
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Episode Description: In this episode, we explore the masterclass theoretical paper, "Values without Value: A Commonist Contribution to the Axiological Turn in Critical Social Theory," authored by sociologist and political theorist Dr. S. A. Hamed Hosseini (building on Commonist Value Theory co-developed with Barry K. Gills).
Hosseini delivers a sharp, crucial diagnosis of modern critical social science. While scholars across various traditions have accomplished an "axiological turn"—learning to boldly declare their ethical commitments to climate justice, recognition, human rights, decoloniality, and multispecies flourishing—these declared values remain structurally vulnerable.
When progressive movements armed only with ethical declarations confront a global capitalist order operating on a highly aggressive, operationalized account of value (enforced through accounting metrics, prices, and credit ratings), the result is a set of three recurring systemic failures:
To bridge this gap, Hosseini introduces Commonist Value Theory (CVT). The paper distinguishes True Value—generated through life-affirming commoning—from Fetish Value, which capital produces through the systematic decommonization of human and extra-human capacities.
We unpack the four interdependent commoning capacities that generate True Value (rooted in an Aristotelian causal framework):
Finally, we discuss the paper's reflexive Anti-Fetishist Coda: the warning that Commonist Value Theory applies to itself. If any metric, framework, or "commonist index" becomes a mere academic badge or compliance dashboard detached from the actual reorganization of living capacities, it has failed as a fresh instance of fetish value.
Hashtagged Keywords:
#ValuesWithoutValue #HamedHosseini #BarryGills #CommonistValueTheory #AxiologicalTurn #CriticalSocialTheory #TrueValue #FetishValue #Decommonisation #PoliticalEconomy #WellLiving #TheCommons #Pluriverse #TransformativeScholarship
Episode Description: Critical social theory has spent decades learning to boldly declare its normative commitments—from climate justice and human rights to decolonial freedom and multispecies flourishing. But what happens when our progressive values meet a global capitalist system that operates on a highly aggressive, operationalized theory of value?
In this episode, we explore the masterclass meta-theoretical paper, "Values without Value: A Commonist Contribution to the Axiological Turn in Critical Theory", authored by sociologist and political theorist S. A. Hamed Hosseini (building on Commonist Value Theory elaborated alongside Barry K. Gills).
Hosseini delivers a sharp diagnosis: critical scholarship has learned to declare values in the plural while leaving the concept of value in the singular untheorised. This creates a dangerous asymmetry. When movements armed only with ethical declarations confront a system armed with accounting metrics, credit ratings, and price mechanisms, the default result is not refutation, but metabolism—where capitalism absorbs, standardises, and commodifies progressive vocabularies (turning care, diversity, and sustainability into corporate reporting metrics and asset classes).
In this episode, we unpack:
Whether you are a scholar of critical theory, a student of political economy, or an activist seeking a causal vocabulary to defend the commons, this episode offers an essential roadmap for turning ethical ideals into actionable, systemic transformation.
Hashtagged Keywords: #ValuesWithoutValue #HamedHosseini #BarryGills #CommonistValueTheory #AxiologicalTurn #CriticalTheory #TrueValue #FetishValue #Decommonisation #PoliticalEconomy #WellLiving #TheCommons #Pluriverse
Beyond Declared Oughts: Building a Commonist Theory of True Value
Episode Description:
In this episode, we dive into the preprint paper, "After the Axiological Turn: A Reflexive Case for a Commonist Theory of Value", authored by sociologist and political theorist S. A. Hamed Hosseini. Serving as a direct response to the companion review Grounding the Ought, this early-release work takes social science past the simple declaration of progressive "oughts" to build a rigorous, life-grounded theory of value capable of challenging capitalist realism.
Hosseini argues that while the "axiological turn" in social theory has successfully taught scholars to declare commitments to justice, sustainability, and liberation, these declared values remain defenseless before a dominant capitalist order without a middle-layer theory of value regimes. We explore how the paper addresses three fundamental structural gaps—the mechanistic gap (how emancipatory values get captured), the adjudicative gap (how conflicting goods are prioritized), and the causal-praxeological gap (how utopian visions acquire real-world traction).
In this episode, we unpack:
Whether you are a student of critical theory, a researcher in political economy, or an activist seeking a causal vocabulary to defend the commons, this episode offers a masterclass in the future of transformative scholarship.
Hashtagged Keywords:#AfterTheAxiologicalTurn #HamedHosseini #CommonistValueTheory #TrueValue #FetishValue #PoliticalEconomy #CriticalTheory #Decommonisation #WellLiving #FourCommoningCauses #JudgmentalAxiology #Pluriverse #TransformativeScholarship
Grounding the Ought: The Axiological Turn in Social Theory and the Future of Liberation
Episode Description: Can social science ever truly be "value-free"—or has social thought always judged, performing better when its normative standards are explicitly owned? In this episode, we dive into the comprehensive academic review paper, "Grounding the Ought: A Critical Review of the Axiological Turn in Social Theory, from Classical Prohibitions to Multispecies Futures", authored by sociologist and political theorist S. A. Hamed Hosseini.Hosseini explores the core paradox structuring modern social science: while Max Weber’s founding methodological doctrine mandated "value-freedom" (Wertfreiheit), the most consequential achievements of social theory—from Karl Marx and Émile Durkheim to W. E. B. Du Bois—are unintelligible without an answer to how human and more-than-human life ought to be arranged. Hosseini maps the "axiological turn"—the cumulative, multidisciplinary movement that moves past hidden partiality to explicitly ground social critique in articulated positions on liberation, flourishing, and justice.In this episode, we unpack:
Whether you are a researcher navigating the ethics of inquiry, a student of social theory, or a political economist seeking firmer ethical foundations for post-capitalist futures, this episode provides an essential map for a social science that explicitly knows what goods it serves.Hashtagged Keywords: #GroundingTheOught #AxiologicalTurn #HamedHosseini #SocialTheory #CriticalTheory #ValueTheory #MultispeciesJustice #DecolonialTheory #CapabilityApproach #RealUtopias #MoreThanHuman #StandpointEpistemology #PublicSocialScience
Can social science ever truly be "value-free"—or does every critique of society secretly rely on an unspoken vision of what a good society ought to be? In this episode, we explore a masterclass in normative social theory: the landmark paper "The Axiological Turn in Social Theory: A Critical Reconstruction and the Case for Commonist Value Theory" (also presented as a reflexive review of the field), authored by sociologist and political theorist S. A. Hamed Hosseini.
Hosseini takes us on a sweeping intellectual journey through the "axiological turn" in the social sciences—the broad movement that abandoned Max Weber’s classical ideal of value freedom (Wertfreiheit) in favor of an explicit, deliberate grounding of social critique in moral stances, transformative visions, and more-than-human liberation.
In this episode, we unpack:
Whether you are a scholar of critical theory, a student of sociology, or an activist seeking firmer philosophical and ethical foundations for social transformation, this episode offers an essential roadmap for a social science that explicitly knows what it stands for.
Hashtagged Keywords:#AxiologicalTurn #SocialTheory #HamedHosseini #CriticalTheory #CommonistValueTheory #WellLivingParadigm #JudgmentalAxiology #UtopianMethod #RealUtopias #DecolonialTheory #MoreThanHumanJustice #PoliticalEconomy #SociologyOfValue
Can social science ever truly be "value-free"—or does every critique of society secretly rely on a vision of what a good society ought to be? In this episode, we explore a masterclass in normative social theory: the comprehensive review article "Grounding Social Critique in the Good: The Axiological Turn in the Social Sciences from Value Freedom to Utopian Method, Commonist Value Theory, and the Well-Living Paradigm", authored by sociologist and political theorist S A Hamed Hosseini.
Hosseini takes us on a sweeping intellectual journey, tracing how social inquiry has moved away from Max Weber’s classical ideal of value neutrality (Wertfreiheit) toward an explicit, deliberate "axiological turn." This turn reorients social science toward the rigorous analysis, justification, and pursuit of life-affirming values, positive utopian visions, and more-than-human justice.
In this episode, we unpack:
Whether you are a scholar of critical theory, a student of sociology, or an activist seeking firmer philosophical ground for social transformation, this episode offers an essential roadmap to a social science that explicitly knows what it is for.
Hashtagged Keywords:#AxiologicalTurn #SocialCritique #HamedHosseini #CriticalTheory #ConscientiousSociology #CommonistValueTheory #WellLivingParadigm #UtopianMethod #DecolonialTheory #MoreThanHumanJustice #PoliticalEconomy #SociologyOfValue #RealUtopias
Can Capitalism Survive the Planet's Response?
In this episode, we tackle one of the most pressing questions of our time: Can the biosphere persist under the endless accumulation drive of global capitalism? Our guide through this existential inquiry is the landmark chapter, "Would the Planet Survive Capitalism? Ecology, Accumulation, and a Two-Hundred-Year Argument" by sociologist and political theorist S A Hamed Hosseini.
Hosseini maps out a sweeping, two-hundred-year intellectual history of environmental thought, tracing how our understanding of ecological crises has evolved from early limits-to-growth anxieties to the precise, data-rich Earth-system sciences of today. Rather than settling for simple slogans, we dissect the systemic machinery of our planetary crisis and evaluate the competing frameworks trying to solve it.In this episode, we discuss:
Ultimately, we turn the classic question upside down. The geological planet will endure, and complex life has survived mass extinctions before. The real question is whether our current economic system can survive the planet's physical feedback loops, and how we might organize a post-capitalist future that no longer requires ecological bankruptcy for human flourishing.
#WouldThePlanetSurviveCapitalism #HamedHosseini #PoliticalEcology #Capitalocene #PlanetaryBoundaries #LimitsToGrowth #Degrowth #Ecosocialism #ClimateCrisis #SystemChange #EnvironmentalSociology #Anthropocene #EcoMarxism
Beyond Simple Explanations: Deconstructing the Global Rise of Right-Wing Populism
Why has right-wing populism swept across the globe, from Brexit and Trumpism to the rise of radical nationalists in Eastern Europe and the Global South? In this episode, we explore the groundbreaking book chapter "Right-wing Populism in a Global Perspective: The Necessity for an Integrative Theory", by S. A. Hamed Hosseini, with Lawrence J. Saha, and Elizabeth Adamczyk. Together, they offer a critical mapping of the fast-growing social science literature on right-wing populism (RWP) and provide a vital blueprint for a new, consolidative way to theorise its rise.We unpack the three main axes of discord that currently divide scholars and researchers in this field:
Ultimately, the authors argue that single-cause explanations are no longer sufficient to understand this global shift. We explore their call for an integrative theoretical framework that can successfully bridge the gaps between macro-, meso-, and micro-level processes, drawing on rich lineages like Frankfurt School Critical Theory and multi-level sociological models.
Hashtagged Keywords: #RightWingPopulism #HamedHosseini #CriticalTheory #PoliticalSociology #Neoliberalism #AntiGlobalisation #SocialChange #IntegrativeTheory #AcademicPodcast
The Limits of "Anything Goes": Why True Open-Mindedness Must Be Critical
Episode Description: What does it actually mean to be "open-minded" in a highly complex, diverse, and often polarized world? Is it simply a passive "anything goes" attitude that tolerates every possible perspective, or does genuine open-mindedness require a sharp, critical edge?
In this episode, we dive into the fascinating sociological research paper, "How ‘Critically Open-Minded’ Are We? An Australian Perspective Through the World Values Survey", co-authored by sociologists S. A. Hamed Hosseini and Lawrence J. Saha. Drawing on extensive data from the World Values Survey, the authors introduce a groundbreaking concept that challenges how we think about tolerance, diversity, and social progress: Critical Open-Mindedness.
We unpack the key insights from this crucial study:
Whether you are looking to cultivate a more reflexive perspective on social issues, curious about how sociology measures complex human values, or passionate about social justice, this episode offers a refreshing and rigorous blueprint for moving beyond empty tolerance toward an active, engaged, and critical open mind.
#CriticalOpenMindedness #HamedHosseini #LawrenceSaha #Sociology #WorldValuesSurvey #SocialPsychology #Tolerance #Diversity #SocialJustice #PoliticalEconomy #ActiveCitizenship #AustralianSociology #CriticalTheory
Physical science has delivered a stable, undeniable diagnosis of human-caused warming for over forty years, yet global greenhouse gas emissions continue to rise. For the social sciences, the real puzzle is not the geophysics of climate change itself, but why human societies continue to destabilize the very conditions of their own survival. In this episode, we dive into the landmark paper, "Root Causes of the Climate Crisis: A Critical Review of Social Scientific and Interdisciplinary Diagnoses and Remedies", authored by sociologist and political theorist S A Hamed Hosseini.Hosseini guides us through a century and a half of intellectual history, showing how our understanding of the climate crisis has successively deepened over generations. We trace the evolution of global environmental thought across three distinct eras:
Ultimately, because remedies always follow diagnoses, understanding where we locate the "root cause" of climate change determines how we attempt to fix it. This episode offers a vital map to help us move past fragmented debates and work toward a disciplined, integrated transformation of the structures we live in.
Hashtagged Keywords: #ClimateCrisis #SocialScience #PoliticalEconomy #HamedHosseini #ClimateJustice #FossilCapital #Degrowth #Anthropocene #EnvironmentalSociology #DecolonizeClimate #SystemChange #CommonPoolResources
From the publisher's feed

2,853 Listeners