This week, we’re heading to Erie, Pennsylvania in 2003, where a bizarre bank robbery unfolded into one of the strangest and most disturbing crimes in modern history.

In this episode, we explore the case of the “Pizza Bomber.” A man walks into a bank, and what follows quickly spirals into something far more complex and unsettling.

We’ll touch on the key events, the people involved, and the investigation that tried to make sense of it all.

So grab a drink, settle in… this one isn’t just strange, it’s downright bonkers.

This week, we’re heading to a quiet road in Cornwall, England in 2003, where what should have been an ordinary night turned into a brutal and baffling crime that still raises questions decades later.

In this episode, we explore the Perch Garage murders. A small, family-run petrol station. A late-night robbery that escalated into something far more sinister. When morning came, the scene told a story of violence, but not a clear one.

We’ll walk through the timeline of that night, examine the evidence, and dig into the investigation that followed, including the suspects, the convictions, and the lingering doubts that continue to divide opinion. Because in this case, the most unsettling question isn’t just who did it… but whether the full truth was ever really uncovered.

So grab a drink, settle in… this one might leave you questioning everything you think you know.

This week, we’re heading to a remote Bavarian farm in 1922, the site of one of the most unsettling unsolved cases in true crime history.

In this episode, we explore the Hinterkaifeck murders. Strange footprints in the snow. Unexplained noises from the attic. Keys disappearing. Then, a gruesome discovery: six victims, no clear motive, and no confirmed suspect.

We’ll break down the eerie timeline, the disturbing details, and the theories that still surround the case more than a century later. Because what makes this story so chilling isn’t just the crime, it’s the possibility that the killer never really left.

So grab a drink, settle in… the deeper we go, the stranger it gets.

This week, we’re continuing a story that refused to stay buried.

In Part Two, we dive deeper into the case that captivated the world and divided opinion at every turn. As the investigation unfolds, the focus shifts and so does the narrative. 

We’ll explore the mounting pressure, the courtroom battles, and the way public perception began to harden into something much more dangerous. Evidence is questioned. Motives are speculated. And the line between truth and assumption becomes harder to see with every passing moment.

But this isn’t just about what happened in the outback, it’s about what happened after. How a story can take on a life of its own, and what that can cost.

So grab a drink, settle in, and get ready… because the deeper we go, the more unsettling it becomes, and the answers are anything but clear.

This week, we’re heading somewhere a little different.

In this episode, we begin Part One of a case that shocked the world and blurred the line between tragedy and suspicion “A dingo ate my baby.” You’ve probably heard the phrase… but the story behind it is far more complex, and far more unsettling, than it’s often made out to be.

We’ll be stepping into the Australian outback, where a family camping trip turned into a nightmare. What followed wasn’t just grief. It was scrutiny, media frenzy, and a narrative that quickly spiralled out of control.

This isn’t a story that stays still. It shifts. It twists. And from the very beginning, something about it just doesn’t sit right.

So grab a drink, settle in, and get ready… because this is only the beginning, and the truth is anything but straightforward.

Pack your bags… we’re not done yet.

This week, we’re continuing the story of Edmund Kemper, and things take a darker, more unsettling turn. After the murders of his grandparents, the psychiatric evaluations, the time he spent locked away, the decisions that eventually put him back on the outside, he's out and at it again.

But this isn’t a story that explodes all at once. It lingers. It builds. And the more you learn, the more uneasy it gets.

So grab a drink, settle in, and get ready… because this one doesn’t hit all at once; it slowly sinks in.

Pack your bags, we’re heading into the early life of Edmund Kemper, and it's gonna get unsettling... fast.

This week, we’re diving into the beginning of the story. The troubled upbringing, the warning signs, and the murders of his grandparents.

But that’s just the start.

We’ll also get into the psychiatric evaluations, his time inside, and how he eventually made it back out into the world.

So grab a drink, settle in, and get ready because this one doesn’t start loud… it slowly creeps in.

Pack your bags... we’re heading to the far end of Long Island, where conspiracy theories get very strange, very fast.

This week we’re diving into the Montauk Project. The alleged secret experiments, the underground base beneath Camp Hero, the supposed mind-control tests, time travel claims, and yes… even the stories about opening portals to other dimensions.

Depending on who you ask, it’s either one of the wildest conspiracy theories ever told or one of the strangest secret-government stories that refuses to die. Along the way we’ll get into the origins of the myth, the people who claim they were involved, and how this whole thing spiralled into tales that are… let’s just say, extremely weird.

Think psychic soldiers, memory wipes, mysterious creatures, and a rabbit hole that only gets stranger the deeper you go.

So grab a drink, settle in, and prepare yourself, because this episode gets weird. Like really weird.

Take a trip back to 1947 Los Angeles. A young woman supposedly chasing Hollywood dreams is found brutally murdered, and the press quickly gives her a name the world will never forget: the Black Dahlia.

This week, we’re diving into the infamous Black Dahlia murder. The horrific crime, the media circus, and the institutional failures that turned Elizabeth Short into a headline instead of a person.

So grab a stiff drink and buckle up. We may not have all the answers… but we’ve got plenty to say about this one.

This week we’re stepping back to the hazy, gas-lit streets of 1840s New York…

She was young, charming, and known across the city as “the Beautiful Cigar Girl.” Men lined up at the shop just to catch a glimpse of her smile. But in the summer of 1841, Mary Rogers vanished and days later, her body was found floating in the Hudson River.

What followed was a full-blown media frenzy, a chaotic investigation, wild theories, questionable witnesses, and a case so sensational it even inspired a detective story by Edgar Allan Poe.

This week, we take you through the mystery, the suspects, the rumours, and yes, approximately 47 completely unhinged tangents, give or take. We’re talking 1800s policing, Victorian gossip, dramatic men with strong opinions, and how this case helped shape the way we consume true crime today.

So light a (metaphorical) cigar, pour something strong, and settle in for two girls who may not solve a 19th-century cold case, but will absolutely have thoughts about it.