In the quiet Ohio town, residents began receiving terrifying letters that exposed their darkest secrets. The anonymous writer knew everything: affairs, scandals, and private lives. The letters didn't just threaten reputations; they predicted violence and death. When the police thought they had their culprit, the letters didn't stop. Was an innocent man framed? Or was there a conspiracy hiding in plain sight? Join us as we unravel the decades-long mystery of the Circleville Letters, one of the strangest unsolved cases in American true crime history.

Between 1976 and 1977, New York City was gripped by fear as a mysterious killer called the 'Son of Sam' stalked the streets. When David Berkowitz was arrested, the truth was even stranger than anyone imagined. This episode explores the twisted mind behind one of America’s most infamous serial killers.

In 1956, one-month-old Peter Weinberger was taken from his family’s front porch in broad daylight, sparking a massive manhunt and national outrage. What unfolded was a tragic case that changed how America handles child abductions forever. This episode dives into the heartbreaking story of Peter Weinberger’s kidnapping.

In 1996, college student Kristin Smart vanished after a campus party—and for years, her case went cold. But whispers, lies, and one man’s strange behavior kept the mystery alive. This episode uncovers the decades-long fight for justice in the disappearance of Kristin Smart.

In 2012, Florida teacher Danielle Harkins gathered her students for a secret ritual to 'cleanse' them of demons—burns, cuts, and bizarre beliefs followed. What drove a trusted educator to lead a cult-like ceremony? This episode unpacks the disturbing case of a teacher turned tormentor.

Wealth, secrecy, and ritual sacrifice—The Order of the Solar Temple promised spiritual enlightenment, but ended in mass murder and mystery. What led doctors, elites, and professionals to follow this doomsday cult to their deaths? Uncover the chilling truth behind one of the most disturbing cults in modern history.

In 1974, newspaper heiress Patty Hearst was kidnapped by a domestic terrorist group—but weeks later, she reappeared as one of them. Was she brainwashed, or did she join willingly? Explore one of the most bizarre and controversial cases in American history.

In 1971, a man known only as D.B. Cooper hijacked a plane, demanded $200,000, and vanished into thin air—never to be seen again. No body. No parachute. No trace. Dive into one of America’s greatest unsolved mysteries and the legend that still haunts the skies.

On this episode of Macabre at Midnight, we delve into one of the most notorious family murders in American history—the case of Lyle and Erik Menendez. In 1989, the affluent façade of the Menendez family shattered when the two brothers brutally murdered their parents, José and Kitty Menendez, in their Beverly Hills home. The crime was shocking, but what followed was even more disturbing: a courtroom drama filled with explosive allegations of long-term abuse, manipulation, and betrayal. Was it cold-blooded murder driven by greed—or a desperate act of survival? We unravel the twisted timeline, examine chilling courtroom testimony, and revisit the cultural impact of a case that still divides public opinion decades later.

Grab a drink, dim the lights, and join us as we pull back the curtain on the dark truth behind the Menendez brothers.

Much like last week's episode, today's murder went unsolved for decades but scientific advancements made it possible for her killer to be found.