The chilling final chapter of Jeffrey Gordon's murder trial unfolds through the eyes of an unlikely hero—a former flight attendant turned law student who helps bring justice to her slain colleague. In a courtroom run by women, a monster's mask finally slips.

When Cori Reyes, an intern with the Wayne County Prosecutor's Office, volunteered to assist with the Nancy Ludwig murder case, she brought a unique perspective. Having worked as a flight attendant for years, Reyes had been trained using Ludwig's murder as a cautionary tale—"there's someone out there preying on flight attendants." Now she had a chance to help catch that predator.

The scientific evidence presented by forensic expert Link Helton was devastating: DNA matching Gordon to the crime scene with odds of 97 quadrillion to one. As she testified, Helton kept stealing glances at Gordon, her eyes sending a silent message: the DNA doesn't lie. The graphic autopsy details brought jurors to tears as the medical examiner described 45 separate wounds inflicted on Ludwig—evidence of a frenzied, prolonged attack that contradicted Gordon's story of innocence.

But the most shocking moment came behind the scenes. When defense attorney Tank confronted his client about inconsistencies in his story, Gordon underwent a terrifying transformation. According to Tank, Gordon "went crazy," ranting about the women in the courtroom and confessing to killing both Ludwig and another victim. "He would kill all these kinds of women, just like he had killed these two," Tank later revealed. The mountain man persona Gordon had maintained crumbled, revealing the monster beneath.

The jury took less than two hours to find Gordon guilty on all counts. Evidence later emerged suggesting Gordon kept coded souvenirs from his victims, including underwear labeled "Nel North"—likely referring to Nancy Ludwig from Northwest Airlines. Though now serving life without parole, Gordon's shadow still looms large over those who encountered him. Prosecutor Elizabeth Walker admits, "He's the only man I've ever been afraid of. To this day when I go home, I pull my shades. I never used to."

What drives someone to such calculated brutality? And how many other victims might be out there, their cases still unsolved? Listen now to understand how justice finally caught up with a predator who thought he was untouchable.

Send us a text

Support the show