Would you spend a night in a Haunted House for $10,000? In this episode Caitlin tells Cassie the story of House on Haunted Hill and they discuss just how far they would be willing to go to collect their money.

In this week's episode, Cassie tells Caitlin a home invasion story with a twist — and the twist is intense enough to force us into our very first 0% survivability score.

You're going to want to hold on to your darkest secrets for this episode as Caitlin tells Cassie the story of 'There's Someone Inside Your House' - this killer wants to expose you for who you really are...

In this episode, Cassie tells Caitlin the story of a super market serial killer - and he's quite possibly our most deranged killer yet.

In our giggliest episode yet, Caitlin tells Cassie all about the Heart Eyes Killer - a killer who hunts down couples on Valentine's Day.

In this week's episode, Cassie tells Caitlin the story of a cultish kitchen staff running a fine dining island experience…except tonight, nobody gets to leave.

In our funniest episode yet, Caitlin tells Cassie the story of The Slumber Party Massacre (1982) and the two of them *die* laughing through absurd kills, questionable decisions and... snail hunts.

In this episode, Cassie tells the very complicated story of a killer robot…and Caitlin has no idea that this is a robot movie. 'Companion' explores much more than just 'robots', though — and offers a lot more laughs than expected.

This week, Caitlin tells the story of The Ritual (2017) and we debate the decisions of 4 men lost in the woods... who will make it out alive?

In this episode, Cassie tells Caitlin the story of a cannibalistic family that lives in the hills of a desert and trigger warning — a dog does, unfortunately, die.