Charles Fain Lehman, Carolyn Gorman, Renu Mukherjee, and Ilya Shapiro discuss the deadly shooting in Manhattan on Monday, exploring issues of mental health, gun violence, and the political implications for the upcoming mayoral election. The conversation shifts to cultural reflections on violence, community responses, and the dynamics of public safety.

The panel also delves into the backlash against American Eagle's ad campaign with Sydney Sweeney and discusses the effectiveness of advertising in shaping consumer behavior.