This week Stacy tells Kim a special Halloween story, just in time for the upcoming holiday! Kim has something in common with one of the players in this story, in that, no one truly knows her age.

We are flipping the show on its head this week, as KIM tells the story of a baseball player surrounded by tragedy, while Stacy… still knows more than Kim.

In this episode, Stacy tells Kim about a man named Clarence Elkins, whose story is filled with twists and turns as he is accused of killing his mother in law. Kim has a lot of things to say about pop culture in the 90’s.

This week Stacy tells Kim about the tragic murder of a high school girl names Shari Smith. Kim makes a surprisingly relevant reference to the 90’s movie “Big Daddy.”

In this episode, Stacy tells Kim about the 1924 kidnapping and murder of a 14 year old boy that was called the “crime of the century.” Kim makes potentially the first ever comparison of a kidnapper to Leslie Knope from the TV show Parks & Recreation.

This week Stacy tells Kim about the murder of Cara Knott in San Diego, California in 1986. Kim talks about her beloved San Diego Padres, of course!

In this episode, Stacy tells Kim about a super creepy murderer who lives in a missile silo. Kim has questions about mustaches, and Stacy has a “wild card” for Kim to help tell the story.

We are back from summer break with a brand new murd for ya! In this week’s episode, Stacy tells Kim about the horrific murder of Andre “Angel” Melendez, a Club Kid of the 1990’s. Kim tells us how she spent her summer break.

In part two of this special episode, Stacy tells Kim about the man who set around 2,000 fires in California in less than 10 years. Kim is going strong with the nickname she has given this creep, “potato chips.”

In this special two-part episode, Stacy tells Kim about one of the most prolific serial arsonists of the 21st century. Kim doesn’t know everything about firefighters, but she does know about Brooklyn 99!