In the small town of Tipp City, Ohio, 37-year-old beloved coach and mom Ashley Flynn was initially believed to have been killed during a burglary gone wrong after her husband, Caleb Flynn, called 911 reporting a break-in. But as investigators found no sign of an intruder and labeled the crime “targeted,” suspicion shifted, and Ashley’s husband, a former pastor, worship leader, and one-time American Idol contestant, was arrested and charged with her murder. Court documents now allege Caleb shot Ashley with a 9mm handgun, staged the scene to mislead police, and is facing homicide, assault, and evidence tampering charges. Law&Crime’s Chris Stewart is On the Case.