Patriotism, Authority, Rebellion
It’s 4th of July weekend. Memorial of the beginning of rebellion, 241 yrs ago, 1776. The colonies rejected "the Powers that be" (Rm 13:1 KJV) and began a war for independence. US history is long and complicated, with great advances and profound problems that we still wrestle with. It’s one of many nations, empires, colonies, people groups across history.
Christians live within all nations, under all authorities, in tension with all. We all experience patriotism, connection to the land of our birth or ancestors or ethnic group or home.
A modern nation like US is not like ancient Israel: tribal/royal, under covenant with God. Nor exactly like the Roman empire. But it’s more like Greco-Roman pluralism than like Israel. Our texts all try to make sense of life under Rome in language from the scripture of Israel. Paul, Peter strive to find a way to live at the bottom of empire that can be hostile power. Today’s church lives in a pluralist society open to faith (as private opinion) and non-faith. Strong civil religion, materialism, individualism, and freedom. Religion is a marketplace.
Church and Power
Church leaders, like others, have long felt the lure of power, control (to do good, of course). Rom 13:1-7, influential in history. King James saw it as the divine right of kings. It was written by Paul whose back was bloodied by Roman rods and Synagogue whips. Why write this: to help believers live by their values within a society with hostile destructive power. It’s abstract, affirming authority, not Nero as emperor. Under God’s universal sovereignty. Paul often went against authority and received its wrath. But he knew that the rulers were not absolute, had a task to support right and punish wrong, for which they’d be judged.
Peter uses scripture images for believers as a "holy nation" living in exile scattered among the nations. They submit to emperors in order to live exemplary lives. They’re free, but honor everyone, even the emperor, in order to live the life of love to which they are called.
As Rome persecuted the church, the evils of the empire became more central. John saw a vision of God’s judgment against Rome/Babylon. Against its web of power that involved other nations, against its economic web of trade that treated humans like commodities. It is a call to believers not to commit themselves to a particular power, which will fall.
None of these could imagine a truly Christian government. Nor has there ever been one.
In spite of such warnings, the leaders of the church, structured their power as a hierarchy like Rome. With Constantine, Rome did not become Christian, but the church was coopted by the empire. Jesus’ command about greatness was swamped by the lures of power.
Living within the Empire
Jesus contrasts the power of human rulers to a different kind of greatness rooted in service and self-giving love. Our faith is a testimony to the truth that at its deepest level the universe is not based on the power of law, imposed will, and violence but on the power of love that is the heart and character of God. Any government leaders are capable of corruption, sin, injustice, like any of us. More so under of the corrupting effects of power. In our society we as citizens are part of "the Powers that be" and must take responsibility.
As Christians (aliens and exiles) our aim is not a theocratic state. No coercion, ever! But God is profoundly concerned about justice in society, about how the poor and vulnerable are treated, overcoming oppression and treating all people as God’s creatures with honor.
Christians have the right and responsibility to engage. Enter the fray with others for political and social improvements in society. Our society is important, but so also the larger story.