This week, the TBR jar gave us mildew, madness, and a haunted mansion! We’re getting into Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia, a horror full of creepy colonial houses, eerie family secrets, and one very fashionable heroine. Spoilers abound as we unpack all the twists, horrors, toxic tea, and disturbingly damp bloodlines. Plus, why we’ll never trust wallpaper, or mushrooms, again. 🏚️🍄💀

This week we’re joined by a special guest Danelle who brought along their pick: Billy Summers by Stephen King. On the surface, it’s the story of a hitman taking on “one last job,” but underneath lies a layered tale of morality, trauma, and unexpected connections. Together we talk about King’s sharp twist on the assassin archetype, the surprising depth of his main character, and the way this story blurs the lines between violence and vulnerability.

This week, fate picked The Five-Star Weekend from our TBR jar, and we’re here for it! Elin Hilderbrand’s story about one woman’s attempt to bring old friends together for a weekend getaway is equal parts heartfelt and chaotic—think sun, secrets, and a whole lot of feelings. We’ll talk discuss the plot point and or thoughts on the characters, and why it might just inspire your next girls’ trip (or staycation).

This week’s theme is Beautiful Disasters, and our spotlight book is Sometimes I Lie by Alice Feeney. Secrets, tangled timelines, and unreliable truths make this story a perfect storm of chaos and beauty. As we peel back the layers, we’ll talk about the messiness of human flaws, the fine line between love and destruction, and why some disasters are impossible to look away from.

This week, the TBR jar handed us Caraval by Stephanie Garber, and we went all in—talking through every twist, turn, and trick hidden in this glittering story. From the first page to the final reveal, nothing was off-limits in our discussion. If you’ve already stepped into the game, you’ll know exactly what we’re talking about… and if you haven’t, maybe let this episode wait until you’re ready to risk the magic yourself.

We’re getting real in this bonus episode. From dog-earing pages to abandoning classics halfway through, we’re confessing our biggest bookish “sins” — and airing the reading habits that make us cringe. Whether you’re guilty of judging a book by its cover or side-eyeing people who crack the spine, this episode is packed with hilarious, relatable, and mildly scandalous reader confessions. Plus, we share some of your bookish pet peeves and hot takes! No judgment… okay, maybe just a little.

This week we’re joined by Leslie, who brought the Crescent City series by Sarah J. Maas to the table! Packed with magic, murder, mysteries, and a cast of very attractive people making very questionable decisions, this series gives us plenty to scream about. From angels to wolves to a city that never sleeps, buckle up for a ride through chaos, charm, and way too many secrets.

The TBR jar has spoken, and this week’s pick is Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt. Set in a small town with unlikely friendships, hidden connections, and an unforgettable octopus, this story weaves together lives in surprising ways. Tune in as we explore the world of this book and what makes it stand out on our reading list.

This week’s book was chosen at random from our trusty TBR jar, and fate delivered a juicy one: In My Dreams I Hold a Knife by Ashley Winstead. Join us as we dive into this dark, twisty campus thriller full of ambition, secrets, and the kind of reunion you definitely don’t want an invite to.

Set against the backdrop of a prestigious Southern college, the story follows Jessica Miller as she returns for her ten-year reunion—determined to prove she’s more than just her past. But when old friends gather and old wounds resurface, the night turns into something far more sinister.

This week’s book club pick came from our trusty TBR jar — landing on Murder in the Family by Cara Hunter. With its tense atmosphere and tightly wound characters, this choice had us diving into the complexities of family dynamics under pressure. We talk about how the book’s suspenseful tone keeps you guessing, and why sometimes an unexpected pick leads to the most gripping discussions.