In Between Sundays

What happens when life unravels, and God invites you to trust Him anyway?

In this raw and emotional testimony, Jordan and Michaela share their journey through addiction, anxiety, foster care, financial uncertainty, and a life-changing step of obedience. 

From panic attacks to career transitions, from mental health struggles to miraculous provision—this is the story of what it really means to go all in with Jesus.

Their vulnerability is powerful. Their faith is contagious. And their story might just be the encouragement you didn’t know you needed.

Why do we always feel like we need more?
More money. More stuff. More success. More security.

In this episode, Tony and Maggie talk honestly about contentment—where it breaks down, why comparison and culture fuel discontentment, and how Scripture reframes what real peace actually looks like.

From everyday struggles (like shoes, campers, and comparison) to deeper spiritual insight from Philippians 4 and the writings of C.S. Lewis, this conversation explores why discontentment isn’t just a bad habit—but a powerful distraction.

If you’ve ever thought, “I’ll be content once I get…” this episode is for you.

👉 Watch, reflect, and consider this question:
What would it look like to be at peace with what God has already provided?

Every January, millions of people make New Year’s resolutions — and most of them quit by mid-January.

So why do we keep doing this?

In this conversation, Tony and Maggie unpack why resolutions often fail and how Scripture invites us into something far better than willpower-driven self-improvement.

They talk about:

Why most resolutions collapse within weeks

The pressure people (especially women) feel to “set goals”

The difference between resolutions and spiritual commitments

Three biblical categories for real change:

1️⃣ Stop harmful things

2️⃣ Start faithful things

3️⃣ Continue fruitful things

Why your why matters more than your goal

The uncomfortable but powerful question: “What would Jesus resolve for you?”

This episode isn’t about becoming a better version of yourself — it’s about becoming the person God is forming you to be.

If you’re tired of starting over every January, this conversation will help you rethink how real transformation actually happens.

It’s Christmas — and that means lights, music, memories… and apparently strong opinions about Mary Did You Know.

In this Christmas conversation, Tony and co-host talk about:

• Why Christmas feels so emotionally powerful

• The Mary Did You Know debate (yes, we went there)

• Eggnog, Christmas music, and nostalgic traditions

• Looking back at the year and noticing how God showed up

• Gratitude, growth, and celebrating what God has done

This episode is honest, funny, reflective, and deeply human — a reminder that Christmas isn’t just about what happened then, but about recognizing what God is still doing now.

If you’re ending the year tired, grateful, reflective, or somewhere in between, this conversation is for you.

🎄 Merry Christmas.

The holidays are supposed to be joyful… so why do they feel so heavy for so many of us?

In this episode of In Between Sundays, Tony and Maggie have an honest conversation about mental health, grief, seasonal depression, and the struggle of navigating Christmas when your heart is broken.

They share personal stories of loss, unexpected emotional crashes, family traditions that now feel different, and how the presence of God—and His people—can meet us right where we are.

Whether you’re grieving, feeling low, or just struggling to fake joy this season, this episode is for you. Because Christmas is still for you too.

🎙️ In this episode:

• Why grief intensifies during the holidays

• How seasonal depression shows up—and what to do about it

• Psalm 34:18 and the nearness of God in pain

• What Blue Christmas services offer for those hurting

• How you can show up for others who are suffering

📖 “The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit.” — Psalm 34:18

Finding your purpose can feel overwhelming — and for many Christians, it’s easy to confuse your calling with your career. In this episode of In Between Sundays, we unpack what it really means to discover your God-given purpose… and how it’s often revealed over time, not in one big “burning bush” moment.

Tony and Maggie share their personal journeys of figuring out purpose, the tension between success and significance, and why your job isn’t always your calling. They’ll walk you through three key questions to help you uncover your unique role in God’s kingdom — and how to start living it out right where you are.

We also talk about:

👉 The difference between your universal purpose and your specific calling

👉 Why waiting for a “stamp of approval” can hold you back

👉 How your gifts, passions, and the world’s needs intersect

👉 Practical steps to test-drive ministry opportunities

Whether you’re just starting to explore your purpose or you’re ready to take the next step, this conversation will encourage you to stop waiting and start walking in the life God designed for you.

What do men really want in a relationship?

It’s not just sex or surface-level connection. In this honest and vulnerable conversation, Tony and Maggie unpack the four things most men long for in marriage: to be respected, to fight battles that matter, to feel needed and wanted, and to experience deep, authentic connection.

Whether you’re married, dating, or single—this episode will give you insight into the heart of biblical manhood, how respect fuels a man’s soul, and why emotional safety is vital for your relationship to thrive.

👉 A follow-up to our “What Women Want” episode, this one flips the script and explores what it means for men and women to truly understand each other.

What do women actually want from men?

In this honest and funny episode, Maggie and Tony dive into a vulnerable conversation about what women desire most in relationships — especially with men. Drawing from Scripture, real-life stories, and Maggie’s own experiences, they explore five themes: humility, being seen, safety, respect, and shared partnership.

Whether you’re married, dating, raising daughters, or just trying to be a better man — this conversation is for you.

Plus: what the Bible really says about masculinity, how men can create emotionally safe spaces, and why dishwasher loading can cause more fights than you’d expect.

Why is masculinity under attack and is the church part of the problem or the solution?

In this powerful interview, Tony sits down with Professor Nancy Pearcey, bestselling author of The Toxic War on Masculinity, to explore the cultural, historical, and biblical roots behind today’s crisis of manhood.

Whether you’re a pastor, parent, or just someone trying to navigate manhood in a confusing world, this episode will challenge assumptions and offer practical hope.

How can we stay united in a church when we disagree on… almost everything?

In this episode of In Between Sundays, Maggie and Tony get real about what it looks like to pursue unity in a diverse body of believers. From pandemic-era tensions to deeply held theological differences, they share personal stories, biblical wisdom, and practical steps for loving one another when opinions clash.

You’ll hear:

Why trust can outweigh disagreement in healthy relationships

The “window vs. mirror” principle for engaging with different perspectives

Biblical examples of diversity making the Church stronger

Practical ways to walk with people instead of just standing on issues

If you’ve ever felt the tension of loving someone whose worldview is very different from yours, this conversation will encourage you to lean in instead of walk away.