
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Staying safe around the holidays is important and the hazards around the Thanksgiving holiday can pose different challenges. Distracted driving, food poisoning, and burns are the three most frequent causes of injuries during the Thanksgiving holiday period. Find out more about these and what one company did with it's Thanksgiving leftovers on this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast.
Resources and Links:
NSC.org – Injury Facts - https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/
Tedx – Heather Stagl - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79LI2fkNZ2k
Tedx – Peter Anderton - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDsMlmfLjd4
MEMIC Safety Net Blog –
YouTube – Belgin Texting While Driving test - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z2FHKVzGhgA
YouTube – Distracted Driving Shocker - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbjSWDwJILs
MEMIC Safety Director Login – www.memic.com/workplacesafety
NY Daily News – Turkey Fryer Fire - https://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/ny-turkey-deep-frying-deep-massachusetts-woman-injured-homes-destroyed-20201127-53nf6t3ymvffzjdx3qv4hhabla-story.html
Alton Brown Turkey Derrick - https://altonbrown.com/how-to-build-a-turkey-derrick/
Turkey Fryer Stats - https://www.austintexas.gov/sites/default/files/files/Fire/Articles/TurkeyFryerFiresStats.pdf
SlowMo Guys – Oil Fire - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PbgdRR4yj8Y
USDA – Turkey: Alternate Routes - https://www.fsis.usda.gov/wps/portal/fsis/topics/food-safety-education/get-answers/food-safety-fact-sheets/poultry-preparation/turkey-alternate-routes-to-the-table/CT_Index
CDC Food borne illness - https://www.cdc.gov/foodborneburden/index.html
Food Safety – Cooking Temps - https://www.foodsafety.gov/food-safety-charts/safe-minimum-cooking-temperature
260 Tons of Turkey - https://www.nationalgeographic.com/culture/article/how-leftover-turkey-launched-the-tv-dinner
Leftover Safety - https://www.foodnetwork.com/holidays-and-parties/articles/food-safety-storing-thanksgiving-leftovers
Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch, and thanks for listening today. We have another installment of our fractional safety series where we don't jump in so deep into a topic, but just give you the highlights. And in this episode, we talk about safety around the Thanksgiving holiday. Why Thanksgiving? Well, there are some unique circumstances that can make the hazards and exposure around this holiday a little bit different than what you might see with others. But before we dig in, did you know that on November 11th, two thousand twenty one, the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast just celebrated our two year anniversary? Hopefully, you've enjoyed listening as much as the team here has enjoyed putting the episodes together for you, and to help us understand more of what safety content you like. Be sure to drop me a note at [email protected] To let me know if you like the shorter episodes like this one or one where we go into a deeper dive with a guest.
Peter Koch: [00:01:00] So [00:01:00] jumping right into it? Here's a holiday dilemma for you what happens when you cook way more than you have people for? Well, more specifically, what do you do with five hundred and twenty thousand pounds of leftover turkey? Yep. Five hundred and twenty thousand pounds of leftover turkey. You heard me right? And if the first thing that popped into your head was freeze it, then you're on the right track. Way more practical than I am, because the first thing that popped into my head was, where would you even put it? The answer to that question about leftover turkeys will come a little bit later, but for now, let's think hard about holiday safety and leaving aside, but not forgetting the history of Thanksgiving and the treatment of Native Americans that will forever be part of the American story. This November holiday can be used to find gratitude and appreciation for family, friends, neighbors and dignity of those in our extended communities. The days before, during and after Thanksgiving are usually filled [00:02:00] with preparation, decoration and celebration, and each carries their own share of exposures that sometimes cause injury and sometimes can turn tragic. According to numerous internet sources and my own personal experience, the top three injury causes around the November holiday are traffic accidents, fires and either food poisoning or some sort of alcohol related event. Think about food poisoning and that two hundred and sixty tons of leftover turkey now that could be a recipe for disaster if it got out. So before we go there, let's talk about traffic first. Did you know that the National Safety Council has a holiday traffic fatality estimate report they put out for each year? So if you go to injuryfacts.NSC.org and search holiday traffic, you'll find it. And for the Thanksgiving holiday period for two thousand twenty one, the National Safety Council estimates that four hundred and eighty five people will die in the United States from traffic [00:03:00] accidents. That's second only to the Independence Day holiday period, with an estimate of four hundred and eighty two traffic fatalities. So why is Thanksgiving travel different? There are many possibilities, such as road rage, impairment, fatigue and even weather. But regardless of the reasons, one fact is the sheer number of travelers around Thanksgiving. The Thanksgiving holiday period sees the highest usage of the interstate system than any other holiday period, and we've had a reprieve this last year with the COVID travel restrictions. But this holiday, the National Safety Council is expecting another increase. So if you're traveling or have employees traveling around the holiday period, try these driving safety tips.
Peter Koch: [00:03:43] First plan ahead. Be sure your vehicle is in good condition and allow for extra time around your travel. Nothing drives road rage and aggressive decisions like the combination of traffic jams and a tight time schedule. If you're an employer of drivers, then considering allowing [00:04:00] extra time this time of year to get the job done, and there's a lot of psychology around leadership and behavior change and leading teams around production expectations is a lot more nuanced than you think. So check out this TED talk about how to deal with resistance to change with Heather Stegall. Or there's another talk about how great leadership only has two rules by Peter Anderton. We'll leave the links in the show notes, and I think these are pretty good things for you to watch and maybe get some ideas about how to lead some change around the holiday season. So now that you have enough time to get where you want to go, be sure that you can stay alert so alertness can take many different forms and first is to just stay awake. People fall asleep at the wheel all the time and caused fatal traffic accidents. Or sometimes they're lucky and they wake up just before something happens and they're able to manage it. But really, be sure that you're well-rested before even starting the trip. If you start from fatigue, that will only exacerbate the problems that we face when traveling [00:05:00] and along the drive. You should find time to stop and get out to get the circulation going. The old adage that the brain can only take with the butt can withstand goes for driving too, getting up and getting moving. Gets the blood flowing and will help with alertness, as well as making you feel better at the end of the journey. Interested in some quick exercises and stretches that can help for the long haul? We'll check out the stretching posts at the MEMIC Safety Net blog. The links will be in the show notes, but you can search at any time you want by going to MEMIC.com/WorkplaceSafety Find the safety net blog and just search for stretches.
Peter Koch: [00:05:37] Now that you are awake, stay on task and avoid distractions. Your brain can't manage the phone or even an in-depth conversation combined with the demands of a changing driving environment. You may think you can, but what you're really doing at any given point when driving and doing something else is using old information to respond to the current situation. Think about it before you [00:06:00] look up from your phone or return your attention to the road. Your brain has been using information from the last time that you were fully engaged and has been making assumptions about speed, trajectory based on experience and that information. So when you look back and the roadway, suddenly changes surprise a curve, a pothole pedestrian, another vehicle, an animal. Whatever it is, your brain has to readjust to the current environment and make a snap decision. Do I turn? Do I slow down? Do I speed up? Do I swerve? Maybe I do it all together, and that readjustment takes time. And if you add speed and other people's decisions into the mix, then it's a recipe for disaster. What can you do besides being rested? Put the cell phone on Do Not Disturb and keep it out of sight because no call or text or post is really worth it. If you need it for navigation, put in a place that's not going to be in the way and that you can reference it only when you need to get [00:07:00] to where you're going. If you want to see an interesting video on texting while driving, I'll leave a link to one in the show notes. It's where Belgian learner drivers react to being told that they had to pass a mobile phone usage proficiency test in order to get their driver's license. It's pretty funny, so the instructor sits in the car with them and actually tells them that they have to text while driving and they're on a closed track so that there's no other things that are going to get in the way, but they're still having to text and drive at the same time. Their reactions are pretty hilarious, and it's funny to see what the instructor has to do just to keep them on the road. So these are just a couple of tips of having a good journey. And if you're interested in more, you can go over to the CDC and search for holiday road safety. Or if you're a MEMIC policyholder, you can go to the MEMIC Safety Director at www.MEMIC.com/WorkplaceSafety for more good information.
Peter Koch: [00:07:59] Now that you've arrived [00:08:00] safely, what's the next most frequent cause of injury over the Thanksgiving holiday? Well, burns from hot pans, liquids and utensils or from fires. Lets take the burns from hot pans or utensils first. This is a pretty easy one, so just assume, assume I know it's crazy, but just assume that everything in the kitchen is hot. Sure, you might have asbestos hands, but not everybody does. So you should keep some good oven mitts or pot holders handy in the kitchen and then use them. You'll be surprised how a little leading by example will set the stage for others to follow. So the next are hot liquids and lots of things that we cook have liquid in or on them. And from the water we boil to the fat's used to cook or are the result of cooking spilled hot liquids can cause significant burns. I had the opportunity to review the unfortunate opportunity to review an injury report from a commercial kitchen [00:09:00] where a line cook was moving a pot of boiling water from the stove to the sink to drain. And he bumped into someone behind him just as he started moving and the water sloshed out of the pot onto his foot and into his shoe. He had second and third degree burns on the top of his foot and couldn't wear a shoe for weeks. It was a pretty miserable injury for him, and I remember having a conversation with him after reviewing the written report, and he's like, You know, I really didn't think that this was going to happen. I've been in the kitchen for years. I'm really good at this. I knew what I was doing. He just at that point in time, lost situational awareness, didn't know who was behind him, didn't check his back. The person that was walking past him didn't see what was going on and the circumstances combined with what he was wearing to cause some pretty substantial burns and injuries to him. So here are some extra tips when dealing with hot liquids in the kitchen. Well, commercial or otherwise, whether you're working over the Thanksgiving holiday, [00:10:00] preparing meals for the rest of us who might be going out, or you're preparing a meal for family and friends at home. So the first? Don't overfill the pot or container when it's filled right to the top or close to it, there's much less room for error. So a pot that's filled right up to the top and you bump it or slosh it, it's going to come out, it's going to overflow. And chances are it could drop onto your hand or your foot or someone else. So second, use covers when moving containers with hot liquid or really anything in them. A container with a top on it can help keep the liquid where it belongs. If it needs to cool, then uncover it after moving. Next, consider using a cart to move pots with hot liquids in them, especially if you are in a commercial setting and are moving containers from one station to another. Using a cart will help keep the hot liquid at a distance if a spill happens and you out of the danger zone. Last but really, there's other things that you can consider to but last in this list is always [00:11:00] wear close toed, slip resistant shoes in the kitchen. Slippers, socks, sandals, pumps or other shoes with open toes or holes in the toes have no business in the kitchen. Many times liquids get spilled because someone slips, or if someone has slipped, it could be because someone has spilled something so slip resistant. Footwear for the kitchen is a key prevention tool.
Peter Koch: [00:11:24] Now let's talk about burns from fires, not consider this. You've decided to fry a turkey for Thanksgiving, so you make room in the carport, garage or deck because you want it to be outside. Break out the turkey fryer, add your oil, crank up the burner and then head to get the turkey that's been thawing in the fridge overnight. You size the turkey when you bought it, so it will fit into the pot and you made sure to place the fryer just outside the carport or garage so that you can still stay out of the elements while you're cooking good to go right? What could go wrong? Well, it turns out [00:12:00] a lot could go wrong. Did you know that the U.S. fire departments respond to more than one thousand deep fryer related fires every year? This includes the fires caused by improper use of a turkey fryer, too. In 2020, the New York Daily Times reported on a Thanksgiving Day fire that left three homes destroyed and a woman seriously injured. It was expected that the fire was caused by a turkey fryer. You can read the whole article from the link in the show notes, but it was a pretty devastating fire where actually the propane tank exploded as well, so they're not exactly sure what happened. But there's multiple ways for that particular situation to happen. If you do find yourself eyeing that turkey fryer to move the turkey cooking tradition outside. Be sure to follow the manufacturer's instructions and use these safety practices. So first, do a perimeter check. Keep the area around above and below the fryer free from any flammable or combustible [00:13:00] material like trees, ceilings, decks, people, decorations, whatever. Keep the space kid and pet free as well. Second, level it up. Place the fryer on a low stable surface that allows you to lift the turkey out of the fryer easily. If you want to check out a pretty cool in a very interesting take on getting the bird in and out of the fryer, check out Alton Brown's Turkey Derrick, and I'm going to leave a link to that video in the show notes as well. Next, measure up, so use the correct amount of oil to prevent any spill over, and it's really important that you do this. You have to measure the correct amount necessary by first placing the turkey in the pot with water, and that's going to give you an idea of how much volume the turkey is going to displace, so that that's the amount of oil that you can keep in there just enough to cover the turkey and not too much. So it's going to overflow when you put the turkey in it. This is going to help you avoid overflowing the hot oil onto the burner when you load the turkey into the fryer. Next, [00:14:00] warm it up and pat it down. And that's all about the turkey. So thaw and dry the turkey before frying as a partially frozen turkey can cause the water that's in the turkey when it meets the hot oil to vaporize instantly, changing to steam and expanding more than 1000 times its original volume. When this happens, the oil will bubble over and contact the flame underneath. This can, and when it does happen, it happens explosively. If you want to see what happens when water hits hot oil, check out the slow mo guys video about an oil fire at two thousand five hundred frames a second. The link is in the show notes, and don't try this at home for sure. Next, turn the flame off first, turn the burner off before adding or removing the turkey from the fryer. This will help avoid an explosion or an uncontrolled flame if you miss any water or frozen bits when inserting the bird. Or if you misjudge the amount of [00:15:00] oil next. Make yourself comfortable. Make yourself a comfortable space to hang out while the turkey is cooking because you want to stay close enough so that you can tend the fryer and make sure the oil doesn't get too hot. Most turkey fryers don't have any kind of temperature regulation, so the oil can be heated to its ignition point and beyond. And that in itself is a recipe for disaster. So last, and this is just for prevention, but last, make sure that you have a fire extinguisher charged and ready. Make sure it's an ABC or k rated fire extinguisher. You never want to use water on a grease or oil fire. It's just going to spread the fuel. If you're looking for more safety tips around different ways to cook your bird. Check out an article the USDA put out recently called Turkey alternate routes to the table.
Peter Koch: [00:15:50] After burns, the next most frequent cause of injury is around food prep and food safety. Poisoning from poorly prepared food or languishing leftovers is [00:16:00] really a thing. Even today, the CDC estimates that 48 million people get sick. One hundred and 28000 are hospitalized and 3000 people die every year from food borne illness. Some of these incidents occur from bacteria that contaminates the food at the processing facility. Some come from cross-contamination when preparing the food, and still, others happen when people eat improperly stored food. Regardless of how the food was contaminated, we must rely on good preparation and storage techniques to ensure the safety of the food that we consume. Consider the phrase keep cold food cold and hot food hot when you are preparing or putting away food this holiday season as hot food cools and cold food warms. Bacteria can start to grow at some level of temperature and time. Food can go bad and, if consumed, can cause food poisoning. If the dish or the ingredients are designed to be served hot or cold, then keep [00:17:00] them that way. Plan on serving smaller portions and leave the balance in the warmer or in the fridge ready to refill the serving dish. Check out FoodSafety.gov for more information about minimum cooking temperatures. We're going to put some links in the show notes for that one as well.
Peter Koch: [00:17:16] So let's end with leftovers and the answer to the question of what do you do with two hundred and sixty tons or five hundred and twenty thousand pounds of leftover turkey? So the story goes in 1953, the CA Swanson and Co. slightly overestimated the demand for Thanksgiving turkeys that year and found themselves with 260 tons of leftover turkey, and they had to store it in the railcars. So in the 1930s, refrigeration was still just beginning to become a common thing in the households. And by 1950, there were still limitations, especially around transportation of refrigerated foods or frozen foods. At that time, [00:18:00] when Swanson made that overestimation, the refrigeration units on the railcars only worked when the train was moving. So the company recognized that unless the train kept the moving, the turkeys with thaw and then spoil. So to preserve the frozen birds cold food cold, remember the railcars they were stored on were sent back and forth between the company's headquarters in Nebraska and the East Coast until the company could figure out what to do with them. Legend has it that eventually these turkeys were turned into Swanson's first frozen dinners. Pretty interesting story. So if you're looking for more about that and how they came to determine what to do with all these turkeys and how they made a frozen dinner and how frozen dinners really took off, you can check out the story at National Geographic.com And we'll leave a link for that one, too. In the show notes So good thing modern refrigeration doesn't rely on locomotion anymore.
Peter Koch: [00:18:55] So to keep your dinner ready for yummy leftovers, follow these tips. First. [00:19:00] Don't let them languish. Cool your leftovers as quickly as possible. Don't let them sit out on the table waiting for everyone to wake up after the game before you start to put them away. Always use clean containers for your leftovers instead of wrapping the existing serving dishes. Number three. Think shallow pack leftovers in shallow containers, and this is going to help with the cooling process so that it'll pass more quickly from the warm stage to the cold stage and prevent bacteria from growing quickly. Number four. Consider short term storage only in the refrigerator. You want to keep your leftovers in the fridge for only up to four days any longer. Can allow bacteria to begin to grow. We've all found that container of what used to be food long lost in the back of the fridge. Food doesn't need to be green and fuzzy or slimy in orange to be dangerous. It just takes a little bit of bacteria that we consume to put us into a state of food poisoning. [00:20:00] So number five and last for this particular list is keep frozen, so when we think about preservation, the colder, the better and frozen can keep something preserved for a long time. So you want to freeze any leftovers that you want to keep longer than four days. And if you package these in smaller portions for freezing, it makes the thawing and rewarming easier later on. And you don't have to take out a huge container of turkey or potatoes or sweet potatoes or vegetables and thaw the whole thing for just a small meal, for lunch, or maybe for dinner at a different time. If you're looking for more leftover food safety tips, check out the article from the Food Network that we're going to leave in. The show notes there as well.
Peter Koch: [00:20:47] So there's a lot more that we can talk about but this is going to wrap up our fractional safety episode of the Safety Experts podcast. So today, remember that we've been talking about the three most frequent causes of injuries around Thanksgiving, and they were [00:21:00] traffic accidents or driving burns and then food poisoning. If you'd like to hear more about a past topic or have an idea for an episode, then email me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/podcast, where you can find additional resources and links to the articles that I referenced, as well as our entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for the Safety Net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates. And if you haven't done so already, I'd really appreciate it. If you would subscribe to the podcast and then take a minute or two to review us on Spotify, iTunes or whatever podcast service that you found us on. And if you've already done that, well, thanks because it really, truly helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing this show with a business associate friend or a family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support and until next time, this is Peter [00:22:00] Koch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.
According to the National Safety Council, following highway crashes, falls to a lower level is the third leading fatal workplace event and the fifth leading event resulting in cases with days away from work.
In many cases fall protection is relatively simple. Put up some sort of engineering control that prevents the workers from access the unprotected edge – like guardrails. Other times, the work being done requires a personal fall arrest system with the anchor located at or near floor level. Not all systems can do this and making the wrong choice can be fatal.
On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, I speak with David Kozlowsky, President and Owner of Safe Approach in Poland, Maine about the leading edge in fall protection and what goes into picking the right system.
Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch. According to the National Safety Council, following highway crashes, falls to a lower level is the third leading fatal workplace event and the fifth leading event, resulting in cases with days away from work. So, yeah, you guessed it. We're talking about falls and fall protection today. Getting back to the stats in 2019, out of the eight hundred and eighty eight thousand nonfatal injuries and illnesses involving days away from work, 711 workers died and 48,000 were injured in 2019. And if you dig a little bit deeper to put some perspective on the seriousness of those injuries caused by a fall to a lower level, the median days away from work were 22, compared to only eight days for other exposures. So that makes it a little bit different. You can almost be assured [00:01:00] if someone falls from a height to a lower level and gets hurt, they're going to have a more substantial injury than someone who might just fall on the same level or maybe a slip trip without a fall. So and in many cases, fall protection. When you think about falling from a height or falling to a lower level fall protection can be relatively simple. You put up some sort of engineering control that prevents the workers from accessing the unprotected edge like guardrails. But other times the work is done or near the unprotected edge and the anchor location, or the design of the anchor doesn't allow for a restraint system or the location itself doesn't allow for those guardrails, and it becomes a little bit more challenging. So a good example of that may be installing metal decking for flooring in a multistory building. Or even if you're a residential carpenter building a deck that's more than six feet off the ground. There's plenty of complications when you're doing leading edge work, like when the unprotected edge has a sharp or narrow radius or your anchor is [00:02:00] below your D ring. And those can combine to render traditional fall protection solutions like a personal fall arrest system with a shock absorbing lanyard ineffective and to confuse matters even more if you look out to the experts. Well, when you're choosing that fall resolution and you jump out to the OSHA standard, or maybe if you go up to the ANSI standards, they use the term leading edge in different ways.
Peter Koch: [00:02:25] So on today's podcast, to help us explore the leading edge as it applies to fall protection and clear up some confusion about best practices, we have David Kozlowsky, president and owner of Safe Approach right here in Portland, Maine, and led by David Safe Approach their team designs and builds fall protection systems from harnesses, anchors and lifelines to safety netting and custom fall protection worksite solutions. And over the years, they've developed some really creative fall prevention solutions for a variety of different industries. And so I'm actually here [00:03:00] in David's office today. We're doing the podcast Offsite. We got tired of doing the WebEx and Zoom things, so we're in person doing it together. We just took a tour of the shop floor and saw where the magic happens, so it's pretty cool. So David, you're getting to be a regular here on the podcast. So welcome back.
David Kozlowsky: [00:03:16] Thank you, Peter. I appreciate it. These are fun. I like doing them, so it's good to good to come back. Thanks for having me.
Peter Koch: [00:03:22] It's awesome. So before we jump into the topic, I want to kind of pick your brain some more. So is there anything new on the horizon for safe approach or in the fall protection industry?
David Kozlowsky: [00:03:32] There are a few things that we're working on as a as a company. There's a few products that are not necessarily ready for the market yet, but there are some items that I have been working on long term. I've been working on a self rescue device, got some neat ideas on that. It'll be kind of revolutionary if it does come out. So I don't want to give away too many secrets, but it's a way for we've [00:04:00] been approached several times in the past years, especially with actually the new aerial work platform standard, which I understand you're going to be talking to somebody about with self rescue. And so what we're trying to do is we're trying to develop a reasonably seamless way where someone can have something attached to them that's moderately unobtrusive that would allow them to work as normal. And then if they were to fall off of something and rescue was not easily or readily available, actually be able to rescue themselves by lowering themselves to the ground.
Peter Koch: [00:04:37] That's a great idea and a very challenging problem to manage within the workplace. And it's one of the conversations that I have with all my policyholders and clients from around. That's the part of the plan that they're missing is the rescue part.
David Kozlowsky: [00:04:52] And it's the item itself is when I first started looking at it, it really seemed like such a simple concept to me. [00:05:00] There's lots of defenders on the market, especially for climbing, I mean, this is a regular occurrence. These people use these types of things, but when you started, as you do with everything in fall protection, when you start trying to figure out how to make it at least reasonably universal for everybody to purchase and sell and not custom for each individual. And when you start looking at the foolproof factor, we try to make something that is easy to use as possible. And there's fewer ways for the user to make a mistake, especially in this application. When you're talking about probably being scared hanging, who knows how far above and you're nervous and you're shaking. And you know, the more things that you have to think about or do the likelihood of making a mistake or failing at it just goes up exponentially. So when I started factoring in different things, like different weights of people and having to arrest the fall in different ways of being able to go from a fall arrest [00:06:00] to actually disconnecting the fall arrest onto something else and again having it foolproof and having as fewer functions as possible. I bit off a lot. It's a it's a challenging task, but we're there. We're working on it and I don't want to promise of when it'll be out, but it's definitely on the horizon, something we're working on. We're working on some ladder stuff. The ladder standard changed in 2018. So there's, you know, even though that was a few years ago, they gave people till twenty thirty six to kind of modify and update their ladders that have cages. And so we've started to notice a slight uptick in people, you know, trying to take that serious and trying to be proactive. So we're working on a few things to try to get ahead of the curve on that, too. So when people really do start working on all those ladders there's got to be a million of them out there and people will start having to retrofit those.
Peter Koch: [00:06:56] They will. And that'll probably happen in twenty thirty five,
David Kozlowsky: [00:06:59] 2035, exactly [00:07:00] if they if they start that early, they have until November of 2036.
Peter Koch: [00:07:05] So yeah,
David Kozlowsky: [00:07:07] I expect around August, September, I'll start getting calls.
Peter Koch: [00:07:13] You know, it's a really great point changing of the ladder standard and the modification of fixed ladders to have either a personal fall arrest system or a ladder safety device incorporated into it. It's a pretty that's a pretty big nut to crack when you consider all of the ladders that are out there and just in Maine where we are, there's a ton. It's not just your it's not just a lot of your older manufacturing facilities or the mills. You can start looking at recreation, and there's a lot of every tower on a ski lift has a fixed ladder.
David Kozlowsky: [00:07:45] Has a fixed ladder yeah.
Peter Koch: [00:07:46] And at some point the ones that are 24 feet or higher are going to have to be modified.
David Kozlowsky: [00:07:52] And we have a cable system already, so we do have our own. I've been slow with the rigid rail portion of it, and there are times when a rigid [00:08:00] rail for various reasons I won't get into today is kind of the only option available, but there are certain features that I want it to be able to do, and I also need to make sure I don't obviously violate anybody's patents. So I've been working on trying to come up with my own idea for how I'd like that to work.
Peter Koch: [00:08:19] So yeah, that's cool. And like you alluded to, you know, there's only so many ways to skin that particular cat. So yeah, and there are new ways out there. I mean, you know, folks like yourself and other engineers that are really thinking about this, there's different ways to do it. But you know, collectively, the solutions that have been out there, whether it's a T track rigid or it's a cable system, they've been out there for quite a while there might be some new ways to make that work a little bit better.
David Kozlowsky: [00:08:47] Yeah, I've used a lot of them. I've seen a lot of them and I have a couple of ideas on how I think they should be able to operate, and that's what we're working towards.
Peter Koch: [00:08:57] Good deal. Yeah. All right. Let's round back [00:09:00] to the topic for today, which is leading edge fall protection. And so in our last podcast that it kind of came up as a discussion or a brief discussion outside of the recording. And you know, I think leading edge work happens more frequently than people know, and I'm not sure that they understand all the risks involved with it. So I think we'll take time to discuss that. So let's start with the definition of leading edge. What is leading edge work? And then let's talk a little bit more about maybe the differences between how OSHA sees it and how ANSI sees it.
David Kozlowsky: [00:09:33] So this is interesting. When we were talking about the topics, you know, you presented it this morning that you were going to ask me about the definition. I go ah man like, I don't really know what the definition is. I should be ready for this question. So I'm going to quit and I'm going to research it. And you know what? The weird thing is I went all through ANSI, and I can't find where ANSI actually gives a definition of leading edge. They talk about everything else. The SRL standard [00:10:00] three fifty nine point fourteen that's out there. They have they don't have any definitions, they refer you back to Z three fifty nine point zero, which is the base standard, and you go through all those definitions in there and they really don't ever give you one. And so you're kind of left to kind of infer on your own what the definition of a leading edge is. So I am going to give you my own definition. This is my opinion. And here it goes. So based on the way they have the testing done and the way the differences in the testing for the two different types of SRLs, actually there's three or four, but the two basically the ones that are made to attach above the D ring and then ones that are made to attach below the D ring. My definition of a leading edge is a two fold test, one you're attaching below your D ring and two the material of the lanyard leg itself of the self retracting lifeline [00:11:00] to any degree bends around another object. So there are many cases where just tying off at your feet does not necessarily introduce a leading edge. So my personal definition is you're tying off at or below the D ring and the leg of the SRL or lanyard is going to bend around another object, whether it just be a little bit or 90 degrees or whatever it ends up being, it's bending around another object.
Peter Koch: [00:11:31] I think that's a good definition because it takes into consideration more than just working at an unprotected edge. Like I'm laying down metal decking or I'm doing work on a rooftop someplace, and I'm right next to that particular edge. Or I have to work with part of my body over the edge because you could set that up where depending on the location of your anchor, where even though I [00:12:00] am working on that leading edge, I might not need something that's specific to leading edge.
David Kozlowsky: [00:12:05] So I'm going to add one further test, which I know I said two, but I'm going to make it three now. So in order to be true and again, this is my opinion. But in order to make it true, leading edge what you just mentioned, so the radius of test required and we can get into this in a little bit, but there's a very specific piece of material in a very specific radius in the ANSI test that you need to test a leading edge retractable. And it's what we call in the industry the sharp edge test. So to me, a leading edge should also include a sharp edge. There's many instances where you might meet two of the tests you might be tying off at or below the D ring. It might be bending around something, but that object presents zero risk of actually sawing or cutting the material, which is where the leading edge sharp edge test comes from. So it would need to meet those three tests. [00:13:00]
Peter Koch: [00:13:01] So if I think about this in the real world and we're going to take this into industry, right? And I'm the supervisor or the safety manager and I'm doing my job hazard analysis or my risk assessment for that particular day. And I'm trying to choose what type of fall protection I'm going to have. I need to look at where the work is being done, how close to that edge I'm going to be, where my anchor is going to be and not just distance from the edge, but actually location based on the position of the individuals d-ring. That's a really good point that you brought up. What's the material or what is the edge actually look like?
David Kozlowsky: [00:13:39] So the test that I came up with, which was any time it's bending around something or over something, this z three fifty nine point one three, which is the lanyard and shock absorbing lanyard standard for ANSI, has already in it. Testing and information for foot level tie off what they call 12 foot free fall [00:14:00] lanyards. And so the idea behind that is four foot level tie off. Well, someone might say, how is it that you can have foot level, but not a leading edge? Well, if you're connecting steel and you have an I-beam and you're connected to it, it's possible that it might be leading edge depending on how big the I-beam is and where the D ring is. But it's common practice when you're tying off with a lanyard to include a D ring extender, so to speak. So what you would want to do is add a D ring extender to the D ring so that no portion of the hardware or webbing on your lanyard would be bent over the IV when you fall, so it would be at the edge. So that would be an example of a 12 foot freefall or a foot level tie off. That's not necessarily a leading edge. And then other tests, you know, the sharp edge there's you know, we worked with a contractor a number of years ago that was working on windmills and you know, the [00:15:00] tops of those are round. They're like. The cells on an airplane engine, so there's really no risk of cutting any of the material. So we kind of got into a discussion with the general contractor about is this really a leading edge? Can you really need that type of equipment or is foot level sufficient, you know, to satisfy the need
Peter Koch: [00:15:20] Yeah, so let's qualify that for a little bit, too. So our listeners understand the difference. There are certifications for leading edge fall protection equipment that would meet the tests or at the very least, you know, work for foot level connection and then be robust enough to not be damaged or and continue to work when it's bent over a particular radius and material.
David Kozlowsky: [00:15:46] Right. So the lanyard standard 359.13 only has the 12 foot free fall. The test is virtually the same. It's the same two hundred and eighty two pound weight. It really just depends on how [00:16:00] far you allow the weight to fall and then measure the forces. So there's definitely not a sharp edge component to the foot level tie off for regular lanyards. Z359.14 is really the first one to differentiate and introduce a different test for that. So for the performance testing, for dynamic testing, the weights, two hundred and eighty two pounds the same, it's 300 for strength testing, but for performance testing is two hundred and eighty two pounds. And so now what they've done is they've classified self retracting lifelines into what's called Class A and B, which are for overhead tie off. That's anything above your D ring. And then they've created a test for SRL-LE, which is their designation for leading edge the same weight, but you are introducing a five foot free fall now instead of just hanging it from an overhead [00:17:00] point. So you need to introduce a five foot free fall. The distance back from the edge needs to MEMIC the length of the unit you're testing because they want you to test it to a certain percentage of its overall use. And then you drop it over the edge 20 inches away, and then you do a second test at a five foot offset to introduce a sawing effect. So it's the first standard to really kind of give you an actual specific test specifically for that, which is partly the way I came up with my test or my definition of what leading edge is. You know, the idea that it's going to bend over something and be a sharp edge and be a five foot free fall?
Peter Koch: [00:17:42] Yeah, right. So if I understand that correctly, going back to the classifications of SRLs, you've got A, B and now you have LE
David Kozlowsky: [00:17:53] LE and you have R2, which is four rescue devices that have built in winches. But that's a completely [00:18:00] different thing for what we're talking about. But yes, A B and LE and A and B are overhead, and those basically determine the total fall distance allowed and the average arrest force that's allowed OSHA in ANSI don't ever allow any more than 800 pounds max arrest force, but the average arrest for us class A is twenty four inches total arrest and thirteen hundred and fifty pounds average, and then Class B would be up to fifty four inches and only 900 pounds average arrest force. And then you go to LE and LE has to have the same thirteen hundred and fifty and fifty four inch max. And then it also now again, but it also has to pass the sharp edge test.
Peter Koch: [00:18:43] Yeah, stay intact once it connects with the edge.
David Kozlowsky: [00:18:46] I forget what the number is, but it does also have to maintain, regular ones is a thousand pounds. I think static after the fall, but I think it's a little less. I can't remember the exact number. It might be like six hundred and fifty pounds or something, but it does [00:19:00] have to pass also a static test after it's arrested the fall.
Peter Koch: [00:19:05] It's got to sit there and be able to stand six hundred pounds.
David Kozlowsky: [00:19:09] Yeah. You want to be able to have somebody hanging on it for a while and, you know, not risk that it's going to tear the rest of the way through?
Peter Koch: [00:19:16] Yeah. Which is a it's a pretty good test. I would want to have that test there if I'm wearing it for sure.
David Kozlowsky: [00:19:20] Yeah, sure. Me too, for sure.
Peter Koch: [00:19:21] We've talked about it in the testing, but let's talk about that leading edge and like specifically, what are the additional hazards that are there? You talked about what it needs to withstand, but when I'm looking at the when I'm looking at the edge and I'm trying to determine what type of SRL or what type of lanyard you're going to use, what are the hazards, what are the dangers there for leading edge?
David Kozlowsky: [00:19:45] Well, there's multiple dangers in some of these MEMIC foot level tie off and then some of them are new ones that are introduced with leading edge. But when you're doing fall calculations, I mean, the first thing you need to take into consideration is the [00:20:00] additional five foot free fall most. People don't realize that if you're tied back from the leading edge, even if you're tied off at your d-ring height, so even if you're technically tied off at or above your d-ring, but let's say it's four feet back from the edge of a roof, you don't realize it, but the retractable is probably not going to start arresting the fall until your d-ring is passed past the leading edge. So you're going to fall off the side when you're d-ring passes. That's when the rate of extension is going to increase enough to actually arrest the fall. So that's why they tested it five feet. So you need to take into consideration that you need to add that five feet of fall clearance to virtually every chart that you have. So Leading Edge introduces that extra fall clearance. And in some cases, like I said, even if you're tied off at or above your d-ring, if it's a leading edge, you need to add that five feet you can't count it as [00:21:00] an overhead tie off.
Peter Koch: [00:21:01] Right, that makes sense. If you're going to have a fixed anchor and you're going to be traveling horizontally on whatever surface you're going to be. How far are you traveling? So if I fall off the edge with a 25 foot, you know, I've got a 30 foot SRL or and I'm traveling 10 or 15 foot horizontally beyond the center of that anchor point. How far am I actually going to fall before it catches me.
David Kozlowsky: [00:21:27] Even if you're even if you're dead perpendicular to the anchor, even if you take out the pendulum effect, if you're dead perpendicular to the anchor, if you imagine in your mind, you know the edge and your, you know, your line comes in even horizontally. The increase horizontal to the angle is so little that the rate of extension is probably not going to catch up and actually start locking until your D ring actually passes and it goes over the side, then [00:22:00] it becomes a line pull. So now the rate is the same of your falling and the extension, and that's when it's going to lock. It's not going to lock before. So that's why it's important even when you're at or above. Even if you're dead perpendicular, you need to add that five feet. So then the other thing, of course, you touched on was the pendulum. I mean, there's always the possibility of the swing fall. So you need to calculate that into your fall clearance chart, the extra payout because you're falling further. So you're going to get more energy absorber extension than if you're just falling overhead. And then the and this is the most important thing is the biggest hazard is the actual edge itself. So, you know, the sharp edge component that I told you, that's that kind of third test of leading edges. The test is a zero point zero five radius. They have a very specific radius because [00:23:00] they say that's what structural steel is.
Peter Koch: [00:23:01] So put that put that into context that someone can wrap their head around if they don't know what point zero five is.
David Kozlowsky: [00:23:08] Is five one thousandths of an inch. I mean, it's
Peter Koch: [00:23:12] So that's like, like pencil lead.
David Kozlowsky: [00:23:14] Yeah, right? Yeah. It's like, really, really. It's basically a sharp edge. I mean, so you know, not just the straight fall, but especially if you're not perfectly perpendicular, there's going to be a sawing effect. And that's the most dangerous part of leading edge. And why they do. The sharp edge test is if your five or 10 feet off of perpendicular and you fall, you know, from other studies of fall protection that you're going to run along the edge until you're lanyard, you're just perpendicular to your tie off point. And however far that is, is how far it's going to saw that webbing or the cable. And I've seen tests where even cable can get cut if the edge is sharp enough. Especially if it's, you know, steel. So [00:24:00] that's really the most dangerous thing is, you know, that sawing effect that you might have. So you want to take that into consideration in each application and in the material that you're using, whether you're using a cable lanyard, a web lanyard, you know, as a shock absorber or not.
Peter Koch: [00:24:15] Sure. And it makes sense. You know, you think about the maximum amount of force that OSHA allows or ANSI allows is 1800 pounds. You can't put 1800 pounds of force between your hands pulling a piece of rope. But if you pull a piece of rope tight between your hands and touch a sharp knife to it, it's going to part.
David Kozlowsky: [00:24:35] It's going to part.
Peter Koch: [00:24:36] So put 1800 pounds on that and then roll that over a sharp edge. There's going to be some damage if it's not designed for it.
David Kozlowsky: [00:24:43] Right. Exactly. So that's why I introduce that, because not every edge is sharp enough to do that. I mean, certainly steel is if you're doing roofing, you know, you might have metal decking or metal roofing. I mean, certainly that can be a knife edge sometimes. [00:25:00] So certainly that would be a sharp edge. Concrete can be a sharp edge, especially if it's a Web lanyard, maybe not so much for cable, but certainly possible, you know, if it's a soft edge. If you're talking, you know, like we talked about the wind towers or, you know, if you're doing wood construction and you get two by dimensional lumber, I don't know if I would say that there would be a risk of cutting, you know, especially a cable lanyard. So maybe just foot level would be sufficient for that. Again, this is my opinion. Somebody else might disagree with me, but that's my opinion. That's the way I look at it.
Peter Koch: [00:25:34] And it makes sense. It's logical to think that, but I think the key point to take away as you're listening to this is you've got to do your own. I won't say research, but you have to evaluate the fall hazard that you have. So it's not just the distance between the anchor and the ground anymore. There's more information that you need to gain about the situation before you can make a choice on material and [00:26:00] the type of fall protection system that you're going to have.
David Kozlowsky: [00:26:02] So, you know, that's part of the job of the safety manager of whoever is for whatever construction company or whatever company that you work for. And I think especially nowadays, it seems like safety managers probably spend all their time dealing with COVID and stuff and less time with fall protection. But, you know, I liken it to a lot of us here have taken the rigging and signal test for cranes because we do contracting work and we need to be qualified by and CEO to rig or signal a crane. So we've all taken the classes in, you know, the studies that you do for the rigging part of it, it's pretty in depth. There's a lot of calculations. If you're not going to preplan it, it's difficult if you're going to just show up on site and say, All right, what do I need? And you can start to calculate sling angles and how much does this way and how long are the straps and, you know, stuff like that. So it gets pretty complex. And, you know, I don't think a lot [00:27:00] of safety people sometimes realize that that's your job, really. If you're not, you know, you might not be rigging a pallet, but your job is the safety manager is to analyze the risk. And you know, the guys that are on the field don't have the time to stop and spend two hours figuring out what they need. Your job is to kind of, you know, survey the area and kind of look ahead of time and see and make all those calculations. You're the one who wants to do all the fall clearance. You want to analyze the risk. You want to look at the edge, see if it's sharp. It's really your job to go in and perform all those fall clearance calculations and everything that you need to do, tell the people on site this is what you need to do to operate it safely. And so that's an important task.
Peter Koch: [00:27:48] It's a really important task. And I think especially in some smaller companies that might not have a dedicated risk manager or a safety coordinator on site with them all the time. You [00:28:00] might be foreman or a supervisor that has those safety responsibilities. So your company is going to purchase fall protection equipment and you're going to have it at the shop, you're going to have it in the truck, whatever that is. And then you're going to get to the area and you're going to try to apply whatever you have to, whatever that scenario is. And since, well, especially since talking to you, but in my experience, having done a lot of fall protection training and work at height, not every fall protection solution is functional for the scenario that you're going to come and come encounter with. So just like you said, if you do it ahead of time, you can send the team with the right tool. If you don't send them what the right tool they're going to use, whatever tool that you have.
David Kozlowsky: [00:28:51] So a job hazard analysis, we all hate them. I've filled out a million of them. It's a lot of work sometimes, especially for a small contractor like [00:29:00] us. We also don't have a dedicated safety person, that's all they do all day long. So it's extra work for me or for the foreman. But you know, it's something that you complain about, but it's definitely needed. It's definitely that you catch a lot of things that you might not have considered if you take the time to do it ahead of time. And this is one of those things the fall clearance, the edge, the proper equipment and what you need definitely take the time to analyze each situation ahead of time.
Peter Koch: [00:29:31] Yeah, it's a great idea, and you can fairly easily I won't call it easy, but you can set yourself up for success by having the questions asked when you're setting up the job, when you are bidding the job. So as you start to bid the job and you know you're going to be working at height, you're building a roof, you're building deck and you're doing whatever that is. Consider the plans. Where are you going to be? Where is your anchor point going to be? What's the material that [00:30:00] you have the potential to fall off of? Yeah. If I can't put a guardrail in, then I need to start looking at these different scenarios. So, you know, if you get to that part in the flow chart where it says, yes, I'm leading edge, it changes the fall protection equipment that you have to bring with you.
David Kozlowsky: [00:30:16] And that happens all the time, Peter. That's not a that's not as rare of a scenario as you would think is, you know, XYZ contractor is calling saying, Oh man, I need all this stuff for this. Like, I didn't put this in the job. I didn't know I needed it. And you know, the safety officer for the general contractor is going around saying, No, you can't do this until you have the right equipment. And so that it does happen a lot.
Peter Koch: [00:30:40] Yeah, yeah. Totally changes that. You know, we've talked about the relationship between safety, quality and productivity. And even there, like if I can plan for safety ahead of time, it totally changes my productivity because the scenario that you just described where the GC safety guy is saying, I'm sorry, Pete's [00:31:00] contractor, you can't do this unless you have this in place. And now he's got another bill that he's got to come up with, and it's time for you to. I mean, it might even be a custom solution, and that's not something that you can say, Oh yeah, I'll have it shipped to you tomorrow. That's not going to function.
David Kozlowsky: [00:31:15] No, and it's certainly going to take a chunk out of, you know, whatever they budgeted for, you know, materials and expenses for the job.
Peter Koch: [00:31:22] Profits get a little bit tight that way.
David Kozlowsky: [00:31:25] Yeah, if you're going to be working at height, I think if you're a contractor that does any kind of work at height, I mean, you should be spending the time to analyze the job ahead of time before you do something like that to make sure you either have what you need or you factor in some budget money to, you know, to obtain what you need.
Peter Koch: [00:31:46] Yeah to see it. You know, you might not know it happens. You might be planning for a job that was described to you X and you get on the job. And all of a sudden it's Z and you have to be agile in your adaptation to whatever's there. [00:32:00] But having worked with hundreds of different teams on the ground where you know their supervisor or manager or the safety guy is not there and we're talking to them about fall protection, and so what about this particular hazard or why are you using this solution in this scenario? And the answer is more times than not is it's all we have, right? Like, I've got a harness and I've got a six foot lanyard, and they might even they might not even have a large enough hook on the end of it to tie in to whatever anchor they're supposed to. So they're tying back to the lanyard and they're changing the dynamics of that particular fall protection solution.
David Kozlowsky: [00:32:40] Yeah. And that's one of the things that I can say about the culture of fall protection that is definitely changed in the last, you know, 10 or 15 years is that if you're going to do work for any larger contractor, you're going to have your ducks in a row or you're not going to be able to work on site. So I could see that happening in [00:33:00] smaller jobs where, you know, you might be the general contractor and you're just there doing a little job for a customer. But if you're on any, any larger site, that's not going to happen. And it's, you know, in some ways, it's actually it's actually a help. I mean, if you don't have a safety person on site and as much as you might want to not like the, you know, intrusion or the extra cost, you basically just got, you know, free help from, you know, probably a pretty good safety person, you know, telling you what you need.
Peter Koch: [00:33:32] They're great. They are truly a great resource.
David Kozlowsky: [00:33:34] A good one is a great resource. A good one is, yeah, definitely qualifier.
Peter Koch: [00:33:39] Good one is a good resource, right? Absolutely. And you know, so let's take this out of the construction environment for a moment, because they're not the only industry that has fall protection requirements, even though the threshold is different. We talked about this in previous podcasts. Six foot four construction as the general threshold and then four foot four general industry. Yeah, you [00:34:00] get to some maintenance guys that are not doing construction, they're doing maintenance work and they might not be able to have guardrails in a particular situation, but they might actually have a leading edge scenario where a fall could put them at risk of damaging or severing that lifeline.
David Kozlowsky: [00:34:18] I have run into this quite a few times, and the unfortunate thing with general industry with the four foot rule is that a lot of people want to quickly go to the fall protection because it's less expensive than guardrails. The problem is, it is virtually impossible to arrest a fall on a four foot height at a leading edge. As I told you, it's five feet to the d-ring to begin with, so you're 100 percent going to hit the floor before the retractable even starts locking up and arresting the fall. It's just impossible. So in those situations, it's a scenario that just kind of can't exist. You'd sometimes just have to tell people, Listen, you [00:35:00] need to be further up the hierarchy. You need to prevent the fall rather than try to arrest it in this particular situation. And even that's somewhat true, even for overhead. I mean, even if you have the perfect scenario of an overhead retractable perfectly over where you're working, you have all the right equipment and it's only four feet to the next level. Arresting a person before you contact the floor is going to be extremely difficult. So you definitely see less leading edge issues in industry. But it's not unheard of because we've run into many applications where you have like an open sided mezzanine. You're loading material to a, you know, a second floor mezzanine and someone has to remove the guardrail in order to get material up there. We run into that all the time. That's a classic situation for a potential leading edge and especially a sharp edge.
Peter Koch: [00:35:52] Yeah, truly, truly about that. That's a great scenario. I think about maintenance guys in the hotel industry that are, you know, [00:36:00] going to different areas and having to do some repairs that are going to be exposed to those fall hazards. There's plenty of different scenarios that your traditional, you know, fall protection in a bucket. It's not going to be what you want to send your guy with, right? And so that preplanning is huge. So if you are going to calculate the fall distance and you've explained this somewhat. But if we're going to look at this from a leading edge perspective with a SRL and I needed it to deal with the fall clearance, let's see. I've got maybe it's 10 feet from the work platform to the ground and I've got my anchor set right at D-ring height. So let's call it five feet off the deck. So thinking that through. How would I calculate whether or not I am using the right tool for that scenario?
David Kozlowsky: [00:36:54] Well, the general accepted industry standard is you want to maintain [00:37:00] try to maintain a two foot safety factor, if you can. So you need to try to arrest that fall basically, if it's 10 feet within eight feet and that starts getting really challenging because depending on where you are, you might need to start doing some trigonometry to figure out the length of the hypotenuse and how much if you fall, if you're 10 feet off center, once you hit the edge, how much webbing is over the edge and what's the difference in the hypotenuse between the offset center and the perpendicular center? So even when it locks up how much additional webbing, how much travel from the retractable? Is it going to be twenty four inches? Is it going to be fifty four inches? You know, you need to take and those are things that you can, you know, you can use the manufacturer's information to help you calculate. I can't do it off the top of my head. If you ask me to do one, I can't. It's too complicated. Yeah, on my laptop, I created a calculator. [00:38:00] If you give me a minute to get it out, I could probably do one for you. But there's too many. There's too many trigonometric calculations to actually figuring out. And I've also custom tailored my fall calculator to take into consideration actual fall distances from our SRLs, rather than just the published maximums. So like a class, a retractable can extend up to fifty four inches, but they very rarely do all the way. Fifty four would be a worst case scenario a full five foot free fall, a full three hundred pound, three hundred and ten pound worker. All of these things. And if you're only one hundred and eighty pounds and you don't fall quite the full five feet, then you know the number would be less the payout. Right. So besides all the trigonometric functions, I have an actual calculator that calculates the estimated actual payout, so it's way too much to just do right off the [00:39:00] top of my head.
Peter Koch: [00:39:01] No I think it's a great answer because normally people, I got that this, this and that and boom, it's all set. Yeah, that's not always the answer.
David Kozlowsky: [00:39:08] Well, if you want to take if you want to be safe and you want to take the standard things you can like, if you're standing on the edge of something and you're tied off overhead, then you know you can take the from foot level. You can take the, you know, the total arrest distance plus the total payout, plus the flex in the, you know, the D ring and the harness and all that. You can add all those up and just come up with a general number. The problem is if you don't have 18 to 20 feet of fall clearance and it's getting a little tighter, then you need to start getting a little bit more in depth in your calculations to make sure you, you know you cover it.
Peter Koch: [00:39:44] No, I think that's a great point, too, because most people will take those standards and say, this is going to work normally. I don't know. I don't see very many times where the worker, the guy who's actually got to use the fall protection [00:40:00] stuff that he's given by the company. He works at those particular standards like so great when we set it up. You might have had 15 feet of fall clearance, but now because of stuff that's parked below the edge, now we don't have 15 feet of fall clearance. We've got eight feet of fall clearance or 10 feet of fall clearance. And all of a sudden it changes whether or not that piece of equipment is going to work. And great, I've got one anchor point, but I've got, you know, 15, 16, 18 feet to either side of the anchor for the guy to do his job. And that changes. What he can do.
David Kozlowsky: [00:40:36] And this goes back to what I said at the beginning about when you're calculating those, it's important to add five feet to pretty much anything you calculate with leading edge. If you're tied off behind you because you're going to fall that five feet to the D ring before the system even starts doing what it's supposed to be doing. So that's why I went back to, you know, if it's four foot if it's, you know, general industry [00:41:00] and you have to add five feet to every fall to begin with,
Peter Koch: [00:41:02] That math doesn't work,
David Kozlowsky: [00:41:03] Doesn't add up, does it?
Peter Koch: [00:41:04] You don't even need your laptop for that.
David Kozlowsky: [00:41:06] No I don't. That's right.
Peter Koch: [00:41:09] So let's talk a little bit more about the kind of the setup because we discussed this and this was sort of a revelation to me. I hadn't thought of it this way, but just because your anchor might actually be at your D ring height or above doesn't mean it's not leading edge because there's a relationship between where the edge is and the distance back from the edge for the anchor. Because you're going to, you might have a sharp enough radius across that sharp edge, depending on how far back it is. Talk a little bit about that and how that might factor in this might be a surprise to people.
David Kozlowsky: [00:41:46] So basically, what you're looking at is depending on the well, going back to what I said originally about how if it's in my opinion, if it's bending over something and it's a sharp edge and you're tied back from the edge, so it's bending [00:42:00] over something, then you're basically technically a leading edge. Now, that doesn't necessarily mean that it's going to be the maximum freefall. Certainly, the maximum calculated freefall would be, say, a roof anchor at your feet. Back from the edge, you're going to fall the full five feet. If you're tied off, you know, above your head back from the edge, you might not fall the full five feet you might actually get. And this is the relationship to everything centrifugal bass. So an SRL locks up based on pulls and springs. It's all engineered so that a certain number of feet per minute that the cable comes out. It's going to lock those things. So if it's not traveling fast enough, then it's not going to lock. This kind of even goes back to our last discussion. We were talking about low sloped roofs, and I said there's some discussion about I kind of put myself out there by saying you could use a retractable on a low sloped roof, but some people say you can't because what happens is if you're sliding down the roof, you're technically [00:43:00] in a free fall technically, but you're sliding slow, right? You're not really free falling, so to speak, so you could slide all the way down the roof and your retractable might never lock up. So the same concept applies to this. If you're tied off, say above your D ring behind you a little bit and the ultimate angle that's going to come over that edge. If it's not very much, it's going to pay out quicker. So it's going to lock up quicker than, if you're, say, tied off at your feet. But again, that's a calculation for the for the laptop. I would say if you're at a leading edge to be safe, if you just use the five feet to begin with, then you're going to be safe. I mean, that would be something you might want to save for a very specific application where you're really trying to get some work done and you know, it's a tight fall clearance.
Peter Koch: [00:43:53] Sure and even like the choice between getting something that might be leading edge certified as opposed to something that's more general [00:44:00] certified for a SRL, just because I'm tied off at my d-ring or above and back, you know, the further back you are as I for the anchor point, if I've got, you know, 10 or 15 feet of distance between my anchor and the leading edge, that's going to be a fairly sharp radius. As you think about. I've got five feet of height, 15 feet below. There's your hypotenuse calculation that you come in from there all the way to the leading edge. It's going to be a fairly sharp radius as you come across. Rather than if you had your anchor almost directly above that leading edge where you're not going to have much there.
David Kozlowsky: [00:44:36] You're not going to have that. In fact, you can even get further into this if you want to. Some people that like to have brainy discussions about this stuff would even say that retractable can only, the springs will only retract the cable at a certain number of feet per second to depending on the retractable. So some people would also say that if you're tied off like on a roof anchor and your way far below the D ring, [00:45:00] that. There's a possibility that you would even have more than five feet because if you accidentally it's different if you roll off the edge or if you step off the edge. So if you literally just take a step off the edge and you're instantly free falling, there's a possibility that you could fall faster than the retractable can pull the cable back in. So you're going to actually have loose cable at the edge. So you're not only going to go the five feet, but you might go an extra foot. You know the loose cable?
Peter Koch: [00:45:29] Yeah. So that really goes into that industry standard of that two foot safety factors critical in that consideration,
David Kozlowsky: [00:45:38] And that's why you do it. Yeah, definitely. Because they're I mean, it's definitely a science and it's reasonably exact science. But and there's just so many variables. It's hard. I mean, even the friction of the edge can change it. How you know how easy it is for it to slip over the side. Obviously, the weight of the person can change it. The type of fall can change it. If you're backing up and [00:46:00] literally step off the edge of a roof or something, that's going to be a totally different dynamic than if you're kneeling down and, you know, working, or if you slip and fall down and kind of roll off the side. Or, you know, if you bump into somebody and you both fall off the side, I mean, that can affect things. So that's yeah, that's why the safety factor, there's just too many variables,
Peter Koch: [00:46:22] Tons of variables. I always tell people when we get to do those fall calculations and just the basic math, not the laptop math.
David Kozlowsky: [00:46:30] Can't go wrong with that.
Peter Koch: [00:46:31] Yeah, just to kind of look at that and look at the standards and you get to that end where you put the safety factor in and they all look at me and go, Why would I want to do that? It's like because your math isn't as good as you think it is. And your eye is not as good as you're estimating, you think or in estimating as you think it is, so have the safety factor in the event that you make a mistake. But here, when we consider that you might not have made a mistake at all in the calculation, the mistake happens in the relation or not the relationship, but the design of [00:47:00] the equipment and the use of the equipment.
David Kozlowsky: [00:47:02] Well, even just the equipment itself. I mean, you know, a retractable and we have pretty exacting standards of, you know, the torque on the brake nut when we reassemble one or when we repair one. But you know, there's a range that you're allowed to be in. So if you're on the tighter end or the looser end of that range, I mean, that could make a few inches. It doesn't sound like much, but a few inches could turn into more than that, depending on how far the fall was and stuff. So, you know, there's all these little things that you just can't take into consideration. So the safety factor is there to cover that.
Peter Koch: [00:47:37] Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. And so that's a good point. You manufacture SRLs and you manufacture lanyards and things like that. So what besides or in order to get the LE certification, what's the material difference is like what? I know it can't break, but what kind of material goes into making SRL? That's LE certified.
David Kozlowsky: [00:47:59] Well the cable ones [00:48:00] are really no different as far as the actual guts of the unit. Based on the older overhead style, it's the same size cable, basically same drum, same springs, same pulls because a lot of the tests are still the same. The static tests and a lot of those retraction tests and everything are all the same, whether it's overhead or it's LE. So the difference mainly being there's going to be a slight adjustment on the brake tension. So there's going to be a little bit of an adjustment. So an overhead one and an LE one is going to have a slight adjustment in that the nut that actually adjust the brake tension and then you're going to also have on any newer retractable as you're going to have a shock pack on that. So the newer the 2014 standard removed, the old standard used to say that if you could pass the leading edge test without an external shock pack, then you could do it that way. [00:49:00] The new standard basically took that exemption out, so it basically says a leading edge retractable must have a shock pack unless it's designed to be worn on the body, so the movable braking portion of it is on you instead of at the connection point. So most larger, retractable is anything bigger than, you know, like a little six foot job is going to. They're going to have an additional shock pack because the braking mechanism is still in the unit. So there's that difference. And then, like I said, the shock, that's basically the main two differences.
Peter Koch: [00:49:33] Ok, and then can you have fabric? That would that would get certified?
David Kozlowsky: [00:49:38] If you can get it to pass the test, you can. Our weight our six foot unit is the mini six foot mini is. We tried to get that to pass leading edge. It's got dynamo webbing, which is very strong and very abrasion resistant, couldn't quite get it. It's really hard that sawing test [00:50:00] is the hardest one, so we passed foot level tie off with that no problem. We actually passed the straight line leading edge, sharp edge test with it. No problem. But as soon as you introduce the five foot offset and have that sawing motion, it does. It cuts the webbing and it doesn't it won't hold up. So getting a fabric one to withstand the leading edge test in a bigger unit, you probably could do it because the webbing is much thicker and much stronger. But those little six foot jobs, they're only like three quarter inch wide webbing and it's real thin. So you're trying to put it in a compact housing. So there's just not room for a beefy enough material. But so most, most everything leading edge is cable. Yeah, I mean, if you could get it to pass, you could. There's no reason why you couldn't.
Peter Koch: [00:50:52] Yeah, that makes sense. Again, you're balancing that safety, quality productivity like I can. I can make it if I can get a big enough, beefy [00:51:00] enough, sturdy enough piece of webbing. But then I'm not going to want to wear that on my back all the time. Or, you know, have it attached someplace else too.
David Kozlowsky: [00:51:09] Then users are saying, Well, everybody else is only this big and you know, yours weighs this much and it's, you know, then like you said, productivity, right?
Peter Koch: [00:51:18] It just goes back to the plan, right? In order to have the right fall protection equipment, that's not going to break the budget, that's going to be applicable. You have to have a plan, you have to know what the exposures are. And I, you know, we talk about that almost every time we have a conversation about fall prevention and fall protection, but it's the crucial part of any process of thinking about fall protection. You got to know what you're protecting from.
David Kozlowsky: [00:51:47] It's a crucial part of any process. I mean, how productive. Let's take fall protection out of it. Let's say you're working on a piece of machinery. How productive is it to repair that piece of machinery if you just [00:52:00] show up and then it's 14 trips back to the toolbox and four trips to the parts store to, you know, get parts and, you know, a 10 minute job might take you all day. I mean, it's no different than safety. It's just you need to start applying that same principle where any job, whether it's safety or maintenance or anything, is far more productive and efficient if you figure out what you need ahead of time and hopefully have it on hand.
Peter Koch: [00:52:26] Yeah, we I think we get spoiled sometimes in our sort of instant gratification society when we think, Oh yeah, I can just get that it's not a big deal, but like talk to the guys that maintain the wind turbines and you're 600 feet in the air and you drop a wrench or you don't bring the right size socket with you. It's a half a day project sometimes to get all the way back down and get all the way back up.
David Kozlowsky: [00:52:50] If you're at the, you know you're on the roof of a, you know, an older building, maybe it doesn't have an elevator and you're going up there to service HVAC equipment and you and [00:53:00] I forgot the belt, you know, and it's 12 stories back down to the van twelve stories back up. I mean, might take you 45 minutes because you forgot that belt. You know, it's those kind of things can be applied to safety, too. If you try to plan ahead and you have the equipment hopefully on hand that you need, then you're going to be way more productive, just like any other task.
Peter Koch: [00:53:20] Yeah. And I think a good point, too, like if you don't have that dedicated safety person for your company, which fine, then use the people that are on the right on the front line and start getting information from them about how it works, how it applies. Does this tool that we have actually function for you, some of it, they're not going to know, like a lot of the qualifications and certifications and the risk assessment part they might not understand, but
David Kozlowsky: [00:53:48] That's where people can help. We can help them, though that's the kind of thing that, you know, if you're going into an industrial or commercial application like you're talking about, I mean, you might your safety [00:54:00] person might be an industrial hygienist or something. Or maybe they're really good at some things, but all of a sudden they've thrown at them a fall situation and they're not sure. I mean, that's where we come in. I mean, if they don't know, they have us to call and we're the experts.
Peter Koch: [00:54:16] Yeah, that's a great point. Google can get you quite far, but really getting to the expert person is going to take you a lot farther, a lot faster. And people always think, Oh, it's going to just cost so much money. I have to incorporate this expert person to come in and do that in the long run. You were talking about that before. You might be able to give information that will allow someone to get a smaller, more efficient unit for their team rather than having to go with a big gummy one. Because you're you only have information that's going to be the max standard for evaluation.
David Kozlowsky: [00:54:55] We're always cognizant of that and we always go in and try to lead [00:55:00] off with. Whatever we feel would be the most economically feasible for the customer, and we never go in and try to oversell them something. I mean, sometimes that's the only thing you can use and that's just the way it is. But there's many times where we have been in and we've come out and the customer said, Wow, I thought that was going to, you know, cost me a lot more. Thanks for walking us through this.
Peter Koch: [00:55:21] Cool. That's really cool. And you know, I'll, you know, I'll look at that as well and think, Geez, like there's been times where just with my own expertise, I don't have all the information that I can. I can correctly or efficiently advise a policyholder. So even myself, as an expert within the safety industry, you have to look to somebody who has a lot more experience within fall protection because I don't have the fall calculator that you've developed through years of experience and then testing your own equipment to get certifications through ANSI to make sure that it meets [00:56:00] the standard that's functional.
David Kozlowsky: [00:56:02] Yeah. And even with that, I've said before, I mean, way back to the first one, you ask me, you know, what's one thing you wish you could tell younger you? It's like, it's OK to not know everything. I still don't. I'll say it again. I mean, when you when you gave me the list of topics, I had to go on and look up definitions because I'm like, Oh man, I never thought of that. It's just one of those things where if you know where to find things, or if you know people that can help you, that you can, you know, along in the process, then that's everything really. You don't have to know everything I don't
Peter Koch: [00:56:32] No, and you can't. There's so much information out there and it's a blessing and a trap, right? Because there's so much information out there. It also means that there's a lot of misinformation out there. And as I was doing some research and investigation for this particular episode, you can Google leading edge fall protection and there's a zillion Google hits that come up for that. So which one do you choose?
David Kozlowsky: [00:56:57] Well, there's no substitute [00:57:00] for actually on site, like, that's why I said, if you're on site, you can google it all you want. You can see all the lanyards there are and all the SRLs, and you can see all that equipment. But you know somebody on a Google search probably not going to be able to look at your particular situation and say, I would recommend that you use this. And that's where you just you just can't substitute like somebody in person, you know, actually helping you and looking at it.
Peter Koch: [00:57:27] Yeah, that's a great that's a great example. I just made me think, if you know, if I am a contractor or I've got a new job that I'm trying to bid out and I need new fall protection equipment for it, you know, many times you're just going to go to the website. And all right, so this is what I've purchased before. I purchased this, before I purchased that before. And you might talk to the sales guy, maybe at the website and you're going to give them a little bit of information. He's going to tell you what he thinks. What we've talked about here is [00:58:00] you need more specifics.
David Kozlowsky: [00:58:01] Yeah, a lot more specifics. We've I've not gotten a lot of sales because I wouldn't sell somebody something that I knew wasn't going to work. And then, you know, I don't want to drop names, but they'll go on their favorite, you know, catalog du jour with all of the industrial and safety gear in it. And they'll just buy what they want and then they'll call it good. And we won't do that. I mean, I'm not going to sell somebody something if it's not going to work. And leading edge is the perfect time to talk about that because leading edge is can be potentially far more dangerous than any other type of fall protection, both in terms of fall clearance and in terms of what happens during the fall. And when you have that false sense of security, you think you're safe because you're tied off and then God forbid, it breaks, you know, when you're hopefully you're safe and you're not.
Peter Koch: [00:58:55] Yeah, there's some pretty dramatic videos out there around [00:59:00] leading edge equipment testing and the difference between something rated for leading edge, whether it's cable or fabric in just watching the instantaneous parting of that lanyard as it comes over the edge. And, you know, as the guy who is maybe wearing that equipment to think, alright, so this is going to protect me and that's, you know, as a manager, if you hand someone some PPE in the back of their head, they're thinking, OK, this is going to keep me safe. Well, if it's not the right thing and they do have a leading edge fall and it's not appropriate for leading edge, the thing in their mind of I'm going to be hanging here, parts when the cable parts
David Kozlowsky: [00:59:42] Back early on in my days at safe approach back around the late nineties. We had a situation where a customer had a couple of our stations and a cable and a lanyard, and they were tied off doing what they were supposed to be doing work in a leading [01:00:00] edge, doing decking. And so the worker stepped off the edge and fell in the stanchions, and the cable and the lanyard did everything they were supposed to do. He got caught and everything worked. He was hanging sixty feet off the ground. And because there was the way he fell and because there was a slight slope because they were on the top level, one of the sheets of roofing continued to slide off the roof, went off the roof, sliced right through his lanyard, and he fell. And this is after the fall. So here's a guy who is here and he thinks he's saved because the product did its job and then a sheet comes off and slices through the lanyard, and that was before they really had leading edge or anything like that. And honestly, that was an accident that would have been hard to prevent. I mean, that wasn't a leading edge situation. It wasn't a, you know, a situation where [01:01:00] he was using the wrong equipment. It was just that one in a million chance. And so, you know, things happen less than one in a million chance. Things happen and you want to make sure you have the right gear. And leading edge is it's no joke. I mean, it can happen to you.
Peter Koch: [01:01:16] Yeah, it very much can. And then going back to that, the conversation about job hazard analysis like a comprehensive job hazard analysis would take into consideration where is your material? How is it being secured? What's the pitch? What's the potential? And then all that information can be if you bring it to someone who's not just picking something out of a catalog can start to look and say, Well, hey, you know, if you're not going to secure this, if there's areas where you can't do this, you might want to have something else in the event that all these factors come together. In a worst case scenario.
David Kozlowsky: [01:01:55] Yeah, exactly. It happens.
Peter Koch: [01:01:56] Yeah, right on. Is there anything else that you want to tell us about for [01:02:00] Leading Edge that we haven't talked about is anything that I didn't ask you
David Kozlowsky: [01:02:03] Off the top of my head. I can't think of anything. I think we covered it pretty well.
Peter Koch: [01:02:07] We did pretty well. I think today.
David Kozlowsky: [01:02:08] Don't want people to get bored either.
Peter Koch: [01:02:10] No, no, no. And I guess one last plug that I have about reaching out to experts that there is a there's a definite benefit to recognizing that you don't always have all the information and then reaching out to an expert to engage them about a particular product or scenario or situation. And I can't stress that enough that Google is great, but it doesn't always give you all the information. And in all of the research that I did around leading edge the conversation around the five foot part, the additional five feet never was in any of it. And so that's I mean, just that piece changes your fall calculation, changes a lot of what equipment you might choose for [01:03:00] the particular scenario.
David Kozlowsky: [01:03:01] Yeah, and that's where an expert can help.
Peter Koch: [01:03:04] Yeah, absolutely. Reach out, right?
David Kozlowsky: [01:03:06] Try to be careful not to plug myself too much here.
Peter Koch: [01:03:09] You've I think you've done a great job and safe approach is definitely a place where people can reach out to their local right here in Maine. But there is also other experts that are out there that have a lot of expertise in this. You know, they might not be manufacturers, right? They might be salespeople, but there are other people that have a ton of experience. Just make sure that you reach out to the expert with questions.
David Kozlowsky: [01:03:31] And I mean, that's something that we can help with, too. I mean, if you have questions that we don't, I mean, I have a pretty good knowledge base of people that I know if you need training or you need a specific type of information that I don't have, I mean, I do know people that do this for a living that do training and consulting and whatever. So just reaching out to me doesn't necessarily mean that I'm going to try to sell you something somebody else can help you. I might be able to help you, you know, find that person that can [01:04:00] do what you need.
Peter Koch: [01:04:01] Point you in the right direction. Yeah, and last point, that's another really good point that we can't overlook is the training part of this. So whatever fall protection that you have, your people need to have training around the systems and the exposures and the design and limitations and inspection and maintenance before they're exposed to the hazard, right? And so it's a critical part that they have all that because just because they have it doesn't mean that they know how to use it.
David Kozlowsky: [01:04:28] Most of the accidents that happen with fall protection are just because it's being used incorrectly or they're using the wrong equipment.
Peter Koch: [01:04:39] Yeah it's always interesting to me doing training with folks that maybe have not been exposed to fall protection equipment before and putting a harness on how do you know, how does it get sized appropriately? How tight is tight? How comfortable is comfortable? What side does the D ring go on? And then w [01:05:00]hat end of the lanyard do you connect to the anchor and what end of the land do you connect to the harness? And some are pretty obvious. You know, you get a dual leg lanyard. It's relatively easy to figure out what you connect. However, it's not always that easy,
David Kozlowsky: [01:05:16] Depending on the type of the lanyard. It's not even always that easy. And then you have the factor of people just, you know, they want to get the job done too. So they'll take shortcuts or do things that they shouldn't because they just want to get it done and move on. But you know, and it's to your benefit to do that training. I mean, if something happens and somebody has an accident, I mean, it's your employee. So you're going to you're going to want to be able to show that you train that person on how to use the equipment. If not, then you know, you might be opening yourself up to additional liability, certainly.
Peter Koch: [01:05:50] And then I was at a job site. This is fairly recently actually, and we're looking across to a property that wasn't [01:06:00] owned by the policyholder and was not being built by a policyholder and on the roof. They were actually replacing the roof and they were removing sheathing and watched the guy who was moving his self retracting lifeline from anchor to anchor. And the way he was doing it was fairly interesting. You know, he took his big self retracting lifeline, which was connected to his harness. Oh yeah. And then just on clipping walking across the ridge of the roof and clipping into the next set into the next piece. So way too many things going wrong there to even start.
David Kozlowsky: [01:06:38] That certainly wouldn't be considered 100 percent tie off application.
Peter Koch: [01:06:43] Right? That would be the first thing.
David Kozlowsky: [01:06:45] Yeah, yeah, there's better ways to do that. A little bit of help from an outside person could help you figure that out.
Peter Koch: [01:06:53] Absolutely. Hey, so just an interesting question that popped into my head. So what happens if I take a [01:07:00] self retracting lifeline and install it the opposite way around? So instead of attaching the hook to me and the CRL to the anchor, what happens if I switch it around?
David Kozlowsky: [01:07:09] Absolutely nothing. They work both ways. Yeah. In fact, in a lot of ways, it's probably safer to have it attached to you, especially in a leading edge where one of the reasons for the additional shock pack is the braking mechanism being on the other side of the sharp edge. But the bottom line is going to be the manufacturer. I mean, we allow it. It's there's no reason why you can't. It's not unsafe other than just being heavy and potentially clunking you in the head if you do fall. But if the manufacturer, you need to follow the manufacturer's recommendations. So if they don't want you to do it, then whatever your piece of equipment is, you shouldn't do it. And that's I like, try to stress that each time we talk is manufacturer, follow their recommendations because they're really the one that OSHA's going to fall back to. [01:08:00]
Peter Koch: [01:08:01] Perfect. So that about wraps up today's podcast there. Thanks a lot again for coming on, and thanks for inviting me down to the shop here to do the podcast in person.
David Kozlowsky: [01:08:10] Yeah, no problem. It's been fun.
Peter Koch: [01:08:12] It has been fun. So where can our listeners find out more about safe approach?
David Kozlowsky: [01:08:16] Yeah. You can go to our website www.safeapproach.com, or you can call (800) 471-1157 or you can email [email protected], or you can email me directly. [email protected].
Peter Koch: [01:08:33] Perfect. Thanks. I really, really appreciate you.
David Kozlowsky: [01:08:36] Thank you
Peter Koch: [01:08:36] Right on. And to all of our listeners out there, thanks for spending some time with us today. We've been speaking about leading edge fall protection with David Kozlowsky, president and owner of Safe Approach, right here in Portland, Maine. If you have any questions about fall protection or I'd like to hear more about a particular topic on our podcast. Email me at [email protected]. Also check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/podcast, [01:09:00] where you can find additional resources, links to other podcasts with David and I, as well as our entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for the Safety Net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates, and if you haven't done so already, I'd really appreciate it. If you would subscribe to the podcast and then take a minute to review us on Spotify, iTunes or whatever podcast service that you found us on. And if you've already done that, thanks because it really, truly helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing the show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Koch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.
According to the US Small business Administration, 99 percent of firms in the US are small business and according to JP Morgan Chase, the vast majority, nearly 88%, have fewer than 20 employees.
At MEMIC, we partner with small businesses who understand that the health and safety of their employees leads to a more productive and profitable workplace.
On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, I speak with Elise Brown, partner and Executive Vice President at Evergreen Home Performance and Brian Schortz, General Manager at Evergreen Home Performance about developing and leading a safety culture at a small business.
Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch. Small businesses make up the lion's share of the employers across the country, and most large businesses started out as a small business venture where just a few people with a passion for something took their product or service to the people. And while not everyone or every small business will be the next Apple, Exxon or Tesla. Just about everyone, especially if you are or have been a small business owner, can relate to the struggle of building or owning a small company at MEMIC. We see that at the heart of every company that has enjoyed long term success, that there's a correlation between productivity, quality and safety. Of course, we're a safety company, so we would see that. But statistics do show that long term success does come from a balance between those three things. And there's analogies out there about the business [00:01:00] being like a three legged stool where safety, quality and productivity support the success of a company. And without all three of those, the stool is going to fall. Really, what has to happen is there needs to be a balance because you can't have a short leg on the stool and have it function for you, otherwise you will be precariously perched on one of the other legs and that's not going to be functional for anyone's long term success. So safety, we see it as the foundation upon which a business can build production and quality and without people, which is the crux of safety and the right people in place, most businesses will fail and we've all seen this and especially now. And if you're listening to this in 2021 are probably even in 2022. Finding employees is a very challenging part for any business large or small, and it becomes even more challenging when you find an employee, spend the time to train them to make them part of your team, and then they either leave [00:02:00] because they found a better offer someplace else or they get injured and they can no longer work for you. Because when people get hurt or leave because of conditions, your businesses may be unable to fulfill the productivity demands or quality demands. So having a robust workplace safety program and a culture allows an owner or a manager or a supervisor to be flexible around increased productivity and quality demand changes while still keeping a skilled workforce in place. A strong safety culture and program provides those parameters and tools to protect employees while still maintaining a focus on productivity and quality. Now, creating and maintaining that culture and program is a true leadership challenge, and I believe that small businesses can find really elegant and creative solutions to balance productivity and quality on a culture steeped in safety that large businesses can't always or sometimes struggle to find. So today, [00:03:00] to help us look at safety leadership in a small business are Elise Brown and Brian Schortz from Evergreen Home Performance. Elise is a partner and executive vice president, and Brian is the general manager. So, Elise and Brian, welcome to the podcast today.
Brian Schortz: [00:03:16] Hi, Peter.
Elise Brown: [00:03:17] Good morning, Peter. Thanks so much for having us.
Peter Koch: [00:03:20] I'm excited to talk to you guys. You know, we have you and I don't have a long history, but you guys have a fairly long history with MEMIC. We were just talking about this before we started the podcast that you've been with MEMIC for somewhere around 15 years. A colleague of mine, Randy Klatt, is your lost control consultant, and he has spoken very highly of you guys, both as a company overall and as really leaders on the safety aspect. So we wanted to talk to you today, some about who you are. What Evergreen Home Performance is and how do you manage safety in such a, and really, it's a fairly challenging industry that you work in from a safety standpoint. [00:04:00] How do you manage safety and how do you keep it going? So let's find out a little bit about you guys first, Elise, let's start with you first. Why don't you tell me a little bit about you and your history with Evergreen? How does that sound?
Elise Brown: [00:04:14] Sure. I come from a background, a varied background. I guess I would say I've been a Jill of all trades. I've worked in construction. I've worked as a boat builder and the basis of my career before coming to Evergreen was in emergency response services. So I've been a professional and a volunteer firefighter and officer in our local volunteer fire department, and I've been an EMT and emergency medical technician as well as an ambulance driver. And currently I'm the emergency management director for the town of Liberty. And so all those prior and current experiences really have me steeped in the whole concept and value of safety. And [00:05:00] so when I joined Evergreen, that was an obvious place for me to put some attention.
Peter Koch: [00:05:04] Yeah, sure. All of those really have substantial focus around safety, especially the emergency management part, but construction as well. And then boat building. I didn't realize that you had a boat building background to talk about that offline sometime and see where that goes. That's pretty cool. Brian, how about you? What's your background and how did you come to Evergreen?
Brian Schortz: [00:05:27] Thanks, Peter. I have been, you know, with an evergreen for 11 years now and transition to evergreen from a corporate food service world. You know, basically, it was a large international companies that had lots of systems in place. And you know, you didn't have to think about safety. Safety was kind of presented as part of the operating plan. So there was there was not a lot of creativity. There was a plan. If you could follow the [00:06:00] plan, it was put together, you know, for success. So it was more of an implementation rather than kind of. Trying to figure it out for our business. And again, I've been with Evergreen for 11 years. I'm most recently, we've done a little bit of reorganization in the last year or so have taken the safety responsibility for Evergreen as my, one of my primary duties. This was Elise's passion and you know, up until and this is more of a soft handoff, and perhaps it will be handed back to Elise in the future. But nonetheless, we work at it collaboratively.
Peter Koch: [00:06:41] Awesome.
Elise Brown: [00:06:43] Hey, Peter, just to jump in a little bit here, I kind of started rambling about my safety background, but I didn't talk necessarily about what I'm doing in my role currently with Evergreen is that should I say a couple of sentences about that or
Peter Koch: [00:06:56] No, we'll get to that because I was going to bring it back after Brian. So great [00:07:00] lead in, actually. So the background actually in foodservice and I have a background in food service, not that large international corporate, but definitely corporate food service through college and then worked in small restaurants. And then that's actually how I paid for part of my college tuition is working in the cafeteria. So it definitely was a kind of a cookie cutter safety plan. And if you could follow the plan, you could be safe. But it really all depended upon if you wanted to follow the plan. So very, very interesting and neat background. So both of you have some background within safety, corporate emergency management, but let's find out a little bit more about evergreen itself. So Elise, why don't you talk a little bit about what you do for Evergreen? And I think more of an umbrella to like what is evergreen do? What is evergreen home performance about and what's the product that you have out there?
Elise Brown: [00:07:54] Sure. Evergreen Home Performance is a contracting company, and we have two locations in Portland [00:08:00] and Rockland. Each location has about 12 people, and within those groups we have a group of salespeople, two or three salespeople and the rest are in production, working in Maine homes, doing retrofit work to make them more energy efficient and comfortable. So the bulk of the work is in cramped spaces like attics and basements. And so, you know, as we think about safety, it's a fairly creative and customized approach in interpreting a lot of the rules. My role in the business has changed over time, but I tend to think about systems and I like in a small business. It's a very creative endeavor to try to make a system first, create it and then keep adjusting and adapting it to suit the businesses need. So currently I'm working on IT System improvements also work on sales processes in terms of how we flow our contracts through [00:09:00] a process and advising Brian on our safety system.
Peter Koch: [00:09:05] Awesome. Lots of balls in the air for that, and I think there's kind of going back to the introduction there is an interwoven theme of safety that can be related to each of those systems, whether it's in a sales system. And we'll talk about this, how you know, how our salespeople can actually help or hinder some of the safety processes that we have in place. Our IT systems can certainly support or break down some of those safety systems that we have in our HR systems can certainly be a boon or a challenge to our safety systems. So interesting that you've got all those pieces in there. And really, from a systematic standpoint, it's not what I thought when I saw you as the executive vice president or heard that to think about that would be your focus in developing all those systems. So that's pretty cool. And again, [00:10:00] more of that conceptual piece as a small business leader in keeping safety at the forefront. Awesome. Brian. So as a general manager there? So what are your responsibilities and how do you interact with those systems that that Elise is getting in place for you or fine tuning for you?
Brian Schortz: [00:10:22] Well, one of the duties one of my duties is I'm the human resource manager, so we're often talking about safety in use. So you know, our a lot of our work requires wearing respirators and true respirators, not, you know, paper masks. We're talking about respirators with P1, hundreds on them for a lot of the day. So that's a conversation that we're having. You know, all the interview is, you know, talking about the importance of the safety, the culture is that something that would even work for people? Some people do not want to be [00:11:00] saddled with a respirator or the primary thing you see and Elise is doing it is every person who we interview walks in the door with a beard and if you are going to wear a respirator. Unfortunately, that beard is not they're not friends, and the beard has to the beard has to go. So we talked about like, you know, maybe a very tight Elise calls them, you know, a fire fireman's moustache or so. Know things like all this over here has to go. So the seal works and your respirator is actually doing what it's intended to do. So we're talking about it at the very beginning, kind of making sure that we've got candidates and understand that it's super important that we're dealing in really hard work, tough conditions. Places that require respirators, so if it requires a respirator, that means there's something there that you don't want to be ingesting. You know, taking in your body, so you know, it does take [00:12:00] a certain kind of person and a commitment from the employee's standpoint to work, you know, to come to work for a company like that. I work in, the other part of my duty is I'm working directly with, we call our teams that are doing the work, production our production teams. So I manage the group in our Rockland office directly and, you know, have some scheduling input in our southern Maine. But so really just connecting with the people that are doing the work on a daily basis as well,
Peter Koch: [00:12:32] Great making sure that they have what they need. And I like that tie in right back from the interview, starting with a safety discussion. Whether you use the word safety right from the beginning or start talking about some of those different exposures that your employees will be exposed to. So the hazards that your employees will be exposed to right at the beginning in the interview, so they understand not only that you take it seriously, but you're aware of it, and there are some expectations around their [00:13:00] interaction and performance around those exposures. Awesome.
Brian Schortz: [00:13:03] I think we found early on that we needed to let people know that safety was an important part of working at Evergreen two ways. One is that we take it seriously so that we're often interviewing folks that have worked in small businesses. They're not coming out of a corporate kind of world or a perhaps like DIW, where there are a lot of rules coming from a lot of mom and pop places that are used to operating, you know, sometimes fast and loose. And so, you know, trying to just get people to understand that this is not, that that's not the culture that we're, you know, is this the right fit? Because we do. We're not perfect. But these are some of the, you know, these are this is the culture
Peter Koch: [00:13:47] Great set in that expectation right up front. I think that's a good it's a good thought process to have to recognize that not everybody is going to come in with the same habits and understanding of not just [00:14:00] the expectations for performance, but that you do know what the hazards are, and there are some rules around how you interact with them. And not every business recognizes that. And as a small business, I think that's key for anyone listening that it's a great takeaway to know that you have an opportunity when you hire somebody on to reset their expectations. Hopefully for the positive, sometimes for the negative of what they should be doing when they're working here. You have that option as a business owner, as the hirer, or as the supervisor, as the manager. So kudos for, you know, weaving that in and throughout the hiring process and then the interaction as you go forward with those staff to Elise, did you have anything to add to that part because you know, you've been a part of this for a long time as well and putting the systems in place, you need to be able to support just what Brian's been talking about. So how does some of those systems interact and what else do you have to add [00:15:00] to that?
Elise Brown: [00:15:01] Yeah. My head is just abuzz with all kinds of ideas. So here's one thing that became apparent to us right out of the get go is, you know, as a contractor, we needed a CRM, a contact resource management tool all the way to a database to track our customers in a way to develop our pricing and get proposals out to customers. And we looked at out of the box solutions we could just purchase. And one of the things we came up against is we could not tailor what we sold to our satisfaction, both from a quality perspective, but from a safety perspective, because for us, no two spaces are the same. And if we were to just sell Widget X for the same standard price in every situation, we would be creating pressures on our teams to execute at that level, even if the space didn't allow for them to do that safely. So we need we built our own pricing tool so that our advisors, our sales [00:16:00] team, when they go in and build a project, they can incorporate safety considerations into the pricing structure so that the cost of almost everything we sell has some safety consideration, the ability to build that into the price. And so from a systems perspective, we had to build that ourselves so that we had the capacity to do it. And from a training perspective, we had to train our sales team and it's an ongoing process and all the things they need to be looking at and thinking about as a designer project and price it out. And so it's this constant evolution of really keeping them in touch with what our production teams are seeing and experiencing so they can properly price a job for them to do it safely. So that's just one example of how the entire business has to think about safety from a systems perspective.
Peter Koch: [00:16:55] Yeah, and that could really make or break someone's experience as an employee in the field. [00:17:00] And I love the way you said it before, like, no, no space, no two spaces are the same. And I can just think about that from my experience with my own home, which, you know, is circa 1832. So that can give you an idea of what it looks like on the inside. And then so say my brother in law's house, which was built in the 90s. So a vastly different environment for you to work in. And if it's cookie cutter, you could really set somebody up to end up with the wrong tools to do the job. It's still essentially increasing the performance of the home from an environmental standpoint, from a heating and cooling standpoint. But the tools will be different if you have to go into an older home versus a newer home versus a home that's been remodeled before something else has changed. So interesting the way that works. And Brian, how do you see that enhance performance in the field? So Elise talked about [00:18:00] how the systems are working? And do you see that truly are really functioning for the people who are out there doing the job, doing the work when they get out into the field?
Brian Schortz: [00:18:10] I guess what we see is people may not kind of understand what went into the pricing, necessarily the pricing and the thought process, but they may understand that there's less pressure. So I think that we have a metric that, you know, an informal metric of kind of production per day know each group of three when they're working in a house should be able to produce a certain amount of revenue per day. And what I think where I think this connects is that people understand that if the space is very tight or there's just, you know, kind of some very challenging elements to it that that's been factored in to the pricing [00:19:00] so that they have a little more revenue to work with. So they're not under the same kind of constraints to feel like they've just got to really cut corners. So from a customer standpoint, cut corners or even the safety corners that if it would call for normally we would do something. But they're feeling under, you know, under a pressure to get the project done in three days. They may skip that integral step of kind of making sure that they've done the right, the right process to make sure nobody gets hurt. And so I think that's where some of that and some of that is just really communicating what our goals are for the project, kind of some of the some of the challenges per project that we're seeing and getting feedback. You know, I think part of this also is hearing from the folks in the field that, that space was too tight. You know, honestly, it was too it was. If they're going to be like that, we shouldn't. We probably shouldn't do a project like that [00:20:00] because it really was way too physically exhausting, you know, taking it back to Elise and our sales team and just trying to figure out what the minimum space that we're going to work in. And, you know, kind of taking that feedback for real as we do want to keep people safe and employed at Evergreen. They have other needs to go places. If we put them in torture spots every day, the job becomes a lot less enticing.
Elise Brown: [00:20:27] Well, so one example is we often work up in attics, and it used to be that we didn't necessarily have a line item to price for the necessity of placing or building out walk boards up in the attic. So before we specked that out and made sure it was part of the work scope, sometimes our production teams would come to an attic and go up and find that they had nothing to stand on. And so if they had come ill prepared and didn't have those materials and we hadn't priced in [00:21:00] enough time for them to build in a safe working platform, you can imagine the pressure they would feel to just do the dance along the floor choice and hope for the best, rather than have it built in and expected that they would take the time to build that walkway and have the materials with which to do it.
Peter Koch: [00:21:19] That's a great example, because that takes a long knowing that because that's my attic. There are no walk boards up in the attic, and there's enough blown in insulation up there that you can't see any of the joists. So you're always wondering where you are. So, yeah, building that out takes some time. You got to have materials. And while you were both speaking, it made me think that this is part of that evolutionary process of, you know, how the systems can support the people in the field and how the people in the field can support the system. So there's this ongoing spiraling process of information flow back and forth to [00:22:00] overall balance those three pieces safety, quality and productivity. Because you know, you talked about it, Brian, you need to be able to make enough money to be successful to have the business continue. So that's a given that has to happen, and that's based around a lot about the quality of the work that you do. So not only the quality of the end product, but the quality of the work that's done while the people are there. And I know I've talked to folks that have had a particular construction crew or carpentry crew or remodeling crew come in. And even though the end product was functional, the process to get to that end product was not very functional. It was very conflicted a lot with the homeowner and the process of living and functioning and what was said. And lots of stuff goes on to reduce or increase the perception of quality that the customer might be getting. And it seems like [00:23:00] those systems that you have in place can help support all of that.
Elise Brown: [00:23:03] Well, you know, when you look at a job hazard analysis for construction, one of the primary sources of injury is slips, trips and falls. So the easiest way to address that is through simple housekeeping. And so even just in the project set up, you know, taking the time to have a good greeting with the customer, find out which access points work best for them. You know, setting up your hoses and your cords and your workstations in a way that works well for them makes it super efficient for the crew and safe. You know, then you've kind of solved every problem, all in one fell swoop. And so it just makes sense to take the time to do that right at the outset. It makes the day go better for everybody.
Peter Koch: [00:23:47] It sure does. It sure does. And it sounds like you set that expectation that that is the expectation of your crews when they get on the job, that they know that they're expected to do that. You don't just leave it to chance that [00:24:00] they're going to bring the habit from another company or their own personal life, that that's how they'll interact with your customers.
Brian Schortz: [00:24:06] And they do. They understand that it is part of part of what we're doing here, and we're not selling something that is that is glamorous, that is shiny. And it's not, you know, it's not some trophy counter. It is. Once we're done in the attic, they might pop their head up for five minutes and then they're hopeful they never have to look up there again. So where we have the opportunity to kind of make a strong impression on a customer is, you know, with the people that we bring into their home and the experience. And so that's, it is super important, you know that that aspect of working in someone's home where contracting experiences haven't always been positive. You know, we're kind of we're, you know, we start off, you know, working against people's experiences often. And so we have to be better than, you know, than what they're expecting.
Peter Koch: [00:25:00] Now [00:25:00] that's great. So how do you like, how would you quantify, maybe quantify as not the right word, but how do you how do you make sure that you get the buy in from your staff that this is like this is not just the because you can set the expectation, and I think a lot of people listening will have had this experience where you set an expectation and then you go out and look at the performance that's happening in the field or on the shop floor, wherever you are. And the expectations aren't met because the buy in is not there. So how do you make sure that your staff stayed bought into this process?
Brian Schortz: [00:25:43] That's the biggest challenge is I think most people buy like verbally and mentally buy in, you know, to the idea because no one wants to fall down the steps. No one wants to fall through a ceiling. And, you know, kind of crack their ribs. People get rushed. People [00:26:00] kind of forget they get, you know, started to develop bad habits. So, you know, our job is to just to continue to be vigilant, to continue to reinforce, you know, kind of the standards most people want to play along. You know, they just develop bad habits over time. And it's just kind of bringing out, you know, kind of refreshing those and making sure they understand how important it is. And it's important to the company success. And most people here understand the correlation between the company's success, their happiness. You know, it's kind of all tied together that they play an important role at Evergreen. And if the people that are doing the work aren't able to do the work, it impacts the company negatively. So if they're out because they've fallen down the stairs, that's a beyond the torture that you know, puts us through and feeling bad about their injury and physically hurts them. [00:27:00] It also hurts the business, and I think everyone understands how it all kind of plays together for evergreen's success.
Elise Brown: [00:27:08] One of the things I noticed when I was in the fire service was that it was really at the level of the lieutenants that would make or break a safety culture because they were the ones that would sort of embody whatever the values were that the management was trying to impart at the ground level. And one of the things that I've noticed Brian Schortz do really well in managing his production teams is he really cultivates good relationships with his site supervisors, the project managers, and develops a real culture of safety with them so that they feel free to communicate with him. Concerns of any kind. You know, when a job is especially difficult, when they notice something that feels unsafe to them. So I think a lot of it is really in sort of the HR culture that a [00:28:00] business develops so that the middle the mid-level management feels free to express what they see going on and developing, you know, a work atmosphere that feels friendly and supported, I think creates a receptivity when the management team says, Hey, we really got to work on our safety. You know, people are slipping up a little bit or I noticed you weren't wearing those safety glasses. Let's talk about it. And often there are other issues or concerns that we haven't thought about. And so if you don't have that culture of safety where people can really express what's bugging them or what they really need, then you can do all the preaching you want. But maybe there's not going to be on the buying because they don't feel respected or heard about something else.
Peter Koch: [00:28:52] Yeah, it's a really, really great point on both sides for Brian and Elise, you guys. I'm glad you said it because [00:29:00] that's something that I talk often with my policyholders, with the clients that I work with, that, you know, accountability is not just going out and trying to figure out what's somebody doing wrong, but it's the back and forth between your employees, the supervisors, the line staff and make sure making sure that you have all the information to make good decisions and letting them know that they're heard. So I've got a question for you on that particular one. Do you have any examples around like how your employees, maybe they're your middle managers or your line supervisors, or maybe your staff have come up with different ways to be safer in the field and that have been implemented company wide so that they know that they're heard because I think that's an important part because we can talk at all the time. But unless they're really seeing it, they're not going to buy in. So I know you've got some examples out there. So [00:30:00] what might be one that you can relate to our listeners?
Elise Brown: [00:30:04] Well, I think we can take the example of hot attics, and we'll each have something to say about it. So I can talk about hot attics from a system perspective. So as we've mentioned, we're a retrofit company. We work often in attics to air, seal and insulate them to help an occupant save energy and be more comfortable. Well, that often means that we're up in the attic doing that work and six months out of the year, those temperatures can be quite elevated. Brian, will talk to you about some of the improvisation that our field technicians figured out to do to cool those spaces. But we also got feedback from our line staff and from our site supervisors that some of the conditions were just unbearable was unsafe. You know, when we did temperature monitoring, we were hitting the heat index. It was unsafe to be in. And so we made a decision [00:31:00] from a management perspective to not schedule some of those projects in the summer and to defer them to cooler months of the year. And that had all kinds of implications for our marketing, for our project scheduling. So we had to implement those from a systems perspective, and I'll let Brian talk about some of the improvisation for how we can continue to work in some attics that we found were acceptable.
Brian Schortz: [00:31:26] So working and, you know, when we were less prepared to not work in attics in the warmer months as this was starting to become the concern as an issue, you know, some of our some of our production managers developed systems to help cool the spaces. So ultimately and using, you know, some unique thoughts, they created a way to water roofs to ultimately bring the temperature down, you know, in those, you know, in those spaces and it could be [00:32:00] 10 15 degrees that they would see the difference of, you know, getting these long kind of contraptions that held a hose and a sprinkler up to a roof to safely get it up there and have it attached to the roof and making enough of a difference to make it palatable and safe to work in those environments. You know, during certain points of the day. So, you know, that's just one innovation that the folks have a lot of different fans and air conditioning units. And again, because every space is so different that we work in, it's trying to figure out which tool we have that we'll kind of make little work in that particular environment. So it does require a little bit of, you know, innovation. Each project say, what are the containers? Are there? Are there actual window schematics that windows in them? That's a very convenient, you know, if you've got an attic that has a window and [00:33:00] some power, you know, a small, a small AC unit in there, it might make the difference. No windows, no anything. You know, you're bringing fans tube fans up from the basement because the cold air from the basement, you know, is much different than the summer or the air outside your house in the summer. So, you know, those are a couple of different things that you know that we've kind of put in place to make work happen safely.
Peter Koch: [00:33:23] So I guess two questions for follow up on that, and I guess this will tie into the systems as well. But Brian, when your team came up with the watering the roof, which I think is a very innovative plan, it's not something that you would normally think of and it makes scientific sense, but it's not something that your regular attic insulation installer is going to think of right off the top of their head. So how did that go from idea to one of the potential solutions for attic cooling when you're [00:34:00] in those situations?
Brian Schortz: [00:34:02] Good question, Peter, and I'm not sure that I can kind of go back to the genesis of this, but we are a building.
Elise Brown: [00:34:10] I remember.
Brian Schortz: [00:34:11] I'll speak to one aspect and all that Elise up in, you know, part of our business is we adhere to building science concepts. So we're not just a traditional insulation company, you know, we use building science as the backbone of the work that we're doing. And so people that are in the company are exposed to building science concepts so that the concept of, you know, of a roof cooling with water is something that, you know, that perhaps came out of, you know, some of those discussions. Some of the building science discussions and not your normal water cooler talk.
Elise Brown: [00:34:52] But I remember one of our I guess I think he was still a technician at the time. Brian Pringle got this concept and he asked, Hey, [00:35:00] do you mind if I make a prototype and try it out? So we said, sure, and he went and bought all the items from Home Depot or the hardware store, and we paid for the materials and he rigged one up and tried it and liked it and took a little video and showed it around and people got interested. So I think we gave him the time and the budget to build a couple more. And then the shop up in Rockland did the same. So it was just a little seed money and a good idea. And the encouragement to do it,
Peter Koch: [00:35:30] That part, that encouragement part and giving employees and you had spoken about both of you spoke about this earlier is the having both your managers and your technicians, your line staff, the ability to be heard and then not just being heard in a meeting and then everybody nodding and then going away. And you do the same thing the next day, but actually taking a potential concept that people see value and bringing it to fruition and then installing [00:36:00] it as part of one of the solutions. That's very powerful for an employee to be heard. And it's not just the moneymaking solution, but it's a safety solution. It's a really interesting way of managing a very dangerous exposure for your staff. And it's innovative. That's a fantastic a great story, a really great story. And I think it speaks to some businesses, whether you're a large business, a medium sized business or a small business, we sometimes get roped into all of the solutions have to come from me. And when you have a group of employees that you're training and you're caring for and you're working with a lot of solutions or at least ideas for potential solutions can come from them. And that's a it's a great story. Water on the roof. It's a great story.
Brian Schortz: [00:36:53] And I just like to add to at the other end of the business level, from a management owner perspective, [00:37:00] we had to be willing to stop selling certain things. You know, if it was just too hot and too dangerous, we had to be willing to walk away. And so it was it was in conjunction with that concern of hot attics that we started considering adding other services to our business offerings so that we could generate revenue in ways that were safer. And so we started installing windows and doors as another offering that had different safety hazards, of course, but not the same hot attic exposure.
Peter Koch: [00:37:34] But again, another really innovative way of seeing an exposure and knowing that no matter what happens, you're still going to have some times where you, you really shouldn't be in the attic. You shouldn't expose employees to that for a multitude of reasons. One is safety. And then Brian said, the other one that, you know, if you continue to expose people to that kind of environment, they might find another place to go. So looking at safety [00:38:00] as the impetus of saying, Hey, here's the boundary that we have to work within. And if we come up against that boundary and it's not going to be functional for us to go beyond that, but it's going to restrict our productivity or our quality, we have to find something else. So again, another great way of looking at safety as being an innovator to move you to different product lines, different ways to make the business grow and stepped you up into a place where, you know, maybe 10 or 15 years ago, you didn't expect to be there. So just another market, another place for you. So let's think about just safety and other ways that as a small business, you are able to move that safety needle because again, you're balancing safety quality. Productivity, you have incorporated safety really into the business, it's not just an add on or something that gets checked [00:39:00] off as a box, but it's something that you live and breathe. You still need to draw on different resources in order to help move that safety needle. So what are some different resources that you draw on a regular basis to help your employees stay safe?
Brian Schortz: [00:39:15] Most recently, six months ago, we found that there was another a company that was very similar to Evergreen at one point in their history, a home performance company doing similar work out of New York state. They had received a lot of a lot of funding to really put high level systems together. And so they developed a really incredible library of video safety best practices that were applicable to our industry. So we ended up purchasing kind of their system that group's plan and been very, you know, it's been very beneficial in that in [00:40:00] the past and we had a ladder safety or an electrical safety. It was, you know, could be very some of the videos that went along with it were instructing me, you know, but not they weren't our industry. These videos actually speak to the hazards that folks in this actual industry in similar housing stock are going to encounter on a day to day basis. So we found it really having that resource has been a great tool. You know, it's been much more it's just been much more effective. If you're spending, you know, an hour and you're in a safety training, it's much more targeted and real world, you know, real experiences that these folks are going to encounter on the job. So that's one example.
Peter Koch: [00:40:48] That's a great example. Always looking for different resources, which is which is excellent to not just think that you have all the answers yourself, but look outside and see what other organizations can help you with that.
Elise Brown: [00:41:00] Well, [00:41:00] when I first started working on building a company safety program, so it was really hard to know where to start because you can look up all the different OSHA regulations and just tear your hair out and trying to interpret how they apply to your business. And that can be maddening. I called upon safety works quite a lot. That's the training and education arm of the Maine Department of Labor. Those consultants were really friendly, helpful. I had them come out and do a number of site visits so they'd come right to the site and we'd just poke around and get all kinds of ideas. But then we also had some really specific questions like we didn't understand what the requirements were for our folks who were applying spray foam product in a space, and we didn't understand what was going to be required in terms of their respiratory protection. So they were able to come in and do some air monitoring for us at no cost. [00:42:00] And that was really helpful because then we took those results and we could develop a safety program tailored to our needs. And after using safety works, you know, then really started developing a close working relationship with Randy Klatt. He's our guy at MEMIC our safety management consultant and using him as a resource, you know, we'd come up against something and not be sure. So we'd ask for his guidance or if we had an accident, you know, just try to reach out to him and have him help us think through how we might do it differently to prevent that happening again.
Peter Koch: [00:42:40] That's excellent. And I think safety works is an underutilized resource here in Maine. And I know so there's people across the country listening to this podcast. Just about every state has a safety works within their state, so it's the educational arm of their Department of Labor that will be able to go and do different [00:43:00] things for them, whether it's an exposure, specific training or, like you said, the air quality monitoring or the air monitoring that they're doing and that when we think about respirators and Brian, you talked about that at the very beginning as one of the things you discuss at hire about. Are you willing and able to wear a respirator or shave to wear a respirator, to be able to go back to the data and say this is why we're wearing a respirator, not just because we think you should wear a respirator, but here's the product. Here's the space. Here's the concentration. Here's the type of respirator. Here's the cartridge. Here's the change out schedule. Here's all this stuff that you need goes a long way to make that employee feel comfortable and confident in the methods and the resources that the employer is putting forth. So that's fantastic to tap into a resource like that. And then the resource of your insurance carrier like MEMIC is [00:44:00] relatively unique. But we are not the only insurance carrier that has lost control or safety management consultants out there. So you know, if you're insured with MEMIC, give us a call if you've got a question from a safety standpoint and. If you're not insured with MEMIC, you know, call your carrier and see if you do have some safety resources that you could tap into. You might be surprised of the amount of experience that your carrier can bring to the table for you.
Brian Schortz: [00:44:29] To your point earlier about making people feel comfortable and part of our orientation is very it can be a little scary. You know, we're talking about lead. We're talking, you know, exposures to lead, we're talking about potential exposures to asbestos. And, you know, do we find that every day? No, we find it very rarely. But the point being that, you know, when you're telling someone that they may encounter asbestos [00:45:00] and you know, these are, you know, folks are not kind of hardened tradespeople that, you know, have seen this and heard about asbestos their whole lives. These are some, you know, folks that are new to the trade, perhaps. And you know, it's a scary, you say asbestos and that's scary to someone. So if you can let them know that you know they'll be wearing a respirator, that's appropriate so that if there is a discovery and unexpected discovery that day that they've been protected, you know, they've got the right respirator for the conditions and we're not going to once we find it, you know, that's kind of a job stopper for us. We back out. But the fact that you've had that rescue, you'll be wearing the appropriate respiratory protection really goes a long way and not scaring people away from the job.
Peter Koch: [00:45:48] I think that's another underrated tool that small businesses don't take advantage of. And then you said it's orientation, and I've been through many different types [00:46:00] of orientations, been part of presenting an orientations, receiving orientations from the whole, the whole gambit from those that are really just kind of checking the box to make sure that people are quote unquote oriented to the job and others like yourselves that are actually taking the time to let people know what the exposures are, what the hazards are, what the expectations are and then what is going to happen if they do encounter something. So what are these? What are those expectations? And that's a powerful part of the orientation process that we miss. So let me just ask you this question on orientation overall. So when you're orienting a new person, how much time does that new person, how much time do you spend with that new person in orientation from the time that they're hired, to the time that you consider them to be oriented enough to be competent on the job?
Elise Brown: [00:46:54] One of the things that I found so interesting is a couple of years ago, we [00:47:00] asked Randy, our safety management consultant, if he could go through our particular data on accidents and injuries and give a report over the years of what had happened for our business. And the amazing thing it was like an inverted bell curve. And so we had the highest number of injuries with new people and then it would go way down. And so our hires who had been with us say from one year to six year years had relatively few injuries. And then the folks who'd been with us a long time started to get more injuries. That was really illuminating for me. And so from an orientation perspective, it became apparent that really the first three months are not about productivity at all. It's really about getting oriented to the safety culture, the safety program and the safety mechanics and habits. And so right at the get go, you know, we're talking about safety as the [00:48:00] primary focus. And for a business like ours where you're in strange spaces, where you're not just standing on a flat floor all day, but you're in attics or crawling in a basement, really just focusing on a presence of mind, you know, really being oriented in time and space is a really critical function in being able to be safe in those environments. So we just kind of start hammering that and we started doing that in a new and a different way. And it was thanks to that graph that really got me fired up to make that such an important part of our beginning with any new employee.
Peter Koch: [00:48:37] Yeah, that injury data can be very enlightening and it's something that I think we miss like we don't know many businesses tend to treat the injuries kind of separate from other data that their business takes in to use to evaluate what those steps they need to take to be successful. And I would I would imagine that if [00:49:00] a business decided to pull their injury history for the last, however many years that they would find if they looked at it in the same light that you looked at it from how long someone had been employed with you, that they would find a similar bell curve. We do find statistically overall when we look at MEMIC data aggregated that we do find there's a predominance of new employees being injured, and so that goes depending on the seasonality of your business. That new employee could be, you know, six months in or three years in as a new employee. And then it'll peter off. You know, you won't have so many injuries as people understand the exposures and the controls that are out there. And then you'll see it to start to increase on the other end as people get very comfortable with those exposures. And they forget, I love the way you put it, Elise the presence of mind. When you're in a space, how do you get people to have presence of mind? Can I can [00:50:00] I throw that odd question out at you? Like that's do you have a way to really help people keep their presence of mind when they are in a space where there are different exposures?
Elise Brown: [00:50:12] I think it comes back to the work culture. I think it comes back to, you know, creating a work environment that doesn't feel so rushed where people feel cared for, where it's a friendly environment. You know, it's amazing how much those kinds of factors help remove distractions or pressures that take your focus away. And, you know, if people are relatively happy and like the people they're with, they're, you know, they're not going to just be angry and thrashing around or just trying to hurry through the day. So I don't have any magic answer. I really don't know. But like we hear from our folks that they appreciate the friendliness and how accepted [00:51:00] they are just on a very human level. I don't know if that answers your question, but I think it would help.
Peter Koch: [00:51:07] Yeah, no, I definitely do. And I think it adds to the comments that you were both making before about the importance of your middle management group because I think that's the group that sets the stage for that presence of mind within the job site, at the job site. So Brian, when you go on to the job site and you, you know, you're working with that management team, you're bringing that presence of mind to them, they're bringing that presence of mind to the staff that are working there. So it's a key thing. I'm not sure that you can teach it, but I think you have to be the example and have people emulate that.
Brian Schortz: [00:51:51] We're not creating best practices in the office. We're hearing from the people that are doing the work. And you know, they're often [00:52:00] the people that are innovating for our business. They're innovating, you know, best practices, some of the safety, you know, some of the safety practices that ultimately they want to go home at the end of the day, you know, with what they started with and no more, no less as well, you know, in terms of their bodies. So I mean, you know, we're hearing about things that aren't safe. You know, they'd like to see different, and we also there's an example of this past safety training in our sales team. So we, you know, we'll break up our groups and we'll have different departments and the sales team. We did a ladder safety training and honestly, they use ladders the least of our groups. And so in a little ways, you know, it was an hour's worth of ladder training videos that, you know, they may have felt wasn't, you know, the best use of their time. But I want it to be phrased it in a way that was that they need to understand the company. You know what we do [00:53:00] as a company and what the safety goals of the company is so that if they're out on a job site, they see the ladder is being used inappropriately. They've got the opportunity to be an intervenor. Tap someone on the shoulder and kind of gently say, Let's maybe we should reconfigure this. Not that's not the way that wants to be used. And I actually got feedback from one of the salespeople. He was at a job site this past week. And you know, part of that message was it's your job to say something. It's not like we're teaching you this. It's your responsibility to say something when you see something. And you know, we teach on saying it respectfully and not, you know, we're not the Hammer Company, you know, we really try to say things in an appropriate way. But one of the salespeople came back and said, Well, I was at a job site today and they had us all out and they didn't have to stand for it. So they had it on these rickety, rickety set up. And he said, I went over and said, Rick, I [00:54:00] was told to tell you, this is like, that's not the right way to do this, you know, in our training. And you know, let's can I get you a stand like, what do you need here? Do you need do you need the stand? Where's the stand? You know, I can get. And they hadn't. When they bought the saw, the stand was back ordered, and I think they never they just never end up getting around to it. But it was, you know, it was purposely given to me as, you know, look what I did. I helped, you know, I was listening to you. You know, it really was wasn't about a ladder. It was about something else. And they took it seriously. So it was great.
Peter Koch: [00:54:37] I think that's a great example.
Elise Brown: [00:54:39] Here's another example of presence of mind, you know, sort of indirectly, Peter, and that is, is that, you know, because Brian and I guess evergreens tried to cultivate, you know, a good relationship with the site supervisors. And we have pretty tight teams that work together frequently. They know one another. And so a site supervisor might call [00:55:00] Brian and say, you know, Joey seems a little off today. He seems distracted or tired or I know he's had a hard time at home, so I'm not putting him on the tough job today. You know, I'm going to have him do something else, and that really is good hazard management because you know, why put a worker, you know, is kind of stressed in a position where something's more likely to go wrong. So those are, you know, some examples of how a workplace culture can really avert something going really wrong just because you know the people and you're not going to just make them do it because they're supposed to
Peter Koch: [00:55:34] Right that that trust in the culture that you know the has got your back. My fellow colleague employees got my back, my supervisors got my back. So it's all about it's all about success. And it's not like realization. I bet you if you if you did like a company culture survey that try to ferret out what people's attitudes were around, what you're all working for and you're all working [00:56:00] together for the success of each other and ultimately then the company. So I think as I'm hearing that there's a lot of openness within the culture and at the foundation of that, you know, is safety. It's hard to talk about productivity only productivity and get that openness. But there is that compassionate part of safety where there's a moral part of safety. It's not just checking the box for compliant, but that's a moral component of we all have a responsibility of going back home at the end of the day to our family, our friends and our loved ones. That's awesome. So I got a couple more questions and we're getting right towards the end of it. This is one that I don't know that we've talked about in the past, but you brought up the injury trend. So I wanted to ask you because like you said before, you're not perfect. No companies perfect injuries do happen. And even if a company is going to end, it happens more often [00:57:00] than not with small businesses. So I don't have any injuries. Well, I guarantee you that your employee has gone home, injured and just never told you it's going to happen, whether it's a splinter or it's a strain or a sprain or something more significant. And they just never told you and came back to work the next day. No harm, no foul or. They left work and never came back because they got injured, so when there is an injury at your company. After all, the reporting happens and you care for the employee because I know that's part of your process and you get them the treatment that they need. What do you do around the analysis and trying to prevent that from happening again? What do you do with the information about that injury?
Brian Schortz: [00:57:47] Well, you know, unfortunately, we had an injury a month ago and it was not insubstantial. It was, you know, was a fairly painful injury and some lost time. Not significant lost [00:58:00] time, but more pain and more pain and suffering than the last time. But. And you know, this is a struggle, you know, to try to get to, you know, very good at reporting it and staying on top of, you know, requirements and then getting back and figuring out, you know, we do a hazard analysis, you know, we kind of go and do that, do that, dig in. And it's often there's nothing all that, you know, this is not that complicated. We use the wrong tool for the wrong, the wrong job. And we realized it, you know, during the during the job that we just kind of put our head down and kept plowing through it and didn't happen to be a site supervisor, you know, on site that day. And, you know, maybe it might have been different, you know, had there been someone, you know, someone at that level on site. But when you don't take the time you realize you've you don't have the right tool on site that day, the cost of not going back to the shop was significantly less [00:59:00] than the cost of the physical pain. And you know that this person went through by getting hit in the face with a drill that got seized up on a wall. So it's just really getting back to folks and letting them know now that no one had bad intentions there. You know, the intention was they had no, they didn't think anything bad would come of it, but ultimately they also knew that it wasn't the primary tool for the job. So just letting them know that's not the right answer and that we're all here to support. If they're 30 minutes away, they call the office, someone can bring them the right tool if they can't get back there. It's just making sure that they know there are options or not firewalled into just walking straight ahead. Straight ahead all the time.
Elise Brown: [00:59:50] One thing I'd like to add to that is as a system oriented person, I always think about, Well, how can we make this different so that it's less [01:00:00] likely to happen? And you know, when you think of human nature, it's so hard to stop, you know, people just want to keep going. So I when an accident like that happens, you know, I really want to understand and help communicate to the crew, you know, the steps they can take to help prevent it. But then I want to take it back, you know, a few steps back in the process and think, how can we make it even less likely that it would even be an option to occur? So, you know, for me, it's like, do we need more of those tools available? Do we need a different packing system? So it's always on the truck? You know, what are those kinds of steps that happen five, six, seven, 10 steps prior to even, you know, being standing at the wall using the drill in the first place? So it does take a willingness to look at a lot of different layers. And that's really hard to do when you're a small business and you're just trying to stay afloat. And sometimes we succeed [01:01:00] and really, you know, digging to the bottom of it and sometimes the best we do is put some ointment and a Band-Aid on and hope. I hope we get the time to really look deeply. A little later on. And that's a hard thing to be honest about. I think sometimes
Peter Koch: [01:01:19] You're both right on the money, and I love that you really described a progression that many businesses go through. Some stay at the we've reported it. We've taken care of the employee and it's done. Some take the next step, take that data and bring it back to the employee to recognize that the tool wasn't used correctly. And then there's the next step of looking at it, as there was a decision that was made to not use the tool correctly and then the decision to not go back and get the right tool. And then finally, that that next step or that downstream step of how do you integrate the solution of using [01:02:00] the right tool or having the right tool available or eliminating the decision back to the systems process? And that's a really great progression. And you hit the nail on the head super hard to do and super hard to do. Whether you are a small business, small business owner, a medium business or you're an enormous business, there's just. Different challenges that come up because an enormous business in order to change a system could take an act of Congress where the benefit that you have of a smaller group, you can actually tweak the system in order to make a more reasonable or a reasonable change in a small amount of time. So there is benefits on both sides. One might have more resources and as a small business, you're a lot more agile to make to make better decisions as or change decisions to go forward. So great. Great example, and I appreciate you just taking the time to explain that process to us and be a little vulnerable there. You know, I asked you a [01:03:00] pretty challenging question around, you know, what are your injuries? And it's never easy to admit that, yeah, they happen to us too. But they do. They do happen. All right. So I got one more question and this will go to both of you guys. So what's the one thing that you know now about workplace safety that you wish you would have known when you started out?
Brian Schortz: [01:03:23] I was thinking about this earlier today. Not directly, but I was thinking about what makes someone who's in the safety role of an organization potentially successful and assuming a lot of other things being there, is, you know, finding someone who has the passion for safety. You know, I found that when Elise joined Evergreen, she came in, you know, with a zeal, you know, and a concern and a focus, you know, about safety that you know that frankly, I cared about people and I, you know, we had that caring culture, [01:04:00] you know, really wasn't it didn't focus on the safety side of it the same way. And Elise, such a passion and kind of a drive for it that that allows, you know, the business to really to strive in that level. So putting someone, you know, trying to match up a skill set with that, you know, with someone that's in charge of safety that truly has a passion that cares about it. And you know, I think is part of making a program that will be vibrant.
Peter Koch: [01:04:31] Yeah, passion is a huge part. And you know, I wish I had recognized that when I was first starting out, that safety is not just all about the data. There's a lot of personal drive and commitment that's going to make it successful. So great. Thank you for that insight, Brian. Elise, what about you? What's the one thing that you wish you had known when you started out about workplace safety?
Elise Brown: [01:04:55] Well, I gave my answer away already when I talked about the nice curve [01:05:00] that Randy gave us with our data. But here is another thing, and that is that I wish I had understood better how much mental health is such a critical part of safety. And COVID has just made it altogether clear that workplace safety is every bit as centered around mental health as it is around physical health and safety. I think that would have been beneficial for us had we realized and incorporated that sooner.
Peter Koch: [01:05:31] Yeah. So can I follow up on that a little bit? I think we've talked about a number of threads throughout this podcast around that will address mental health. But so what are some of the learnings that COVID has brought up that you've implemented to help employees with that mental health that would pay dividends in safety later on?
Elise Brown: [01:05:50] I don't think we have the answers yet. I think this is all pretty new territory. But you know, I think as a small, sort of family oriented [01:06:00] company, we've always understood that, you know, people's personal lives matter and that you kind of bring a certain amount of your mental equilibrium or lack thereof to work on a daily basis. But the stresses of COVID, you know, really brought out that some people have a lot of instability at home and that that can have an effect on the team esprit de corps. It can have an effect on how patient people are and how willing they are to proceed cautiously. You know, it can make people maybe drive more erratically. Who knows? You know, there are all kinds of ways in which mental health stress can make it harder for a company's safety culture to be successful. And so, you know, just kind of trying to create a place where we're much more aware of that and we're kind of got our radar, you know, kind of out to sense how people [01:07:00] are doing from a mental standpoint so that we can maybe talk to the supervisors or help them. I mean, they're not immune, either, you know, it's a big thing and we don't know yet. We're really at the very beginning of learning about this.
Brian Schortz: [01:07:15] And that's a whole other podcast.
Peter Koch: [01:07:16] Good. All right. We'll talk about that maybe in a few months when we get some learning, but I think the awareness that's a really insightful again, another really insightful part that mental health has a lot to do with the success of your safety program. And when I think about safety is being the foundation of what you build, your productivity and quality on mental health and the ability of the person to really understand the impact of their choices on their safety. And then especially when you're working in a tight space with a couple other team members, somebody else's safety. That's huge. And so recognizing that if my mental health isn't where it needs to be, if [01:08:00] I'm not focused on what my job steps are, I could easily put somebody else at substantial risk for injury, especially working in a tight space and with some of the hazards that you guys have to manage on the job.
Elise Brown: [01:08:13] Here's a quick example. Brian Schortz, you said this to me just the other day, he said. I realize that I have to come to any kind of meeting, you know, with a certain amount of confidence and convey that to people because it really impacts people. And when you think about COVID, you know, when we were trying to figure out our protocols for how we work in homes, you know, we wanted to be really upfront and convey the exposures and the risks and be very clear about what the hazards were. But at the same time, we had to convey confidence that we could manage this. We were all in it together. You know, there was a way to be safe and still be productive, you know, so that we didn't create more stress in their lives. But, you know, give them a path [01:09:00] where they could feel successful, feel safe and feel confident that they could earn a living and not bring some illness home to their family. So it's tricky.
Peter Koch: [01:09:10] Yeah, it is tricky. And I don't think just from our conversations today and just previous to this, I don't think you could have been successful in that conversation had you not laid the groundwork for the open communication, for the support, for the understanding of the employees about that. Yeah, the company's got my back. So I trust them because that's really essentially what you're talking about, that confidence. You can come up with confidence. You can be falsely confident in front of a group of people and they will smell you out like a 10 day old rat and that won't go well and won't go well at all. So you not only have to be confident, but you have to be genuinely confident. And that comes from all the prep work that you've done for all these years of building the company and building [01:10:00] the safety culture through a lot of trial and error. I mean, you've said it from the beginning that, you know, you're not perfect and this is it's a process of becoming not just a statement of being right. Well, we are right here at the end of our podcast. Believe it or not, it's been a little over an hour. It's gone by pretty fast, but a fantastic conversation with you guys. Thank you very much for sharing your expertise with us or myself and all of our listeners out there. So thanks for that.
Elise Brown: [01:10:28] Thank you, Peter, for the opportunity. It's always humbling to talk about safety because it's always a work in progress and it's so easy to focus on the failures. But the conversation has helped get me excited about some next steps for Evergreen. So thanks a lot. Awesome.
Peter Koch: [01:10:45] Appreciate that. So where can our where can our listeners find out more about Evergreen Home Performance? If they are interested in more about that or about who your company is and what they do? Where can they find out more about you?
Brian Schortz: [01:10:57] Well, you know, we have a YouTube [01:11:00] channel that's Evergreen Home Performance, and there's a YouTube channel which talks about the exciting career opportunities that evergreen straight from the, you know, straight from the employees mouths. It's not something that we helped put the put it together, but this is all their own dialogue and, you know. Some good ideas about what it would be like to work in evergreen. And you know, our website, Elise for, you know, for us all to look at Evergreen as a business is where should folks go
Elise Brown: [01:11:31] And visit us at WWW.Evergreenyourhome.com Or visit us on our Facebook page. Evergreen Home Performance
Peter Koch: [01:11:39] Perfect. And we'll put those links into the show notes so people can grab those and they just have to write them down when they're listening, because that's not good if you're listening while you're driving. So we'll put them in the show notes for you guys. So thank you again for joining us and then to all of our listeners out there. Thank you so much for sticking with us today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast. We've been speaking about [01:12:00] safety leadership in a small business with Elise Brown and Brian Schortz from Evergreen Home Performance. If you have any questions about safety leadership, or would you like to hear more about our particular topic on our podcast? Email me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/ 56podcast, where you can find a. Additional resources, links to other podcasts, as well as our entire podcast archive, and while you're there, sign up for our safety net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates. If you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it. If you took a minute or two to subscribe and review us on Spotify, iTunes or whichever podcast service that you found us on. If you've already done that, thank you. Thank you very much because it really helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing the show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support and until next time. This is Peter Koch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts [01:13:00] podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.
According to BLS data, workplace fatalities from falls to a lower level were up from 615 on 2018 to 711 in 2019.
Fall hazard exposures exist in almost every industry and finding the right fall protection solution for you' your situation is not always easy. There are many factors that should go into choosing the best fall prevention method, especially when it comes to fall protection on roofs.
On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, I speak with David Kozlowsky, President and Owner of Safe Approach in Poland, Maine about fall protection requirements for roofs.
Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch. There are fall hazards in almost every industry or business, and personally, whether it's scaffolding, ladders, anchors, fall protection, arrest systems, rope access rescue or fall protection training and education, that all makes up a significant part of what I do with the businesses that I serve. And today we're going to talk about falls and specifically falls from a height and even more specifically, fall exposures while you're on a roof. So before we get into that recently, I got the chance to talk to one of my friends, who's another safety professional in a different area of the country. And we got to talking about fall protection and the excuses or reasons that workers and business owners have given us for why they don't or won't use fall protection on their job sites. So here are some of the ones that we've had in common, and I bet you you'll find some of [00:01:00] these are actually pretty familiar to you. If you're a safety professional and if you're a business owner, maybe you've used one of them yourself. I know before I got to be a safety professional, I've used a number of these to make an excuse of why I'm not or won't use fall protection. So the first one that came up, which was, I think, one of the more common ones, it's way too time consuming to set it all up. I can get the job done and half the time. If I can just get on the roof and do my roofing work, that's the first one, too time consuming. It gets in the way you talk to workers all the time that they're on the roof you have the rope gets in the way, the guardrails get in the way it just gets in the way. Another one is it makes me feel less safe. So the ropes are a tripping hazard. And honestly, I think maybe the pneumatic hoses are probably more of a tripping hazard than the lifelines, but it's all perception. So it makes me feel less safe. It limits what I can do. It's uncomfortable, and I totally get that. If you're in a harness all day long [00:02:00] on a roof, you've got enough discomfort up there from the environment and the pitch that you're on and everything else. So the harness can add a little discomfort to it. But again, it's an excuse, so it causes more of a hazard. Getting back to that makes me feel less safe. It doesn't add value to the job, so we quantify that one is it just costs too much. I can't bid successfully for a job against the guy down the road. He's not using fall protection. If I bid the job with fall protection, it's going to cost me way too much. I won't get the job. Another excuse that my friend and I have heard often is when I did buy it, my employees didn't use it, so I stopped buying it and asking them to use it. So they just kind of gave up instead of powering through and making it an initiative and part of the culture. But again, there's the excuse I'm only going to be up there for a minute. I can't tell you how many times I've heard that particular excuse, and more often I've [00:03:00] heard that excuse during an investigation or an analysis of why the fall occurred. So I'm going to a client and we're talking to them about why this person got significantly injured, falling off the roof, the ladder, the whatever it was. And the answer is, well, they were only going to be up there for a minute. I didn't think I needed to set up all of the fall protection. Another one, which is interesting because it's all about perception. Again, I've never used it before and I'm really comfortable working at height or being up on the roof. So my comfort level is driving the non need, I guess, for fall protection. Another interesting one is what we are using fall protection and I'm talking to the business owner and he's pointing up to the roof where his roofers are on roofing planks instead of actually a fall protection system. So that's not fall protection. We'll get into that as we talk through this in the podcast. And this last one probably was my most favorite. And it's more than just a statement. It's a couple [00:04:00] of statements. So bear with me here. So when I was asking this individual about fall protection on the job site, the answer was, Well, we have a safety monitor and that's all we need. Because for roofing, there is an accommodation there to use a safety monitor under very specific conditions. But his answer was we have a safety monitor. That's all we need. And he was saying this while he's pointing to one of the workers who was on the ground shoveling shingles from the ground of the dump trailer. But he was in an orange vest so that designated him as the safety monitor. But his buddies or the other workers were up actually stripping the roof on a 10 12 pitch. So the safety monitor was doing something else while the guys were up stripping the roof. And while I looked at him, the follow up to that was from the guy was, well, he's only there for a few minutes because he needs to stay ahead for the cleanup. And while the other guys are at the peak, he doesn't need to pay attention as much. He'll pay more attention when they get closer to [00:05:00] the edge. Like, OK, fine. Excellent. So all of those are different excuses, you'll hear them all over the place, but none of them really help you because there's a lot of stats out there that really drive the need for fall protection, and you can talk to anyone who has taken a fall off a roof or off a ladder, and I'll bet you that they wish that they had done something a little bit different, so they didn't have an event that changed their life. So if we look just at the stats, according to BLS data, fatal falls from roofs accounted for seven hundred and sixty two of the three thousand seven hundred and twenty two fatal falls between 2011 and two thousand sixteen. And that's just fatal falls. That's not all of the other types of fatal injuries that happened in the workplace. Those are just fatal falls back to 2016. And if we look specifically at roofing and some more current data in 2019 roofers accounted [00:06:00] for 111 of the five thousand three hundred thirty three fatal injuries. And that's just in one year, and it's up 15 percent from 2018. And the BLS data also shows that roofers have a fatal injury rate of fifty four fatal injuries per one hundred thousand workers. All right, so fifty four per one hundred thousand doesn't seem like a lot. Well, I guess to me as a safety consultant or just as a human, fifty four people dying on the job is a big number, regardless of how many workers you're comparing it to. But let's add some different perspective to that. So the average fatality rate across all industries, regardless of what the industries are, is three point five per one hundred thousand workers. So that makes the rate for roofing 15 times higher than the average. And it's only preceded by fishing, logging and pilots or flight engineers with a higher [00:07:00] fatality rate. And while those industries logging fishing in flight engineers have a myriad of different exposures that could cause fatalities and a significantly more limited set of choices for controlling the exposures, roofing fatalities come almost exclusively from falls and fall protection or prevention, or excuse me, roofing fatalities come almost exclusively from falls and then fall protection and prevention technology has really exploded over the last 10 or 15 years, and there's been a huge increase in what's available to the person working on a roof. So to help us explore fall protection and how it applies to roofing and tearing down some of those stats and maybe giving you some better ideas about what to do when you're on a roof, is David Kozlowski, president and owner of Safe Approach right here in Poland, Maine. So, led by David Safe Approach's team designs and builds fall protection equipment from harnesses, [00:08:00] anchors and lifelines to safety netting and custom fall protection worksite solutions. Over the years, they've developed some really creative fall prevention solutions for a variety of different industries. So David, you were on the podcast back in March of two thousand twenty one talking to us about the basics of fall protection. Welcome back today, and I'm glad to have you to talk about some more specifics.
David Kozlowsky: [00:08:24] Peter, thanks. And thanks for having me back. It was a lot of fun last time and hopefully people got something out of it. And hopefully I can give you some good information that people can take back to their places of employment and help them implement safer work practices.
Peter Koch: [00:08:43] Oh, I'm sure they will. There's a lot of great information on the other podcast. We talked about the hierarchy of controls and different types of fall protection and fall prevention that were out there and when to apply it. And I know we were talking before the podcast about how prevalent roofing [00:09:00] exposures or working on a roof. It doesn't have to be roof work, but working on a roof is. And just the other day I was driving down my road and two property owners were actually standing on the peak of the roof, installing a chimney lining. So there was not a stitch of fall protection. Well, let me tell you, the only fall protection was in my car driving past them. It wasn't anywhere on the roof, and you made the comment to me that you spend the majority well, quite a bit of your time having conversations with different clients about fall protection for roofs because it can get a little bit confusing, I guess.
David Kozlowsky: [00:09:39] Well, all the reasons that you gave earlier are still very prevalent. I mean, I spend a lot of time in my truck driving around, and I can't tell you how many residential roofing projects that I drive by where I still see them not wearing fall protection. Even though the exemption was removed many years ago, [00:10:00] they still aren't wearing it or. I'll see them wearing their harnesses, but knowing what to look for, I can clearly see that they aren't connected to anything, so I think they often put them on. So at a quick glance, somebody driving by might think, Oh, there they are, they're wearing their fall protection, but it's not actually connected to anything. And I see it, you know, so often they still a lot of them, for all the reasons that you gave, are very resistant to it. And I don't think it's really going to change until we can help change the attitudes in the hearts and minds of the people that are actually there to be protected. If they don't want to protect themselves, it's really hard to overcome that mountain.
Peter Koch: [00:10:42] Yeah, it really is. And if you've never fallen off a roof or had an injury like that, it can be difficult to understand why you need it. Because some of those some of the comments that were made to resist fall protection are the reasons [00:11:00] why I'm not using it are actually valid. I mean, they can be uncomfortable. They can, if you're used to not having vertical lifelines and something else on the roof and you're just used to having a naked roof that you're on maintaining or re-shingling or putting new roof material on it. It does get in the way. It's a change. It changes your workflow and work process.
David Kozlowsky: [00:11:26] Well, all of those all of those excuses are basically variations of the one single most common excuse, which is not just used in roofing, I've seen it with confined space training with all kinds of other types of injuries that can happen not just fall protection. They're all variations of the same basic excuse, which is I've been doing this job for insert number here a number of years and I've never had a fall, so [00:12:00] I don't feel that I need it. And I've heard that excuse in rooftop safety and confined space safety and all kinds of industrial safety applications where people just don't think they need it. I've been doing this job for 30 years and I've never even had a close call. Why do I need to do this different thing now to protect myself? And it all goes back to what you just said. If you've never fallen off a roof or if you've never got your hand caught in the machine or, you know, you've never tripped and fell into a hole or never been run over by a truck. You don't think that you need those protections. I mean, again, it's the attitude of the user is trying to overcome the attitude that you don't need it. And once you overcome that mountain, I think people will get a lot more receptive to it.
Peter Koch: [00:12:51] Yeah, I'll relate a quick story. I have a good friend of mine that I worked with in a previous industry, and he and [00:13:00] I share a love of climbing. So he's got a great climbing background. And after we had a downsize at the company that I was working at, he actually went to go work for a local roofing contractor, and he actually brought that skill sets and understanding of not just fall prevention and fall protection, but actually if he's going to be setting up aide climbing or setting up protection on a rock face someplace. He wants to be able to work with both of his hands. So he sets up positioning. And so he brought a lot of that information to the company. And interestingly enough, when I got to work for MEMIC, he was one of or at that company was one of the first companies that I was assigned to from a construction standpoint, and I met him again on the job and I was looking at what he was doing and he had taken a lot of that thought process of, look, I get it. You know, from a fall standpoint, this is really not a whole lot different than if I'm climbing [00:14:00] somewhere in the wilderness. I can use that same technology to make my job actually a little bit easier to be able to feel comfortable. I mean, if you're installing metal roofing panels someplace, it's hot, it's reflective, it's slippery. Why can't you set up a system that will allow you to actually work more effectively right in there so it can be done? It totally can be done,
David Kozlowsky: [00:14:24] And you just hit the nail right on the head. Most of the reasons why people don't want to use it is effectiveness of the fall protection. It's, you know, it doesn't. It doesn't do any good to set up a system that's technically quote unquote compliant that it doesn't work well. And I literally just this week went to look at a client who was looking to. They just had 11 ladder climb systems installed on some silos. So they had silos with these ladders and somebody [00:15:00] came in and said, you. Need to put climb systems on these, they installed it and the employees were complaining, so when I got there, the argument was is these aren't compliant? Well, I went and looked at them and they were. Everything was as it should be. But the ladders were too narrow and they had installed them, you know, in the center of the climb. And there was it was when I climbed the ladder, I found that it was extremely difficult to get between the ladder climb system and to step through and get on to the top of the tank. Very difficult. And when I came down, I said, I have to agree with the employees. This system is compliant. But it really isn't set up to be very effective. And so they were hoping that I could come in and figure out a way to modify and change or provide something new that would be a little bit more seamlessly integrated [00:16:00] into what they had and make it not just compliant but actually usable so that the workers felt safe and felt better using it. And you know, that's one of the other big things, especially with roofing is you were talking about in the beginning is not just the culture or the attitude, but you know, there is a certain amount of it that is cumbersome. It does get in the way, it's not easy and we haven't invented the perfect integrated seamless system yet. So, you know, we kind of have to work around that a little bit, but you can try to do things to make it as effective as you can and as seamless as you can with what's available out there.
Peter Koch: [00:16:41] Cool. So we'll definitely get into that because I think that's a great discussion about what would be effective. And it's going to depend on the environment, the work that you're doing, the skill set of the people that you're going to have always it's going to have some price component to it. So because you know, you can always you can look to get the Cadillac or [00:17:00] you can look to get the jalopy one of the two regardless of what you have. If it is compliant, it definitely needs to fit within the work that you're doing to keep it effective because there's always that balance. We talked about this last time between safety, productivity and the quality of the work that you're doing. And if those aren't in balance, then something's not going to work well. And I think in the case of the silos, right, they focused on the safety component, but they missed the productivity and the quality component like you can't,
David Kozlowsky: [00:17:31] Right?
Peter Koch: [00:17:32] It wasn't functional for the work that they were doing.
David Kozlowsky: [00:17:36] Right. And that becomes that's going to become plainly evident when we start talking about low slope roofs, because that's one area where there really is a vast difference between, you know, effectiveness and costs in some cases and the seamless integration on the on the flat roofs.
Peter Koch: [00:17:53] Yeah, very true. All right. Awesome. So let's jump in and talk a little bit about the requirement so that OSHA has a duty [00:18:00] for fall protection and it's both it's a little different in construction and general industry. So could you talk a little bit about what OSHA requires for fall protection in the construction industry and in general industry?
David Kozlowsky: [00:18:15] Sure. Well, there's obviously a million different areas we could touch on, but sitting in fall protection and kind of talking about roofs and kind of narrowing it down a little bit. You know, the major differences are construction. The construction standard has a different kind of set of rules for construction operations or the act of roofing, whereas the general industry standard does not, the general industry standard has a set of rules that apply to all. I get this question a lot. If you know John Smith works for XYZ Company and he's up there patching a roof, isn't he in, you know, roofing operations? So his standards [00:19:00] are different, and that is not true because he's not a roofer in the act of roofing. He's still under general industry. I get that question a lot. So the biggest difference is that in for most of your clients that are not construction related clients, they should be following 19 ten and not nineteen twenty six. They should be following the general industry standard. There's a slight difference in the height standard general industry as a four foot rule, construction has a six foot rule for most applications and some slightly different ones for connecting steel and some other things. But across the board, mostly it's roughly six feet. So those are the main differences. And then other than that, they both point towards the same standards. If you look at the requirements for safety nets or guardrails or personal fall arrest systems and the loading requirements and all of that, they all point to basically the [00:20:00] same thing. So the quality. Of product that you can use to solve either one is the same, so there's no difference there. And so I think what we're going to do is probably focus maybe a little bit more on the general industry. I guess today it's kind of confusing, but 1910.28 has a lot of information in it. And the construction standard, other than removing the exemption for residential roofers, hasn't that portion subpart M hasn't really changed significantly in the last number of years, so I feel like the listeners are probably pretty well up to speed on that. So maybe we'll focus a little bit more on the general industry.
Peter Koch: [00:20:48] Yeah, I think I think we will. There's a that's a big topic, but before we delve into that, I think it is important to restate that it's been a number of years already since the [00:21:00] fall protection exemption for residential roofing has gone by the wayside. So that is no longer. If you are doing residential roofing, you are required to have fall protection when you are six feet above the ground or a surface above the surface that you're working on.
David Kozlowsky: [00:21:18] Correct.
Peter Koch: [00:21:19] So you got to have it. And there's multiple different ways to do that. And there's some different requirements if you're on a low pitched roof versus a steep pitched roof. And maybe we can spend a moment defining those two things because it gives a different threshold for the level of protection that's necessary.
David Kozlowsky: [00:21:37] I was going to say most of your residential roofing would fall under a steep pitched roof. I know there are some houses built with a low, low, low slope, but most of them would fall under the steep. But OSHA defines the line of demarcation at four 12, four over 12, so four inches of rise and 12 inches of run. If [00:22:00] the roof is four 12 or less, then that's considered a low slope roof. It's walkable, and so the standards and rules are a little bit different. Once you get above four 12, that's a steep slope roof. A lot of the options for steep slope roof go away. A lot of options that you have for low slope go away, it becomes very limited. So on a steep pitched roof, you have basically, for practical reasons, pretty much personal fall arrest systems. You do still have guardrails which are extremely difficult to set up, especially on a residential roof. I've never seen anybody really do it effectively. Safety netting is still an option, but it's not really practical. So for a steep pitched roof, you're mostly limited to a personal fall arrest system, which would include some type of anchor, a connecting device that includes some sort of energy absorbing device [00:23:00] in it. And then your harness the big three.
Peter Koch: [00:23:03] Yeah. And I think for those specifically for like the difference between your guardrail system, which is what you'd normally want to see from an engineering control standpoint for fall protection, you can set up on a steep pitched roof a good system that will prevent you from getting off the roof in the first place or falling off the roof in the first place. So if you slip and fall on the roof and you don't fall off the roof, you're eliminating the need for rescue. You have probably much less significant injuries that will occur if you're on a steep pitched roof, and all you ever do is put guardrails on the bottom and someone takes the big whipper from the peak of the roof. You're probably going through the guardrail because the requirements for guardrails are like we talked about the last time 200 pounds in any direction. If you're a 200 pound guy and you're sliding down the roof, you're hitting that guardrail with a lot more than 200 pounds of force. So you're going to the ground.
David Kozlowsky: [00:23:58] Yeah, so the [00:24:00] options are a little bit more limited as far as tying off on a steep pitched roof. There really is very little reason or excuse in today's day and age why you can't other than making excuses about it being too hard or too difficult or too cumbersome. Other than that, there's plenty of product available. I don't care what kind of roof that you're working on. There's probably something out there that's compatible may require a little extra effort or work, but it's definitely there's definitely plenty of product out there that's available for that.
Peter Koch: [00:24:37] Sure. And I think what you're talking about is really the anchorage, right? So that's the bigger challenge for most folks of where and how and what do I use to set up my anchor to connect my lifeline into or my lanyard into? And that becomes somewhat of a challenge. But like you said, there is a myriad of different types [00:25:00] of anchors that can be used. Out there, some which will penetrate the roof and some will not penetrate the roof, even there's plenty of different options out there for you.
David Kozlowsky: [00:25:10] People just need to research what's available for options for residential roofing. There are different ways to set up a system which can make it easier and simpler. One of the biggest problems is rope management. So when you talked about setting up a system so that someone wouldn't fall off the roof, that requires good rope management. And so ninety nine percent of the complaints that you listed for a residential roofers basically center around the rope management so you have your ropes and your grab and you're constantly if you're doing it properly, your rope is almost always in one hand, and whatever you're doing is always in the other because you're always adjusting, especially if you're nailing shingles. Those guys are going back and forth on the roof so much it's almost [00:26:00] impossible to employ effective rope management. If you're not switching Anchorage points or if you don't have different people working in different sections of the roof because rope management can become, you know, dangerous if you're not paying attention to it. So in an effort to have freedom of movement and not get held up, most of these guys will just pay themselves out a bunch of slack behind the rope, grab and the anchor. And so what could potentially happen if someone fell off the roof as you could hit the ground before the rope gets taut, depending on how high the roof is and how much rope you have paid out so you can move around, it's basically you're putting it on for looks, but it has actually no functional value whatsoever. And so to manage that, it is a little bit more difficult a retractable [00:27:00] is a better solution. But there's a lot of people that would disagree with me on that. There's been many case studies done about retractables on pitched roofs and how quickly they lock up and the potential for someone to slide off the roof and actually not engage the retractable because they're not moving fast enough. So it doesn't think they're falling. So that would be ineffective in preventing them from necessarily falling off the side. But it would turn into, you know, a free fall once you went off the side. So there's many different people that have many different arguments on that, and I don't know that there's really necessarily a right answer other than the manufacturer. So you should always go back to the manufacturer if the manufacturer allows the retractable on a pitched roof, you can use it. If the manufacturer says no, then you, then you definitely shouldn't. But rope management is definitely the biggest complaint and the biggest area I see [00:28:00] with problems with roofing. So if we could find a way to make that easier or find ways for companies to plan the jobs to make it a little bit easier for the workers, then that would remove quite a few objections.
Peter Koch: [00:28:16] Yeah, I'm sure that's a big objection that you have and you have a large roof where you have multiple people up there, even if it's just a couple of guys up there and they're crossing paths. It can be challenging just managing your own rope. And then, like you said, making sure that I don't have slack, that my rope grab is always at my anchor or higher. That provides the greatest level of protection for me because as you said, if I pay out enough slack to be able to move anywhere on the rope or anywhere on the roof that I need to without having to manage my rope grab. And I do take a fall. You may hit the ground or if it's high enough, you may not hit the ground, but you pull your anchor out because it's not [00:29:00] designed for the forces that the extended freefall will cause.
David Kozlowsky: [00:29:06] And that's the biggest fear to me and to probably a lot of other people, too, is because, you know, if the product is not being used properly in a lot of cases doesn't really matter. Once the lawsuits start flying around, it very much becomes more about percentages and bean counting and how who, which companies we can get to pay out, how much money, rather than whether or not the person was actually at fault or not. And so that's a big fear to me and to a lot of other people with the roof anchors is, you know, they're only designed to hold a certain amount of load and used properly. They are fine. But as you said, if you're if you don't have or if you have too much rope paid out and you overload the anchor, I mean, it could, you know, it could come off the roof and then we're stuck proving [00:30:00] that. Wasn't the anchor that failed, that it was the usage and that can be that can be difficult sometimes.
Peter Koch: [00:30:06] Very difficult, very, very, very difficult.
David Kozlowsky: [00:30:09] And it behooves employers to pay attention to that too, because, you know, most of these contractors, you know, they leave it up to the employees to, you know, use the fall protection and they don't really pay attention. But I have news for all of them. They're going to get drug into it just as much as anybody else. If an employee falls off a roof and gets injured severely, even to the point of maybe disabled or worse, everybody's getting sued, including them, and they're going to start looking at their safety policies. They're going to start looking at their safety plan. If they have anything written up, they're going to look at the job. Was anybody paying attention to what they were doing and out of sight? Out of mind is not a not a good thing.
Peter Koch: [00:30:56] No, not a good thing at all. And those are some basic requirements that OSHA has [00:31:00] from a compliance standpoint. They require training. They require you to have a plan before you go up on the roof. You're required to have the appropriate equipment for the hazards and exposures that your people have and that they're not exposed before they have training and access to the proper equipment. So those are all parts of the general fall protection requirements that OSHA has, whether it's construction or general industry. I wanted to back up just a second and ask you a question, and this is kind of in setup for a steep pitched roof. And these are this is not going to be a hard and fast piece. But in your experience, as you are looking at a roof or talking to an employee or an employer about setup, how do you assess a steep pitched roof as to where might be the best places to put your anchorages? Are there any recommendations that you would feel comfortable talking about?
David Kozlowsky: [00:31:59] Yeah, so [00:32:00] a lot of it centers around the conditions of the job. So you're going to want to look at the size of the roof and you're going to want to look at, even more importantly, the fall clearance distance between the roof and the ground. There is a lot of fall protection out there that were you to be working and actually fall off the edge, may or may not arrest a fall, especially in residential. I mean, if you're looking at a, let's say, a six 12 pitch on a ranch, you know, a low built ranch on the eve of the roof may only be, you know, 10 feet or even less from grade. And so, you know, if somebody's standing near the leading edge and falls off, I mean, it becomes highly critical that the system was set up and is being used specifically if you even have any hope of arresting that fall before someone falls off. So [00:33:00] a rule of thumb that I try to go by is 15 degrees off perpendicular. So you want to look at your roof and you want to take a measurement on the length of it, and then you want to draw up a perpendicular line from the peak down to the to the eave. And then you want to draw two more lines in a V-shape from the peak at 15 degrees on either side. So you're drawing like a 30 degree window. And so what you want to do is you want to set up enough. If you're going to use a peak anchor and not a line of some sort, you want to set up enough peak anchors so you have the entire edge or eve of the roof covered in those 15 degree windows off perpendicular. That's a good rule of thumb. Number one So it's not really easy to say put one every so many feet or this or that, because depending on the length of the run and the length of the ridge, I mean, those can [00:34:00] all affect, you know, how often you may put one every 12 feet or 10 feet or even six, depending on what's going on. So to say X number of feet doesn't work. The 30 degree window is a much more effective system. And so what that does is that sets up enough anchors so that you can work an area. Your line will not be too far off center, so it gives you a good working area. It helps limit and prevent pendulum falls, so it prevents you from being tied off too far away from the anchor so that if you fall, you don't swing towards perpendicular because that's what's going to happen and then risk impacting something below you or even the ground. And it gives you enough points to have multiple workers up there so that each, you know, we recommend each one takes a zone. I know a lot of these guys like to lay shingles and literally run back and forth the entire length of the roof with the nail gun. [00:35:00] But. With this kind of thing that's really just not that practical. You're going to tangle up your ropes, tangle up your air hoses and tangle up everything, so you have enough anchors that there can be enough guys working their own zones to get that accomplished. So that's kind of a rule of thumb that we use that really helps setting up and then again, management paying attention to the amount of rope between you and the anchorage point.
Peter Koch: [00:35:27] That's great. That's really good advice that 15 degrees off and then have overlapping zones so that you cover the entire roof edge. Good. I think that helps. So let's move from our steep pitch roofs because we'll have another we'll focus on that. Maybe another podcast. But what we really wanted to talk more about is that low pitch, that low sloped roof or a flat roof. And granted, there's a lot of roofs out there, not so much in the new England area from a [00:36:00] residential standpoint, but certainly commercially. There's a ton of flat roofs out there and there are some rules around building or constructing a flat roof that would be covered under the construction standard and some different operations. But once that's done, once it's built, the majority of the time, you're going to have employees or contractors up maintaining either the roof or the HVAC units or the skylights or something else that's up there. So let's talk some more about the low slope or a flat roof and how or what are the what are the standards and how does fall protection enter into managing the exposures around a low pitched roof in general industry?
David Kozlowsky: [00:36:48] Sure. So the first thing is people need the first thing just by way of introduction is that people need to start thinking about their roof as another floor of their building really [00:37:00]. Most people don't. They think about the roof as being out of sight, out of mind. But OSHA considers it another floor of your building. If employees are going up there and doing work, which means all of the same standards that apply to general industry for work inside also apply on the roof. The four foot rule, the unprotected leading edge open floor openings, which would be skylights or roof hatches. I mean, all of those things, it's a walking working surface. And so kind of what they did with 1910.28 I felt like was they included low sloped roof into the walking working surface, integrated much, much more deeply to hopefully help people understand that, you know, unguarded floor openings and edges and whatnot on a roof are the same standard as they are inside your building. So what they did was [00:38:00] they took some of the construction standard and applied it. But then they included a lot of things that are not included in the construction standard. So what I can do if you want is just do a brief overview of what the what the standard basically says. So for low slope roof, for activities on the roof, even if you're patching a roof because you're not actually a roofer in the act of roofing or construction, you're just making a repair, which is maintenance. So even if you're repairing a roof or patching a hole or working on HVAC equipment, that's all wrapped into maintenance of the roof. So OSHA set up three zones now. So the old interpretations of there's no safe distance from the edge and all those vague things are pretty much gone away. They still don't feel there's any safe distance from the edge. However, they have at least now [00:39:00] set up some lines of demarcation and some options from what for what you may or may not do within those areas. So the two lines are six feet and 15 feet is the two distances that you need to remember. So your whole roof area should be protected, and the most dangerous area is area within six feet of the edge. They've highlighted that is obviously the most dangerous. You're the closest to the edge, a trip or a slip, you know, could easily lead to going over the edge. So any work or any activity at all, even if it's just walking and not working any activity at all within six feet of the edge of the roof must have a guardrail, fall arrest, fall restraint, personal fall arrest, a safety net, something. There's a list of things that they put in that you're allowed to do. They mostly center around guardrails, personal fall arrest and safety nets, and then fall restraint also kind of gets lumped into personal [00:40:00] fall arrest. So, but if you're within six feet of the edge, you either need to be tied off one hundred percent of the time to a horizontal lifeline or roof anchors or something, or have a guardrail or a safety net if you're within six feet of the edge. So the next area is what if I'm not quite six feet from the edge, what if I'm just a little bit more than six feet? What do I have to do? So the next line of demarcation is 15 feet. So if you're in a in a zone on the roof, that's between six feet and 15 feet, you have the same options that you had before. You can put a guardrail or you can have a horizontal lifeline or roof anchors or safety netting or some other form of fall protection, but they've also opened up an area of a designated area. So from six feet to 15 feet, if you are up there temporarily and [00:41:00] infrequently, they will allow a designated area. So what is temporary and infrequent? Well, they define it in the preamble. They don't really say it in the standard, but in the 500 page preamble to the standard that they came out with, they kind of they kind of defined temporary as two hours and they define infrequent as monthly. So if you're performing monthly maintenance, you are not up there infrequently. And if you're up there for more than two hours, you're not up there temporarily. So if you have an HVAC unit up there and you only go up twice a year to replace a filter, but it takes you more than two hours to replace the filter. That's not temporary and infrequent because it doesn't meet both standards, and it's important to remember that your roof area is considered one area, not just spot that you're working on. So this is the thing that I deal with all the [00:42:00] time. It's like, Oh, well, I'll just put a guardrail right here where this unit is, and I'll cover the standard. Meanwhile, there's 14 units on the roof, and they might only spend 30 minutes at each unit, but they're up on their roof for an entire day, working, replacing all these filters. So your whole roof area becomes the standard that you need to meet, and there's a few different ways we can. We can approach that. But just by way of general knowledge, if you're up there temporarily and infrequently, which means you're less than once a month and you spend less than two hours, both of those are met, then you can do what's called a designated area, which means you can set up a warning line system as long as you stay behind it. And it's very important to note that a designated area is very specific. It is a physical barrier between you and the edge of the roof. It is not a line painted on the [00:43:00] roof. It's not a sign posted on the thing saying don't go past this line. It is a physical barrier with actual standards. A warning line should be between thirty nine and forty five inches tall and must have a two hundred pound brake strength minimum and has to be visible from 25 feet away, and the posts need to withstand 16 pounds of force at the top. So all of those standards point to no, you cannot paint a line on the roof and call that your warning line. It's a physical barrier, and there's a bunch of reasons in the preamble they give why a warning line's a physical barrier, but you can do that around areas if it's temporary and infrequent. So then we've established now, OK, let's say the roof hatch comes up in the middle of the roof and all of my equipment is centered towards the center of the roof. Do I really need to do anything now because I'm more than 15 feet from the edge? [00:44:00]So at 15 feet, if all of your equipment is set up more than 15 feet and you're up there regularly, you know, like I said, monthly maintenance or weekly maintenance if you're up there regularly. Yes, you are still required to have something. You must still have a designated area to corral people into where they're going to be working. So we erect a lot of warning line at 15 feet back from the edge, where rooftops don't have units that are closer than 15 feet and they're much further towards the center. So we set up a designated area at the center of the roof, 15 feet back. We put the warning lines. You can go up there as much as you want and do as much as you want for as long as you want, if you have that designated area. If you're a small company and it's more than 15 feet from the edge, you have one unit [00:45:00] on the roof, you go up there once a year and you change a belt in the filter and it takes you a half an hour to do that. That is definitely considered temporary and infrequent. OSHA does allow you to not do anything under that rare situation. It's temporary and infrequent. You do not need to install any type of designated area or fall protection. However, controls would definitely need to be in place. So just because someone tells you, no you don't need to install any fall protection doesn't get you off the hook. And I've done quite a few things on this telling people, you know, they say, What do I need to do? And each situation is different. But at a minimum, if you have a roof that's temporary and infrequent and you're allowing employees to go up there without fall protection, we would recommend that minimum a roof sign off sheet for people that go up there to sign off, that they've had rooftop training. [00:46:00] We recommend that you have a map of the roof with a walk path delineated. And during the training, you tell employees this is where you may and may not go and this is where you stay and have them sign off on that. The roof itself should have a delineated walk path. There should be pavers or the glued down path or something. There should definitely be a delineated walk path from the entry point to the thing, and the sign off sheet should make sure people commit to staying on the walk path and not deviating from it. So those are at a minimum, a few things that people should do to cover themselves, because one of the big reasons why OSHA said there's no safe distance from the edge is because employees wander. They do it all the time. I've done it and he's sitting on a roof and you're walking around and you get bored or whatever. So you, you know, you walk [00:47:00] over to the edge and you look down to the parking lot, you see what's going on, and lots of people do that. They wander. So you want to make people sign off saying that they're not, you know, they're not going to deviate from that walk path. So that's at a minimum. Those are the kind of things you should do. So yes, there is a rare instance where you don't need to have fall protection at more than 15 feet from the edge, but it has to be temporary and infrequent. So those are the those are the three zones, the two lines of demarcation, six feet and 15 feet. And when you can and can't use a designated area or a physical, you know, fall protection or prevention system, and that's all in 1910.28, I think it's B 13 because the paragraph and it's all in there and you can review that. But those are those are basically the zones now.
Peter Koch: [00:47:58] Let's take a quick break at MEMIC, [00:48:00] while we strive to help our policyholders prevent workplace injuries, we also understand that they do happen. No workplace is immune. And when they do happen, a solid injury management plan must be in place, including reporting and a return to work program. Statistics show that returning an injured worker to work in a temporary modified duty capacity instead of keeping them out of work until one hundred percent, will reduce both the length and cost of the claim, as well as increased the likelihood of a positive outcome for the worker and the employer. Did you know that MEMIC has created a seven step process for developing a return to work plan, as well as a matrix to rate your current plan against what our team has found to be the gold standard in return to work programs? Check out our claim, reporting and return to work resources at MEMIC.com/employers. Now let's get back to today's episode.
Peter Koch: [00:49:03] That [00:49:00] makes sense, and I think there's a lot of information there. But it does make it a little more clear, so temporary and infrequent, you know, it is kind of unfortunate that they buried that in the preamble with those definitions are because I know that that information is or that question has come up quite often. What does that mean? But that was a great answer. So, you know, less than less than a month in less than two hours. And then the other point you made it shouldn't be lost on our listeners is that the roof is an, take the roof as an entirety. You could have one unit or you can have 50 units up there. And again, it doesn't matter if you're going to spend 30 minutes at one unit or 30 minutes on the roof, right? If you're going to spend 30 minutes at each of the 50, it's still going to be beyond that temporary requirement. So then you're moved into. I need to do something. I need to do something different. I can't.
David Kozlowsky: [00:49:58] We've done a couple of roofs [00:50:00] where people have that situation where they have like I can think of one roof in particular that had a half a dozen units on the roof and they were all within 15 feet, not quite to the six feet mark, but within 15 feet. And so at each one, individually, they could maybe make an argument that it was temporary and infrequent. But the roof area itself, when they're up there, they're walking around and they're going from unit to unit and they're not paying attention to where they are. And so what we were able to do is we went up and we kind of corralled each unit with a guardrail and then we just set warning lines back 15 feet from the edge and then just had little pathways connecting the central part of the building to each one. So the employees were corralled within an area that was designated that you don't go out of this area. And then as they approached closer to the edge where they had the actual unit, there was a physical hard guardrail to meet to [00:51:00] meet the standard so you can do hybrid type systems. We do hybrids all the time that are combination of physical guardrail barrier and then designated area to keep people corralled and within the area that you want them to be.
Peter Koch: [00:51:17] Yeah, great idea hadn't even really thought about it that way. I tend to be more black and white when it comes to some of those solutions, and that hybrid solution might be very effective. If you've got, well, if you don't have the ability to put guardrails up on the entire perimeter of the roof, which would be the most simplistic solution. But there is a lot of equipment to make that happen.
David Kozlowsky: [00:51:40] This goes back to what you were saying when you just said that this goes back to kind of our discussion back at the beginning about, you know, seamlessly integrating and the cost. So the most effective solution, the simplest and most effective and best solution is for, you know, if you're up on the roof, you just put a guardrail around the perimeter [00:52:00] of the roof. Problem solved. You can have as many people as you want up there wherever they want. No limit. You can do whatever you want. You can shovel the roof, you know as much as you want and you're completely within the standard. But it's also really expensive. I mean, a lot of guardrail. Sometimes the weight is an issue. If we can't do penetrations, they want to do counter weighted guardrail. You know, with all the weight up there, sometimes that's an issue in the cost. So you know, there's definitely there's definitely the simplest and easiest solution isn't always the most cost effective.
Peter Koch: [00:52:33] Yeah. So that's a great point. And it gets to the fact that you, you know, as a business owner or building owner, if you have a flat roof that you, you have to have people on, it may be worth your while to jump out there and contract with someone to do an assessment to figure out what are your options because you might want to say, Yeah, I can do that, we can put up guardrails all the way around the roof. [00:53:00] I hadn't even really thought about the if I can't penetrate the roof, from my stanchion, for my guardrail now, I have to have a weight that's going to allow for that 200 pounds of outward and downward force. And that's pretty substantial when you start thinking about how many stanchions you need on some of these large commercial roofs. So yeah, it's a really good point. Reach out get some help.
David Kozlowsky: [00:53:21] Yeah, get some help. And each in each situation, you know, is unique. A lot of them are unique. So we have the ability to have a combination, like I said of guardrails and maybe warning lines or other solutions that might help somebody accomplish what they are trying to do without breaking the bank, so to speak.
Peter Koch: [00:53:46] Yeah, great. Hey, so I've got a question for you and it's around access. So I got I don't have internal access to my roof. I have to have external access to my roof for whatever reason, right? Didn't get didn't get [00:54:00] planned correctly. Didn't wasn't in the budget to put internal access in, so I'm climbing up on a fixed ladder or maybe even a portable ladder. And how do I manage that type of thing within flat roofs? So what is what are the requirements around access zones?
David Kozlowsky: [00:54:16] So what we usually do with a fixed ladder, first thing to do is look at the look at the height of the ladder. So if it's under twenty four feet, you don't need to do anything specifically with the ladder itself. But if it's over twenty four feet, then the ladder itself needs to have fall protection as of November of twenty eighteen. The standard for ladders was changed to basically say anything produced after that state after that date should not have a ladder well or cage on it and should have active fall protection. And then basically it was left that after November of twenty [00:55:00] thirty six, that I think the original standards said that all ladders had to have the cages removed. But I think they changed that to say that they only had to be removed if they interfered with the function of the fall arrest system. So if it's over twenty four feet and you have a cage, if it was built before twenty eighteen, you're currently OK. You have until twenty thirty six to upgrade that in retrofit it. But if it was built after that date, it should not have a cage on it and it should have an active fall protection system. So what we do, what we try to do with the ladders is once you once you've established that the ladder itself is safe and it meets the standards and it has fall arrest if it needs. Usually what we do is depending on again, the layout of the roof. If it's a small roof and there's it's densely compacted and there's a bunch of things up there. Normally what we just do is try to ring the roof in guardrail, [00:56:00] tie the guardrail into the ladder and put a swing gate at the top of the ladder. So you always want to have that swing gate just because that that becomes an entry point or an unguarded opening at the side. So if it's a larger roof and there's not a lot of stuff right in the area. What we usually try to do is we try to put like a little corral or a little runway. So we try to get back 15 feet from the edge of the roof, or sometimes 10 feet, depending again, on the usage and how often you're up there. But we try to get back at least 10 or 15 feet with a hard guardrail, little runway or corral with a swing gate at the end of it. And then we tie that into either additional guard rail or a warning line, a designated area from there. So we try to corral people to approach the ladder down a guardrail area. So as they approach through six feet from the edge, they're protected in between the guardrails [00:57:00] with a swing gate at the end, and then they can open the gate and get onto the ladder from there.
Peter Koch: [00:57:06] Yeah, so full protection all the way through from the time you step into that six foot danger zone until you either get back onto the ladder to climb down or you get into the area that's beyond 15 feet or the workspace that you're within that warning line area.
David Kozlowsky: [00:57:24] Yes. Yeah. So we usually tie hard guardrails back from some thing, either warning line or guardrail, or sometimes there is nothing. What we've done and we've done it a few places is we'll put a kind of the runway to the ladder with a gate and then at the end of the runway is either an anchor point or access to the horizontal lifeline system. So when they come out, they go on before they exit the kind of corralled area they hook on to the fall protection and then they go on the roof from there. That's most common on [00:58:00] roofs that have a little bit of a slope to them. I could think of one client that has it's a pretty low slope. It's definitely under four 12, but it's a white TPO roof. So when it's wet or if it's even snowed at all, it is absolutely treacherous. And so we definitely wanted 100 percent tie off up there. They didn't want to try to ring the guardrails all around. I'm not sure that it would have worked anyway unless they were permanently mounted because of the slipperiness of the roof and the counterweight and the fact that it was sloped. So it probably would have had to have it permanently penetrating. So we made sure that there was a swing gate at the ladder, that it was tied into the ladder, that it was highly secure all the way back to the point where they tie off onto the fall protection. So that's another option as well. You can always tie that runway back [00:59:00] into an anchor point.
Peter Koch: [00:59:03] Yeah, that makes sense, and I haven't seen it employed, but I can see where that could be employed well, especially from a snow removal standpoint as we think about the New England area and you might have a multi-tiered roof where you might have a steep pitch above, but you've got an overhang that is within that four 12. And just to be safe on that, as you come up to stand on that, it's going to be less than six feet sometimes and having that horizontal lifeline running behind you that I can tie into and then shoveled down to the leading edge of that roof and then come back to shovel against the end.
David Kozlowsky: [00:59:41] So, that goes beyond. So that goes beyond a kind of a controlled access zone into what we call a designated area.
Peter Koch: [00:59:50] Ok.
David Kozlowsky: [00:59:51] So we've done that quite a few times on roofs. So especially for shoveling operations on large roofs. One of the complaints is, well, I you [01:00:00] know, first of all, this snow up there, I can't tie off to, you know, roof anchors because they're buried in snow. The cables are buried or I need 10 guys up there shoveling and your cables only rated for two. I can't have five cable systems running around the whole roof. I mean, it's just not going to work. So what we do is a designated area. We take a section, we take the warning line and ring the roof with morning lines. So you can have basically as many people as you want back from the edge shoveling snow to one or more designated areas, which are areas closer than 15 feet where employees will stay permanently as movers to get the snow from the roof off the roof. So in those areas, what we do is we warning line it or guardrail it off and then install a couple of anchors so that when they go beyond the warning line and remove the warning line, they go into an area that has [01:01:00] anchors for fall protection. Those employees stay in that area tied off and move the snow off the roof and have everybody else kind of feeding snow towards them for shoveling. So again, another hybrid solution that's not uniform throughout the roof, picking pieces that work the best for each area.
Peter Koch: [01:01:20] Now that makes, it makes sense. And I'm thinking it from thinking about it, from a business owner or a building owner standpoint. You might not actually have your guys removing the snow, but if you're installing a system like this, you're going to need to do a little bit of training about how this particular system works with your subcontractors so that they can take advantage of the safety or the protection pieces that you have, regardless of compliance, because again, go back to a comment that you made before. If one of your subcontractors falls off the roof at some point in time, you're going to get hauled into that lawsuit, or you're going to get hauled into the worker's comp claim as well. So regardless of how it works, you're going to get [01:02:00] tied back to it.
David Kozlowsky: [01:02:01] From that, you're much more versed in that area than I am. So you would have more information about that other than I do know there is a bit of gray area in this particular type of applications to fire is who's actually responsible for the fall protection. The way it's mostly been handled is the building owner provides it because usually what happens is they'll say, OK, you can't do this unless you have fall protection, and then they'll either put it back on the contractor to bring all of their own fall protection, which becomes difficult when the roof is covered in snow. So the contractor kicks it back to the building owner and says, Well, OK, that's all fine and good, but what do you expect me to put up there when it's already covered in snow? So there's a little bit of gray area there. I know for building maintenance, especially façade maintenance, which is a different set of standards. We won't go into that today. But if façade maintenance, if you're over the side of the roof suspending doing [01:03:00] anything that does fall back on the building owner exclusively. So that's definitely there's no gray area there. But for this, I'm not really sure. Maybe, you'd have some insight into, you know, who is actually ultimately responsible for this or is it basically what I've been saying? It's basically an agreement between the building owner and the contractor as to who's going to supply it.
Peter Koch: [01:03:27] So OSHA's going to look at it from the perspective of the you're going to have the exposing employer, the controlling employer or the creating employer. So there could be multiple different roles that the employer or the subcontractor can play, depending on what they're doing. So do you own the building and did you hire the subcontractor? Did you create the hazard? Did you expose the employee to the hazard? So there is some liability around there from an OSHA standpoint, depending on what part [01:04:00] you play in. That role from a workers comp standpoint, it's going to come down to who are you employed by? And so if I'm the worker's comp person and I'm insuring the subcontractor and the subcontractor didn't put the or didn't use fall protection, it doesn't matter because they got hurt. It's going to be on my dime and it's going to be something that I'm going to have to manage as the worker's comp carrier between myself and the person that I am insuring from a loss control consultant standpoint. When I'm going out to work with a subcontractor who might be in the business of either roofing or if they're going to do something for a snow removal or maintenance, then my recommendation is you have to protect your employees. So there's two routes for you to go. You can either work with that building owner to provide you with the appropriate fall protection that [01:05:00] fits within the work that you're going to be doing and the workflow that you have to do to maintain safety, quality and productivity, or you bring it yourself and you implement it there. So at the end of that long description, I think the bottom line comes down to not from a worker's comp standpoint, but or even from a worker's comp standpoint, because it helps clarify is to make sure that there's a contract that you describe who's responsible for what within the contract that you have with the subcontractor. So if you're the building owner or the business owner and you're reaching out to a subcontractor, make sure it's outlined in the requirement. Who's responsible for the fall protection and following all of the OSHA rules around fall protection? That would be that'd be my recommendation to one to make it clear and to then to have something to fall back to if there ever is the unfortunate situation where you do have a problem.
Peter Koch: [01:05:56] It's been a great conversation so far around fall protection. What I like [01:06:00] to touch on it, just a couple of fringe things that come on to the flat roof discussion here. I almost said flat Earth discussion, but the flat roof discussion, right? So are there any requirements or changes to the requirements around or if there is around roofs size? So if I got a big roof or a small roof, are there any changes around what I need to do for fall protection around roof size, David?
David Kozlowsky: [01:06:25] Not per the standard other than the roof size and the amount of equipment on the roof would probably it would do more to limit your options rather than to require a different set of standards. The only deciding factor in 1910.28 is the slope of the roof. And then after that, you know, the larger the roof, the more options you have if you have a small 20 by 20 roof. Obviously, it's going to be hard to stay more than six or 15 feet from the edge at all times. So it just basically would just do [01:07:00] to limit your options.
Peter Koch: [01:07:01] That's good. That's a really good point and just a good thing to consider because I want people that are listening to understand that we're talking about the general industry standard 1910.28, not the construction standard where there are some changes if you're doing if you're working as a roofer or doing roof work, actually, there are some roof size requirements in there and we're not going to touch on those. That's going to be a topic for another podcast. So thanks for that clarification. Another one I have are what are the fall protection requirements if I'm actually doing an installation or building, say, an HVAC system on an existing roof. So I'm not maintaining, but I'm not actually building the roof. Are there any differences in what's required for fall protection if I'm doing that kind of activity, either as a subcontractor or as the building owner?
David Kozlowsky: [01:07:54] Yeah, so that's basically going to go back to the activity. So [01:08:00] as you were saying before about the liability, the difference between, you know, workers comp and liability. So workers comp is made to cover the employees of the organization. And so basically, the 1910.28 is the general industry standard is I mean, it's not really a perfect correlation, but I kind of like in that towards the worker's comp kind of thing where it applies to the employee. So if you're XYZ company and you're maintaining the roof and your specific employees are up there, that's what 1910.28 is mainly supposed to cover. Not exactly like I said, but mainly once you switch over, like when you said the word construction, you hit the nail right on the head. You're doing roofing construction with, say, building a new HVAC system. Then you really did cross over from [01:09:00] general industry into construction. So the standards that the workers, including the roofers and anybody working on erecting or dismantling the existing HVAC would fall under the construction standard, so they would have to follow that set of rules as far as that's concerned.
Peter Koch: [01:09:21] So just making that differentiation, knowing that if I'm building something, constructing something, I'm going to be having to look into that different set of standards. And again, I hate to keep saying this, but there's just so much in this one particular topic on flat roofs for general industry that we don't want to cross too much into the construction side of things. So we'll deal with that in a different podcast. So one more challenge and this happens. Actually, it's happened fairly recently within Maine's history, especially in our wintertime, are skylights and skylights and flat roofs. We've had employees [01:10:00] who are up there doing maintenance, who are up there doing inspections actually fall through a skylight that's hidden underneath the snow or they're not paying attention and they take a step back and they fall into the skylight. So what are the requirements around skylights for flat roofs regarding fall protection?
David Kozlowsky: [01:10:20] So the rule of thumb for protecting a skylight can start with the curb height, so the guard rail standard is forty two inches. So in a situation where you might have an architectural skylight that might actually have a forty two inch curb height so that glass doesn't start until you're at forty two inches, and that really becomes a non-issue at that point because you're not. It's not technically part of the walking working surface. Once the glass portion gets lower than 42 whether it be a architectural type skylight or one of the smaller like the dome light type skylights, [01:11:00] then those. I'm just going to come out and say those need to be protected either with a screen or a guardrail. There are limited situations if you have documentation from the manufacturer stating that the glass is rated for, you know, a walk on surface. Basically, if you don't have that documentation from the manufacturer, regardless of however strong you think it might be, then you will need to. You will need to get that protected. If an inspector goes up there and sees a skylight and it's not protected, they're going to ask you for documentation showing that. And if you don't have it, you'll get cited. I've seen it happen a couple of times, actually, especially those the ones that get ignored. Most people pretty much know those little dome skylights, you know, by the time, even if they're new from the factory with whatever pound load on them, by the time they've been up there for 20 years and [01:12:00] they're all faded and cracked. And, you know, I mean, that's pretty self-explanatory. The ones that I see people get dinged on the most is the architectural ones because there are a lot of them have really heavy duty double pane glass, and some of them are designed to be walk on for maintenance and whatnot. And so I see people get dinged on those because they don't have they don't have the paperwork. So if you have paperwork, you're OK. But other than that, you should definitely have a guardrail or a screen of some type over it.
Peter Koch: [01:12:33] And then again, the guardrail has to meet those certain certifications or qualifications for strength. And also, I would imagine the screen has to have similar ratings for walk on or fall through, correct.
David Kozlowsky: [01:12:47] So basically, the screen kind of it's kind of a little bit different. It's a little bit different application, but the screen falls under protecting a hole, an open hole. [01:13:00] So that's really more what it's like. And the standard for protecting an open hole is that the fall protection, if you don't use a guardrail, whether you use a safety net or some other in a screen, believe it or not, loosely falls under a safety net standard. It's kind of a rigid net if you think about it. So that has to be able to withstand and you're going to have to forgive me because I think I've forgotten the exact number. It's either a three hundred and fifty or a four hundred pound bag of sand dropped from the highest point from which a person may fall, but not less than 42 inches. So in other words, if the nets mounted five feet below the surface, it has to be able to withstand that times. Five feet three. I think it's a four hundred pound is the on site and then three hundred and fifty, I think, is the test weight. But anyway, so then if you're at the walking, working surface or above, the standard says a minimum of 42 [01:14:00] inches. So I believe that most screens would be designed to that four hundred pound bag of sand at forty two inch drop. So that would be the equivalent strength required for that, right?
Peter Koch: [01:14:14] Nice. And so again, if you're going to purchase one or you're out looking for to retrofit or to replace, it's easiest actually to go and look for the manufacturer's certifications and qualifications so that you know that it's going to meet those standards. So that's always good to know. You can just even if you go build your own, have your welders fab up something and there are some particular standards that it has to meet. And then you have to prove that you are able that it's able to do that. And when you test it, it can't just be tested at that. It has to be tested beyond what the rating actually is.
David Kozlowsky: [01:14:50] Mm hmm. So and you could if you wanted to build your own, I mean, you could. But you would have to either invest in some onsite [01:15:00] testing to make sure you cover it and document it thoroughly or get it, get it engineered. So you'd have to hire a P.E. To come in and do all the calculations and stamp it. I believe OSHA would accept either one of those. I can't say the same for ANSI because they've just kind of gotten a little bit crazy with the requirements, but OSHA would, I believe, accept either one of those, yeah.
Peter Koch: [01:15:26] And you know, either way, you want to go, it's. I do find that there's enough suppliers out there and manufacturers out there that can produce something either as a one off. If you have some, some need that doesn't fit what's standard out there or they have enough that will fit some of the standard sizes for your skylights, and it'll be great.
David Kozlowsky: [01:15:49] There definitely is, and they're reasonably priced too good.
Peter Koch: [01:15:53] All right. So we're getting towards the end of where we are, and I've got one question that I've been wanting to ask you ever since our first podcast [01:16:00] since you have you got tons of creative ideas? You know, I've worked with you. Way back. Well, before we started this podcast, when I first started working for MEMIC, we actually worked together with the client to try to get some flat roof fall protection for snow removal, believe it or not. And the question is, if cost and technology were no issue and I know I mean pie in the sky. But if cost and technology were no issue, what would you create as the perfect fall prevention system for a roof?
David Kozlowsky: [01:16:31] Oh, that's so easy because and you really opened that up by saying cost and technology. Yeah, because I we've joked with clients eight million times that the first person to in invent levitation technology was going to become perfect. There's eight million reasons and times when you're on the top of something [01:17:00] and you need to protect yourself from falling off, but there is nothing above you to tie off to. There's no beam or roof or structure of any kind, and you're left constructing this massive support thing to hang a single anchor point over somebody's tank or roof or something that they need to work on. And you could ever invent a levitating anchorage point where you could just hang in mid-air and let somebody tie off too. You would put a whole lot of people out of business?
Peter Koch: [01:17:32] You definitely win. I totally thought of that. There's been many times where I'm sitting there going, if I could only have that. And you know what? That's funny because I'm right there with you. If I could, just if I could just not fall, like, take something where I could, if I could step off into space and I'm not going to fall would be perfect.
David Kozlowsky: [01:17:48] Or if you could just or if you could invent a levitating anchor point where you could just bring it above you and just tie off to it like that would be the way to go.
Peter Koch: [01:17:58] Or I think that's the [01:18:00]scouting thing. I remember when I was in scouts, when I first in scouts, they sent me off. I had to go get the left handed and smoke shifter to be able to be attached to the Skyhook. And those were the two things that I searched all over the campsite for, and they never existed, so
David Kozlowsky: [01:18:16] They never existed.
Peter Koch: [01:18:19] Awesome. So thanks, Dave. That about wraps up this week's Safety Experts podcast. So thank you so much for coming on again and sharing your expertise with our listeners.
David Kozlowsky: [01:18:29] No, thank you. I love doing these. It's fun, and I appreciate that you invite me on. Thank you.
Peter Koch: [01:18:35] Oh, fantastic. So where can our listeners find out more about Safe Approach in your business and what you do
David Kozlowsky: [01:18:42] If you can go on the internet at www.safeapprocah.com? You can email us at David [email protected] or [email protected] or the 800 number 800-471-1157 and we'll be happy to help.
Peter Koch: [01:18:58] Perfect. Thanks. [01:19:00] I appreciate it, and thanks for all the listeners out there for joining us today. Today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast. We've been speaking about fall protection specifically on roofs with David Kozlowski, president and owner of Safe Approach, right here in Portland, Maine. If you have any questions about fall protection or would like to hear more about a particular topic on our podcast. Email me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/podcast, where you can find additional resources, links to other podcasts with Dave, as well as our entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for our safety net blog. So you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates, and if you haven't done so already, I really appreciate it. If you took a minute or two to review us on Spotify, iTunes or whichever podcast service that you found us on, and if you've already done that and subscribe. Thank you because it really helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing [01:20:00] the show with a business associate friend or family member who you think you'll get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Koch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.
When it comes to workplace safety, Maslow's hierarchy of needs can shed light on why you can't gain real traction in developing your safety culture. From physiological needs to self-Actualization and accountability, this episode will look at how miss alignment of business objectives and employee needs can be the cause of on-going crisis management that will prevent us from moving our safety culture forward.
In 2005 Patrick Nelson, while serving in the US Army paratroops, had an experience that changed his life and his perspective on being a leader. Leadership, good or bad, is made up of moments. On this podcast, Patrick helps us see the impact of those moments and how leaders can engage safety through story telling.
Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch. It was a summer a while ago, and my wife Laura, pregnant with our first daughter and I were traveling back from a quick trip to visit my family and celebrate a birthday. It's about a five hour drive one way, and we're like, we always do with family trying to fit it in with an increasingly hectic work schedule. So we had left late from my family's house and our ETA back to Maine was somewhere around two a.m. and as was my habit, I was driving and around two hours or so out from our home. Laura asked if I wanted to take a break and have her drive. And I remember in the moment choosing to tell her, nah I'm OK. And then she should go ahead and catch some sleep so she would be all set for work in the morning. Leading my family, right? I remember telling her that, and then she asked me if I was sure and she had this look on her face like, Are you really sure you're OK? And [00:01:00] the next thing I remember is her screaming at me, and then we were in the guardrail. So leadership, good or bad is made up of moments, and these moments are where decisions and choices get made. Sometimes they're obviously critical to the team's path, while other times the purpose of those moments is not so obvious. Sometimes the choice in the moment is easy, and sometimes it's hard. Sometimes you can clearly see the potential impact of the choice, while in other moments the future of that choice is cloudy, but always. In hindsight, if we look closely enough, we can see the choice or choices in the moments that were made that were the cause of the success or failure and the night that we crashed into the guardrail. I was given at least two of those moments, and it's only by the grace of God and my wife screaming at me that my family has more. So as a leader, whether you're a spouse, your coach or manager, supervisor, [00:02:00] CEO, Commander, Sargent doesn't matter. You will have leadership moments where you're going to be at a crossroads and have the opportunity to choose to act or pass on that moment. And when it comes to safety, these moments are all around us. You think about a moment where you saw one of your team maybe not wearing safety glasses or choosing to take a shortcut that you yourself had taken just the day before, or maybe even with that employee together? Or that employee might be rushing to get the job done, making normal work a crisis. And you didn't take a moment, you name it. I expect we've all had an experience like this to reflect on. And then when you do choose to act on that moment, especially in the workplace for workplace safety, what do you get in the response when you act on that moment? It's my experience that that receiver is not always gushing to thank you and really appreciative of you stopping to have them put his safety glasses on. Most likely, they're [00:03:00] sullen and possibly can't understand why you're bringing the nanny state to bear in this particular opportunity, because it was just for a moment that they weren't wearing their PPE or that it took too long. And why are we doing it this way here anyway? Or add your excuse, you can find any excuse so you don't act or you don't act in a way that can engage the individual or your team, and the cycle of moments start all over again. Well, today I have the distinct privilege of speaking to someone who sees the importance of recognizing these moments and choosing to engage. Joining me on the podcast is Patrick Nelson. Patrick is an experienced leader, having served as a paratrooper in the U.S. Army, leading soldiers through three combat deployments earning a Bronze Star and a Purple Heart. Beyond his military career, he has a master's degree in sports management from Minnesota state and another in organizational development from Pepperdine University. Patrick [00:04:00] lives in Minnesota and is the CEO of Loyalty Point Leadership, working with small businesses and Fortune 500 companies to deploy leadership development programs. There's a ton to Patrick's story, and we're only going to scratch the surface today. So with that introduction, Patrick, welcome to the podcast today.
Patrick Nelson: [00:04:20] Thanks, Peter. It is great to be here, and I just want to thank you for sharing that very personal story at the beginning because I think as you'll find throughout our short time together today that sharing stories is very important to me to really move the needle on safety. So I think it's awesome that you did that. Thank you.
Peter Koch: [00:04:40] I appreciate that. And yeah, I noticed that like we, we just met a couple of days ago talking over WebEx and trying to figure out, Hey, so how does this all fit in with the safety podcast? And I have found that you speak the truth like stories are very important to you. And you found that it really does make [00:05:00] an impact. And that's going to be part of what we talk about today because, I don't know, engaging in safety. I have found in my career it's been 18 years with MEMIC. Now, as a safety management consultant, engaging people in safety is really important and I think you've had a similar experience as well with trying to engage people regardless of what that is.
Patrick Nelson: [00:05:22] I did, yeah, you know, when I was in the military, I used to have to give pre-mission briefings before every combat mission we rolled out on, much like the civilian world, whether it's a start up meeting the shift change a tower talk whatever you want to call it. I was faced with the same challenge that many people are faced keeping people engaged in those meetings. You're providing some valuable information, but a lot of times that information is the same thing those employees are hearing every single day. And I sat in on a couple of these with different clients throughout the country, in different industries, and it seemed [00:06:00] like people were more worried about finding the pen to sign in than they were listening to what the person had to say. And one of the things that I learned in my time in the military giving these briefings is the power of being able to use personal stories to keep people engaged. I knew that I had to get creative and think outside the box instead of just going through my little checklist. And you know, hey guys, make sure you got your helmet on. You got your eye protection, everybody's got their gloves on. Telling very personal and brief is a very key word because we don't have the longest attention spans, but personal and brief stories related to those topics that people can specifically relate to is really what's going to get people engaged.
Peter Koch: [00:06:46] Yeah, right on. So like when you were given those pre mission briefings and possibly before you started seeing the value of telling those stories, like how did you know that you were getting the message across? [00:07:00] Or maybe that you weren't getting the message across? Like, what was the what were the team's reaction when they were like, All right, Patrick, I've had enough of this. Let's just get going on the mission.
Patrick Nelson: [00:07:09] Yeah, that's a good question. You can tell, by the way, people look at you. I mean, you can tell when people are fully engaged in a conversation with you. Or you could also tell when they're kind of just stared at you blankly and their mind is thinking about 12 different other things. And that's something that I realize, especially in a combat situation where even though you're in a very dangerous place, it's still very easy to get complacent. Guys are thinking about home. They're thinking about their families, their mind can wander and the same thing happens whether you're working in construction or on the manufacturing line, especially what I found during COVID. People are thinking about their kids that are, you know, there's a kid have to home school. They're thinking about their parents that, you know, might be in an age population that may be at a higher [00:08:00] risk. It's easy to get distracted from the very important stuff. And so one of the things is just having that eye contact and making sure that people are engaged. And another thing that I actually used to do was I have one of my soldiers leave that briefing. I let him know the day before, Hey, tomorrow you're going to go ahead and leave the briefing, and I'd sit down right next to them and help them prepare. And I would stand right next to them when they were doing it to throw them a lifeline in case they needed some help to make sure that everything was covered. Worst case scenario, they were going to get up there and they were going to stink it up. However, it was going to be an opportunity for them to step outside of their comfort zone and a huge learning opportunity for them and to keep them engaged in the process.
Peter Koch: [00:08:43] Yeah, that's awesome. That's that leadership moment. Like, here's the moment I have. I can either do it myself or I can. I can recognize that somebody else might have a better story to tell or have better impact with my team since, you know, they've been listening to me for the last, however many weeks or days. And then what I like to about [00:09:00] that particular instance that you described was you didn't just throw them the checklist and say, All right, buddy tag, you're it. It's OK, here's the day. Here's your responsibility. This is what we're going to go through. Let's talk it through. Let's make sure we can figure it out so that you're giving them the resource to be successful in that point, which is another great leadership piece, whether it's in safety or just leadership in general. Awesome. Awesome part there.
Patrick Nelson: [00:09:26] Yeah, absolutely. I mean, as you know, Peter, it's inherent in anybody who considers himself a leader to be able to coach and mentor those that follow them.
Peter Koch: [00:09:37] You know, we're initially talking about leadership here and you know, your experience in the military when you talked about it, it's a combat zone. So the choices that are made within that particular venue for combat, you can connect the consequences really easily. And even though you said you get complacent, you don't always see [00:10:00] it. Sometimes it happens surprisingly. But looking in at from the outside, there's more implications to not taking advantage of the moment in those situations that than there are, say, maybe in construction or maybe in manufacturing or something else where you doing the same thing day after day after day, but honestly. Even though you might not have the same number of opportunities to lose your life as you do in combat, you have a myriad of opportunities in any industry to be injured to change your life in an instant. You had a particular experience, I'm sure, out of many different experiences across your seven years in the military where you saw the impact of a moment. And I wonder if you might take some time and relate that story so that we can hear it and kind of get an idea where you're coming from. And then we can talk [00:11:00] about that story and how it's impacted you and how you see things differently for current and future.
Patrick Nelson: [00:11:09] Yeah, absolutely, Peter. You know, I have that one traumatic experience that has changed my life, and it's been that experience from 15, 16 years ago that has led me to right here being a guest on your podcast right now. And it was June 8th, 2005. I was operating out of a small forward operating base near the Pakistani border. So I was in Afghanistan. This was the type of place we were short on everything except the enemy. We faced regular indirect fire attacks participate in several large battles that saw between 50 to one hundred enemy fighters each time. And on this particular morning, we were getting resupplied with some ammunition by a chinook helicopter. Resupply procedures were a common part of what we did, and our platoon was divided into two sections. So any time a resupply [00:12:00] would come in, one of those sessions would be designated as the hot gun. Basically, they were responsible for standing by to respond to any type of attack. The other section, which responds with unloading the supplies from the helicopter. So on this particular morning, my section was the hot gun. We're going to get resupplied with some ammunition. But the other section had a sergeant leaving to go on R&R and I was going to go ahead and backfill his position with them. So as the helicopter approached, I hopped in the Humvee with my good friend Luke. And just as we were about to drive out to the landing zone, my soldier Emmanuel Hernandez, hopped in the back. Now he was supposed to be back with the hot gun, so I turned around and I was about to yell at him. But I thought for a second, you know what, I value that kind of work ethic. He wants to come lift some heavy boxes and help out the team. I know that our section will be fine without him. I value that in [00:13:00] my soldiers, so I didn't say anything. And as I was turning around. I noticed that he didn't have his helmet on, and so I literally opened my mouth. But I quickly realized I don't have mine on, either. It's kind of hard for me to say something if I'm not doing the right thing, so I said nothing. As we got out to the landing zone, a group of 10 of us stepped to the side of the aircraft so they could take a machine gun off the back ramp. The rotors on the helicopter were turning, couldn't hear each other. My platoon sergeant handed me a piece of paper with some serial numbers to items we were expecting, basically saying, Hey, it's your responsibility to make sure we get these specific items. So I grab that piece of paper from him and I turn my back to that group so I could ground guide Luke in the Humvee to back them up a little bit closer to the helicopter. And the next thing I remember. Everything went dark, and as I was laying on the ground, disoriented, unable to [00:14:00] hear. I thought maybe somebody came up behind me and had just hit me on the back of the head maybe played a joke that went too far.
Patrick Nelson: [00:14:09] But then I looked up and there were bodies of blood all over the ground in my hearing came back, the helicopter quickly powered down and I heard that very distinct whistle of an incoming rocket. And so I got up and I dove underneath the Humvee for cover as rockets started to impact all around. And as I was laying there, I realized there's a rocket that had landed next to it, instead it knocked me to the ground. So as the barrage finally ended. I crawled out from underneath the Humvee, started making my way back to the soldiers that were still on the ground, unsure of what I was going to find. And as I was doing that, a marine yelled from behind me that I'd been hit. Now, up until that point, I had not felt any pain, but I turned my head and look at the back of my uniform and it was shredded and blood was starting to pour out. And it was at that moment that the pain all of a sudden hit me. The other soldiers quickly [00:15:00] triage those of us that were hurt, loaded us into whatever type of vehicle they could find and brought us to this small clinic on our base that was ran by an Afghan doctor who treated locals. Now my wounds were very, very minor compared to everybody else. I was peppered in the back with shrapnel, small holes in there, nothing too serious, but it definitely hurt. And I was quickly bandaged up by Luke, and I saw Sergeant Michael Kelly, a supply sergeant from the Massachusetts National Guard, who is recently attached to our unit.
Patrick Nelson: [00:15:33] He was laying on this elevated stretcher off the ground, and the local Afghan doctor who worked in that clinic was performing CPR on him. He's standing on this. I'll never forget this red milk crate because he was like five feet, two inches tall. And so he's standing on this red milk crate performing CPR on Michael. And I did a quick lap around the clinic to see who else was hurt. I came across my platoon sergeant, one of the just handed me the piece of paper right before [00:16:00] the explosion. He's laying on a stretcher, on the ground, on the outside of the clinic because the inside was already full of others who were hurt. The femoral artery and his leg was severed along with other severe wounds. And by the time I came back around, I couldn't have been more than thirty or forty five seconds and they have lowered Michael to the ground and we're zipping them up into a body bag. And I found my way into a small room in the back of the clinic where I found my soldier, Emmanuel Hernandez, he's laying on a table. His head is bandaged. He's unconscious. But we were fortunate to have a special forces battalion surgeon in our area that day who responded, so I knew he was giving the best care available and I could see his chest rise and fall. So I knew that he was breathing and I just I grabbed him by the hand, whispered to him everything was going to be OK.
Patrick Nelson: [00:16:52] Medevac helicopters arrived brought us to four surgical teams spread throughout the country. I was on a helicopter ride with my platoon sergeant, [00:17:00] who had by then lost consciousness. But thanks to the quick thinking of the soldiers on the ground, we're putting a tourniquet on his leg and the medical staff that treated him. He survived and he kept his leg. The surgical team removed several pieces of shrapnel from my back. They left a few souvenirs in there that were little too deep to get out that I still carry with me. But they stitched me up and bandaged me up, sent me back to the landing zone for another helicopter ride to Bagram Airfield for some more advanced care. And as I was waiting there, my commander approach to see how I was doing. I said, I'm going to be just fine. How is? How is Emmanuel? And he looked at me. He said he was going to be OK. I just felt such relief. And he turned to walk away, and he got about four or five steps. And he turned around. And with tears coming down his cheeks. He said, I'm sorry that I lied. Hernandez didn't make it. And [00:18:00] my knees got weak as I hit the ground, my commander embraced me. Emanuel died because shrapnel from the explosion hit him in the head. He died because I was not doing the right thing. Because I didn't have the courage to speak up and to say something, and there's been so many days where I thought how simple it would have been if I would have just said, Hey guys, wait, let's go get our helmets quick.
Patrick Nelson: [00:18:27] I mean, nothing would have been delayed. It would have taken a matter of moments just this morning at breakfast. Emanuel was telling another soldier how he couldn't wait to get home and started having kids with his wife. And if only I would have stopped and said something. His wife, Jessica, would still have her husband. His mother would still have her son. And Emmanuel would still have his life ahead of him. But guess what, we've done it like that hundreds and times before. And nothing has ever happened. It's so [00:19:00] easy, I don't care whether you're in a combat zone or you're out there, you know, paving roads or working on some type of line or swinging a hammer. It's so easy to get complacent and to sort of fall and get that tunnel vision and get used to doing things a certain way, especially if it's the wrong way. You know, if you stay in your industry long enough, you might have some lucky days, but you may not have a lucky career because sooner or later, whether it's your fault or not. Something can happen to you. I know it's such a cliche. So one in a million chance. But Peter, I'm here to tell you that it absolutely can happen. You know, I like to ask people this when I'm working with clients, I'll say, Hey, who here has ever bought a lottery ticket in their life like a Powerball Mega million? And most people raise their hand, right? And we bought that ticket knowing that the chances of us winning [00:20:00] are astronomical.
Patrick Nelson: [00:20:03] But we have this sliver of belief that maybe just maybe it might be us. Well, let me tell you, if you have that attitude towards winning a lottery jackpot that it could happen to you. I definitely hope you have that attitude towards workplace safety because the chances of you getting hurt at work are a heck of a lot higher than you winning a lottery jackpot. Again, it's so easy to get comfortable to get used to doing things one way or another. And there's a phenomenon called the diffusion of responsibility when you're in groups of people. You're less likely to speak up to say something or to lend a hand. And why is that? Because you think somebody else is going to do it?
Peter Koch: [00:20:55] It's not my job.
Patrick Nelson: [00:20:56] It's not my job, right? It's not my responsibility. Nobody [00:21:00] else is speaking up. So I guess everything's OK. And it doesn't matter to me if it's your second day on the job or if you've been there for twenty five years, you can get sucked into that diffusion of responsibility. I got another story that I'll share later here with you where that happened to me just two short years ago. But thankfully, I have an awesome wife just like yours, who spoke up and was able to help change that situation.
Peter Koch: [00:21:30] Right on. Oh my gosh, that that is a hugely powerful story, and I thank you for sharing that and realize you're on the podcast to help share things, but that to share the story in the way that you did and for us to realize all of the all the decisions that that went into that one moment, like in that that hindsight 20 20 analysis of the plan and what happened [00:22:00] all the way back to that moment where you look back at them and you open your mouth and you were like, not this time. And then the story goes on from there. So that's a hugely powerful story, and it resonates, resonates for me. I know the diffusion of responsibility kind of thinking about that. I geez, I could go through my career and find hundreds of times where that's happened, where I almost raised my hand, but I didn't quite feel like it was my job. And as a leader, right, do you think about as a leader, it is your job, but that is your only job. So take away everything else that you have as a leader, if you're in charge of a family, you're in charge of a platoon, you're in charge of a team. Whatever it is, you're only job is to make sure that your team is properly equipped for success. And [00:23:00] if you don't take that moment to say something. Like you said, you buy the lottery ticket and some days you win and some days you lose, but as a leader, you really can't take those chances.
Patrick Nelson: [00:23:14] Yeah, absolutely. For everybody listening right now. You're listening to this because more than likely you work in an industry or, you know, somebody that works in an industry where the consequences are very real if something happens. And again, it's not a matter of if a lot of times, unfortunately, it's a matter of when. Again, when I go into clients, I love to ask people. It used to be a variety of people. It might be that second day employee in there or that's employee who's been there 10, 15, 20 years. But I'll ask them who here has ever taken a shortcut when it comes to safety or not wearing the proper PPE? Been complacent been negligent not follow procedure and every hand in that room [00:24:00] goes up. We've all been guilty of it at one point in our career or another. But again, go back to what I said. You might have some lucky days, but if you stay in that industry long enough, you may not have a lucky career. We got sucked in to that comfort zone of being and we were in a combat zone where our lives are on the line. Twenty four seven. And we got sucked into it. So if it can happen to me during combat operations in Afghanistan, I know that it absolutely can happen to you.
Peter Koch: [00:24:35] Yeah, complacency it's the bane of what we do. I mean, even if your job is different day to day, hour to hour, there's still things that are going to pull your mind away from it. There's still things that are going to force you into position where you're going to recognize a moment and then need to make a choice. And then when we get complacent, you start to think about, well, like coming [00:25:00] up to a yellow light. What do you do? Right. So the yellow light means, do I speed up and get through it before it turns red? Or do I slow down and pay attention, or maybe even stop and let the traffic go through? So if I've had the experience of being lucky time after time, after time, I might not take that opportunity to say something or to go back and get my helmet or to put my PPE on or, you know, I think we could probably swap stories for a few hours about successes and failures personally that we've seen and then that we've heard other people tell us about or things that I've had to go and investigate as loss control consultant of a fatality that has occurred on the work site where the same thing if we walk back to. The critical decision that was made that allowed the scenario to unfold the way it did. It was a leadership failure. Almost always, it's a leadership failure.
Patrick Nelson: [00:26:00] Yep, [00:26:00] I absolutely agree with you, you know, the research is clear, ninety nine point some percent of all incidents are completely preventable. Yeah, save those lone acts of God. But there are opportunities there when you're doing, whether it's your root cause analysis, you're asking why five times whatever process it is that you're using, you're going to get back to that situation where that could have easily been prevented. And you'll probably find about five or six different situations where somebody could have easily raise their hand or spoke up, and they didn't for whatever reason it is. And so, yes, as leaders, absolutely again, our inherent responsibility to take care of those around us.
Peter Koch: [00:26:45] Yeah. And so beyond the diffusion of responsibility, like why in your experience talking to all, all your clients and having your experience within the military and even outside that, why do you think leaders don't [00:27:00] make that choice? I mean, you have your personal experience. I've had my personal experiences where I haven't stepped up and made that choice. Why else do you think leaders don't step into the breach to say something?
Patrick Nelson: [00:27:15] Well, first of all, you chose your words very apropos there, because you said choice, because I like to say safety is not an option, but it's still a choice. It still comes down to that individual. And I think there's a plethora of reasons of why and a lot of the ones that I see is. Pressure. We have to meet our numbers, we don't want to come in and have to work this weekend, and a lot of times that pressure is driven internally. Now there can absolutely be external factors and it's the way a lot of times it's even the way people choose their words. You're not going to go into a company that's [00:28:00] going to tell you blatantly, you know, we disregard safety so we can meet our numbers. You know, a lot of them are going to expose like, Oh, no, safety is our number one priority. And if you need to slow down, go ahead and slow down, we support you. But yet the words that they're choosing are being received by the people that are out there doing the dangerous work as, Oh boy, we need to get this done and we need to get people to realize you don't need to compromise safety for performance or vice versa. You can be a very high performing team and be really safe at your job as well. We can do both at the same time. That is absolutely possible. So there's definitely that idea of the pressure driven situations where leaders may not want to step up and say something. Leaders may not want to what they see as rock the boat, and that was one of my things that held me back with not speaking up with Emmanuel.
Patrick Nelson: [00:28:59] Look, we're [00:29:00] we're in a combat zone. I don't want to have to yell at him. You know, he's just trying to come and help. I don't want to say anything and have to get into him and. It's like I found out the consequences of not speaking up, and so one of the things is not knowing how to have those difficult conversations with people we don't like as humans. We don't like conflict. The majority of us, we do not like conflict. We're going to shy away from it. And again, one of the reasons is because we think, you know, if we go tell somebody that they're doing something wrong or give them that negative developmental critical or whatever nomenclature you put on that feedback is it's going to cause some adversity or tension there in that relationship, and we don't want that. However, there are absolutely ways to be able to have those conversations to take sort of that judgment that comes out of it, and it's really just focusing on the behavior of that person and try to make it as objective as possible. [00:30:00] And for me, it really starts with empathy, and empathy is really kind of been a buzzword in leadership circles over the last couple of years. But it comes down to empathy, and a lot of people think of empathy as this very soft and cuddly type thing. And you know, I come from I was in a unit full of paratroopers, one hundred and twenty alpha males in that unit, and I can tell you, I learned a lot about empathy.
Patrick Nelson: [00:30:26] It's just what it really is. It's being able to see things from somebody else's perspective. You know, I'm not for treating everybody the same. I'm for treating everybody fairly. And its leadership is not a one size fits all approach to everybody, I had the opportunity to work with the diverse team of soldiers from all different walks of life and from all different areas across our country and even the world. And the one size fits all approach doesn't always work. You know, I'd have those soldiers where I could yell at them till I'm [00:31:00] blue in the face and it just would not get across or I'd have them where I just had to raise my voice just a little bit. And that was it. They understood. And so it's being able to really know your people and how to have those conversations. You got to know what motivates them. And I'm not talking about, you know, money or bonuses, right? Nobody's coming to work if they're not getting paid. We know that. But there are still reasons that people have chosen that job, especially in the market. Today, you can go out there and you can get a paycheck down the road. Almost any other place right now. There are reasons that they are right there in your organization and you need to find out what those intrinsic motivators are and really leverage those in your relationship and how you communicate with that person.
Peter Koch: [00:31:50] Let's take a quick break. In our experience here at MEMIC, successful companies are safe companies, and those companies have good leaders from front line seasonal supervisors [00:32:00] to middle management and beyond. Growing the leadership team is a critical part of that success. MEMIC recognizes the value of leadership and safety, and that not all supervisors and managers have had formal leadership training. That's why we've created a series of resources and workshops specifically for supervisors and managers called integrating safety into business goals from the breakdown of three basic skills every supervisor needs through how recognition works and conflict management. Integrating safety into business goals is a great starting point for developing your leadership team. Already, a MEMIC policyholder then reach out to your MEMIC Safety Management consultant for more information about these resources. And if you're not already a policyholder and you're interested in how MEMIC can partner with you for workplace safety, contact your independent insurance agent and ask about MEMIC. Now, let's get back to today's episode.
Peter Koch: [00:33:00] Yeah, [00:33:00] it's great, so tie in for me, like how you how you use the power of stories to connect in and bring the message of safety because. I think it's easy to talk about success as a company and you can get recognition because you're successful as a company and we met our numbers here, but safety is one of those weird things where it's the measurement of the negative right. It's the measurement of the thing that doesn't happen. And yeah, you can only save so much money from an insurance standpoint, and you can show that you saved this much money because we didn't have this many people get hurt, but there are people who will look at that and go, Well, it's because we worked harder because we were luckier because of this or because of that. So. Engaging people in safety with the power of a story to help with that empathy, I think is key. So how does that how does that work together for you? How do you see using a story to tie [00:34:00] safety or make safety important for people?
Patrick Nelson: [00:34:03] Yeah, again, it absolutely comes down to engaging people, and in my experiences, I found that telling those personal brief, powerful stories is what really can get people's attention. And you know what? Three weeks or three months down the road, they may not remember every single word that you said, but they're going to remember how you made them feel. And so I really focus on that emotional aspect of it, things that people can easily relate to any time you start telling a story and you're using the words my son or daughter, my mother or father, brother, sister, right? People start to be able to pay attention. And through some of the work that I've done with some clients is I helped equip some of those people with the stories. And at first, I honestly did not know how it would translate into the civilian world again. [00:35:00] I had all that great experience in the military, very bureaucratic organization. My soldiers had to listen to me. They didn't have much of a choice. But again, I think a leader is somebody who influences outcomes and inspires others. Is that about being in control or having power, notoriety, prestige? Anyways, I digress. Telling personal stories and equipping them with every single person, I saw the impact that it can have. So these organizations I work with, they've the numbers are there, right? They've seen that decrease in their recordable incident rate. Like you were saying, the business case, we all know the business case for safety is there. But more than anything, it's that personal and moral obligation that we all have to take care of each other. And what's even more interesting, Peter. Is that I help equip these people with their own what I call a safety stump speech and some of the most powerful ones that I [00:36:00] heard and ones that really helped move the needle on safety had nothing to do with an incident on a job site. I've heard people tell very personal stories of, you know, accidents at home, accidents or situations that they even heard about, or that one of their friends or family were involved. And those are the type of stories when somebody can get up there and they start getting tears in their eyes and they tell these people, Look, I care about you. And I'm here to help you and to keep you safe. It's really developing that connection and engagement with the person. Again, it may not be remembering every single word that that person says in that story, but it's really that connection that's built. And it gets people to start to take ownership over safety. I mean, again, that I go into all these clients and that's what they say. We want our employees to start taking ownership of safety and in order to get their, [00:37:00] well one, it obviously has to start at the top and be mirrored up there because as humans, we have a tendency to mirror the behavior of others around us. So if people up there are not doing the right thing, I can expect others to be able to do the same. And the second thing is it's being able to empower people. To be able to tell their story and to share it with others, giving them the opportunities, and again, as you know, as a safety expert, Peter. It's about being proactive.
Peter Koch: [00:37:31] Yeah, it really is. As you were talking about that, what was coming to mind for me is something you said earlier on was the words that you use are important when you are addressing somebody. From a safety standpoint, because it helps them engage, and if you promote that storytelling within your company and again, whether it's storytelling that happens because of an incident that occurred at your business or it's a personal story. I think that emotional connection can almost be like [00:38:00] this guy or gal cares. So when you're going to build that kind of emotional trust bank up with that person so that when you come back to them later on and you're in that moment, you have that, only you have that millisecond to make a decision. And you might not be able to be warm and fuzzy in that moment to tell that person that put their PPE back on or to put the lockout back on that or to get off the frickin top of the ladder or whatever it is.
Patrick Nelson: [00:38:31] Right
Peter Koch: [00:38:33] They are going to know that you have their back and they're going to look at you and go, OK, he's not just being a jerk. He really cares and I'm going to do that and that's going to pay it forward later on. I think there's a key part in that. That's an awesome thought using stories that way. Patrick, thanks for connecting that for me.
Patrick Nelson: [00:38:54] Yeah. Well, you're welcome. I love that you said the emotional trust bank. I never heard that before, [00:39:00] but I am going to be taking that now, and I'm going to help people open their own emotional trust bank in those relationships because I think that's important. What's interesting is you're reminded me of the very first platoon leader I had on my first deployment to Afghanistan. He was a guy by the name of John Post. And a young lieutenant, a few years removed from West Point, what this guy lacked in experience he more than made up for in his leadership behavior. So this was the type of guy and I've seen him do it. He could sit you down and tell you the 12 different ways you sucked at life, but you leave the conversation with a smile on your face. Ready to charge up that proverbial hill because you knew he cared about you. You knew he had your best interests in mind, and he was going to give you every single resource that you needed to be successful.
Peter Koch: [00:39:48] Yeah, and that's hard work as a leader. I mean, it really is hard. It's harder than going and doing the job that your, that your guys are doing or your gals are doing like that technical [00:40:00] skill of doing the job is one thing and you as a leader, you probably came from that world. You came, you got your job as a leader, as a foreman or a supervisor or a manager because you were good at that job or you were good at the tasks that you are now leading people in. But I think the harder part is connecting with those people and making sure that you are able to motivate them to do the right thing when you're not there, right? So that, you know, as a leader, when you go away and you have to manage the other project that these people understand what the expectations are and they're doing it for the right reasons. Because if they're only doing it, going back to our initial part of this conversation, when you're doing the pre shift meeting or pre-deployment meeting. And you're just checking the boxes if they're only doing it because they're checking the boxes that guaranteed at [00:41:00] some point in time, they're going to take that shortcut. And if you're not there to take advantage of the moment, somebody else on your team needs to be there to take advantage of the moment and if you haven't built that, trust up. It's not going to happen. It's just not going to happen.
Patrick Nelson: [00:41:14] Absolutely.
Peter Koch: [00:41:15] Right on. You know, thinking about influence there before I became the risk manager at the ski area that I worked at. You know, I was the patrol director and I was like, Oh, I figured all this safety stuff out and I got responsibility for being the risk manager. And the first phone call that I took as the risk manager was from a father. And it was a father of a young, like a 16 year old girl who was getting her first job as a lift operator or a lift attendant at the ski area. And he called me up and he had worked in the local mill. We have a paper mill within our area. And he was a supervisor and a manager up there. And so he gets working around equipment. I mean, he knows what [00:42:00] can happen if you make a mistake, if you get in the way of equipment is not going to stop, you know, equipment plus people, you add them together the equipment's almost always going to win and in the phone call, he said to me, it's like I expect you to make sure that my daughter has all the tools that she needs in order to be safe on the job. And I remember that meeting with this guy, I don't remember his name because it was a fairly brief, it might have been a five or six minute phone call. But I remember that conversation because it really made me think about the responsibility that I had, even just as a safety person who has. And if there's a safety person and I know there are listening to this podcast today, you are that individual that has all the responsibility for safety, but no authority. So I'm thinking, Wow, now I'm this guy is looking at me and I'm [00:43:00] responsible for his daughter's safety, and I need to know whether or not the lift op. supervisor has all the tools to help keep this guy safe. So then I have to develop a relationship with the lift ops. manager, a supervisor, so that I can influence him to make changes if he needs to. Because I didn't have any authority over his position, all I could do is offer him resources. And if I hadn't built up trust with him so that he knows that I've got his back, then it's just going to be a head nod. And as soon as I go away, he's back to his old jobs and tasks. And the successful part of that story was that the girl was successful. She had a great season. She enjoyed it really well. Got a thank you note from the dad at the at the end of the season and we went on from there. That was 25 or so years ago, but those little, those little connections of who is going to influence you. And it's typically because you will remember the [00:44:00] emotional connection of that particular story. That's pretty awesome.
Patrick Nelson: [00:44:06] Yeah, absolutely, I mean, again, that's just reinforces exactly what we're talking about here. It happens in moments and we remember again, like you said, that emotional connection that we build with another person, that's what we're going to carry forward.
Peter Koch: [00:44:19] Yeah, awesome. So I have another thought here to maybe explore with you a little bit. And it's about it's about role perception, right? And how that affects an individual's decision to say something or not say something. And it kind of goes back to that that leaders piece, right? So if I'm a leader and you might be the designated leader or you might be working in a team where you are all peers. So the leader is not physically present in your work group at that time and you're all peers. The diffusion of responsibility, right? So it's not my job type [00:45:00] of piece. How does role perception like somebody's role perception fit into their choosing to take advantage of the moment and say something or hide in the background and not take advantage of that? I'm not sure if I've asked that question well enough, but can you? You think about that and maybe throw that around in the safety mix for a bit?
Patrick Nelson: [00:45:22] Yeah. Well, you know, I can relate it to my experiences that I've had, especially here in the civilian world with the companies that I've had the pleasure of working with in a lot of it comes down honestly to culture. And again, if people are taking ownership, are we empowering these employees to be able to speak up, to be able to make decisions in the absence of maybe that person who's technically in charge? And there's several different ways. Are we empowering people to stop the job? I mean, it never fails when I go into an organization and [00:46:00] I start asking, Hey, who here can stop the job? And they said, Well, anybody can. And then I said, Well, how do they know? We tell them every single day. And then I ask them if they one hundred percent believe that every single person out there would stop the job if they saw an incident or didn't know something. And of course, the answer is no right. You can tell them to your blue in the face, but there's misconceptions out there where people don't feel empowered. One of them is when it comes to stop the job. There are some people, unfortunately, that think when you say stop the job or whatever again nomenclature you put on, it means you're hitting this big red button and you're shutting everything down. Stopping the job could mean those are the very rare circumstances, right? Right. Stopping the job. You mean you're just taking a step back. You're asking a question to get some clarity or something may have changed. And then you diving back into your work. Another thing that hampers that empowerment of people is they think they're going to get in trouble if they stop the job. [00:47:00] And a lot of that kind of comes back to that having that pressure on us to perform to meet some type of number. People think they're going to get in trouble. Now again, that's usually not happening. But as humans, we have this innate fear that if we do something wrong or if we slow things down, or if it's not the right reason, we're going to get in trouble for it. And so one thing that I tried to make clear to people is you need to go out there and you need to stop the job and you stop the job one. Maybe it's for no reason, but to show them you're not hitting this big red button. And that's OK to do so because I would rather have somebody out in the job nine hundred and ninety nine times out of a thousand because they didn't know something in order to catch up. One reason that prevented an immediate incident from happening. Because those nine hundred and ninety nine other times are learning opportunities, chances for us as leaders to help grow and develop those around us. So it's really [00:48:00] about being able to empower people to make those decisions to feel comfortable, to be able to speak up. And again, a lot of it points back to just people taking individual ownership over their safety at work. Nobody is getting paid enough to not go home at the end of their shift. Nobody wants to be that person knocking on the door, picking up that phone, letting that little girl or boy know their mommy or daddy is not coming home. Nobody ever wants to be in that position. But yet we don't talk about it. And so I think whether you're a large organization or a small organization is having those conversations. And again, just I think a lot of it goes back to being proactive when it comes to safety.
Peter Koch: [00:48:48] That's interesting. I want to clarify something here. I think I heard you say that. As an example to kind of lead by that example, to stop the job, to get people to understand is as a leader, [00:49:00] go and stop a job. Right.
Patrick Nelson: [00:49:04] Ya. Absolutely.
Peter Koch: [00:49:05] How many leaders do that like? I think so. If you're listening and you're a leader, how many times have you gone onto a job and stop the job to ask a question? And that's all you're asking. That's all you're doing. You're just asking a question for clarification. And it might be you're stopping the job for a moment, and it might be your stopping the job for 15 minutes because of the complexity of the question that you're asking. But have you actually done that? And whether it be because you see a problem or because you're just going to show that it is possible to stop the job?
Patrick Nelson: [00:49:39] Yeah, absolutely. And another point with that is whether you are a HSC safety professional or that's an additional duty or you're just a leader coming around and checking on your people. People should not pucker up when you come around thinking you're coming to catch them doing something wrong. If people are doing that, [00:50:00] then your visibility on the floor on the job site could use some work. You know,
Peter Koch: [00:50:08] Agreed.
Patrick Nelson: [00:50:10] People should get excited when you come around, they should, you know, like, all right, he's here, you know, it shouldn't be some big surprise, like you're once a year sort of visit again. I know you've got other tasks and responsibilities that might tie you to the desk for a little bit. And I always have people say, Well, I wish I was able to spend more time in the field with my guys. Well, apparently you're not making it a priority.
Peter Koch: [00:50:31] Surprise, right?
Patrick Nelson: [00:50:33] Some of those other tasks are tasks that are tying down to that desk and delegate them to somebody else.
Peter Koch: [00:50:39] Yeah, that's you know, that was when I went from and again, so interesting job career path for me to get where I am. But I was a ski bum to start with, got a job as a ski school instructor, was a patroller for a while and then I moved from a patroller to the patrol director's job. And when I got the patrol director's job, I had [00:51:00] gone from skiing. I don't know, maybe one hundred and twenty to one hundred and thirty days a year, which is I'm pretty excited about that. Like, I like doing that to pushing a lot of paper right and dealing with all that stuff. And I remember having that same thought. I wish I could get out more. And so the thing that got me to do that was when I got in in the morning. The first thing that I did before I did anything else was I put my ski boots on, and if I hadn't, if I didn't put my ski boots on, I was destined to ride desk jockey for the rest of the day and deal with stuff that's happened in the office. But if I had my boots on, I had an excuse to go out and almost ninety five percent of the time if I had my boots on, I was going to be out for a few hours to be able to go out with my guys and gals and see what was going on out there and build that relationship. But I had to choose to do it. It didn't just happen magically, and you can't look at your boss and go, I don't have enough time [00:52:00] to be out there in the field because I have so much stuff to do. Your boss isn't going to go well. We'll take away some of that responsibility, pay you the same amount so that you can go deal with your people, you have to be able to figure that out. You might be able to go to your boss and talk about strategy. But don't expect the responsibilities to get lessened so that you can go out and do that, part of a leader is figuring out how you connect with your people.
Patrick Nelson: [00:52:26] Yeah, that's absolutely what it is. And I like to ask people, I say, Look, are you a manager or a leader? Now you can be both. But those are very distinct positions. You manage things, data processes, equipment schedules, but you lead people. And it's kind of hard to lead people if you're not out there with them.
Peter Koch: [00:52:47] Yep. Great point, great point. And I think we lose that in the in the cluster of everything that's going on, I think we do lose that and to be a good leader, there's a balance because in order to be a good leader, you [00:53:00] need to be able to spend some of that focus time to understand the impact of the product of the work that your people are doing. So you have those conceptual skills to be able to see where things are going. But then you also have to have some of those human and technical skills to be in the field, to ask good questions, to lend a hand. Maybe if you need to lend a hand in the field, that's awesome.
Patrick Nelson: [00:53:22] Right. Absolutely. And you know, you can ask anybody what good leadership looks like and we all know it. We all know what good leadership looks like. I'll sit there and I'll ask people, I'll give them a piece of paper and say, Build me a perfect leader right there right now, whether they're accountable and empathetic and good communicators, good listeners, and that laundry list of things that we know go into making somebody good leader now look. I've been a leader in the military, I've lead people in combat. I teach leadership now and I don't encompass all of those things. We know a good leadership looks like. But it takes work to be able to do that [00:54:00] and exactly like you're saying. I mean, there's twenty five different other things that are pulling us in different directions. You got emails and reports and conference calls and meetings and. Again, it's being able to as a leader to find that balance. And again, a lot of it might come down to being able to delegate. And one thing I like to say is like, Look, you can delegate authority, but you can't delegate responsibility as a leader because when it comes down to it, it is still your responsibility.
Peter Koch: [00:54:30] Yeah, your responsibility to make that choice, to see the moment and act in that moment, act in that moment. That's great. Awesome. Well, gosh, it's almost been an hour. Holy cow. This has gone really fast, actually. So I guess, you know, we started this thing talking about stories and how the power of stories can really connect with your with your team and help build [00:55:00] that emotional trust up and then be able to help you connect with them to make safety important. You had mentioned you had another story that you might want to share, and I wonder if you want to lay that on us here?
Patrick Nelson: [00:55:13] Yeah, absolutely. You know, I love sharing this story because again, it just shows the impact that we can have on those around us. So this was February of 2019. My wife and I are coming home from church on a Sunday morning. We're making it right at a stoplight and it goes into two lanes. And I can see ahead that something is blocking traffic. People are starting to merge over. And as we creep closer, there's about five or six guys from the instant oil change business that's right there on the side of the street, and they're pounding on the windows of this car that's blocking traffic. And as I get closer, I see there's an older gentleman slumped over in the driver's seat. Again, they're pounding on the windows, trying to get this guy's attention traffic's blocking [00:56:00] like these guys got this under control, so I shoot right on by. But I did not get very far because my wife turns to me and she said, if that was you or my dad, I want you to stop because you know what you're doing. And she was right. I came back around the block. I parked, I ran out there by then. They had busted the back window. They had gotten the guy out onto the road. One guy was doing chest compressions. Five others were standing around their thumbs up there you know what? So I did what we're trained to do, I went up to his head, I put my jacket under a head tilt and lift, started clearing his airway with all the chest compressions, food and other not nice stuff were coming and blocking that airway. So I'm fish hook in some nasty stuff out of this guy's throat to clear that airway. Me and this guy are tag-team and CPR. I still hadn't heard the siren, so I started to question, OK, did anybody even call 9-1-1? I could barely detect [00:57:00] a pulse on this guy. He looked like he was dead. But Peter, out of nowhere, like Clark Kent coming out of the phone booth, this guy shows up with an AED, a guy driving in a car. He's not an off duty EMT, he's not part of a volunteer fire department. He's a guy in a car driving by. And he stops and he gets the AED, and I'm sure most people listening have been through the training. If you haven't, it talks you through it. It is dummy proof. We get it hooked up, give them a big old shock. We continue CPR. Finally, the ambulance arrives. We let them take over. I go back to my car and go home. And of course, now all I'm thinking about is that guy. Like, What's his status? Later that afternoon, I call the non-emergency number and the Public Safety Office because I have to ask knowing that they're probably not going to tell me anything, but I have to ask. And they said when we dropped him off at the hospital. Things [00:58:00] weren't looking too good. He had gone over 10 minutes without oxygen to his brain. Later that evening on a neighborhood Facebook page, people are talking about this incident and somebody shares in the comments, they said, Yeah, that was Carl from the Home Depot. So Monday morning, I wake up and I'm in Home Depot and I'm asking around about Carl if anybody knows anything and they said yeah, it's not looking too good. And Tuesday morning, I go back into the Home Depot. Same thing Wednesday, same thing. Thursday, I go in and they said Carl's sitting up in his hospital bed telling jokes. He had a major clog the Windowmaker artery that put a couple of stents, then he was going to be OK. Now, fast forward four months later, and I'm in Home Depot for like the fourth or fifth time that day because I'm not a DIY guy. I can barely change the light bulb in my house, according to my wife. We needed something hung up on the wall. We call her dad. But anyways, again, I [00:59:00] digress and I run into Carl. And I said, Carl, the last time I saw you, you were laying in the middle of the road and fish hooking pieces of your lunch out of your throat. And now I like to share that story, Peter, because. First of all, I could not save Carl's life, I played a very, very minor role, but a role that would not have happened basically if my wife didn't have the courage to speak up. To kind of stop the job and say, Hey. We need to do something. The guy with the AED is the one who saved Carl's life. He had the courage to stop. He could have easily been sucked into the diffusion of responsibility been like, Oh, that crowd over there. They got that under control. The ambulance is probably going to be here in like forty five seconds. And he could have just shot right on by that guy, had the courage to stop and to do something. Our words and our actions can have such a tremendous impact [01:00:00] on those around us or our lack thereof. Now, if you speak up and say something. Point out a safety incident you may not never know. What you truly prevented from happening, but if you don't speak up. Sooner or later, you're going to find out, just like I did, by not speaking up and telling Emanuel to put on his helmet by me, not wearing my helmet. Sooner or later, you're going to find out what your inaction can cause and so, you know, sharing that it's almost sort of the circle of life almost right, it's my decision to not speak up because again, it was a decision that I made to not say something. And Emanuel losing his life, but then that man in that car who stopped at the AED who made the decision to stop and to put into [01:01:00] action that AED and save Carl's life. I mean, that's the kind of stuff that's really going to move the needle on safety. It's not going to be. Here's the hottest new piece of PPE that's going to save your life. Here's the newest OSHA regulation that's going to move the needle. It's going to be getting people to start taking safety, personal,
Peter Koch: [01:01:18] Personal and relational, personal and relational. You've got to connect it back with them. Thank you very much for sharing that, and it is cool how there is that circle in there where you know the lack of choice versus the. Even though it was kind of a forced choice because, you know, sometimes you have that like you, you will see the moment. And you will start to pass by the moment choosing not to act, but then there'll be somebody or something else that'll smack you upside the head and go, Hey, dummy. That's your moment. That's your moment. And we all have those moments. And I think out of all of this, I'm hoping that people will [01:02:00] recognize the different moments that they have as they go through their life and as they go through their work that they can substantially influence the outcome of someone else's life if they take advantage of that moment. Awesome, thank you so much, Patrick, for sharing, for sharing your expertise and sharing your stories with us very, very engaging. I really have enjoyed listening and talking with you. So before we go, where can our listeners find out more about loyalty point leadership and more about you? As you know, as a speaker, as a leader, as a connector for leadership and for safety.
Patrick Nelson: [01:02:47] Yeah, absolutely. You know, www.loyaltypointleadership.com find me on LinkedIn, Patrick Nelson loyalty point leadership. I'd love [01:03:00] to engage with anybody that wants to talk safety. I'd love to be a resource for you going forward and I'd love to learn from you. It's important leadership, a journey. It's not a destination. It's not like you go to some sort of leadership class and you get blessed off and now your leader go forth. You're good to go. We learn something from everybody, and I learned something from being on the podcast here today with you, Peter, that emotional trust bank. I'm going to carry that with me. That's going to be something. You can find me 10 years down the road and I'm going to be talking about that. So I appreciate that. And yes, would love for people to stay in touch.
Peter Koch: [01:03:37] Thank you, Patrick. Thank you very much. Thanks for joining us today and to all of our listeners out there today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, we've been speaking about leadership and engaging people in safety with Patrick Nelson, CEO of Loyalty Point Leadership, and about engaging your team. And he's been gracious enough to spend an hour with us today and talk about that. So again, thank you for [01:04:00] that, Patrick.
Patrick Nelson: [01:04:01] You're welcome. Have a great day.
Peter Koch: [01:04:03] Thanks. And if you all have any questions about leadership, safety or like to hear more about a particular topic on our podcast, email me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show notes for today's podcast at MEMIC.com/podcast, where you can find out more about Patrick or other leadership podcasts that we've had, and then our entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for our safety net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates, and if you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it. If you took a minute to review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whatever podcast service that you found us on. And if you've already done that, thanks because it really, truly helps us spread the word about safety. So please consider sharing the show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support and until next time, this is Peter Koch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you [01:05:00] learned here is even better.
Back in 1892, President Grover Cleveland signed a law making the first Monday in September of each year the Labor Day holiday. Do you know the history and the struggle of the American worker that pre-dates this historic day? On this podcast, Randy Klatt, Director or Region 2 Loss Control here at MEMIC helps me explore what it was like to be a worker in the late eighteen and early nineteen hundreds and workplace injuries, fatalities, child labor, and deplorable conditions were the catalysts for fair wages, the 8 hour workday, and workplace safety.
Wage Trends, 1800-1900 (nber.org)
Age of workers
Lewis Hine - Photographer
These Appalling Images Exposed Child Labor in America - HISTORY
The Photographs of Lewis Hine: The Industrial Revolution and Child Laborers [Photo Gallery] | EHS Today
Teaching With Documents: Photographs of Lewis Hine: Documentation of Child Labor | National Archives
Search Results: "Hine, Lewis Wickes, 1874-1940" - Prints & Photographs Online Catalog (Library of Congress) (loc.gov)
Search Results: "" - Prints & Photographs Online Catalog (Library of Congress) (loc.gov)
Achievements in Public Health, 1900-1999: Improvements in Workplace Safety -- United States, 1900-1999 (cdc.gov)
History of Workplace Safety — SafetyLine Lone Worker
Deadliest Workplace Accidents | American Experience | Official Site | PBS
Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire - HISTORY
Child Workers and Workplace Accidents: What was the Price Paid for Industrializing America? – Our Great American Heritage
(1857) Frederick Douglass, "If There Is No Struggle, There Is No Progress" • (blackpast.org)
Haymarket Riot - HISTORY
https://www.dol.gov/general/laborday/history
Labor Day 2021: Facts, Meaning & Founding - HISTORY
History of Labor Day | U.S. Department of Labor (dol.gov)
Deadliest Workplace Accidents | American Experience | Official Site | PBS
History of the Holidays: Labor Day | History
#82 - Comparative wages, prices, and cost of living : (from the Sixteenth ... - Full View | HathiTrust Digital Library
History of The US Minimum Wage - From The Very First Minimum Wage (bebusinessed.com)
Profile of work injuries incurred by young workers (bls.gov)
History of Workplace Safety in the United States, 1880-1970 (eh.net)
Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast. I'm your host, Peter Koch, as we're about to celebrate Labor Day. I expect that you're getting up and gearing up for family and friends around the pool, the barbecue, the yard, getting people together, trying to enjoy that day off. Well, while you're doing that? Have you ever thought about where we get the Labor Day holiday from, where did it hey come from? Why do we have it? Why was it even started in the first place? So for today's episode, how workplace safety influenced Labor Day and vice versa. Celebrating the American worker. I'm speaking with Randy Klatt, CSP director of Region two, lost control here at MEMIC. Randy leads a team of consultants serving the central and southern Maine area. So, Randy, welcome back to the podcast. I'm excited to have you on to talk about Labor Day today.
Randy Klatt: [00:00:55] Thank you, Peter. It's always great to talk to you. Happy holiday.
Peter Koch: [00:00:59] Yeah, it's coming [00:01:00] right up here. And, you know, I was thinking about, well, the podcast and MEMIC and what our mission is to get out there and to work with companies to help keep workers safe. And I was thinking about the Labor Day holiday. And I'm like, you know what? I've enjoyed the Labor Day holiday now. I've enjoyed time off or on the Labor Day holiday. But what is it? Where to come from? And that got me to thinking having a conversation with you actually around. Well, what was it like to be a worker? Well, before our time being a worker, before our parents, and probably before our grandparents, maybe around the time of our great grandparents, because prior to, you know, the early nineteen hundreds. Labor Day didn't exist. And I think we kind of take it for granted. So let's talk about that. What was it like to be a worker in, say, the late eighteen hundreds and what were the conditions? What was going on? And I know [00:02:00] you've been doing a little bit of reading. I've been doing some reading, too. We certainly don't have any firsthand experience, even though we're both a little grayer than we were last year. We're not that gray yet. But there are some fascinating history about work in the late eighteen hundreds. What do you think it was like out there?
Randy Klatt: [00:02:18] Oh, I think it was pretty horrible, quite frankly. And there is plenty of gray. In fact, I am all gray now. So thanks for the plug. But that's the way it is. Yeah, it we when we think of the industrial revolution, we sometimes think about progress and automation and heavy machinery and, you know, the wonderful products and everything that we developed and could put out there. What we don't really think about often enough is the workers who actually made all that happen. And often the horrendous conditions that they had to work under and for what we would really call minimal pay and no benefits whatsoever. [00:03:00]
Peter Koch: [00:03:01] So some of the benefits you got to go home maybe at the end of the day.
Randy Klatt: [00:03:06] Yeah, that was your benefit. Maybe one day off a week and maybe enough money to put a little food on the table and keep a roof over your head, if you were lucky. It was really quite horrendous. If you look at some of the statistics regarding how much people were paid in your average manufacturing facility and, you know, the textile mills or the steel mills. It's an eye opener, even in today's standards, if you adjust these things for inflation and when you're when you're making 55 cents an hour in 1860, I'm sorry, per day. That's easy to confuse, isn't it? Fifty five cents a day. Not per hour. You know, bring that to today's standards. It's still poultry. It's just amazing. [00:04:00]
Peter Koch: [00:04:00] Yeah. It's really hard to think that you could live on that. And I think that's why you had multiple people in the same family, from dad to mom many times, all the way down to the kids going out and getting a job instead of going to school or maybe after school if they had the opportunity to go to school, because, you know, you add 55 cents a day up and it doesn't go very far when you've got to purchase food and pay for rent and mend clothes and all of the things that come with just the daily burden of life.
Randy Klatt: [00:04:39] Right. And you add to that the strenuous physical labor that was involved in most cases, and then the hazardous conditions. We go into manufacturing facilities today and we see some things that are well in our world. They're pretty scary. Oh, my gosh. You really need a guard on that in [00:05:00] running nip point. Well, take that back a hundred and twenty years ago, and there were things spinning and turning and pulling every which way all over the building, and no one gave it a second thought. And you sent people in there to work in close proximity to all of that every day and just accept it, because if you don't want this job for fifty five cents a day, then someone else will. Yeah. So you're almost a commodity to me is if you're not going to work, then we'll find someone else who will. Because these are good jobs. Fifty five cents a day. Oh, my goodness.
Peter Koch: [00:05:38] And really, some of the only jobs, you know, when we started to see the advent of us moving from that agrarian society to the advent of the industrial revolution and people moving into cities and towns to be closer to where the work is, because they couldn't find jobs or the jobs were too taxing in the agrarian culture, [00:06:00] in agriculture and farming, getting those better jobs in manufacturing and textiles and steel and construction and carpentry, just kind of looking more at some of those wages. You know, the difference in that that textile manufacturing, daily wage of 55 cents in 1860, you could make a whole dollar, 40 a day as a skilled carpenter. Just a few years later, in in the later eighteen hundreds. So depending on what job you had, I mean, you could you could earn some decent wages rather than just being a farmhand for a while or again, dealing with all the hazards that we knew about within the agricultural society and working on a farm, getting kicked by a cow or getting caught up in some of the horse or ox driven equipment to plow the fields and the hours that were there moving into the or moving into the cities. Sometimes, [00:07:00] you know, you're trading maybe one evil for another, but you're getting paid more for it.
Randy Klatt: [00:07:08] Yeah. And if not more, you're actually being paid if you work a full day in most cases. Anyway, you were actually paid for that day. When you're on the farm, any farmer out there today understands this. Clearly, it's still the case. Mother Nature rules the day. And you just might not have the crop this fall or to harvest. And you don't have enough to feed your family, much less to sell to actually make a living. So seeing these jobs was an attraction for people. Nevertheless, it was still not what we would call desirable in the way of a job today. I was interested how Andrew Carnegie got his start. Most people know who Andrew Carnegie was. And, you know, the forerunner to U.S. Steel Corporation, my gosh, in [00:08:00] the railroads and all kinds of industry. And at one point was the richest man in America. He actually started his first job in this country in 1848 at the ripe old age of 12. And he was a bobbin boy, changing the spools of thread in a cotton mill. And he had to work 12 hours a day, six days a week. So he did have one day off. And for that, what, 72 hours of labor for a 12 year old boys starting wage was a dollar twenty per week. So even adjusted to it by inflation or with inflation over the years, that equal that's equivalent to about thirty six dollars in today's numbers. Can you imagine telling a 12 year old today that I'd like you to work 72 hours this week and I'm going to pay you thirty six dollars to do it?
Peter Koch: [00:08:59] I think the conversation [00:09:00] would have stopped at work.
Randy Klatt: [00:09:04] Well, quite possibly.
Peter Koch: [00:09:06] Good. And then you get into all the rest of the reasons you don't want to work is the limited wage. And how come I don't have a day off and. Well, you have one day off but it's not enough days off. And yeah, there's a lot of challenges out there.
Randy Klatt: [00:09:20] Yeah, you probably have to pay your babysitter thirty six dollars to watch your kids for a couple, two or three hours when you go out for an evening.
Peter Koch: [00:09:27] For sure.
Randy Klatt: [00:09:28] Can you imagine that
Peter Koch: [00:09:31] You had mentioned this just a bit ago, too, about the conditions that you'd work in. And I doing some research for this looking or you can find so many different really amazing images of workers from this time frame. And one of the most prolific photographers that were out there is Louis Hine. And some of the most famous pictures that he has are from like the steelworkers having lunch [00:10:00] on the suspended beam. Therefore, I'm not sure what they were building, you remember what they were building in that particular picture, I can't recall.
Randy Klatt: [00:10:08] I don't remember which building it was. I believe it was New York City.
Peter Koch: [00:10:11] Yeah, I think it was to regardless. But that's the picture that people think of when they think of Louis Hines. However, when you start to look at other photos that he took, it's really representative of the American worker in the late. Eighteen hundreds, early nineteen hundreds. And there are thousands of photos which depict kids, really young kids, women, children, men all working together in some very dangerous occupations, whether it be textiles or in the fishing industry or in some of the other manufacturing industries where, you know, those in running nip points, you're surrounded by in running nip points. There's one of those photos we were talking about earlier [00:11:00] where there's a couple of kids standing on a mechanical loom right next to all the bobbins. And the caption is, they had to stand on the loom because they weren't tall enough to reach the bobbins that they had to change out.
Randy Klatt: [00:11:17] Yeah, exactly. So eight year olds, nine year olds working these 60, 70 hour weeks around this equipment with absolutely no regard to their safety, simply get the job done. And we see that mentality some today. You know, we've got to get the job done. So we bypassed some things, but certainly not to the scale that we were doing back then, and not just with adults, but with children full time employed as fish cutters. And yeah, they cut their hands a lot. But, you know, that's part of the job. We're going to just overlook that piece because we're paying them by box. [00:12:00] So, you know, piecework was also something that was fairly prevalent, too. So it simply encouraged people to do things quicker, faster, which, of course, is often less safe. But as long as they got the job done, then they were happy to go home with their twenty five cents because they were able to get four boxes of fish cut for the day and they were paid five cents a box. So woohoo. Yeah. And you just
Peter Koch: [00:12:26] Bring that extra money home to help the family get by for the week. And in those photos, you know, you often see adults with bandages or with a missing limb or a digit. And kids as well. There's a couple of images that I saw where, you know, it's captioned. You know, they're talking about the kid who has a big bandage on his hand, one of those fish cutters. And there's another photo there of all of the fish cutters, all the kids that were probably in one particular factory. And they all had knives [00:13:00] and some of the knives were as big as a kid's forearm, for crying out loud as long as the kids for he's holding this enormous knife out there. And you would be scared and today to hand a kid a knife like that. But if the kid came to work and he was part of the workforce, here you go. And the kids were proud of what they did. I mean, you can't take that away from the kids those days. I mean, they were working for their family. They were working for the wage. They were trying to do the best they can in some fairly deplorable conditions. Really challenging conditions.
Randy Klatt: [00:13:35] Absolutely. And it wasn't just the manufacturing facilities either. There some great photos of the newsies. You know, there was one of the most enjoyable musicals I've seen in the theater was newsies about a young boy selling newspapers. But the reality is you have seven and eight year olds out running around the streets before dawn trying to sell newspapers, and they're getting [00:14:00] paid pennies to do so. So industry during these this time and we're talking anywhere from eighteen fifties or sixties up through the turn of the century into 1920s, it was pretty darn brutal for most people in most occupations. Not to say that it was everyone, but a lot of people made some money. Mm hmm. Including Mr. Andrew Carnegie. There is a reason he became a multimillionaire and the richest man in America.
Peter Koch: [00:14:39] Certainly. And I think that's part of what we're celebrating today is we are celebrating. You know, the labor that the American worker, that through the courage and determination in some of those really challenging places allowed our country to be where it is today. And granted, we [00:15:00] are not in. The best place all the time, but we can certainly look at, especially around work, the work that we do and the innovations that have come out of the American worker and the labor force that's there. There's a lot that they've done and a lot that they've allowed us to do. And that we take for granted today. A lot of those things that we take for granted today, whether it be a day off or equal wage or a living wage, are things that came out of the labor force and is part of what Labor Day really is. And we'll talk about more of that kind of later on as we go, because we certainly didn't end with a photographer taking pictures of kids with bandages on their hands. That got us to Labor Day because there were you know, there were injuries and there are definitely fatalities that occurred. And individual fatalities happened probably more frequently than we thought. They're doing a little research. Again, there's [00:16:00] the death calendar. If you if you want to look it up and talking about an article about from achievements in public health. Nineteen hundred through 1999 and improvements in workplace safety. So there's a death calendar in industry. So all industries for Allegheny County. And it has the months of July through June in that order. And they have little red x's in each of the boxes where somebody has died. And sometimes there's one, sometimes there's multiple. And this is just one county where it occurred. And there are very few days that are blank or that do not have a red X in that calendar. It's a fairly stunning graphic to think about that back in that back in that time frame,
Randy Klatt: [00:16:49] I was really impressed with the impact that that calendar has. Well, first of all, how many times have we ever seen a death calendar? [00:17:00] I mean, that's just the topic. The title itself is pretty indicative of disaster. But nineteen O' six July through nineteen O' seven and June five hundred and twenty six workers. And you're right, it's hard to find a date there where there's no red X and many of them have multiple. That's just inconceivable. And that's, like you said, one county, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania. Oh, my goodness.
Peter Koch: [00:17:31] There's one week, August 19. Oh six where? Twenty one through twenty four. Those three days in there. Four days in there. There's an average, I think of probably four X's in each of those days, if I can peer through some of the blurriness of the reproduced image. So like one week you're talking close to 20 people, 20 people, different days, probably different occupations passed. [00:18:00] And never came back home from work. So there's that part again, where, you know, you have that that vision of leaving for work, kissing the family goodbye, saying goodbye to your girlfriend, your wife, kissing the kids, whatever, with the intent that you're going to be able to come back home and enjoy something of your labors for that day and your family to for you to come back home to. And you never do. Five hundred and twenty six people in that year in that county didn't come back in 1906, 1907.
Randy Klatt: [00:18:36] Yeah. When we look at the Bureau of Labor Statistics, as you alluded to earlier, statistics weren't well, they certainly weren't to the point where they are today. So much of it was manual and so much of this was undocumented. So who knows really how many people died. Those, I guess, are the ones that were identified. It could have been a whole lot more. But [00:19:00] we're talking twenty three thousand people a year, in some cases, working out through an equivalent of somewhere around sixty one deaths per 100000 workers. Today's rate is somewhere just over three. So we have certainly come a long, long way since those days.
Peter Koch: [00:19:24] Yeah, I think so. And you bring up a really good point around, you know, injuries, statistics being important because, you know, individual injuries and even individual fatalities will have you know, people will get focused on that and then you'll move off to the next thing. It was one person who got injured. It was one person who didn't come home. And it is a tragedy. But we don't tend to look at those individual incidences as critical. But only when you start to pull all of those statistics [00:20:00] together and you look at it as a whole. Did they become really powerful like the image that we were just talking about? So if you get a chance, go up and Google, search that death calendar for an industry for Allegheny County, and it'll pop up and you'll take a look at. And that's a really powerful image when you see all of those red Xs, because we live in an age where information is plentiful and it's easy to pull that trend together. It wasn't always that easy like you talked about before. And sometimes it really took like a mass casualty incident for workplace injuries or fatalities to get noticed beyond the immediate family and friends and the workers that it truly affected.
Peter Koch: [00:20:38] And our history of work is really riddled with those issues. And again, we didn't start keeping good records probably until the eighteen hundreds and into the nineteen hundreds. But you get back you know, there are some statistics back there from a website [00:21:00] called The Deadliest Workplace Accidents in the American Experience. So back in the late 60s in Lawrence, Massachusetts, the Pemberton mill, large cotton goods factory collapsed without warning and it killed one hundred and forty five workers and injuring another one hundred and sixty six. And again, an injury back in 1860 is not like an injury. It is today in two thousand twenty one. We're going to go to the doctor, going to get good treatment. Chances that you're going to make it out of the hospital whole and return to the workforce is pretty high. Back then, you had an injury. There's a good chance you never return to the workforce. And then instead of being part of the family growing, you became a burden because they needed to support you and you could no longer go back to work.
Randy Klatt: [00:21:49] Yeah. At that point, you became a real liability for everyone else, right? Yeah. We weren't talking about days of health insurance and disability insurance [00:22:00] and EMS coverage for your community. So you have emergency responders and fully manned fire departments. And we just that wasn't there. You get hurt. What are the odds that that's going to become infected or you're not going to get the right care? It could have been treated properly and you might get back to work, but there was no way to access the care. So you ended up with a disability for the rest of your life and no way to be compensated for that. It really is a sad part of this industrial revolution that we don't often think about. What did it really take and what are those mass casualty incidents that we really should know about? And then on Labor Day, look back and appreciate what people went through to get to where we are today.
Peter Koch: [00:22:53] Yeah, because even after Labor Day was thought about and initially [00:23:00] celebrated, Labor Day, initially was celebrated in the late eighteen hundreds, so 1882 was that first Labor Day celebration in New York. And there's a couple of myths out there, not myths, but stories out there about competing people who suggested that you gather the laborers together to celebrate labor and to hear people talk about labor and organized labor and what you could do as a as a community of laborers. Well, yeah, that's the first the first celebration, 1882. And they talk about Peter J. Maguire being from the Carpenters Union and then Matthew Maguire from the Machinists Union were the two guys that are credited with first bringing Labor Day into the forefront here in the Americas.
Randy Klatt: [00:23:50] Which obviously came from labor. And this wasn't recognized by anyone else, by the federal government or state government [00:24:00] or any other organization. It was the laborers who actually took the day off in 1882 unpaid to parade, to celebrate their accomplishments or to at least try to make people aware of the significant contribution they have.
Peter Koch: [00:24:16] Yeah, so and the power that you have together that the power that you have as a group to recognize that there are some challenges out there and to really fight for the rights of the American worker back then. And there was a lot to fight for back then. And still even after they celebrated Labor Day. And again, you alluded to it took the day off, not were given the day paid to have off and celebrate Labor Day with your family. The first labor days were people didn't go to work. It was almost like a protest. They didn't show up that day. They went to New York and they marched the Labor Day parade to go to Union Square in New York City and march, [00:25:00] almost in protest. So, yeah, it's an interesting piece. We celebrate Labor Day today as a holiday or as an opportunity. And they celebrated Labor Day really as a chance back then, which is pretty interesting.
Randy Klatt: [00:25:15] Indeed it is. And we're talking 1882. But if you look up some of the worst disasters in history and you started to read some of those, at least one of those on that list, there are all many years after those first Labor Day celebrations and even after it was actually a recognized federal holiday. So there were still a lot of struggles to be had down the road by workers to reach that equitable pay and equitable treatment and safer workplaces and all those things of the livable wage you mentioned earlier.
Peter Koch: [00:25:54] Yeah,
Randy Klatt: [00:25:54] It was still worth fighting for. And you still [00:26:00] had a pretty good chance of not coming home after going to work, especially if you were in heavy industry is still working in mining in particular. Oh, my gosh. Imagine being underground in a mine with the conditions they were in around the turn of the century.
Peter Koch: [00:26:18] Oh, my gosh. No, I can't. And some of those pictures from Lewis Hine were showed groups of boys, young boys who were working in the mines. And you read some of those descriptions and what they did and they were they were the ones that went places in the mines that are grown adult couldn't go. So not only were they exposed to all of the same exposures that are hazards that an adult would be in a mine, which back then was a myriad of things that weren't controlled, everything from air quality issues to explosives to all sorts of things that never really came into play until labor [00:27:00] started to look into it and say, we need to do something about this. But the boys were then, for like I guess lack of a better term, allowed to go wiggle their way in the places and place charges and find different passages where a full grown adult couldn't go. Being a little claustrophobic myself, I'm not sure that I could do that.
Randy Klatt: [00:27:22] Yeah, that wouldn't be on my list of to dos, that's for sure. And the worst mining disaster in American history occurred in nineteen O' seven. So just a few years after the turn of the century. And the wording just kind of gets to me when it describes this, the underground explosion. This was in West Virginia that kills three hundred and sixty two out of the three hundred and eighty men and boys working that day. Oh, my goodness.
Peter Koch: [00:27:55] That's it's almost a whole a whole community of people that were wiped out. You [00:28:00] know, it's three hundred men and boys, three hundred men and boys that, you know, had families to go back to. You've just cut out half of the population of probably a mining town, you know, within that one particular event that occurred.
Randy Klatt: [00:28:16] Exactly.
Peter Koch: [00:28:17] And it didn't stop there. And it wasn't just in the mines where things were really challenging. And we found a lot of a lot of people getting injured or killed. We talk about this often, especially if we're talking about the history of OSHA and where OSHA came out of and safety in America. One of the watershed moments, I think, in workplace safety came out of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire disaster that happened back in or on March 25th in 1911, which the history of that particular fire. Not even looking at pictures, just reading a [00:29:00] description of it can almost cause nightmares. It's pretty can be pretty scary.
Randy Klatt: [00:29:04] It sure can. And a well known incident that we've learned a lot about being in the worker's comp industry and knowing that this was one of the key moments that brought forth the need for some sort of compensation for injured and fatally injured workers. But I agree. You read the read the description of what happened when this factory started to burn and where the people attempted to evacuate when there are 600 workers in this building. And of course, the fire hoses weren't working because they were rotted and the bowels were rusted shut. And so their panic ensued as they tried to get out and only a few people could fit into the elevator at a time. So, of course, eventually that broke down with many people still trapped in the building. So many fell to [00:30:00] their deaths in the elevator shafts, trying to somehow escape the floor that was on fire. And so many died in the building. But then just to learn that there were 58 people who died jumping to the sidewalks from the building, it's just that is horrifying to think about the loss, a total of a hundred and forty six people.
Peter Koch: [00:30:22] Yeah, and in those the conditions in in how this all came about is the tragedy. I mean, I think I know when I've described part of this in a class before, people immediately think about 9/11 and those iconic images of people plummeting from the Twin Towers. And, you know, that's that is a horrible image to have fixed in your mind. And it is a horrible reason for those things to happen, to have a plane, a terrorist attack happen on our home soil [00:31:00] for that to occur. But in the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory, we did this to ourselves. Right. So the doors the exit doors were chained closed because management didn't want people taking breaks when they shouldn't be taking breaks. You know, I guess having someone work 12 hours a day, six days a week just isn't enough. Right. So. Got to make sure that they're not taking a break when they shouldn't. You know, the fire started in a rag bin. Right. So we look at this often. We go different places and we see a bin full of used oily rags in a maintenance facility. And we talk to people about, hey, this is going to combust at some point in time, like, yeah, we'll take care of it. We'll take care of it at the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory, something that we take for granted, the exit routes. Right. So your fire escapes were too narrow. There wasn't enough room on the fire escape to handle the occupancy [00:32:00] of the floor of the building. So when people went out to the fire escape, the fire escape collapsed. So consider that like oh fire. Right. So I'm going to go out and I'm going to go out. What I know is the fire escape, and I'm going to walk onto that. And I'm assuming that fire escape is going to hold me and it doesn't. And it collapses and prevents everyone else from escaping. And then considering the response and you said this early on, like we didn't we had some organized EMS, we had some especially in the cities, there was fire response. A lot of it was volunteer, some of it was professional. But the fire occurred on the eighth floor. The hoses only reached to the seventh floor like. So that math just doesn't add up. Right. So there's lots of things that we take for granted today that came out of these. Disasters. [00:33:00] One of those is workplace safety. In a in a focus on workplace safety, another one is building code and making sure that the building is able to support the number of people and what they're doing in there and how do they get out in the in the event of an emergency. And we tend to forget that these rules aren't there just so that our jobs can be more annoying. But they're there because there has been substantial issues. And they talk about this in the history of Triangle Shirtwaist, too, with like 18 minutes from the time of the fire to the time that was all done and all. One hundred and forty six people died. Eighteen minutes. That's crazy to think that that many people would die almost in an instant.
Peter Koch: [00:33:47] Let's take a quick break. Maybe you didn't know, but MEMIC is committed to making workers' comp work better for everyone. It's been our hallmark since day one. And through compassion, partnerships and a relentless commitment to workplace [00:34:00] safety, we make an impact, whether it's our claim specialist, connecting injured workers with the best medical care and helping them understand the worker's comp system or our safety specialist conducting training for frontline staff and workplace assessments with your supervisors. We understand your industry and how a robust safety program is a pillar of any successful company. Already a MEMIC policyholder. Then reach out to your MEMIC safety management consultant for more information about resources that can help. And if not, and you're interested in how MEMIC can partner with you for workplace safety. Contact your independent insurance agent. Now, let's get back to today's episode.
Randy Klatt: [00:34:45] It is crazy. And as you said, self-induced. And we see that to some degree in business today when we do mention something about the regs or the exit was partially blocked or you can't get to the fire [00:35:00] extinguisher. And, you know, those sorts of things that we always point out. And it's the overriding philosophy of, yeah, we'll get to it, but really, we have to do business first and it's not going to happen. What are the odds? Right. What are the odds that this building is going to catch on fire, that we're going to have a problem and that's not the right way to look at workplace safety. And we should have learned from these incidents. Every manager, every supervisor, every business owner should have a real good appreciation of history. So we don't repeat it.
Peter Koch: [00:35:39] It's that's a very good point. There's a phrase out there for those who don't know their history are destined to step in it again. Right. Or fall into it again, or however you want to finish that particular phrase. And there's an author out. There was this quote came out of another website that we're looking through, the [00:36:00] article called Child Workers and Workplace Accidents. What's the price paid for Industrializing America? They talk about how between the years of 1830 to 1880, there's this overworks generation of Americans that reached adulthood with hunchbacked weakness, both legs, damaged pelvises, missing limbs from working in those conditions for so long. And you have a generation that has human damage that doesn't allow them to interact in the same way with everyone else that we take for granted today. And I thought it was an interesting connection, because if we just take the example of how industrial technology back in the eighteen hundreds changed a generation and moved that same phrase to today and how technology take the industrial out of it, technology has changed a generation. What kind of injuries [00:37:00] are we seeing in a lot of young people today? And it might not always be work related. It might be just someone going to the doctor because they've got aches and pains, but it's neck injuries, it's wrist injuries, it's overexertion injuries. And most of it's coming from the phone posture. The technology posture of the hunched back, the rounded shoulders, the hands together, typing with their thumbs, staring at a small screen for hours a day. And you're seeing injuries or challenges to people that are really we saw similar things from introduction of technology back in the eighteen hundreds to. So, again, that whole concept of we need to understand our history to be able to see our current day and possibly even the effect of the current day on the future accurately, too. So there's a lot in this history that we can really take forward. [00:38:00]
Randy Klatt: [00:38:00] Right. That's those are great points. It's all about those musculoskeletal disorders that take place over time and know. One hundred and fifty years ago, it was manual labor in horrible conditions and long hours and no days off. That resulted in these injuries and these long term problems that people had today. We still have a lot of people working in industry and construction and such. But you're right, there are a lot more people using the computer or using a phone or a tablet. And we actually have young people who are starting to grow spines out of their cervical spine. So like bone spurs that are developing, which is not that uncommon with elderly people because you do have to hold your head up. Right. The human head weighs 12 pounds, 15 pounds, give or take. And [00:39:00] that takes some effort to hold up. We don't really think about it until we put our head down looking at the phone. Then after a few hours, our neck really starts to hurt and we ignore it. And over time, we forget the pain and we just deal with it. And we're actually starting to grow these things out of our spine that are being found in teenagers when normally they wouldn't be found until you're in your 70s. So there are workplace challenges today that we really need to face that are, you know, from different causal factors. But again, looking at history, we should be able to learn from them and find a better way. And let's listen to your safety consultant when they make recommendations. Gosh darn it,
Peter Koch: [00:39:50] Every once in a while. Don't delete the email. Read it through. Think about it before you delete it, possibly, right?
Randy Klatt: [00:39:55] That's right. We know what we're talking about. So interesting [00:40:00] that that even in 1911, we see this disaster and it did spur a lot of work in building codes and, you know, the sort of standards for the workplace. But it was still another 60 years before OSHA was founded. The Occupational Safety and Health Act was founded. So it took a long time even to get to that point where we actually had federal regulations about workplace safety.
Peter Koch: [00:40:35] Yeah. And even beyond or even before that. So OSHA, from a workplace safety standpoint, which is near and dear to our hearts, but just from a fair labor part, like what's fair, what's fair work, what constitutes fair work that even get passed until 1938, the Fair Labor Standards Act, where they addressed child labor and they addressed [00:41:00] the workday and they addressed fair wages and living wages, all which kind of come together to help the American worker be a more valuable component of the success of America.
Randy Klatt: [00:41:13] It did take a long time, way too long.
Peter Koch: [00:41:17] Way too long. And, you know, like we said it before, our current workplaces aren't free from problems. They're not free from hazards or free from people getting injured. We have come, like you said, we've come a long way. But the way there was really hard won. And whenever you've got struggle, there's going to be some progress. And to flip that around, Frederick Douglas, it's a quote that comes out of the, uh, around 1857. If there is no struggle, there is no progress. So you look at all the challenges that occurred back there and that started the labor union. It started to pull organized the different factions, not [00:42:00] factions, but the different groups from the different industries to come together and start to advocate for better conditions in the workplace. And those unions came forward and they fought for better hours, equal pay and safer working conditions. And actually, you know, Randy, when you think about it, that's somewhat on how MEMIC was actually formed and not on that, you know, not out of that particular quote. But really, there was a struggle in Maine in the early 1980s through the early nineteen nineties and through those struggles MEMIC was actually formed. It was it didn't come out of it wasn't somebody's brainchild because they thought it would be an awesome idea. It was a response to a crisis like a lot of this. Right. So the [00:43:00] the Labor Standards Act and the building codes and OSHA you hear many times that OSHA standards were written in blood because they were there's every standard in that OSHA standards book is because there's somebody or some body part that's attached to that, that didn't make it home or didn't make it home with the person after the incident occurred.
Randy Klatt: [00:43:27] Yeah. And then early 1990s, Maine had one of the worst, if not the worst, workplace injury records. Our injury rate was really high and worker's compensation insurance was extremely expensive. And insurers were, in fact, withdrawing from the state. And we got to a real crisis point with the businesses in Maine and something had to be done. So thank goodness MEMIC was founded. An initial [00:44:00] mission statement really did talk about not only providing great insurance and great safety services, but we wanted to promote fair and equitable treatment for all workers. And that's still true today. We've updated the mission statement and our vision and values and all that along the way. But that's still at the core of what we do is taking care of people. And ideally, we take care of people before there's an injury. That's our role as a safety consultant, is to get out there and find those issues, find those emergency exits that are blocked and make sure that they're taken care of. So in the event of a disaster, we actually get people out of the building instead of trapping them inside. But when injuries do occur, MEMIC is also there to provide the insurance benefits and medical care so that people can get back to work healthy and happy as soon as possible. So it is an important mission. I never conceived of myself [00:45:00] working for an insurance company. I know I don't like to pay insurance premiums any more than anybody else does. But this is an important piece of every worker's life, and it is important.
Peter Koch: [00:45:14] Yeah. And we're not saying that, you know, MEMIC was formed so that you could celebrate Labor Day, but I think it fits within the whole the whole thought of, you know, Labor Day came out of a struggle. And there's good things that come out of a struggle. And we have a long history of struggling for things and to things in America. You know, after those first two celebrations in New York in 1882, it still wasn't a national holiday like you didn't once. They all met together and had the parade in New York and they figured out which McGuire was the one to recognize as the person who suggested Labor Day still wasn't a national thing. I mean, that was [00:46:00] just New York City. And it took five more years for the first state in the Union to actually recognize Labor Day as an official holiday. And I don't have a lot of information about that. But Oregon was the first state back in 1887 to make Labor Day an official holiday. So I'd be curious if we can go back in time and kind of look at that first Labor Day. And was it just the day off or was it like our current Labor Day and certain companies you get that benefit of having a paid day off. So I'm not sure all of the labor in Oregon were paid for that first Labor Day holiday, but that was the first state to declare Labor Day a holiday. Oregon in 1887.
Randy Klatt: [00:46:50] Oh, go Oregon.
Peter Koch: [00:46:51] There you go.
Randy Klatt: [00:46:52] Go Ducks!
Peter Koch: [00:46:52] And even after that, it still didn't catch on. It's still a number of years, another five or six years [00:47:00] for more states to sign things into law. There again, seven more years. Grover Cleveland, are the president at the time finally signed the Labor Day holiday into law. So then it was a national holiday. And prior to that, in between 1887 and 94, 23 other states had adopted the holiday. And then Grover Cleveland signed it into law because it was becoming a trend, I guess, across the nation.
Randy Klatt: [00:47:32] Ya he saw the inevitable, huh? Yeah. Yeah. Looked at it, decided to do the right the right thing for a change.
Peter Koch: [00:47:38] And that's even that's an interesting history, because there, you know, prior to that, in that same year was the Pullman strike where the railroad workers were on went on strike for two, almost three months. And it was pretty nasty. There was a lot of violence and [00:48:00] some deaths, both on the strikers side and on the government side that tried to break it up. But ultimately, the labor won it out, but it was still, you know, still a violent part of our history. So, you know, again, 1894, a watershed time in our history to signing Labor Day as a holiday into law. But there is still a lot of struggle around that just to make it happen.
Randy Klatt: [00:48:30] Yeah. Can you imagine having to riot and to get into gunfights on the streets and calling in the Pinkerton agents to protect your facility and all those kinds of things just because you're not willing to pay a fair wage or workers are complaining of unsafe working conditions?
Peter Koch: [00:48:54] Sure, I don't think I can. I don't think I can. And I think it [00:49:00] highlights, you know, as we think about Labor Day and we think about the roots of Labor Day, it highlights, again, the need for both parties to come to the table rationally to talk about what's right and not what's just good for the one, but what's good for more than just the one. How are we going to be successful as a company as well as be successful as the individual? Because, you know, there are many cases where when you just focus on the company being successful and not the workers being successful, you're not going to end up being successful as a company. And we've talked about a lot of challenges, there's hundreds, if not thousands of companies out there that have not been able to be successful for one reason or the other, and sometimes it is because they didn't have the right priorities in mind when they started looking at labor.
Randy Klatt: [00:49:59] After [00:50:00] all, who is the company? We want to make the company successful. And I don't know of any company that will be successful if their workforce isn't successful. They're the ones that make it happen. So protecting those workers is not only the right thing to do from an ethical standpoint, but certainly the right thing to do from an economic standpoint. We all know just the small part of that whole pie being the worker's compensation insurance premium and how much that costs of business. And just like any insurance, the more you use it, the more it costs. So you can drive those direct costs of an injury through the roof pretty darn quickly. And it would be far less expensive to get ahead of the game and take care of those workers in the first place so that that doesn't happen. Safety is always a pay me now or pay me later proposal and [00:51:00] now is going to be a lot less expensive than later. It's just that's the way it always works.
Peter Koch: [00:51:06] It always does. And we can be really short sighted. And think about the not putting out a little bit now, but it's like you said, it's going to come around later. Back to you. Well, so we've been talking about Labor Day here for almost an hour. And I think it's good for us to recognize. Right. So back before 1994 or excuse me, back before 1894, even farther than 1994, right back before 1894, Labor Day didn't exist. We didn't recognize the success of and the input of the American worker, that construction worker, the textile worker, the manufacturing person, the firefighter, the police officer, the nurse, the doctor, the whoever it is, the [00:52:00] American labor, the person that's out there doing things and making things for to make America successful and then to try to be successful on their own. That symbiotic relationship between the work that needs to be done and the worker that's going to do it. And the history of Labor Day is just filled with struggle, courage, defiance, injuries. And as we've talked about, even death out there today, we celebrate Labor Day on the first Monday of September. And most of us will enjoy a day off from work sharing time and maybe a meal with friends and family.
Peter Koch: [00:52:34] And it's become the last hurrah before summer ends and the school year starts in earnest. So people are celebrating a lot of things. And when we do it, it's easy to forget the history of our modern workplace and how we got the eight hour workday overtime pay holidays or even machine guards, air quality monitoring respirators, lock out tag out, fall protection, all of the tools and standards [00:53:00] that give us the opportunity to come home after work and see those friends and family. So when you're celebrating, don't forget the thousands of workers out there in retail, hospitality, food service, emergency services and health care that are going to celebrate Labor Day by working for us or in some cases with one of our loved ones. So this Labor Day, remember that it's not just a holiday from work, but it's a holiday about work. And without the lives and the limbs of the workers that came before us and the unions and officials that spoke out, we would not have the day to celebrate. There's a good chance more of us would be spending this first Monday of September in the hospital or worse yet, in the morgue.
Peter Koch: [00:53:49] Thanks again to everyone for joining us. And today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast. We've been speaking about the history of Labor Day and how it has influenced safety with Randy Klatt, director of Region two here at MEMIC. If you have any suggestions for a safety related podcast [00:54:00] topic or we'd like to hear more about a topic we've touched on. Email me at [email protected] Also, check out our show notes for today's podcast at MEMIC.com/podcast where you can find links to the articles and resources we used for today and our entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for our safety net blog so you never miss any of our articles and safety news updates. And if you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it if you took a few minutes to review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whichever podcast service that you found us on. If you've already done that. Thanks. Hope you've subscribed because it really helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing this show. With a business associate friend or a family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Koch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even [00:55:00] better.
In June 2021, the FDA revoked its Emergency Use Authorization for Filtering Facepiece Respirators. Learn what an EUA is and how it affects the use of non-NIOSH approved N-95 respirator in healthcare.
Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch, and the topic today is revoked EUAs. Often I need to hear or read something a second time to understand what's going on. And it's not for lack of education or interest. It's just sometimes a sentence tries to do way too much with too few words or letters or using abbreviations to try to help with understanding. So try to wrap your brain around this. Early on in the sars-cov-2 pandemic, the FDA as a department of the DHHS, created the FRREUAs for HCP in conjunction with NIOSH and the CDC to help combat the spread of covid-19 now due to the increase in availability of NIOSH approved and n-95 FRRs, the FDA has revoked the FRREUA for [00:01:00] HCP. Got it. Yeah, I don't. I didn't either. Every one of those, TLAs adds meeting to the message. And a TLA is a three letter abbreviation, by the way, so that's way too many TLAs packed into two sentences to be functional and I expect that if it was in print you would have to read it again and maybe again and maybe google some of those to figure out what all the pieces are. But just listening, I expect it was almost as confusing as it was to read. And if I were to pull a number of us who heard that headline for the first time, everyone would have a different opinion on its meaning. And unfortunately, many times when I'm in the field talking with clients about new regulations or safety standards, there's often confusion and most often a different opinion on the meaning or applicability. And the FDA's recent revocation of the FRREUA is no exception. So to help clear the air on the [00:02:00] podcast with me today is Steve Badger, CSP, OHST and safety management consultant with MEMIC. Steve has more than 35 years of experience working in the paper, medical sterilization and construction industries. He's an authorized training instructor for the OSHA Training Institute in Manchester, New Hampshire, and is a member of the American Industrial Hygiene Association. Steve uses his experience in different industries and formal training in industrial hygiene practices and indoor air quality testing to help the companies he works with manage their respiratory protections, challenges and others today. Steve is going to help us shed some light on the recent FRREUA revocation. So, Steve, welcome back to the podcast.
Steve Badger: [00:02:45] Thank you very much, Peter. Glad to be here.
Peter Koch: [00:02:47] That's fantastic. It's been a little while since we've had a conversation here. So I was really happy to I actually read some information that you sent out about the revaccinated EUAs and [00:03:00] it sparked the conversation for us about what they are and why they got revoked. And I thought it would be an interesting conversation to have on the podcast and try to get the word out about some of this. So I'd like to start by jumping right in and define some of those TLAs or three letter abbreviation. Let's start right with an EUA. What isn't EUA in the first place and why are they issued?
Steve Badger: [00:03:26] Sure. And an EUA stands for emergency use authorization is really a mechanism to facilitate the availability and the use of medical countermeasures such as vaccines and other medical equipment during public health emergencies. And you see this happen rarely they're not done frequently. But as it says in their own definitions, that the public health emergencies, we don't have a lot of them, but when we have them, we need to be able to use our resources and things that are available to try to help us get [00:04:00] beyond that. And obviously, the covid-19 pandemic has proved to be that in more than one area, including the vaccines, as well as the filtering Facebook's respirators. Now, under this particular EAU, the FDA meeting, the Food and Drug Administration is the one that issued this particular set of EUAs and they can do, as I mentioned earlier, medical products, vaccines to diagnose or treat or even prevent serious life threatening diseases and conditions when there's no approved or adequate available alternatives. In this case here, you know, we're talking about filtering face piece respirators. And as we know that has been a contentious issue from the beginning as to the availability of NIOSH approved respirators.
Peter Koch: [00:04:52] Why don't we help people understand? Because there's lots of different terminology about respirators and some people just think a mask is [00:05:00] a respirator or a respirator is a mask. We see we see people in a doctor's office wearing a mask. We see people on a construction site wearing a mask. We see firefighters wearing a mask. So when we talk about an n-95 respirator, what are we talking about and what's the difference between, say that and like a half face respirator and maybe that surgical mask that you might find in your doctor's office?
Steve Badger: [00:05:27] Great question. The really the difference comes down to what is doing the filtering and filtering face piece respirator. The ones that we're talking about here, the mask itself is the filter. It's filtering out everything that you're breathing in. The whole entire thing acts as a filter and you know it. The same with a surgical mask is designed to filter out throughout your whole breathing zone everything that's there as opposed to say, you know, elastomeric like a half face or a full face, negative pressure [00:06:00] respirator that is fit tested. They've got it. It's got a seal that has to seal. And then the ear that's getting to you is being filtered through actual filters, cartridges that are designed to filter out different types of contaminants. So there's a big difference between those and the filtering face piece in its function and its ability and its protective qualities. Because if you think about a filtering face piece, it's filtering in both directions, whereas the elastomeric respirators, the cartridges you're breathing in, when you exhale, you're breathing out through an exhalation valve that's not filtered. So this was one of the reasons why these this particular type of respirator wasn't the first and best choice when it came to the health care professionals,
Peter Koch: [00:06:51] Because it's filtering the filtering face piece or like a paper mask. Respirator would filter both ways, both in the inhalation and the [00:07:00] exhalation, as I hear you correctly.
Steve Badger: [00:07:02] Correct.
Peter Koch: [00:07:02] Now, with the filtering face piece and especially the n-95 respirators, some of the similarities beyond the filtering on the inhalation, they do have to be fit tested, is that correct, the n-95 respirators?
Steve Badger: [00:07:18] Yes, that is correct. They do have to be fit tested. And the initial people that are first using these things, it was absolutely mandated that everyone had to be fit tested before they could wear them and they had to get a medical approval before they could even do the fit testing to make sure that they were physically capable of wearing these respirators with the people that had already been fit tested. And maybe they've been beyond that year from the initial time that they had been tested. They were given a, I will say, a waiver, but an extension so that they did not have to get that additional fit test within that year, that they as long as they were using the same type and brand of filtering [00:08:00] face piece respirator, that they could extend that fit test beyond that year deadline.
Peter Koch: [00:08:07] Oh, good. So that that actually took some pressure off the numbers of people that would have to be tested for an n-95 or one of the respirators that would have been covered under the EUA originally. Now what's the biggest difference between that filtering face piece and say like the surgical mask that you might see in the doctor's office or the dentist office?
Steve Badger: [00:08:34] The largest difference really comes down to the pore size. And when we talk about pore size, we're talking about what is the maximum, you know, filtration of that particular respirator or in this case, surgical mask. Now, with the filtering face piece, we know that it will filter out 95 percent of the particles at a certain size and which is which is a very good filter, a very good filter, 95 percent, [00:09:00] as opposed to a surgical mask, which really doesn't have the small enough pores to prevent the viruses from actually getting through that. And they're not fitted as well so that people, if they don't have them appropriately put across their nose or across their face, there's still gaps in them that can allow the escape of the of the virus.
Peter Koch: [00:09:24] Good. So that makes sense then why someone who would be required to say treat or come into contact with someone who might have covid-19 needing to wear that n-95 mask instead of just the surgical mask? But, you know, there again, that's the requirement, higher level of protection, especially when there's a significant exposure. And then for everyone else, when there's other options for us to go out there. That's why that cloth face mask or even a surgical type mask would be functional for someone of the public [00:10:00] who maybe isn't required to come into contact with someone who has covid-19, I remember early on masks, you couldn't find them, you couldn't find n-95 mask's anywhere. And I know just outside of the covid-19 pandemic, I mean, respirators are used in industry all the time for particulate respiratory protection, chemical respiratory protection. There's many reasons why you might use an a 95 respirator and you couldn't find them. You just couldn't find them anywhere. So I guess this is a good time to maybe talk a little bit about the history here and to get a better understanding of why the EUAs were issued in the first place. So we did talk about the FDA, the federal Food and Drug Administration, and they are in charge of approving medical products and vaccines for use, and especially when it comes to the medical industry themselves to be approved for [00:11:00] medical use. It's not just, say, NIOSH. Correct. So if I'm going to use a respirator, an approved respirator for medical use, NIOSH isn't the only organization that will approve that respirator for use, is that correct? That needs to be the FDA.
Steve Badger: [00:11:17] Well, it is the NIOSH does the approval and how to look at this is that they do the testing, they do the approval. And then the FDA says, OK, based on the NIOSH testing and approval, we will accept these particular respirators.
Peter Koch: [00:11:35] Gotcha, I think that's a that's a good point for qualification there. So NIOSH still doing the testing. And then the FDA is saying that these are the group of respirators that are going to be functional for a health care setting. Awesome. All right. So let's look more about the historical context. And if we all remember back to the start of the covid-19 pandemic, which seems like forever [00:12:00] ago, but it wasn't all that long ago, actually, that the virus was determined to be transmitted through the air and into the respiratory system via the droplets expelled when an infected person coughed, sneezed or they spoke. What wasn't really well understood then was how a mask could protect you and why someone in a health care settings should wear an approved n-95 mask and someone not in health care could wear a mask that wasn't approved. So let's talk a little bit about what an n-95 is and then what makes it approved and then we'll get into the timeline. So Steve, take us through what an n-95 respirator n-95 mask is and what makes it approved versus a mask that might not be approved.
Steve Badger: [00:12:41] You know, certainly the n-95 respirator is exactly what it sounds. It's designed to filter out 95 percent of the particles within its range, what it's approved for. And so, you know, when we take a look at what's on the outside of the respirator [00:13:00] and what gets inside, it's designed to filter out 95 percent. And that approval process, as we mentioned earlier, is done by NIOSH, the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health. And they do a lot of testing on these respirators and they put them through their paces to make sure that they really are what the manufacturer tells us they are and that they're going to, you know, meet those standards. Now, to take that one step further, these n-95 respirators, which were, you know, being approved obviously very quickly, the supplies of these got used up. And so they started looking at these different alternatives as to, OK, maybe these aren't approved yet, but there are respirators out there that have been through other trials, through other organizations throughout the world that may be good enough to be able to provide some protection for the health care professionals.
Peter Koch: [00:13:58] Oh, all right, I [00:14:00] think I understand so NIOSH is going to approve an n-95 respirator based on their testing and it has to meet a minimum qualification for the for filtering out 95 percent of a certain size particle or particles above a certain size. But there are other organizations I know Canada has their own organization and other countries have their own certification organizations for different types of personal protective equipment. So but it might not be the same testing method or it might not be they might not have the same standard possibly that NIOSH does so when the supply got short. Am I correct that businesses started to look for other supply chains that might not be approved by NIOSH? Am I correct in that?
Steve Badger: [00:14:50] Absolutely, that is correct. They started looking outside of the U.S. because of the fact that the U.S. supplies fell [00:15:00] behind very quickly. And so they started looking at countries that everywhere from, you know, Vietnam to New Zealand to places Europe, Italy, that that had companies that were creating respirators that met their standard for it would be an n-95. But they had not yet approved them for use in the United States.
Peter Koch: [00:15:24] Very good. So that that sets up kind of sets up a challenge. Right. So as your safety person at the hospital or OSHA or the FDA are going to say, these are the things that you have to use, the companies might not have enough of those things. So they go look someplace else, find other respirators that meet a certain standard, but not the NIOSH standard. So now there's a challenge there. There are companies that are trying to protect their workers, but there aren't enough of the NIOSH approved [00:16:00] n-95 filtering face pieces to go around. So the FDA takes the next step. And I'm expecting that's the emergency use authorization, correct?
Steve Badger: [00:16:12] Correct. You know, any time that there is an emergency use authorization, there has to be some reasoning behind it. And for this case here, you know, they gave three main reasons as to why they wanted to implement this. And, you know, first of all, it was the sars-cov-2 virus that causes covid-19 causes serious life threatening disease. There was no question about that at this point, including severe respiratory illness. The second reason was that based on scientific evidence available to the FDA, that there was some benefit of using these filtering face piece respirators, even though they were not NIOSH approved. And third of all is that, you know, there just wasn't any other available alternatives. There was just nothing else out there that was in the pipeline that could possibly [00:17:00] take the place of that or help supplement that. So this is why the FDA decided that this was a good time to implement this particular EUA.
Peter Koch: [00:17:13] That's great. And as I understand it, too, there were multiple or at least there were two EUAs that were issued. So talk to us about the first EUA that was issued and then we can talk about the second one.
Steve Badger: [00:17:26] Sure. The first EUA was the imported NIOSH Non-NIOSH approved disposable filtering face piece respirators, and that one really covered respirators that were made outside of the United States everywhere but China. And we'll talk about a little bit about that in the second one as to why they separated those. But this particular one this first one was for every other country, the Italy, the Australia, the New Zealand that were making respirators that had not been previously [00:18:00] NIOSH approved. And within that EUA, they had what's called exhibit one. Exhibit one was the list of approved filtering face piece respirators that could be used by health care professionals under this EUA.
Peter Koch: [00:18:17] Ok, so once that EUA was issued, they had a list of all the different respirators. So the health care community could go out and choose from that list. They couldn't find NIOSH approved filtering face pieces. They could then look at which ones were then being approved through the emergency use authorization. That's cool. So that list one was a pretty critical list for people to have get their hands on. And then I think it was still hard to find some of those. And then there was another EUA that was issued and you referenced that earlier. That was the one for respirators manufactured in China. So can you talk a little bit about that one?
Steve Badger: [00:18:56] Yes. The first EUA approved about 50, [00:19:00] I believe it was 54 different types of respirators from different countries. And as we talked about the use and the need and far outweighed the number that were available. So the second EUA was issued in October of 2020, and that was for respirators that were constructed in the country of China. Now, that particular list was also quite extensive and they actually had about 200 approved respirators that went into Appendix A of that EUA that were approved from that point that the EUA was initiated. So now they've brought in the they had the rest of the world will say in the. First, the EUA and then China and their respirators were the second EUA.
Peter Koch: [00:19:55] Right, and so through your reading, were you able to determine why they had a [00:20:00] separate EUA for the respirators made in China versus the ones that may have been made in the other parts of the world?
Steve Badger: [00:20:07] There's been nothing that I've been able to find in the reading that would indicate why? You know, there's a lot of conjecture out there as far as, you know, thinking about the fact that, you know, early on they thought that maybe, you know, they wouldn't have to go to that extreme to get enough respirators available. But, yeah, there's definitely nothing in writing that I've been able to find that's indicated as why it was separate after the fact. You know, when we talk about here later on, but after the fact, it became obvious that there were a lot of knockoffs and a lot of, you know, fake respirators that were being sent in, ones that weren't nearly close to approval. And so, you know, after the fact, they started, you know, weeding out those pretty quickly when they started testing them.
Peter Koch: [00:20:59] Yeah. [00:21:00] So I do remember some of that information coming through. There were a number of respirators that were packaged to represent themselves as being NIOSH approved or had the OSHA seal of approval, which isn't a thing. You know, she doesn't approve those. They just say you're supposed to wear a particular type of PPE. And then there were some testing information that was placed out there, too, about how the NIOSH respirators and respirators made in other parts of the world and even some of those in China did come it did come very close to meeting that NIOSH standard over the samples that they had. But there are others that didn't do it at all. And so part of the approval, as I see it, is how I've come to understand this as a safety professional is one of the reasons that you want in a third party testing and approving is because it provides you with some information about [00:22:00] the minimum amount of protection that you're going to get. So if you buy something that's going to have the stamp of approval on it, you should you should be able to feel comfortable that it will that it will protect you at this particular level. And so then if you take that protection level and then you look at what you're trying to be protected from, if they match up and you use it the way it's supposed to, you have managed the hazard or exposure to that hazard in a good way. But if it's not going to meet that base level of approval, then it may very well put you at greater risk if you're going to use something that that doesn't have that minimum level of protection.
Peter Koch: [00:22:42] Let's take a quick break, integrating workplace safety into your business is a key part of the long term success of any company. And like most components of success, there is no one size fits all solution. MEMIC is committed to partnering with employers across all industries for workplace [00:23:00] safety. And we recognize the key to that partnership is understanding the unique demands of the industries that we ensure our safety experts bring experience from the industries that they serve. And this experience provides a unique perspective through a critical eye when it comes to understanding the particular exposures and challenges of an industry from construction, retail and manufacturing to hospitality and health care. Our team of experts will work with policyholders to identify opportunities to improve safety. Interested in finding more about MEMIC, check us out at MEMIC.com. Or better yet, contact your local independent insurance agent for more information. If you're already insured by MEMIC, then check out our safety resources at MEMIC.com/workplacesafety and sign up for access to our video lending library, our LMS platform or our Safety Director Resource Library. Now let's [00:24:00] get back to today's episode.
Peter Koch: [00:24:04] I think as we as we start to look at the EUAs this, you know, the podcast is pretty short today. There is a pretty focused topic. There's not a ton that we need to go through. But we learned about what an EUA is, what the FRRs are, who does the approval process, who issued the emergency use authorization in the first place and why. Now, let's talk about the well, the title of the podcast is that they have been revoked or the EUAs have been revacated. So why were the EUAs revoked here? Why did the FAA pull the EUAs for those filtering face pieces?
Steve Badger: [00:24:48] Yeah, looking at, you know, the beginning of this, where they were authorized, the EUAs were issued from that point on, we had a list for [00:25:00] the exhibit one and also for Appendix A for the second. And that list of respirators were really, you know, for lack of a better term, we're really unknowns. And so what NIOSH did was they started doing testing on these particular filtering face piece respirators to see if they met the n-95 standard that 95 percent filtration. And so the process that they would go through is they would take ten samples that were sent to them by the manufacturers. They would test them and come up with an average filtration. And so as they started going through and doing these testing, they found out early on that there were many that either didn't make it or that were very bad respirators that they could tell that they were bad, they tell that they were they were the fakes, that they were the fraudulent ones. And so what they did was they started [00:26:00] eliminating some of these from that list, from that approved list and a couple of different times during 2020, they took some of these out, started weeding them down to the ones that actually that they could say would filter out 95 percent. Now, it's important to note at this point that this did not give them a NIOSH approval. OK, what all this did was that NIOSH did this testing and that they were able to say that in this testing that it did reach that 95 percent. So none of these respirators were able to gain NIOSH approval numbers from this particular testing. So as time went on, the manufacturers that NIOSH had approved previously started catching up on the numbers of respirators that were being in demand as the pandemic, you know, slowly started coming down and the number of cases and the health care workers were able to better protect themselves with NIOSH respirators. [00:27:00] These lists, this Appendix A and exhibit one, they started becoming less and less important. And so in the end of June or actually towards the end of June, the FDA decided to revoke both of these EUAs, meaning that these respirators are no longer approved for use by health care professionals.
Peter Koch: [00:27:25] And that's another interesting point to note, that the lists were kind of live. So the Appendix A. And the list one, as NIOSH started testing, they actually eliminated some of the respirators from those list. Is that correct? Did I hear that correctly?
Steve Badger: [00:27:43] Yes, they did, they initially they eliminated from the second EUA, the ones from China there was about I want to say it was about 75 respirators that did not meet the first cut right out of the gate. And there was a there was several from [00:28:00] the first the UK from the European and other nations that were creating them. And so they were slowly, you know, they would get several of these on that list and they would eliminate them. And so they would, you know, say, OK, from this point on, from this date on, these are no longer part of this EUA and therefore the health care providers should not be using these.
Peter Koch: [00:28:23] Yeah, and I think that's a good point, because if this ever does happen again and another EUA is issued for non-NIOSH approved filtering face pieces that. The purchasing groups for these health care organizations need to understand that, unfortunately, we can only work as fast as we can work and that those lists could be live. So are the lists will be live. And as more testing gets done, those lists might change. So it's important to go back to those lists on a regular basis, work with your suppliers to make sure that you have [00:29:00] you're working off the most accurate list and you're getting the equipment that's best suited for your for your workers. So we come to the end and the EUAs are revoked and what I'm hearing, Steve, is that you're saying because manufacturing picked up enough with the NIOSH approved n-95 respirators, that that there are enough now to go around to outfit the needs of our health care professionals. So that's really the reason why they were revoked, because there wasn't a need for emergency use anymore. We were able to use the approved respirators in most cases. Is that correct?
Steve Badger: [00:29:43] Yes, it is correct and you know, and obviously there's a couple of reasons for that. I mean, one, we don't have the certainly have not had the number of cases that we had initially early on, you know, and also, you know, we have to think about respirators as they are. They're the last [00:30:00] line of defense. And so when we think about, you know, you know, hazards and controls that, you know, the controls that have been put into place have also helped eliminate a lot of these potential exposures to the point where maybe not as many respirators are needed to be used because they are that last line of defense. And therefore, you know, if something happens to them, the respirator fails, that person could still be exposed. So we want to try, you know, to eliminate those hazards initially before you get to that respirator point.
Peter Koch: [00:30:32] Very good now. All right. So the EUAs are revoked the non NIOSH approved respirators are no longer approved for use in a health care setting. What do I do, I've got maybe a stockpile of respirators that were once approved by the EUA and they're no longer functional or at least no longer proved to be used in a health care setting. So does the FDA have [00:31:00] any recommendations going forward?
Steve Badger: [00:31:03] Yes, they do. They have several recommendations for the stockpiles of these things that they're assuming that are out there for the health care professionals. And just because these respirators are no longer a part of this EUA, doesn't mean that they can't be used for other purposes outside of the health care organizations that you could, you know, actually, you know, redistribute these through, you know, into non health care settings, such as, you know, construction or even general industry? You might be able to you know, they offer the suggestion that maybe you could donate them to other countries or other places where approved respirators are still in very short, you know, short quantities as they're very much in demand. They also, you know, tell us that we may even consider, you know, holding on to them to [00:32:00] be used for other purposes so that's where they've kind of left it with us, that we don't want to just, you know, we just don't want to throw these things away, that there are other uses for them. And I think that's very good advice.
Peter Koch: [00:32:12] Yeah, I think it's great advice as well. So just because you have a resource, make sure you're using the resource appropriately just for that health care setting of if I'm a health care professional and I'm going to be exposed to someone who potentially has covid-19, I want to make sure I'm protected. So you want to make sure you're using that NIOSH respirator. And since you should be able to have sourced enough of those for the exposure potential that that is out there now. But like you said at the end, there again, it's a good idea. As we you know, we look at where we are currently and there's starting to be an uptick in cases, an uptick with the Delta variant and maybe some other variants that are coming down the road. It's [00:33:00] always good to be prepared. So we don't want to be in a place again where we're scrambling to find respirators. We want to make sure that we have things in stock. So, you know, good advice, use it or do with those stockpiled respirators, what you, as your company feels is going to be the best use for them. And if that is a donation grade, if that's moving them to a different industry, fine, too. If that is holding on to them just in case, that's not a bad idea either. So, Steve, why don't we try? So we learned a lot today in a very short time. And I think most of it is kind of clearing up some of those three letter abbreviations like EUA and FRR and even some larger abbreviations like NIOSH or CDC. So why don't we take that sentence those two sentences we had in the intro and let's try to add the actual words that come up and see if it makes any more sense to us. So here we go. Early [00:34:00] on in the sars-cov-2 or Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome coronavirus two pandemic the Food and Drug Administration as a Department of the Department of Health and Human Services created the filtering face piece respirator emergency use authorization for health care providers. They did this in conjunction with the National Institute for Occupational safety and Health, or NIOSH and the Centers for Disease Control, or CDC, to help combat the spread of covid-19. Now, due to the increase in availability of the NIOSH approved n-95 filtering face piece respirators, the Food and Drug Administration has revoked the filtering face piece respirator emergency use authorization for health care providers. Makes a little more sense. Still a mouthful to say, but there seems to make more sense to that. So I [00:35:00] guess at the end here, Steve, as you were going through the emergency use authorization, the process and how they were revoked, is there anything else that you want to add to that or maybe something that you found really interesting as you were going through that?
Steve Badger: [00:35:17] Yeah, you know, I would say that I probably one of them the most interesting things that I found going through this was, you know, the ability of the government organizations to be able to work together to get to that point where these EUAs were being issued. Because, you know, it wasn't just the FDA. They had to rely on the NIOSH group for their testing and approval. And, you know, and that all, you know, in conjunction with the CDC, the Centers for Disease Control, that they had to all work together to make this work. And I think that that's the part that really drove home to me. The point that, you know, when we're in a crisis and these things happen, that these people can work together, that they can, you [00:36:00] know, do you know the right thing and get these things out to people and in a big hurry. I mean, this was these are not something that typically happens overnight. And in this case, here it did. These were given this temporary approval and this emergency approval. And so they were they were able to help that health care professionals out of a very tough position.
Peter Koch: [00:36:26] Yeah, I think that's a really good point. The working across departments at the federal level can be challenging at times. And they definitely collaborated well together and came up with a with good response for a very, very challenging situation for sure. So, Steve, if someone had more questions about the FDA or and or the emergency use authorizations, something happens in the future. They see something over the Internet that there was a new EUA or they want to learn more about these [00:37:00] EUAs in particular, where would they go for more information?
Steve Badger: [00:37:05] Certainly the Food and Drug Administration, the FDA has a website that you can go on and, you know, you can look and search for EUAs under that website and it will bring up all of them. And they're, quite frankly, right now there's quite a few of them out there for different types of medical processes and procedures. And also the vaccines, the very vaccines that we're taking to prevent covid fall under these EUAs. So you kind of have to do a little bit of searching through there. And the other place that I would look in regards to the filtering face piece respirators is whether or not the respirator that you've chosen that you have in your hand, is it NIOSH approved or not? Easy enough to go on to the NIOSH website and actually determine that you can do a search and look to see which respirators are really approved? You know, it's not just stamped [00:38:00] on the box from, you know, someplace, you know, out of nowhere that you can actually make sure that that thing is actually what it says that it is so that you're getting that protection factor that you're expecting.
Peter Koch: [00:38:12] That's a great point. And to not all, you know, don't always trust the packaging. So if you're looking to purchase n-95 respirators, a good idea is to double check them against the list there for the NIOSH approved respirators. And you'd find that you said right on the NIOSH site or is that the FDA site, Steve?
Steve Badger: [00:38:33] You would find it on the NIOSH site for which respirators are approved and they will be given approval number. And you can determine that, you know, from that list is whether or not that one you have in your hand, if it's NIOSH approved, it's going to have a number associated with it that matches up with that NIOSH site.
Peter Koch: [00:38:53] Very good. And most of your reputable distributors are going to be familiar with that and be able to help [00:39:00] you if you're purchasing PPE for your organization, whether your health care or not, they should be able to work with you and then know what's approved and what's not approved. And if you ask them questions, is it on it? What's the number they should be able to give you that. So if you're wanting to double check, you can always ask those questions of your supplier. All right. Very good. Steve, thanks so much for coming on and sharing your expertise with us today.
Steve Badger: [00:39:27] You're very welcome, Peter. Thank you for having me.
Peter Koch: [00:39:29] Excellent. We'll have to bring you on again and talk some more about respirators. I, I know we've been chatting back and forth about a podcast, around respiratory Protection, and it's a pretty enormous topic. And we've got to kind of whittle it down so we can fit it in within our podcast format here. So we'll have you back on again. And I'm looking forward to speaking with you.
Steve Badger: [00:39:50] Thank you.
Peter Koch: [00:39:50] Perfect. So thanks again for joining us. And to all of our listeners out there today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, we've been speaking with Steve Badger, safety management [00:40:00] consultant, with a MEMIC about the Food and Drug Administration's revoked emergency use authorizations for filtering face piece respirators. If you have any questions or would like to hear more about a particular topic on our podcast, e-mail me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/podcast, where you can find additional resources and our entire podcast archive. Did you know we've had more than 50 episodes so far and we're still going strong and hope to do another 50. And while you're there on the website, sign up for our safety net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates. And if you haven't done so, I'd appreciate it if you took a minute or two to review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whichever podcast service that you found us on. And if you've already done that, thanks, because it really helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing this show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of [00:41:00] it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Koch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.
In a February 2021 article from Harvard Health Publishing, research links some surprising health problems to slouching, including incontinence and constipation. On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, Al Brown, MEMIC's Director of Ergonomics takes a look at slouching, how it affects your health and some strategies for prevention.
Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast. My name is Peter Koch, your host, and today we are here with Al Brown, the director of ergonomics for MEMIC. And we're going to talk about slouching. So we don't want you to be a slouch. And I want you to think about this right now. And I bet you if you heard this, you might have even sat up or stood up a little bit more straight. But think about your posture right at this moment or just moments ago whether your drive in your car, sitting at your desk, maybe you're sitting on the riding lawnmower or you're sitting on your couch at home or whatever you're doing. What's your posture like? Are you seated? Is your low back curved or your shoulders hunched forward? Is your head in a forward posture that's slouching? We're going to talk about that and the effects of slouching, how we got there, because that's certainly not how we were, how we were designed to sit and to stand. But that's a common posture and it has a lot of different negative effects on [00:01:00] our body and sometimes even our longevity. So I guess with that, Al, welcome to the podcast today. Thanks for being back again and sharing some fascinating it I think a little frightening information about what slouching might do for you. So talk to me about slouching. What's going on with slouching and why is this a big deal? Because I don't know. I like the slouch every once in a while. Right. Feels good. So what's the problem with it?
Al Brown: [00:01:26] Well, first, Pete, thanks. Thanks for having me back. Much appreciated. It's an interesting thing. It's a phenomenon I'm watching unfold as I travel about different industries and particularly the office world and even watching my own kids. And the advent of the laptop, I think sort of was the thing that started that precluded all this. And, you know, the laptop is a lovely thing. It's portable. It allows us a lot of information in this little thing that we just kind of carry in our hand. But when we interface [00:02:00] with it. We sit down and we place it somewhere, they call it a laptop for a reason, a lot of times that's where it ends up. And but unfortunately, particularly, the younger crowd has pretty good vision. So they flip open that screen the keyboards down where their hands are and overcomes the head to view the content. This is sort of the initial start of creating muscle memory and this forward slouching posture, it's unconscious subconscious, not really recognized, and a lot of things begin to happen physiologically and it's very subtle over time. And then you begin to see the results of it after someone's been doing it for a couple of months, a couple of years. And I see it oftentimes when we have someone new young coming in to MEMIC and they have been a laptop user and are now [00:03:00] shifting to a desktop. And that's where the behaviors become very apparent to me when I see them positioning themselves in front of the screen. We talk about proper ergonomics and how to set up, and it's very hard for them sometimes to adapt to it because of all the things that we that have occurred because of the excessive laptop using and the slouching, which will get into more detail today.
Peter Koch: [00:03:25] Sure, I see it well, I see it myself sometimes. I've lots of times I'm going to work off an iPad with a keyboard attached to it and the same thing that it'll sit right on my lap and my head will be bent over and I'll type and you'll get a little tightness in the back of your neck. And I don't have the greatest eyesight anymore. I'm certainly not one of the younger users anymore, unfortunately. But looking through my progressive lenses or my bifocals, I'll have to look down or look up to see part of that screen. And you really have a limited range of motion. I see it with my daughter, too. So a couple [00:04:00] of daughters in high school, of course, just about every kid in Maine gets a laptop or they have a laptop and they're doing all their work on it. They're sitting at the kitchen table. They're sitting on the couch. They're sitting on the porch. My youngest daughter was sitting in a hammock the other day, leaning back kind of in this banana shape with a laptop on her lap and like, wow, that's really uncomfortable looking. But yeah, so that's the habit that they're in. So I can only imagine what happens when you try to move to a different place, whether it be a desktop or you watch I'll actually watch my oldest daughter, who's home now who drive and she'll be in the same head forward position when she's driving seat back a little bit of that. You referenced this before we were talking the low rider position. So sit back a little bit, head forward, kind of looking just above the steering wheel in that same [00:05:00] posture translates between her laptop use at home and the car driving. And if she concentrates, she'll stand up straight. But if you just watch her kind of relax, sometimes that forward head posture will just become a normal a normal thing for her.
Al Brown: [00:05:16] It's almost like if you look at it from a profile view, someone sitting at the desk. You'll see almost a C, you know, shape, you know, where the head is forward and then you follow the curve around at the mid thoracic area and even the lower back, which has normally, you know, a curve in the opposite direction of the mid back, is actually now continuing that same shape down to the pelvis. So you get this giant C shape and that has an impact all the way through the body. What happens is basically you're shutting your abdominal muscles off and you're kind of hanging on your back muscles. I always reference [00:06:00] a shirt, and when you're sitting there leaning forward, the shirt on the front side's all wrinkled up, which kind of represents muscles that are sort of tightening up. And then you look at the fabric on the back of the shirt and it's being overstretched, which happens to the muscles on the back of the body. They're being sort of statically stretched passively for an extended period of time. If you stay in the position long enough, it actually creates inflammation in a lot of the soft tissue. And then you start to see diagnoses like fibromyalgia and myofascial pain. And we can all experience it. You know, for the listeners at home, you can take one of your fingers gently and pull it back words so that it's fully extended and just keep a stretch on it for, oh, you know, maybe 15 to 30 seconds, a good stretch on it and then release it and curl it up. And you can feel that stiffness [00:07:00] that you've started. And think of that finger stained in that position for an hour, two hours. Eventually the tissue becomes in flames and you create an injury. So over time, someone who slouches at a computer is doing that same thing to all the muscle tissue on the back side of the body and weakening the abdominals on the front side. So that's just that's just the musculoskeletal system, you know, and sitting, you know, we have to throw in you look down at the hips and the hip flexors are shortening up. And so when you go to a standing position, you never get somebody that goes fully erect simply because the longer we do it, the more our body adapts and our more the muscles will shorten, tendons will shorten, ligaments will shorten. And so unless you take an active role in sort of reopening your body back up, you will, like you had mentioned your daughter, you'll see that transferred to from the hammock to the desk to [00:08:00] the car, and it becomes normalized in the brain. And we'll start to hear complaints about it because and people will only make a change when they get the discomfort. And we see young folks going for shoulder surgeries now, having back pain. I think the tag line now thirty's the new 40.
Peter Koch: [00:08:22] Oh boy.
Al Brown: [00:08:22] And those comorbidities are coming sooner simply because of this sort of slouched posture.
Peter Koch: [00:08:29] Wow. So and I always think about it, too, that there are you have complementary muscle groups. So, you know, when you're in the habit in that C shape to stretch out those back muscles and kind of relax those abdominal muscles, then you go to come back and combat that. If you haven't been working those abdominal muscles to help keep yourself in good posture, it will become more difficult over time to combat the bad posture that you have to move out of that habit. So the [00:09:00] longer you spend in it, the worse it is for you.
Al Brown: [00:09:03] Yeah, I mean, what it does to tightens up those hip flexors and then you keep the back the inward curve of the back actually goes concave or convex. It goes in the opposite direction. And what happens, it's very difficult to roll out of that posture again. You know, if you think of yourself sitting, there's two ways to sit to a certain extent. I mean, all kinds of ways to sit. But one is sort of sitting back on your sacrum, which is what the slouches will sit on. So if you just kind of let your back roll that your low back flatten and you roll back on your tailbone and your head has to come forward as that happens. So you are creating that C. But if you actually arch your back and you pull your pelvis around, you actually come up on there's these two sitting bones as they're skilled, tuberose, and there's two of them, you'll pull yourself around up on top of those and you'll feel your core go [00:10:00] upright and your head will align. The chair should positively support you than the back of the chair should be in there and supporting your back for the low riders of the folks have been doing the slouching. If we pull their chair up into that position, they feel like they're almost being thrown into the computer. And that's because that visual mental image they have of themselves and sort of their muscle memory keeps them in that forward C posture.
Peter Koch: [00:10:28] Yeah, that kinesthetic sense. They think their father forward and they should be because their natural well, their habitual place to be is in that forward head posture. Yeah. I just think that's where they are.
Al Brown: [00:10:39] You'll see it in like older people go to the dentist now, you know, and the dentist tends to lay a pretty flat and you know, because as we age we tend to go into that forward posture. It's we're trying to look for stability. And what happens is when they lay you down on the chair, someone that's, you know, creeping [00:11:00] over into the forward posture, they'll go, oh, that's far enough that you've got me almost upside down. And there's still about 45 degrees, you know, before they even get the flat. So they'll slowly creep that person down as their muscles and their memory kind of relaxes a bit and they can sneak them down. But you can't get them really flat because of all the physical changes that's occurring earlier in young adults.
Peter Koch: [00:11:24] When you think about that example of a dentist chair, it must change sleep patterns as well because you know, might not be able to lay flat or stretch out or get into that position. So you might not be able to be in a truly comfortable, restful position where your body can recover, which is really what sleep is for.
Al Brown: [00:11:44] Yeah, you'll notice that the number of pillow starts stacking up behind you if you lay on your back and you'll know that when you roll over on your belly and your hands fall asleep a lot quicker, that again, welcome to the C posture. That's where your head. And so those are all indicators, [00:12:00] you know. So it's one of those things that we the more static activity you spend in front of a computer in time, you really need to spend a lot of time sort of resetting the body and opening it back up. You need to set yourself up neutral. But you had mentioned earlier on we were talking that you like to slouch and everybody does. It's a position of fatigue. After a while, you just can't hold yourself upright and you'll slouch. So every 30 minutes you probably should get up and move or change or change your posture. The advent of the dynamic workstation helps because I always tell folks when you start to lean or slouch, just pop the buttons and lift the desk because you'll bring your pelvis underneath you and you'll change that pattern because you won't stand in a slouch. You can, but it'll be more difficult to do that. So and that's kind of the cue. But every 30 minutes, you should be changing your position and posture.
Peter Koch: [00:12:57] I think people listening might agree [00:13:00] with that, but they might find it difficult. And I know for me, if I have a project that I'm doing that requires concentration and you get into that zone and you're focused on what you're doing, 30 minutes goes by like that.
Al Brown: [00:13:12] It does.
Peter Koch: [00:13:13] And if I take that moment to stand up, it may pull me out of the zone, which isn't really true. I mean, I you will move out of it a little bit, but like you said, move from the sitting position, come up to the standing position, do your work for a little while and sit back down. It doesn't have to be a disruptive process. It doesn't sound like just have to change that posture so you can stretch things out, get back to a better posture and then keep going with your project.
Al Brown: [00:13:42] I mean, you can even just roll your pelvis when you're sitting there. If your back is flat and you've got that C, you just roll your pelvis up into a more arched back and that in itself sort of just recuse the brain a bit. And again, we're just talking about what's happening [00:14:00] in the musculoskeletal system. I mean, there's other implications that are out there that, you know, and I think the it was the Harvard the Harvard Health Publishing in February 15th, 2021. They just came out and there was a Megan Markovsky who's at Women and Brigham's that associated with Harvard. You know, they start they're starting to look at other kind of physiological changes, you know, things like incontinence, constipation, and you can really see how mechanically you begin to impact your body. You know, I've said for years, you know, if you sit in that seat position, you know, think about your intestines. It's a giant hose that goes back and forth inside your gut. And that's convoluted enough with a lot of bends. But now when you sit in the C position, you just push it down. So you've not only [00:15:00] you've got this convoluted tube, but now you're going to compress it. And so think about food, trying to move through, you know, peristalsis or whatever that is trying to move down through and there's a little push back, you know, acid reflux, you know, like, oh, gee, I just or gastric upset or I don't feel so good. And again, you're mushing your intestines when you sit in that that poor position. Breathing is another example. You know, your diaphragm are these two conical shape muscles at the base of your of your lungs. That their job is when they're nice and perky is to pull those lungs down. And that creates a negative pressure in the air goes in. And then when they relax, your lungs are elastic, that passively it'll push the air back out. When you're sitting in that C posture slouched. Those diaphragm muscles are not perky. They're almost flattened out. So they have no ability to pull down. So to get a deep breath or even [00:16:00] to breathe normally, you have to almost start raising your shoulders, which is a lot of work. I mean, if you just you know, if you just take your shoulders and try to raise them up, you know, 60 times, you know, a minute or just, you know, even less than that when we breathe. But I mean, just that's very fatiguing because you're lifting up a large mass each time to breathe. So you're working harder to breathe and digest. Just from slouching.
Peter Koch: [00:16:25] That's amazing. And so I get to see the breathing, definitely the breathing thing. And you might find yourself to be a little short of breath sometimes, too, if you're sitting in that position. Some of the results of slouching that you talked about, the incontinence, the heartburn, acid reflux, are those immediate or would you find those to be something that that occurs hours or maybe even 24 hours later after you've had a bout of slouching? I'm trying to think of like that what that Q would be. And are people connecting their posture of what they [00:17:00] did all day yesterday? To now they wake up on Saturday morning after having spent all day or all week in the office and that slouched position. And now they're struggling to enjoy life on Saturday because of what's happening. So when one of those physical cues occur.
Al Brown: [00:17:19] You know, it probably if I were to theorize, I would I would think that it's maybe not something that you notice right away because you're, and particularly if you're younger, you're very tolerant and you probably are a little more active and moving around. But as you continue to have a job that requires that you sit and you begin to change that body physiologically and like you had mentioned, you know, from the hammock to the computer to the car, you repeat that same behavior to sitting at night, chill and watching a movie. You are you are [00:18:00] exposing yourself to that same issue. So it becomes more apparent and probably sort of insidiously sneaks in on you. And that's when you at some point discomfort, you know, you kind of go, what's going on? And I don't think people connect the dots to that sitting piece and off to the doc getting tested and finding out what's going on. Now you're starting to medicate, but when you really look back at the root cause you've got to reopen your body back up. You got to look at your behaviors, because until you change those, you're still mechanically beating yourself up.
Peter Koch: [00:18:37] Right. And I think a lot of people feel that the amount of exercise that they have, maybe at the end of the day they get an hour's walk in or something like that after they've been sitting in that slouch position for let's just call it an hour, six hours at work. Maybe they get up and walk around a little bit at lunch or whatever. So they sit slouched for six hours and then they got two more hours on the couch [00:19:00] and they got maybe an hour commute back and forth. So now you're at eight, nine, ten hours of slouched position. But I got one hour of exercise. You talk about how that's not quite enough and maybe you can elaborate a little bit about that right now, too.
Al Brown: [00:19:16] Yeah. James Levine works at Mayo Clinic and he actually wrote the book Stand Up. I think your chair is killing you, something like that. Or, you know, sitting is the new smoking kind of came from that sort of tagline. But when you look at I mean, that's kind of our mentality. I'm guilty of it, that I'll sit and do my work all day long in front of a computer. And then I think, oh, I got to get out and take my run or I have to lift or I have to exercise. But you won't. The degradation, degradation you've done to your body during those seven to eight to ten hours to eleven hours of sitting, you cannot recover from that one hour of [00:20:00] exercise, I think in Australia that. Actually coined the term they had done some research down there on this, and it's called the Active Couch Potato. So you still are going to suffer the you know, if you're sitting for 11 hours a day, there are I think there's 35 medical conditions, you know, type two diabetes, cardiovascular disease, cancers, that the risk factors will go up exponentially just from that sitting. And you can't recover by just having that one hour of exercise. It's something that you need to incorporate throughout the whole day of movement and each time you move. That's when I always encourage folks to sort of reset their body upright, you know, recue the game of Jenga, you know, get the blocks realigned, because if you don't, you continue down that road of impacting your health negatively.
Peter Koch: [00:20:57] Sure, sure. It's an important point [00:21:00] that I don't think we can stress enough, regardless of if it's the positions that you're in at work or if it's positions that you would like to be in when you're at home. It's we're not made to be stationary. We're made to be active. Everything about us is made to be active from just the amount of assistance the large muscle gives to our heart, to move blood around from our lower extremities to upper extremities, to try to fight off gravity. We're made to move around. We're not made to just sit in one place
Al Brown: [00:21:33] Yup everything sucks down to the earth. So and when you sit down, unfortunately, you shut off the largest muscles in the body. And so now you've lost all that assistance that any time they contract, they actually will milk and push the fluid back up. I mean, it assists your cardiovascular system, obviously, the venous return and the arterial flow, but the lymphatic system really kind of depends [00:22:00] on it. So and it's the filtering system that gets the junk out of your body. So, again, when you sit slouched, you sit and you sit. You know, you've not only are you mechanically compressing all the structures, but then you shut off the big muscles in the body that are assisting. So the accumulated effect of all that going on, you know, you'll start to have those physiological changes and you'll start, you know, like I said, shoulders from the mechanics of your shoulder change completely. And, you know, I can see folks I've seen folks that are queuing up for shoulder surgery and I'm going before you go there. Wait a minute. You need to open up your body first. They go what? And it's amazing how much a person has lost how to pull themselves back into neutral. And it's very cumbersome. It's exhausting for the first week to 10 days. But once they get it and they break on through to the other side, they actually feel a [00:23:00] whole bunch better. It's kind of. You know, it's like walking around with a stick and holding it in your hand and tipping the stick forward, maybe 15 to 20 degrees, that creates sort of a bit of a force on the wrist and hand and shoulder and arm. You're like, oh, you know, after you do that for a while, it's kind of my wrist is getting shaky where if you just balance that stick on your hand and walk around, you know, a little more of a challenge, but it's less awkward forced on the wrist. So you're just kind of bouncing around. So same thing with your body. When you get it all set up and you balance it out, you're much more efficient and it takes a lot less energy to move it around
Peter Koch: [00:23:38] A lot less. Take us through that exercise again of going from that C position and straightening up in your chair just by tipping your pelvis. I think that's that could be a simple thing that people can do. And if the folks listening to us right now, again, like I started this podcast, think about where you are, think about that C position is [00:24:00] your head forward or your shoulders hunched as your back round. And then Al is going to take us through that sequence of how just sit up straighter just by tipping your pelvis in a different direction. So when you do that.
Al Brown: [00:24:11] Yeah. I mean, think about yourself right now and where you're sitting. And if you can imagine that you had on a pair of. Pants or jeans, let's call them jeans, and they have back pockets and are you sitting on your back pockets right now? Are you rolled back? And so those back pockets are actually sort of facing down and on the seat. And if you are, then that's the start of C sitting. You actually are doing more sacral sitting. You know, you're sitting back on that sacrum. So what we want to do is rotate your pelvis and bring you out of that position. So and what you're going to notice is that as you as you bring your pelvis around, you're going to notice that you're getting taller. And you're also probably going to notice that your head will start to tuck back [00:25:00] in because your head follows your butt here, Pete, I'm telling you. So if your pelvis rolls forward and your pelvis is going forward, your head's going to go forward as your pelvis rolls backwards and comes behind your head is going to want to like the game of Jenga. We have to push the block up on top with the block on the bottom to keep it all balanced. So what I want folks to do now is get off your hip pockets and I want you to almost like you're pushing your belly forward and you're arching your back and you're trying to take your head up, you know, up towards the ceiling. So you rotate that pelvis forward and you'll feel a shift up on to that that part of your pelvis. So that's neutral sitting. That's hard to do right now, probably for most folks of in here going, OK, I'm working really hard to do that. That's why you want a good supportive chair that in that position now you want that inward curve of your back filled by your chair so that lumbar support becomes very important. You can't just and some [00:26:00] people do. Perch there are perchers that will sit on the edge of the chair and perch. That's OK. But that's a fatiguing thing to do. And eventually what you're going to do is you're going to, out of fatigue, roll back onto your hip pockets. OK, so, you know, again, it's just what you're doing is you're going have your hip pockets, you're going towards the ceiling with your head and you're rotating your pelvis forward so you'll feel an inward curve in your low back. And that's a more neutral position for your body.
Peter Koch: [00:26:27] And I think that's a good reset for folks when you're you stayed at your chair for a while. And if you can think about that sequence when you've been at your chair and you do tip your pelvis and you sit up straighter and you get a curve in your low back and your head tucks back, that's a cue to continue to get taller and stand up and adjust your desk, get up a little bit, maybe move the laptop from your lap to maybe the counter or maybe someplace else. So you're not sitting in that position slouched all the time.
Al Brown: [00:26:59] What [00:27:00] you know, one thing we didn't mention is the disk pressure. So you know that you have your vertebrae and then the disks are in between. So the vertebrae, the bony structure, the disc is soft tissue, very rugged structure, but again, exposed to long passive forces. It's impacted and sitting. If you think about it, you bring your thighs sort of towards your abdomen, you know, to about a 90 degree position that actually because of the attachment of like your hamstrings are attached to your pelvis and as you bring up that thigh, will tend to pull the pelvis around and want to force you into that C position. That's why it's good to have normal length in your hamstrings and all that kind of good stuff. But if you pull your thigh up into that position and your back does round off and just sitting in and of itself puts about 40 to 50 percent more force on that disc. So just the act of [00:28:00] sitting, you've loaded your back. So it's important to get up. And when you get up, another great thing to do is when you stand, you just hands on waist, feet, shoulder width apart, and you just do a little bit of and keep your chin tucked. You don't want to do the what is it, the limbo where your head goes way back. You keep your head your head tucked and you do a little bit of back extension and there should just be a little bit of pressure in the low back and maybe a little bit of stretching on the front side. But that resets that disc could actually reposition some of the pressure, the gel inside it. It's a slow, gentle movement. It's not something that you force. But any time you're sitting in a car and sitting at your desk, you know, every 30 minutes, that's one of those things you get up and just sort of reset your body in that regard.
Peter Koch: [00:28:52] People will do that. As they feel really fatigued, you'll get really tired, you'll start feeling all those bodily [00:29:00] cues, you'll get achy, you'll get stiff in your mind, I'll get a little foggy. But you really want to make those changes before those cues happen. That's the whole idea
Al Brown: [00:29:09] Right it's too late when you're hurting.
Peter Koch: [00:29:12] Exactly.
Al Brown: [00:29:12] Water over the dam.
Peter Koch: [00:29:13] Yeah. And we ignore those cues, too. So like, oh, just a few more minutes or I'm almost done or I'm going to get this here, but we got to get into that habit and be more intentional, I think. And that's the key word to be intentional about how we go about our day in our body position as we sit at our desk or stand at our desk because our well doesn't even need to be at a desk. You could it could be anywhere you can be in an excavator working for a construction company or a bulldozer or you can be a truck driver. You're going to find yourself in those C positions often. Or I was driving actually back from this area yesterday and there's summer. So there's a lot of road construction and there are quite a few folks out there as flaggers. And you can look at posture's as they get as the day [00:30:00] gets on, they'll be in that standing C position where they might have started to be in the beginning of the day. When they're fresh, they're upright, their shoulders are back, their heads where it needs to be. And as the day goes on, they get kind of in that old man position where they're leaning on the stop sign instead of standing up with the stop sign.
Al Brown: [00:30:19] That used to be a more brutal job, you know, because back they figured out that remember the day when they used to just have a little handle? I do stop sign and they would just flip it around.
Peter Koch: [00:30:29] And they were holding it instead of on a poll right?
Al Brown: [00:30:30] They were holding it. So and some genius came along, probably some famous ergonomist and said, you know, if you had a longer pole, that would be less force on the body. And so you'll see that that long pole is present in all construction.
Peter Koch: [00:30:48] It's ubiquitous now.
Al Brown: [00:30:48] It's ubiquitous. But the problem is, is you're right. You know, here's a person standing there all day long not moving, you know, because you can walk longer [00:31:00] than you can stand still. That makes sense?
Peter Koch: [00:31:04] Does it make sense to me?
Al Brown: [00:31:06] So, like, if you stand there and don't move, Pete, and then I'm going to go walk and we're going to see how many hours I can walk and how many hours you can stand still and see who can last longer. I'm going to last longer simply because I'm sharing the load throughout my whole body. And it's just brief moments. You're statically loading and you can't move.
Peter Koch: [00:31:26] Let's take a quick break so I can tell you about our E-Ergo resource that can be used to help solve ergonomic challenges at your workplace. Sometimes contacting, contracting with and scheduling an ergonomist or occupational health nurse for an onsite evaluation doesn't fit with our Just-In-Time workflow in a competitive economy, fixing the problem right now is essential, and improving worker comfort and efficiency are key components to ongoing success. Free to our policyholders MEMICs E-Ergo, Tool can help you overcome ergonomic challenges. [00:32:00] With just five quick photos or a short 30 second video and a brief description of what's being shown, you can send us the critical demands and essential functions within the work tasks once received. Our ergonomics team can identify risks and exposures and provide reasonable suggestions for ergonomic improvement within just a few short days. Start the E-Ergo process by logging into the MEMIC safety director at www.MEMIC.com/Workplace Safety. Now let's get back to today's episode.
Peter Koch: [00:32:35] And you talked about it before the podcast as we were discussing this, the body carburetor. When I'm moving that carburetors move in your lungs, your heart, there's a demand in there. You've got enough cardiovascular activity to support that demand. But when I'm just standing there and I was on the way home late yesterday evening watching the [00:33:00] gentleman stand with the stop sign, and it was for whatever reason, it was a long stop. We must have been there for ten minutes. And I don't think he shifted maybe once or twice during that entire ten minutes. And I'm look at him going, That that can't be comfortable because if it was me, I'd have been shifting back and forth, moving side to side, because I can't I can't stand in that one position. My back will hurt. My knees will hurt. My feet will hurt. Because my carburetor is not going the way it's supposed to, it's not getting enough air, right? There's not enough not enough air to make combustion happen. Kind of.
Al Brown: [00:33:35] You know, it's funny as a related topic, which I always like to reference this, you know, the sort of the beginning research of cardiovascular function and how it impacts us from a static to a dynamic activity is Jeremy Morris, who's an epidemiologist out of London, and he died in the 90s at 99 and a half years old. But he did the study on the double decker buses [00:34:00] in London and looked at the drivers and compared them to the I'm going to call them ticket takers. And the drivers sat. The whole day and the ticket takers would put in an average, I think it was, if I think back in the piece of research, I read about 600 steps a day that was.
Peter Koch: [00:34:21] Just going up and down.
Al Brown: [00:34:22] Up and down the double decker bus to punch tickets. And in the cardiovascular incident rate for the drivers was 50 percent higher. Then the ticket takers, and that was true cardiac events, that's not you know, they just have, you know, higher risk. And it was you know, it is a longevity. You know, they did it over a long period of time and they just set up incident rate driver to take, you know, and took into account some other. Variables, but for the most part, the drivers were out of, you know, 50 percent higher incidence rate of cardiovascular issues.
Peter Koch: [00:34:58] Wow. And that's supported [00:35:00] in current day. I know a professor that I've worked with in the past, Dr. Delia Roberts, who's done a lot of work within the recreation industry with her fit for ski program. But she's got a fit for Drive program for the long haul truckers out in British Columbia and did a study from a blood sugar standpoint and the effect of diet and lack of exercise sitting in the truck all the time. And just a couple of changes with a little bit of dietary change to manage blood sugar better and then more frequent breaks to be able to increase cardiovascular activity, change alertness, changed accident rates. There's not the studies not long enough to see the morbidity or cardiovascular incidents. But as the study goes on, as she keeps working with them, I bet she'll find some of the same results as the guy from London.
Al Brown: [00:35:54] Sure. Yeah, no, it's I think it was Dr. Levine. He had mentioned that, you know, post dinner, post [00:36:00] lunch, post dinner or go take a go take a 15 minute walk and blood sugar drops by about 20 percent, you know, so it sort of stirs the mix. And it's a healthier mix for you at that point as opposed to, you know, when you get up and now you're hypoglycemic because you just ate and you're like, that lazy boy over there was pretty good. I think I'm just going to go take a nap and, you know, and so it's a you know, one of those things that that it's not rocket science. It's not a magic pill, but it is common sense. It makes a huge difference in our body physiologically. It's kind of like the posture thing. I mean, it's your parents, you know, coming in and going straight up, straighten up, you know, when you're thinking, come on, leave me alone. But it's more present nowadays because of the advent of the laptop. And you throw a phone, a cell phone, and most folks will just bend their neck over and take a look at that cell phone. [00:37:00] So they're just contributing to it when they look even at their cell phone. So it's or you see, you know, a person sitting on the park bench or somewhere in a chair and they're just in that giant seat posture with their forearms down on their lap, you know, looking at whatever's going on the screen. And you're like, oh, you know, it's a physics problem because. You know, we always talk about the head weighing somewhere between, you know, there's 10 pounders and there's 15 pounders, but let's call it 13. But for every 10 degrees, you know, we live in a world of gravity, as you'd mentioned earlier. So for every 10 degrees that head comes forward, we add another 10 pounds of force to the neck and shoulders, to that flat and back to that disc, compressing the front side abdominal intestinal area, lowering the diaphragm so now it can expand. It's just it's messy all the way around.
Peter Koch: [00:37:54] All the way around.
Al Brown: [00:37:54] All the way around. Nothing good.
Peter Koch: [00:37:57] Nothing good can come of this. And [00:38:00] then there's the habit. Right. So you do it for long enough. And how many of us are conditioned to look at that phone? Right. So the phone vibrates or you hear a sound that sounds like your ringtone and you automatically look down at your phone or at least look down at your pocket or wherever it's stored. And it's not even your phone. It's somebody else's phone. But we're conditioned to do that. So we have this habit of looking down, looking at something that's in our lap or below shoulder height. And once you get into a habit. It becomes really hard to break that habit
Al Brown: [00:38:36] Once the genie is out of the bottle. It's hard to get them back in. Yeah, same thing with the posture. I mean, once you're down that and again, because we have a younger population that's kind of they you know, they didn't know life without a cell phone and a laptop. You know, I can go back to when none of that existed, you know, and as I do presentations now, I realize [00:39:00] that, you know, sometimes folks are looking at me like, wow, you know, it's just that it's always been part of my life. So but then I see this change in body posture that's beginning to occur because that thing that's in front of them and when you're young, you just don't think about those things. You're going to live forever and never have an ache or a pain. But, you know, you can talk to anybody who's. In the in the twilight, as would be the twilight, the twilight of life, and they'll say, you get achy and you do. So you don't want to contribute to it. If there are things that are that you can do that are easy, it's just a matter of initiating those and make sure you incorporate those into your daily life.
Peter Koch: [00:39:45] And the younger you are, like you had said, the easier it is to not notice or feel like you've recovered from. But again, if you continue those postures over and over and over again, you're not recovering enough. You're recovering a little bit enough [00:40:00] to not find that discomfort anymore. But as soon as you go back to that posture again, you're doing the same damage that you did before or the postures having the same effect as it did before. So all of a sudden, you know, you're 13, 14, 15, 16, not a care in the world high school. It's great looking on the college. It's awesome at the college. It's great you get out into the workforce and now you're 28 or 30 years old and you've spent 15 years or longer in that posture. Now, going back to that little demonstration you asked people to consider by taking your index finger and pulling it back. So now do that for a day instead of doing it for 15 seconds. And that's, you know
Al Brown: [00:40:44] Do it for a day, do it for a week, do it for a month. Do it for 15 years. And the accumulation of trauma. Leads to.
Peter Koch: [00:40:56] Sure. And it's not just in one place, it's not just work, we talk about this for [00:41:00] hearing conservation. When we talk about hearing conservation programs in the workplace and regardless of how much time you spend in your workday, it's almost always more time in loud noises outside of your workday. For most people,
Al Brown: [00:41:18] They're not as loud, though. At home, the chainsaw is not as loud at home as it is at work.
Peter Koch: [00:41:22] right the homeowner chainsaw is always less,
Al Brown: [00:41:25] Right you don't need the safety stuff. Oh, no, it's a different animal altogether.
Peter Koch: [00:41:29] But as you start adding it up, so now you ask people, OK, so how long do you spend in this, this decibel level? Sorry, it's a hundred decibels and we're going to do this job for an hour or two hours or 15 minutes and we're going to take a break and we're going to go back the noise. And overall, they might be four hours in that that noise environment at work out of an eight hour day. Certainly there's other work that you're going to do. It's going to be louder for longer, but on average, it's not going to be that loud for that long. And then you start adding up the time that people [00:42:00] spend with headphones in with the music up to 100 decibels, or they're going to mow the lawn at home and it takes them a couple hours. I'm not wearing hearing protection or they're using the chainsaw or they're on their snowmobile or they're on their four wheeler or they're out shooting or they're out at a bar or at a concert. And all of a sudden you add up all this time and you've got a lot more time and loud noise outside of work than you do in work. But you have to add it all together. So you have four hours at work, you got six or seven hours outside of work, and now most of your day and it creeps up on you. And like you said, with posture, your body will get a little more achy regardless of how good you take care of it. So when you don't take good care of it, you just end up getting achy sooner. And you get to that point one day. And like you said before, what was it.
Al Brown: [00:42:52] 30 is the new 40.
Peter Koch: [00:42:53] That's scary.
Al Brown: [00:42:55] Yeah, I mentioned that the other day in the presentation. And some of the folks like I don't understand what you mean. [00:43:00] And I said, you know what? But someone in their 60s felt at 40. Because of the technology that now exists in a lot of our lives, those folks using more of the technology and slouching are going to feel those discomforts 30. So there's been a 10 year slip backwards. You know, I mentioned things like technology, like simple things like when we used to back a car, if you would rotate your body, which is good, you like to rotate your body because it helps to sort of lengthen a lot of these old, like tissues in your body. But now today you just look down at the camera and line up the lines. Still can't do it.
Peter Koch: [00:43:38] That's a whole other topic.
Al Brown: [00:43:39] So you just you don't you know, or if to answer the phone, you would have to run to get the phone or, you know, walk or go to the room where it was attached to the wall or on the counter. And now you just lift it out of your pocket and decide if you're going to answer it or not or
Peter Koch: [00:43:55] Or if it's not for you. You throw the phone to whoever it was.
Al Brown: [00:43:58] Yeah. And [00:44:00] that's where you get a lot of your entertainment now, too, you know, from screen time to actually music. So you don't have to go put an album on. You don't have to get a cassette. You don't you don't have to go turn the TV on and adjust the ears on the you know, it's so I mean, those are all kind of funny, very vintage things, but it's true. So we have eliminated movement.
Peter Koch: [00:44:21] Yeah. That almost the devolution said go back even farther. And you talk about the work where we used to do and get back to the agrarian society that we used to be. And you spent the majority your day in the field. They are your milk and cows or you're preparing the field or you're standing at the stove or you're doing you're splitting wood. Whatever those things were, it was you were spending the majority your time in activity and you got home at the end of the day and there was only just enough time to eat, relax for a little bit and then get enough sleep so that you can get up in the morning. And now we have all these conveniences which have [00:45:00] almost devolved our ability to be that active.
Al Brown: [00:45:05] That's right.
Peter Koch: [00:45:06] I have a I have a very good friend of mine who's whose dad has been a dairy farmer all his life, and the dad is now getting into his 70s. But, you know, he will still put in more physical activity in his day just by he still goes out and milks the cows. He's not anywhere near as fast anymore. And he's a little more grumpy. It's sometimes when things don't go his way. But he still puts in a pretty physical day that would kick most people's butts. They would be exhausted. He gets back at the end of the day and he's like, yep, just the same thing I've been doing for the last 60 years or so. . So it's interesting how that lack of activity has crept into our lives and it's made it easy for us to relax. But that relaxation has it [00:46:00] doesn't always have its benefits. It has it detracts from our ability to have really a pain free longer life.
Al Brown: [00:46:08] Hmm. There was there was an utter pun in there, but I just couldn't fit it in. Utterly amazing that he does so well at this age.
Peter Koch: [00:46:20] Yeah, yeah, yeah. I got it right in the bucket.
Al Brown: [00:46:22] There you go. You know, you know, the one thing if you think about, you know, a couple of things we didn't I'm going to throw these in the bucket too. TMJ. Oh yeah. Jaw pain. Because as soon as you project the head forward, you change the function of the jaw, headaches, vision issues. When we look at a computer screen, we blink a whole bunch less so we get dry eyes. So there is a whole bunch of products out there from ballooning my glasses etc. And it's just mechanically you just don't you're not remoistening your eyes often, [00:47:00] as you would if you were just looking out into the world as opposed to a screen. So we blink a whole bunch less. So it's, you know, again, just more things that are not good when we slouch and we tip forward. So you got to pull back.
Peter Koch: [00:47:14] Got to pull back and it becomes habit. And when we get into a habit, our body adjusts to the habit that we're in. So it starts to shut down those things that it doesn't need, but it does need those things. But we're driving that negative behavior through habit. So just over time, just the shortening of the oh, I don't need to be that long as your muscles just shorten up and all of a sudden my hip flexor is getting out of the car becomes painful because my hip flexors have been shortened so much for sitting all the time because you're sitting in front of your computer screen and then long commute, you're not walking as much. So those habits and I think that's a key part to remember too, to break that habit, [00:48:00] you need to be intentional, but you need to try to break those habits so that you. Can be more pain free and not suffer some of the changes that will occur in your body over time through those habits that you've built up for the last 15, 20, sometimes even 30 years. You think nowadays going back through the oh, I was in the in the grocery store the other day and I kept hearing like a video playing. I'm looking around. I can't see anybody like I was expecting someone to be watching a video as a shopping. But what it was there was a kid, probably six years old, in the cart groceries all around him. And he was just watching the video. He was on his phone. And so he's six years old. And we're creating that habit of head because he was head forward looking at the phone [00:49:00] in his lap.
Al Brown: [00:49:00] Yeah, he's been indoctrinated.
Peter Koch: [00:49:03] There we go.
Al Brown: [00:49:03] There we go. Yeah.
Peter Koch: [00:49:04] So, you know, intentionality about the technology that we have and that intentionality of what we do with it and around it and how it affects us. It's important for us to know those effects. And we'll put the reference of the study that you referenced earlier in the podcast. Show notes. But can you maybe talk a little bit more about the Harvard study that talked about those the effects of what's going on when you have that C posture?
Al Brown: [00:49:29] Yes, it's fairly recent
Peter Koch: [00:49:30] You said 2021. Right.
Al Brown: [00:49:33] It's a newsletter they put out. And I think it was Megan Markovsky, who's a physical therapist. And I think it was a Kyle Staller. He's a gastroenterologist at Mass General. But it was an interesting read because I've theorized for a number of years that, you know, mechanically you're compressing all those structures. So they're now beginning to go. And [00:50:00] I'm sure they they've thought the same. I mean, that's what starts the theory. And then they're probably much better about doing the research than me. I just tend to get stuck, you know, bite onto that bone and I'm not going to change. But I feel that's the case. But, I can give you the link to that?
Peter Koch: [00:50:16] Yeah, please.
Al Brown: [00:50:16] And beginning to recognize that that slouch posture is so common, but it's going to create so many common problems that they're probably seeing those same complaints over and over again. And at some point you start to put two and two together and you go, all right, you know, and we can't in the medical world, sometimes we are so busy treating the symptoms, we forget to think about the root cause. And when you when you walk it back and you start looking at it and again in the world we live in, in safety and risk and exposure, I mean, that's what we're always doing, is trying to find the root cause because you can sit there and throw things, tools, money. But until you've discovered where the problem is and again, this [00:51:00] is you know, it's pretty basic to me that it is just, you know, just repeated unconscious behavior of sitting in front of something that you're looking down at throughout the day. And we do a lot more things on that computer than we've ever done in the past. You know, I mean, how many jobs now are just what is about 80 to 85 percent? I think we're closer to 87 percent of jobs now are sedentary and they're sedentary, most likely because of technology. Sure. I mean, look at our logging industry nowadays.
Peter Koch: [00:51:29] Oh, yeah. Yeah.
Al Brown: [00:51:30] You know, there's no more log runs down the river with people with spikes on their boots, running around with pick poles. And, you know, it's you know, there's a forwarder. They go in. I don't mean that they don't even have to get out of the seat. Now, the whole forward spins back around. They drive back out the way they came.
Peter Koch: [00:51:47] And it's like the Starship Enterprise in there with the amount of controls that they have because they can do everything from that seat. Everything most of the things that your hand crew was going to do, you know, 30, 40 years ago, [00:52:00] it's all done by machine now.
Al Brown: [00:52:03] Yeah. So and that's an office that bounces around, you know. So think about now we got that forward head posture with our C posture and you're going to go over stumps and bumps and that creates a forward momentum of your head and core, which translates into a huge extra load on the back. So, yeah, that's an office on steroids.
Peter Koch: [00:52:25] It's watching a guy a couple of days ago at a at a resort. They're doing a big construction job and they're hauling Phil from the pit up the up the mountain road, which is pretty bouncy, full of water bars.
Al Brown: [00:52:37] Don't you think Phil should walk?
Peter Koch: [00:52:38] Well, you know, Phil could walk, but Greg's on his way, so you never know. Put that in the bucket, too. So and, you know, I got a good view of the driver, so and all day long, he probably made twenty trips while we were there doing the training all day. And as he drove past us just in the, you know, maybe [00:53:00] six, seven hundred feet that we could see the truck, a lot of bounce happen and you can see the guy bounce. Up and down in the head, moving back and forth, he looked like he was at a heavy metal concert for crying out loud. How much motion was happening? Even with the air right seat, there was still enough movement. And so he's doing that all day. And just the compression just from being in the posture. And like you said, now you add the bouncing adding to gravity and velocity in that, too. So things aren't going to go well. Over time.
Al Brown: [00:53:29] Yeah, I'm sure he had his fill of that job.
Peter Koch: [00:53:36] And on that note. All right. So we've talked about some solutions for this, right? We have we want to be intentional about how we're setting up our workstation. We want to be intentional about when we take breaks and not just wait for our body to cue us with a pain or fatigue response. You gave us that little exercise [00:54:00] of being able to tilt your pelvis the opposite way to sit up straighter, tuck your head back and get up every 30 minutes or so. What else can we do to combat that forward head posture? And let's talk specifically about maybe the office environments or when you you're actually working at a computer, you maybe you have a laptop and that's the only thing that you have assigned to you for a machine to work on.
Al Brown: [00:54:27] Yeah. I mean, simple things. If you only have a laptop, go out and buy a secondary keyboard and a mouse and just move that laptop up so that if you have good vision and that's, you know, you might have a single lens, single vision lens, not a progressive like you or me, but if you have a single lens glass or you have good vision, most likely you want to put that that laptop screen [00:55:00] up. So where the content that you're viewing is at eye level and then the keyboard should be down so that your upper arm is parallel to your core and your forearms parallel to the floor, that keeps us the quietest and be in a good chair because again, we don't want it with the laptop or the screen too low. You're going to, you know, slump over into the seat position. So that's one of the basic things to do. And with this work from home that we just saw recently, we really kind of pushed at least get a secondary keyboard and mouse and get away from using the laptop for both. If you have a you know, you move that up a level and you go get a docking station and get a screen at home, that's at the right height and the keyboard and all that kind of good stuff. Those things all influence where your head goes. So it's important that you look at where those screens are now as a sort of side note, if you're a progressive lens where that screen won't go as high because you can actually go in the opposite [00:56:00] direction with your head going backwards. So we really want that game of Jenga balanced. So you might have to lower the screen a bit lower than contented eye height might have to be fifteen or so degrees below that level because of the way you use your lenses. Paperwork is another thing that a lot of folks will just lay it. A classic was to push the keyboard away so that the arms were extended and then the paperwork was laid between the keyboard and your belly to a certain extent. So you had an extreme forward head posture to look down at that paperwork, reverse that, put the paperwork on the other side and put the paperwork on a slight incline, 15, 20 degrees. You don't want to cover the screens, but a little bit of a document holder. And it can even be something basic, like a little binder that's propped up and it'll raise that document up enough that you can glance down with your eyes because your eyes can look down 15 to 20 degrees without you tipping your head and you can read the document [00:57:00] and then look back up at the screen. So, you know, look at the things that you interact with on a daily basis and try to get them at eye level, your iPhone or your iPhone Android. Sorry didn't mean to sell advertisement for anything, you know, think about bringing it up to your eyes as opposed to bringing your head down to it. And I know that can be tiring because that that phone weighs a ton, particularly if you're sitting there reading it for a while. Sometimes I tell folks just to cross their arm over almost like they're sticking their arm, like they're half folding their arms. So you might have the left arm under the right arm sort of up in the armpit area and it can support your hand. So the phone is in a better position for your hands. Had to stay upright.
Peter Koch: [00:57:52] Sure. It moves it out a little bit farther away from your body. Yeah.
Al Brown: [00:57:54] Yeah. And you can do it sort of passively and kind of read what's going on. So that's kind of the workstation. Think [00:58:00] about those things and all the stuff you interact with. Same thing in the car, like adjust your mirrors. So that when you're sitting upright in the car, you can see, you know, you might frame out the back window and if halfway through a drive you look in the mirror and all of a sudden you're looking at the ceiling, you're going, oh, and tells you that you've just gone into a forward head see posture. So. Correcting those mirrors so that they give you cues of where you are, you can do fun, little things to like once you have your screens at the right place. I often thought this would be a cool thing to do, is you put a little and you could you could do anything you want. I'm thinking this would be sort of the Elton John kind of tool to help you keep good portion. I reference Elton John simply because I'm thinking eyeglasses, but if you put a little mirror at the top of your screens, you know, just there that when you're in the right position, you can see your eyes. OK, so as the day goes on, all you have to do is and that's why I called the Elton John's, I put a set of glasses [00:59:00] over so you could see yourself in the eyeglasses reflecting back things like you're wearing eyeglasses as the day goes on, if you fade out of out of sight. And you don't see yourself, you pop back up until you see yourself, and it also cues you to get up and move because you're obviously fatigued and slouching. And then just from a walking around standpoint, because here's a showstopper. You never look at yourself. OK, so, you know, how do you have to rely on these internal memory, muscle memory kinesiology to understand where you are in space. So, you know, you're not looking at yourself. So when you were in great posture walking around, you typically don't see you. Let me say that again. When you're walking around in great posture and your head's upright and you might occasionally see your hands swing by, but other than that, you really won't see much of you at all, which tells you you're in good shape. If [01:00:00] you're hanging over in the seat posture and you're seeing a lot of you, you're creating a lot of problems for yourself.
Peter Koch: [01:00:06] Chances are that's not so good right.
Al Brown: [01:00:09] You'll see it coming. Yeah, it's one of those things are good position. You won't see much of you.
Peter Koch: [01:00:16] Yeah, that's an interesting key. And I really hadn't thought of it that way. But it is if I'm looking down, you know, you can see your feet, you can see your knees, some of us might see, you know, shirts or skirts or whatever. But if you're sitting up or standing up straight, you're not really seeing anything now. You might see hands, you might see a toe, but you're looking around. You're looking at the world around you instead of yourself and the sidewalk all the time.
Al Brown: [01:00:40] Good, solid game of Jenga. You know, you're upright.
Peter Koch: [01:00:45] So what are some work if people want to find more information about the effects of slouching and maybe some different ways to counteract it or how to set your workstation up or to do things to counteract slouching, where might they [01:01:00] go to find stuff?
Al Brown: [01:01:02] You can go to our safety director and we have a lot of resources there on the effects of sitting and ways to set up proper ways to set up a workstation. We have work from home references simply because most of us have been doing that for the past year and a couple of months. And we also have stretches, a couple of good stretch posters, movement. I call them resetting posters because it's I mean, some of them are stretches, but a lot of it is just resetting your body. Kind of like I talked about standing up and doing some back bends. That's really sort of a resetting of the body in the back. So there's great material there. You know, James Levine's book on Stand Up, you know, I don't get any royalties from that recommendation, but I found it a great a great quick read. It's one of those kind of
Peter Koch: [01:01:55] It is a really good book. Yeah. Yeah.
Al Brown: [01:01:57] It just kind of hits the physiology of it and you kind of [01:02:00] go, huh? And it really touches on some other things to some. We didn't talk about obesity and all that kind of stuff from sitting and lowering your metabolism, but he really does a great job and he did a solid piece of research on that fidgetors and non-fidgetors and moving so a great book to reference and certainly online. There's always good, good references there. We'll put that the Harvard newsletter on the back side so that you can take a peek at that.
Peter Koch: [01:02:27] Be great. There's a ton of resources out there. Just when you're searching for stuff, always try to go to a reputable resource. There's always new and different information that's out there. Sometimes it's not always the best. So not that you have to start with MEMIC resources, but certainly, like you said, we've got a ton of resources out there. The Harvard Medical Review is also a great place to go. And then some of the books that are out there are good as well. But as long as you're talking about how to counteract those things with just natural stuff, like it's not going to be a quick, easy it's an easy [01:03:00] fix when you think about it set up straight. Right. Get up and move. Those are too quick and easy things to do, but they tend to be difficult because of the habits. So it's not a pill, it's not a surgery. It's not. I can go see somebody else and they can fix me. You kind of have to fix yourself. So that could be the biggest challenge. So when the solution that someone proffers for you to fix your fix, what ails you is that magic pill or the surgery or something revolutionary that someone else can do for you, it's probably not going to correct it. Might help for a little while, but might not correct that all the way. So those things that you can do for yourself are going to be immediately helpful. Just be intentional about them.
Al Brown: [01:03:43] Yeah, I mean, those are just addressing the symptoms. If you think about it and you know, what we're talking about is addressing the root cause. So it's harder, much cheaper, but it works. And, you know, you know, gravity's going to get you in the end anyway. So, you know, [01:04:00] don't help it along.
Peter Koch: [01:04:02] Don't give up.
Al Brown: [01:04:03] Don't. Yeah. Don't start doing the things that are going to happen to you anyway with aging and the breakdown of the body by mimicking those postures. Hmm, I was a little commercial break there, mimicking those postures early on. And again, it's just be mindful. Sure. Of where you are in space. Yeah. Yeah.
Peter Koch: [01:04:29] Excellent. Well, thank you very much for coming back on the podcast and sharing all this great information with us and the listeners out there. So appreciate it again very much.
Al Brown: [01:04:39] Thank you very much. Appreciate being here. Always fun.
Peter Koch: [01:04:42] Always fun. Thanks to all of our listeners out there for joining us today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast. We've been speaking about how slouching can affect your health with Al Brown PT and director of ergonomics at MEMIC. If you have any questions or would like to hear more about a particular topic on our podcast, email [01:05:00] me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/podcast, where you can find additional resources, links to other podcasts with our as well as our entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for our Safety Net blog so you never miss any of our articles and safety news updates. If you haven't done so already, I'd really appreciate it if you took a minute or two to review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whichever podcast service that you found us on. And if you've already done that, thanks, because it really helps us spread the word. And while you're there, don't forget to subscribe. That really helps us to please consider sharing this show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Kotch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.
In 2020, Fall protection was once again, number one of OSHA's Top Ten most frequently cited standards. On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, Steve Badger, CSP, OHST, and Safety Management Consultant with MEMIC breaks down OSHA's Top 10 and how it can be used as a tool for continuous improvement of your safety program.
Peter Koch: [00:00:03] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch. Well, we all make lists. I don't know about you, but I love to check stuff off my list. For me, it represents an accomplishment or at the very least, something I don't have to worry about anymore until, of course, it resurfaces on my lists again, lists tend to be an important part of any safety management process, and they can help keep us on track for the myriad of different topics, hazards and exposures that must be addressed by our teams every day in the workplace. It can be overwhelming about the number of things that we have to manage. So lists become an important part and sometimes we generate lists to help us focus our limited resources and energies. So consider hazard or injury mapping. These are two great ways to generate and prioritized injury prevention and hazard mitigation [00:01:00] efforts and strategies. Well, if you're not sure what those two things are, we can put some resources in the show notes. But this is not a podcast about hazard and injury mapping. We're talking about lists today and specifically OSHA's top 10 list. So OSHA has a myriad of different lists and their lists can also help employers and business owners find a starting place in workplace safety. So to help us with that today on the podcast, with me is Steve Badger, CSP, OHST and safety management consultant with MEMIC. Steve has more than 20 years of experience working with the paper, medical, sterilization and construction industries. He's also an authorized instructor for the OSHA Institute in Manchester, New Hampshire. Steve's experience in different industries and workplace safety, as well as his connection to the OSHA Institute, has allowed him insight into OSHA's top 10 lists and how they can be used to help us focus on the right areas [00:02:00] and overcome some of the barriers to enhancing safety in the workplace. So, Steve, welcome today to the podcast.
Steve Badger: [00:02:08] Thank you, Peter. Thank you very much for having me on here today. And just a little bit about myself and my safety history. I started way back in 1986. I worked for Johnson and Johnson, and that was my really my first exposure to safety. And, you know, what we had to do. And the very first part of it was hazard communications and, you know, those things called material safety data sheets that just came out of nowhere supposedly. And, you know, that had to put together a program. And you have to think about the fact we didn't have a lot of computers back then. We didn't have a lot of resources back then to be able to go in and look these things up. We had to call people. And if we were lucky, we had a thermal fax that we could have somebody fax something to us. And it was a very difficult process when you worked in a laboratory like I did, where [00:03:00] there was a chemical part and there was also a microbiology part. And, you know, in trying to put these HAZCOM safety data sheets and programs together. So that that was that was where I get started with that. And then I moved back to Maine after that. And I worked for an environmental safety company doing lots of air testing and air monitoring and industrial hygiene related stuff.
Steve Badger: [00:03:22] Then I moved back out of state again, went down to the southern part of the country, down to Kentucky and Tennessee, and did a lot of work at the Tennessee Valley Authority Plants doing industrial hygiene, monitoring and safety related to that. Shortly after that, I came back to Maine again and did some more work in the environmental field and started doing a lot of work in the paper industry, doing safety related job safety analysis and things like that for the different companies that I worked for. And then a while after that, I started as the safety director for Fisher Plow, which gave me some industry related [00:04:00] background, which was really interesting. You know, to see a snowplow being made is something that we take for granted every year here in the northeast part of the country. But there's a lot that goes into that, a lot of safety and environmental concerns there. So and then, of course, I've been with MEMIC now for about ten and a half years as a full time employee. So, you know, I feel my background has been varied and it really has helped me in the years.
Peter Koch: [00:04:26] Yeah. It really kind of rounds everything out when you have that experience in all those different industries and makes you be able to I think at least that on my side, to be able to appreciate some of the challenges that a particular industry might have with either compliance or managing safety within their particular industry. But tell me a little bit more, because I know working with you over the last 10 years when I kind of think about OSHA and I want to have kind of an interpretation of maybe what a standard says, especially around the environmental [00:05:00] side of things or HAZCOM side of. Things I tend to think of you and I go back to you and I start thinking about, well, what would Steve what's Steve's got some insight into that maybe he can give me a little guidance in those areas. So talk to me a little bit about kind of your experience with OSHA and how you became, I guess, as interested as you are in the standards and then kind of going through their lists.
Steve Badger: [00:05:24] Sure, absolutely. You know, my interests have always been and I'm a numbers kind of guy and I like looking at, you know, these lists and frequencies and, you know, and how these things tie together with the frequently cited standards. How do they apply to the real world? You know, how do they apply to the injuries and incidents of that happened out there? You know, is there any correlation to it? And we certainly can talk about that later on as we go through this. But, yeah, that was my interest was really looking at and trying to figure out, you know, why are these top [00:06:00] ten violations? Why are they there? And, you know, is OSHA focusing on these things or is it these things that they see every day is they're driving from point A to point B or they get a complaint or something. And so, you know, trying to figure that out, you know, is really important. And we certainly can delve a little deeper into that is as we go through this. But, you know, it really gives us an insight as to what hazards are out there.
Peter Koch: [00:06:28] Yeah, perfect. And OSHA has tons of lists as we start to go through. And they really become a good repository for us for numbers as and they take numbers from the Bureau of Labor Standards and they pull them together and they analyze them and try to figure out sort of where some of the focus's are. And one of those lists we're going to talk about today is the top 10 most frequently cited standards. So why don't you tell us a little bit about what are the top 10 most frequently cited standards and where do they come from, [00:07:00] where they derived from?
Steve Badger: [00:07:02] Sure. Certainly the number one and it has been number one most years, certainly within the last 15 years, is fall protection or the lack thereof. And most of that comes from the residential construction. And in a lot of that is because, you know, is you know, is complaints are made war as OSHA happens to be driving by. They're going from point A to point B, they see somebody in an imminent danger situation, meaning that, you know, the worst hasn't happened yet. They have not been injured, but they are in a situation where they could be injured or it could be a fatality if the person should fall. So that's the number one citation that's out there. Number two, which is near and dear to me, is the hazard communications and hazard communications for the general industry side of things. It's always been number one for the last 15 years in [00:08:00] the overall list. When you combine the two together, it usually comes in second or third. And typically that has to do with one not having a written program. It's usually, number one, not having the safety data sheets, as we now call them, in place, and people just not being trained. You know what are the hazards of these chemicals? Number three, this past year was respiratory protection. And there's a whole host of reasons. Again, take a look at what was going on in our past year, you know, with covid-19 and, you know, and other issues and the difficulty of getting respirators. A lot of people took some shortcuts with respiratory protection.
Steve Badger: [00:08:41] Maybe, you know, some of those were things like not having a medical clearance to be able to wear a respirator. That was a big one. And again, not having a written program in which would have indicated to them that they needed to do these things, scaffolding came in number four. You know, scaffolding is one [00:09:00] of those things in construction and general industry that people use to get to upper heights, to be able to access something that they might not be able to get to from the ground. And there's a lot of rules and regulations around scaffolding, and it's very easy to make a mistake when it comes to scaffolding. Ladders was number five and typically with the ladder use, it was people not using them appropriately. And as most of us know, there's right ways and wrong ways of dealing with or handling ladders and how we access them and how we secure them from falling. And, you know, that message just doesn't seem to get out there sometimes. Number six was lock-out tag-out or controlling hazardous energy. And this one has more than just electrical implications. This has to do with pneumatics and hydraulics and lots of other types of hazardous energy that can seriously hurt or killed somebody. Number seven this past year was powered industrial trucks or forklifts. And typically [00:10:00] the citations that went along with that had to do with the, you know, the operators not being properly trained or the authorization from the employer, even though they might have been trained, they weren't authorized to use it, you know, in doing their daily inspections to make sure that that powered industrial truck is actually safe to operate.
Steve Badger: [00:10:20] We get to number eight, which was, again, a fall protection related issue. And in this case, here, it was training requirements and these training requirements, this had to do with not having a written program, not doing what we call training that is documented by a competent person that is not a certified training. And so there was a lot of citations. So between number one being fall protection and number eight, there was nearly 7000 citations alone just in those two areas. Number nine, was eye and face protection, personal protective equipment and again, these are very important [00:11:00] ones because we only have two eyes and if we're not protecting our eyes, you know, we lose something there. And so there was a lot of those types of citations. And then number 10 this past year was machine guarding. You know, we talk about, you know, guarding on pulleys and saws and all kinds of different types of machinery that has nip points and places where people could get their hands caught or their arms caught or some other part of their body or something they're wearing gets pulled into that piece of equipment. So, you know, it certainly is something that we you know, we could spend a whole day talking about just machine guarding because there's so many different issues around that. So that really rounds out that top 10.
Peter Koch: [00:11:44] Yeah. And it sounds like as we start to look at each of these top fall protection, hazard communication, respiratory protection, scaffolding ladders, lock out, tag out forklifts, fall protection again eye and face safety or PPE and then machine [00:12:00] guarding. You know, as we start to look at that long list, there's a lot that goes into each of those standards. And it seems that OSHA is you know, those citations are coming from particular parts of those standards that employers tend to miss. And I think that's one of the important things that we can think of this list as it is a reminder that, hey, these issues are out there. And, yes, they're coming from citations and OSHA is doing their enforcement process and finding these citations that way. But really, it's a good reminder that this happens all over. You know, if you have someone that uses ladders within your facility, know that Ladders was number five this year of the most frequently cited standards for OSHA. And if you have ladders, there's probably something that you can do to improve in that section. So ladders or utilizing [00:13:00] this list as sometimes a guide or a check to say, hey, how am I actually doing? How would I stand up as an employer for workplace safety based on this year's standards? So let's think about this. So this was this was from 2020, correct? The list that you just read off was from 2020.
Steve Badger: [00:13:23] Yes, that's correct. This is for fiscal year 2020. So I caution people, if you go out there and you're looking for these and these lists from other sources, maybe a magazine or maybe some other online service, you just have to be careful because sometimes these numbers don't seem to match up because they're doing fiscal year versus calendar year. And so the numbers can be a little bit differently because the fiscal year for 2020 ended in on September 30th. So we had several months after that to where some of these numbers may not match up. And [00:14:00] you're looking and you're going, wait a minute, you know, how can it be that much different? And it is because of the calendar year versus fiscal year.
Peter Koch: [00:14:06] It's a really good point, especially if you're trying to prioritize something and say, well, where do I want to focus? I want to focus on the place that maybe has the most frequency and it doesn't line up. So that's a really good point. Let's talk a little bit about because this is not the first year that has done this. They've done this for quite a while and have put together these lists of the top 10 most frequently cited standards. How does this year's lineup match up to say what happened in the past? So are they the same standards that keep getting cited all the time? Or are there significant differences from year to year?
Steve Badger: [00:14:45] Yeah, it's a great question because, you know, when you look back, I mean, just for an example, in 2011, the top three citations frequently cited violations were fall protection scaffolding and HAZCOM. [00:15:00] 2012 fall protection HAZCOM scaffolding, you jump forward a couple of years to 2016, fall protection HAZCOM scaffolding. So as you could see, these things do not change greatly from year to year. That top 10 tend to stay top 10. Now, there is some movement within that in this particular year, you know, for fiscal year 2020, the biggest mover within that was the respiratory protection. And as I mentioned, I think a lot of that was probably had to do with, you know, covid issues that people, you know, what are you giving people respirators because of the fear of somebody catching it or passing it along to someone else. So there was a lot of those type of issues, and most of those came because of initially just giving somebody a respirator and not making sure that they're medically cleared to wear it, which is, as we all know, could be a pretty dangerous situation for anyone that has any breathing difficulties,
Peter Koch: [00:15:56] As could many of these standards. If you think about [00:16:00] it, especially as you have mentioned, as you're describing some of the citations, many of those around training or authorization and OSHA as well as myself. And I think you personally as well think that there's a responsibility on the employers part to not only choose the people that should be doing the particular tasks correctly, but then authorize them to do that task, give them permission to do that task. And then the employer has a responsibility to provide the appropriate level of training so that they can be competent in the task that they're doing. And part of that is understanding the hazards that they're exposed to and the controls that need to be in place. And respiratory protection is a really good one. Because you put a respirator on and you see it all the time, you know, people will wear a paper mask, respirator, sweep and dust up in the shop someplace or they'll have a full face respirator on with. [00:17:00] And what you can see is their beards sticking out underneath the bottom of it. So they've understood that there's a hazard. They're utilizing a particular piece of equipment to help protect them from it. But they're not really understanding the limitations of that piece of PPE. So they're using it incorrectly and probably or possibly putting themselves at greater risk for the hazard that they're exposed to.
Steve Badger: [00:17:28] Yeah, absolutely. With the respiratory protection, it can give you a false sense of security that, you know, it's doing something for you. Whereas like you mentioned, you know, somebody's beard is sticking out from their respirator. That human hair is many, many times larger than a lot of the particles in the things that were inhaling. They get down deep into our lungs and cause the infections and those type of issues. So wherever that hair is sticking out, there's that much less protection that we have. And so it does give us a [00:18:00] false sense of security. Sometimes if we're not properly fit tested, we're not properly trained. To even put it on can be a big issue because that was something I always used to do with respiratory protection training. Was just hand some of your respirator and tell, OK, put it on. And, you know, probably half of the people would have it on sideways or backwards or, you know, upside down because they just didn't understand how that was to go on. So you can imagine with the covid-19 issues and, you know, respirators just being handed out, there was probably a lot of people wearing those incorrectly.
Peter Koch: [00:18:33] Yeah, I can totally imagine that. And then the same thing happens with fall protection. You see that often people using ladders incorrectly, people using harnesses incorrectly. And some of it stems from inappropriate training or lack thereof. Some of it stems from not having the right equipment and some of it stems from possibly ignorance around what the hazards are and the limitations of that particular equipment that they're handed given or that they've [00:19:00] brought themselves to the job site sometimes. So it's interesting if and if you go back to 2011 and fall protection in 2012, fall protection 2016 fall protection, and here we are again in 2020 fall protection is number one HAZCOM number two. To 2016 HAZCOM number two, 2012 HAZCOM's number two. Why are we seeing the same, I know you're not going to have an official, you know, Nostradamus like a predictive answer here. But I guess in your opinion, why are we seeing the same citations over and over and over again?
Steve Badger: [00:19:45] Yeah, I think there's a few really important reasons that I think sometimes it comes to, you know, lack of knowledge, you know, people, you know, they received these citations and they and they're, you know, doing work. [00:20:00] And so we'll pick one here has the communications and they buy a chemical, they don't realize that, you know, even though you go to, you know, your local hardware store and you buy this chemical, that you have to train people how to use it properly. And so there's some of that is lack of knowledge when it comes to things like fall protection. Sometimes, you know, people are in that mindset that, you know, this is the way we've always done it and we haven't had any serious injuries before. We've never had that, you know, that big issue that has come up. So they don't tend to change until there's something to motivate them to change. And so it could be an injury. It could be a citation. Sometimes people worry about the cost. You know, these you know, they're always fearful of, you know, they have their own business.
Steve Badger: [00:20:50] And if we put, you know, all this money into fall protection, you know, is that going to leave anything left for the business, you know, profit wise? And I always talk to people about that [00:21:00] and let them know, look, you know, can you afford the cost of somebody getting injured? You know, that's going to be a much greater cost to you than buying and training people how to wear a harness, you know, appropriately, you know, that personal fall protection stuff. So, you know, culture. Culture is always a big one that we always talk about, because sometimes people just, you know, don't have that culture within their company that helps them understand from the top down that, you know, your safety is our number one goal. You know, it is. And, you know, sometimes people will say it's number two or number three goal for a company. But, you know, the companies that have the best cultures, they understand that their workers, their employees are their number one asset. And if they don't protect those people, they are going to be in trouble.
Peter Koch: [00:21:54] Sure. I think that's those are all good, good insight into why we keep seeing [00:22:00] it and when you really think about it again. So if you take those factors, it could be culture, it could be cost, could be motivation, could be something else that's driving someone to not take a step in the right direction. We're also seeing, I think when we can talk about this next here we are seeing the same citations or the same categories of citations show up because they're the most frequently people are exposed, the most frequently to these things in the workplace. And that shows up. I think, unfortunately, as we start to look at our lagging indicators, they show up in our injury statistics. So can you talk a little bit about maybe how these citations correlate to or these standards, standard citations correlate into injuries and maybe what BLS or the Bureau of Labor Statistics might show for us?
Steve Badger: [00:23:00] Sure, [00:23:00] absolutely. You know, as I mentioned earlier, I'm kind of a numbers guy, I like to look at the numbers. And in this case here, if you take the data that came out of the Bureau of Labor Statistics for 2019, when we look at construction, you know, residential injuries, fatalities, that happened because people did not have proper fall protection. There were more than two thousand seven hundred and ten injuries just in that year of 2000, 19 from people falling to a lower level. There was also seven hundred and eleven fatalities, which was the number one thing that caused fatalities in construction and it is every single year. So 711 people that went to work last year, that did not come home. So it absolutely correlates to these citations. Another example of this is exposure to harmful substances in the environment and which is covered by hazard [00:24:00] communications. There were over 640 fatalities related to that. People using chemicals and think bad things happen, whether it was overcome with the chemical, the vapors or the gases that were related to that. Or maybe there was a physical hazard, something exploded or burned and caused that type. And then looking at respiratory protection number three in 2019, which was where we started this covid thing, they were five hundred and thirty three violations just on no medical evaluations. And so when you think about that and how many people may have been injured from that, you know, is hard to tell because sometimes those numbers don't always translate to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. But you can see from these numbers that they really do tie back to this top 10 citations in a very disturbing way.
Peter Koch: [00:24:59] Sure. And [00:25:00] it's really interesting. I just I just pulled up while you were speaking there. I went on to, you know, your favorite site, Google. Right. And I searched OSHA top 10 most frequently cited standards for 2019. And so you related that in 2019. And residential construction falls to the lower level, generated twenty seven hundred or so injuries and over 700 fatalities. Well, guess what? The top citation was in 2019 fall protection. And there are, you know, upwards of 6000 different citations for fall protection, just the general requirements. So not providing or not protecting the worker from the unprotected edge at some point in time. And then number two, so the second point, you had so exposure to harmful substances and environments of 642 fatalities. Hazard communication was number two in 2019 with 3600 citations. [00:26:00] So it's substantial. There's a strong correlation between what we're seeing as the top 10 most frequently cited standards and that lagging indicator of injuries and fatalities. And you talked about earlier, like, why do we keep seeing the same ones over and over? One of those was lack of motivation until there's an injury or a citation and then we come into compliance or we step up our game a little bit. But predictively, I think and as a safety guy and I like numbers, too, maybe not quite as much as you like numbers, but I like numbers, too. As we start to look predictively, you know, you put these two things up here, you put the BLS information up in front of you for the injuries and fatalities around cause. And then you start to look at the most frequently cited standards. And I think you've got a pretty good roadmap of where to look in your business, at least a checklist [00:27:00] of what to look into and see how do I measure up. So how am I doing on fall protection where does my HAZCOM program look like if I got scaffolding, how does that work? And I went, who's authorized to use it? Who's authorized to set it up, how do I inspect it? Do I even know what OSHA requires for compliance around scaffolding or did I just buy it off a buddy and we're working on it because I need it. Which is not a bad thing by it. However you need it. If you need that tool to do your job, awesome. But then understand what the limitations are and where you should be focusing in order to keep your people safe. And again, so you want to get the biggest bang for your buck. The top ten might be a place to start for sure. For sure. Any other thoughts on that, Steve? Any other thoughts are on correlation between citations and injuries and how the numbers kind of fit together and places that employers can or things that employers can use to. Focus on. [00:28:00]
Steve Badger: [00:28:01] Yeah, I you know, I think the you hit it, kind of hit it on the head there about not knowing, you know, kind of not knowing what they don't know. And that's where I think, you know, we you know, we can certainly help with that. You know, when companies come to us and say, you know, we use scaffolding and but we're not sure what we're supposed to be doing or with hazard communications, what are we you know, I can read the standard and I get very confused by it, which we hear a lot. You know, what do I have to do? So that's where, you know, we do some training. You know, we sit down with our insureds and talk about these things and, you know, try to put it into terms that people can understand, because that's all about, you know, when we talk about hazard communication, they you know, that's a that rule, that law that is in effect is the right to know law. And so you have that right to know, but you also have the right to understand. And so, you know, for the employee that's working with this stuff, they need to understand that if they do something inappropriate, [00:29:00] that bad things can happen from that.
Peter Koch: [00:29:03] Sure. Perfect. I think that's great. So a couple of places to look. Look at the Bureau of Labor Statistics, their information. Look at the top 10. And, you know, certainly use your insurance carrier, MEMIC. If you have a different carrier, use them or your trusted agent partners to look out. Or maybe you're some of the industry experts that are out there to kind of get some more information on some of these areas that you might not have full knowledge of. And they can be complicated. I was looking at you know, workplace safety. There's really two components. There's the moral component to it of like I really want to make sure that all my employees go home in the condition that they came in. I don't want them to get hurt. They could be sore. They can be tired just from physical activity and labor. But I wanted to get hurt. I want them to be safe so there's their moral component. And then sometimes that moral component, you get [00:30:00] to a point where I don't really know how to do it. And the compliance side of it, the standards that OSHA put out together put there is that tends to help with that because it gives you a baseline. Here's the minimum that you can do to try to mitigate the exposure to the hazard that your employees have while they're in the workplace. So those two pieces together and certainly the OSHA top ten gives you an idea of where to focus and what's going to give you the biggest bang for your buck generally. And obviously, if you're operating a company that doesn't have hazards that are encompassed by the top ten, it's not going to give you a whole lot of help. But certainly if you do if you use any of those things, the top 10 is going to going to give you an idea of where to look and then what standards to focus on. So not a bad deal. Well, let's talk a little bit about how Osha comes up with these. You mentioned earlier that [00:31:00] there were there are different ways that, you know, OSHA might drive by or OSHA might come to your business to inspect or to look for how you're doing on the compliance piece. And it's that partnership of helping keep the American workers safe by working with the employers out there to get them to understand where some of the gaps are within their safety process. So how does OSHA come by the citations and how do they come by citing businesses for not following the standards?
Steve Badger: [00:31:38] Yeah, that's great, and I'm glad you mentioned the partnership part of this, Peter, because that's how we absolutely need to look at this. This is a partnership. OSHA's job is to protect that worker, your employee, just like it is yours. And that's why it's a partnership. It's not and it should never be an adversarial type of relationship. They're [00:32:00] not there to cite you. They're not there to fine you. They don't get their you know, their funding from the number of citations that they give out. They're there to help you keep your people safe. So, you know, it should be treated as a partnership, not as a bad thing. You know, I always use the example. You know, it's like police. Their goal isn't to write tickets. Their goal is to keep people safe. And with OSHA is to ensure a safe and healthful workplace that's written into their preamble, into their you know, this is their purpose is to help create that environment. So moving on to, you know, what do how they go about these inspections is, you know, they really it breaks down into two different types of inspections. There's programmed inspections. We'll talk a little bit about that in a minute. And then there's unprogrammed ones. Now, these unprogrammed ones can be anything from an imminent danger situation, meaning that they happen to be driving from point A to point [00:33:00] B, they see somebody on a roof or maybe they're working in a trench where they're not being protected. If that trench should collapse, they could they could be crushed or killed in there. Those they call those imminent danger situations where they have to stop at those because the worst has not happened yet. But potentially it could. And so that their number one, you know, unprogrammed is these imminent danger type of situations or somebody may call them and say, hey, you know, if you know these you know, this is this roofing project going on somewhere. And, you know, there's a bunch of people working without fall protection. They absolutely are going to respond to that because we know what those outcomes of those falls can be, that they can be fatalities.
Peter Koch: [00:33:51] No, I just I was thinking, as you're talking about imminent danger, there's an interesting video on YouTube, and I'm sure you've seen it. An [00:34:00] OSHA compliance officer had driven past road construction that's going on. And there's an open trench happening there. And all you can see in the video is he's already come on site and he's introduced himself and he's asking just questions like, hey, what do you doing how long you've been working there? He's asking the guy to get out of the trench, pretty unstable. The guy is pretty much standing on a pipe in the middle in the middle of the trench and within. I don't think the video goes for longer than maybe 40, 45 seconds. Within that 45 second time frame, the size of the trench start to sluff and the guy jumps from where he's standing to another pipe to get out of the way of the collapsing trench. And had the OSHA guy not been there, the person might have might have been in a lower segment of the trench and not able to jump out of the way had been buried. So that imminent danger piece is [00:35:00] helpful. And I think it highlights sometimes As an employee or as an employer, we might not recognize the danger that we're in, which is why we have standards there. So I might be really comfortable with that risk up until the time that I get crushed or I do fall or I am exposed to very hazardous chemical and all of a sudden I'm not in a place where I can work anymore.
Peter Koch: [00:35:28] Let's take a quick break so I can tell you about MEMIC online instructor led training for OSHA's 10 hour construction and general industry standards outreach workshops. Taking an OSHA 10 hour construction or General Industry Standards outreach course is a great way to set the baseline for workplace safety knowledge with a focus on hazards and controls. MEMICs authorized OSHA outreach trainers take the course's attendees through the required topics for the 1910 or 1926 OSHA standards. [00:36:00]Free to our policyholders. These online outreach courses are a great way to balance the need for engaging training around the OSHA Standards and scheduling time for staff to travel to attend an in-person class. Check out the full schedule of MEMIC workshops at www.MEMIC.com/WorkplaceSafety. Now let's get back to today's episode.
Peter Koch: [00:36:28] So it's an interesting it's an interesting video, I think it really does highlight how a compliance officer can, especially in an imminent danger situation, be able to help. But unfortunately, there's not that many compliance officers and they're not going to be able to drive by every workplace in order to help you be safe. So there's other ways that OSHA has from a priority standpoint in these unprogrammed inspections. And you talked a little bit about someone [00:37:00] maybe calling in a complaint or a referral that be another one of those ways to for them to be called to an inspection, correct?
Steve Badger: [00:37:09] That is correct. complaints, they may be called in complaints. They maybe somebody has filled out a form and submitted it, you know, through the through their website. Those complaints they do take seriously and they certainly take more seriously those ones where someone has taken the time to fill out a form and put it in. It can be done anonymously. They get a lot of calls, quite frankly, people maybe disgruntled former employees or maybe somebody didn't get a job bid that they were hoping to get. You know, they get a lot of these complaints. So they, you know, being not many people to be out there and do these inspections, they have to pick their battles, they have to pick, you know, what ones, you know, mean the most. And if somebody fills out that form, they're going to take that seriously. Referrals can come [00:38:00] from a number of different sources. They can come from here in the state of Maine. We have safety works they may have gone into and done a walk through of a certain facility or a business and found some hazards and made sure that the employer knew about those hazards. And if they have chosen not to fix those or not to correct those hazards, they may refer that, you know, further on other referrals come from places like EMS, fire, police, where they maybe they've had to go and take somebody, you know, to a hospital to get care because they fell off a roof. So sometimes those referrals can come from those directions as well. The second most common of the unprogrammed inspections are the fatalities and catastrophes. That's where the worst has happened. Something bad has happened. Somebodies fallen off a roof. They've been killed or somebody has been put into the hospital because of a situation. And that's also one of those things where, you know, you as [00:39:00] an employer have to make sure that OSHA is aware of these things. OSHA requires that any fatalities that happen on your job site, you have to notify them within eight hours of that fatality catastrophes such as somebody being put into the hospital, you have up to 16 I mean, sorry, 24 hours excuse me, to be able to put that in. But you have to let them know that is part of the rules as part of the law, that you have to let them know about those. And so they will absolutely follow up on those things. You know, anything whether there's an amputation or somebody loses an eye, they're going to investigate that. They're going to require you to, you know, talk to them a little bit about that and what you're doing to prevent that from happening again.
Peter Koch: [00:39:45] And I think for those specifically, I meant obviously imminent danger is something that's pretty obvious from a fatality and catastrophe. You know, something has happened. Like you had said, the worst has happened. And OSHA now [00:40:00] is trying to work with you not so much to point fingers and say, hey, you're doing something wrong. But, hey, let's look at your process. And what did you do? How did you, how did this come to be? Why did it happen? Because, you know, honestly, not that the OSHA standard covers all of the situations that could be out there from a workplace hazard standpoint, but in particular for the most frequent causes of injuries and fatalities. The standard if you apply the standard well, it will cover the majority of the potential problems that would cause injuries or fatalities that are out there. Catastrophe's serious enough injuries to put somebody in the hospital for a period of time. And they're really there to help you figure out how to prevent this from happening again. And obviously, they're doing it from a compliance standpoint, but they have to that's part of their mission [00:41:00] standpoint. And you can you know, if you took the OSHA top 10 standard or top 10 most frequently cited standards to begin with and started to go through your business. And how are you doing on the compliance piece? You may never get to the imminent danger inspection, the complaint or referral inspection or the fatality or catastrophe inspection. So, you know, one of the other, they can help you get to a place where the injury or fatality, either will never happen again or won't happen in the first place. Awesome. So there's one more type of inspection out there we talked about the unprogrammed, the inspections. And why don't you talk a little bit about the programed, inspections, because I think that's a pretty interesting piece because it does have more numbers involved in it and how they determine where they go.
Steve Badger: [00:41:49] Absolutely. With the programed inspections, there are different. A couple of different kinds that we want to talk about first is sometimes they have a local emphasis [00:42:00] program where the local will say state of Maine, OSHA taking statistics from the Bureau of Labor Statistics or, you know, taking them from other sources that there are a lot of particular injuries in a particular occupation. And so they will take those and say, OK, we're going to focus on that this particular year here in the state of Maine. You know, at different times we've had sawmill's we've had things in the health care industry for local emphasis in what they will do is they will focus on those because they're higher than, you know, the average types of the numbers of injuries and the frequencies. The other type that goes kind of goes along with that are national emphasis programs where OSHA as a whole is a federal agency is focusing on a particular subject, in this case, one really common one is silica. The exposure to crystalline silica is a huge one for [00:43:00] them at this point, because silica is one of those things that, you know, it's naturally found mineral in the ground. People, you know, people get exposed to crystalline silica through, you know, cutting of concrete and things like that and dust and so, you know, as more time goes on, they're finding out that the levels of exposure are higher than what they should be. So as they are going along in time, they ended up, you know, doing more of these inspections and keeping the exposures down so that people aren't getting sick from this. Again, that partnership, you know, helping those employers, you know, realize that, wait a minute, this is something that is serious can make people sick prematurely and have breathing difficulties, which, you know, with silica, a good example that once you have it, you know, you once you have silicosis, it doesn't go away. It's something you have for life. So we certainly want to try to avoid that as much as possible.
Peter Koch: [00:43:58] Yeah, for sure. Now, with [00:44:00] the program inspections, if I wanted to find out what emphasis programs were, were in my area, in my state or maybe what national emphasis programs were and what I would be affected by, where would I go? Where do I look that up? Because it's not something that you see a lot in the newspaper or find unless you're following safety publications, you're not going to see it all the time. So as a business owner, how do I find out what those national or local emphasis programs are?
Steve Badger: [00:44:30] Yeah, absolutely, the best place to take a look for these are is at the OSHA.gov website, www.OSHA.gov for government is absolutely the best place to go. And if you do a search when you go in there, they have a very, very good search engine for their website. And you go in there and you plug in local emphasis or national emphasis programs, you will see you there will pop up and tell you different [00:45:00] ones and even some past ones that they've looked at, you know, previously. And then maybe now they put an end to it. You know, maybe they're focusing on something different to, you know, a different type of industry or something. But that is by far the best place to look. Some of the trade magazines will have some of that information, but it doesn't really go into why they're focusing on those particular things as much as OSHA does.
Peter Koch: [00:45:25] Good. I think that's a good place. So. OSHA.gov, good place to go. I know I go there fairly often as part of my job and I guess as a safety, as a safety consultant, you're going to go there as a safety person at a particular facility. It might be a good place for you to check out to. I know quite a while ago here in Maine, I know that one of the, I Can't remember if it was a local emphasis program or a national emphasis program, it was an emphasis program around amputations for metal [00:46:00] fabrication facilities or metal fab businesses. And the employer that I was working for at the time had fabrication shops. So we had employees that were actually working under that classification. And I remember getting a letter saying that, you know, chances are because of the national emphasis program or because of the emphasis program for metal fabrication facilities, an inspection may occur. So you get notice right in the program inspections. If you have employees that fall under that classification for the work that's happening and you may get a letter in the mail saying that you might get inspected, it doesn't mean you're going to get inspected, but you very well might get inspected.
Steve Badger: [00:46:50] Absolutely. And, you know, if you do get that letter, that doesn't necessarily mean that you've done something wrong. I always like to point that out as well. Just because [00:47:00] you're in that particular class code or that particular industry, they're going to try to see as many of those industries as many of those businesses as possible within that period of time that that emphasis program is open. So, yeah, I always like to stress that, that it's not just because you've done something wrong, it's just because you're in that particular industry.
Peter Koch: [00:47:22] Yeah, right on. I think it's worthwhile just spending a minute or two here about if an inspection does happen, if she shows up on your job site for whatever the inspection priority is, could be imminent danger could be because you called them for a fatality, could be because it was a referral or you might be part of the program inspection, sort of what happened. So I guess if they show up, they're going to provide proof of who they are. They are they're required to produce their identification, their badge and state the purpose of what's going to happen and then really have an opening conference with you to tell [00:48:00] you what's going on, why they're there. And one of the things that will probably happen, I mean, it doesn't happen all the time, at least in my perspective. But you might actually have a request from the OSHA compliance officer for you to hand over, give them five years of your OSHA logs. Now, I think it's there's some pretty good data in those OSHA logs. But do you have any insight of why OSHA wants to look at those OSHA logs and maybe how those OSHA logs can be used as the employer as a as a good place to continue their safety efforts?
Steve Badger: [00:48:41] Yeah, absolutely, you know, and I'm glad you again mentioned about the partnership thing, because that is where, you know, that partnership, you know, begins when they come on the site after they've been identified themselves. And, you know, in that, you know, that relationship is very important to build on from the beginning, that, again, they're not they are their [00:49:00] purpose is not there to fine you or to berate you or, you know, make you feel bad about what happened. It's to find out what did happen. And so that's kind of where this the OSHA logs come into play as well as because they want to know, you know, they want to look at these five years, you know, sometimes they don't. But they want to see what types of injuries you've been having as a business and are there like repeated numbers of injuries of certain types, like, for instance, you know, if you have a large number of hand cuts, we'll say each year. You know, you you've had, you know, in this department or that department year after year, you're seeing that that's going to kind of indicate to them that you are not controlling that hazard as well as you should be.
Steve Badger: [00:49:47] And so they're going to look for those type of things and point those out and say, OK, let's focus on this a little bit. I see I see them also look at like hearing related issues where, you know, there's been hearing loss. And [00:50:00] if there's multiple people that have had a hearing loss within your industry or within your company, what are you doing about that? You know, that kind of opens the door. They'll ask some, you know, some questions about that. But again, it's all in that spirit of partnership that they want to help you try to identify what those issues are and how to help control them. They're not going to offer you and say, OK, you need to do X, Y, Z. That's not their purpose. Their purpose is to, you know, say, hey, you know what? This is an issue. You know, they don't authorize pieces of equipment. They don't you know, that's not their job. It's to try to help identify what those things are.
Peter Koch: [00:50:40] Nice. And it seems that they're really using that OSHA log in the same way we should be, not we being safety consultants, but we as the employers should be using that OSHA log to really look at it for trends. They're looking OSHA looking for insight into how's that business doing? They might not have experience [00:51:00] in that particular business or that well in that particular industry, but they're going there and they're looking for clues as to What is the what are the challenges, what are the problem. Not so much problems. What are the challenges that the company is having around workplace safety? And then and then pointing out maybe here are some places where you can step it up a little bit and do a better job for workplace safety. And again, there's a list. It's an OSHA list. It's a list you keep for OSHA, but it's certainly a list that OSHA requiring of the injuries and illnesses that you're going to have in the log. Another pretty good list for us to use to help get ahead of the curve from a workplace safety standpoint. There's a lot more on inspections, we can do a whole podcast around OSHA inspections and what the process is and what the rights are of employees and employers, I don't think this is the place to talk about those now. I thought [00:52:00] it was important to kind of get an idea of some of the paperwork that might go around those OSHA logs.
Peter Koch: [00:52:05] But let's talk a little bit about now that we Know about the OSHA top 10 list and where it comes from, that we see repeated citations year after year. We have many of the same standards are in the top 10 list year after year. And sometimes, like fall protection is going to be number one in years running. What can we do with that? Like, how do we get to a place where we can take the OSHA top 10 or even some of the other information that OSHA provides us in the lists and develop solutions around injury prevention and hazard mitigation?
Steve Badger: [00:52:44] Sure. That's great to be able to follow up with this, because, you know, really, you know, first and foremost for me is the employer's mindset that, you know, I mentioned when we started out that, you know, that philosophy, you know, [00:53:00]it's too costly or, you know, it can't be done that changing that mindset to it can be done. And how are we going to do it that that is key to changing that company culture, which goes hand in hand with that. And as IO mentioned, that's going to be a top down. That's going to start with the ownership, the management. And just saying, you know what, we've had enough of this. We are going to change our belief in how we approach safety. And taking a look at this list and other lists are going to be the way to do that, to change that culture, to stop thinking about it from a lagging perspective. As you mentioned earlier, those lagging indicators changing it from reactive to proactive. How can we do these things initially? How can we prevent these things from happening?
Peter Koch: [00:53:51] Have you had experience? I don't mean to interrupt. I'm just thinking about this from changing that mindset from a can't be done to a can be done. I expect you've had stories [00:54:00] with the employers that you work with where they've had a significant injury or maybe even an unfortunate fatality within their workplace. And they've had to deal with family and co-workers of the injured or the severely injured employee or the employee that's passed and their mindset changes. It goes from it can't be done to a can be done because they have a mission that's really not we see that happen often. But what we would rather have is them use these proactively, like you said, like don't wait for the problem to happen. Like, if all protections your gig, if that's what you do day in, day out within your industry, it could be construction, it could be roofing, it could even be maintenance. It could be as an arborist, it could be whatever it is. If you have a fall protection component to your business, know [00:55:00] that it's going to happen to you. So be proactive with. So have you seen that happen within the employers that you work with where you have a significant event that changes the mindset?
Steve Badger: [00:55:12] Yeah, yeah, I've seen it in more than one time, you know, with more than one of these in this top 10 where either a fatality or a serious injury has happened. And that really has changed the culture, which, you know, you hate to see it happen because of that. But you're glad to see that it's being taken seriously at that point where all of a sudden, you know, somebody says, you know what, we've got to stop thinking about this the way we did 30 years ago or 40 years ago. We have to come into the 21st century and say, OK, this can be done. How can we do it? You know, I've worked with companies that work again fall protection is one of the big ones where it used to be that to put up trusses, they'd be walking the plate, you know, meaning that they're on the top and they're doing this balancing act [00:56:00] and they're trying to hold these trusses up and nail them together. And, you know, having the mindset, is there a better way? Is there a better way to do this? Well, maybe it's putting together on the ground and lifting all up in one big piece. So you've eliminated that fall hazard. And that's how we always want to approach these things, is can we eliminate them first or can we reduce that hazard to the point where it's going to be negligible or something we can better wrap our hands around?
Peter Koch: [00:56:29] Yeah, that's great and again, proactively looking at it and using this list to go there and then moving further through the solutions piece, the employer is a critical part of this, like their mindset, like you said, and moving in that company culture from top to bottom. But then we get to the employees and they play a significant part in this, too. So how does the employee piece fit into injury prevention and hazard mitigation?
Steve Badger: [00:57:00] Certainly [00:57:00] we want to you know, obviously when the employer wants to start with, you know, the employee awareness, so what the hazards are in the workplace. You know, these are, you know, what the hazards are. And this is what we are going to do to prevent these from happening. It may be, you know, training. It may be, you know, proper fall protection, it may be scaffold, you know, construction, training, all of these different types of training. And then, you know, the important thing is there is that the employee sees that this culture is changing, that, you know, it's really a positive step. And that's going to give them that buy in that place where they understand that. You know what? It really is up to me. My boss isn't going to be there every minute of the day. But, you know, I had this conversation with somebody recently about having respect for themselves so that they're not, you know, injuring themselves or worse, but also respecting the company as well. You know, that even though I may not have somebody, [00:58:00] you know, standing over me, making me wear this harness, that I'm going to do it because it's the right thing to do.
Peter Koch: [00:58:06] Yeah. For them to get by. And I kind of think about that from an awareness standpoint. How do you use the top ten list? Well, maybe you end up using that in a safety meeting or a toolbox talk or it gets posted up in the break room. And maybe you can put up a history of showing the last three years of OSHA top ten and look at where the top ten standards are and then what am I doing or what is the employer doing about this and what are the employee's responsibilities around what we're doing? So, again, awareness, you can use the lists that OSHA puts together to help with some of that awareness to get some buy in and start some of the training, possibly with your employees. What part do supervisors play in this process, Steve?
Steve Badger: [00:58:57] Sure, absolutely. Supervisors are critical [00:59:00] to this because they're kind of that middle management level where, you know, they're the ones that may be in charge of this job site or they may be in charge of a crew. And doing inspections are absolutely critical. You know, doing a walk through and making sure people are doing the right thing, that they're using their equipment, they're using their ladder properly, they're using their scaffolding properly. That's been inspected and those sorts of things. And when not which does happen, you know, when they find something being very consistent and how they enforce that, I can't stress that one enough because, you know, just because someone's been there 15 years doesn't mean that they have any special rights or, you know, or are free pass because they've been there 15 years. It's got to be a consistent enforcement, you know, just not the new guy that comes in the door or the new gal that comes in the door. It's got to be everyone. It's got to be consistent because other than that, if it's not, people are not going to have that buy [01:00:00] in. And it is critical.
Peter Koch: [01:00:03] True, very true. You bring up a really good point that 15 or 30 year or, you know, 10 year employee who's been there for forever and now all of a sudden you have maybe a new supervisor who's come in, come in from a different company, doesn't have the same longevity with that company or, you know, you might have to two people that have worked together for the last 10 or 15 years. And one of them moves into a supervisory position. That consistency of enforcement or application of the standards for what you're seeing is really important. And it helps, I think, with that buy in. Right. So the employee buy in. If I see someone being treated a little bit differently than I am, if I'm getting told to wear my harness or put on my respirator or put on my seatbelt in the fork truck, but the other guy is not. Chances [01:01:00] are when the supervisor is not around, I'm not going to use it because chances are the employee is going to think that and supervisor doesn't really care that much. They're just picking on me. And so why should I why should I do it?
Steve Badger: [01:01:15] Exactly.
Peter Koch: [01:01:16] Awesome, and all this kind of fits in with continuous improvement. So talk a little bit about the importance of continually moving your safety program forward and maybe how the OSHA lists the top 10 list can be used for that.
Steve Badger: [01:01:37] Absolutely. Yes. And I think, again, is this is a critical part of safety programs, is that it's not something you write once you put it on the shelf and blow the dust off it once a year, you know, to bring it out, it's got to be something that you're visiting regularly, that as technology improves, as you know, training improves and, you know, different types [01:02:00] of things that are out there improve that you're updating that program to meet those new you know, that new equipment. You know, respirators is a big one that they always talk about where, you know, they specifically say in the standard that they want you to go back at least annually to update your program. You want to have a program administrator that takes a look in. Is there something better? You know, and there's several of the standards that are out there that actually have that component to it that they don't want. You just having this being a static document that, you know, you sit it on the shelf and, you know, it never changes. It's going to be something that's improved. And as this top 10, you know, tying it into that is that, you know, as you know, maybe there's better and, you know, more improved lock-out tag-out devices, you know, that are out there. There's you know, it used to be that you had a lock, you had a tag and you would throw that on anything. Well, nowadays, there's equipment that you can lock [01:03:00] and tag out almost anything that's out there. So things have changed over the years. And so should your program.
Peter Koch: [01:03:07] Nice. And again, using that list as a way to almost as a checklist and again it doesn't go through that list, doesn't highlight all of the standards, only the ones that are most frequently cited, which again correlates into the most frequent causes of injuries and fatalities. So it's a good list to start looking at and say, all right, in my continuous improvement process, how am I doing in all of these? And at least it gives you some sort of barometer and way to check. So maybe you have that when it comes out every year. Take a look at it, use it as a focus for a while in your safety toolbox talks. And then if you are the EHS guy or gal at the business that you're working for, maybe use that as the checklist, how we do it. Like if OSHA comes today, am I going to [01:04:00] be part of that number of the most frequently cited standards or are they going to come in and look at it? Go nope your fall protection program looks good or nope your respiratory protection looks good or HAZCOM looks good.
Peter Koch: [01:04:14] And then knowing that if you miss the piece, that's OK, Continuous improvement, make a change, add that to the process and move forward. That's really great advice. Excellent. We're kind of coming to the end of the podcast time here. And I do want to ask you this question, Steve, because you've had quite a bit of experience with OSHA over the years. You're an authorized trainer for OSHA. What do you know now about OSHA that you wish you had known when you started out back in the 80s doing workplace safety and work in an industry?
Steve Badger: [01:04:51] That's an interesting question, Peter. I tend to look at it the other way around. Really. There's things that I know now that I wish I didn't know then, you [01:05:00] know, you know, types of things, you know, think things like, you know, the dollar numbers that are thrown out there with the citations. I mean, to me, that that's a very unimportant number when we're talking about lists, it's not as important as, you know, what is that violation in and how do we fix it? You know, too often I see people focusing on those numbers that, oh, I got this fine for 5000 or I got this fine for 10000. Yeah, that's the least important part. It really is. And that's why I say I tend to wish that I didn't, you know, back then when I first started in safety in 1986, that wasn't a factor. That was you know, it was doing it for the right reason. And rather than worrying about those money issues, are the money issues important? Sure. But it's not something that should be the focus. You know, that's not that you know why we should be doing this.
Peter Koch: [01:05:56] Right. And I think, like with any good partner, there's some accountability [01:06:00] in there. And I think from an OSHA standpoint, they have little to do around accountability. So there needs to be you need to have some skin in the game. Right. As an employer. And part of that skin in the game is going to be dollars and cents. But like you said, and I think that's a really, really great point, is the dollars and cents are not the important part of this. The focus is what part of the standard what part of that compliance? Aren't you following? Because in that non-compliance, there's a gap someplace in your program where one of Those employees that you hire, which may not have the same understanding that the rest of your employee employees do, is going to fall or is going to use a piece of equipment incorrectly. And you're going to be in that position as the supervisor or the manager or the vice president or the owner of the company to make that call to the significant other to say, hey, you know, Judy fell today and [01:07:00] I'm not sure if she's going to make it home. That's never a place where you want to be. And that's not the time to decide to make a change. I mean, it is you certainly want to stand up, recognize that and make a change, however. Do it before that, use these lists to help recognize where some of the gaps are. I guess that's might be a good place to kind of a good way to think about it for sure. Right. So we're kind of getting again, like I said, we're getting to the end. One more question for you, Steve. If someone had more questions about OSHA and their top 10 lists, where can they go for more information?
Steve Badger: [01:07:40] Yeah, certainly the again, going back to the OSHA.gov website is really good because one of one of the things they do is they give you this top 10, but then they also break it down into the top five violations under each of those top 10 so that you can kind of see, OK, when like number one [01:08:00] here says fall protection, general requirements. But what does that really mean? You know, in the case, you know, when they're talking, you know, when they break that down, they're looking at the residential construction as being the number one within that particular area. Unprotected sides and edges is the second largest. And so it kind of breaks down for you what individually within those sections are the points of pain that we're looking at that, you know, you take a look at that list, that secondary list, and you say, OK, are we protecting our people from unprotected sides and edges? You know, we work on roofs that are low sloped. Are we protecting our people? This gives you an idea of one. You know what they're looking for. But two what are hurting people falls from those heights.
Peter Koch: [01:08:50] Yeah, that's great. So perfect, Steve. I think that's great. So recommending people go back to OSHA and there's lots more information. We've just kind of scratched the surface there [01:09:00] of what that top 10 list can break down for us. So thank you for that. This about wraps up this week's Safety Experts podcast. Thanks for sharing your expertise with us today, Steve.
Steve Badger: [01:09:12] Very welcome. Thank you. Thank you for having me, Peter.
Peter Koch: [01:09:14] Yeah, beautiful.
Peter Koch: [01:09:15] So thanks again for joining us. And thank you to all of our listeners out there. Today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, we've been speaking with Steve Badger, safety management consultant with MEMIC, about OSHA's top 10 list and how they can be used to improve your company's safety in the workplace. If you have any questions or I'd like to hear more about a particular topic on our podcast, email me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show Notes that MEMIC.com/podcast where you can find additional resources and our entire podcast archive. While you're there, sign up for our Safety Net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates. And if you haven't done so already, I'd really appreciate it if you took [01:10:00] a minute to review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whichever podcast service you found us on. And if you've already done that, thank you, because it really helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing this show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Kotch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.
From the publisher's feed