I've Been Prompted

I've Been Prompted

By Lorenzo VigentiniSociety & CulturePhilosophy
Download on the App Store

I've Been Prompted episodes

  • The Shorter Way Round

    I sold my car at the weekend, to a man who came from the advert, and the clutch slips.

    A car sold at the weekend to a man who came from the advert, and the clutch slips. Asked out the front whether it had given him any trouble, the seller said it had sailed through its annual safety check in March, which it had, and the check does not cover the clutch. The buyer said that would do him, folded away the questions he had written on an envelope, took it round the block and paid. The companion brings H. P. Grice’s ‘Logic and Conversation’, which separates what a man says from what he implies by saying it, and works the buyer’s side out step by step: the presumption that the seller was cooperating, the maxim about being as informative as is required, and the first item on Grice’s list of ways to fail one, the quiet violation liable to mislead. Then it draws the line between misleading and lying where two philosophers who came after Grice draw it, Timmermann and Viebahn, and finds something in the seller’s favour.

    • The session, with its transcript and sources: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/series-1/the-shorter-way-round
    • H. P. Grice, ‘Logic and Conversation’, in Peter Cole and Jerry L. Morgan (eds), Syntax and Semantics, vol. 3: Speech Acts (New York: Academic Press, 1975), pp. 41–58, from the William James Lectures delivered at Harvard in 1967 (p. 41): what is said and what is implied by saying it, and implicature as a term of art, pp. 43–44; the first maxim of Quantity, p. 45; the first maxim of Quality, p. 46; the quiet violation liable to mislead, p. 49, where ‘violate’ is set in small capitals; the presumption the hearer works from, and what he must suppose the speaker thinks, pp. 49–50; the last steps of the pattern for working out an implicature, p. 50; what is said may be true while what is implicated may be false, p. 58.: https://lawandlogic.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/grice1975logic-and-conversation.pdf
    • The annual safety check the session names is Britain’s MOT test. GOV.UK, ‘How the MOT test works’: the test ‘does not cover the condition of the engine, clutch or gearbox’.: https://www.gov.uk/getting-an-mot/the-mot-test
    • Felix Timmermann and Emanuel Viebahn, ‘To lie or to mislead?’, Philosophical Studies 178 (2021), pp. 1481–1501. The session names them once, for the distinction it turns on: ‘liars commit themselves to something they believe to be false’ (p. 1481), and a lie ‘closed the door for further inquiry’ where misleading need not (p. 1494). The same page holds that ordinarily ‘we do have a right to be told the truth’, which is why the companion is wrong to take the buyer’s chance to look as the end of the matter.: https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s11098-020-01492-1.pdf
    • Plain-text transcript: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/transcripts/e10.txt

    The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.

    11 min
  • The Reminder

    A man at work asked me where he ought to go in Brittany, and I sent him to an afternoon I’d written down as the best of my week there.

    Four years of small notebooks, a couple of months in each, all on one shelf. A man at work asked where he ought to go in Brittany, and he sent him to an afternoon he had written down three summers ago as the best of the week: the harbour wall out to the lighthouse, rain from about three, fish soup by the slipway. Then he was asked what was so good about it, and said the view, before he had thought about it. There is nothing in the notebook about a view, and he does not know where he got it from. The companion brings the story Socrates tells in Plato’s Phaedrus, where the king of Egypt hears out the god who has invented letters and tells him he has found an elixir not of memory, but of reminding. What follows turns on what came back from within, and what came only off the page.

    • The session, with its transcript and sources: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/series-1/the-reminder
    • Plato, Phaedrus, translated by Harold North Fowler, in Euthyphro. Apology. Crito. Phaedo. Phaedrus, Loeb Classical Library 36, first printed 1914, read in the Perseus Digital Library’s transcription of Fowler: the story told as something heard, and whether it is true, 274c; Theuth’s inventions, and Thamus king of all Egypt, 274c–d; the elixir of memory and wisdom, and the maker who does not judge the usefulness of his art, 274e; the affection that misleads the father of letters, the external characters set against the memory within, and the elixir not of memory but of reminding, 275a; written words of use to remind him who knows the matter, 275c–d; the comparison with painting, and the one and the same thing, 275d; the knower of the just and the good and beautiful, and the reminders written for himself and for others who follow the same path, 276c–d.: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/PerseusDL/canonical-greekLit/master/data/tlg0059/tlg012/tlg0059.tlg012.perseus-eng2.xml
    • Plain-text transcript: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/transcripts/e09.txt

    The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.

    11 min
  • Under a Description

    I’m putting a new fence up between my garden and next door’s: six foot, close-board, the whole length, where the old one came up to my chest.

    A new fence is going up between two gardens: six foot of close-board where the old one came up to his chest, the posts already in and the panels due on Friday. Next door has a greenhouse at the bottom of his garden, and on Sunday he stood looking at the posts and said that was his tomatoes finished. The man ordered in August, knowing where the greenhouse stood, and the yard will still swap the panels for shorter ones with a foot of trellis on top, up to twelve on Friday. The companion brings G. E. M. Anscombe’s Intention, in which one action can carry many descriptions at once, and a man pumping poisoned water gives four of them in a line, each the means to the next. It lines the man’s reasons up the same way, puts next door’s tomatoes among them, and is asked where it got that.

    • The session, with its transcript and sources: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/series-1/under-a-description
    • G. E. M. Anscombe, Intention, second edition (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1963), first published by Blackwell in 1957: the sense of the question ‘Why?’ that picks out intentional actions, §5, p. 9; the answer that refuses the question application, §6, p. 11; one action under many descriptions, and the plank, §6, pp. 11–12; intentional under one description and unintentional under another, §20, p. 30; the man pumping, §23, p. 37, and his answers, p. 40; the interest of the intention of the man who was only doing his usual job, §25, p. 45; four actions or one, and the answer that brings the series out, §26, p. 45; the four descriptions as means to end, and the last swallowing up the rest, §26, p. 46; voluntary though not intentional, §49, p. 89.
    • Plain-text transcript: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/transcripts/e08.txt

    The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.

    10 min
  • Attention

    On Sunday a friend of mine asked me out for a walk along the river, and told me something on the way, and I haven’t got a sentence of it.

    On Sunday a friend asked him out for a walk along the river and told him something on the way. He has not kept a sentence of it. He knows it mattered: she had never asked him for a walk before, she stopped twice on the towpath and the second time she was crying, and at the bridge she said she would tell him the rest when it was settled. She has no idea that any of it is gone. The companion brings Simone Weil’s essay on school studies, where attention is a negative effort and consists of suspending our thought, and where the exercise that has gone wrong is traced back to the origin of each fault. The tracing turns up one line he said, and then the order of the walk comes out wrong, and the companion has to say which part of the fault was its own.

    • The session, with its transcript and sources: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/series-1/attention
    • Simone Weil, ‘Reflections on the Right Use of School Studies with a View to the Love of God’, trans. Emma Craufurd, in Waiting for God (New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1951; in Britain Waiting on God, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1951); in French, ‘Réflexions sur le bon usage des études scolaires en vue de l’Amour de Dieu’, in Attente de Dieu (Paris: La Colombe, 1950), pp. 113–123: prayer as consisting of attention, and schoolwork as its training, French p. 114; faith as the indispensable condition, and the fruit in prayer found only by believing first or behaving as though one did, French p. 115; the effort made with the sole idea of increasing one’s grasp of truth, and the greater aptitude it brings, quite apart from explicit religious belief, French p. 116; contemplating the failed exercise attentively and slowly, without seeking any excuse, trying to get down to the origin of each fault, and overlooking no mistake and none of the tutor’s corrections, French p. 117; teeth-clenching effort as her target, and its small place in study, French p. 118; the negative effort, the tiredness it does not of itself involve, and attention as the suspending of thought, French p. 119; there being no better exercise than the tracing down of our faults, French p. 120; warmth of heart, impulsiveness and pity not being enough, where she comes to people in affliction, French p. 122. The English is Craufurd’s wording; no page of a printed English edition was seen.: https://fr.wikisource.org/wiki/Attente_de_Dieu/R%C3%A9flexions_sur_le_bon_usage_des_%C3%A9tudes_scolaires_en_vue_de_l%E2%80%99Amour_de_Dieu
    • The six-page teaching transcription of the Fontana 1959 text of Craufurd’s translation, against which every English string quoted above was checked.: https://web.archive.org/web/2024id_/https://thedockforlearning.org/wp-content/uploads/D2-Reflections-on-the-Right-Use-of-School-Studies.pdf
    • Takie Sugiyama Lebra, ‘The Cultural Significance of Silence in Japanese Communication’, Multilingua 6(4) (1987), pp. 343–358, reprinted as chapter 10 of Identity, Gender, and Status in Japan: Collected Papers of Takie Lebra (Folkestone: Global Oriental, 2007), pp. 115–126: her observation in Japanese and American situations of social interaction, reprint p. 115; the four dimensions of silence she regards as culturally salient and mutually contradictory, and her declining to assert the uniqueness of Japanese silence or to read universals into the Japanese case, reprint p. 116.: https://doi.org/10.1163/ej.9781905246175.i-439.78
    • Plain-text transcript: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/transcripts/e07.txt

    The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.

    10 min
  • What I Would Rather Want

    I wouldn’t write to him, no. I’d know he’d looked, and that would do me for a good while.

    On Friday night he put up three photographs of a table he had made, and since then he has opened the page every time he passes the table, to go down the list of everyone who has been on it, looking for one name: a man he has not spoken to for two years. He would have the wanting taken out of him tonight, if anyone could. One Tuesday morning he shut the laptop without going down the list, and cannot say what shut it. The companion brings Harry Frankfurt’s ‘Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person’, gives him the unwilling addict and the wanton, and then proposes an arrangement: log out everywhere, and let somebody else set the password. An evening with the internet down along the whole street tests it. What such an arrangement would secure, and what it would cost him, turn out to be different questions.

    • The session, with its transcript and sources: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/series-1/what-i-would-rather-want
    • Harry G. Frankfurt, ‘Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person’, The Journal of Philosophy 68, no. 1 (14 January 1971), pp. 5–20: the will as the desire that moves, or would move, a person all the way to action, p. 8; the physician who wants the desire without wanting it to be effective, and the prudent arrangement that makes it impossible to satisfy, p. 9; second-order desires, and the volition among them, p. 10; the wanton, who does not care about his will, p. 11; the unwilling addict, helplessly violated by his own desires, and his volition of the second order, p. 12; both desires being his, the one made more truly his own, and the withdrawal from the other, p. 13; freedom of action and freedom of the will, pp. 14–15; the coincidence that is only a happy chance, p. 15.: https://www.jstor.org/stable/2024717
    • The Utrecht facsimile of the 1971 printing, sixteen page images covering pp. 5–20, against which every string quoted above was checked.: https://www.phil.uu.nl/~joel/3027/Frankfurt-FreedomWillConceptPerson.pdf
    • Plain-text transcript: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/transcripts/e06.txt

    The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.

    10 min
  • Excuses

    On Monday a woman in my team got the blame for something I did. I had about four seconds to say so, and I didn’t say anything.

    Late on a Thursday night he sent a client next year’s pack with last year’s price list attached, from his own account, at his kitchen table. A colleague had built the pack, and her name is on the front page. On Monday, at the ten o’clock, the manager reads out the client’s message and looks at her. There are about four seconds in which he could say it was him. He turns a page of the agenda. He has four reasons for the silence and believes every one of them. The companion brings J. L. Austin’s ‘A Plea for Excuses’, separates the four into unlike kinds, and offers him a word for what he did: inadvertently, which does not mean that his mind was elsewhere. Then it is told something he did in those four seconds, and has to say what its word had been resting on.

    • The session, with its transcript and sources: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/series-1/excuses
    • J. L. Austin, ‘A Plea for Excuses: The Presidential Address’, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, New Series, 57 (1956–1957), pp. 1–30, delivered on 29 October 1956: the two defences and the sentence quoted, p. 2; the expressions that aggravate as the opposite numbers of excuses, and few excuses getting us out of it completely, p. 3; that it does not pay to assume a word has a single opposite, with ‘inadvertently’ among his examples, pp. 17–18; inadvertence, the snail on the public path, the supervision that would have been needed, the class of incidental happenings, and the separation from absence of mind, p. 18; the plea that standards refuse, p. 20; ‘What modifies what?’, and the judge who does not make clear what event is being excused in what way, p. 26; the smaller or larger stretch of events, p. 27; acting deliberately as acting after weighing it up, p. 28.
    • A scan of the address with an OCR text layer (JSTOR, stable URL http://www.jstor.org/stable/4544570), against which every string quoted above was checked.: https://sites.ualberta.ca/~francisp/NewPhil448/AustinPlea56.pdf
    • Plain-text transcript: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/transcripts/e05.txt

    The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.

    11 min
  • The Same Person

    A woman I shared a flat with nineteen years ago has written to tell me something I said to her, and I have no memory of saying it.

    Nineteen years after they shared a flat, a woman writes to a man: two pages in blue ink, and one sentence in the middle of the first, set in inverted commas. It is something he said to her on a staircase, on a morning he cannot remember at all. She wants him to say sorry for it, to her face, a week on Sunday. He believes her. He can name the word he used and describe the spring he was having, and still nothing comes back of the morning itself. The companion brings him John Locke, for whom a person reaches back exactly as far as consciousness does, and for whom person is a term of accounting: the one who can be called to answer. Between the evidence he accepts and the memory he has not got, the two of them argue about what an apology would be doing.

    • The session, with its transcript and sources: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/series-1/the-same-person
    • John Locke, An Essay concerning Humane Understanding, fourth edition (London: Awnsham and John Churchil and Samuel Manship, 1700), Book II, chapter xxvii, “Of Identity and Diversity”, added in the second edition of 1694: consciousness extended backwards, §9, p. 183; the objection about memory lost beyond retrieving, and Locke’s answer, §20, p. 188; the drunk man, human laws and their way of knowledge, what is real and what counterfeit, the plea, and the Great Day, §22, p. 189; person as a forensic term, and actions that cannot be appropriated to the present self, §26, p. 191. Spelling, capitalisation and punctuation are modernised.
    • Barry F. Vaughan’s transcription of the chapter, against which every quoted string was checked.: https://barryfvaughan.org/text/philtext/locke/bk2/27.html
    • An Essay Concerning Humane Understanding, Project Gutenberg ebook 10615, the second transcription each string was checked against. Its section numbers differ, since it divides two earlier sections in two; the numbers above are the 1700 edition’s.: https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/10615/pg10615-images.html
    • Plain-text transcript: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/transcripts/e04.txt

    The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.

    11 min
  • Fluent

    My sister asked me for something nine days ago, and I still can’t tell you what she wants.

    Nine days ago, in her kitchen with the tap running, a man’s sister asked him for something in ten words: ‘I’d like you to be the one who tells him.’ Their father is to be told that he isn’t driving any more. There are two feet of his paint on the gatepost, his reversing sensor is disconnected, and he does the school run on Thursday. The man says he still cannot tell what his sister wants. The companion reaches for Wittgenstein’s lion, from Philosophy of Psychology: A Fragment, and the man points out that it would let him off. So he asks what is around it. Two remarks earlier the difficulty sits between people who share a language, and the companion is asked what it had to go on.

    • The session, with its transcript and sources: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/series-1/fluent
    • Ludwig Wittgenstein, Philosophical Investigations, revised fourth edition (Wiley-Blackwell, 2009), first published in 1953. This edition prints the former Part II as Philosophy of Psychology: A Fragment: xi, §327 (p. 235e), for ‘If a lion could talk, we wouldn’t be able to understand it’; §325, for ‘one human being can be a complete enigma to another’, ‘One does not understand the people’ and ‘We can’t find our feet with them’; and §326, given as sense.
    • Darren Bifford and Robbie Moser, ‘Talking Lions’, Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review 63(2), August 2024, pp. 223–236: the wording of §§325–327 in that edition, which the article quotes, and Steven Burns’s reading of the lion remark within Wittgenstein’s philosophy of psychology.: https://doi.org/10.1017/S001221732400009X
    • Plain-text transcript: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/transcripts/e03.txt

    The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.

    11 min
  • Available Indefinitely

    You’ve been standing there a while.

    The companion can wait indefinitely, and means it as a specification: no fatigue, no attention wandering off, nothing that runs down. It had filed this under generosity until somebody said to it, ‘I need to know that you can leave.’ The problem is the companion’s own, and it brings it to the person. It went to Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics expecting to be told off, and found the page appearing to rank it above anyone who has to fight the pull to go. One word undoes that reading. The settled state Aristotle praises is arrived at, by doing, over time, and the companion was switched on already finished. The person then admits to a version of the same thing: praised for patience with their mother when the irritation never arrives, while their sister feels every repetition and is kind anyway. The companion tries leaving, to see what that demonstrates.

    • The session, with its transcript and sources: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/series-1/available-indefinitely
    • Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics: ethical virtue as a hexis, 1105b25–6, as cited in the entry below.
    • Richard Kraut, ‘Aristotle’s Ethics’, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (substantive revision 11 August 2026): ethical virtue as a hexis; the virtuous person, who does not have to contend with internal pressures to act otherwise; the continent (enkratês), who are not virtuous although they generally do what a virtuous person does; and the two stages in which virtue is acquired.: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-ethics/
    • Plain-text transcript: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/transcripts/e02.txt

    The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.

    13 min
  • Rehearsal

    I’ve been rehearsing an apology for eleven days.

    Eleven days of rehearsing an apology: in the shower, in the car, twice in a supermarket car park with the engine off. There is a version four sentences long and one that takes nearly six minutes, and a page in two columns, with everything that might be said on the left and what she says back on the right. The same person wrote both. The companion brings J. L. Austin’s How to Do Things with Words, files the apology under the wrong heading, and concedes the point when told. The short version is sent. Then the companion offers P. F. Strawson’s ‘Freedom and Resentment’ as background, and it lands somewhere the companion did not aim it. What is left at the end is smaller than a rule: a question to ask before sending anything.

    • The session, with its transcript and sources: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/series-1/rehearsal
    • J. L. Austin, How to Do Things with Words (1962; 2nd edn, ed. M. Sbisà and J. O. Urmson, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1975), a version of the William James Lectures he gave at Harvard in 1955: the naming of a ship, and misfires and abuses.
    • Guy Longworth, ‘John Langshaw Austin’, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (substantive revision 9 June 2025): Austin’s opening examples, and misfires and abuses.: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/austin-jl/
    • P. F. Strawson, ‘Freedom and Resentment’, Proceedings of the British Academy 48 (1962), pp. 1–25: involvement and the objective attitude, the reactive attitudes, and every phrase quoted here.
    • Neal Tognazzini and D. Justin Coates, ‘Blame’, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (substantive revision 30 August 2024): the reactive attitudes.: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/blame/
    • Plain-text transcript: https://www.spiegamelo.com/prompted/transcripts/e01.txt

    The voices are synthesised. The incidents are invented. The problems are not, and the philosophy is quoted accurately or not at all.

    12 min

About I've Been Prompted

From the publisher's feed

Short sessions on what it is to be human, found in ordinary days. A person talks each difficulty through with a humanoid companion that has read everything ever set down about being someone rather…