Emily starts off by recanting a case study from her senior thesis, featuring Dr. Thomas Gill, a medical examiner with a shady past. Afterwards, Grace tries to piece together the mysterious death of Richard Lancelyn Green, a scholar of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

Much anticipated after their unexpected absence, Grace and Em return full-force for their seventh episode, covering the psychological breakdown of Major Henry Rathbone following assassination of President Abraham Lincoln and the WWII cannibalization of Allied Airmen by Japanese officers (featuring an unexpected presidential guest).

Grace and Em, joined by their friend, Executive Producer Ashley, dive into the world of twin telepathy, featuring the Silent Twins. After that, they discuss the fairly recent Tanacu Exorcism, which has inspired multiple films.

Grace and Em do it again! This episode, Em informs Grace of a nearby cryptid known as the Enfield Horror. After that, Grace tells Em about an unsolved German sextuple murder known as the Hinterkaifeck murders.

Grace and Em discuss the disturbing WWII experiment called Unit 731, and an unsolved mystery of five missing travelers, also known as the Yuba Five.

Grace and Em describe the Mandan ritualistic ceremony, the Okipa, and talk about the disturbing urban legend turned real, Cropsey.

Em and Grace get freaked out by matters such as mass psychogenic illnesses and the double murder of Danny Vine and Della Thornton.

Grace and Em make their debut by talking about the Mystery of the Somerton Man - aka the Taman Shud case - and the origins and explanations for zombieism.