Composers Datebook

Hanslick and Thomson, critics at large


Listen Later

Today we take the unusual step of honoring that frequent bane of composers, the music critic. Specifically, Eduard Hanslick, born on this date in Prague, in 1825. He’s remembered today as the arch-conservative 19th century critic who once said an uncut performance of Wagner’s “Tristan und Isolde” would be, quote, “a kind of murder committed upon singers and listeners alike.”
Wagner had his revenge in “Die Meistersinger,” where the Philistine critic Beckmesser is a thinly-disguised parody of Hanslick. Reviewing “Die Meistersinger,” Hanslick wrote that in that opera’s Overture “all the opera’s themes are dumped consecutively into a chromatic flood and finally tossed about in a kind of tonal typhoon.”
A famous and equally quotable 20th century music critic was the late Virgil Thomson, who once defined a music critic as a person “who seldom kisses, but always tells.” In his years as chief music critic of the New York Herald Tribune, his barbs were often as sharp as Hanslick’s. He called Gershwin’s “Porgy and Bess” “fake folklore,” with “fidgety accompaniments.”
Like all music critics, Virgil Thomson called some right — and others wrong. Unlike most critics, though, Thomson was a composer himself — so, in addition to his witty reviews, there’s his genial music to enjoy as well, such as this brass suite titled “Family Portrait.”
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Composers DatebookBy American Public Media

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

10 ratings


More shows like Composers Datebook

View all
PBS Washington Week with The Atlantic - Full Show by Washington Week

PBS Washington Week with The Atlantic - Full Show

1,340 Listeners

The Book Review by The New York Times

The Book Review

3,851 Listeners

New Classical Tracks with Julie Amacher by American Public Media

New Classical Tracks with Julie Amacher

177 Listeners

Piano Puzzler by American Public Media

Piano Puzzler

499 Listeners

Global News Podcast by BBC World Service

Global News Podcast

7,886 Listeners

Fresh Air by NPR

Fresh Air

38,148 Listeners

Marketplace Tech by Marketplace

Marketplace Tech

73 Listeners

Piano Puzzler by American Public Media

Piano Puzzler

38 Listeners

Gramophone Classical Music Podcast by Gramophone

Gramophone Classical Music Podcast

61 Listeners

Hidden Brain by Hidden Brain, Shankar Vedantam

Hidden Brain

43,396 Listeners

YourClassical Daily Download by American Public Media

YourClassical Daily Download

236 Listeners

The NPR Politics Podcast by NPR

The NPR Politics Podcast

25,838 Listeners

The Daily by The New York Times

The Daily

111,562 Listeners

Sticky Notes: The Classical Music Podcast by Joshua Weilerstein

Sticky Notes: The Classical Music Podcast

2,100 Listeners

Up First from NPR by NPR

Up First from NPR

56,139 Listeners

Broken Record with Rick Rubin, Malcolm Gladwell, Bruce Headlam and Justin Richmond by Pushkin Industries

Broken Record with Rick Rubin, Malcolm Gladwell, Bruce Headlam and Justin Richmond

4,117 Listeners

Short Wave by NPR

Short Wave

6,244 Listeners