
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


This talk centers on the Dhammacakkapavattana Sutta (“Setting in Motion the Wheel of Dharma”), the Buddha’s first teaching after enlightenment. I explore how the Buddha addressed his five companions and introduce the Middle Way between two extremes. Also, I summarize the Buddha’s Four Noble Truths as practical insights for living nobly and compassionately. While suffering is unavoidable, we have agency in how we relate to it—learning to respond skillfully rather than reactively. The talk concludes with reflections on compassion as the heart of wisdom. I encourage self-compassion in the lifelong process of learning to relate well to suffering and extending that compassion to others.
Yesterday, I offered a Dharma talk on the mirror-like quality of all things, including religious or spiritual writings and, especially, the Heart Sutra, to No Barriers Zen. You can listen to the talk via the above embedded audio.
The recording opens with Ōshin Jennings Sensei signing and Tess Wenderski interpreting for him. I begin speaking around the two-minute mark.
In time, a video recording with side-by-side and live ASL interpretation will be available here.
Enjoy—and thank you for your on-going practice and study.
Yesterday, I offered a Dharma talk to the No Barriers Zen sangha. You can learn about us here and listen to a recording of the talk by pressing the Play Button above. A video recording, complete with captions and live interpretation in ASL, will be available in the future.
The centerpiece of the talk are the opening lines of Hongzhi Zhengjue’s poem, “Guidepost for the Hall of Pure Bliss.” Specifically, the couplet that reads:
[The Way's] purity is constant,
I reproduce the poem in its entirety below.
The whole of the Dharma talk—the lesson or message I receive from Hongzhi’s words—is expressed in a single line from Rumi: “Your naked freedom is your shield.” It takes time and play in conceptual space to see some of why that is, though.
Enjoy—and thank you for listening, your practice, and your support.
Guidepost for the Hall of Pure Bliss
My study and writing about the Dharma is offered freely. If you benefit from what I offer here, please consider sharing and subscribing—even becoming a paid subscriber. You may also offer dāna through Paypal. I am grateful for your generosity.
Additional offerings are listed below:
This morning, I had the pleasure of offering a Dharma Talk to the No Barriers Zen sangha—my sangha. I’m grateful for the opportunity, and humbled by everyone’s attentive presence and thoughtful comments and questions.
The talk centers on the practice of zazen (seated meditation), “choppy waves,” how we can navigate them, and what we might find along the way. Part playful and part serious, I speak from my experience and encourage reconnecting with our bodies, all while pointing toward great trust in ourselves.
I refer to Eihei Dogen Zenji’s Fukanzazengi (Universal Recommendations for the Practice of Zazen) several times. You can read a translation of the text here.
Also, I use one of Rumi’s poems to describe how unsettled I felt in zazen during a year of transition. The poem is reproduced below.
Enjoy—and may you discover “the vital path of letting your body leap.”
The moon swooped down the dawn sky
My study and writing about the Dharma is supported in part by you. If you benefit from what I offer here, please consider sharing and subscribing—even becoming a paid subscriber. You may also offer dāna through Paypal. I am grateful for your generosity.
If you benefitted from this offering, you might consider reading:
The following is an approximate transcript of a Dharma talk that I offered on Saturday, July 27th, during O-An Zendo’s Udumbara Sesshin. You can also listen to a live recording.
Enjoy.
Almost one year ago, I sat in this seat and offered a Dharma talk on the topic of the transmission of the teachings. Specifically, I spoke about the first transmission of the Dharma from Shakyamuni Buddha to Mahakasyapa and began with an excerpt from Dogen’s Shobogenzo Menju (Face-To-Face Transmission). Since that talk went well, I will begin this talk in the same way.
Dogen writes:
Shakyamuni Buddha graciously entrusted and transmitted the Dharma face to face to Mahakashyapa, saying, “I have the treasury of the true dharma eye. I entrust it to Mahakashyapa.”
At the assembly of Mount Song, Bodhidharma said to Huike, who would later become the Second Ancestor, “You have attained my marrow.”
From this we know that entrusting the treasury of the true dharma eye and saying, “You have attained my marrow” is this very face-to-face transmission. At the exact moment of jumping beyond your ordinary bones and marrow, there is the buddha ancestor’s transmission face to face. The face-to-face transmission of great enlightenment, the face-to-face transmission of the mind seal, is extraordinary. Transmission is never exhausted; there is never a lack of enlightenment.
Now, the great way of buddha ancestors is only giving and receiving face to face, receiving and giving face to face; there is nothing excessive and there is nothing lacking. Faithfully and joyously realize when your own face meets someone who has received this transmission face to face.
Whether you are hearing this excerpt for the first time, the second time, or the some-number-greater-than-two time, you might have the impression that transmission of the Dharma happens when someone in possession of the Dharma gives the Dharma to someone who is not in possession of the Dharma. You might understand the transmission of the Dharma in the same way you understand someone entrusting a family heirloom to another member of the family, the way a grandmother might entrust a gold locket to her granddaughter, for instance. The grandmother is in possession of the gold locket, and her granddaughter comes into possession of the gold locket when the grandmother transmits it from her hands to her granddaughter’s hands, perhaps accompanied by some words chosen for the occasion.
I have the treasury of the true golden locket of the Jones family, and I entrust it to Betsy! I wager that no grandmother has ever said this, probably.
This is one way of understanding what happened when Shakyamuni Buddha held up a flower, Mahakasyapa smiled, and then the Buddha said, “I have the treasury of the true dharma eye. I entrust it to Mahakashyapa.”
This impression is reinforced by the way our excerpt closes. Dogen writes that this great way of buddha ancestors is nothing other than giving and receiving face to face, receiving and giving face to face. One has, the other does not; one gives, the other receives. Furthermore, sometimes we describe this giving and receiving as happening mind to mind, heart to heart, and warm hand to warm hand—again, not much different from the way a grandmother might entrust a family heirloom to her granddaughter.
Yet, this is not the only way to understand the first transmission or transmission of the teachings generally. Bodhidharma’s expression “You have attained my marrow” suggests less giving and receiving from a “has” to a “has not” and more an acknowledgment of a shift or transformation brought about by Huike’s great effort and sincere practice.
There is also the expression “jumping beyond your ordinary bones and marrow,” which happens at the exact moment in which the Dharma is transmitted. Who can jump beyond your ordinary bones and marrow but you? Where can this leap occur but wherever you are when it happens? You may not feel yourself jump or leap, though you do not need to. Your teacher will recognize it in the same way that Bodhidharma did for Huike: “You have attained my marrow.”
From this point of view, transmission is not exclusively something that happens from without. Instead, transmission also includes that which arises from within.
A Phoenix’s Hut is a reader-supported publication. Please consider sharing, subscribing, or Buy Me A Coffee.
Some weeks ago, I offered a Dharma talk on Dogen’s Shoaku Makusa (Refraining From Evil), which opens with the following gatha:
Refraining from committing various evils
Then, several lines later, Dogen writes:
The actual Dharma teaching and Way of practice of the seven buddhas [Vipassi, Sikhi, Vessabhu, Kakusandha, Konagamana, Kassapa, and Gautama] necessarily include the transmission and reception of that reality and of that practice. Further, it is the internal and direct transmission of how all things are, and it is held in common by all the buddhas.
Giving and receiving, acknowledgment and recognition—that which comes from without and that which arises from within—transmission and reception from teacher to student and internal and direct transmission from within the buddha ancestors themselves.
The first transmission of the Dharma occurred between Shakyamuni Buddha and Mahakasyapa, and the first transmission of the Dharma happened when Mahakasyapa transmitted to Mahakasyapa. I want to explore the latter point of view today.
Sometimes, we say a lot about separation, by which I mean the feeling of separation between us and anything (or everything) else. In truth, there is no separation; it is only a feeling, though a powerful one and its presence can contribute to a great deal of suffering. Other times, we say only a little about separation, usually as a gentle reminder or a passing comment.
However we mention separation, we tend to highlight the mind’s role in producing this feeling. We might mention the mind’s discursive activity and its capacity for abstraction. Or we might focus on the way in which the mind drags attention from the present to the past, from the present to the future, from the future to the past, and from the past to the future through its “secretions.” It also pulls us into the present, by the way, but we tend not to say much about that; the mind is not an outright burden, despite the impression offered by some authors, teachers, and writers.
Or we shine a light on language. Perhaps you have heard someone say that language is “necessarily dualistic.” That is a fancy way of saying it has and creates division and difference—only with fewer words.
Consider the structure of a sentence: there is a subject, an object, and a verb that indicates the relation between the two. “Taishin rings the big bell.” How am I and the big bell related? By the action of ringing: when I bring the striker into contact with the big bell. But what about when I am not bringing the striker into contact with the big bell because I am outside moving woodchips? I still am, and the big bell still is, and we are still in relation to each other. But without some signification of that relation there arises an opportunity to believe the big bell and I are disconnected, separate, each existing independent from the other, and that we need to be brought into a relation once again.
The more time we spend in the world of words, concepts, and ideas, the more opportunities for this belief to become rooted and grow appear. When the belief takes root, you can see it at the edges of questions, such as How do I connect with so-and-so? How can I relate to such-and-such?
Response: You already do, but the form of that connection changes. Its shape is co-dependent on particular circumstances. We cannot quite predict the form in advance, though we try; it never quite matches our predictions, either. For that reason, we feel that there is separation, even though there is not; that we could somehow be “close…
The following is an approximate transcript of the Dharma Talk I delivered as part of O-An Zendo’s Sunday Program on July 14th, 2024. You can also listen to a live recording of the talk.
Enjoy.
Good morning. Thank you for being here and for continuing to participate in the great effort together. As we begin, I ask two things of you. First, please remember this line from Hsin Hsin Ming (Song Of Trusting Mind):
Don’t get tangled in the world, don’t lose yourself in emptiness.
Second, please wiggle in your seat. Yes, wiggle. Thank you for humoring me. I am reminded of Suzuki Roshi’s saying: “What we are doing here is so important that we ought not take ourselves too seriously.”
A Phoenix’s Hut is a reader-supported publication. Please consider sharing, subscribing, or Buy Me A Coffee.
This morning, I want to continue the conversation that followed last week’s Dharma Talk. I spoke about The Verse Of The Kesa and one understanding of what it means to “wear the kesa” and what we commit to when reciting the verse. When we wear the kesa and recite The Robe Chant—another name for the verse—we commit to participating in the great effort to free all beings from suffering. “That is our commitment,” I said. “That is our vow,” I concluded.
There followed a thorny question about the relation between “serving” all beings and “liberating” all beings, which assumes that the two are distinct (though not separate). If we grant that assumption, then, from one point of view, we can consider the former discrete actions and the latter the end goal; we can ask how, say, practicing zazen (seated meditation) with a sangha, how sitting in a room together, facing a wall, and “doing nothing,” contributes to liberating all beings from suffering. This is a common and important question—and a particular instance of the thorny question we explored last week.
By the way, in August, we will have a chance to explore this question about the relation between zazen and liberation in some depth. Then, I will offer a series of talks on Dogen Zenji’s Bendowa (A Talk On The Pursuit Of The Truth).
We also discussed being role models, trusting others, not meddling, and “taking off the cape.” (Or, for some of us, not putting on the cape in the first place.) I am someone, for instance, who would benefit from removing his cape and wearing only robes—they are not the same. I tend to assume that too many things are my responsibility and that things will fall apart if I fail to act and fail to maintain some order. Yet, there is no need for me to fashion myself a superhero who will liberate all beings without help from others. Freeing all beings from suffering is something we do together.
Finally, the Bodhisattva Vows received a mention; that is where I want us to pick up the thread.
Traditionally, we chant The Four Great Bodhisattva Vows in the same way that we chant The Verse Of The Kesa:
Shujo muhen seigan do
The above translation of the Vows is in our liturgy; we chanted them this way two years ago during the Winter Ango period.
There are other translations, too. Sometimes, I mention how Kobun Chino Roshi expressed the Vows:
Sentient beings are infinite, they will save themselves.
I am not interested in shredding the hero’s cape to pieces right now, so I will say only that I appreciate the alternative perspective offered here. Specifically, that all things need not be in my hands. Instead, I can let them be. Furthermore, if there is engagement, then, as I said above, it is collaborative, perhaps even harmonious. It is not all on my shoulders; I do not need to have all the answers or figure everything out. Hallelujah.
I came across yet another expression of The Four Great Bodhisattva Vows. It is an older expression which connects the Vows to The Four Noble Truths, and it reads:
I vow to enable people to be released from the truth of suffering.
Interesting! As I sat with it, I noticed several things and thought each of them attractive. A few things, too, raised an eyebrow, especially the surface suggestion that we enable others to be released from “the truth of” suffering instead of simply “suffering.”
I do not want to say anything more about these several expressions of The Four Great Bodhisattva Vows, though. This is not a Dharma Talk in which the finer points of their formulations are subjected to analysis and debate.
Instead, I offer them this morning because these three expressions of The Four Great Bodhisattva Vows can show us that we need not become tangled in the world. Once more, we read in Hsin Hsin Ming:
Don’t get tangled in the world, don’t lose yourself in emptiness.
They show us that there is “wiggle room.”
We tend to become tangled in the world when we believe that something is just one thing and are attached to that belief about that something being just one thing. For instance, we might believe that there is one way to express The Four Great Bodhisattva Vows. If we believe that the only “correct” or “true” expression of the Vows is that which displays an apparent contradiction, then we are likely to become involved in disputes when others offer different expressions. We “go on the offensive” to stamp out whatever it is that we judge as “incorrect” or “false.” We might even become fearful because we view that presentation of the teaching as threatening. “No more will others pollute the buddha-dharma with these poisons!” you have probably never said—but you could if positioned in this way.
Rarely is changing someone else’s mind an easy matter or abolishing an alternative accomplished without difficulty. Why? Because we get tangled up with others! We wrestle with people who believe just as much as we do that their judgment about the Vows is the only one that is “correct” or “true,” who are also on the offensive, and who are just as tough, even downright stubborn, as us—and we are not going down without a fight, you can count on that! And I can already hear the chest-thumping.
We might also adopt a “defensive posture.” Here, we attempt to maintain distance from potential wrestling matches. Sometimes, we call this “keeping the world out” or “not letting the world in”—and I assume that each of us is familiar with someone who has gone to great lengths to pursue such a goal. But it is challenging to keep the world out, not to let the world in; it is as though the world were all around you, and there is no escape from it. I wonder where those who posture in this way believe they are, for you cannot be anywhere else but in the world, and how can you keep that in which you are at a distance?
It is summertime, and it has been very warm, even hot. At some point, you may have been in a swimming pool, a lake, or an ocean; perhaps you are looking forward to being in one later today or during a vacation. Whichever is the case, I invite you to keep the water at a distance once in the pool, lake, or ocean. With all your effort and heart-mind, keep it at a distance. Then, you will see that adopting the defensive posture is as foolish and futile as the offensive posture.
By the way, these responses I am describing, which tend to follow from the belief that something is just one thing and attachment to that belief, show up everywhere. It is not just about The…
The following is an approximate transcript of the Dharma Talk I offered on June 16th as part of O-An Zendo’s Sunday program. You can also listen to a live recording.
Enjoy.
Last week, we explored one way of relating to the precepts. As a way of complementing Roshi’s admonishment to “forget the precepts,” I suggested that we can also see the precepts as “invitations to exploration.” I said asking questions is part of being a Zen practitioner. We also looked at the precept that encourages supporting life in its many forms to illustrate that sort of relationship.
I want to continue this effort today and discuss a group of precepts we have yet to focus on: the Three Pure Precepts.
Sometimes, we find the Three Pure Precepts presented in the following way:
First, to embrace and sustain right conduct.
You will see this way of expressing them next week during Jukai (Lay Ordination Ceremony) for three of our Dharma Sisters.
This presentation has its roots in an ancient gatha—a short verse or prayer—shared by all Buddhist practitioners, and I learned that, in Japanese, the gatha is called Shichi Butsu Tsukai (no) Ge or “The Gatha of the Commonly Held Precepts of the Seven Buddhas.” The gatha is:
Refrain from committing various evils
Well, that sounds simple—does it not?
If you spend time with this gatha, you will see how it and the Three Pure Precepts provide a foundation for the Ten Clear Mind Precepts.
We can notice the Clear Mind Precepts’ prohibitory form in the gatha: no killing, stealing, abusing sexuality, lying, misuse of intoxicants, dwelling on past mistakes, praise or blame, hoarding teachings or materials, harboring anger, and abusing the Three Treasures. Collectively, these are ways in which we embody the essential teaching, “refrain from committing various evils.”
Also, there is the “positive form” of the Clear Mind Precepts in the gatha: cultivating and encouraging life, honoring the gift not yet given, remaining faithful in relationships, communicating truth, polishing clarity, creating wisdom from ignorance, maintaining modesty, sharing understanding and freely giving of self, dwelling in equanimity, and respecting the Buddha, unfolding the Dharma, and nourishing the Sangha. These are ways in which we embody the essential teaching of “carrying out all sorts of good actions.”
Finally, we call this group of precepts the Clear Mind Precepts, which implies that by refraining from various evils and carrying out all sorts of good actions, we also “personally clarify this mind.” Thus, we embody the essential teaching of all the buddhas.
The matter is not so simple, however. You may have seen this gentle turn coming if you have been around for a while. Or perhaps the matter is as simple as I said it is, but not in the way you think it is simple. Whatever the case, we are going to change direction presently, and I leave it to you to decide (or not) how simple (or not) what we find as we walk together is.
So far, it might seem to you that the ancient gatha and the Three Pure Precepts state general rules, while the Ten Clear Mind Precepts offer specific rules. Yet, for a few weeks now, Roshi and I have said that the precepts are not rules according to our best and shared understanding of the teachings.
But if these precepts are not rules, then what are they? What is the essential teaching of all the buddhas if it is not a collection of rules?
Dogen describes the essential teaching as the same as “awakening to the living reality” and “responding to each matter” in Shobogenzo Shoaku Makusa (Treasury of the True Dharma Eye, Refraining from Evil). That is where I want us to begin—and with a story.
Haku Kyoi was a high-ranking government official and unparalleled poet. Dogen tells us that he was
[…] sometimes referred to as the Manjusri of literati or the Maitreya of poets. There was no one who had not heard of his poetic artistry. The influence of his verse spread everywhere. However, when it came to the Buddha Way, he was just a beginner and was not yet mature.
One day, Kyoi called on Dorin Choka, a Master whose “Dharma-voice,” says Dogen, “was louder and clearer than a roll of thunder.” The story goes that
Kyoi asked Dorin, “What is the gist of the Buddhadharma?” Dorin replied, “Refrain from committing various evils and carry out all sorts of good actions.” Kyoi responded, “If that were the case, even a three-year-old child could say that.” Dorin replied, “Although a three-year-old child may be able to express it, not even an eighty-year-old can actually carry it out.” Hearing the reply, Kyoi thanked him gratefully, bowed, and left.
“Although a three-year-old child may be able to express it, not even an eighty-year-old can actually carry it out,” says Dorin. We can glean from Dorin’s reply that Kyoi’s impression of the essential teaching of all the buddhas is not quite right. “Even a three-year-old could say that,” says Kyoi—meaning, how could “refrain from committing various evils and carry out all sorts of good actions” be the gist of the Buddhadharma? Surely, the essential teaching of all buddhas is something else, something not utterable by a three-year-old, something profound. Only it is—“refrain from committing various evils and carry out all sorts of good actions” is the essential teaching of all the buddhas, and it is profound—but not in the way that Kyoi supposes that it is.
Dogen continues:
Kyoi probably speculated that Dorin earnestly encouraged people to refrain from various evils and carry out acts of good at the conscious level. […] Make no mistake, even if we are cautioned to intentionally avoid various evils and, with every intention, encouraged to carry out good deeds, the actuality takes place in absolute refraining.
This essential teaching of all the buddhas is not embodied at the conscious level; it is not found in the intention that arises before action or the general intention set at a day’s or week’s beginning. It is not what “people ordinarily conjure up in their minds.” It is something altogether different.
What could that something be? Dogen calls it “absolute refraining,” “refraining from,” and again, “awakening to the living reality” and “responding to each matter.” At what are these expressions pointing? Where is the moon?
A response—it is tempting to say, “the answer”—is emptiness. Emptiness is absolute refraining; emptiness is refraining from. Awakening to the living reality is absolute refraining; awakening to the living reality is refraining from. The living reality to which we awaken through zazen is an empty one. All things are empty; there is only one living reality, and there is only refraining from.
Now, let us return to the beginning once more.
I spoke about the Heart Sutra last week, using it to illustrate Karuna, the “intention and capacity to transform suffering and lighten sorrows.” Avalokiteshvara had the desire and the means to do this. Notably, they had the insight and capacity to share with Shariputra that “form is emptiness, emptiness is form, form is not separate from emptiness, emptiness is not separate from form […]” and so on. But it is not just form that is emptiness; it is also sensation, perceptions, volitions, and consciousness. It is also eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mind; it is also shape, sound, smell, taste, touch, feeling, and thought. Nothing, it turns out, is that is not also empty.
So Avalokiteshvara says:
Here, Shariputra, all dharmas are defined by emptiness
All dharmas, including, although not found in the Heart Sutra’s list of things for which the expression “X is emptiness” is true, good and evil. In fact, we can include “good and evil” in two ways. First, we can say that “good and evil” are defined b…
The following is an approximate transcript of the Dharma Talk I offer on Sunday, June 9th, as part of O-An Zendo’s Sunday program. You can also listen to a live recording of the talk.
Enjoy.
Precepts—that is what I want us to explore this morning. What are the precepts? How do we work with the precepts? How do we incorporate them into daily practice and our everyday lives?
Roshi offered one response to these questions in her talk last Sunday. (You can listen to that talk here.) She spoke about "spontaneity" and the uselessness of the precepts when there is a need for immediate or near-immediate action.
Consider the following scenario. You are walking through a park one morning. You are on your way to a job interview and dressed in your best outfit. "Dressed to impress!" as the anonymous they say. Your outfit includes a nice pair of shoes, by the way.
As you round some bushes and approach a shallow pond, you notice a small child in the pond. Only the small child is not simply in the pond; it is drowning in the pond! And its guardians are nowhere in sight, and neither is anyone else.
At this moment, you have a choice. You can either continue walking to your job interview and leave the small child to (likely) drown in the shallow pond. Or you can wade into the pond and save the small child from drowning, but you will ruin your nice shoes. And I will stipulate that there is no time to take your shoes off or change your shoes before the job interview. In fact, you will be late for the interview if you do not miss it altogether.
What would you do?
I do not know what you would do. I am confident, however, that to decide what to do, you would not remove a list of the Sixteen Bodhisattva Precepts from your bag or pocket and begin reviewing them. And I will guess that you would, without any thought or hesitation, wade into the shallow pond and save the small child from drowning. Without any thought or hesitation—never mind your shoes, the job interview, or anything else than responding appropriately to what is in front of you.
This scenario, fanciful though it is, illustrates one of Roshi's main points from last week's Dharma Talk: that the precepts are useless in the moment. We could say that intellectual engagement with the precepts hinders an appropriate response; the situation requires immediate or near-immediate action. It is better to heed Roshi's advice and "forget the precepts." Trust that you see what is needed and act to meet that need.
Yet, some of us keep a Precept Journal. Precept Journals can take many forms, but one common feature is that we do not forget—we remember—the precepts and work with them in various ways.
Sometimes, we explore how the precepts were embodied in a specific situation. Other times, we outline the relation between two or more precepts and notice how the precepts show up together and everywhere in our lives. At still other times, we investigate what obstructed a particular response. What "got in the way" of that response? Was it greed, anger, or ignorance? Was I concerned with securing pleasure and avoiding pain? Was I seeking praise and attempting to dodge blame? These are appropriate questions to entertain, whether by yourself, with a wise friend or teacher, or in a group—just not when a small child is drowning in front of you in a shallow pond.
Zen Questions. How do you hear this expression? Is it as an adjective followed by a noun, together identifying a particular group of questions? "These are not home-economic questions, but Zen questions," someone says. Or as a noun followed by a verb, something that Zen does? "What does Zen do?" a curious person inquires. "Zen questions," replies the teacher. Or, perhaps, as the title of a book by Taigen Dan Leighton, Roshi? That is another possibility, too.
Questioning. Inquiry. Investigation. These are essential ingredients—or, we might say, ever-present invitations—in Zen practice.
The riddles or short stories called "koans" extend them. One of the more well-known koans and often the first case a student receives is "Joshu's Dog," Case 1 of the Mumonkan (The Gateless Gate). The case is:
A monk asked Joshu in all earnestness, "Does a dog have Buddha nature or not?"
Joshu said, "Mu!"
As you meet this exchange for the first time, the tenth time, the ten-thousandth time, you might ask: What has happened between the monk and Joshu? What is Buddha nature? Why a dog? What is "Mu"? What is going on in this case? Although only two lines long, the case is pregnant with invitations for exploration.
The same invitations are present in the precepts, although that may not be obvious because of how you relate to the precepts and the form in which we usually see the precepts.
Roshi said last week that the precepts are not commandments or rules. That is correct, according to our best and shared understanding of the Buddha's teachings. No omniscient, omnipotent being formulated them; no one received them from such a being through a mystical experience. They do not reside somewhere else, over and above your life, hovering and watching with a critical and, perhaps, condemning eye. You cannot "break" a precept or "violate" it partly because the precepts do not demand obedience. And even if they did—suppose the precepts came alive and, as a group, held up signs that read, "Obey us!"—you are free to ignore their plea (and without fear of punishment). Perhaps you should ignore their plea, too.
Yet, most of us tend to relate to the precepts in at least one of these ways. I leave it to you to investigate why if you find that you do. I used to relate to the precepts in all of these ways. Some of that stems from my childhood and adolescent environment; some stems from the kind of person I am. For these and other reasons, I had some "unlearning by learning" to do, which allowed for possibilities once only merely possible to change my way of relating to the precepts.
However, I also said that the form in which we usually see the precepts contributes to a particular way of relating to them. Of course it does, by the way, as nothing is any thing or any kind of thing all on its own; everything is what it is owing to the totality of relations at any given time.
Consider the first of the Ten Clear Mind Precepts. Often, we see it stated as:
Do not kill
Or
Refrain from killing
Its form is simple, straightforward, and direct. There are no "ifs," "ands," or "buts," only three words: Do not kill. It looks a lot like a commandment, something that you can either do or not do, fail to do, or act contrary to and, since it is an imperative, demands that you do.
It is no wonder that Kobun Chino Roshi thought to offer a few more words. We read in our liturgy:
No killing life / Cultivating and encouraging life
The precept is no longer purely prohibitive but also positively prescriptive, which dulls some of the sharp edges.
There are other expressions of the precept, too. Thich Nhat Hanh articulates the first Clear Mind Precept in this way:
Aware of the suffering caused by the destruction of life, I vow to cultivate compassion and learn ways to protect the lives of people, animals, plants, and minerals. I am determined not to kill, not to let others kill, and not to condone any act of killing in the world, in my thinking, and in my way of life.
I want to stay with Thich Nhat Hanh's expression for a while. Specifically, the words, "I vow to cultivate compassion and learn ways to protect the lives of people, animals, plants, and minerals."
What does it mean to "cultivate compassion"? How do we understand this refrain, and how do we do it?
The word "compassion" translates from the Pali and Sanskrit word Karuna, and Thich Nhat Hanh describes Karuna as "the intention and capacity to relieve and transform suffering and lighten sorrows."
We see this intention and capacity in the opening lines of the Heart Sutra.
The noble Avalokiteshvara Bodhisattva
Below is an approximate transcript of the Dharma Talk I gave on May 5th as part of O-An Zendo’s Sunday program. You can read the transcript or listen to the live recording.
Thank you for listening, reading, and supporting. I bow with gratitude.
Two weeks ago, I spoke about the “essential art of zazen [seated meditation]” and kin hin (walking meditation), a companion to our sitting practice. I said that kin hin is an opportunity to “walk our zazen around the room” and that, with a bit of practice, we can also carry zazen into our day-to-day lives.
That might be an attractive proposition to you, however your sitting practice is at some time. If sitting is enjoyable, you may welcome expressing that enjoyment elsewhere. If sitting is not enjoyable, you may welcome other opportunities to be active with an open and expansive awareness. You may even entertain the story—it is only a story, by the way—that spending time off the cushion, whether walking, washing dishes, or weeding with awareness, will bring a change upon returning to the cushion. And it will, necessarily, as all things are connected with all things. “This is like this because that is like that,” as Thich Nhat Hanh taught us.
Will your walking, washing, or weeding bring the change you desire and hope for upon returning to the cushion? Probably not—and I am not sorry about that. What arises when we return to the cushion is not up to us, no matter how much we try to “curate our experience” with beads, candles, incense, and scarves. How we respond, however, to what arises—whether on the cushion, in the garden, or inline in the market—is up to us. From one point of view, that is what it means to “carry zazen into our day-to-day lives.” And from that point of view, zazen is a practice of generosity—specifically, unbounded generosity.
Today, I want to bring these two threads together and introduce a third. I want to talk indirectly about “service,” which means offering to fulfill a service position, whether on Sundays, during a retreat, or some other events. I also want to talk indirectly about samu (work practice), where we give our energy and time caring for the temple, our place of practice. “Indirectly” because a Dharma talk is not the place to remind you that we strike the big bell after announcing the title of a sutra, not before; that roll downs develop at a slow, steady pace; and that we play the drum during Jundo with Umph!
A Dharma talk is also not the place to inform you that we need three more holes dug for trees outside near the Friendship Garden.
What I want to talk about directly is Generosity, the spirit with which we sit, walk, and volunteer to support the Sangha (community of practitioners) and care for the Zendo (temple, meditation hall). To do these things, I want to spend time with the founder of our Sōtō Zen lineage, Dōgen Zenji, and a section from Shōbōgenzō Bodaisatta-shishōbō, “The Bodhisattva’s Four Methods of Guidance.”
A Phoenix’s Hut is a reader-supported publication. Please consider sharing, subscribing, or Buy Me A Coffee.
Shōbōgenzō Bodaisatta-shishōbō begins with the following:
The Bodhisattva’s four methods of guidance are giving, kind speech, beneficial action, and identity action.
Our focus is the first method: “Generosity” or “Giving” (Dāna). What is “Giving”?
“Giving” means nongreed. Nongreed means not to covet. Not to covet means not to curry favor. Even if you govern the Four Continents, you should always convey the authentic path with nongreed. It is like giving away unneeded belongings to someone you don’t know, offering flowers blooming on a distant mountain to the Tathagata, or, again, offering treasures you had in your former life to sentient beings. Whether it is of teaching or of material, each gift has its value and is worth giving. Even if the gift is not your own, there is no reason to abstain from giving. The question is not whether the gift is valuable but whether there is genuine merit.
“Giving” means nongreed. Nongreed means not to covet. Not to covet means not to curry favor.
If you read even a little Zen literature or literature about Zen, you will notice a pattern of describing something “negatively.” Here, Dōgen describes “Giving” as “nongreed,” meaning “not to covet,” meaning “not to curry favor.” Non. Not. Not.
“All right,” you might say, “I got it. But please tell me something positive—meaning without a negation!” Actually, you have not “got it.” So, let us stay with the opening sentences.
What does it mean to “not be greedy”? When we say that something is not some other thing, do we mean the opposite of that other thing? Are Generosity and Greediness opposed to each other? Or do we mean that one thing is present only when the other is absent? Wherever we find Generosity, are we unable to find Greediness? And where we find Greediness, are we unable to find Generosity? Or can the two qualities co-exist? How could we tell? How does it feel when you are generous, when you are greedy? Can you experience both groups of feelings? How about at the same time?
When we “covet” something, we feel a desire for it. But what sort of desire? Must we feel it strongly, or can it escape our notice? Must it always be the same, or can it wax and wane? If the latter, for how long? Can you covet something for many months, many years?
Allow me to speak with Dōgen’s mouth: You should investigate these questions forward, backward, from the middle outward, and all at once as though you were sitting zazen on a zafu filled with red coals.
Whatever the answer to these questions, when we covet something, Dōgen suggests that we seek to “curry favor” with something—probably someone—to obtain that which we covet. The New Oxford American Dictionary describes “currying favor” as “ingratiat[ing] oneself with someone through obsequious behavior.” I trust that you are all familiar with this way of operating because you have observed it in others and done it yourself, too.
Generosity is not this. Giving is not this, which is one way of saying: It is not about you.
The examples that follow illustrate this very point.
Even if you govern the Four Continents, you should always convey the authentic path with nongreed. It is like giving away unneeded belongings to someone you don’t know, offering flowers blooming on a distant mountain to the Tathagata, or, again, offering treasures you had in your former life to sentient beings.
The examples are not chosen at random. Collectively, they form a wide broom well-suited for sweeping away even the slightest impulse toward ingratiating behavior.
Why are there Four Continents? It does not matter! What does is that your station in life is irrelevant when considering whether to “convey the authentic path with nongreed.” Do you preside over the whole world? Great. Still, practice giving. Do you preside over nothing? Great. Still, practice giving. Are you somewhere in between? Great. Still, practice giving.
We are familiar with “giving away unneeded belongings to someone [we] don’t know.” Perhaps you donate gently used furniture to CentrePeace, and though you may say, “I know the people who work there,” they may not be the same people who bring your furniture into their homes. The same applies to offering clothing to Goodwill or contributing to a food drive. You may purchase canned goods for the food drive, but this does not mean they are not “unneeded belongings.” The dollars stored digitally in a financial institution are, and your action demonstrates that they are unneeded. You use them in a way that is “not about you.”
A point of clarification feels necessary. Saying that “giving away unneeded belongings to someone you don’t know” is “not about you” does not mean that you must be unaffected when giving. Someone may express gratitude for your gift. That is all right. You may feel good about giving the gift. That, too, is all right. You will be affected by your generosity! Why? Because you are not separate from all that is. The expression “not about you” does no…
O-An Zendo, the small Sōtō Zen temple where I live, practice, and serve the local community, resumed in-person gatherings last week. This change in the temple’s activities, mostly on Sundays, also changes my activities. Notably, I once more serve as the Doshi (Officiant) roughly every other week during our Sunday program and offer the Dharma Talk.
Zen temples, Buddhist temples, and Dharma Centers are generally structured in specific ways, both in their presentation and in the forms of conduct prescribed and prohibited. These forms help create and maintain a particular sort of experience. It is not much different from a recovery meeting or your local bookstore and coffee shop; as the young people might put it, it is about the “vibes.” And just as some recovery meetings are pretty formal, rigid, or strict about these things, while others are not, so are some temples quite formal, rigid, or strict about these things, and others are not. In all places where there is Buddhist practice, though, there is a “container” of some sort, and that container is important.
Here is how Shunryu Suzuki, Roshi, describes its importance in a Dharma Talk titled “Control” from the now-classic Zen Mind, Beginner’s Mind. Suzuki Roshi has been speaking about “perfect freedom” and closes with:
But perfect freedom is not found without some rules. People, especially young people, think that freedom is just to do what they want, that in Zen there is no need for rules. But it is absolutely necessary for us to have some rules. But this does not mean always to be under control. As long as you have rules, you have a chance for freedom. To try to obtain freedom without being aware of the rules means nothing. It is to acquire this perfect freedom that we practice zazen.
Since containers are important and much of the temple’s non-residential sangha has been away for four months, Meidō Barbara Anderson, Roshi—my Guiding Teacher—and I decided to offer a series of “reorientation talks.” This past Sunday, I talked about zazen (seated meditation) and kin hin (walking meditation). My focus was the “essential art of zazen,” the spirit recommended for zazen and kin hin, the latter sometimes described as “walking your zazen around the room.”
What follows is an approximate transcript of the Dharma Talk. You can also listen to the live recording. I recommend the recording as it includes “moments of inspiration.” In either case, though, enjoy.
A Phoenix’s Hut is a reader-supported publication. Please consider sharing, subscribing, or Buy Me A Coffee.
This morning I want to talk about zazen, our sitting practice, and what often follows when we stand up after sitting down for a while, kin hin. I am not inclined, however, to say much about the “physical posture” part of sitting practice. That is, I am not inclined to spend time on how we approach our seats. When we arrive at our seats, bow to the zafu, seiza bench, chair, or stool that is there. Then, we turn and bow in the other direction, where others may be sitting. Both bows are, from one point of view, expressions of gratitude. The first to your seat, the second to others—and since our zendo (meditation hall) has a window wall, the “others” include the trees, deer, squirrels, and everything else “beyond” this room. All of it supports us, and we support all of it, too.
I am not inclined to spend time on how we take our seats. Generally, simply “plopping down” on the cushion is discouraged. Sit down gently and with awareness, and once you settle the base of your body, sway the upper half from side to side, front to back, letting your spine find its balance and uprightness. Exhale completely, then breathe naturally as you either dim your gaze or close your eyes, and your hands rest either on your thighs or in the cosmic mudra.
Swaying the body in this way also happens at the end of zazen. There is no reason to leap from your seat as soon as the bell rings unless the zendo is on fire—and maybe not even then. During Oryoki—a ceremonial, three-bowl meal—we try to “keep pace” in eating together, neither emptying our bowls too quickly nor too slowly. So, too, when we rise from our seats at the end of zazen. Please stand neither too quickly nor too slowly. I promise kin hin will not begin sooner because you were standing first. More importantly, though, that transition should be done with “utmost care and consideration”—menmistu no kafu, in Japanese—since kin hin is an opportunity to walk our zazen around the room.
Again, though, I want to spend my time on something other than these things. I want to spend time on what Dōgen Zenji calls “the essential art of zazen,” the spirit recommended for zazen. And so that we are clear, this spirit and the physical posture we take when we sit down, while (perhaps) different, are not separate from each other.
Sometimes, we hear that Zen practice is “beyond words and scriptures” and that “thousands of words, myriad interpretations, are only to free [us] from obstructions.” How can I use language to share with you something that is not easily captured in the familiar form of phrases, sentences, paragraphs, and pages? Why do I need to say anything if a particular hindrance—attachment, aversion, boredom, restlessness, or doubt—does not obstruct your way? And might I contribute to the arising of a hindrance because I did say something when I could instead “refrain from”?
It is unsurprising, therefore, that questions, poetry, and stories are standard vehicles for Dharma Teachers, especially when the topic is zazen. Thus, Dōgen begins Fukanzazengi (Universally Recommended Instructions for Zazen) in this way:
The real way circulates everywhere; how could it require practice or enlightenment? The essential teaching is fully available; how could effort be necessary? Furthermore, the entire mirror is free of dust; why take steps to polish it? Nothing is separate from this very place; why journey away?
What is the practice of zazen or shikantaza (just sitting)? What is the specific style of practice recommended here at O-An Zendo? There is no goal, no striving, nowhere to go. That is all.
When Chinese ancestor Shitou Xiqian was asked about the essential meaning of the Buddhadharma, he responded with “Not to attain. Not to know.” When asked if there was any other pivotal point, he said, “The wide sky does not obstruct the white clouds drifting.” I typically offer the latter when I meet with someone for beginner’s instruction to describe the spirit of shikantaza. I am considering, though, using the following lines from a poem by W. H. Auden instead:
It was Easter as I walked in the public gardens
That is pretty good, too. And I am confident that some of you are familiar with this story from the Genjōkōan (Expressing What Is Most Essential):
Mayu, Zen Master Baoche, was fanning himself. A monk approached and said, “Master, the nature of wind is permanent and there is no place it does not reach. Why, then, do you fan yourself?”
“Although you understand that the nature of wind is permanent,” Mayu replied, “you do not understand the meaning of its reaching everywhere.”
“What is the meaning of its reaching everywhere?” asked the monk.
Mayu just kept fanning himself.
The monk bowed deeply.
The actualization of the buddha dharma, the vital path of its authentic transmission, is like this. If you say that you do not need to fan yourself because the nature of wind is permanent and you can have wind without fanning, you understand neither permanence nor the nature of wind. The nature of wind is permanent; because of that, the wind of the buddha house brings forth the gold of the earth and ripens the cream of the long river.
There are many other examples of oblique attempts to express the spirit of our sitting practice, ways of sharing the heart of the matter that skirt along the edges of discriminatory thinking.
Some expressions state the spirit …
From the publisher's feed