A special two-host episode this week as host Mark Radigan is without John Baney but with producer Andrew Leigh to talk you through the entirety of the brief New York City FC run in the 2025 Leagues Cup.

Yes, another midseason cup tournament has unsuccessfully come and gone, with three matches played and two losses sending New York City out meekly in Phase One of the overhauled tournament between MLS and Mexico's Liga MX.

Episode 50 starts with Mark and Andrew reviewing the pair of mixed results earned across the Hudson River at Sports Illustrated Stadium, beginning with the disastrous tournament-opening 3-0 loss to Club Puebla.

It all went wrong for a rotated version of NYCFC, behind after two minutes of the tournament and ultimately handed a heavy three-goal defeat that essentially doomed the club to elimination. We wonder what that loss really said about the depth available to Head Coach Pascal Jansen, which also leads to some talk more generally about the new Leagues Cup format, an unforgiving one for results like the Puebla loss.

It wasn't all bad in Leagues Cup, though, as proved by NYCFC's 2-0 win over Club León. That match gave us reason to talk about a rare goal from Agustín Ojeda, and the challenge in front of him to try to take advantage of the opportunity to start throughout Leagues Cup. We also had lots to say about both Alonso Martínez, who scored and assisted in the win, and Matt Freese, who denied Colombian megastar James Rodríguez of Club León from the penalty spot.

After the break, Mark and Andrew drop in from the press box at Yankee Stadium to give an immediate post-match reaction to the Leagues Cup-closing 2-1 loss to Deportivo Toluca FC. There's talk of the latest loss, but also talk of what the tournament as a whole did for our rest-of-season NYCFC expectations, and whose stock we thought rose during Leagues Cup.

Listen to our one all-Leagues Cup, all-the-time episode of 2025, and then get more of our coverage by following Hudson River Blue on Bluesky, Instagram, and Threads, and by reading HudsonRiverBlue.com. 

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.