David Young (Late Night with Jimmy Fallon) stops by to watch an episode of "Are You Afraid of the Dark?" that terrified him as a kid. David confronts his fear as Craig admits to being too scared as a kid to watch SNICK (Saturday Night Nickelodeon). Listen as David and Craig revisit their childhood TV watching while Craig subtly introduces David to the world of Scientology.

Eric Slovin (Slovin and Allen, SNL) drops by to watch one of his favorite childhood shows "The Bob Newhart Show." Will the show hold up? Will there be tons of dated jokes about divorce and alfalfa sprouts? The answers are "no" and "yes." All that and talk about Eric's first days writing at SNL. Become a fan on Facebook.

Alex Waxman and Ben Johnson from the Brooklyn band Pre War check out a rockin' Episode of Tales from the Crypt featuring Iggy Pop and Sam Kinison. Things get spooky, but in a rock 'n' roll sort of way (so not really that spooky).

Aubrey Plaza (Parks and Recreation) introduces Craig to the most insane cooking show ever, "Sweet Genius." Aubrey talks about her obsession with reality TV and the time she auditioned for a reality show for female comedians. Also, Aubrey and Craig discuss depressing movies. Become a fan of "It's That Episode" on Facebook.

A live recording from the NYC Podfest with Kevin Allison (The State, RISK!), Ilana Glazer (Broad City) and Anthony Atamanuik (30 Rock, Death By Roo Roo). Kevin Allison discusses the origin of The State's "Taco Mailman" sketch and explains why The State didn't do more episodes at MTV. Ilana Glazer talks about Oprah hosting SNL in 1986 and how Oprah beat out "Hugh Humphrey" in the ratings. Anthony Atamnuik introduces the world to virtual reality "Murder She Wrote." And a special clip from "Cop Rock" that will blow your mind.

Mike Lawrence (Conan, Nerd of Mouth) stops by to check out the '90s "Ninja Turtles" knock-off "Street Sharks." Mike and Craig have a FIN-tastic time talking about how FISHY this show is. You'd have to be HAMMERHEADED not to listen. "Like" It's That Episode on FaceBook, yo.

Matt Fisher (30 Rock, The Law Firm) starts off the new year like everyone should, by watching "The Twilight Zone." Craig and Matt zone out on "The Zone," and get sidetracked by Arnold Schwarzenegger and Disney talk.

John Murray (30 Rock, Death By Roo Roo) really likes Magnum P.I. Like, he really likes it. Like a lot. Also Craig read the whole Magnum P.I. article on Wikipedia, which was extensive, so you'll learn some kickin' Tom Selleck nuggets including the fact that he was originally set to play Indiana Jones.

Abbi Jacobson (Broad City) watches the episode of "Frasier" where Niles professes his love to Daphne. Learn about the original sitcom idea that led to Frasier, find out about the time Abbi was in the studio audience for an episode of "Friends," and hear what Abbi learned while shooting the Comedy Central pilot for "Broad City."

Michael Delaney (The Other Guys, The Stepfathers) drops by to spread some Christmas spirit with his deep love for SCTV. Get a glimpse of what it meant to be a true fanatic pre-internet: going to libraries with a razor blade to cut out SCTV news clippings, stalking Catherine O'Hara outside of 30 Rock, and driving the Second City Touring Company around Florida to get a taste of the comedy world.