I read my Old and New Testaments concurrently throughout the year and sometimes the pairings fall in interesting ways. Recently, I was in both Exodus 3 and John 20. As I reflected on the lives of Moses and Simon Peter, I found some interesting similarities in both their personalities and failures.
Over the next few posts, I’d like to share my reflections and what I learned—especially when I feel like I’m “too much” or maybe not enough.
I’ll begin with Peter. He is easily one of my favorite Bible characters because he is so relatable. I see in Peter some of my own personality that I’ve tried to tame because I worry that I am “too much.”
Peter is bold. He speaks up. When Jesus comes to them walking on the water in Matthew 14, the other disciples are afraid but Peter says, “bid me come.” Yes, we can discuss how he began to sink with fear, but he wasn't afraid to ask.
He speaks in definitive, impulsive statements. He doesn't hedge. “Yet will I never be offended.” (Matt. 26:33) “Be it far from thee, Lord: this shall not be unto thee.” (Speaking of Christ's crucifixion, Matt. 16:22) “Depart from me; for a I am a sinful man...” (Luke 5:8) “I will lay down my life for thy sake.” (John 13:37)
He thinks of bold gestures. “Let us make three tabernacles...” (Luke 9:33) He tells Christ to not just wash his feet “but also my hands and my head.” (John 13:9) And, as previously mentioned, he has the crazy notion of asking Jesus to let him, too, walk on the water.
I wonder if the other disciples thought, to use modern vernacular, “Peter's... a bit much.”
So as I read John 20, I see Peter running into the empty tomb. His boldness leaps off the page at me, because John acts more “proper,” right? He stooped down, looked in, “yet went he not in.” (John 20:5)
I've seen the memes about John outrunning Peter, but this whole story isn't in the Bible so that some kid in 2025 can make a meme about it.
John gets there first, but he is...reserved. Respectful? Proper? Timid?
When Peter finally arrives, he goes in.
I love this picture. John looks in. Peter runs up behind him and just bursts on into the empty tomb.
Good ol' Peter... he's always a bit much.
But look what happens next—Peter enters the tomb in verse 7 and in the next verse, John “went in also...and he saw, and believed.”
I wonder if there was something about Peter’s character, his impulsive, I-gotta-see-this response that spurred John to go in as well.
I don’t think I’m alone in relating to Peter.
We as women are emotional creatures. We can be impulsive, forget to “mind our manners,” struggle to bite our tongues...
And when we see other women who are just so good at being meek and quiet and gracious, we can feel like a flop.
“Me and my big mouth... I bet Mrs. So-and-so wouldn't have acted like that.”
“Why do I have these big, wild ideas... I'm sure everyone thinks I am just too much.”
“Why do I care so deeply? It just leads to heartbreak.”
Just before his tomb-rushing, Peter had experienced one of the greatest failures of his life—complete denial of his Lord Jesus Christ. No doubt, that look from the Savior as described in Luke 22 is still burned on Peter's mind.
Despite this failure, he doesn't suddenly give up. He doesn’t start drowning in an identity crisis. Three days later, he doesn’t run upon the tomb and think, “oh, wait, John is that ‘beloved’ disciple, and he's not going in... maybe I better hold back.”
Peter is still Peter.
And Christ doesn't reject him.
In John 21, there is a beautiful restoration—three times, the Lord tells Peter to "feed [his] sheep."—one for every denial, is what I have been taught.
Peter is not immune from the comparison trap, however, and in the midst of this beautiful reconciliation, he asks Jesus about John— “Lord, and what shall this man do?" (John 21:21) Twice, Jesus responds by saying “what is that to thee?”
Bro. Mike Wells preached an awesome sermon on that passage during the NCGC in 2024 and the note I made in my margin is: “Don't be focused or worried about what others are doing—God needs you just the way He made you.”
It can't be said any better.
I have to pause here and say that I am beyond thankful for ladies who are more quiet, more gracious, more... the opposite of “too much,” whatever that is. I can learn from them, and should learn so I that I can bear more of that beautiful fruit of the spirit that is meekness.
But what can I learn from Peter?
He failed but didn’t quit. Didn’t try to become a carbon copy of John, standing at the tomb, just looking in... Peter, through his boldness, somehow encouraged John to come in to the tomb, and experience something deeper and richer, something that spurred John to believe. And then, Jesus essentially tells him, “who cares what I call John to do—you do what I called you to do.”
Peter never quit being Peter.
I don’t want to bury who I am, either. I just want to yield my spirit, my messy, impulsive too much-ness, and be surrendered to whatever God can do with me as me.
But what about those times when I have failed and the boldness is replaced with searing doubts? When I don’t feel like rushing in anyway, but instead question everything I once felt called to?
That hesitation is where Moses comes in. I hope you’ll come back and read Part 2 in a few days.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit lightinthemargins.substack.com