In Cold Theory

In Cold Theory

By Audrey SmithTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

In Cold Theory episodes

  • The Pixy Stix Murder - Trick or Treat

    On Halloween night in 1974, eight-year-old Timothy O’Bryan came home from trick-or-treating in Pasadena, Texas, and asked for one piece of candy before bed. Less than an hour later, he was dead from a giant Pixy Stix filled with cyanide. Four other children, including his little sister, had been given the same candy.

    Everyone thought a stranger had poisoned the candy, but the police couldn’t find the house it supposedly came from. What they found was a church deacon drowning in debt, a stack of life insurance policies on his kids, and a father who couldn’t remember where he got the candy.

    In this episode, we’re covering the Pixy Stix Murder, the case behind the candy check so many of us grew up with. We’ll talk about how Ronald Clark O’Bryan planned it, how his story fell apart, and the psychology of a man who used Halloween’s biggest urban legend to cover up the murder of his own son.

    Content Warning: this episode discusses filicide, the murder of a child by his own parent. Please listen with care.

    37 min
  • Amityville Horror - 3:15 A.M.

    Most people know the Amityville Horror as America’s most famous haunted house: the flies, the slime, the glowing red eyes, and a family who fled after just 28 days. But before the ghost story, there was a real one. In November 1974, six members of the DeFeo family were shot in their beds at 112 Ocean Avenue, and the only survivor was the man who did it.

    The actual story is much different from the media's legend. Was the house haunted, or did Hollywood turn a small-town tragedy into a worldwide hit?

    47 min
  • The Axeman of New Orleans - Fell Demon from Hottest Hell

    In 1918, New Orleans was a city of jazz, parties, and celebration, worn down by war, the Spanish flu, and deep prejudice against its Italian immigrant community. Then someone began breaking into homes in the middle of the night, chiseling through back doors and attacking families in their beds, often with an axe from their own house.

    The police chased vendettas and the Mafia, innocent men were convicted, and the killer was never caught. Then, in March 1919, a letter arrived at the Times-Picayune. The writer claimed to be “a spirit and a fell demon from hottest hell,” and he made the city a deal: anyone playing jazz on a certain night would be spared.

    Was the Axeman one man, several, or partly a newspaper invention? And did the person who wrote the letter even commit the murders?

    Content Warning: this episode discusses attacks and murders.

    47 min
  • Jack the Ripper - Catch Me When You Can

    In the fall of 1888, five women were murdered in the dark streets of Whitechapel, London, and the killer was never caught. More than 130 years later, Jack the Ripper is one of the most famous names in history. But who were the women he killed, and who was the man behind the legend?

    Content Warning: this episode includes detailed descriptions of violence, mutilation and suicide. Listener discretion is advised.

    59 min
  • Salem Witch Trials - Confess or Die

    In 1692, a small Puritan village in Massachusetts turned on itself. Two young girls began screaming and convulsing in their minister's home, and within months, about 200 people were accused of witchcraft and 20 were dead.

    In our first Halloween episode, we go beyond the myth to look at why it happened: a divided village, a minister under siege, a war on the frontier, and a court that accepted invisible attacks as evidence. We dig into the psychology behind the afflicted girls, the confession paradox that let liars live while honest people hanged, and the centuries-long fight to clear the victims' names.

    Content Warning: this episode discusses the deaths of innocent people, and the imprisonment of a young child.

    52 min
  • O.J. Simpson - The Trial of the Century

    In 1995, America stopped to watch the "Trial of the Century." This week, we're diving into the case of O.J. Simpson: his rise from the Potrero Hill projects to NFL superstar, his volatile marriage to Nicole Brown, and the night of June 12, 1994, when Nicole and her friend Ron Goldman were murdered outside her Brentwood home.

    We cover the infamous white Bronco chase, the forensic evidence, the Dream Team, the Fuhrman tapes, the glove that didn't fit, and the verdict that divided a nation. Then we follow everything that came after: the civil trial, If I Did It, the Las Vegas robbery, and how this case changed America forever.

    Content Warning: this episode discusses domestic violence, suicide, and murder.

    1 hr 9 min
  • Lizzie Borden - Innocent

    On a brutally hot Thursday morning in August 1892, Abby Borden was killed upstairs in her own guest room. Ninety minutes later, her husband Andrew was killed on the sofa downstairs. The doors were locked, nothing was stolen, and nobody saw a stranger come or go. The only person in the house both times was the couple's youngest daughter, Lizzie, a Sunday school teacher.

    This unsolved case has been the topic of gossip for decades, so we're walking through the whole case: from the family's background, to the autopsies, to the corrupted trial. We're also talking about myth versus life and ending by traveling back to the 1600s.

    Content Warning: this episode discusses a double homicide and includes non-graphic descriptions of injuries and autopsy findings.

    Quick note: the audio quality isn't my best this week. I had trouble finding a quiet place to record and my microphone was giving me trouble. Thanks for bearing with me!


    1 hr 5 min
  • Black Dahlia - Hollywood's Starlet

    In January 1947, a woman walking with her toddler in Leimert Park found the body of a 22-year-old woman. Within 24 hours the police knew her name. Within a week, the newspapers had given her a different one.

    This week we're discussing the Black Dahlia, but mostly I'm covering Elizabeth Short, which turns out to be a different story than the one everybody knows. A father who faked his own suicide and came back from the dead twelve years later. A mother who raised five daughters alone through the Depression. A fiancé who died in a plane crash before he could come home. And a letter, written seven days before her body was found, saying she was leaving California for good.

    Content Warning: this episode discusses murder, mutilation, and the sexual violence the press invented around it.

    48 min
  • Steven Stayner - Dennis Gregory Parnell

    In December of 1972, seven-year-old Steven Stayner was walking home from school in Merced, California when a man stopped him with a handful of church pamphlets and offered him a ride.

    Steven spent the next seven years living under another name, with the man who took him. He went to school. He had friends. He was never locked up, and that turns out to be the most important thing about this case.

    This week, the Steven Stayner kidnapping: how a child is taken without force, what happened when he came home at fourteen to a family frozen in 1972, the trial that gave his kidnapper seven years, and the tragedies that kept finding the Stayners for decades afterward.

    Content Warning: this episode involves a child abduction and child sexual abuse (no graphic detail), and murder.

    45 min
  • Peter Weinberger - Seven Days

    On July 4, 1956, Betty Weinberger left her one-month-old son asleep in his carriage on the patio and went inside for ten minutes. When she came back, Peter was gone and a ransom note was in his place.

    Federal law in 1956 said the FBI had to wait seven days before getting involved in a kidnapping case, and by the time agents were allowed in the door, they had almost nothing left to work with but handwriting.

    Peter Weinberger is the reason the response to a missing child now starts in the first hour instead of the second week.

    Content Warning: this episode involves the kidnapping and death of a baby.

    42 min

About In Cold Theory

From the publisher's feed

In Cold Theory with Audrey Smith is a true crime podcast that examines the psychology behind the crime. Every episode looks into a new case by exploring the facts of the crime, followed by its…