In this segment, the hosts debate Florida politics, beginning with speculation about Jeb Bush’s potential 2012 presidential run. They question how Bush could launch a national campaign when his endorsement of Marco Rubio conflicts with Charlie Crist’s competitiveness in the U.S. Senate race. Tim argues a Bush candidacy is unlikely because the family name remains politically damaged, while Catherine agrees that the Bush brand is still “sullied.” The group jokes about Bush’s Spanish fluency and discusses whether he could position himself as the “smart brother,” though Tim doubts any campaign could escape the weight of the family legacy.
Conversation turns to the Republican Party’s weak 2012 bench—Palin, Gingrich, and Romney—and whether Rubio losing would further harm Bush’s prospects. They note GOP tendencies to nominate the “next in line,” yet Romney’s ideological baggage and religion may hamper him in early primaries.
Shifting to Alabama, they analyze Robert Bentley’s surprise victory over Bradley Byrne, crediting crossover Democratic voters and the Alabama Education Association’s anti-Byrne effort. This leads back to Georgia politics as guest Eric Gray, Communications Director for the Georgia Democratic Party, joins the show. Gray discusses the party’s neutrality during primaries, the focus on the governor’s race, and plans to deploy organizers statewide. He addresses low early-voting turnout, potential advantages of a May primary, and whether national Democrats might campaign in Georgia. Gray outlines post-primary messaging strategy, concerns about intra-party divisions, and evaluations of Republican gubernatorial contenders, while Catherine raises challenges in down-ballot races such as Attorney General and School Superintendent.