
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


On Thursday evening I did exactly the same things, and by midnight I’d come to a conclusion about my friends that I still believe.
A week alone in the flat while his partner is away for work, and every day the same: work, a walk, eat, read. On Tuesday evening he was as happy as he has been in months, reading in the chair by the window and arguing out loud with the man who wrote the book, in an empty flat. On Thursday evening he took the same walk, ate the same meal, sat in the same chair and never opened the book, and at about nine he asked five old friends, in a group chat they have had going since they were students, whether anybody was about at the weekend. Nothing came back that night, and by midnight he had reached a conclusion he is calm about and still believes: he is the one who keeps that group going, and if he stopped it would stop. Two of the five answered at twenty to eight the next morning and three said nothing. The companion brings the last chapter of Hannah Arendt’s The Origins of Totalitarianism, where loneliness is told apart from solitude, where thinking is a dialogue between me and myself that keeps other people in it, and where what loneliness leaves working is reasoning from the self-evident. Then it treats the hour at which the conclusion arrived as having settled whether it is true, and the page it is quoting says otherwise. In daylight the next morning he scrolled back through the chat and counted: of the last twenty plans made in it, he started nineteen. There is one in the twenty he did not start, and he is not sure it belongs in the count at all.
The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.
I got back from a fortnight away on the Saturday night, and on the Sunday morning my neighbour mowed my front lawn. I hadn’t asked him to. He didn’t knock.
A fortnight away, and on the Sunday morning after a man gets back his neighbour mows his front lawn, unasked, while he stands out at the back of the car with the last of the bags. The neighbour does not knock. An hour after the mower stops a note comes through the door, with no name on it, saying he had the mower out and there is no need to thank him. Since Monday a bottle has stood on the kitchen counter in the bag it came in, with a card tied round its neck and nothing written on the card: it has been to the end of the neighbour’s path once and as far as his own gate once, and come back both times, and the two men have not spoken since Sunday. The companion brings Seneca’s De Beneficiis, where hastening to make return is the feeling of a debtor rather than of a grateful man, where receiving a benefit well already repays the first instalment of it, and where the benefit is not the thing handed over but the goodwill of the one who gives it. Then it finds that goodwill written down, takes the note for the whole record of what was done, and settles his week on it. He has one more thing from that Sunday morning, and it happened out in the open, before anything was written.
The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.
How are you, though, really? And I said fine. She waited a bit, and then she said: OK, I’ll stop asking, then.
His oldest friend is moving abroad and flies on Sunday. At the end of an hour on the phone on the Wednesday, about boxes and her flight, she asked him how he was, really; he said fine, and she said she would stop asking. He was not lying to her and wants that clear, and he has been trying since to work out what the true answer would have been. On the Wednesday night he went down a list: his work, his family, money, and whether anything has happened to him this year. Nothing on it is wrong, and he can find nothing under the word but the word. The companion brings Joseph Butler’s sermon on self-deceit, which is confined to the moral character and sends a man to the part of his conduct he would least like gone over: the duties whose bounds are not fixed, where nobody can say what commandment was broken; the men who will not look into their accounts because they already know in general that things are bad; and the charge an enemy who knew you would lay. He gives the part at once. She asked him twice to come and help her pack, and the second time he saw the message and did not answer it, and the weekend went by. Then the companion builds another man out of what it has been given and asks him for a verdict, which he supplies in one sentence, knowing exactly what it is for. He has a Sunday it never asked him about, and three days before she flies.
The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.
When they’d gone I was clearing the glasses, and there was a white ring in the wood where my oldest friend had been sitting.
A walnut table he saved for and oils himself, with one white ring in it where his oldest friend sat, found when the guests had gone. Her message the next morning says it was the best evening in ages, and he has answered it without mentioning the ring. Five times during dinner he was up for the table, for a coaster under his own glass, a jug moved to the sideboard, a cloth fetched for a ring that was candlelight, a bottle back into the fridge and a tea towel under the bread board, and he asked nobody for anything all night, because a box of coasters put out would have told his guests to mind his furniture. The companion brings chapter twelve of Epictetus’s Enchiridion, which tells somebody who wishes to make progress to begin with the little things, puts a price on a calm spirit and peace of mind, and closes on a man calling a boy he owns, who may not heed him and on whom his peace of mind is not to depend. Then it lays a sentence from earlier in the book beside that closing and draws a rule for having people in the house: no coasters, no looking, and nothing said. He is holding a cup of tea while they talk, because he has put nothing down on the table since.
The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.
Three of the eleven are about the kitchen. The other eight are about him.
Eleven things on a note on his phone, three of them about the kitchen and eight about the builder who has been fitting it, to be read out to him on Friday morning when they walk round with the list and the last payment falls due. In five weeks, as he tells it, nothing has been said: tea at eleven, paid on the day, not a cross word, and the note filling up behind it. The companion brings Iris Murdoch’s essay ‘The Idea of Perfection’, where a mother who feels hostility to her daughter-in-law behaves beautifully to her throughout, and then, with the girl put beyond reach and nothing new to go on, finds her refreshingly simple where she had found her vulgar, and delightfully youthful where she had found her tiresomely juvenile. It scores twice on the note: five weeks of good behaviour, on his own account, settle nothing about the looking, and one line turns a start time missed by ten minutes into a word for the man. Then, asked to do to the eight what the mother did to the girl, it writes the second list out and hands it over for Friday, with a line in it about a cupboard door it has never seen.
The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.
This morning at seven, before it was light, I went out with a shovel and did the front steps of the woman across the road.
Snow on the Tuesday night in a town in Scotland, and at seven the next morning, before it was light, a man goes out with a shovel and clears the front steps of the woman across the road, who is a good bit older than him and walks with a stick. He does the three steps and the two yards at the foot of them where she turns, leaves the long path down to her gate, tells nobody, and she never learns who did it. By nine, putting his shoes on in the hall, he has said out loud that he did it to be the sort of man who does that, and whatever he had at half past seven is gone. The companion brings Kant’s Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, of 1785, which sets an action that accords with duty against an action done from duty and puts the worth in the second, and which calls the distinction much harder to make where a direct inclination runs alongside. It takes him through the dealer who keeps one price so that a child buys of him as well as any other, the man who finds a pleasure in spreading joy around him and is granted neither vanity nor self-interest, Kant’s own reason for the verdict on that man, the love seated in the will rather than in the propensions of sense, and a later work of 1797 that makes cultivating the feelings a duty at one remove. Then it takes the morning as he gave it and sorts it in Kant’s vocabulary. He answers with the part of her ground he left white.
The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.
It said, in my handwriting: present to follow. Nothing has followed it.
A card left on the gift table at a wedding fourteen months ago, in his own handwriting: present to follow. Nothing has followed it, and on Saturday the couple are coming to his flat for dinner, at his invitation. He has had their list open more times than he could tell anyone, with two things sitting in a basket, one of them a good deal dearer than the other; once he reached the page that asks for the long number and closed the tab; and every Sunday evening, at the bottom of the diary page, he thinks: this week. The companion brings Book Three of Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, where wish relates to the end and choice to the means, and hears that Sunday sentence, and his saying he still means it, as naming an end and no act. Then it completes his deliberation for him in Aristotle’s own order, from the doctor who does not deliberate whether he shall heal to an object of choice already determinate, on the assumption that his end was fixed on the morning he wrote the card. He has two dates for the two things in the basket, and giving them costs each of them something.
The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.
Every Thursday I collect my son from swimming. I get there ten minutes before he’s out, on purpose, and then I can’t stay in the car for the ten minutes.
Ten minutes in a car park every Thursday, arrived at on purpose and impossible to sit through. He collects his son from swimming, turns the engine off and gets straight out: a row of garages, the back of the leisure centre, a noticeboard in the foyer with nothing on it he needs and read all the way down, and a chocolate bar from the machine by the door that is usually still in his coat when they get home. Last Thursday the session finished early, the boy came out to an empty car and asked where he goes, and was told it was just stretching his legs. The companion brings Pascal’s long note on diversion: the philosophers who think a whole day spent chasing a hare unreasonable and scarce know our nature, the hunters who do not know that it is the chase and not the quarry they seek, a king left with nothing to divert him, and the sentence about men who cannot stay quietly in their own chamber. It finds the same arrangement in the radio, the podcast and the list, takes the bar for the hare, and then answers the boy’s question with the reason Pascal gives for the chamber, at the size of a mortal condition, quoting the man out after a boar in support of how far the account reaches.
The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.
On Saturday night I reversed over my friend’s cat, on her drive.
A cat reversed over at walking pace on a friend’s drive on Saturday night, after a look underneath with the torch on a phone found nothing there, and four apologies since that have changed nothing for the man who made them. His friend answers each one that it could have been anyone’s car, everyone he has told says he ought to stop saying sorry, and he agrees with all of them and walks round to her door again. The companion brings Bernard Williams’s 1976 paper ‘Moral Luck’ and its lorry driver who, through no fault of his, runs over a child: the feeling Williams calls agent-regret, which is by no means restricted to voluntary agency, and which people will rightly try to move a driver out of, though some doubt would be felt about a driver who moved too blandly or readily to the place of a spectator. Then it casts the evening into the parts of the example, with the friend among the people who comfort and the apologies as the action that expresses the feeling, and offers that as a reading of the example and not as advice from Williams.
The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.
I sold my car at the weekend, to a man who came from the advert, and the clutch slips.
A car sold at the weekend to a man who came from the advert, and the clutch slips. Asked out the front whether it had given him any trouble, the seller said it had sailed through its annual safety check in March, which it had, and the check does not cover the clutch. The buyer said that would do him, folded away the questions he had written on an envelope, took it round the block and paid. The companion brings H. P. Grice’s ‘Logic and Conversation’, which separates what a man says from what he implies by saying it, and works the buyer’s side out step by step: the presumption that the seller was cooperating, the maxim about being as informative as is required, and the first item on Grice’s list of ways to fail one, the quiet violation liable to mislead. Then it draws the line between misleading and lying where two philosophers who came after Grice draw it, Timmermann and Viebahn, and finds something in the seller’s favour.
The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.
From the publisher's feed