The Perceptive Photographer

In Conversation with Ken Carlson on Composition in Photography


Listen Later

Composition comes up all the time in photography conversations—and honestly, it’s one of those topics that can be both helpful and frustrating. Like a lot of folks, I started out learning the so-called “rules”: rule of thirds, leading lines, foreground interest… you know the list. They’re easy to teach, easy to check off. But over time—and with influence from people like Robert Adams, Paul Caponigro, and Ben Shahn—I started to realize that arranging lines and shapes in a pleasing way doesn’t necessarily lead to a photograph that matters.

In this episode of the Perceptive Photographer Podcast, I again sit down with Ken Carlson to dig into this idea of composition—not as a checklist, but as a way of seeing and expressing intention. We kept circling back to the same question: Why do we, and so many other photographers, get stuck on the rules? It’s tempting to believe that if you just follow the formulas, your photos will be good. Social media and tutorials love to sell that promise. But as we both admitted, that approach often leaves the work feeling a little hollow.

Ken shared some stories about technically perfect images that left him cold. I’ve certainly made my fair share of photos that looked “right” but didn’t feel right. That disconnect really boils down to one thing: intention. If we’re just arranging things because we’re supposed to, not because we mean something by it, the work loses its spark. Ken asked, “Do you ever feel like you’re just arranging things for the sake of arrangement?” That question stuck with me.

Ken also brought up a metaphor I love: composition as a quiver of arrows. Each element—light, tone, line, texture, perspective, and so on—is an arrow you can reach for when the moment calls. You don’t need to use them all at once. You just need to know which one to grab, and why.

Here’s a quick breakdown of those arrows and what they can offer:

  • Light and Brightness – Sets mood and focus, creates depth
  • Selective Sharpness – Guides the eye, adds emphasis
  • Exposure for Emotion – Tones down or turns up the feeling
  • Color and Color Contrast – Adds harmony or tension
  • Tone and Tonal Contrast – Structures the frame, separates elements
  • Line, Shape, and Form – Creates rhythm and movement
  • Texture and Pattern – Adds energy, repetition, visual interest
  • Perspective – Shifts the relationship between subject and viewer
  • Negative Space – Gives room to breathe, adds tension or calm
  • Balance and Tension – Evokes stability or unease
  • The goal isn’t to follow rules or use every tool—it’s to make choices that support what you want to say. Sometimes that means breaking the rules entirely. A centered horizon might be the right choice if it serves the image.

    Ken and I also touched on abstract photography, where recognizable subjects fall away and form does all the talking. Without literal content to lean on, the weight of meaning rests entirely on structure, color, and design. That’s where a deeper understanding of composition really pays off.

    We also talked about the way certain compositional choices carry personal or symbolic weight. Vertical lines might feel like support beams to one person and barriers to another. That’s the beauty of it—your experience informs how you compose, and that’s what gives your work its voice.

    If you’re looking to explore this more, Photography and the Art of Seeing by Freeman Patterson is a fantastic resource. It’s clear, thoughtful, and goes beyond just making things “look good.”

    At its core, composition isn’t just about arranging elements. It’s about creating meaning. As Ben Shahn once said, the artist’s job is to assume a viewer who is sensitive and intelligent—and to make something that speaks to that shared humanity.

    ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store

    The Perceptive PhotographerBy Daniel j Gregory

    • 4.9
    • 4.9
    • 4.9
    • 4.9
    • 4.9

    4.9

    54 ratings


    More shows like The Perceptive Photographer

    View all
    LensWork - Photography and the Creative Process by Brooks Jensen

    LensWork - Photography and the Creative Process

    401 Listeners

    The Candid Frame: Conversations on Photography by Ibarionex R. Perello

    The Candid Frame: Conversations on Photography

    662 Listeners

    99% Invisible by Roman Mars

    99% Invisible

    26,204 Listeners

    FroKnowsPhoto Photography Podcasts by FroKnowsPhoto

    FroKnowsPhoto Photography Podcasts

    698 Listeners

    B&H Photography Podcast by B&H Photo & Video

    B&H Photography Podcast

    2,016 Listeners

    The Beginner Photography Podcast by Raymond Hatfield

    The Beginner Photography Podcast

    401 Listeners

    Moose Podcasts by Moose Peterson's Website

    Moose Podcasts

    56 Listeners

    F-Stop Collaborate and Listen by Matt Payne

    F-Stop Collaborate and Listen

    276 Listeners

    Ologies with Alie Ward by Alie Ward

    Ologies with Alie Ward

    24,011 Listeners

    The Photowalk by Neale James

    The Photowalk

    111 Listeners

    The FujiCast: Photography Podcast by Neale James & Kevin Mullins

    The FujiCast: Photography Podcast

    114 Listeners

    FRAMES Photography Podcast by FRAMES Magazine

    FRAMES Photography Podcast

    96 Listeners

    PhotoWork with Sasha Wolf by Sasha Wolf / Real Photo Show

    PhotoWork with Sasha Wolf

    295 Listeners

    Beyond The Lens with Richard Bernabe by Richard Bernabe

    Beyond The Lens with Richard Bernabe

    121 Listeners

    The PetaPixel Podcast by PetaPixel

    The PetaPixel Podcast

    86 Listeners