Historical Thoughts and Interpretations

Historical Thoughts and Interpretations

By Christian BasarEducationArtsHistory
Download on the App Store

Historical Thoughts and Interpretations episodes

  • Strategic Thoughts: The Kerch Strait Incident of November 25, 2018

    In this episode we will look at the incident that occurred between Russian and Ukrainian ships in the Kerch Strait on November 25, 2018. Here I will analyze the strategic situation surrounding this clash. Key factors leading to this incident were the legal status of Crimea, the Sea of Azov, Russian-Ukrainian maritime interactions in the region, and Russia's attempts to consolidate control over the area. I will also provide some commentary on possible motivations or thoughts (on the parts of both the Russian and Ukrainian leadership) which caused the Russian and Ukrainian ships to confront each other.

    Episode thumbnail courtesy of European Space Agency via Wikipedia.

    41 min
  • The August 1991 Coup: Inevitable Failure and the Soviet Union's Death Knell

    In August 1991, hardline Communists took power in Moscow.  They claimed that the actual Soviet leader, Mikhail Gorbachev, was ill and unfit for work.  They were upset with Gorbachev's attempts to accomodate the Soviet Union's consituent republics in new treaty negotations, and they feared that his weak response to communism's fracturing control over Eastern Europe would lead to a similar situtation within the USSR.  But the coup had failed within four days.  This was the time of Gorbachev's famous "perestroika" (restructuring) and "glasnost" (openness) reforms, which were meant to reform the Soviet Union's economy and allow for increased freedom of expression.  Though many were skeptical of these reforms, they had had some effect on Soviet society, and the coup plotters did not have a sufficient answer to them.  Nor did they establish effective political or military command over the situation, and people openly resisted the seizure of power.  Gorbachev was very soon restored to his position as head of the USSR.  But by the time of the coup, the Soviet Union was riddled with economic problems.  There also remained the burning question of how to reorganize the relationship between the center in Moscow and the constituent republics.  Under such circumstances, the putsch not only failed, but it is also arguable that the Soviet Union would have soon collapsed, with or without the August Coup.

    Episode thumbnail courtesy of BBC News.

    35 min
  • #9 - The August 1991 Coup: Inevitable Failure and the Soviet Union’s Death Knell

    In August 1991, hardline Communists took power in Moscow.  They claimed that the actual Soviet leader, Mikhail Gorbachev, was ill and unfit for work.  They were upset with Gorbachev's attempts to accomodate the Soviet Union's consituent republics in new treaty negotations, and they feared that his weak response to communism's fracturing control over Eastern Europe would lead to a similar situtation within the USSR.  But the coup had failed within four days.  This was the time of Gorbachev's famous "perestroika" (restructuring) and "glasnost" (openness) reforms, which were meant to reform the Soviet Union's economy and allow for increased freedom of expression.  Though many were skeptical of these reforms, they had had some effect on Soviet society, and the coup plotters did not have a sufficient answer to them.  Nor did they establish effective political or military command over the situation, and people openly resisted the seizure of power.  Gorbachev was very soon restored to his position as head of the USSR.  But by the time of the coup, the Soviet Union was riddled with economic problems.  There also remained the burning question of how to reorganize the relationship between the center in Moscow and the constituent republics.  Under such circumstances, the putsch not only failed, but it is also arguable that the Soviet Union would have soon collapsed, with or without the August Coup.

    35 min
  • Holy War: Memory of the Great Patriotic War in the Russian Orthodox Church

    Because the Russian Orthodox Church is such a vital part of Russian culture, its views can be an important influence upon the society in which it operates.  During the Great Patriotic War (1941-5) against Nazi Germany, the Church encouraged Christians to resist the enemy and pray for victory.  The Church's memory of the conflict fits with the modern Russian government's remembrance, which upholds the war's Soviet fighters as moral role models.  This dynamic also creates a somewhat ironic memory of the Soviet Union itself, especially considering the Communist government’s persecution of religious believers.  Through the religious historical documents, modern statements, and media productions studied in this podcast, the non-religious Soviet Union is somewhat turned into a "basically Christian" nation that fought the evils of fascism.

    Photo by Christian Basar.  Taken in Volgograd, showing a small church and the statue known as "The Motherland Calls."

    2 hr 12 min
  • Rewriting the Scriptures: Religious Justification for Nazi Anti-Semitism within Radical German Protestant Christianity

    During their rule in Germany, the Nazis tried to provide religious justification for their anti-Semitic ideology. A large Christian population and tenets such as neighbourly love presented the Nazis with a potentially large hurdle. But due to the defeat in World War I and fears of social "corruption," Nazism had some Christian support. Some scholars even modified Scriptures to suit Adolf Hitler's agenda, creating a new "Nazi Christianity."

    Episode thumbnail courtesy of Das Bundesarchiv via Wikipedia, showing "Deutsche Christen" celebrating Luther Day in 1933.

    39 min
  • "Grammar School Strategy:" An Appraisal of the Japanese Invasion of the Aleutian Islands

    During World War II, the Empire of Japan captured some islands in the Aleutian chain off the Alaskan coast.  In theory, it might have looked like the Japanese had dealt a true blow against their American enemy.  But not all ideas that appear good on paper work well in reality.  The Japanese hoped to bolster their defenses with the capture of these islands, but this plan was ultimately fruitless due to mistaken ideas, impracticalities, and the disaster at the Battle of Midway.

    Episode thumbnail courtesy of Australian War Memorial website via Wikipedia.

    30 min
  • "Sighs too Deep for Words" - Internal Prayer in Orthodox Christianity

    In the Orthodox Christian school of hesychasm, the Holy Spirit’s energies, or actions, can act within and sanctify a Christian’s life and heart.  Internal, constant prayer is an important practice for allowing this to happen, and it involves the body as well as the soul.  In this summary of the subject, I will look at internal prayer’s theological background as well as its spiritual effects, as described in such works as The Way of a Pilgrim.

    Episode thumbnail courtesy of Nioras.com.

    26 min
  • #6 - “Grammar School Strategy:” An Appraisal of the Japanese Invasion of the Aleutian Islands

    During World War II, the Empire of Japan captured some islands in the Aleutian chain off the Alaskan coast.  in theory, it might have looked like the Japanese deal a true blow against their American enemy.  But not all ideas that appear good on paper work well in reality.  The Japanese hoped to bolster their defenses with the capture of these islands, but this plan was ultimately fruitless due to mistaken ideas, impracticalities, and the disaster at the Battle of Midway.

    30 min

About Historical Thoughts and Interpretations

From the publisher's feed

In this blog Christian Basar analyses historical events or ideas one may encounter in the historiographical field. Though this podcast will cover many different topics, Basar’s main interests lie in military and Russian history.