Discussion of Fellowship of the Ring, Book Two, Chapter One

Join Cam and Maggie as they return to the books – and are surprised by some old friends! Gandalf and Bilbo are both back from the dead, even though Cam thinks one of them might be a ghost. Old School Tolkien returns here – Gandalf feels like narrator, we're reminded that Bombur is fat, and Frodo is exceedingly polite. We express our growing disappointment with the wizard and his lack of answers (despite apparently having global omniscience). For the first time in any Middle-earth book, the phrase "Lord of the Ring" is used in this chapter. Cam and Maggie have very different understandings of the phrase, and the true identity of the titular "Lord". We also consider the colorless, peaceful characterization of Rivendell – and what theological implications that might have for Middle-earth's occupants and afterlife.

In our Second Breakfast, we discuss two very different perspectives in this chapter about heritage and the power of bloodlines. Are all members of certain families fated for greatness, or are great families doomed to produce diminishing returns? Frodo is presented with both views at Rivendell, and we wonder which he finds more sympathetic. This leads to a discussion about Frodo's identity as a descendent of Bilbo, and we question his desire for adventure.

Have an observation, comment or theory on this episode? Email us at [email protected]

Follow us on Instagram @secondbreakfastpod