We're back after the holiday break! Hear stories about transportation woes, and The Bachelor! Also, find out if you've been Gilmore'd.

Polly and Shelby share their favorite Christmas memories and traditions - including fights over the best kind of Christmas tree, the viewing of Christmas vacation, and what makes the best items for stocking stuffers. Also: Polly's mom is impossible to surprise, Christmas cookies are great, and the Bachelor starts in a few weeks. Enjoy! Happy holidays and a happy new year!

Carolyn joins the ladies of Likely Story for a full episode. They dig right into the latest NFL updates, including Brock N'Roll and the Rodgers Duo. After a quick check-in on Fall TV Shows, they get down to business discussing the first half of The Walking Dead Season 6. Also: Star Wars, Thanksgiving stories, and Zoo.

Shelby and Polly are back with Episode 21. Nothing brings the mood down like talking about grief and loss. But don't worry - they get back to discussing bad tv quickly. For example the Bastard Executioner, which has already been cancelled. Also: The Walking Dead, VEEP, and Life in Pieces are winning the world.

It's fall! Shelby and Polly are back to discuss favorite fall activities, all the tv shows they're watching (or not), and how excited they are for the Gilmore Girls revival on Netflix. Oh, and there might be some goats in this episode too. Also, special guest Carolyn joins to discuss Fear the Walking Dead.

Polly is back and she's married! In her absence, Shelby finished watching True Blood. Now, Shelby and Polly are reunited for a recap of Polly's wedding before they dig into the insane amount of Fall TV they are each watching. Some good (Life in Pieces and Quantico), some bad (Bastard Executioner and Minority Report), and everything in between. At one point in the recording, Polly sounds like a robot for no reason.

Shelby is joined by Likely Story's midwest correspondent Carolyn as they talk the highs and lows of the Emmy Awards, Shelby going to D.C. with the Pope, and how Carolyn almost went to jail.

Polly and Shelby catch up before Polly gets married! The ladies discuss how much Fall television they are going to watch and review for your benefit. Then it's finally time for an in-depth discussion of the USA hit show Mr. Robot. Shelby is then joined by Carolyn to discuss Fear the Walking Dead. Also: Shelby and Carolyn decide who would survive a zombie apocalypse.

Polly is only days away from her wedding! As a distraction, the ladies of Likely Story talk about cats, road rage and how terrible the Zoo tv show is. A special guest joins to discuss Wet Hot American Summer First Days at Camp. Also: Project Runway updates and places to visit in Denver.

After a recording mishap, Polly & Shelby manage to record episode 15 as a treat for your ears. There is a summer slump of television, but the ladies of Likely Story dig into the new season of Project Runway and do a gut-check on So You Think You Can Dance. Polly’s wedding is getting closer and Shelby can’t stop watching True Blood. Also: Cats are discussed.