In celebration of surviving 10 episodes Sarah and Emily drink Whiskey shots. Emily shares the story of Mandy Stalvic and Sarah shares the survival story of Barbara Jane Mackle.

With a very story and delicious drink in hand, Sarah covers the insane case of Katherine Knight and Emily attempts to solve the Circleville Letter writer(s) mystery.

While fighting the southern California cold with a warm Hot Toddy, Sarah discusses the case of the murder of Martha Moxley and Emily theorizes about the Dyatlov Pass.

While enjoying a refreshing cocktail the girls share very important cases of missing and murdered indigenous women. Emily shares the incredibly frustrating story of Amber Tuccaro, while Sarah shares the story of Anna May Aquash to bring us some long-needed satisfaction.

In attempt to sober up Emily and Sarah sip Diet Cokes while sharing stories that hit close to home. Sarah shares the story of a murder in Creek Park in La Mirada and Emily shares the bizarre story of the Yuba County 5.

Emily recounts the crazy story that unfolds in the Netflix documentary "Abducted in Plain Sight." Sarah shares the mysterious story of the Dupont de Ligonnès family.

After the girls reminisce about Smirnoff Ice, Sarah tells the story of the death of Megan Weathers and Emily shares the wrongful conviction of Clarence Elkins.

Ryan makes a delicious smoothie for Emily and Sarah while they share some strange and infamous stories. Emily delves into the bizarre story of Dr. Hicks and Sarah shares the story of Elizabeth Smart.

Emily and Sarah share hometown stories. Emily shares the mysterious death of the Savage siblings and Sarah shares the mysterious disappearance of Douglas Grinstead.

In their first episode, Emily and Sarah share the stories that have stuck with them. Emily dives into the disappearance of Bobby Dunbar and Sarah covers the stories of Ashley Pond and Miranda Gaddis.