Talk to Al Jazeera

In the grip of drought: Should Australia's farmers be subsidised? | Talk To Al Jazeera In The Field


Listen Later

The east of Australia is in the grip of drought. Parts of the states of New South Wales and Victoria received virtually no rain at all over the Australian winter, and that lack of rain came after more than a year of much-dryer-than-average conditions.
Farmers across the country are struggling to grow crops and feed their animals.
"The grind of a drought gets to you. You get a 50 kilometre per hour wind blowing in your face all day and there's a bit of dust mixed through it and you've still got to feed your stock and that .... It's just the fact that you're out there every day and things are going backwards not forwards," says sheep and cattle farmer Wayne Dunford.
Agriculture contributes three percent to Australia's gross domestic product (GDP). The industry is worth more $40bn a year and directly employs 300,000 people. It also has a unique place in the Australian psyche - and in politics.
"This is a way of life that is important to Australia's future. And as a result of that I think that means there's a special responsibility here," says Prime Minister Scott Morrison. "I'll make sure that way of life continues to be preserved."
The way colonial settlers tamed a rugged land to produce crops and graze animals is part of Australia's history and has become part of its self-identity. Even though most Australians live in cities, they have a strong affinity with what's known as 'the bush'; and have sympathy for those growing their food there.
Linda Botterill is a political scientist who has worked in the offices of two government ministers for agriculture. She says the political attachment to farming is rooted in Australians' cultural affinity with those who work the land.
"Drought makes great television. And in Australia - visually - our droughts are really confronting. So people in the city who don't necessarily understand the economics of agriculture - who have this deep cultural sympathy for farmers - want their governments to act."
Australia's national and state governments have just announced an aid package worth almost $2bn for farmers hit by drought. But what used to be an uncontroversial government expenditure is now, for the first time, attracting critical eyes.
Disapproving economists say that aid packages unlike any in other industries distort the agriculture industry. They also claim subsidies keep uneconomic farms alive artificially and discourage necessary prudence and innovation.
"If you want to be in agriculture then you've got to take the good and the bad times," says Melbourne-based economist John Freebairn.
"I feel sympathy for them. But ... farmers voluntarily choose farming .... From the perspective of individual farmers and of the nation, we would want them to be involved in farming if on average the money they make during the good times will carry them through the bad times. If the farmer can't do that and the country can't do that, then we're better off shifting those people to some other activity," he says.
"Why subsidise farming but not tourism or manufacturing or restaurants? ... You're really taking resources away from one side of the economy ... to subsidise the agricultural sector. Why would you want a bigger agricultural sector and a smaller services and manufacturing sector?"
As eastern Australia is in the grip of drought, what is the best solution for the country and its farmers?
Talk to Al Jazeera travelled to inland New South Wales to talk to farmers about how bad this drought has been and to those who are now questioning financial help for farmers.
- Subscribe to our channel: http://aje.io/AJSubscribe
- Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/AJEnglish
- Find us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/aljazeera
- Check our website: https://www.aljazeera.com/
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Talk to Al JazeeraBy Al Jazeera

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

7 ratings


More shows like Talk to Al Jazeera

View all
The Truth of the Matter by CSIS | Center for Strategic and International Studies

The Truth of the Matter

282 Listeners

Focus on Africa by BBC World Service

Focus on Africa

372 Listeners

Newshour by BBC World Service

Newshour

1,080 Listeners

The Listening Post by Al Jazeera

The Listening Post

41 Listeners

The China in Africa Podcast by The China-Global South Project

The China in Africa Podcast

207 Listeners

The Interview by BBC World Service

The Interview

362 Listeners

The Intercept Briefing by The Intercept

The Intercept Briefing

6,118 Listeners

EU Confidential by POLITICO

EU Confidential

101 Listeners

Closer Than They Appear by Al Jazeera

Closer Than They Appear

619 Listeners

Game of Our Lives by Al Jazeera

Game of Our Lives

257 Listeners

Al Jazeera News Updates by Al Jazeera

Al Jazeera News Updates

254 Listeners

The Take by Al Jazeera

The Take

483 Listeners

The Intelligence from The Economist by The Economist

The Intelligence from The Economist

2,540 Listeners

Al Jazeera Investigates by Al Jazeera

Al Jazeera Investigates

102 Listeners

The Owen Jones Podcast by Owen Jones

The Owen Jones Podcast

163 Listeners

The Inside Story Podcast by Al Jazeera

The Inside Story Podcast

128 Listeners

Centre Stage by Al Jazeera Media Network

Centre Stage

0 Listeners

Makdisi Street by Makdisi Bros.

Makdisi Street

459 Listeners

Necessary Tomorrows by Al Jazeera Media Network

Necessary Tomorrows

13 Listeners

Unshocked with Naomi Klein by Zeteo

Unshocked with Naomi Klein

51 Listeners

Now You Know by Al Jazeera

Now You Know

7 Listeners