Send us a text

In this episode of Justice Seekers, we revisit one of the most infamous criminal trials in American history: The People v. O.J. Simpson.
What happens when overwhelming evidence collides with police misconduct, racial tension, media spectacle, and a deeply divided jury? We break down the case beyond the headlines, examining how the prosecution lost control of a winnable case, how the defense reshaped reasonable doubt, and why the verdict still sparks debate decades later.

Send us a text

In this episode of Justice Seekers, we examine the controversial death of 28-year-old teacher Ellen Greenberg — a case initially ruled a homicide, then quietly changed to suicide despite more than twenty stab wounds and troubling forensic inconsistencies.

Through a legal lens, we break down how early assumptions shaped the investigation, the significance of the locked door theory, missing evidence, and the Greenberg family’s years-long civil battle for transparency and accountability.

Was this a tragically misclassified death — or a system too quick to close the case?

Send us a text

In this episode, attorneys Natalie and Katrina examine the 1996 abduction and murder of 9-year-old Amber Hagerman, the case that prompted the creation of the Amber Alert system and reshaped law enforcement response to child abductions nationwide.

We analyze the investigative timeline, evidentiary breakdowns, and jurisdictional delays that limited early rescue efforts, then break down the legal framework governing Amber Alerts today—including statutory criteria, constitutional considerations, and concerns about equal protection, alert fatigue, and public trust.

Nearly three decades later, the case remains unsolved, but its legal legacy endures as one of the most significant reforms in modern child-protection law.

Send us a text

In 1991, a fire ripped through a small home in Corsicana, Texas, killing three young sisters. Their father, Cameron Todd Willingham, escaped; but within days, investigators accused him of deliberately setting the fire.

In this episode, attorneys Natalie and Katrina revisit the Willingham case and examine why so many believe Texas executed an innocent man.

What We Cover

• The fire and early suspicion
• Outdated arson methods used to claim the blaze was intentional
• Jailhouse informant testimony later revealed as unreliable
• Defense failures in a death penalty trial
• Prosecutorial misconduct allegations
• How junk science continues to drive wrongful convictions

Why It Matters

The Willingham case exposes cracks in the justice system, reminding us that flawed forensics, unreliable witnesses, and weak defense representation can mean the difference between life and death.

Send us a text

On Christmas Eve 2002, 27-year-old Laci Peterson, eight months pregnant, vanished from her Modesto, California home. What began as a missing persons search spiraled into a national obsession, exposing infidelity, media mania, and one of the most polarizing murder cases in American history.

In this episode, Natalie and Katrina unpack the timeline, investigation, legal missteps, and cultural impact of the case that transformed Scott Peterson from an average husband to the face of presumed guilt across America.

Send us a text

In this episode of Justice Seekers, Katrina and Natalie journey back to small-town Minnesota in the late 1980s, where trust and freedom defined childhood -- until one tragic night shattered a community’s sense of safety.   We'll explore the ripple effects of Jacob's abduction, including the creation of the first national sex offender registry, the evolution of child protection laws, and the ongoing tension between public safety and constitutional rights.

Mixed & Edited by Next Day Podcast

[email protected]

Send us a text

 Mary Rogers’ death inspired Edgar Allan Poe’s The Mystery of Marie Rogêt — but nearly two centuries later, the real mystery remains unsolved.

In 1841, Mary Cecilia Rogers, a young New York cigar shop clerk known as the “Beautiful Cigar Girl,” was found dead in the Hudson River. Her murder became one of America’s first true-crime media sensations — and remains unsolved. 

Mixed & Edited by Next Day Podcast

[email protected]

Send us a text

In this episode of Justice Seekers, hosted by two attorneys, we examine the mysterious case of JonBenét Ramsey, the six-year-old beauty pageant star found dead in her Boulder, Colorado home in 1996. We explore the investigation, media frenzy, and ongoing theories, while reflecting on the lasting impact on her family and the justice system.

Join us for a thoughtful look at a case that continues to captivate the nation.

Send us a text

Gabby Petito’s story captured the nation, but her parents made sure it led to action. In this episode, we examine Gabby’s tragic death and the powerful advocacy led by her parents, Nichole Schmidt and Joe Petito, in her name.

Through the Gabby Petito Foundation, they’ve worked to raise awareness about domestic violence, expand resources for victims, and push for real legislative reform. Their efforts helped pass Senate Bill 117 in Utah and the Gabby Petito Act in Florida, requiring law enforcement to conduct lethality assessments during domestic violence calls.

They also played a key role in passing Billy’s Law (Help Find the Missing Act), improving how missing persons are entered into national databases—because, as Joe Petito said, “Everyone deserves to be found.”

Gabby’s life mattered. And through her parents’ courage and advocacy, her legacy continues to save lives.

If you or someone you know needs help, contact the National Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-7233.

Mixed & Edited by Next Day Podcast

[email protected]

Send us a text

In this episode, Natalie and Katrina break down the controversial case of Karen Read, accused of killing her boyfriend, Boston Police Officer John O’Keefe, during a 2022 snowstorm. What first appeared to be a tragic accident spiraled into allegations of police bias, mishandled evidence, conflicting timelines, and possible cover-ups.
 
 Update

Since recording this episode, the story reached a dramatic conclusion: a jury found Karen Read not guilty on all charges. After years of controversy, public scrutiny, and questions about the integrity of the investigation, justice finally prevailed.
 
Karen was convicted of a lesser charge, operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol (OUI), and was sentenced to one year of probation.