. (I will leave the synopsis to the below linked Terry Gross interview on NPR. The interview does a better job than I can at this point at describing the premise of the show).
One thing I noticed seeing a piece of theater multiple times is the nuance an actor/actress brings to a role. Even the sound can be different on one night. Yet, the biggest theme for me running through A Strange Loop is the difference in family dynamics. Usher, the main character, is a large, gay Black man raised in a Christian household. There is a Black acknowledgement of qualities of life, of personalities, relationships, and belief systems that are widely spoken to Usher and around Usher. There are tenets to the family and everyone knows them. Usher’s queerness is widely spoken of and at, wildly dealt with between characters, and the conversations ricochet off each other. Silence in these family dynamics is not an option. Silence is not tolerated. Usher faces his own struggle of silence with holding back his own feelings of judgement, shame, and failure until he unleashes his own truth on his parents about three-fourths through the 90 minute show. As a white midwestern gay man raised Catholic in a suburb, silence was the chosen tool among my overwhelming white community. Silence from my parents, brothers, teachers, coaches, and other influences in my life. And it still is in many regards the chosen tool, silence has built invisible walls in my life. Neither communication “tool” is better than one another. It creates different opportunities for one to maneuver one’s life, and save yourself. Ghosting has even become a popular tool for young people not choosing to face difficult conversations. We have built our society on these tenets. Yet, it is obvious the pain caused by this acknowledgement in Usher’s life. The characters (all Usher’s thoughts) all have depth, nuance, and texture highlighted in the lyrics in A Strange Loop. Michael R Jackson noticed these opportunities and leveraged them to create robust characters out of the fragments. His music ricochets off of each audience member’s own experience of family creating a universal feeling - our own desire to be loved for who we are fully and completely. Usher’s story is not fully autobiographical, but there are pieces of Jackson’s family woven within. How can a writer not be shaped by the people around them, specifically their family? I used to think of my own pain in silence as mosaics, shattered pieces forming a whole. After A Strange Loop, I am investigating silence in a different manner and it is difficult notion to write to, this quietness. How might one describe withdrawal, a non-recognition, a palatable fear of unknown, nothingness, and emptiness? One of my favorite songs in the show is not a song easily listened to: Periodically. (The song is also featured in the NPR interview with Terry Gross linked below). It is difficult to piece together why the song pierced into my heart and where I noticed similar paralleled reminders came into my life. The song takes place between Usher’s mother and Usher. The reminders that “Hell is real” came daily at my Catholic grade school, on Sunday via a priest’s homily, or my parents “harmless” judgements on others in the community. Usher’s mother is desperately seeking connection with her son and is certainly truly concerned for his safety after death. If you believe in Hell and Hell is real, Jesus is the only pathway to a full life: “Hell is realThough we love youDon't repent cause you know it would please usSon, you should do it so you can see JesusHe is realAnd He loves youAnd He don't want your soul to be wastedBecause the pain of the world, he done faced it”
This comes down to acknowledgement and a recognition that the Christian paradigm does not want to make space for queer people to live a full life. Sure, Catholics are “okay” with some of us if homosexuals are celibate. The same language is now being leveraged as Monkeypox is moving through those who have multiple sexual partners and men who sleep with men (though the virus will impact everyone soon). The shaming language, the judgement, and the ignorance is the same as it was in the 80s with HIV/AIDS, the language does harm us. I never thought I would have experienced this kind of failure of our society. But, the language, actions, and chosen silence will continue to remind us that queer people are certainly “apart” from the rest of society. A Strange Loop provides a lens, possibly a microscope into one moment where these words mattered and burned into Jackson’s memory.
It is near impossible not to be inspired, to be moved to action with A Strange Loop during this time of division. Jackson worked twenty years to craft his own acknowledgement. I hope A Strange Loop will travel to your regional theaters, that you may get the opportunity to acknowledge this character’s confusion, pain, and joy. Choose to go, choose to seek it out. It is impossible for theater to take the full responsibility for changing our society because so many of these stories are limited to the darkness of the theater, a privileged space in its own right, as Jackson calls out to a primarily white Broadway audience. It provides a certain controlled space for an audience and actors to be in dialogue.
James Baldwin wrote “To accept one’s past—one’s history—is not the same thing as drowning in it; it is learning how to use it. An invented past can never be used; it cracks and crumbles under the pressures of life like clay in a season of drought.” Michael R Jackson certainly learned how to use his painful past and create a pathway for us to heal. I have not yet drowned under the weight of my own past. I am learning to use it. I choose to cultivate and let the weeds grow out of the cracks. The young oak trees will create shadows, and the underbrush will form. I am writing a great forest, though it is young, untidy and untrimmed, the buds are beginning. It is a forest of words, of pain, of joy, of healing, and certainly, of acknowledgement. It is a familiar tree, you will recognize it. Interview with Michael R Jackson on NPR * Last week’s Color & Light entry was featured in “Substack Reads!” Welcome to my new readers! *
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit gregorymeander.substack.com