Send a text
This episode is a blunt, practical deep-dive into why patient refusals are the most dangerous decision a paramedic can make—not because the paperwork is hard, but because the mindset shifts: crews treat refusals like “not a real call,” cut corners, and then get crushed later when the outcome goes bad. Paul Girard breaks down how refusals become career-ending events through weak assessments, vague documentation, and failure to prove true decision-making capacity.
Paul lays out what investigators and plaintiff attorneys actually do: they deconstruct the call to answer whether your actions were reasonable and prudent, and they’ll use far more than your narrative—EPCR metadata, timestamps, geolocation, monitor data, audit trails, and third-party video can all be pulled to expose inconsistencies or outright fraud. His message is simple: you can’t “clean it up later.” If it didn’t happen—and you can’t prove it—it will be assumed it didn’t happen.
The core refusal skill is capacity, and Paul defines it in plain terms: the patient’s ability to understand their situation and the risks/benefits of refusing—and your ability to document that understanding. The most common “capacity failures” he sees aren’t exotic—they start with a bad or incomplete assessment, refusals signed by minors or intoxicated patients, and refusals done across language barriers without a real interpreter. He also calls out provider-induced refusals—subtle or direct steering (“the ER is slammed,” “it’s expensive,” “you sure?”) that looks like you’re trying to avoid transport.
From there, the conversation goes hard into documentation: stop hiding behind “advised of risks up to and including death.” Paul explains why generalities destroy credibility and what works instead—specific risks tied to your assessment, plus a reasonable “we can’t rule out everything in the field” caveat. He also shares the brutal reality: your report is often your best defense or your demise, and short on-scene times, missing details, or signatures done later can sink you fast.
They round out with high-exposure scenarios that trip up even good crews: lift assists as “hidden refusals,” repeat callers (the “boy who cried wolf” problem), police-driven evaluations in custody situations, and when to elevate to online medical control—not because it fixes every refusal, but because sometimes a physician voice gets a patient to go, and it documents prudence. Bottom line: treat refusals like high-acuity events, slow the scene down, do the assessment, and write the report like your career depends on it—because sometimes, it does.
🔗 Website for Paul Girard & Associates – Expert EMS QA/CQI consulting and resources: 👉 https://girardassoc.com/
🎙️ Official Podcast – The G&A Way – Paul and Kevin’s EMS CQI podcast: 👉 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-g-a-way/id167567
Support the show
In-Service: The EMS Podcast is dedicated to the professional on the front lines of emergency care - in the field, the classroom and behind the scenes. Subscribe for new episodes featuring EMS leaders and innovators shaping the future of pre-hospital care.
Merchandise Store: https://www.bonfire.com/store/in-service-ems-podcast/?utm_source=copy_link&utm_medium=store_page_share&utm_campaign=in-service-ems-podcast&utm_content=default
If you have suggestions for future guests email: [email protected]
