Polly and Shelby rejoice that the Bachelorette is finally over! Upon completing the Lifetime Movie Challenge, the real outcome is a new addiction to Lifetime movies. Also: Shelby realizes that Mr. Robot is an amazing show and Polly is happy about some of the latest NFL news.

Shelby’s back from vacation and obsessed with bears. The ladies walk through their fave picks for the Emmy’s. The Bachelorette is almost over, thank goodness. The rumors for the new Bachelor are spinning out of control and Polly isn’t happy with them. Also: Summer tv shows that we’re watching include Mr. Robot and Zoo.

Polly and Shelby celebrate the Supreme Court ruling on gay marriage and Polly stresses about her own wedding. They have a quick sidebar to talk about Teen Mom before discussing the new Lifetime series, UnREAL as well as the big drama on The Bachelorette. Finally, they chat about A Deadly Adoption, the newest Lifetime original movie starring Will Ferrell and Kristen Wiig.

Polly’s wedding is coming up fast and Shelby survives a spider attack. They are compelled to discuss the iZombie season finale and the latest shenanigans on the Bachelorette. Later, Shelby takes back her disappointment in SYTYCD. Also: latest tv show addictions and the amazingness that is Jurassic World.

Polly and Shelby hit double digits in released episodes! They share theories on the plot of a Gilmore Girls reunion and discuss the crazy shenanigans happening on the Bachelorette (Tony, Clint & JJ - we’re looking at you). The ladies of Likely Story are joined by special guest, Carolyn, to discuss her connection to American Ninja Warrior. Also: Stephen Colbert is awesome and CBS hits a new low.

Shelby moved to the suburbs and got cable again. The new season of The Bachelorette just started and it’s as crazy as you would expect. Polly explains the new toll lanes along US 36 in Colorado. Also: an update on iZombie and rumors of a Gilmore Girls reunion.

Polly gives an update on her wedding plans including a transportation solution. Did you know school buses are typically 45 feet long? Meanwhile, Shelby returns from vacation where she probably worked too much. Polly allows Shelby to tell three stories about animals. You won’t want to miss the special guest host this episode - the title is a clue. Also: Tim Tebow jersey insurance is a thing that exists.

Polly has mixed feelings about zombies, serial killers, and recording during the Pittsburgh Penguins playoff game. Shelby is obsessed with Game of Thrones. Oh yeah, and Tim Tebow is back in the NFL.

Polly bought her wedding dress. Shelby complains about being tired. The Slap is finally over and everyone is thrilled. Polly & Shelby have a love-fest about CW show, iZombie. Also: Summer tv premieres are discussed.

Polly finally finishes House of Cards Season 3 and shares her thoughts. The Slap is still happening and it's kind of boring. ALSO: Shelby gets rid of cable but still manages to watch a lot of TV.