Welcome to the In the Nick of Crime podcast! Join hosts Courtney and Michelle as we take you through various true crime cases, spooky stories, lore, and everything in between. We hope you will join us every Tuesday (and every other Thursday for bonus episodes!)

Hey creeps and freaks! We have a new Scoops and Lore adventure for you today! Courtney takes us on a journey through the dark history of one of Salem's longest standing historical landmarks, the Joshua Ward House. And Michelle proceeds to ruin your childhood by talking about the dark meanings behind the fairy tales we all know and love. This one is pretty wild, but we hope you enjoy!

Thank you as always for listening!

Source material for the episode:

Have you heard of the death of Kenneka Jenkins? We, like many others, have questions about this case. There are so many aspects of it that just don't make sense. This week, Michelle dives into all of the details and questions of Kenneka's death, as well as her mother's journey to get answers for her daughter. There is an active Change.org petition to have her case re-opened - and it is linked below. If you believe that this case has more questions than answers, please consider signing it. 

Thank you as always for listening! 

This Episode's Podcast Shoutouts: 

Source material for the episode:

Happy Tuesday, creeps and freaks! In this week's episode, Courtney tells you about the twisted and heartbreaking case of Cari Farver. This one is equal parts unbelievable and gut-wrenching. 

Thank you as always for listening!

Source material for the episode:

Hey little creeps and freaks! The third installment of our Scoops and Lore series is a day late, but that's only because we had so much content to bring you this week! In this episode, Courtney talks about one of pop culture's most well known mythological creatures, and Michelle talks spooky buildings! Would you expect anything less? 

Thank you as always for listening!

Source material for the episode:

We are back with part 2 of the Long Island Serial Killer case! In this episode, Michelle discusses the Gilgo Four, along with the potentially 12 other bodies that were found in this area at this time. We also talk about theories to try to get a better idea of a profile for the monster(s) responsible for these senseless deaths. 

If you have any information or tips that you feel may be relevant to this unsolved case, please contact 1-800-220-TIPS. No piece of information is too small!

Thank you as always for listening!

Source material for the episode:

Happy Tuesday, creeps and freaks! This week, we've got a 2 parter for you! Part 1 drops July 26th, and part 2 will drop Thursday, July 28th. This week, Michelle dives into the twisted world of the Long Island Serial Killer. Part 1 talks specifically about the disappearance of Shannan Gilbert and what the search for her lead to. While we realize that it is not proven that Shannan was a victim of LISK, we discuss the similarities and why this is still all connected. 

If you have any information or tips that you feel may be relevant to this unsolved case, please contact 1-800-220-TIPS. No piece of information is too small! 

Thank you as always for listening!

Source material for the episode:

Happy Tuesday, creeps and freaks! In today's episode, Courtney discusses the incredible case of Precious Jane Doe. This case is sure to pull at your heartstrings. We also have a lengthier introduction this week, but we do hope you stick around and listen to the whole thing! 

Thank you as always for listening!

Source material for the episode:

Happy Thursday, creeps and freaks! Today we bring you episode 2 of our "Scoops and Lore" series. We talk about UFOs, ghosties, and have a great time. We hope you enjoy! 

Thank you as always for listening! 

Source material for the episode:

In this week's episode, Michelle covers the heartbreaking case of the McStay Family Murders. The family mysteriously disappeared from their home in 2010 and for years, no one knew what happened to them. There are many mysteries surrounding this case, many of which are still unanswered today. 

Thank you as always for listening! 

Source material for the episode: