🔥 In this 'Hot Item', Kyung Sin Park (aka ‘KS Park’), Professor at Korea University Law School and co-founder and Director of Open Net Korea, & the internet lab discuss the recent joint statement by the European Telecommunications Network Operators’ Association (ETNO) and the Korea Telecommunications Operators Association (KTOA) on network fees.

📌Hot Item Highlights
⏲️[00:00] Intro
⏲️[00:39] KS Park
⏲️[10:11] Wrap-up & Outro

🗣️ [Network fees] have really suppressed the development of small to mid-sized content providers in Korea. That has not been addressed at all by the joint letter by KTOA and ETNO.

🗣️ The more people choose [specific] content, the more the content’s author has to pay to the telecom operator. It’s basically a taxation on speaking online, if speaking includes making available videos, audio, or files, etc. That's what's happening in Korea.

🗣️ [In 2021]: TeleGeography, found that the transit fee in Seoul was eight times more than London and ten times more than Frankfurt, and you can see the impact on the Internet ecosystem.

🗣️ On the argument of payments being imposed only on ‘large traffic generators’: lots of people make a living on those platforms (...) [which] are bound to shift the burden to users, and that will suppress growth of individuals and SMEs.

➡️ KTOA-ETNO Joint Statement on Network Fees
➡️ Comparisons of transit fee costs: see here and here

In this podcast Klaus Landefeld (DE-CIX Group) & the internet lab discuss what’s wrong with the EC consultation on the future of telecoms

📌Episode Highlights
⏲️[00:00] Intro
⏲️[00:47] What’s Wrong With the EC Consultation on the Future of Telecoms
⏲️[06:08] Outro

📌About Our Guest
🎙️ Klaus Landefeld | Member of the Supervisory Board, DE-CIX Group
🌐 DE-CIX
🌐 Klaus Landefeld

Klaus Landefeld is a member of the supervisory board of the DE-CIX Group. He is an expert on the topics of infrastructure and networks, net neutrality, data retention, telecommunications surveillance, and IT security. Klaus provides advice and support to organisations and authorities across the world, including as a member of the Committee for Technical Regulation in Telecommunications of the German Federal Network Agency (BNetzA). He is also a founding member of multiple internet exchange points.

In this podcast Dr. Tito Rendas (Católica Global School of Law) & the internet lab discuss what’s wrong with the EC consultation on the future of telecoms

📌Episode Highlights
⏲️[00:00] Intro
⏲️[00:53] What’s Wrong With the EC Consultation on the Future of Telecoms
⏲️[04:08] Outro

📌About Our Guest
🎙️ Dr. Tito Rendas | Executive Dean and Assistant Professor, Católica Global School of Law
🐦 https://twitter.com/titorendas
🌐 [Event] Debate | 'Telcos v. Big Tech' (17 April 2023)
🌐 29 Internet Experts and Academics send a Letter to the Commission urging to abandon the “Sending-Party-Network-Pays” proposal
🌐 [Op-ed - O Jornal Económico] Back to the future, or why Netflix shouldn't pay Vodafone (Regresso ao futuro, ou porque é que a Netflix não deve pagar à Vodafone)
🌐 Dr. Tito Rendas

Dr. Tito Rendas is Executive Dean and Assistant Professor at Católica Global School of Law, where he also co-coordinates the Masters in Law on. Law in a Digital Economy. He has been a speaker at conferences and seminars at several institutions worldwide, including the European Parliament, Yale Law School, Tel Aviv University, and the University of Cape Town, and he holds visiting teaching appointments at Freie Universität Berlin and Stockholm University. Dr. Rendas has also been an agent for the Portuguese Republic before the Court of Justice of the European Union in several preliminary reference procedures on different topics at the intersection of law and technology.

In this podcast Rudolf van der Berg (Stratix) & the internet lab discuss what’s wrong with the EC consultation on the future of telecoms

📌Episode Highlights
⏲️[00:00] Intro
⏲️[00:43] What’s Wrong With the EC Consultation on the Future of Telecoms
⏲️[06:19] Outro

📌About Our Guest
🎙️ Rudolf van der Berg | Partner, Stratix
🐦 https://twitter.com/internetthought
🌐 internet lab Season 1 Podcast with Rudolf van der Berg
🌐 [Presentation] Why You Need to Respond to the EU’s Questionnaire on Internet Connectivity (or risk the end of INEX - the Internet Neutral Exchange)
🌐 Leaked EU Connectivity Document Sets off Alarm Bells
🌐 Fast Internet Doesn’t Cost EU Telecom Operators Much at All
🌐 Internet Traffic Growth Is Not Out of Control, and Nothing Like Telcos Want You To Believe
🌐 [Video] NLNOG 2022 - Rudolf van der Berg | Big Telco vs Big Tech, Or Why Telcos Want Money for Traffic Again
🌐 [Slides] NLNOG 2022 - Rudolf van der Berg | Big Telco vs Big Tech, Or Why Telcos Want Money for Traffic Again
🌐 Rudolf van der Berg

Rudolf van der Berg is a consultant with 20 years of experience in Internet, telecom, privacy, online content, standardisation and related topics. In the past, Rudolf was an Economist and Policy Analyst at the OECD working on telecommunications and Internet-related policy. He notably wrote reports on Machine-to-Machine communication, Internet of Things, connected television, mobile termination rates, fixed mobile convergence, international cables and Internet exchange points. Working together with BEREC - the Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications, he organised two meetings on IP-interconnection, which brought the Internet peering community and regulators together.

In this podcast Ernesto Falcon (EFF) & the internet lab discuss what’s wrong with the EC consultation on the future of telecoms

📌Episode Highlights
⏲️[00:00] Intro
⏲️[00:45] What’s Wrong With the EC Consultation on the Future of Telecoms
⏲️[05:31] Outro

📌About Our Guest
🎙️ Ernesto Falcon | Senior Legislative Counsel, Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF)
🐦 https://twitter.com/EFalcon_2024
🌐 Network Usage Fees Will Harm European Consumers and Businesses
🌐 Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF)
🌐 Ernesto Falcon

Ernesto Falcon is Senior Legislative Counsel at the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF)  with a primary focus on intellectual property, open Internet issues, broadband access, and competition policy. In the US, his work includes pushing the state of California to pass the strongest net neutrality law in the country in response to federal repeal efforts.

In this podcast German MEP Sabine Verheyen (EPP Group) & the internet lab discuss what’s wrong with the EC consultation on the future of telecoms

📌Episode Highlights
⏲️[00:00] Intro
⏲️[00:45] What’s Wrong With the EC Consultation on the Future of Telecoms
⏲️[07:27] Outro

📌About Our Guest
🎙️ MEP Sabine Verheyen | German MEP, EPP Group
🐦 https://twitter.com/sabineverheyen
🌐 9 February 2023 - EP Event on Network Fees Organised by MEP Verheyen
🌐 European Parliament MEP Page

MEP Sabine Verheyen has been a Member of the European Parliament for the German Christian Democrats (CDU) since 2009 and is Chairwoman of the Committee for Culture and Education since 2019. MEP Verheyen focuses in particular on media policy, intellectual property and digital agenda issues and she took part in the past in the conciliation committee on the telecom package.

In this podcast Prof. Luca Belli (Center for Technology and Society, FGV Law School) & the internet lab discuss what’s wrong with the EC consultation on the future of telecoms

📌Episode Highlights
⏲️[00:00] Intro
⏲️[00:55] What’s Wrong With the EC Consultation on the Future of Telecoms
⏲️[08:03] Outro

📌About Our Guest
🎙️ Prof. Luca Belli | Professor & Head, Center for Technology and Society, FGV Law School
🐦 https://twitter.com/1lucabelli
🌐 29 Internet Experts and Academics send a Letter to the Commission urging to abandon the “Sending-Party-Network-Pays” proposal
🌐 Belli, L. (2017). Net neutrality, zero rating and the Minitelisation of the internet. Journal of Cyber Policy. Vol.2, 2017 - Issue 1
🌐 Belli, L. and P. De Filippi. eds. (2016). Net Neutrality Compendium: Human Rights, Free Competition and the Future of the Internet. Springer
🌐 Belli, L., & Van Bergen, M. (2013). Protecting Human Rights through Network Neutrality:  Furthering Internet Users’ Interest, Modernising Human Rights and Safeguarding the Open Internet. Council of Europe. CDMSI(2013)misc19E
🌐 Center for Technology and Society, FGV Law School
🌐 Prof. Luca Belli

Luca Belli is Professor of Digital Governance and Regulation at Foundation Getulio Vargas Law School in Brazil, where he directs the Center for Technology and Society and the CyberBRICS project. Luca served as Net Neutrality specialist for the Council of Europe and was the founder of the Net Neutrality Coalition of the UN Internet Governance Forum. His works have been quoted by numerous media outlets, including The Economist, Financial Times, Forbes, Le Monde, BBC, China Today, The Hill, O Globo, and Folha de São Paulo.

In this podcast Dean Bubley (Disruptive Analysis) & the internet lab discuss what’s wrong with the EC consultation on the future of telecoms

📌Episode Highlights
⏲️[00:00] Intro
⏲️[00:53] What’s Wrong With the EC Consultation on the Future of Telecoms
⏲️[06:14] Outro

📌About Our Guest
🎙️ Dean Bubley | Founder, Disruptive Analysis
🐦 https://twitter.com/disruptivedean
🌐 LinkedIn Contribution on the 'Fair Share' Debate
🌐 Disruptive Analysis’ Response to the UK Ofcom Consultation on the Net Neutrality Review
🌐 Dean Bubley & Disruptive Analysis

Dean Bubley is the founder of Disruptive Analysis, a technology consulting firm based in London, UK. He is known as a visionary in the telecoms and more generally connectivity sectors, and is therefore a frequent speaker at major conferences on these topics, as well as a source of quotes and contributions for publications such as The Economist, the Financial Times and the Wall Street Journal. Dean’s clients include many of the world’s leading telecom operators, vendors, regulators and industry associations.

In this podcast Nicolas Guillaume (Nasca) & the internet lab discuss what’s wrong with the EC consultation on the future of telecoms

📌Episode Highlights
⏲️[00:00] Intro
⏲️[00:49] What’s Wrong With the EC Consultation on the Future of Telecoms
⏲️[09:02] Outro

📌About Our Guest
🎙️ Nicolas Guillaume | Président, Nasca
🐦 https://twitter.com/nguillam
🌐 Télécoms et GAFAM: mais que fait l’Union Européenne ?
🌐 Netalis
🌐 Nicolas Guillaume

Nicolas Guillaume est Président du groupe français Nasca dont la filiale Netalis est un opérateur télécoms alternatif qui propose des services de connectivité dans toute la France et qui déploie son réseau de fibres optiques dans plusieurs métropoles. Expert des infrastructures Internet et réseaux télécoms depuis près de 20 ans, il a été également secrétaire général de l’AOTA, Association des Opérateurs Télécoms Alternatifs, structure nationale créée en 2017 qui fédère près de 50 opérateurs régionaux partout en France. Il s’exprime à titre personnel sur l’évolution du marché des télécoms B2B en France et en Europe.
 
Nicolas Guillaume is President of the French Nasca Group, whose subsidiary Netalis is an alternative telecom operator that offers connectivity services throughout France and deploys its fibre optic network in several metropolitan areas. He has close to 20 years of experience in Internet infrastructure and telecom networks. Nicolas has also served as secretary general of AOTA, the French association of alternative telecoms operators (Association des Opérateurs Télécoms Alternatifs), a national structure created in 2017 that federates nearly 50 regional operators throughout France. He speaks in his personal capacity on the evolution of the B2B telecom market in France and Europe.

#NetworkFees #FairShare #NetNeutrality

In this podcast Cláudio Teixeira (BEUC) & the internet lab discuss what’s wrong with the EC consultation on the future of telecoms

📌Episode Highlights
⏲️[00:00] Intro
⏲️[00:50] What’s Wrong With the EC Consultation on the Future of Telecoms
⏲️[05:47] Outro

📌About Our Guest
🎙️ Cláudio Teixeira | Digital Rights Legal Officer, BEUC
🐦 https://twitter.com/Claudi0Teixeira
🌐 Sept 2022 BEUC position paper - ‘Connectivity infrastructure and the open Internet: BEUC preliminary position on possible introduction of network infrastructure fees’
🌐 Jan 2023 BEUC letter to EU Executive Vice-President Margrethe Vestager - ‘Telecoms Joint Venture on a new digital identification solution for online advertising’
🌐 BEUC - The European Consumer Organisation
🌐 Cláudio Teixeira

Cláudio Teixeira is a Digital Rights Legal Officer at BEUC, the European Consumer Organisation, where he focuses on telecommunications, digital services and cybersecurity. He was previously at the Permanent Representation of Portugal to the EU during their 2021 Council Presidency, working on the negotiations of the Digital Markets Act (DMA) and the public Country-by-Country (CbC) Reporting Directive.