When I bought an old bar in Jefferson City 16 years ago, the rumor had been propagated for many years, by previous owners and others, that it was the oldest bar west of the Mississippi River. At the time, I was working for the State Historic Preservation Office, and I knew that the bar wasn’t even considered to be the oldest in our state.
Folks who live here will come to the bar, usually with friends from out of town, and they’ll say, “Tell them, tell them- isn’t this the oldest bar west of the Mississippi?”
It takes a little diplomacy to tell them that it isn’t true without embarrassing them in front of their friends. I usually say something like, “Well, we used to think that it was, but some research has shown that it isn’t,” or “yeah, it’s easy to make that mistake, but it’s just the oldest bar here in town.”
They always look disappointed. Sometimes even miffed, I guess because I shattered their cherished beliefs, something they had boasted to others; “Our pub is the oldest bar west of the Mississippi!” I’m sorry, folks, but its just not true. Don’t be upset with me; I can’t in good conscience perpetuate the myth.
But people want to believe, they want to have a connection, a physical connection, an emotional connection, to their history and their past.
When I take tour groups to Ireland, the old pubs are some of the biggest attractions. They want to have a drink in the bar where Michael Collins took his last pint before he was assassinated, or where JFK hung out when he worked in Dublin in the late 1940’s, or where Brendan Behan and Patrick Kavanagh used to have it out.
There is something about these places; these old bars, these dens of imbibing from a time of antiquity. For those of us who like to bend an elbow, there is something neat about having a drink in one of these touchstones to the past.
Back to the question; what is the oldest bar west of the Mississippi River? Well, I wanted to know that myself, and now you probably do, as well. Over the years I have done some digging. The list that I’ve pulled together, is not exactly the ten oldest bars west of the Mississippi, but it is the oldest bar in each of 10 different states west of Mississippi- The complete list of the oldest bar in each of the 24 states west of the Mississippi River can be found at the bottom of the blog
So by process of elimination, the oldest bar on this list is going to be the oldest bar west of the big river. Another thing, these are just a list of the oldest verifiable bar in each state that I could find. All of these establishments have been historically documented to have either been built or had the business started on the year given, in as much as I could authenticate the dates. I double-checked as much as the internet and the National Register of Historic Places would allow, and there is not a lot of scholarly research done on this subject; so, for all of you aspiring History PhD candidates out there, especially those in Historic Preservation, you’re welcome, here’s the start of your thesis subject.
And regarding Prohibition from 1920 to 1933; everybody gets a pass. Some areas of the country the Volstead Act was not enforced at all, while in other states, violators were staunchly cracked down upon. Also, some of these listed, after doing the research, I found were not continuously open. But, unless I found another property that had a stronger claim, I went with these...