Hallmark Mysteries & More

By Eric Rutin & Andrea Claassen

The podcast Sleuthers can’t stop talking about.

If you love Hallmark’s cozy whodunnits, sharp sleuths, and slow-burn romances, you’ve found your new favorite podcast. Ha

... more

4.7

5555 ratings

FAQs about Hallmark Mysteries & More:

How many episodes does Hallmark Mysteries & More have?

The podcast currently has 313 episodes available.

Best of Hallmark Mysteries & More

The most played episodes among Podcast App listeners.

Number 1: Hallmark's Much About Love Review
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. Eric and Andrea sit down with Hallmark's modern spin on Much Ado About Nothing, Much About Love, starring Ashley Williams and Niall Matter as feuding exes Beatrice and Benedict. Both hosts land on the same 3.5 out of 5 stars, but for very different reasons, and one wordless scene at a kitchen table nearly wins them over completely. Along the way, they also reveal the fall Hallmark movies they're each committing to review next, and neither one saw the other's pick coming. What You'll Hear: • Hallmark news: Brendan Morgan lands the lead in a new scrapbooking-themed Christmas movie opposite Lindura. • A look at what's airing this week, including Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder. • Andrea's fall movie shortlist, from a near-miss with Falling for Vermont to her pick for next review, 2017's A Harvest Wedding with Jill Wagner and Victor Webster. • Eric's fall movie shortlist, including a real debate over whether Dating the Delaneys even counts as a fall movie before he lands on Country at Heart with Jessy Schram and Niall Matter. • The full breakdown of Much About Love: what Ashley Williams and Niall Matter's chemistry pulls off, and where the plot's manufactured conflict loses them. • The standout scene: a wordless moment with crayons at a kitchen table that both hosts call one of the most romantic scenes of the year. • Two comfort-watch recommendations for fans of the Beatrice-and-Benedict banter, plus a spicy Murder, She Wrote episode that shares the movie's restaurant joke. • Trivia on Ashley Williams and the surprisingly rough road Niall Matter took to his first Hallmark role. Chapters: 0:00 - Cold Open: Andrea Goes Full Shakespeare 1:05 - Hallmark News: Brendan Morgan Lands a New Christmas Lead 3:15 - This Week's Preview: Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder 4:45 - Andrea's Fall Movie Picks (Runner-Ups & the Reveal) 9:30 - Eric's Fall Movie Picks (And the Country at Heart Debate) 15:15 - Much About Love: The Setup and the Rating 18:00 - What They Loved: Ashley Williams & Niall Matter's Chemistry 22:30 - What Didn't Work: That Hallmark-Forced Conflict 25:00 - Standout Scene: The Wordless Crayon Table Moment 27:15 - Ranking the Romance 28:45 - If You Liked This, Watch This 30:30 - Trivia: Ashley Williams and Niall Matter's Real Stories 32:00 - Next Week & Sign-Off Which fall pick are you more excited to see reviewed, Andrea's A Harvest Wedding or Eric's Country at Heart? Leave a prediction for which one beats Much About Love's 3.5 stars. New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive. #MuchAboutLove #AshleyWilliams #NiallMatter #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #HarvestWedding #CountryAtHeart #GarageSaleMysteries #HauntedHarmonyMysteries #FallIntoLove #RomanceMovies #MuchAdoAboutNothing #JessySchram Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.
September 03, 202633min
Number 2: Love Finds You Review
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. Eric and Andrea review Love Finds You, the Fall Into Love kickoff starring Aimee Teegarden and Chris McNally as a jewelry designer and the delivery driver who gets pulled into her search for the rightful owner of a mislabeled package. Andrea gives it 4.5 stars. Eric calls that an insult and gives it five stars, no notes. Along the way they also cover the Garage Sale Mysteries premiere date, their fall movie watchlist, and what they've each been watching on BritBox and Acorn. What You'll Hear: • Andrea's rules for the "official" fall movie list, and why Lovestruck Cafe and Autumn Dreams didn't make the cut • Eric on Murdoch Mysteries hitting a rough patch in season ten, plus his current BritBox rotation (Return to Paradise, Brokenwood, Life on Mars, Blood, Ludwig) • The full synopsis and both hosts' star ratings for Love Finds You • Why the fire release ceremony scene had both of them singing along • The scene-stealing side characters (Christine Park as the BFF, plus Karina) and praise for director Eva Tavares • The one flaw they could find in the entire movie • Where Love Finds You ranks against the best Hallmark movies of the year so far • Similar movie recommendations if you loved this one • Aimee Teegarden trivia and behind-the-scenes secrets from the set Chapters 0:00 - Cold Open: Lost Packages & Podcast Intro 1:15 - Up Next: Garage Sale Mysteries Hits Hallmark Channel 3:15 - Fall Movie Auditions: Lovestruck Cafe & Autumn Dreams 6:00 - Murdoch Mysteries Burnout Watch 7:30 - Eric's BritBox Rotation: Return to Paradise, Brokenwood, Life on Mars & Ludwig 9:45 - Love Finds You: The Synopsis 10:30 - Andrea's Rating: 4.5 Stars and the Fire Ceremony 14:00 - Eric's Rating: "This Is a Five" 17:00 - Scene-Stealing Side Characters & Director Eva Tavares 20:30 - The One Thing They Didn't Love 21:30 - Standout Scenes and the Fire and Aspire Callback 24:00 - The Romance, the Wrong Men, and the Conflict That Worked 28:00 - Movies to Watch If You Loved This One 30:30 - Ranking Love Finds You Against the Best of the Year 33:00 - Trivia: Aimee Teegarden, Friday Night Lights & Set Secrets 35:30 - Next Week: Garage Sale Mysteries & Much Ado About Love Andrea gave Love Finds You a 4.5 and Eric bumped it to a five. Where do you land on it, and does it crack your top movies of the year so far? New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive. #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #LoveFindsYou #ChrisMcNally #AimeeTeegarden #HallmarkFans #FallIntoLove #HallmarkMysteries #CozyTV #GarageSaleMysteries #BritBoxMysteries #HallmarkPlus #RomanceMovies #EvaTavares #HallmarkReview Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.
August 27, 202638min
Number 3: Hallmark Channel's Aussie at Heart Review
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. Eric and Andrea review Aussie at Heart, the Hallmark original starring Rhiannon Fish and Daniel Lissing as a former lawyer turned event planner and her ex coworker who reunite in Queensland to plan her parents' anniversary party. Andrea gives it a two and a half. Eric gives it a three. Both of them still rank it dead last of the three movies they've covered this month, thanks to a boat problem, a B-roll problem, and one of the laziest misunderstandings in the Hallmark playbook. What You'll hear: • A full recap of Samara and Nate's reunion in Queensland, planning her parents' anniversary while dodging their own history • Why Andrea can't get past the boat movie problem, and why she'd rather have a murder on that yacht • The vow renewal scene and a mother of the bride whose eye acting deserves its own award • A detour into KitchenAid mixers, Eric's wife's Hanukkah gift versus a mixer that's been in Andrea's family since the 1950s • Rhiannon Fish's performance measured against her turn in Our Norwegian Holiday • The B-roll overload, the old elevator music montages, and the classic Hallmark misunderstanding that sinks the third act • Movie and show recommendations for anyone who wants their boat drama with actual stakes • Trivia on Daniel Lissing's music career and whether Rhiannon Fish actually has an Australian accent • Where Aussie at Heart lands in Eric and Andrea's ranking of this month's three movies, plus a look ahead to A Love Finds You 0:00 - Intro: Boats, Beach Balls, and a Real Men Wear Hallmark Shirt 3:00 - The Recap: Samara, Nate, and an Anniversary in Queensland 4:30 - The Ratings: Andrea's 2.5 vs Eric's 3 6:30 - What They Loved: The Best Friend, the Vows, and the Fireworks 10:30 - Rhiannon Fish's Performance vs Our Norwegian Holiday 13:00 - The Chemistry Verdict 15:00 - What Didn't Work: B-Roll Overload and That Classic Hallmark Fight 20:00 - Standout Character: The Best Friend 21:30 - If You Liked This, Watch... 23:30 - Trivia: Daniel Lissing's Music and Rhiannon Fish's Real Accent 25:30 - Ranking Aussie at Heart Against This Month's Movies 27:00 - Next Week: A Love Finds You Where do you land, closer to Andrea's 2.5 or Eric's 3? And be honest: team boat romance, or team someone-gets-pushed-overboard? New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive. #AussieAtHeart #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #RhiannonFish #DanielLissing #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #RomanceMovies #HallmarkReview #HallmarkOriginalMovies #OurNorwegianHoliday #ChickFlicks #HallmarkCountdown Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.
August 20, 202628min
Number 4: Hallmark Channel's Paris is Always a Good Idea Ep 4 Review
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. Eric and Andrea are back in Paris for episode four of Paris Is Always a Good Idea, and it's the one both hosts agree has the most packed into it. Chelsea and Knightly finally close the distance between them, Lacey Chabert turns in what Eric calls her best Hallmark performance yet, and one subplot has the hosts split right down the middle. Andrea says it adds welcome variety. Eric says it's stealing time from the couple everyone actually tuned in for. Here's what Eric and Andrea get into: • Andrea's full recap of how Chelsea and Knightly's backstory comes together, plus the real Eiffel Tower shoot both actors talked about on Hallmark+ • A quick detour into why the Hallmark+ app keeps logging Andrea out, and why she's sticking with the $39 subscription anyway • The sister subplot debate: Andrea calls it welcome variety, Eric calls it a distraction from the main couple • Eric's case for why this might be Lacey Chabert's best Hallmark role yet, including the scene he calls the spiciest she's ever played • The donation numbers continuity hiccup both hosts caught in the nonprofit storyline • Why Knightly is the one pushing Chelsea toward her billionaire ex Marco, and what that says about his insecurity instead of hers • The standout scene both hosts pick, from the elevator kiss to the closing cab ride banter between Knightly and the sister • Predictions for the rest of the season, including who Marco really is and whether that castle wedding tease means what they think it does Chapters: 0:00 - Bonjour From Paris: Episode 4 Kickoff 1:15 - Recapping "Knightly": Chelsea and Knightly Grow Closer 4:00 - Spoiled by the App: The Hallmark+ Eiffel Tower Mishap 5:30 - The Sister Subplot Divides the Hosts 8:00 - Eric's Take: Lacey Chabert's Best Role Yet 11:00 - The Insecurity Twist: Why Knightly Pushes Chelsea Toward Marco 13:30 - The Big Debate: Is the Sister a Distraction or an Asset? 16:30 - Standout Scene: The Elevator Kiss (and That Cab Ride Callback) 19:30 - Rating the Romance: How Spicy Is Chelsea and Knightly? 21:30 - Season Predictions: Who Is Marco, and Does the Wedding Theory Hold? 23:30 - Sign-Off From Paris Where do you land: does the sister add welcome variety to Paris, or is she pulling focus from Chelsea and Knightly? And who do you think Marco really is? New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive. #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #HallmarkPlus #ParisIsAlwaysAGoodIdea #LaceyChabert #ScottMichaelFoster #RomanceMovies #HallmarkSeries #ChelseaAndKnightly #HallmarkReview #ParisEpisode4 Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.
August 18, 202625min
Number 5: Absolutely Devoted to You Review
We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. Eric and Andrea run through the entire Fall Into Love 2026 lineup, eight new movies, before sitting down with this week's big premiere: Absolutely Devoted to You, starring Jesse Metcalfe and Kimberley Sustad. It's Hallmark's swing at a 90s boy band reunion story, and both hosts walk in a little skeptical. Eric lands at four and a half out of five. Andrea can't get past one thing: the age gap between the leads. What You'll Hear: • Eight new Fall Into Love 2026 movies previewed and rated thumbs up or down, including Love Finds You, Much About Love and the return of Garage Sale Mysteries • A first look at Hallmark's two new Halloween movies, A Knight to Remember and The Spirit of Halloween • The full premise of Absolutely Devoted to You and why its 90s TV talk show framing gives it a different feel than most Hallmark romances • Andrea's case for Hanson as the greatest boy band of the 90s (and why Bop is still on her playlist) • Eric and Andrea's honest read on Kimberley Sustad and Jesse Metcalfe's chemistry • One plot point neither host can fully explain: how the ending's jump from studio to stage actually works • Eric's biggest Hallmark pet peeve, unpacked using this exact movie as the example • Standout character talk built around Tetiana Ostapowych's scene-stealing, fangirling newscaster • Behind-the-scenes trivia from director Stacey N. Harding, plus a preview of next week's Aussie at Heart and Paris Is Always a Good Idea 0:00 - Cold Open: Boy Bands, Big Hair and This Week's Menu 1:20 - Fall Into Love Preview: Love Finds You & Much About Love 5:45 - Haunted Harmony, Falling Into Place & Garage Sale Mysteries Return 10:15 - Pumpkin Regatta Romance and Two New Halloween Movies 13:40 - Absolutely Devoted to You: The Premise 15:10 - What They Loved: 90s Boy Band Nostalgia and Kimberley Sustad 19:40 - What They Didn't Love: The Confusing Finale and Eric's Age Gap Pet Peeve 24:20 - Standout Character: Tetiana Ostapowych Steals the Show 26:40 - Final Rating and Movies to Watch If You Loved This One 29:00 - Trivia: Hanson, Director Stacey Harding's Secrets and Jesse's Boy Band Past 33:00 - Next Week Preview: Aussie at Heart and Paris Is Always a Good Idea 34:10 - Sign-Off Where do you land on the age gap debate, does nine years bother you in a Hallmark pairing or is Eric overthinking it? Drop your rating for Absolutely Devoted to You below. New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive. #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #AbsolutelyDevotedToYou #JesseMetcalfe #KimberleySustad #FallIntoLove2026 #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #GarageSaleMysteries #LoriLoughlin #HauntedHarmonyMysteries #AKnightToRemember #TheSpiritOfHalloween #HallmarkHalloween #HallmarkReview #RomanceMovies #HallmarkMysteries #CozyMystery Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.
August 13, 202636min