MEMIC Safety Experts

MEMIC Safety Experts

By Peter KochBusinessHealth & Fitness
Download on the App Store

MEMIC Safety Experts episodes

  • Top 5 Causes of Injury During July 4th Weekend

    According to the Pew Research Center, during July 4 and 5 more than 90,000 people visit hospital emergency rooms for treatment of injuries sustained during the holiday. This episode will cover safety issues that are not just workplace related, and explore the Top 5 injury causes that center around the 4th of July holiday, as well as share some tips on how to not become a statistic this summer.

    Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hey there, listeners, this is Peter Koch, host of the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast. This podcast is dedicated to discussing, describing and even debating safety across all industries and applications with industry leaders, top executives and safety experts right here at MEMIC. Just because it's legal doesn't mean it's safe. That's a statement from Glenda Lynch, from a flyer that she created around firework safety after her son died of injuries sustained when a firework mortar went off prematurely. Fireworks are one of the top five causes of injuries around the Fourth of July holiday. And this story is a particularly tragic one. So in today's episode, I'm going to take a slightly different tack and cover safety issues that are not just workplace related and explore injury causes that center around summer and the Independence Day holiday, as well as share some tips on how to not become a statistic [00:01:00] this summer. So let's jump right into it. According to the Pew Research Center, during July four and five, more than 90,000 people visit hospital emergency rooms for treatment of injuries sustained during that July 4th holiday. In his July 2019 article, Drew DeSilver writes that the average daily number of E.R. visits across June, July and August hovers around 40,000 or less than half the average of the Independence Day holiday visits, even the Memorial Day and Labor Day holidays that don't compare with the average totals for July four and five.

    Peter Koch: [00:01:37] The Elite Care E.R. center out of Texas published an article that highlighted the top five causes of injuries around the July 4th holiday. They are, according to them, outdoor grilling and cooking, swimming and boating, fireworks and last but most fatal car crashes. So let's go through those and start in reverse order. Tackling outdoor cooking and grilling first. The National [00:02:00] Fire Protection Agency, or NFPA, states that 64 percent of all American households own at least one outdoor barbecue grill or smoker. And between grease fires leaking propane, spilled charcoal and the misuse of flammable liquids. There are lots of ways someone could get hurt when they're grilling and chilling. Add to that, adult beverages and other distractions. And it's no wonder that outdoor cooking makes the top five injury causes list. Here are some stats from the NFPA. July is the peak month for grill fires and averages 18 percent for the entire year. July is followed by June with just 15 percent and May with 13 and then August with 12 in 2014 through 2018 fire departments went to an annual average of 8,900 home fires involving grills, hibachi or barbecues. And in that same time frame, an average of nearly 20,000 people [00:03:00] per year went to the emergency room because of injuries involving grills. Nearly half or 9,500 or 48 percent of those injuries were for thermal burns, including both burns from fire and from contact with hot objects. So let's look at a couple of tips that can keep you safe this summer when you're grilling outside.

    Peter Koch: [00:03:21] First, outside, any grill that generates heat from combustion, propane, charcoal, wood pellets, whatever should be used outside. Yes, outside, even when it's raining. Never, ever use your grill in the garage shed or the kitchen. Keep it well away from the house, out from under the eaves and away from other combustible materials like the deck railing or furniture. Second, the grill top and sides get hot, so keep the kiddos, pets and other unpredictable partygoers away from the grill. I remember two different gatherings where people at the party unintentionally mixed [00:04:00] it up with the hot sections of the grill. Both times involve the dog and both were Rube Goldberg-esk occurrences. So in the first instance, the Unleashed family dog bumped into the walker of the grandmother. The grandmother toppled over into the people that were helping her get to a seat on the deck. One of those stumbled into the six year old that was walking near the grill, who then fell into the grill where hot water from the pot of boiling corn was on the side burner, which eventually sloshed out onto his arm and his face. Not a great day. The second instance was a leash dog that took off after a ball, the trailing leash wrapped around the leg of the charcoal grill, dumping its contents onto the deck. The coals caught the grease from the food on fire, which ignited the wood of the deck. [00:04:48] And the injury occurred then when the person with the fire extinguisher ran through the sliding glass door coming out of the house onto the deck, you just really can't make it up.

    Peter Koch: The next [00:05:00] safety tip involves two steps, but first, I'll explain why these steps are important. I visited a friend a number of summers ago for what I had assumed to be a barbecue. When my family and I arrived, my friend was in the process of removing the dripping, charred and blackened husk of the gas grill from his deck. Seems he had lit the grill to preheat, then went into the house to get whatever it was he was going to serve and then promptly got distracted. When he returned, the grill had black smoke roiling out of it and flames shooting out from every opening. He pushed open the lid with the hopes of putting the fire out with long tongs, which then promptly intensified the fire. He finally put it out with copious amounts of water from the hose. I expect that you know what happened and maybe it's even happened to you. Seems that the heat from the closed grill during that extended pre-heat time ignited all of the leftover grease in the bottom of that grill and opening the lid, it just fanned the flames. It's a good thing the propane [00:06:00] didn't explode.

    Peter Koch: [00:06:02] The moral of the story, keep your grill clean by removing grease from the inside of the grill and from the trap trays below. Then never, ever leave your grill unattended when it's on. The last grilling safety tip is always, always keep the lid of the grill open when the lighting it. I don't have a personal story to share, but there are plenty of people out there who have experienced the woosh and subsequent loss of facial hair or worse, when the un-ignited gas trapped under the closed lid finally reaches a mixture that will support combustion. Keep these in mind when cranking up the grill this summer, and there's a good chance you won't contribute to the summer injury statistics. Speaking of stats, though, statistically boating and swimming, the next two on the list are very safe. But both activities can cause injury if you don't take precautions before and during enjoying the water. The most common causes [00:07:00] of accidents when boating or swimming are participating at a level above your ability. Intoxication, distraction and in particular with boating, speed. Though boat speed can have a negative effect on swimmers when they share the same waterway. The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources provide boaters some great safety reminders. So you want to check them out on their website or I'll go through some of them here. So first and foremost is to leave the alcoholic beverages on the shore and be a sober boater.

    Peter Koch: [00:07:31] Operating a boat is the same as operating a motor vehicle. Don't drink and drive applies on the water as well. This leads to a similar rule for boaters, distractions of any kind can lead to collisions or other boating accidents, phones and passengers can be an even bigger distraction on the water than they are in the car. Operators and pilots must keep their attention to the waterway, put the phone down and have a spotter when towing skiers, [00:08:00] tubers or other devices. The next tip is apropos as we open up around covid and they say to practice social distancing when boating, they mean it from a stop the spread perspective. But I think this message has larger implications. Think about it. Nothing good can happen if your boat tries to occupy the same physical location as another object or person. Consider the following. Give other boaters space, keep up good right away practices and don't try to squeeze in. It's hard to crash into someone or something if you keep your distance. The next tip is for when things go wrong on the water, and that is to wear a life jacket. A wearable life jacket can save your life, but remember only when you wear it. The U.S. Coast Guard makes the following recommendations around life jackets and they're pretty important. So all recreational vessels must have a U.S. Coast Guard approved life jacket for each person on board.

    Peter Koch: [00:08:56] That means not just one for the kiddos, but one for everyone on [00:09:00] board. No sharing. The second is federal law requires that when a vessel is underway, children under 13 years of age must wear their life jacket. There are exceptions for when they are below deck or within an enclosed cabin, but for the most part, when they're on the boat, they need to be in a life jacket. Though it's not always required by law, a life jacket should be worn at all times when the vessel is under way because, you know, if you go overboard or something happens in an emergency, you're probably not going to be next to the life jacket. So it's always best to have it on. And that brings us to the fourth tip. Wearable lifejackets must be readily accessible, and you must be able to put your life jacket on in a reasonable amount of time in an emergency. They should not be stowed in plastic bags or in locked or closed compartments or have other gear stowed on top of them. They really need to be accessible. Own your wake is the last tip on the list [00:10:00] of boating safety tips here, and it crosses over to the safety of others and swimmers, too. So when operating a vessel that generates a wake, be aware of the proximity of other boaters, swimmers and paddlers and some of the effect that your wake may have on them.

    Peter Koch: [00:10:15] Swimmers and paddlers have some responsibility here as well, though we all need to share the resource. So just because you can swim or paddle in a particular area or at a particular time, it doesn't mean that you should keep in mind that from the cockpit of a motorized vessel or sailboat, a swimmer or a paddler is a really small target and is easily missed. As for swimmers, while the old adage wait for an hour before swimming, after eating may not always be necessary, some precautions to prevent drowning are the Red Cross, through which I took my own swim lessons when I was a kid and then went on to become a certified lifeguard instructor in my teen years. They have some excellent advice to [00:11:00] prevent drowning. They call it the Circle of Drowning Prevention, which describe the different layers essential to prevent drowning and helps us plan ahead for any aquatic activities. So first in that circle is to learn swimming and water safety skills before you get in or around the water. This is all about being water competent and your competency depends on the environment that you're going to be in. You'll need different skills if you're floating in a shallow backyard pool versus recreating or swimming in the ocean or cold mountain lake. According to Water Safety USA, which is a coalition of Red Cross and other aquatic safety groups, necessary basic skills should cover the following.

    Peter Koch: [00:11:42] You should be able to step or jump in water over your head, then turn around or over and orient towards safety. Then you should be able to float or tread water and then at the very least swim 25 yards to safety using controlled breathing and then exit [00:12:00] the water. They also say that you should be able to perform these skills, whether you're in a swimsuit or you're fully clothed. That's harder than it sounds. So maybe you should practice. The second is to be water smart. This covers a whole slew of points, many of which are common sense, but all can be found missing in any drowning or near drowning news story. I'm not going to list them all, but honestly, as a former lifeguard, a few do bear repeating. So first, like with anything else, know your limitations. Most drowning scenarios occur when someone gets in and pardon the pun, over their head, they panic and then become too exhausted to continue keeping themselves above water. The second is to know your environment, understand the topography, temperature and the currents in the area that you're swimming. Even a backyard pool can have a shallow and a deep end that can be the nemesis for the non-swimmer. And then last in this list is never [00:13:00] swim alone. If you think you can rescue yourself, really think again while it's possible your preparedness and the environment will dictate your success.

    Peter Koch: [00:13:10] So when I was in my teens the same summer I was taking a lifeguard class, my parents took my brother and I to a water park. There was a really cool water slide that we were trying to get our dad to go on with us. We finally convinced them and it was it was superb. The slide followed a number of drops and loops and then finally emptied into this deep pool where you had to swim toward the shallow end and then finally walk out. So I go down the slide. I remember landing in the pool and then taking a few strokes ahead, turning around and watch for my brother and my dad. So they shot out of the slide one right after the other. Splash, splash. My brother popped up and swam to the side and then started heading towards the shallow end. My dad, however, stayed under a little longer than I think he should have and then finally struggled to the surface. So I went out to him and then after helping him to the shallow end, [00:14:00] I found out that he didn't know how deep the pool was and thought that he could just float his way to the shallow end and then stand up. When they hit the water, he got all disoriented. Then he panicked. And I learned then that he had never figured out how to swim. And all those years, the last part of water competency is to be ready to help others.

    Peter Koch: [00:14:20] This is essential whether recreating in the backyard pool or fishing off the dock or pier, you don't ever want to have that sick feeling in the pit of your stomach of not knowing what to do when your co-worker friend or your father is struggling in the water. So be prepared, go take a class, try to figure it out, have stuff with you and be prepared so that you know what to do if someone falls in and they need your help. If you want more great information about boating and swimming safety, check out the resources at USCGBoaters.org and the water safety resources at RedCross.org. So no list of Fourth of July injury causes [00:15:00] would be complete without fireworks. You may think that many of the injuries caused by fireworks are the result of mishandling or horseplay. Not all of them are. Some happened to recreational users who might not understand all of the implications of what they're using. And some even happened to professionals. Many years ago now, I remember well when I was planning for this podcast, I was remembering some of the experiences that I had with fireworks. And many years ago now, I recall attending a fireworks display. One summer, bunch of friends and I were on the beach and the fireworks were being launched from a raft out in the middle of the lake.

    Peter Koch: [00:15:38] During what I thought was going to be a normal pause in the display, I looked down from the sky to the water just in time to see the mortars being launched out toward the other side of the lake, streaking across the water. In the glow of that fire, you could see the technicians jumping into the water. Well, it turns out that one of the racks that [00:16:00] held the firework launch tubes had become unsecured and had tipped over in the process of trying to reload and launch. No one was hurt, thank goodness. But it wasn't until years later that I thought about the implications of what would happen if that wreck had flopped over the other way and launched toward the beach. We all missed serious injury that day and they were set off by professionals. Tragedy and fireworks can really go hand in hand, and especially in the hands of untrained and unexperienced people. The quote at the beginning of the podcast from Glenda Linge Just because it's legal doesn't mean it's safe rings true when it comes to fireworks. Her son Shane was with his dad at a backyard fireworks show when a mortar, which he had loaded into the launch tube, exploded in his face. The news reports explain that the impact shattered his forehead, cracked his skull in half, and the heat from the firework burned his brain. [00:17:00] Shane never regained consciousness, and they had to make the decision to take him off life support.

    Peter Koch: [00:17:08] Glenda became an advocate for firework safety and regulation after that fatal accident. They learn from the investigation that the premature ignition of the fireworks could have been caused from either static electricity or possibly even embers left in the tube from the previously launched mortar in the hands of inexperienced people or unqualified people, fireworks can be dangerous and they can be dangerous at many different levels. Injuries occur from small burns to life threatening injuries to fatal injuries. The Consumer Product Safety Commission reminds us that even if fireworks are illegal in the state that you're in, all fireworks come with risk. Their data shows that 62 percent of the 90 100 fireworks related injuries in 2018 occurred in the months [00:18:00] surrounding the Fourth of July. So that would be June 22nd through July 22nd, 62 percent, even children under five are part of that statistic and half of their firework related injuries are from sparklers. Fun fact. Did you know that sparklers, even the ones that you can buy at the convenience or big box store, burn around 2,000 degrees Fahrenheit. That's hot enough to melt some metals, so keep them away from the kiddos. The CPSC gives some great tips around fireworks safety. So check them out, make sure consumer fireworks are legal in your area before buying or using them. And as a consumer, never use or make professional grade fireworks.

    Peter Koch: [00:18:43] Now, as an aside here, fireworks packaged in brown paper are often made for professional displays and are not for consumer use. So that's a pretty big hint if you're looking for fireworks to use in your backyard. Next, never place any part of your body directly over a fireworks [00:19:00] device when lighting the fuse always move to a safe distance immediately after lighting the firework. Never point or throw fireworks at another person or towards an occupied area, always light fireworks, one at a time, and then move away from them quickly. Keep a bucket of water or a garden hose handy in case of fire or other problem. Always soak misfired fireworks with water thoroughly before throwing them away and never try to relight them. After fireworks complete their burning douse the spent device with plenty of water from a bucket or hose before discarding the device to prevent a trash fire. The bottom line is all fireworks carry risk. Know, and prepare to control the risk before using them. Or just go to watch the professionals shoot them off. They can be a beautiful display and a fun time with your friends and family.

    Peter Koch: Let's take a quick break and reflect this Fourth [00:20:00] of July and both the success and struggle that we have had as a nation since independence and political separation from Great Britain was declared in 1776 and how we've been shaped by them. This is a shout out to all of the workers that make it possible for Americans to enjoy the Fourth of July holiday. [00:20:19] They are the reason your favorite restaurant, bar, hotel, resort, state or national park campground or a convenience store are open on those days. The rest of us have off. I'm not going to list all of the occupations and industries here as there are far too many. And I know that I'll miss one. But let's not forget the police, fire, EMS warden and ranger teams that respond when our recreation day goes wrong. If you want to do something for the countless workers that have and continue to work to keep the doors open and the lights on in those establishments that we like to frequent as a customer. Start by saying thanks and as an employer, start by keeping them safe. They all [00:21:00] need to go home to their family and friends at the end of the day. If you need a place to find safety resources, then you can check out the MEMIC safety director at www.MEMIC.com/WorkplaceSafety. Now, let's get back to today's episode.

    Peter Koch: Last on the list are car accidents around the Fourth of July, and I would like to welcome Randy Klatt, director of region two loss control here at MEMIC as our expert on transportation exposures to help me dissect some disturbing statistics around driving fatalities. So thanks for being here, Randy. I wanted you to help me understand some of the fatality statistics that the National Safety Council has put out. [00:21:44] They have a website or a Web page called Holiday Traffic Fatality Estimate. And here you can go through any of the big holidays. So New Year's Day, Memorial Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas. And they have Independence Day or the Fourth of July. And that's what we're talking about here. And [00:22:00] they're talking about four hundred and eighty-two people may die over the Independence Day holiday, which goes this year from Friday through Monday. They're looking at like three point two five days, which is where they get the average over. But that seems to be a fairly substantial amount of fatalities that are happening just over the road. Now in the podcast, before I've been talking about other areas where injuries can happen and fatalities happen, but certainly none of the other activities grilling, using fireworks, swimming and boating are coming up with the same number of fatalities that the National Safety Council is estimating may happen over this Fourth of July weekend. So let's talk about those stats for a little bit and why they're important. And then let's get into some things that you can do to not become a statistic, because that's the whole point of this. We want people to stay alive during their holiday period. So let's talk a little bit about the stats.

    Randy Klatt: [00:23:00] We [00:23:00] certainly do want them to stay alive Peter, and we also want them to remain uninjured. So we could talk about the nearly 500 people that are estimated to be killed on that holiday weekend. But you could add to that, oh, probably one hundred thousand injuries from accidents as well. Now, that's just mind boggling when you think about it. And of course, the real problem is most people don't think about it. They're using their car every day. It's something that especially in America, we rely on. And most every car has one person in it and there are millions of them on the road. And that's just what we do. And we don't really consider that it's probably the most hazardous thing that you're going to do in any given day. And of course, with the topic of this discussion, you had holiday weekend, summertime weather you had a little alcohol and maybe some long hours. And it's not surprising that those [00:24:00] estimates will rise. Also noted that the statistics were increased. Their estimate was increased slightly this year due to the covid pandemic shut down, relaxing this year. So unlike last year when most people were stuck at home, this is the first Independence Day weekend where we'll be out and about in more normal conditions. So they're not really sure what's going to happen.

    Peter Koch: [00:24:26] Right. A lot of pent up expectations or desires that kind of get out and be in the world again, which is going to put a lot more traffic on the road and a lot more challenges. I think.

    Randy Klatt: [00:24:37] I think you're right. And again, we take driving for granted. And I say everybody does it every day. Of course, that's not quite true. Some people don't. And there is a large percentage of the population that hasn't driven very much in the last year due to everything that's happened. And now they're going to be out there. Maybe they are taking the road trip to [00:25:00] someone's house or an extended weekend holiday somewhere. And they haven't been on the roads very much. And. Well, do you think we can get rusty at driving? Yeah, I think we can. It's operating a mechanical device, you know, a moving vehicle. So there may be an element of that, too. It's just, jeez, we haven't been out in traffic very much and we don't remember the way like we would if we'd driven it every day of the week. And, you know, there's going to be some of that sort of thing going on.

    Peter Koch: [00:25:32] That's a really good point. I experienced that myself as we got back out into the field as loss control consultants. And some of my policyholders are quite far away. And I hadn't seen him in a while or been to their place of business in a while. And I'm making the trip for the first time and like, wow, this has been spent 18 months since I've been on this road. And now you forget kind of where you're going and where all your turns are and where you're going to be. And you end up maybe not [00:26:00] focusing so much on the road, but the map or the path that you're supposed to take. So you might miss some of the cues. You might miss a turn, panic a little bit more and possibly even make a wrong turn or try to get out of that wrong turn, get back into traffic when someone else is trying to pull up behind you. So you might not be rusty. The mechanics of driving like you still know where the gas pedal is and the brake pedal and the steering column and everything, but you might not know the path and that, as we've discovered before, when you add one more thing to think about in that complex process of driving puts us at substantial risk for making mistakes and actually being distracted not from a phone or from a conversation or for something else, but just by not knowing where the heck you're going.

    Randy Klatt: [00:26:46] Yeah, I had a similar experience just yesterday, I went to a policyholder I hadn't been to and a year and a half and at a particular intersection when I went by, I realized, holy cow, there's a building that wasn't there last year, you know, [00:27:00] huge brand new. And you find yourself kind of watching or gazing. Wow, that's interesting. Well, guess what? The vehicle's still moving at 35 miles an hour, and that's when things happen. You know, in my driver training and we've always talked about reaction time and, you know, how long it takes for a driver to react to what happens to perceive an issue and then actually do something about it. And how many feet per second you're traveling. And anyway, that's still applies. Physics doesn't go away. And so the distracted brain, that's a thing. It's a real thing. And it may be worse this year when you realize that, wow, there are a lot of buildings out there that weren't there last year or other things, highway construction and things like that, that we really have to be careful.

    Peter Koch: [00:27:49] Certainly and some of that is going to, you know, take away from your schedule. Right. So not, you know, not realizing that, you know, we're out for the first time again, traveling someplace at [00:28:00] a distance and not knowing where all those construction stops are so used to take me two hours to get from point A to point B, and now it's going to take me two and a half hours to get from point A to point B, and people feel the pressure of not being someplace on time or meeting that deadline. So even that could be a challenge. And again, distracting.

    Randy Klatt: [00:28:19] Right. And just imagine if over this three-day weekend, if we were to crash three major airline airplanes in this country. Imagine the outrage, the publicity, the media coverage, the government intervention that would happen. I mean, it would just be just a tremendous reaction to something horrible like that. Well, equivalent lives lost. That's exactly what's going to happen over this weekend and sadly enough, the National Safety Council's predictions over the years are freakily,[00:29:00] really accurate. So talking about five hundred people that are here now that might not be here after the weekend, and that's sad. So, yeah, let's do everything we can to prevent that to you, to your family, to your friends, to coworkers, to your staff if you have a chance to talk to them before the weekend. It's just it's a reminder. I know everybody knows how to drive and they'll get the eye rolls and whatever, but it's a real thing that too many people take for granted.

    Peter Koch: [00:29:31] So let's talk about some of those things that might cause that accident, that result in a fatality. So what are some of the more common things? We talked a lot about distraction. So that's on the table. We've chatted about that. But what are some of the things that would contribute to the accident that would cause a fatality?

    Randy Klatt: [00:29:49] Well, again, those statistics are pretty consistent over the years as well. Number one is excessive speed. And we just talked about not knowing the area or being late or, you know, things [00:30:00] like that that might delay your trip. And the tendency would be to increase your speed to make up some time. And that's when you're really pushing the envelope a little bit. So always be cognizant of your speed. And along with that, a different issue. But related is following distance because we're always just too darn close to the car in front of us. Doesn't matter if you're on an interstate highway or you're on a two lane country road somewhere, you have to allow space in front of you so that you as a human being can make those decisions, react and do something when something unusual happens in front of you, be that the car in front of you slams on their brakes or an animal runs out in front of you or a child or whatever the case may be, not giving it enough time and space puts you at the mercy of physics and then you're stuck. So you've sealed the deal unknowingly until you find yourself when it's too late, [00:31:00] you're too close. So if you can allow more space in front of you, drive the appropriate speed for the conditions and the laws. And of course, we always say use your safety belt, that's almost a no brainer in the in the country now we're up to about 90 percent seatbelt use across the country, give or take a few percentage points and different states. Every state but one has a law for front seat passengers and drivers to wear their seatbelt, so do so. I can say as a paramedic back many years ago, I never took a body out of a seatbelt.

    Randy Klatt: [00:31:39] I took a lot of bodies out of cars. Now we know that people do die while wearing their seatbelts. The statistics are pretty clear that they aren't magic, but they do certainly help and they limit injuries to those that are just injured in accidents as well. And I always ask the question on driver training [00:32:00] about the seatbelt, and I say, will it help prevent injuries? Will it help prevent an accident? And of course, ninety nine percent of people say no. And that won't prevent an accident that will help you if you are in one. It helped prevent the injury or decrease the odds of a serious injury. And I ask what would happen if you're driving your car and suddenly you have to swerve, you have to swerve left because a car pulls out or that animal or whatever. If It's a small animal hit the animal only if it's small, but if it's a person, you might want to swerve. And if you do that, what's going to happen to you in the driver's seat if you're not wearing your belt? Well, you're probably not going to be able to control that car beyond that first swerve, you can be thrown down in the console or you lose the grip on the wheel, that kind of thing, because you're not buckled in. And we all make that first maneuver sometimes too late. But we all see the skid [00:33:00] marks of the tire tracks that go off the road. Well, they made the first move. They just worried it could make the second one to keep them keep the car under control after they missed the object or whatever it is. So, yeah, the belt is important in that regard, too.

    Peter Koch: [00:33:16] You think about professional drivers, professional racers that are dealing with a lot of G's in their movement from side to side, whether it be rally car drivers or Indy car drivers? And they're driving in a harness for two reasons. One, that's going to keep them within that crash cage if the car goes off the road, but it keeps them in the bucket so that they can then steer and not use the steering wheel to hang on kind of lose a little directional control when you're just hanging onto the steering wheel instead of actually using it to steer the car.

    Randy Klatt: [00:33:46] Right. Right. And similarly to when you do a little bit of that gazing of the what's going by you on the roadway or that new building that's up, you have a hold of the wheel and you turn your head to the left to look at it. What's the tendency to happen? A [00:34:00] car goes to the left. Yeah, it's going to move the way you're looking because that's what you've done with the wheel. So there is a lot to driving that we just don't think that much about. And two cars in the same place at the same time just shouldn't happen. It's going to be a human failure that makes that occur, which means it is avoidable. So that's what I want everyone to do, not only over this weekend, but every day take this driving task seriously and arrive alive. That's the goal.

    Peter Koch: [00:34:33] That's good. I think there's one more. One more, cause that's kind of the elephant in the room that we need to we need to talk about. So, you know, we talked about speed driving or driving distance between you and the car in front of you, and then seatbelts as a good injury prevention strategy are all good injury prevention strategies. But I think impaired driving is something that we need to talk about and not from a distracted impairment, but other [00:35:00] impairments. How much in your experience and whether it's statistics or your experience prior to coming to MEMIC, how much does alcohol or other substances that will alter your mental state, how much do they contribute to driving accidents and fatalities?

    Randy Klatt: [00:35:20] Well, sadly, significant contribution from personal experience. I was a paramedic for about six years, so I worked a lot of traffic accidents, a lot of fatalities. Now, this was back in the day when seatbelt use was about twenty five percent. So fatality numbers were higher and survivability was far less in vehicles. But I can tell you that I can count on one hand, in fact a portion of one hand, the number of accidents, fatal accidents that I remember working that did not involve alcohol.

    Peter Koch: Wow.

    Randy Klatt: It was [00:36:00] just as prevalent as can be. I worked every Friday night. I had shifts that were to two days a week. Twenty-four hour shifts each. But Friday night was one of them. And I wouldn't say you could set your clock by it, but we knew it was coming, especially as the weather got warmer. It was motorcycles and cars and it was people out having fun on long, sunny, beautiful, warm days. I saw very little actually as a result of weather. In fact, the one fatal accident I do remember that wasn't alcohol related did have a weather contribution to it in the way of icy roads, but. It's just people out having fun, too much fun. I remember riding in the back of the ambulance with one of the fatalities because we actually at that time occasionally transported a body to the morgue.

    Randy Klatt: [00:36:52] And I had to be in the back, you had to have someone in the back if there was someone else in there. I remember just looking at the poor young man under the sheet [00:37:00] and thinking to myself, boy, I hope you had a good time tonight because you're done. And that's just so sad and so unnecessary. The statistics say that back then when I was a medic, about 50 percent of all accidents were involving alcohol. We've gotten better at that. It's gone down to about twenty eight percent. So that's a positive move. If you remember Mothers Against Drunk Driving, the MADD organization, they're still around and you don't hear about them quite so much, but they made a huge difference. There is much more awareness of it. And I think designated drivers and especially the advent of on demand transportation like Uber and Lyft and all that, people are taking advantage of that and they're being smarter about it. Yet still, nearly a third of fatal accidents will have an alcohol component involved. So it's still a significant problem that we need to address. And it's going to be worse over the holiday [00:38:00] weekend because, again, look at the statistics from the NSC and Independence Day holiday statistic has more involvement of alcohol than any other weekends.

    Peter Koch: [00:38:13] Yeah. If you go through that statistic, it does show that for Independence Day, the difference between the annual average and the Independence Day average or the Independence Day estimates are almost 10 percent. So you're going to have 10 percent more. So if we're at 28 percent for this Independence Day on annual average for an alcohol related auto fatality, Independence Day, you're going to have close to 40 percent are going to be involved with some sort of or have some sort of alcohol involvement.

    Randy Klatt: [00:38:41] Yeah, and that's sad because that goes back to that. That's the same as it was in the 80s when I was a medic. The light bulb hasn't quite come on bright enough yet

    Peter Koch: [00:38:52] Or it's on and we just sort of dim it down when the holidays come around, I guess.

    Randy Klatt: [00:38:56] Well, yeah, it doesn't apply to me because I can handle this, right? Yeah, [00:39:00] well, not so much. We're all human beings. We're all subject to making mistakes. And if you add something like alcohol or drugs, it just makes that worse. And I would also say, don't forget your prescription medications, allergy pills and, you know, muscle relaxants for that back pain and all those other things that are pretty typical that people often have to take. They usually say don't operate heavy equipment, which I would include a vehicle, so just be really careful. Go have fun. Have a great holiday weekend. And you can consume some adult beverages and have a good time yet. Do it safely. And if you plan ahead, plan your trip appropriately. Understand the risk you're facing with driving any time. But how if you are tired on a long weekend after having a good time and the weather's been hot and maybe you had a few drinks, it's [00:40:00] probably not a good combination to then get on the road.

    Peter Koch: [00:40:03] Yeah, all good points. All really great points. You know, check your speed, make sure you have great following distance between you in the car in front of you, wear your seatbelts and then at the end of the day, make sure you understand what your limits are. And don't get in that car if you've had too much to drink, if you've taken something that could change your mental status. So it's going to modify how successful you would be in that car. So thanks, Randy. I appreciate you coming on and going through some of those stats with us and giving us some good feedback and some suggestions for a safe and healthy holiday weekend. Appreciate you being on the podcast again.

    Randy Klatt: [00:40:39] Any time, Peter. Thank you for having me. Be careful out there.

    Peter Koch: [00:40:42] So that about wraps up this week's Safety Experts Podcast. Thanks to all of you who listened today. And if you're looking for additional resources around holiday safety, check out the MEMIC safety director at MEMIC.com. If you have any questions for me or I'd like to hear more about our particular topic on our podcast, e-mail [00:41:00] me at podcast@ MEMIC.com. Also, check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/podcast, where you can find links to resources for a deeper dive into this topic. While you're there, you can check out our entire podcast archive and as well sign up for our Safety Net blog. So you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates. And if you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it if you took a minute to subscribe and review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whichever podcast service that you find us on. If you've already done that, thank you. Because it really helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing this show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Koch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.

    43 min
  • Preventing Heat Stress in the Workplace with Tom Bernard

    Heat stress is no joke. Exposure to excessive heat and working in hot environments can cause Heat Exhaustion, Heat Cramps, and even Heat Stroke. The stress that heat puts on the body can be deadly if not identified and addressed.

    On this episode, Thomas Bernard, PhD, CIH, CSP, and PE talks about heat stress, its effect on the body and how to prevent it. Tom is a professor at the University of South Florida, College of Public Health and director of the Sunshine ERC a NIOSH Education and Research Center. He has done extensive work studying the components of heat stress and has helped develop heat stress management programs for a variety of occupations.

    Pete Koch: [00:00:03] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch. Heat stress is no joke. Exposure to excessive heat and working in hot environments can cause heat exhaustion, heat cramps and even heat stroke. The stress that he puts on the body can be deadly if not identified and addressed. And even in its early stages, heat stress can deteriorate mental and physical performance to the point where minor hazards can become major exposures. Personal factors can also complicate the prevention of heat related emergencies. So a better understanding of how heat affects the body and how to gauge how hot is too hot are key. So on the podcast today with me is Thomas Bernard, Ph.D. in C.I.H. and Tom is a professor at the University of South Florida College of Public Health and the director of the Sunshine ERC, a NIOSH Education and research center. Some of Tom's other [00:01:00] certifications and qualifications are a Fulbright scholar from the Lambroso University in the United Kingdom. He's certified in public health. He's a certified safety professional, a certified industrial hygienist, a certified professional ergonomist, and a registered professional engineer. Tom's interests in heat stress include how clothing affects heat retention and dispersion, physiological monitoring, personal cooling methods and exposure assessment. He has done extensive work studying the components of heat stress and has developed heat stress management programs for a variety of occupations. Tom, welcome to the podcast.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:01:37] Peter it's great to be here and I'm looking forward to talking to you about heat stress and maybe just a tad bit of cold stress as well.

    Pete Koch: [00:01:45] That's fantastic. And, you know, as we were talking before the podcast, the heat stress piece really was supposed to be the main focus. But I threw a couple of questions in there at the end about cold. My background is really in the ski industry. But as we talked about before, there are some [00:02:00] heat related challenges, even in colder occupations. And cold has its own set of unique challenges that I hope we get to touch on just a little bit. So maybe at the end. So as we start to flow through here, why don't you tell me a little bit about how you got interested in heat stress and came to understand that it needed more further study?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:02:19] It can be, and in some regards, a long story. So it goes back to the fact that the early 70s, I was working at a department at the University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health, and this lab was famous for their heat stress work. And while I was studying metabolic demands of coal miners, I was in this department and actually participated in a couple of experiments that were going on at that time. So I think my introduction to heat stress was back when I was a graduate student. It continued at my time at Westinghouse, [00:03:00] where I was primarily interested in heat stress in nuclear power plants. And in fact, we developed some guidelines for the power industry that started with the nuclear field, but was eventually distributed out to all the electric power industry. I ended my move to the University of South Florida. That became a major interest in terms of a research agenda and that's been going on for more than 30 years. And I still remain fascinated by it.

    Pete Koch: [00:03:38] It really is a fascinating piece, just the effect. I mean, we're warm blooded creatures, so you wouldn't imagine that living in heat or working in heat would have such an effect on us. But it really does. And I think everyone listening can relate to being too hot at one point in time in their lives or maybe multiple times. So I think it's a good [00:04:00] time to talk a little bit about what the effects of heat stress are on the body. What does it do to us and what are some of the things that we might feel when we start getting too hot?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:04:10] And you know, you're right. So the first thing I want to point out is that, yes, this has been the experience of almost all of us. My caution to the health and safety people are because it's such a common experience that we often don't appreciate all of the risks. If you allow me a very bad analogy, it's like driving. We all drive. We all thoroughly under appreciate the risks that we undertake every time we drive. So in terms of response, we're warm blooded. That is true. But the other is we're fundamentally tropical animals so that we evolved in a way that we're accustomed to dealing with heat and we have natural physiological [00:05:00] responses. So the first of those is as we need to dissipate heat from the body. And by the way, heat stress is a problem of taking that internally generated heat and dissipating it out to the outside environment. So when we work, we generate heat that has to be dissipated out. The very first thing that happens is we increase our blood flow to the skin. So it's a cardiovascular demand and a cardiovascular response. Once it reaches the skin, then the most important way we have of dissipating that heat is then by sweat evaporation. So the second response is that evaporation of sweat or sweating and the evaporation of sweat and the other responses that's very kind of been there is that we do have an increase in our body core temperature as [00:06:00] well as an increase in our skin temperature. So the basic responses, our cardiovascular body temperatures and the sweating.

    Pete Koch: [00:06:11] So when those and those are all normal responses to us getting too warm and that that in itself is heat stress or getting warm, I guess. And then we go beyond our and our body starts to not be able to dissipate heat enough. And we get into some really negative effects then of heat stress, correct?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:06:32] Yes, that's correct. And I may drift into this and later in our podcast. So I want to make a differentiation. So stress will be those things that are external to the body that are causing the physiological responses. And then heat strain represents those physiological responses. So like stress strain relationships and in other areas of science. So the stress [00:07:00] comes from the work demands and the environment. The strain is our response back to this and that strain becomes excessive. Then it's manifested in the heat related disorders and these can be seen in the excessive demands on the cardiovascular system and will usually then classify those illnesses as heat exhaustion. So a cardiovascular insufficiency and heat exhaustion can go hand in hand. The other is that if the temperatures get high enough that we actually affect the central nervous system. So we affect the brain and the way the brain helps control our responses to heat stress. And then those will be heat stroke so that when we have a CNS dysfunction, central nervous system [00:08:00] dysfunction, then we have heat stroke. Heat exhaustion is serious heat stroke as a medical emergency.

    Pete Koch: [00:08:10] That's a really good differentiation there. And we're going to get in towards the end of the podcast about the responses to those, because those are a really it's a really key thing to understand, and especially when you get to that central nervous system shut down almost in the later stages of heat stroke or of that heat strain that you have to recognize it right away. And a lot of people don't. One of the things that I love to do is to actually coach. I coached high school girls soccer. We start our preseason early on, later in the summer, so early August, end of July. And we have some really hot days. And if you don't pay attention to how the girls are functioning during that practice, they can easily go into [00:09:00] a heat emergency. And you need to be prepared to manage that if you don't see the cues early on. And we'll talk more about that later on. But it's near and dear to my heart when we start talking about the responses to that. And so let's talk a little bit more about how, as you get into our bodies, inability to manage the stresses that are there, how does that affect the person from and we're talking about workplace safety. So how does that affect the person's ability to perform in the workplace?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:09:36] Ok, and I appreciate your example of soccer, so let me deviate for a moment and the fact that you started in early August and I presume that you step up your practices, you don't go for it right away. And we do this in order to allow our athletes and in your example and workers [00:10:00] and mine to adapt physiologically to heat exposure. So what we have is a process of acclimatization, and it does a couple of things. One is that there's an earlier onset to sweating, and that's important because then we get cooling going earlier. The other is that we have water and salt management physiologically. And so acclimatization helps manage and retain electrolytes and so that the sweat becomes more and more diluted so that it becomes almost water. And that's important. OK, so another physiological adaptation as we get exposed. What we find is that at the very early step ups is that we are actually making the transition for something that's thermally [00:11:00] comfortable up to where we reach what would be ordinarily an occupational exposure limit. We're already beginning to see an increase in unsafe behaviors. And in fact, there's some classic studies that go back and show that from a neutral environment where unsafe behaviors are minimum, not zero, to where we get to the widely accepted occupational exposure limits, we already see more than a 50 percent increase in unsafe behaviors. And following from the unsafe behaviors are accidents. And with accidents, we have injuries and resulting losses to the environment or our equipment. So this becomes important and it continues to go up as the heat gets higher. Then with that, we get starting to get a decrease in work performance [00:12:00] because we're taking some of that cardiovascular capacity that we would ordinarily use to support work. And now we're shunting that blood off to the skin in order to be able to cool ourselves. So it's clear that productivity will decrease with increasing levels of heat stress. And that has all to do with how the body's allocating blood.

    Pete Koch: [00:12:27] Since how the body allocates blood and how it responds to the environment in their own. Your own internal temperature is going to be different with every person. I imagine that heat stress will affect people differently. So it's not going to be it's not going to be a consistent response across the board like you would have with another exposure that might not be environmental, like fall protection or exposure to like a spinning machinery or something to that effect.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:12:56] Yes, so heat stress has a lot to [00:13:00] interindividual variability, so there's some people who, first of all, there's a small group of people or just heat intolerant, but let's set them aside for a while. Even in the range of heat tolerant, you're going to see a huge variation. Some people can deal with heat stress in incredible ways, and other people are going to be somewhat less tolerant, not importantly less tolerant. And we set our guidelines to protect those people with less tolerance. So not the intolerant, but people with less tolerance. And then that means those people with a with a high level of tolerance. Wonder why it is that we are saying that you're in a heat stress situation. And, you know, it's not only the difference between people, but even [00:14:00] within the same person, the day to day variations can be quite substantial. So you may be less tolerant one day and more tolerant the next. And we really don't know why that is, but probably has to do with recovery and just how our days vary a little bit.

    Pete Koch: [00:14:20] I can definitely see that with the athletes that I work with and because I can work with them every single day. And as a safety professional, I don't always get to work with the same group of people every day. Sometimes I do, but it's typically in a workshop or a training standpoint, and you're not going to have the same kind of physical demands that you would as an athlete on the field or a worker in a hot environment or highly physical environment that they might have that same challenge. So I can definitely see that in the athletes, you're going to have a group of people that are really, they're very tolerant to heat. They can manage it all the way through. And we do step our [00:15:00] practice sessions up. We start very slow and then we work our way up as we go through the summer. We step it up within the practice as well. So there's definitely a warm up period, a cool down period. And we don't just jump right into a lot of heavy physical activity so that we can work the athletes into that process or into getting warm and then getting their body used to be able to dissipate that heat as they go. What I've found with the athletes from the difference from day to day is there is a sort of an unknown component like you'd say, I just like I don't know why yesterday you were very tolerant to the same temperatures and today it's actually a couple of degrees cooler. The humidity is a little bit less and you are not responding in the same manner. Those are the outliers. I think consistently, though, what I've seen, especially with the younger athletes, [00:16:00] is their food management and their hydration management is relatively poor in that, you know, they might be drinking in practice. But what we typically tell them is that it's what you drank yesterday. It's going to help you hydrate for the practice today. And I think that's a key part. So in your studies, how does water management help someone deal with heat stress?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:16:29] Yeah, water management is incredible stuff. But and I want to caution your listeners at the same time. It's not the answer to all your problems. So this is one thing I like to point out. So on a job where there's a lot of profuse sweating, we recommend that you plan to have one quart of water per hour per person, and then that tends to be on the high end of [00:17:00] what the what will actually be drunk, but assures that you'll have sufficient water or other drinks available. But it's important to know that you probably cannot replace more than about six quarts of water and a working shift be at eight or 10, 12 hours. You're almost always going to have a deficit of water by the end of the day. And then what we really rely on is that you get that hydration completed during the off hour. So let's just assume it's a day shift, you know, in the evening and in toward the night that the water gets replaced. So you show up to work the next day. We always assume well rested, fully recovered and hydrate. That's what we pray for when they show up for work the next morning,

    Pete Koch: [00:18:00] And [00:18:00] that always happens. I mean, that's consistent, right? Everyone shows up well hydrated, well rested and prepared for the day. But that is an interesting part. I think education and again, getting into this, we'll get into it later as we talk about response and training. But education about, you know, if you're working in a hot environment, if you want to be prepared for that environment for the next day, what you do in the off hours really does affect you will affect your performance and response during the on hours as well. And it won't just help you at work. It will help you in the softball game after work or in the fishing expedition that you have over the weekend and any of that. So water management, education around that I think is good and great caution out there. It's not it's not the panacea. It will not be the solution for all the problems. And again, something that we'll talk about a little bit later on

    Thomas Bernard: [00:18:54] One thought I left hanging there. You have to be well hydrated [00:19:00] in order to be as tolerant as you're going to be of heat. So hydration doesn't give you any sort of superpower. It allows you to be yourself when you're dehydrated, you detuned yourself. And so we have to be careful that that water is permissive. But it's not an intervention that will make things better. We only want them to be hydrated.

    Pete Koch: [00:19:29] Excellent point. I like that water. Water is not a superpower. Perfect people. Yeah. And you hear it all the time. Drink water, drink water, drink water. Like it's going to make you better. It's only going to allow you to be yourself that sorry to repeat your words, but I think that's important for our listeners to take with them. And that's a really important point. Let's talk a little bit about now how you might measure heat stress and, you know, we all we all have that feeling of it's hot. Well, like, [00:20:00] how do we know what hot is? How do you measure hot? So in in my preparation for this podcast, the term Wet Bulb Globe Temperature came up in a lot of the research that I saw. And I have some understanding of that just from my years making snow because we used the wet bulb temperature to determine humidity and whether or not we could make snow actually above 32 degrees, which you can believe it or not. So how does Wet Bulb Globe Temperature? How does that get used in measuring heat stress? And how does it differ maybe from ambient temperature?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:20:37] Ok, so let me try that in a couple of different ways. So first of all, remember, I mentioned that the primary way that we lose heat is by sweat evaporation. And so that means that we have to have that. Pardon me for a technical term for a moment, but we have to have a gradient that drives that's sweat [00:21:00] evaporation. So I've got saturated water vapor on my skin and that drives to the environment. Getting away from the technical point then for a moment is that the drier the air, the more rapid that sweat evaporation is going to be in, the greater cooling I get. And then, of course, is the air becomes more humid. That ability to move water off the skin and into the air gets lower and lower. And by the time I reach one hundred percent relative humidity, I can no longer get sweat evaporation. And that really limit starts in and around 70 percent or so you start to see a diminishing return. So that is humidity is really the critical issue and not the air temperature. So when we talk [00:22:00] about the how hot it is in terms of the air and even to the extent that we talk about radiant heat, those are relatively small thermal loads on the body when we in comparison to the metabolic demands.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:22:16] So remember, I mentioned earlier, heat stress is a problem, getting internally generated heat out to the environment and the heat would be alone on the body from higher temperatures and radiant heat is probably no more than 10 percent of the metabolic rate. So it's not a big piece of it. And said the other way, sweat evaporation is that at least 90 percent of the heat loss there. So when we talk about assessing the environment, it turns out that we really want to wait that humidity. So the wet bulb temperature, the dew point are good [00:23:00] way. So when you listen to the weather station and they report, you know, they'll report dew point. Don't think about relative humidity, think about dew point. And once you start getting dew points that are up over 60, say, sixty-five degrees Fahrenheit, you're starting to report that it's humid. And by the time you're up to 70, you're clearly in a very humid environment. And so when people say it's hot, they may report dry, they may be reporting dry bulb temperature, but they're probably really reporting this kind of synthesized humidity and temperature.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:23:39] And if they're saying that it's hotter occupationally, it probably already is. All right. So that guidelines not too bad. And in fact, that might be that even though you're standing there, it feels a little bit comfortable. But when you begin to work and have to dissipate that extra heat, it's actually [00:24:00] going to be important. So WBGT getting back to actually your question is that that's wet bulb globe temperature. So wet bulb we now we've established is, is what is going to be sensitive to the level of humidity and the and the globe temperature is really a combination of the air temperature and radiant heat in the environment. So if you will, the wet bulb temperature represents our ability to dissipate heat to the environment and the globe. Temperature takes care of the convective and radiant heat load that we may have. And the WBGT is highly weighted to the wet bulb temperature so at 70 percent of the wet bulb temperature and 30 percent of the globe, and I like the WBGT [00:25:00] because it really represents in a very simple index, the ability of the body to dissipate heat to the environment and back our physiological responses will map to WBGT pretty well.

    Pete Koch: [00:25:16] So then as we as we start to look at the workplace, how do you measure that in the workplace? Typically you see thermometers in the workplace or you might get someone with a weather report in the workplace. I know that we had when we were working at the ski area to look at the wet bulb temperature, to determine humidity in the air and making snow on the other end. So the cold part of that, we had thermometers and different devices that would do that. But it wasn't something that you just ran out to the hardware store and grabbed. So what do you use to measure that?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:25:47] Yeah, well, in a minute, I'll tell you, how to go to the hardware store to get this stuff. But more likely, you need to have a high [00:26:00] quality instrument that will measure WBGT and there is a lot of cheaper things that pretend to measure this. So, so cheap is not going to be an answer. I'll provide you that answer in a moment. From a credible vendor a WBGT instrument is the usual way that a health and safety person will measure that in the environment. Globe temperature. Though, historically, is that somebody in the nineteen thirties, I think it was, went to the hardware store, got a toilet bowl float that happened to be a six inch copper globe copper sphere, put a thermometer into the middle of it and that became globe temperature. So, yes, you can go you're not going to go [00:27:00] to a hardware store anymore because they're plastic in the ellipsoid. But you can order online a fairly cheap six inch copper globe and make your own globe temperature. And in the same way, wet bulb temperature is you get a regular thermometer, you put a wick that can be something like a white shoelace that is then immersed in water and then allowed to freely evaporate to the air. So you can build, if you will, your own homemade WBGT device. That will be very good. And the thermometers have to be a good quality, but there are some not good thermometers that are readily available.

    Pete Koch: [00:27:51] I think you've just given me a new science project for our homeschooling group, so I think we might be doing that in a couple of weeks. See how that goes. I'll get back to you [00:28:00] if I need a list of supplies. So considering that, you know, so the best way then for an employer to measure heat stress in the workplace is WBGT. And I think you've described why, because it does represent the workers ability to maintain their thermal equilibrium. What other factors contribute to heat stress in the workplace and how do they affect it?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:28:28] So we talked about the environment and WBGT is a good measure of the environment and especially because we are concerned about the humidity. Obviously it once I say it out loud yet again, is the metabolic rate, the work demands.is the second job risk factor, because what's going to happen is whatever limiting WBGT there is, you're going to have to make it cooler and drier, [00:29:00] if you will, with the higher metabolic rate. So it's not going to be one value WBGT, but rather a relationship between the environment and the internal heat generation so that you can maintain thermal equilibrium. So the environment has to be more conducive to the sweat evaporation the harder you work and then. We have to worry about what they're wearing. So the third job risk factor is the clothing. Not most of all, occupational exposure limits are going to assume work clothes, so that would be something like a six ounce woven material, long sleeve shirt and eight ounce woven material pants. It could be coveralls as well as woven material that. But that's [00:30:00] the base unit. If you're in shorts. Or a T-shirt, you can afford to be a little bit higher than if you're in a double layer, coveralls are in the worst case, barrier clothing. Then we have to really change that threshold WBGT to match.

    Pete Koch: [00:30:24] It sounds as we start to look at the workplace itself and we have the humidity and the temperature and the WBGT in the environments, and then we have the work rate in the environments, it's compounded really not just by what they wear to work, but what they're required to wear for work, possibly personal protective equipment and things of that nature. So that's even going to be a contributor. And if you can't remove one of those, then it really comes back down to trying to mitigate the environment [00:31:00] or mitigate exposure. So maybe the amount of work time or time in the environment.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:31:07] Yes, that's correct. So and let me just go off on a tangent for a moment. It's almost always going to be the clothing that's going to be the big factor, a full face, negative pressure respirator, which is about the worst that you can imagine, really doesn't affect heat stress. You'll be very uncomfortable. But it won't affect your level of heat stress. The same can be said about gloves and shoes. That's where the major part of the body surface is covered. That's the question of what the PPE effect will be. And I totally lost track in your question.

    Pete Koch: [00:31:51] That's OK. I think just thinking more about the PPE itself, and I think that's a good point. And it's not going to be one particular piece [00:32:00] of PPE, but it's going to be the combined effect. And how much of the body is covered by clothing and PPE? Because, again, if you're if you're in a full-face respirator, but you are in a position where you can have more of your skin lightly covered instead of, you know, I was actually thinking about working in the woods and as a logger here in Maine in the summer, you might be in the woods. You're going to have chaps or you're going to have Cutter's pants on. And that's covering a fairly sizable chunk of skin with a fairly heavy fabric that's way more than. And that 12-ounce cotton woven pant that you're going to have. So it's going to have a different effect than, say, someone with minimal or clothing that's not that heavy wearing a full face respirator. So I think that's a good point. It's not just one piece of PPE or PPE itself, but a combination of all that are going to come together to drive [00:33:00] the heat stress higher.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:33:03] Yes, that's right. And then getting to the issue of mitigation, if we work just in the context of the job risk factors that we've been talking about, you have to pair up your actions so that you're on average, say, over the course of an hour, you get it within what would be the occupational exposure limit. So if you're wearing PPE, that's really interfering with sweat, evaporation, taking some time where you can dock that in order to be able to cool down will be important with the metabolic rate. If you're going to have periods of high metabolic rate, you're going to have to balance those with periods of lower metabolic rate or if you were in a very hot environment, periods where that environment will be a little bit cooler. But it's that combination of those three [00:34:00] things that are going to dictate how it is. You can mitigate that level of heat stress.

    Pete Koch: [00:34:09] I think that's a good way to think about it. And I think many times as I work with employers, they're really looking for one solution. And when it comes to heat stress, it's not just a single thing that you that you're going to be able to do. It's an advantage that you get to look at the combination of things and make some modifications. But it's not like, drink water or go to the shady spot that's going to be the solution. So there are different things that the employer is going to have to look at. Kind of brings up a point. I want to just kind of maybe jump back a little bit and talk about what factors contribute heat stress. And as I was thinking about outdoor activities, I was thinking about the flager on the side of the road, standing there all day in direct sunlight. How much does direct sunlight change [00:35:00] the impact of temperature?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:35:03] So the direct sunlight, you know, you'd rather be obviously in the shade than the sun, but the sun is going to make you feel warmer. So there's going to be a sensation because it's heating the skin. But the thermal load, if you will, is still going to be small compared to even the metabolic rate of just standing there. All right. And so it's important. And in the effect might be actually a little bit of a side effect is that you're warming the skin, which means you're going to bring a little bit more blood with the opportunity, especially standing, with the opportunity for that blood to pool down to the legs. And then you're going to feel faint and then you might succumb to a heat syncope, which [00:36:00] is a painting of that. All right. So, you know, just building on your example of the flagger they're going to want to walk a little bit or pump that blood back up to the heart, but the sun is going to make them uncomfortable. It's not adding substantially to the level of heat stress.

    Pete Koch: [00:36:24] Gotcha. And again, it's a combination of different things. Right. So thinking about that flager again and that static posture of being there, gravity always wins. So pulling blood down to the extremities, not providing enough oxygenated blood back to the brain, we actually talk about that from a fall protection standpoint. So, you know what happens if you're hanging in a harness for too long? How long are you going to be able to stay conscious in that particular position without being able to move? And it's one of the strategies for response after you've fallen to be able to move to be able to get muscle pump, to help your heart [00:37:00] move blood back up into the organs that need it to keep you, keep you awake, keep you alive. So, again, the combination of different things to look at, so movement to get the blood flowing and in this case, not only for oxygen, but to help dissipate your warmth back to all parts of the skin and not just the parts where the blood's hanging out down in the legs, so interesting. As we think about prevention, some more continuing down that track. Is there reliable data to support effective regulations around heat stress in the workplace and still trying to balance quality and productivity at the same time? Because I know that's always the thing. Like we have to have productivity, productivity, productivity and quality and quality. But if the person's not able to do it, you're not going to be able to manage either of those. So is there good data to support that?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:37:53] So the answer is yes, and then maybe some of your listeners aren't going to want to really [00:38:00] know the answer to the issue of productivity. OK, so let's talk about two parts of what regulations and I'd even broaden it to say what's good professional practice, OK, whether there's a standard or not. So one is that we're going to have to do exposure assessment. And is there good data to support that need that? The answer is yes. And the primary data asks the question, where can most people maintain thermal equilibrium? So how can they tolerate that environment for long periods of time? And you'll see these. Generally expressed as a WBGT limit at a given metabolic rate, and then the side of that is, of course, the increasing metabolic rates could lead [00:39:00] to a reduction. And what that limiting WBGT will be and then adjusting that for any kind of clothing that's being worn. So that's the exposure assessment. The point being is that it's well-established. We understand and know it. And it also follows the public health model that we're protective of most people. And we've already talked that there's a huge range. So we have to be careful that we don't fall into the trap of face validity where somebody will say, well, wait a minute, everybody, almost everybody can tolerate something higher.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:39:41] All right. But we don't know who those people are and we don't know how much higher than the other part is. What's the least you want to be doing to manage those exposures? And so I have my I have my list [00:40:00] of what you minimally have to do. And that falls into training, which is just, you know, accepted gospel truth in any occupational health and safety issue. I call them hygiene practices, but there are things that individuals can do to reduce their individual risk. Hydration is one example of hygiene practice. Arguably, acclimatization in terms of adjusting expectations is another hygiene practice. And then the third is surveillance. And that's really knowing what your environment is that a give them time because it does change during the course of the day. And it's also medical surveillance. It's the employer keeping track of even first day. So the data, so they can better appreciate what's happening in their workforce. [00:41:00] And then in the final thing is having an emergency response plan and if you will, I'm going to go I'm going to go back to your example of the harness and having fallen and now somebody is just sitting there.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:41:15] All right. I heard a safety professional probably 20 years ago say, talking about a fall protection program. And they said if your emergency response is calling 9-1-1, you're in trouble. And that is also the case in heat stress. If you think your emergency response plan is that somebody is going to dial nine one and you have nothing else to do, you're in trouble. Right. So it's those four components. It's having the training. It's practicing heat stress hygiene, it's doing surveillance, and it's having an [00:42:00] emergency response plan. And that emergency response plan, in my mind, also includes just first aid. Then I think in this way, what we've done is put in the backstop just in case we've made a mistake with our surveillance or we have someone who is heat intolerant because our usual standards don't protect everyone it protects ninety nine percent of the exposures or one percent of the exposures is once during a summer per person. All right. So that's not exactly overwhelming odds of protection. And so we do need to have that backup. We do need to say, OK, when that person slips through our protection, that we've got them covered.

    Pete Koch: [00:43:00] Let's [00:43:00] take a quick break. How hot is too hot, anyway, as we are hearing during this podcast, often it's not as simple as looking at the thermometer, humidity, airflow, the physical nature of the work and how the person is equipped all play a part. Not identifying and mitigating heat exposure in the workplace can cause serious or even fatal illnesses and injuries because workers will react differently to different conditions when hot environments are identified in the workplace. Employers must be equipped to respond appropriately for resources to help you identify and respond to heat stress exposures. Check out the heat stress resources from NIOSH through the Center for Disease Controls Web site CDC.gov and search heat stress. If you're a policyholder with MEMIC, you can sign into the MEMIC safety director and search for heat stress to find more resources there. Now let's get back to today's episode.

    Pete Koch: [00:44:00] So I like that as [00:44:00] we talk about those basic work practices, those are the essential things that we need to do to make sure that we can respond properly to heat stress in the workplace. So let's go back and take training just as one of those pieces, because I think training around heat stress is quite varied if it's done at all in in different environments. So let's talk a little bit about what might be important for an employer to do for training for their employees around heat stress.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:44:32] So training is going to be much like an employer would do for every other health and safety. So I always have to be careful to keep that perspective that they've got more than one problem to deal with. But once we work within that format is that you want the employee to be able to understand their hazards and then make rational decisions [00:45:00] about how to deal with those hazards to protect themselves and protect others. So you want to educate them to what are the factors that cause heat stress? So that's the environment, especially the humidity, the work demands. And if there are special clothing that they have to wear so they understand how these contribute, then having a little bit of basic understanding about what are the physiological responses so that there is a cardiovascular demand and there is a demand on water. We give up water from our body in order to cool ourselves, hence the need for hydration. So they've got that rationale for the hydration. Importantly then what they need to know or what are the signs and the symptoms of heat related disorders so that they can immediately recognize them. And we rely on people [00:46:00] to recognize them in themselves. But very importantly, we rely on people recognizing the signs in somebody else. And these then go toward the early recognition of the disorder. Then we can have the proper first aid or the proper response. So they need education on what these are. So that leads to what's the first aid, an emergency response plan.

    Pete Koch: [00:46:28] I think that's great and really kind of outlines well, it takes that training component and it incorporates all of those other components into it. So as an employer, really seeing it as not just a standalone piece, but if you're going to have if you're going to have a heat exposure within the workplace, then the training should include all of those components all the way up into. What do you do as an employee if you recognize this in one of your co-workers, which is a key part. And we actually [00:47:00] talk about that quite a bit on the cold side, like we talk about hypothermia, exposure, because a lot of folks, you're not going to know that you are in the early stages of hypothermia if you've got the fumble, stumbles and mumbles. So it really relies on your partner, your co-worker to understand what those symptoms are and start to address those we're going to touch. I'm going to ask you another question about cold stress here in a minute. But at the time of this podcast, there's actually a bill within the Maine legislature that's proposing setting a standard for maximum and minimum temperatures for indoor places of employment. And I just wondered, with all your experience around heat stress and how it affects the person and the variability of that, what are your thoughts about setting those limits and making them legislation for state?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:47:51] Again, I'm not opposed to legislation. I think, in fact, legislation and the actual rulemaking. The rules are [00:48:00] really very important. And I am a proponent of these. There's just a couple of things. First of all, I did a quick read of the brief legislation that's in front of the Maine legislature, I presume by maximums they're really thinking in terms of heat stress. And when they talk about minimums, they're really talking about cold. And these are really two different things. So let's talk first about heat, I think heat stress has to recognize that there are the three job risk factors that we've been talking about and therefore, any exposure assessment needs to be framed in the way that we've been talking about. And you're not going to do that by saying, here's the temperature. If you do that, you're going to be setting a temperature so low, that everybody's [00:49:00] going to fall under it. And I don't think there will be very many people that are happy about that circumstance. For cold stress, if I can just go there for a moment and you started to allude to it. So I do want to come back. First of all, about cold stress, humidity no longer plays a role, so it air temperature and a bit air speed, but it's more nuanced than that. So you talked about hypothermia and hypothermia. We worry a lot about what is the temperature and then what is the clothing. And really to manage that cold stress exposure, we have to have enough insulation on to protect ourselves from hypothermia for any given temperature and work demand because remember, you're generating heat. And then what you want to do is preserve enough of that heat that you don't lose body [00:50:00] temperature, but then you need to allow the rest of it to dissipate.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:50:05] And so adjusting clothing, insulation and being in the skiing industry, you know how to do that. And I'm not a skier, but I imagine going up the chairlift, you're going to be all bundled up because your metabolic demands are low and then you're going to loosen up your clothing before you start heading down, because now your metabolic rate is high. So you have to adjust the effective insulation of that clothing. So this is key for managing hypothermia. Then the other thing we worry about is actually a localized effect. So it's getting frostbite or frost nip. And that then is what is the air temperature and what is the air speed, because that will dictate the rate of cooling of a patch of skin. So in cold stress, we have both hypothermia managed by clothing and we have local [00:51:00] effects that are managed by. Basically, if you will, managing the wind chill, and that works, the other thing that's worth noting from the safety point of view is, remember, we talk that the risk and the probability of an accident that could be an acute injury or loss of property or however it might manifest itself, goes up with heat and it does. But it goes up on the cold stress side and it goes up 10 times more. So cold stress in terms of having a risk associated with accidents is much more of a worry. It's I think it's a worry on the heat stress side, but it's an incredible concern on the cold stress.

    Pete Koch: [00:51:51] If I can ask a follow up question around that, why does it go up so much more? Why do the probability of accidents go up so much more [00:52:00] in cold than it does in heat?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:52:02] And I don't have a clue.

    Pete Koch: Fair enough.

    Thomas Bernard: But I got to tell you, it's an absurd phenomenon, right? It is there clearly enough that it's a problem. And I reported on it in an aluminum smelter, which is really a very hot place that if you're located in a northern location with a lot of air ventilation and smelters require a lot of air. When it gets to be zero outside or subzero, it gets incredibly cold in there at that time. And so we saw the accidents increase. But we're not the only investigators that found it. There were many others, too, who observed the same thing.

    Pete Koch: [00:52:52] I've totally found that in my experience with the ski industry as well, that I don't know that I could have, from my experience, say that it went up 10 times. But [00:53:00] I do know that even with a little cold stress. Your reaction time lessens physical reaction time, mental capacity at a much lower rate than I think for heat stress. I think your body can get warmer and still have a relatively functional processing capacity whereas you start to get cold and you start to shiver or you start to stop shivering, which is worse, you're not able to function anywhere near as well as you could just a few minutes ago before that that metabolic change happened for you.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:53:40] So if I can abuse something that I told you earlier, we're tropical animals. So we have learned to adapt, not learn to adapt. We have. Physiologically, the capacity to deal with heat being tropical animals, [00:54:00] we've relied totally on behavioral modification to manage cold.

    Pete Koch: [00:54:07] Yeah, that makes a lot of sense, tons of sense. So I guess kind of coming back to that legislative question then to have a hard and fast maximum and a hard and fast minimum from a temperature and just looking at temperature and they haven't even defined temperature in that particular bill that's there. I think there's probably a lot more work to do to make legislation functional for the protection of employees that still allows quality and productivity to live symbiotically in that.

    Thomas Bernard: [00:54:39] Thank you for bringing us back to the productivity. So let me get to that in a moment. Yes. You know, there's an incredible amount of work that staff and the Department of Labor are going to have to do to try to actually make this workable. That that was a fine action by the legislature, [00:55:00] if that's what they take. And other than, you know, in my mind, I read that by I say, well, they've given a command to the agency, develop something. The agency is going to quickly discover that this is a more complex process than that legislation would suggest. And that's fine. You know, we rely on the rulemaking process to discover those things all the time. The second part of this is that if you manage the heat stress and I'm also an expert on the cold side, but the cold stress, your quality of work is probably going to stay pretty close to the site. But what's going to happen is that you are going to have a decrease in productivity. And this is just simply inevitable because you're taking physiological [00:56:00] capacity and redirecting it from work to dissipating heat. You simply can't avoid it. So from a compliance point of view, I don't like thinking about compliance point of views, but it frames it well enough to maintain that level of compliance by necessity or your productivity is going to drop. How well you manage that heat will tell you how much your productivity is going to drop. And if you think you can beat that by saying, OK, we will just pay people a piece rate, their productivity is still going to drop. It might not drop as much, but I posit that I study again to show even increased rate productivity drops. But if you're not managing that exposure, what's happening is that the workers are taking on more risk and they're not doing it consciously. So that's not a willful taking on a risk. That's an unconscious [00:57:00] take on of risk that will lead to a higher probability of a heat related disorder and especially a heat stroke.

    Pete Koch: [00:57:12] I think that's a really good point. That's because it's a fine line, internal perception of where you are metabolically in your temperature. It's not easy. So as you're working, you're going to feel hot. But that moment that you go from feeling hot to not being able to manage the load anymore is a pretty fine line. And then going from that to heat stroke is an even finer line, and it's different for every person. So it really does make sense to try to manage that and knowing that productivity is going to have to suffer because it's a math thing. When you kind of get to it, what goes in has to come out. Otherwise the person is going to get hurt. That takes us into and I think it's a good lead into what [00:58:00] might be the appropriate medical response for heat stress. And if we start to look at it from. All right, so we've done what we can within the workplace, but this individual is not reacting well to the mitigation that we've had. And they're starting to experience heat exhaustion or heat stroke. And we're going to call 9-1-1. We know that's an important part of the response, but it's not the only part of the response. What's the appropriate response to heat stress once an employee has reached the point where they need intervention?

    Thomas Bernard: [00:58:33] So if you'll allow me to get away from the model that heat stress and the fact that now they're experiencing heat related disorder, which is the excessive strain, is that and pardon me, but that's just my obsession. So it's staged. You know, if it's a mild heat exhaustion it's going to be a symptoms driven identification [00:59:00] and the risk. And if you will, that's the early recognition. We like that. If somebody is reporting that they feel fatigued and they're thirsty and we like that, dizzy maybe a little bit of a headache, then they can stop work, go into as cool places they can find and drink. And chances are within 15 minutes they're fine and they're fully recovered and ready to go back to work. We like that. That's early recognition, early treatment. And if they go into a more advanced so a severe heat exhaustion, their body core temperature, we're not going to measure the body core temperature, by the way. And I'm not advising that, but it's going to be somewhere and still in the vicinity of what we would expect. But the cardiovascular demands are going to be huge. All right. So they're going to, again, [01:00:00] report headaches and tired. You know, their blood circulation is where we would want it to be. But now we're also starting to rely on signs, OK, they're going to be wobbly. They're just not going to be walking that straight line. We're going to notice that drop and physical capacity. Then we have to if they're not coming off the job to try to cool down, recover, we need to pull them off.

    Thomas Bernard: [01:00:29] Right. So this may be where we're starting to make bad judgments. And in the buddy system needs to see that and again, it's sitting in a cool place, it's drinking fluids and keeping a close eye in severe heat exhaustion. My friends in the sports area will take a towel soaked in ice water, put it over [01:01:00] their head and shoulders. And they use this not because it cools them better, but it helps give them an idea about the severity of the severe heat exhaustion. Right. So if they begin to feel better relatively quickly, then they know they're dealing with heat exhaustion. On the other hand, if they're not there, they're keeping an eye on the symptoms for heat stroke. And this is important now for heat stroke, nobody is going to report symptoms so much like you use the example of the hypothermia. The same is true for heat stroke. You're now not thinking this is now a central nervous system failing your brain is letting you down. And now this really requires your buddy to notice this. And in the cases that I've worked on, it's often gibberish that they're just [01:02:00] talking nonsense. They're going off and doing things. They don't know where they are. They just threw down your tools and left the job. OK, so behaviors that you just don't expect and you've got to open up your head to what are behaviors that are normal. And if anybody says I quit, the last thing you let them do is leave.

    Thomas Bernard: [01:02:23] All right. Because this is going, you know the "Bernard Pointer" is this looks like a heat stroke. Then the absolute best way to deal with that is put them in a cold water or ice water immersion bath. So you want to emerge and you'll see the old emergency medicine textbooks say, no, no, don't do that. Now, clearly, all of the evidence is ice water immersion is the best way to cool them down. Now, if you're out doing the timber harvesting that you discussed, [01:03:00] you know, hopefully you've got that one quart of water per person per hour. You know, who's sitting there and you probably have some left over. Hopefully it's cold. Well, you wrap somebody in a tarp and dump all of those in alright. You do whatever you can to cool them down. Right. And then you call 9-1-1. Notice that we're not calling nine one waiting that 15, 20 minutes, one hour for them to show up. And by the way, you want to alert them that you're dealing with a possible heat stroke so they can prepare to deal with that so that they can get them to the emergency room. So that's part of the plan. And when I'm working with but like right away maintenance, where they could be almost anywhere then knowing where you are and going over that [01:04:00] emergency plan, making sure you have cell phone service and everything else that you need, becomes part of that tool box safety meeting prior to any job that you begin.

    Pete Koch: [01:04:12] Those are great points, and it's interesting how a lot of those points are relative to really any job that has a significant risk of serious injury, whether it be fall protection or you're working around heavy machinery. Working alone is not the best thing, because, again, if you're risk assessment about the job that you're doing indicates that you're going to be in a high heat environment, you have the potential to not understand your own symptoms. So having someone there that can help is a pretty key part. And I do think that people do miss that part of their hazard assessment, like they talk about the environment, but they think about weather like high winds or something unexpected. But you can have a day that's, you know, in the high 90s and very [01:05:00] humid and very close and still. And you could have a significant heat load on the person and there could be a lot of heat stress. And then the person can experience a lot of heat strain from that. Great recap on the medical response there.

    Thomas Bernard: [01:05:14] And I just want to go back and reiterate about the buddy system, because when you do, you know, there's reports in the literature of these cases of heat strokes and a number of times that somebody wanders off and dies alone. You know, even though I'll tell people you never leave anybody alone.

    Pete Koch: [01:05:38] It's a great point. And that's an interesting point, too, because a lot of folks were like, oh, he just needs his space. He needs his time. Well, understand the environment that they're in and what they're responding to, because it might not just be they need a break from whatever they're doing, like you said. What's abnormal about their behavior? Is this something that they typically do or is this something very different than they've [01:06:00] presented in the past? And if it is, I think you said it was the "Bernard Pointer" don't let them leave. Right. I like that.

    Pete Koch: [01:06:07] So we're kind of getting towards the end of the podcast here. I do have a couple last questions. And one of them I well, it's a big question, so I'm not sure if it's fair, but I'm going to ask it to you anyway. So what do you know now about heat stress that he had wished you had known when you first started out when like when you were in the working with the mines and in the smelters and all that before you came to your position as being a professor? What did you what do you know now that you wish you had known then?

    Thomas Bernard: [01:06:36] Just about everything I know now. I wish I had known then I so I don't have a good answer. I've been asked this before and in some variation or another. And one response that I have is that every time I work on a case, for instance, I learn something new and I put that in my bucket [01:07:00] of knowledge. So I've got an accumulation of thirty or more years of this. Then, you know, I also think about this question all the time because I am a researcher that's beyond teaching. I investigate and we always are asking ourselves questions to this very day. We're rethinking what it is we know about acclimatization and the associated risks. What is it that we know about time weighted averaging and recently I've been more staging and thinking about severity. So we always think in terms of that hour after hour for an eight-hour day. But, you know, one of the things that we found is, for instance, of three degrees C I'm sorry, I think in degrees C increased, which is not huge changes the response of an individual from [01:08:00] being able to just thermal regulate to putting them into a situation where they're where they're at high risk for heat stroke doesn't it's not a big change from an upper limit to what can be a very serious outcome and how we can begin to do the risk assessment. So I'd like to say that you know every year I learn something new and I'm hoping, you know, next year, if you ask me that question, I've got more things to add to that list.

    Pete Koch: [01:08:32] I think that's awesome with all the knowledge that you have. And then just being open to that. There's something else out there that we just don't know that can shed a little bit more light on what you already know to give you insights. Some places. I think that's an awesome response Tom. So thanks for that. Is there anything that I should have asked you? But I didn't ask, is there something else that you want to reflect on for us?

    Thomas Bernard: [01:08:55] So the answer is we talked about the four [01:09:00] essential things. I want to go back and first put a context. If you suspect you have heat stress, those are the four things you need to do. That's the training the hygiene practices. Surveillance and having a first aid emergency response plan, when you get up to where you're reaching an occupational exposure limit, you also need to follow that typical hierarchy of controls. We're not likely to be able to do elimination and substitution, but there are engineering controls that are effective and administrative controls and there are personal cooling systems that work well. I want to go back, though, to the first four. And it's the hygiene practices, hydration we've really talked about. And it is about anywhere you go, people are going to talk about it. It is drinking cool flavored drinks doesn't [01:10:00] have to be electrolytes, but we know that they drink more electrolyte drinks than anything else. So I think that it just happened that there have been at least palatable water, its direction or self-determination, so that if you are feeling well, there ought to be a freedom to go recover. And most employers that I work with, you know, acknowledge that they do that. But it's getting the people to take advantage of that that tip, and especially if they're on piece rate, that the conflicting goal they ought to know about, if they've got chronic health issues, their personal care physician should clearly know that they work in a heat environment because there's not a disease or treatment that probably won't interfere with thermal regulation.

    Thomas Bernard: [01:10:50] The for acute illness, you know, the public health person to me to stay home because you're going if you go to work, you're going [01:11:00] to infect somebody else. But if you do remember that any nausea, you're not going to drink and you're not going to eat well, vomiting and diarrhea are going to dehydrate you. Fever is going to reset your thermal regulatory system. There's just a whole bunch of things that say you shouldn't do that and that a good diet, well balanced diet, no fad diets, getting plenty of rest don't do drugs are, you know, good advice. And I probably forgot something in there. But that gets I think, you know, an the acclimatization, adjusting your expectations, you're not going to run with everybody else. Until you get used to working in the heat. And even then, there's somebody who's going to be less tolerant than everybody else. So there's going to be somebody who can't keep up with everybody else.

    Pete Koch: [01:11:53] Those are all great tips. And some of them don't get pushed hard enough within the workplace. And I think that having [01:12:00] employees understand and then have a culture that gets them to feel that it is OK to not be first, especially when you're in that acclimatization process and that there's always going to be someone who is going to be better. It's not that you shouldn't try to be better, but know that heat is going to be in effect here. And it's going to effect everybody differently. And it's not something that you may be able to overcome in the same manner that someone else is. And then you really hit the nail on the head there, whether it's piece work or something else. But that permission to just say, hey, I've recognized in myself, that I've hit the limit and I need to go and cool down before I can come back and be a functional part of this job team again. And that's a really key part. And I do think that's missed often in our training or our discussions with our employees. You see it often when you walk into different places. And there's just something odd about the culture. They're like people are working super hard. But you're also looking at looking at people thinking [01:13:00] you probably need to step away from that machine for a little bit and take a break, reset and come back to it because you're bound to get injured. Good, good. Really good points there, Tom. Thank you for those. I think I could talk to you for another few hours, but. Well, I think we're going to have to end it here pretty soon

    Pete Koch: [01:13:18] If our listeners are interested. And I know they're going to be, about finding more out about heat stress and your work around heat stress, where can they go?

    Thomas Bernard: [01:13:27] That's great. I'm always willing to kind of help where I can. I'm not going to send you to my website because I've got to get it back right again. The systems people moved on a server behind on that. But there's some materials that I can make available.

    Pete Koch: [01:13:47] There are other organizations like NIOSH that have done research on heat stress and how to prevent it within the workplace, too. So but there's other places to go as well. So [01:14:00] besides NIOSH, are there any other organizational places or websites that folks can go that you would recommend?

    Thomas Bernard: [01:14:07] Yeah, a great resource is NIOSH. They've revisited their criteria document three and two types, so they issued one, revised it once and revised it again, that's almost unheard of. So it really reflects, I think, the current thinking. Their most recent revision is 2016. So anybody serious about heat stress management, she should avail themselves of the NIOSH criteria document dated 2016. If you just do an Internet search, you're likely to find it. OSHA and NIOSH have materials on heat stress on their websites and I think they're generally pretty good. My only hesitation [01:15:00] and it's a modest hesitation is that they will in some areas talk about stages of heat reflected in the heat index. And I think their ideas generally right. I'm not sure that I totally agree with their thresholds. I think a couple of them are too high in a couple of them were too low. But the idea, you know, the content for training programs and heat alerts and all of the things that they discuss are really very sound approaches, because I've been on the physical agents committee and the ACGIH. But I'll remind you that the ACGIH has a TLV for heat stress and strain and associated documentation so members can easily get a copy of this and nonmembers it is available for purchase. And I'll [01:16:00] give a heads up. We're in the process of doing a major revision not of the thresholds, but the associated documentation. So in a year I think it's going to be even better.

    Pete Koch: [01:16:12] What we'll do is we'll take those, we'll take those documents and we'll put those links on to the podcast website. So you go to MEMIC.com/podcasts. They'll be able to see the transcript from this and then they'll also be able to grab those resources. I think that's great. You spent a ton of time with us and I really, truly appreciate this conversation. Tom, it's been fantastic to have you on and share your expertise with us. Really.

    Thomas Bernard: [01:16:39] It was fun to do it. So I appreciate the opportunity.

    Pete Koch: [01:16:45] And Tom, thanks again for joining us. And thank you to all of our listeners out there. Today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, we have been speaking about heat stress with Thomas Bernhard, Ph.D. Tom is a professor at the University of South Florida College of Public Health [01:17:00] and the director of the Sunshine ERC a NIOSH Education and Research Center. If you have any questions or would like to hear more about a particular topic on our podcast, email me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/podcast where you can find additional resources as well as our entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for the Safety Net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates. And if you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it if you took a few minutes to review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whichever podcast service that you found us on. And if you've already done that and you subscribe, thank you. Because it really helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing this show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Kotch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast [01:18:00] is good, but using what you learned here is even better.

    1 hr 19 min
  • All Hands on Deck with Al Brown

    In 2018, BLS data shows hand, wrist, and finger injuries comprise more than 43% of all upper extremity injuries that caused days away from work. On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, Al Brown, MEMIC's Director of Ergonomics takes a look hand injuries causes and some strategies for prevention including MEMIC's E-Ergoโ„ข๏ธ๏ธ tool, use of gloves, and tool and workplace design.

    Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch. Besides our voices, our hands allow us to express creativity and emotion through gestures and complex movements. The hand and wrist, believe it or not, have more than 27 different bones and 30 muscles, in addition to tendons and ligaments that allow for a staggering number of movements in positions. We use our hands every day to point, grasp, move, support, throw, catch, you name it. Our hands are usually involved with what we're doing, even gesturing right now. As I'm talking, I'm using my hands. You can't see them, but I am using my hands. Without them or even without one of them will struggle to live up to our potential. Think about it for a minute. Consider your day. So far, whenever you're listening to this podcast, what have you done that didn't require one or both of your hands? How did you put on your glasses or put in your contacts or on your sunglasses? How did you tie your shoes or brush your teeth, drive your car, [00:01:00] grab that cup of coffee? Using our hands to do things is so commonplace that we typically take them for granted until we hurt one of them. So a story, I had to take my dad to the E.R. the other day after a fall and we were checking in. And as we were checking in, a chef who, you know, you could tell he was a chef because he had the apron and the chef's coat that had his name on it. Chef Andy, he walked in holding his left index finger covered in a bloody rag, and he was treated in the next space over from my dad and I. And once the bleeding was stopped and I was listening, he was whisked away to see the orthopedic surgeon because they couldn't treat him there. I expect he's going to have a good outcome, but I imagine, at least for the next few weeks, he'll struggle with everyday activities, not to mention his work duties. So cuts and lacerations, crushing injuries, struck by injuries are all pretty common. There's good data out there to show that PPE can help reduce the severity of the injury that was caused by the event. However, there are a raft of other injuries [00:02:00] that are even more difficult to prevent because they're not always caused by a specific event like a splinter or a laceration. Injuries caused by prolonged static or awkward postures can be just as crippling as a traumatic event, and the healing process can be way more prolonged and dependent upon the injured person's changing their behavior or the workplace changing configuration or tools. So on the podcast with me today is Al Brown PT and director of Ergonomics, for Maine Employers Mutual Insurance Company, or MEMIC. Al has been on the podcast a number of times before and always brings a great perspective as to how the body interacts with the stressors in the workplace and what to do about them. Today Al is going to help me get a better grasp. Pardon the pun, of the causes of hand and wrist injuries and how to prevent them. Al welcome back to the podcast.

    Al Brown: [00:02:51] Thanks, Peter. Appreciate that. I have to hand it to you. That was a great intro.

    Peter Koch: [00:02:55] Oh, I'd Shake your hand Al for that for being on so many times and hopefully we'll stop being [00:03:00] quite so punny as we get moving

    Al Brown: [00:03:03] Jazz hands. I'm so excited about this.

    Peter Koch: [00:03:07] So this is awesome to have you back on. And I know we've talked about this subject a lot because hand injuries, regardless of what it is, are very common and one of the more common types of workplace injuries that we're going to see. So let's talk about some of the stats that are out there like we know it's a problem, but how big a problem are hand and wrist injuries out there in the workplace?

    Al Brown: [00:03:28] Looking back through some of the data and when you look back through some of the Bureau of Labor reporting and OSHA, they probably account for about a third of work related injuries. And that's when you sort of include, you know, the hand, the wrist and a little bit of the, you know, the forearm. But they account for about a third and their second, probably only to back injuries when you look at that data. So significant. Significant. [00:04:00] And then, you know, there's you know, when you look at costs, for example, loss of a thumb, you were talking about the gentleman that walked into the E.R. with the bloodied finger had he chopped off his thumb and could not put it back on. That's a thirty five thousand dollar for permanent disability kind of thing. That that's a chunk of change. When you think about it, you know, when you look at tendon repairs, they can cost up to 70,000 dollars. So it because of the intricacy of the hand, the fine motor activity, the abilities, there's a lot of things that can go wrong. You know, we often think about hand injuries to in the world of manual material handling, lifting, moving, carpentry, things like that, the chef. But we do see a lot of hand injuries just in the office environment, too. As matter of fact, a good portion when we look at banking and looking at law firms and accounting for in places like that, [00:05:00]probably the leading injury. Second, I should back up and say slip trips and fall seems to be number one, but when we look at strains, sprains and injuries along those lines, their leading body part injury is the hand. Wrist and hand or upper extremity. So it is very common that we see these across all industries.

    Peter Koch: [00:05:21] Yeah, and I think people tend to think about the severity of the hand or wrist injury with those traumatic type injuries. And I imagine you have stories like this, too. I have a friend way back when I was actually building houses, he was a phenomenal carpenter, an amazing guitar player, fingerpicking guitar player, could play just about any style, could hear it, and within a few minutes figure out the melody without any music in front of them. And just amazing guy. And he was ripping some plywood on a table saw without a guard, and he got a little kickback and put his hand down [00:06:00] on top of the spinning blade and pretty much cut his hand from his index finger across the meat of his thumb down to his wrist. And it took enough of the muscle out of there where it took him almost five years to get the dexterity back, to be able to finger pick again. And just, you know, you think about those severity things. People think about machinery, like you said before, with the severity of the injury. But we've also seen some pretty significant injuries that have come from those awkward postures or repetitive type injuries that might happen in an office. They just happen over a longer period of time. It's not that instantaneous. I touch something and it caught me or it crushed me and I have a permanent injury. So those same things can happen regardless. And I think it's important to know not just what can injure you in around the machinery, but what can injure you within in the other parts of the workplace. Those maybe not quite [00:07:00] so dangerous sounding jobs that are out there.

    Al Brown: [00:07:03] My common thread, if you ever listen to the podcast that we've talked about, I always talk about gravity. I talk about neutral. And the reason, you know, we are a structure walking around in this world of gravity. So balance is real key. Our body likes that balance the wrist and hand. There's an orchestration between brain and hand. And it's funny, we're you know, we're right. People who are either right handed or left handed. There is a core of the population that is ambidextrous. But you're either right handed or left handed, right handed people, believe it or not, your right hand is controlled by the left side of your brain and your left hand is controlled by the right side of your brain. So about 80 percent of the population is right handed. So there's about 10 to 15 percent of the population that's left handed. You talk about guitar, you're going to buy a guitar. You know, just and you said my son was left handed. He said, I went into the store, music store and I said, hey, we'd like to get a left handed guitar. They totally [00:08:00] discouraged us from doing that because they said wherever he goes, if he walks in somewhere and that happens to be a guitar laying there and someone says, hey, you play the guitar, why don't you strike a tune for us? And he picks it up and it's a right handed guitar and he's learned on a left handed guitar, he will have a very hard time playing it unless you're Jimi Hendrix.

    Peter Koch: [00:08:19] I was just thinking about that, too, right,

    Al Brown: [00:08:22] Who flipped a right handed guitar upside down and learned to play it left handed. So there's, you know, looking at fine motor again, that's that relationship between brain and hand and the fact that it's such a complex structure and much of what we do is unconscious in nature. When you start to create those muscle patterns going between hand and you look at the complexity of it and it's repeated patterns over and over and over again, they say that the hand will go through twenty five million bends and stretches over a lifetime. That's one hand.

    Peter Koch: [00:08:58] Wow.

    Al Brown: [00:08:58] So, I mean, that's [00:09:00] just incredible. And if you are someone like a guitar player or a piano player or a carpenter, that hand is just put through those repeated motions over and over again. We do a lot of unconscious repeated behavior.

    Peter Koch: [00:09:14] We definitely do. And there's that. We were talking about this before the podcast as well. There's that relationship between power and dexterity that the hand has. That's pretty amazing. You talk about a carpenter, right? So I need to have the dexterity in my hand to be able to pick up a nail and hold it in place. But I also have to have the power in my other hand to be able to mash that nail into whatever wood that I'm going to be driving it into. And so that's tough, too. Now, you are doing a little bit of research on some of those fun facts around, like what the hand can actually do. And I think it's pretty fascinating. So, like, if you think about power, like how strong are people's hands compared to how dexterous people's hands are because it lives in the same body, you can do the same thing. Dexterous things and pretty strong [00:10:00] things.

    Al Brown: [00:10:01] Yeah. I looked up some of those things, but, hey, back to that hammer thing. Yeah. And the ability to hold on to that nail and come down and strike that thing with something very hard, hoping you don't hit the wrong nail.

    Peter Koch: [00:10:17] Very true. Very true.

    Al Brown: [00:10:19] There's a relationship there. A rookie, the new employee is going to hit more fingernails than maybe the person that is more seasoned. So, you know, there is that. But when we look at the extremes, it was a fun little search I did on the internet and I said, OK, what's one of the most powerful things the hand could do? And I said, well, grip. And I said, what's the most? So I looked up, what's the biggest deadlift of the world record for the deadlift? And I guess it was set back in May of 2020 by a person named Hawthorn Bjรถrnsson, nicknamed Thor, [00:11:00] very apropos from Iceland, and he lifted over eleven hundred pounds of force in the deadlift. So that's, you know, granted he does have an assist with the grip, with some straps. But other than that it is, you know, each hand is handling, you know, five hundred and fifty pounds of force that he has to hang on to in order to stand upright, that the large muscle body, large muscles in his body is his buttock, his back extensors, his quads have to lift, but he has to hang on to the weight with his hands. I'm going to go to the other extreme. You go to the other extreme. And I said, what's the most difficult piano piece to play? And there was a number of top choices. But the one I picked was it was Beethoven's number twenty nine B flat major Opus 106, which if you look at that online, it has got to be one of the fastest hand movements and so intricate that it's very difficult [00:12:00] to even the most seasoned piano players to play. So you look at that extreme from those fine manipulating motor activities that have to move each individual finger to lifting 1,100 pounds, you know, that that just fascinates me in the extreme abilities of the hand.

    Peter Koch: [00:12:20] It is amazing what the hand can do. And that's just fascinating to be able to lift 1,100 pounds with the weak link being the coupling of your hands. Right. To be able to lift that whole thing. And then I'm pretty sure Thor's not a piano player. But, you know, if he is, he's probably not playing Beethoven. But you never know

    Al Brown: [00:12:37] Could be could be.

    Peter Koch: [00:12:41] Even to be dexterous enough to take a pencil and write your name, all of the fine motions that have to happen to be able to hold the pencil at the particular angle and then produce the motions and the movement with your hand, your wrist and your fingers to make the script occur on the page is all fascinating [00:13:00] and how your hand can do that and the connection between your brain. And we've all probably maybe some of our younger listeners might not have had this as much. But I bet you remember going back to school and getting a cramp in your hand, taking notes in class at some point in time, like you're just you're furiously writing notes to keep up with the professor who's up in front of you. And, you know, you're shaking your hand out because it hurts, because you're gripping it so hard that I'm not at neutral anymore. I'm causing some discomfort and from not so much overuse, but probably not the best posture or trying to produce those different fine motor functions in a way that's not allowing me not long enough circulation to move through. So really amazing what the hand can do. And fascinating, there's lots of different parts of the body that have that like we talked about the spine before, that have that's a lot of power and in functionality and movement [00:14:00] within that as well. But the hand really lots of cool things that can happen that it can do for sure.

    Al Brown: [00:14:05] Well, it's been a big paradigm shift. I mean, you go back to me and you start with chalk on a chalkboard, go to a pencil, you know, and you know. So chalk is a different kind of prehensile grip to actually right on the chalk. Prehensile grips or the different things like pinch grips, like, you know, your thumb, your pulp grip. And, you know, there's three point chuck grip. The chalk was like a three point chuck grip. Then you went to a pencil, which was more like a prehensile grip or fine motor activity to now where we hover over a keyboard. So if we hearken back to the days, it's a matter of fact, the handwriting has gotten progressively worse simply because most folks are hanging out on the keyboard now, typing away. So the ability to write and take notes is really sort of it's just a different format.

    Peter Koch: [00:14:51] I Finally feel normal because my handwriting has been messy all my life and now I fit in with everything else.

    Al Brown: [00:14:56] You fit in with the rest of the crowd.

    Peter Koch: [00:14:57] Lowering the bar [00:15:00] every day. Right. There we go. Just kidding.

    Al Brown: [00:15:03] I'm still trying to figure out the keyboard. So, you know,

    Peter Koch: [00:15:06] It is an interesting shift. And that shift from writing on the chalkboard to taking notes with a pen or pencil to the manual typewriter, to the automatic typewriter and now to the computer keyboard has really changed how writing or written communication affects our physical the physical demands. Right. So the written word hasn't changed. You could we could have a whole other podcast on how that is altered. But you think about written communication. I have to send something or write something that someone can read going from the student or the professor to the student, the student to the paper. And now, you know, all the way to the computer keyboard has really changed the demands of what the body needs to do in order to get the word onto whatever medium you're doing. And there's different exposures there. Right. So that exposure [00:16:00] of writing is very different than the exposure for typing, and it creates different challenges for us.

    Al Brown: [00:16:06] Then throw in the mouse, you know, if we go back to that office environment and then, you know, a lot of things are sort of driven by the mouse and the mouse was a later invention from the keyboard. And then we all sort of kind of placed it out to the side. So then the fine activity of the hand, there's different shape mice out there nowadays because I can't tell you how many folks I deal with that have you know, they've got tingling in this hand. They've got discomfort like on the corner right below the bottom of your little finger, like way back by your wrist. There's a bone right there. And it's called your pisiform. And a lot of people that have limited space by their keyboard will be pivoting on that. And they create what's called a contact stressor. So you'll see it'll be red and angry and they'll go, it hurts right there. And it's yeah, I don't know why. And it's, you know, just hanging out [00:17:00] on that mouse and pivoting on that part of your wrist, just moving the mouse back and forth. So it's or you take people to ask about vertical mice, mice that are vertical. Well, if it's too vertical, your fingers want to drop down to earth. Welcome back to Gravity. So even though that's a small muscle group, you tend to hang on to that vertical mouse a little bit harder than you would maybe a semi vertical or a flat mouse. So all of a sudden you're noticing discomfort in the back side of the thumb or in the forearm, the different names from De Quervain's tendonitis. And it's because you're trying to hang on to this mouse just because of its positioning. So those subtleties in life have become more frequent simply because the way we compose words nowadays are kind of hovering over these things in front of us.

    Peter Koch: [00:17:52] So let's just break that out a little bit, because, you know, we've talked about some of the most frequent injuries being cuts, lacerations, abrasions, and we're going [00:18:00] to touch on those and prevention of those. But let's break apart the process of typing, because most people are going to do it. You know, even if you are, you don't have an office job, you don't have a job that demands you be in front of the computer all the time, the majority of us are going to be on something, whether it's an iPad or a phone or some electronic device that's going to have some sort of static posture that's you're going to be generating words with in some form or another. So why do we see so many repetitive stress or awkward posture type injuries or claims coming from keyboard and mouse use? He talked about the pisiform bone and the pivoting on that piece and mouse. But there's other stuff that happens to, you know, people do you know, how does that happen? What happens and what do we do to prevent it?

    Al Brown: [00:18:49] Sure. Yeah, no, that's just one little tiny piece. But yeah, we could do a whole lot.

    Peter Koch: [00:18:53] Yes, we could.

    Al Brown: [00:18:54] Let me give you the highlights. I mean, some simple basic problems. We run into standard desks [00:19:00] that were those writing desks that we used to have in the past, that we still have are twenty nine and a half inches high and most chairs that we sit on probably go up to about 20 inches. The seat pan. There's quite a difference between twenty nine and a half and twenties, about nine and a half, almost ten inch difference between seat pan height. So if the desk, which often is the case, is too high, we have to manipulate that keyboard and put it in certain positions which as if we can't reach parallel if our forearm and wrists, are recess to be in line with our forearm and hovering over our keyboard. If we can't get to that posture on our current situation because the desk is too high, the chair's too low, we tend to either push the keyboard back or we put the keyboard might be too low or too high. We change that angle between wrist and forearm. And as that changes, the further it gets away from neutral, where the hand is parallel with the forearm, the more [00:20:00] you close down a place that delivers the nerve and blood supply to the wrist and the hands. And the more you start to fatigue the shoulders, too, and the more you start weight bearing on those and creating these awkward postures so you can get tingling in the fingers. If you're seated too low, your arm might wing out to the side and you might rested on the arm of your chair. It might be resting on the return on your desk and all of a sudden you expose and compress the little nerve that goes right around your elbow called your funny bone or your ulnar nerve. And you're noticing that your fourth and fifth finger kind of go and tingly. So again, just the height of the desk and this little discussion we're having will impact what happens to your hands if the reach to the mouse is too far. And again, remember standard keyboards, Pete, you've got the qwerty, which are the letters which are typically like a typewriter, but then, I don't know, someone mandated we got to have a number [00:21:00] pad. So they hung that out on to the right side of the keyboard. And then if you look at 80 percent of the population is right handed. Where do they all tend to put the mouse? To the right hand side of the keyboard? So now that arm has moved way out of neutral to go get it and people tend to hang on. That's when they start pivoting on the wrist or loading up the wrist in hand. And that's when we start to see the forearm elbow tendinitis, because folks are parked in a very long distance away from the body. So we're trying to bring everything back in closer. You were talking about the connection between brain and hand. One of the suggestions we often give for the keyboard with the number pad to the right, with the mouse to the right with a with a standard bilateral mouse, one that you can use in either side is what you put the mouse on the left hand side of the keyboard. What do you think the response is when we say that?

    Peter Koch: [00:21:52] I can't do that.

    Al Brown: [00:21:53] I can't do that.

    Peter Koch: [00:21:54] I can't do that.

    Al Brown: [00:21:56] And it's a simple motor pattern, just moving something around and clicking it. But it [00:22:00] brings it's a quick, easy solution to bring things more into neutral and reduce the forces on the wrist and hand and shoulder and neck. And it takes a couple, three days. It's just a motor pattern, but that's a plan. But again, that's that right left brain. This is my dominant hand. Don't try me. Tell me. And again, you go back to injury. Many folks listening to the podcast today that may have been that are right handed, that might have fallen and sprained their wrist, the right wrist or fractured it. And we're casted very quickly discover how dependent they are on that right hand, but realize after a couple of days that the left hand is a good second choice and it steps up to the steps up to the plate and does a pretty good job after a couple, three days.

    Peter Koch: [00:22:49] It is amazing how you can train your body to do a different act or an activity in a different way when you're forced to do it. But that's an interesting [00:23:00] part, too. And I think we'll talk about this as we go through that prevent the prevention piece. It's one of the challenging pieces of repetitive motion or awkward postures, because they're cumulative, because they take time to do that and it takes time for you to learn the other way to do it. You should be kind of doing this all along, switching from side to side so you don't have the repetition or the constant awkward posture of the constant pressure on that one side happening. But it just takes time. It's weird. I know one of my friends, they broke their right forearm and they were casted. So they really couldn't do a whole lot with that. And I remember them. The hardest thing for them to change was brushing their teeth. And they came to me one day. We got coffee together and a blistering hot cup of coffee and they took a sip of the coffee. And it burned. Right. But I took a sip of the coffee and it was hot, a little burning. But they were like incredible pain, like, [00:24:00] Dan, what's going on? It's like, well, I was brushing my teeth today with my left hand because I can't do it my right hand and I stab myself in the back of the throat with a toothbrush because they just didn't have the fine motor control of that. But, you know, a week later, they were like at no big deal. It works just fine. So it just takes a little while to figure it out, to learn it. Yeah. Yeah. That retraining of that.

    Al Brown: [00:24:21] Yeah. Discomfort breeds change. But I mean, that's the only thing that kind of, you know, and that's the problem is that's why people won't learn, you know, kind of flip flop back and forth unless there's some discomfort or problem or, you know, something that restricts you. You typically don't change simply because it's just more efficient to just keep moving forward and using that your right hand or your, you know, whichever handed you are. Yeah. And why change, you know, until you have to.

    Peter Koch: [00:24:46] Right. Right. Now, let's talk a little bit about anatomy and physiology of the hand and wrist, like we talked about that it is a really it's a very dexterous body part for us. We can do lots of things that can be powerful. It can be really it [00:25:00] can do a lot of fine motor stuff. But what allows it to do all those things? What's the anatomy that makes it all up? And then how does some of those postures affect the anatomy that cause some of those challenges in repetitive or awkward posture injuries?

    Al Brown: [00:25:17] Sure. Yeah. Well, you had mentioned earlier there's about and again, it varies. Some people have some extra little bones in the hand, but somewhere between 27 and 29, bones that make up the wrist and hand and it's about it, believe it or not, that's about a quarter of all the bones in the body are little spot. Yeah, right there, you know, about thirty muscles, about 129 ligaments, about 17,000 touch receptors in the palm, you know. So when you look at all those things that come together. Now, here's the thing. Most of the muscles that run the fingers, there's only tendons up in the finger, the belly of itself, the muscle itself. So if you think of a bicep, because everybody's kind of familiar with the bicep, the biceps [00:26:00] has this big meaty part in the middle of your upper arm. And then it what it does is it pars down to like a tendonous structures that connects below the elbow and then another two tendonous structures that go up into the shoulder. Very much like the hand, the meaty part of that muscle for the fingers is in the palm of your hand and it's just the long tendon structures that go up into your fingers and those things run your fingers. You can kind of wave your fingers around. You can make it sort of, you know, like bring your knuckles down and straighten your fingers out that your lumbar curls. But then the thing that moves your wrists, those muscles, the long tendons go up your forearm and those meaty part of it is your forearm itself and then attach to the elbow one of the problems we run into when you make a fist. OK, if you if you hold your hand up in front of you so that your thumb is kind of facing you and you make a fist, OK, you're going to look at the upper fingertips. They're all curling down. [00:27:00] But as they curl down, you'll notice the knuckles, you know, sort of at the base of your finger where the hand comes up and then the base of the finger. If you look at the back of that, hand back your hand, which way is the back of your hand moving? It's actually moving backwards away from that curl. Well, that's an orchestration between the flexors and the extensors of the wrist. The flexors are curling your hand down, but the extensors at the same time are pulling your wrist back because it makes it a more efficient grip. And that's why your hand tends to drop back in. Those muscles, the flexors attached to the inside of your elbow, kind of the part of your forearm that doesn't have much hair sort of that. And you get a little bump on the inside of your elbow. The extensors go up, that sort of the hairy side of your forearm and attach on the outside of your elbow called the if people have injured that before, it's called tennis elbow. And the reason for that is it tends [00:28:00] to be an injury that tennis players got. And when they would hit backhand, the ball would hit the racket and do a quick jerk and they'd get sort of a torque on that tendon. Making a fist, that balance between those muscles is so important. And, you know, we will do if you took the hand and you had someone just grip and we can do this with a grip dinamometer where you can measure the grip strength. And say you could generate 100 pounds of force with that. And you did it in neutral, which means that hand is balanced and right there in front of you. But then if we put the hand in an awkward position, kind of reach out, you might have to flex the wrist a bit. People will lose when we have them do that same amount of effort and force. They'll lose anywhere between 20 and 40 percent of their ability to generate grip strength. So think about that in the world of work in that if I have to work in an awkward position with my wrist in hand, I think of a company that I was working with that were putting trailer lights on. They [00:29:00] had to hold the light, what they were holding the light with the left hand and then there reaching up around and back to put the knot on. So that hand was on a very awkward position for an extended period of time, very inefficient, lost most of their ability to generate force. So it took more energy to do that all day long. Fatigue came quicker. What do you think the quality of the work was by the end of the day?

    Peter Koch: [00:29:25] Oh, I'm sure a lot more mistakes could happen there, too, right?

    Al Brown: [00:29:27] Oh, dropping the nut, you know, not, you know, not fully tightening the nut. Even you start to lose your ability to palpate and feel and touch and your sensory your muscle strength goes. So now here is a worker hurting themselves, the product going out of the door, out the door. You know, you're driving down the road is the consumer. But yourself a nice new trailer and you're looking at the trailer lights banging along the road because they fell off, you know, and again and you bring the trailer back and go this trailer's horrible, I'm going to give it a one star. And so, again, [00:30:00] looking at design, how are workers working? How are their hands neutral? Understand that neutral position, set that workforce up so that they're more in a balanced position, better quality work, happier worker, happier customer.

    Peter Koch: [00:30:13] Yeah, and you can't change you can't change anatomy. So you've got to change something else about the work. So either the tool that they're using or the ergonomics of it. We talked a little bit about how to set that, you know, an ergonomic workstation up to be more in neutral. And that's the key. You've talked about that before. You said it's been a theme throughout many of the podcasts. And it is because any time you interact with something you want to look at, if I can start the job in neutral, how far out of neutral do I go to complete the job and how often am I there and how long am I there so neutral posture is a fairly important thing to remember, regardless of what the task is, and especially for something that you're doing with your hands, arms or shoulders for sure.

    Al Brown: [00:30:55] Pete I mean, think of tooling, you know, we were talking about pencils and computers [00:31:00] and you threw in typewriters. I forgot about those. I sort of skipped that era. But think about the morphing or the or the number of iterations. Of the screwdriver.

    Peter Koch: [00:31:14] Right, right,

    Al Brown: [00:31:15] You know, think about what a screwdriver looks like nowadays, it's you know, it's a pistol grip, you know, if that's what we're using and it's power driven. And, you know, think about, I remember having to put together a friend of mine said, hey, I got this shed and it was one of those aluminum sheds. And they said, I got it for free. And they handed me a bag of screws. I mean, we're talking a giant bag of screws like we're talking a small kitchen trash bag full of screws and said, could you put that together? And I had, there was no such thing as a power screwdriver. And, you know, two days later, I couldn't even, like, wash my hair after it was all over. I just couldn't move my hands [00:32:00] because of the number of rotations to put that together. But had I had a power screwdriver, life would have been glorious

    Peter Koch: [00:32:08] Sure faster, quicker, less repetitions. But I think that that breeds even a better question because take the power screwdriver out of it. Take the screw gun out of it for a moment. You can buy a screwdriver in many different sizes and configurations, not just the, you know, a Philips versus a star versus a flat bit, but the handle can be configured very different. Some are bulbous, some are long. Some are short. Some are textured. Some are smooth. And really, if you're thinking about it, there's multiple reasons for some of the different configurations. But when we talk about ergonomics, if I can't have the power screwdriver with the pistol grip and I have to use a manual driver to do that, because sometimes you have to what's the best way? Like what's the best type of grip for that hand tool [00:33:00] that you aren't going to be able to pistol grip it with?

    Al Brown: [00:33:04] We were just looking at some ergo film the other day, some film a company had sent to us in what's called our E Ergo process. It's where a company can submit video footage of a job and have us analyze it. They were manufacturing small products and in that particular case, and it's on a workbench and they're sitting and if they had a pistol screw gun, the problem is they actually have to, we call it deviate the wrist, which would be instead of flexing and extending. So instead of flexing your hand forward and extending it backwards, they actually have to deviate, which would be sort of tipping your hand toward your little finger side. And there's two deviations. There's ulnar and radial deviation where you can tip your hand towards your thumb side. But in this particular case, they'd have to go towards our little finger side with a pistol grip to actually do the work. In that particular case, a shaft electric screwdriver where they could literally [00:34:00] grab and come straight down with a power grip was much better for them. And with this particular tool, some of them are air driven, even we have them on a tool balancer. So when they release this thing, instead of laying it back down on the workbench, it actually hovers back up over the workbench so they can just reach up, pull down and do the screws. So in that particular case, a pistol grip would not have been effective, would have created probably more problems in some cases when there's really fine motor like small screws, even just a standard Old-World screwdriver works a whole bunch better. So, you know, you really have to look at the specific job and the tasks to determine what's the best tool. You know, you don't go out just by a bunch of pistol grip tool, you know, screwdriver to go there all fixed. You may be creating some of the problems along the way. So, again, go back to how do I keep that person's hand in good, neutral, working posture balanced? [00:35:00] You know, I wanted balance when I see really awkward extremes of the wrist. I know there's potential problems ahead.

    Peter Koch: [00:35:07] Right, so that deviation on their side radial side or flexed forward or flexed backwards are things to consider with the position of the work that you're doing and then thinking about where neutral is and then determining what type of tool is going to keep you in that neutral position. Best give you the best grip. That's good advice.

    Peter Koch: [00:35:31] Let's take a quick break so I can tell you about our E Ergo resource that can be used to help solve ergonomic challenges at your workplace, sometimes contacting, contracting with and scheduling an ergonomist or occupational health nurse for an onsite evaluation doesn't really fit with our Just-In-Time workflow. In a competitive economy fixing the problem right now is essential. And improving worker comfort and efficiency are key components to ongoing success. So [00:36:00] free to our policyholders. MEMIC's E Ergo tool can help you overcome ergonomic challenges. With just five quick photos or a short 30 second video and a brief description of what's being shown, you can send us the critical demands and essential functions within the work tasks once received are ergonomics team can identify risks and exposures and provide reasonable suggestions for ergonomic improvement within just a few short days. Start that E Ergo process now by logging into the MEMIC safety director at www.MEMIC.com/Workplace Safety. Now let's get back to today's episode.

    Al Brown: [00:36:42] One thing I didn't mention is when you look at if you were looking at a tool like a hammer or very much like a tennis racket or something like that, people want to get the right size grip, too, because of the tool is too small. I see this in dental offices, too. Like if you look at the pics and the different fine motor things that they're doing on your teeth, [00:37:00] you may notice that some of your dentist, your hygienists have like fat handled tools now. Well, they discovered that those really small stainless steel, tiny tools, they were actually over gripping because it was too small. So they had to work harder. You can also go in the other direction if it's too fat over gripping. So if you're going to go out and buy a tennis racket or a racquetball racket or a nice hammer, it's always good to go down. There's like a couple of creases in your hand, but the one that kind of goes right across the middle of your hand, if you measure from that crease up to the tip of your middle finger, that's a good sort of rough way to measure what the circumference should be of that thing that you purchase. It's you know, it's a good way to kind of determine what's a good efficient grip for you.

    Peter Koch: [00:37:47] Would a tool that measured, similar to this, the distance between that crease in your hand or the tip of your you said middle finger, index finger,

    Al Brown: [00:37:57] Middle finger, middle finger

    Peter Koch: [00:37:58] For that. So [00:38:00] if the circumference measure is pretty close to that, well, that feel pretty comfortable in your hand, like, is it does it pass sort of the straight face test of it feels good or will it feel fairly awkward in your hand if you're not if you're not used to it?

    Al Brown: [00:38:14] It should for the most part, you know, call it rule of thumb.

    Peter Koch: [00:38:18] I applaud you Al for bringing that in.

    Al Brown: [00:38:22] That it will you know, and this is we're talking about a power grip, too. We're not talking about a dental tool that should be that creates. But we're talking more of a power type tool, a racket, something like that. Yes. Most likely that'll feel pretty comfortable because that's probably one of the more efficient grips that will keep the muscles that are holding it. Remember those muscles on the back side of your forearm, on the front side of the forearm, make that power grip, you know, coupled with the thumb. You know, the one thing we didn't talk about is that thumb opposes, which makes us very different from a simian hands. I mean, the hand of the ones that you see in the monkey, but the [00:39:00] human hand can oppose the thumb. There's nine muscles that run that thing. So that's what helps us determine that most efficient grip.

    Peter Koch: [00:39:08] Is that one of the reasons we see, like if you think about landscaping or yard work, you're seeing a trend over the last I don't know how many years now you've seen it where you've gone from a very small wooden handle on your rake and your shovel to maybe a thicker fiberglass handle or a cushion, the thicker cushioned handle on that rake or the shovel or whatever hand tool that you're going to be using to give you a larger grip. Because I do remember like doing work when I was growing up or for my parents or my grandparents where, you know, you had the really thin broom handled rake to rake the yard with. And now if you grab one of those, I can tell you my forearms, my elbows, my wrists start to fatigue a lot more quickly. And, you know, old tendinitis kind of comes back, it feels like. But some of the larger grips, they feel a little bit more comfortable. So [00:40:00] is that the reason why they're doing that for those tools as well?

    Al Brown: [00:40:04] Yeah, that's a perfect example, Pete. I mean, that's a that's a prime example of how there's been a transformation of tools. And part of that, too, is if you remember the old rakes and old shovels and things, a lot of them, they were wooden handles and sometimes they were then varnish. So they became very smooth. So it's even that texture to that. You now look at modern day tools. If you go down to the hardware store, there are a little bit more rubberized. There's a little bit higher friction surface maybe at the end in the middle, the rakes, because that ability to grip on you don't need as much force if there's a better texture between your hand. Same thing with gloves. You're seeing gloves. Now, remember the old leather gloves, the old sort of cowhide leather glove with the big gauntlet cuff on it. And, you know, people just hand them out and, you know, you just really couldn't grip very well with them. And in fact, ill-fitting [00:41:00] gloves can really reduce your ability to grip. You can lose 20 to 30 percent of your grip strength simply because the glove is ill-fitting. I remember working at a large industry here in Maine and all they handed out were those gloves in large. And they have hands of every size there. So the person that fit them well, you know, fit their hand well would probably do well again, fitting the work to the worker. But then you give someone that, you know, might be a small person or very large person, probably more small where the hand goes in there and he got all this extra material and then folks. Well, you can't how come you can't grip on to that? And it's not because they have any less skill or ability. It's just they're trying to overcome all this extra material. So, you know, it's amazing how tools and gloves and things like that have really changed. And it's important to look at the right tool, the right glove, the right, you know, the texture [00:42:00] when you're when you're looking at ergonomics.

    Peter Koch: [00:42:02] So it enhances the grip. It provides better dexterity to give you the ability to use the hand and the arm in the way it was designed in the most powerful way so that you can do the work. Otherwise it gets in the way. I know I've been I've had that same thing where the only glove I have is one that doesn't fit well and all of a sudden it's I just can't do that. So what do you do? You take your glove off and then you go do the work and it might be better for you from a dexterity standpoint. It might be better for you from an economic standpoint, but it exposes you to all the other hazards which really haven't got into yet. And I think it's a good time to jump in to that particular exposure because we you know, we started this conversation with the chef coming into the E.R. with the bloody rag and cut his finger and having to go see the orthopedic surgeon. But there's a lot more ways that you can hurt your hands and probably for lack of a better term, more popular ways to hurt your hands [00:43:00] than a repetitive motion injury. So talk a little bit about that. What are the other ways beyond a poor ergonomics or a poor workstation set up where you can find hand and finger injuries?

    Al Brown: [00:43:12] Sure, sure. I mean, if you look at some of the common causes, it's, you know, fatigue, distraction and attentiveness. I'm guessing the chef someone yelled to him, "hey, hey", he turned and was still chopping as he was still doing that unconscious behavior. And just that inattentiveness changed things. And, you know, there goes the finger. So he has a new restaurant called Nine Fingers. It's a great place that no. So probably serves finger sandwiches. But there you go. One of the one of the things I always try to encourage, particularly in the manufacturing or the construction industry, is very simple thing. Jewelry and one in particular rings are really they contribute big time [00:44:00] to hand injuries that simply I encourage employees or employers to just say take your ring off and just put it on a chain on your neck, if you want to make sure that it's still with you and all that kind of good thing, or they have these breakaway rings now that now exists, which I'm actually seeing more and more in the industry because a simple ring Pete, to give you an example, coming down a ladder, if you're walking, you coming down a ladder and your hand over your feet and you're in good contact if you're lowering your body in that left hand with that ring, gets hooked on the ladder rung and you lower yourself, you don't react quick enough to go back up to protect your finger. And oftentimes we've seen fingers that are literally amputated or degloved where the skin is kind of pulled up and off. So just taking that ring off, having a glove on would have probably helped a bit. But still, the other [00:45:00] exposure that has to is in the automotive industry and ring on it. And you are working with something that's electric, like the battery, and you happen to ground out with that hand. That ring will conduct the electricity and cook the base your finger pretty quickly. So again. So those are two just jewelry. You know, as I say, if you want to keep your finger, don't put a ring on it.

    Peter Koch: [00:45:26] Oh, Beyonce.

    Al Brown: [00:45:28] Oh, sorry Beyonce. But that is true, you know, so we really tried. I worked with the lumber company and really, you know, I actually put together a sort of a fact sheet on that the degloving and that kind of thing to convince workers that you really, it was funny because I had one worker got stood up there and there was his ring finger gone and he goes, oh, yeah, that happened to me. I said, so there you go.

    Peter Koch: [00:45:53] Don't lose that story. Right. Gosh.

    Al Brown: [00:45:56] So and then, you know, other things like an industry. And it's funny because I'm [00:46:00] an ergonomist. So I walk in the industry and I look at more kind of physiology things that can happen to tendinitis is the muscle strains. But in manufacturing, you know, there's a lot of I learned the term at MEMIC pinch points where there are open wheels and belts where a finger can fit in and that, you know, you can create a amputation, you can create a crush injury, you know, so guarding and things like that or something, just like your friend took the guard off the saw and decided, you know, something went. And again, it's usually a tool that sort of changes its behavior, maybe either misuse or inappropriate use of the tool or, you know, he didn't have the guard on. Quickly it occurs. You know, you're thinking that wasn't good.

    Peter Koch: [00:46:50] No. And it just it really just takes an instant. I was reflecting, as you were talking about the ladder in the ring. And I imagine just about anyone [00:47:00] who's climbed a ladder. Often has had that experience where they're coming down and their ring catches for just a moment and it might not be enough to injure, but it's enough to remind you that, oh, that was close. And I got away with it. But, gosh, maybe the next time I'm not going to get away with it, maybe the next time I'm going to get caught and I'm going to actually start to load my entire body weight on that. And I'm going to what's going to happen. And there's plenty of evidence in the world to show that that's not a good thing. And again, like amputations, machinery, amputations, where someone either an improperly guarded tool or the employee purposely defeats the guard or the guard is not functional. And they get their body part, their finger, typically the tip of one of their fingers is going to get too close to those rotating parts. And there it's gone. And even, you know, we don't we take for granted a lot the weight of things that we work around. [00:48:00]Again, it's funny, there's always a story for something. But again, I worked with a guy. They were loading jersey barriers onto a back of a truck after they had finished a construction project. And as he was loading the second to last one, he was guiding it with his hand. Right. So had it on the inside of that. And it didn't touch really hard against the Jersey barrier. That was that it was sitting down against what had touched enough. So it crushed the tip of his middle finger inside his glove. But, you know, pretty much lost the tip of his finger from his nail bed up to the top because it was crushed with the weight of it. And it just took an instant. And he talked to him later on. He said, oh, I knew how heavy it was, but I only think about the quote unquote, impact of what would happen if it just tapped against another immovable object. So just we take things for granted. A lot of things for granted.

    Al Brown: [00:48:53] Yeah. Speaking of granite, in the world of stone masonry and building stone [00:49:00] walls and landscaping, that same incident occurs when someone is moving a large rock and placing it on another. And it's actually referred to as the granite kiss. And that's where two rocks and your finger become. And so that's something you can't take for granted when you're placing rocks.

    Peter Koch: [00:49:23] You sure can. And I would imagine you start to look at that type of industry and this goes to landscaping or even carpentry or any time you're going to be working with your hands in an environment where there's a lot of abrasive materials, just a glove. And again, the right fitting glove is going to go a long way to prevent many of those minor injuries. And in a minor injury like a cut or laceration, even someone's using a box knife to cut sheetrock or they're cutting up cardboard to put in the recycling piece. A fairly [00:50:00] minor injury is going to take that person out of the work for a little while to go get treated. And they might not even go to the doctor, but they got to go get a bandage and clean it out properly, because if they don't, chances are it's going to get infected and then it's going to be worse later on, where a simple 5, 10, 15 dollar pair of gloves, depending on how dexterous you really need your hands, would have fixed that or prevented the injury. The event would have still happened, like the slip with the knife or the granite kiss would have still happened. But the glove would have reduced the severity of that event. That's something we don't always think about. But it's a recommendation that happens almost all the time when we go down onto a job site where they're doing something manual with their hands and they're not using gloves, why not use gloves?

    Al Brown: [00:50:47] Yeah, just think like passing lumber. You know, I worked at a lumber mill or just slide boards off what they call the green chain and sliding, you know, and if barehanded, how [00:51:00] many times have you slid a board through your hands and just taken a sliver somewhere? And just that tiny piece of wood is painful and we're not even talking about something that might be, you know PT, which has got the chemicals in it, which now you would you know, you've introduced a sliver with chemicals into your hand. So just a glove allows you to let that slip through and avoid or at least mitigate that risk a lot just by having that extra protection.

    Peter Koch: [00:51:29] Sure.

    Al Brown: [00:51:30] So, you know, I never sort of do anything without my gloves on. You know, as I've gotten older and I'm less physical, my hands are less resistant. I don't have the buildup. So even more important. And that's when you look at some of the data from OSHA, NIOSH, it's a lot of times it's the new employees, the sort of the new workforce less experienced that, you know, these things occur. So even more to protect and guard them. Folks [00:52:00] in the middle tend to be a little bit more seasons have been around, they kind of get the value of that, and then the next exposed group is more the older worker, 55 and older experienced understand. But their recovery time takes a lot longer. So you really do want to make sure they're protected doing what they're doing.

    Peter Koch: [00:52:19] Recovery's a lot longer, and I think reaction time is a lot slower as well. So you just think about what a glove would do, even that simple passing lumber from point A to point B or even if you're a finished carpenter and you're moving sheet goods from point A to point B and it slips a little bit in your hand, your reaction time isn't good enough to keep it from moving enough to maybe drive a splinter in your finger so the glove would help. It would help prevent that potential for injury there. And there's so many different types of gloves to.

    Al Brown: [00:52:54] Yeah, and Pete think of this, we're talking manual material handling, you know, grip protection. [00:53:00] But think about your world of ski resorts. Sure. You know, and thermal protection, you know, and that you got to have, you know, if you're protecting the hands. Because I tried to find the naval study that I wanted to look mid-shipment. They actually looked at mid-shipment and they said they wanted to see how temperature affected the hand dexterity. So they said, I want you to tie a knot. It was very simple knot I don't know what the knot is, but they said just tie as many of these you can in a minute. And they had their hands at 70 degrees. You know, it was just room temperature, 70 degrees. And that was the ambient temperature. And they could tie I think it was 42 knots in a minute. I mean, it was a symbol, bup bup bup bup bup bup. So they could go pretty quickly. Then they lowered the ambient temperature down to like fifty degrees and just really reduced. You know their hands were cold. And you know what happens when your hands get cold. They went down to six knots a minute. They couldn't they didn't have the dexterity to [00:54:00] complete that task. So when you look at oil delivery folks, when you look at the ski industry, when you look at anybody who's out in a cold environment, that might have to do fine motor activity know that, look at power workers up in bucket trucks up trying to do nuts and bolts during this, you know, winter storm, you know, and then they've got on double gloves for insulation. You know, their ability to generate force and be dexterous drops off considerably. So you have to keep that in mind when you're looking at the worker and what it is they're doing and how is that going to impact them?

    Peter Koch: [00:54:40] I can tell you from personal experience, both myself having to tie knots in cold weather as a ski patroller and then as the patrol director going back in and, you know, looking at those really bone chillingly cold days where as a patroller, you're out doing something and then you're having to repair a fence or do something that requires [00:55:00] you to be dexterous with your fingers and your hands. And you look at the result and many times the knot won't be the same knot. It'll be something that's much easier to tie rather than trying to tie a more complex knot that would be the correct, not for that particular situation. Easier to untie later on when we have to, but it was the only knot that they could tie because their fingers just weren't functioning well enough. And that doesn't even need to be a hypothermic issue where you've got some brain function challenge. It's truly the dexterity of your fingers and the gelling of everything, just not making it work the way you want it to. And that goes it doesn't need to be an outside person. Many times in the wintertime, you might have a mechanic working in a shop, right. That the door's open and closed, open and close, open and close. And it might be warm in the office or the parts room, but you get out onto the floor where the guy is doing work and it's pretty chilly out there. And it might be in the, you know, low 60s, which could be comfortable for you. [00:56:00] But when you're there all day on a concrete floor, your hands could get pretty chilly and work production is going to go down and the potential for mistakes and injuries go up from there for sure.

    Al Brown: [00:56:10] Well, that's you know, what happens in a situation like that is core temperature drops off your body, core temperature drops off. And what it will do is it'll pull the blood in from your extremities to kind of it's a survival mode and your core will try to stay warm. So what happens is your ability to do fine motor activity drops off exponentially. So I dealt with this once in the manufacturing environment where they had a cold mist blowing on, you know, to help them with the work. I'm not sure what the reason for the cold mist, but it really impacted. And they were putting together plugs, electric plugs. They just couldn't understand. And I said, you know, with the cold mist, it's very difficult. You'll change the temperature, the core temperature of the hand and their ability to manipulate goes down tremendously. [00:57:00] And that the example there's a sort of local example of how can we improve that and then the general example of you of opening the door to the whole bay and you're chilling the person, reduces their ability to produce fine motor activity. So you've got to keep those things in mind when you're when you're thinking about was my production down?

    Peter Koch: [00:57:23] Yeah. There's so many different things that could go into that. That's a whole body challenge. Right. When we started thinking about core temperature drop and one of the first effects you're going to see are going to be your fingers getting chillier because blood is trying to come back into the core something. But, you know, knowing that there's different ways to prevent it, you could prevent it locally with gloves. But that's not going to change the overall core temperature of the person you might need to look at different opportunities to do it. Yeah, so lots of different ways to lots of different reasons that people might put their hands in the wrong spot. It could be because the dexterity [00:58:00] isn't there. It could be because they're moving a lot of physical things around, whether it be stone, rock or other product. And whenever you're doing it with your hands, you're putting your hands at risk. And they are. They are I mean, they are the things that really get us to interact with our world. You think about what you can't do if you don't have use of your hands like we started at the beginning of the podcast. It's phenomenal how many times you interact with the world, with your hands and even if you lose another sense. So you talk about someone who might have vision issues or hearing issues like that tactile sense that you have with your hand to be able to identify something in front of you or around you by touching it is just makes your world that much bigger. And without that, because of an injury, whether it be repetitive injury or because of a traumatic injury, you lose a whole part of your world. We talk about it like when we do when [00:59:00] I do hearing conservation training, we talk about your hearing and how it really broadens your world and that inability once you start to lose your hearing, to have great conversations with people or talk to them in a loud environment or when it gets really bad hear, the beauty of the world around you. And when you start to get hand injuries, those same things you're going to miss out on, it might not be something you hear, but to be able to shake someone's hand or to be able to pet your dog or something that you really enjoy, you're not going to be able to do that if you don't take care of your hands. And it's just a big part of it. We just take them for granted. Truly take them for granted.

    Al Brown: [00:59:39] You know, a thought Pete just think about us as aging to, you know, we're an aging population, so, you know, we didn't touch on the thing about arthritis and those kinds of changes that occur on the hand or comorbidities. But as we age, what do we tend to do? But, you know, what's the leading cause of injury in the work environment that's slips, trips and falls? And what's the thing that we stick out [01:00:00] to kind of, you know, cushion that fall is usually the hand. And even in the ski world, you know, you're talking about skiing before. And when you fall down, you tend to put that hand out. And what's the thing that usually takes the hit is that, you know, there was a fracture or usually it's a broken wrist. And the function, all that, that had been taken for granted before, as you just mentioned, really comes you know, you realize, oh, my goodness, I really lost the function of my hand. And as a physical therapist, it takes months of rehab to regain just the majority of that range of motion and strength. But you'll never come back 100 percent. So, you know, it's one of those things to think about again as an employer or just around your everyday life. Think about, you know, yeah, I want to get the right tool and all this, but look at slip trip and fall hazards all around. You know, that that could lead to a broken wrist.

    Peter Koch: [01:00:59] Sure. You [01:01:00] could do everything that you can to get, like you said, the right tool. I've set everything up ergonomically, but the box that I didn't pick up behind my workstation that I just tripped over and now I've done the same thing to my hand that I that I might have done if I didn't get the right tools. So it's a big picture of peace preventing injuries. No matter what it is. It's truly a big picture view that you've got to take, because even if you take care of one particular hazard, if you haven't identified and manage the others, you can still put yourself at significant risk there. So what else, did we miss anything about hand injuries, whether it be a traumatic injury from a hand to wrist, or an injury from awkward postures or prolonged postures? Is there something else that we want to touch on here before we kind of get towards the end of our podcast?

    Al Brown: [01:01:45] Right. Yeah, I guess just the final thing, because I think we've handled this really well. I think we've covered most topics and, you know, think of contact stresses in the hand. You know, we [01:02:00] never talked about, you know, there's different things. De Quervain's tenosynovitis pain on the back side of the thumb, you know, that's created by we'll see with scissors, manual scissors, where you're constantly opening the scissors back up to create the cut, that lifting the thumb is not really made well to pull open, you know, abductor's pull the thumb back to open the scissors up and they make scissors now that have a spring-loaded that will self open. So you have to do is grip and close to your power grip. So that's where your most efficient ganglion cysts, where you get some pressure on a tendon or a trigger finger. To a certain extent, you know, you have sleeves those remember those long tendons. I talked about the go to the tip of your finger. They actually pass under sleeves, so they stay. So these tendons don't bow out away from your finger. It looks like your skin's blown away. These little sheets hold the tendon close to the finger. Well, if you inflame one of those tendons and now it's bigger and it's on one side of these this little loop, [01:03:00] and then when you close your finger, you kind of force it through, it'll click and then you notice that your finger is stuck down and you have to kind of grab it and pull it back up to move that thick intended. It's a lot of times you're getting a contact stressor or one of the tools in your hand by putting a lot of pressure on that tendon, which creates the enlarged, you know, the large tendons. So now it's bulbous and can't go through that sheet. So again, you look at padding proper grip size, shifting hands to kind of avoid some of those things, you know, cortisone injections, dental surgery, you know, those kinds of things you want to avoid if you can. But again, that's proper tooling. You know, looking at contact stressors, neutral posture, you know, efficiency of what you're doing reduces those risks.

    Peter Koch: [01:03:48] I think you put your finger right on that last piece. Absolutely. No I think that's awesome. And I think a great thing to leave [01:04:00] us with is, you know, you don't want to get to the point where surgery is necessary. Like they talk about oh well I'm going to have carpal tunnel surgery I'm going to be fine. Well, you might have carpal tunnel surgery, but the rest of that sentence is false. You're not going to be fine, because if you haven't changed, what put you in that condition in the first place, you're going to go right back to it before. So, you know, looking at all those parts of the workplace that so what is neutral for me. Right. So when I work at this place, what is neutral? How do I keep how do I hold my body? And then how does the job put me outside of neutral? How much do I have to lift? How often do I have. To do that and then work backwards towards how do I reduce the stress on my body and there's multiple ways to do that, we talked about using gloves, utilizing the correct tool, supporting those tools properly in a way where I don't have to hold onto them all the time. I don't have to pick them up all the time. But there's other ways to manage that, too. If [01:05:00] the workplace can't be adjusted, maybe that's work rotation. So I'm not going to do the same job over and over and over and over and over and over and over again throughout the entire day. I can change the amount of times that I go through the cycle in the day and increase the amount of rest so that I can move more oxygenated blood and pulse, some of those byproducts of work away from the muscles and the tendons and I can stay more healthy.

    Al Brown: [01:05:27] You know, you're talking about root cause to a certain extent, your sort of covering root cause or if you go back and try to figure out the root cause, that's probably the most important. You know, some of the most success we've had is to, you know, as a physical therapist, I can start treating a wrist, you know, with whatever my tools are. But if I never go back and address the root cause, I'll never change the problem, because once the person feels better, they're going to go back doing the job that probably created it. I think of a welder that I was dealing with once back many years ago, and they had to weld [01:06:00] around a corner and it was very hard for them to see. And actually our senior vice president in lost control. I worked with him in a different work environment, and he was able to create an offset welding device so the person didn't have to do that. And then we actually went back to a different department and they could weld this thing before. So the worker no longer had to put their hand in that awkward position. So there's an example of addressing the root cause. I also deal with office workers sometimes that we can look at all the ergonomics, correct them, and they're still having problems with tingling in their fingers. And I will always ask the question, when you go to bed at night, you know, where are your hands and do you curl them up and they'll go, Yeah, I do. And I go, you can't do that. Because when you when you make a fist and you curl it up like it's a fetal position, you actually are compressing the median nerve and you won't necessarily feel it until you move your hands. And then you go, oh, my hands are asleep. So, you know, there's an unconscious behavior that's not [01:07:00] even part of the work environment, but still contributing to the problem and ongoing cause. So until you address those root causes, the hand symptoms don't go away.

    Peter Koch: [01:07:09] So let's talk about resources here. And you had mentioned it early on, but that we have a tool called E Ergo that employers can access. And so why don't you talk a little bit about how E Ergo works and how employers can use that tool to help search for a root cause and maybe look for solutions?

    Al Brown: [01:07:27] Mm hmm. Sure. Pete E Ergo is a is a virtual tool. It is. It can be used in a variety of ways as our consultants get back out on the road post covid and on sites. They can either the employer or our consultant can take some video of a job where they see some awkward wrist hand postures or might be a go back to your loss runs where you know, where your losses are and go play with a lot of hand injuries in this area and you gather some photo or [01:08:00] video of that. Typically, video works the best of a job cycle and you try to get three or four job cycles so we can see what the unconscious behavior is. It's funny when you first have a camera and you set up, people are very understanding and neutral and you give them time five to ten minutes, then eventually that camera kind of disappears and they go back to their normal work behavior. But we get to see that and we can analyze it. You can send that in to us. We can analyze it and get you back some insight as to what might be causing some of the problems. And we look at it from a physiological standpoint, you know, human behavior standpoint, tooling and offer up suggestions or recommendations that have worked maybe in other locations, in other industries and kind of share those with you. And that's in the manufacturing environment. It's typically video in the office environment. It's more static. It can be photos. As a matter of fact, it's been a very valuable tool during this work from home time where [01:09:00] we can't go into a person's home to analyze the ergonomics. But we get folks that can take these five photos on us and then we can even have a virtual meeting like this. And, you know, we can look at their workstation in sort of a virtual way and make and oftentimes solve the problem. So this E Ergo tool has been great. If you if you have a safety consultant with us and you can certainly ask them about it, they can guide you through it. But it's a great way for us to try to help you solve some of your ergonomic issues.

    Peter Koch: [01:09:38] Yeah, it has been a good tool. I know some of my policyholder's that I work with have used it before and they've used it in two ways. One, they've used it from a post pain standpoint, like an injury has occurred or someone is expressing discomfort and they're taking pictures or video. And then in other cases we're doing it from [01:10:00] a like a almost a new process set up, like we're setting up a new process. Here's the area. Here's where things are. We're going to do a move. So let's talk about what's not so good and good in these in these areas. So they'll send some of those photos that I know in the past years, your team has provided some recommendations that have been excellent in injury prevention on the forefront, not so much the not on the back end like the injury has prevented injury from. Happening in the first place, so it's another way, I think, to think about that E Ergo tool, not just from a post injury prevention, but a from a pre work injury prevention standpoint.

    Al Brown: [01:10:37] We just we just did that. We actually looked at some video where a company is in Maine and they're going to be locating to another state, you know, keeping the company in Maine, but expanding to another state. And they said we want to not repeat the mistakes we may have made here or we'd like to improve operations, probably to improve upon the ergonomics. What do you see that we might incorporate in this location? And we went [01:11:00] through that process with them. So, yeah, that was that was a nice use of the tool because, again, it's trying to, you know, fit the work to the worker, eliminate those risks and exposures on the front side.

    Peter Koch: [01:11:14] Yeah, that's great. Good. awesome. So anything else that we need to cover as we talk about hands and wrist injuries? I think we have we've grasped most of it today, I believe.

    Al Brown: [01:11:26] And there it is again.

    Peter Koch: [01:11:29] Had to.

    Al Brown: [01:11:30] You put you put your finger on it buddy.

    Peter Koch: [01:11:32] Right on. Well Al, I really appreciate you being here today and talking to us about hand and wrist injuries. So thanks for really sharing your expertise with us. Again, I appreciate that very much.

    Al Brown: [01:11:42] Thanks. It's always a pleasure.

    Peter Koch: [01:11:45] So thanks again for joining us. And to all of our listeners out there, thank you very much for joining us today. Today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, we've been speaking about ergonomics and hand and wrist injuries with Al Brown PT and director of ergonomics at [01:12:00] MEMIC. If you have any questions or I'd like to hear more about our particular topic on our podcast, email me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show notes that MEMIC.com/podcast where you can find additional resources, links to other podcasts with Al, as well as our entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for our Safety Net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates. And if you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it if you took a few minutes to review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whatever podcast service that you found us on. And if you've already done that, thanks, because it really helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing this show with a business associate friend or family member that you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Kotch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.

    1 hr 14 min
  • Industrial Athletes with Al Brown and Clayton Cartwright

    Workers today face many physical challenges, from a demanding pace to heavy loads and static postures. While the demands may not be at the same level as a professional athlete, a certain level of fitness and preparation is necessary for any worker to stay healthy or recover if an injury does occur.

    Athletes at all levels benefit from functional movement training and proactive prevention that comes from the athletic training model. If work can be thought of as an athletic process and the worker as an industrial athlete, then workplace safety can benefit as well.

    On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, I speak with Al Brown, MEMIC's Director of Ergonomics and Clayton Cartwright, Safety Management Consultant about the Industrial Athlete and how the athletic training model can be used to maintain and improve worker health and safety.

    Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch. So in the world of workers, there has been a long history of people doing physical jobs, non-physical jobs and also injuries over time, we've seen people get` injured doing really anything. It could be sitting at a desk. It could be doing a lot of manual material handling. It could be working in a foundry. It can be working in a construction space. It could be working in the retail area or hospitality or health care. So injuries happen across the board. And also, as we're starting to look at our workers, they're doing a lot of physical things, but they're sometimes those physical things aren't so obvious. So when we look at physical things, we might look at our athletic areas and our sports teams, whether it be a high school sports team, a college sports team or a professional sports team. And we see injuries there as well. We almost [00:01:00] expect an injury once in a while from those athletes because of the work, quote unquote, that they're doing. But we want to connect those two things together, because if we can see our workers as an athlete, we may actually be able to help them manage not only the load that they have to deal with on a regular basis, but also if they do get injured, to look at them as an athlete and treat them as we might treat an athlete as well. Well, on the line with me today is Al Brown P.T and MEMIC's director of ergonomics and Clayton Cartwright P.T and safety management consultant here with MEMIC Al and Clayton. Great to have you on the podcast today.

    Al Brown: [00:01:39] It's great to be here, Pete, thanks.

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:01:41] Thanks, Pete. Thanks for having me.

    Peter Koch: [00:01:42] Fantastic. So it's great to have you both on today. And before we get started, let's get to know you a little bit better and tell our listeners a little bit about yourselves. So Al, you've been on the podcast before and let's start with you. Tell me about how you came to be interested in the worker as an industrial athlete.

    Al Brown: [00:01:58] Thanks, Pete. Yeah, actually, [00:02:00] I started my life out as an athletic trainer. I was a graduate of Penn State University and got to interact with a lot of their athletes, the football team and the soccer team, and then went on to be an athletic trainer, junior out of college in Huntingdon, Pennsylvania. And then from there was actually where I got to work with a professional team, the Los Angeles Dodgers, down in Vero Beach, and then from there on to physical therapy school and became a physical therapist and from that foundation of an athletic trainer and then becoming a physical therapist and working in the orthopedic world, working in worker's comp, began to make sense to me how I used to deal with the athletes in those settings and how I was dealing with injured workers in these new settings. So it made sense to me. It all kind of came together and it has been part of my philosophy since my beginnings [00:03:00] in this world.

    Peter Koch: [00:03:01] I didn't realize that you had done some work as an athletic trainer with sports teams before. I've known most of your history, but that's a nugget that I really didn't know before today. So thanks for sharing that.

    Al Brown: [00:03:14] I'm older than you think, Pete. You know, I'm older than dirt, so I've been doing a lot of things, but I only disclose dribbles of it every so often, you know,

    Peter Koch: [00:03:24] Teases out with it. That's OK.

    Al Brown: [00:03:26] Yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Peter Koch: [00:03:28] All right, Clayton. So this is your first time on the podcast, and you're somewhat new to MEMIC as well, but you've had a ton of experience working with athletes before you came to MEMIC. So tell us about your experience and how you came to see the worker as an industrial athlete.

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:03:43] Sure. So, you know, very similar to Al is my undergraduate studies were in the athletic training world and I went to the University of Pittsburgh, where, again, we worked with a lot of the sports teams and just so happened that our [00:04:00] university had a contract with the Pittsburgh Steelers. And I was able to, you know, fortunately enough for me, was able to land that position and did a season long internship with them that year. Amazing experience. And, you know, from there, it was kind of the same path. I went to P.T school, took that information that I had gathered as an athletic trainer. And then when I graduated P.T school and got into the orthopedic world, similar to Al, you know, I started making those comparisons to the, you know, worker's comp patients that I was treating, what they were going through, what types of settings they were in, and really comparing that to the athletes that I was seeing or had seen, you know, as an athletic training student. So very similar to Al. And again, it just kind of all made sense and put the puzzle pieces together, so to speak.

    Peter Koch: [00:04:54] Yeah, that's cool. And I think it's a really interesting path to take. And obviously, I've never [00:05:00] been an athletic trainer. I'm not a physical therapist. Played sports all my life and that that experience actually, as far as I got to look at injured workers before I came to MEMIC as a risk manager or as a patroller, as I would respond to injured workers at the ski area, it was interesting for me to bring in that experience as an athlete and look at some of those injuries, whether they be coming from the Hill as a ski instructor or maybe a lift mechanic or a lift operator, or I would see them in the office or someplace else in the hospitality. So let's break that open a little bit more about why we want to look at the worker as an industrial athlete. So let's talk a little bit about that. And why is it why is it good to be able to see them as it industrial athletes and make some connections to athletics and some of the work that gets done out [00:06:00] there in the field?

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:06:01] Sure. So I think, you know, when we look at them separately, you tend to see a lot of similar movement patterns. You know, they're doing repetitive type motions. You know, the stresses that they put on their body can be very similar in that regard. So, again, it's that comparison between even though we look at it differently, I think it's a good comparison to make when you're looking at them together like that. And one of our conversations we had had where, you know, there's so many different sports, but there's also so many different careers and job paths. And so that's where we really can make a connection as well. You know, sports have their own unique injuries per sport, sort of sports specific, you know, and you kind of look at that as a job site, job specific or site specific injuries. So, you know, there's a lot of similarities between the workforce and that sports athletic [00:07:00] population.

    Peter Koch: [00:07:01] That's cool. So can you maybe break it down a little bit more? Like is there an example that we can use maybe a factory worker or someone who is a package handler and maybe another sports analogy that we can make those two connections and see how those moving patterns might be similar, you know, and also how those moving patterns may create an injury as well.

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:07:28] Yeah. So, you know, let's take, for example, maybe a swimmer, a swimmer is a lot of overhead movement patterns, you know, and then they have to do kick turns. And depending on how they've been coached, they may kick turn in the same direction the same time, or they maybe have the ability to switch. That's a different conversation. But, you know, then we can maybe take somebody that you wouldn't think would be an athlete, maybe like a mail delivery, you know, person who's driving. You know, they are maybe constantly reaching or turning to the left [00:08:00] to open a mailbox. So they're constantly pulling open a door. And it's just that repeated motion day in, day out for, you know, eight hours a day. So you're just seeing those repeated motions that are in a certain movement pattern. And that's where we get those repetitive stress sort of injuries that we tend to see with repeated motions like that.

    Peter Koch: [00:08:22] Yeah, again, really interesting. And I like that analogy of the swimmer, because it is I mean, if you think about if I'm doing a five hundred or if I'm doing a one hundred or whatever that is and I'm doing the backstroke. Kraul Butterfly doesn't matter what it is, the repetitious nature of the shoulder circle that has to happen is just constant. And then the forces placed on that. But it's different, too, because as a professional swimmer or even as a college level swimmer or high school, you're going to have a coach that helps to work you through some of those processes. And they understand the warm up and they understand the stretching and they understand good movement [00:09:00] patterns. And they understand that when you start to do these things, that you could be on the cusp of an injury. So they're going to adjust for you, but the worker in industry doesn't have that. And so I think if we if we start to look at the worker a little more as an athlete. Maybe we can adjust how they will approach their own job and maybe how they or as a supervisor or a manager may be able to make that connection so that we can stem off an injury, whether it be by job change or by a behavior change. So one of those two things. So neat connection there, Clayton, neat connection. And I'm going to throw this out to both of you and maybe, Al, you have something in there as well. Can you, is there any statistics at all that are out there that that talk about companies that have done some studies around the work patterns that have happened and maybe things that they've [00:10:00] done to be successful in changing patterns, much like a coach would change if they're looking at their team or their athletes individually?

    Al Brown: [00:10:10] It's interesting. I see three types of injury or three kinds of injuries. You see the trauma and we have trauma in the workforce. You know, the sprained ankle, sprained ankle. In sports, you have the overuse which you guys were talking about, which is a biomechanical repeated activity, which we will see that. And then you have sort of the fatigue kind of injuries, those things that occur, the, you know, the end of the day or at the end of the game or, you know, when someone's really starting to get tuckered out. So there is those parallels that you see. One of the downsides is with the athlete or one of the upsides to the athlete. It's sort of a natural selection process. And as those skill levels in those athletic levels continue to proceed towards professional, they bring [00:11:00] some genetics along with them and they also bring a team of people that keep them healthy. Unfortunately, in the workforce, we don't always have that and we certainly don't have that team that sort of follows them along. And I think industry's beginning to discover the value of that, that we need to look at those.

    Al Brown: [00:11:20] And to your question about have industries looked at that, I think there was a study done by UPS and it was in Northern California. You can look it up online. It was around 2005. And they had one of their they have five or 50 districts. And there was one district there that was the worst in terms of injuries, injury rate, frequency, severity. And so they took it upon themselves to focus a sports medicine model in that region, which included stretching, strengthening, awareness, education. And [00:12:00] within two years, they went from being fiftieth in the region, the worst to number one. And it was simply by changing those behaviors and changing the focus of care to more of a sort of athletic training model. It's, you know, let's be right there. Let's look at the root cause. Let's try to figure out the biomechanics of some of the problems and solve those, but then also incorporate the stretching, the strengthening, the balance, the core strength, those kinds of things so that you made a better industrial athlete. Cool study.

    Peter Koch: [00:12:38] Yeah, cool. And that's interesting. Just by utilizing that athletic training viewpoint in in how they're making changes or how they're viewing the worker and the tasks that they're doing, you can make a big change. And I think we're going to get into that. I know we're going to get into that a little bit more in the podcast as we start talking about some of the things that they did in and how [00:13:00] they actually implemented that athletic training model. But Clayton, maybe I can have you explore this a little bit more to about what that athletic training model kind of is. And talk a little bit about your experience with the sports teams and how you brought that into your PT career and what that athletic training treatment model might be when you're working with an athlete.

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:13:24] Yes, so, you know, just based off of, again, my experiences as a clinician and going through the athletic training to the party, know then eventually into some fitness stuff that I really enjoy doing. You know, I kind of break it into sort of three parts. Right. So that athletic training model is really that observational piece where you're there on the sideline, you're watching games, you're watching practice. And if you see an athlete go down, you've observed that injury. And just through education, you know, you can start to put it together, you [00:14:00] know, of maybe some of the injuries that could have happened for that. You know, I you know, I'm a big football fan. So sitting on the couch watching football, you know, if I see something, I see a play or player go down. I've done it so many times with my wife, I'll say I bet you that's an actor. Next thing you know, ACL tear. So, you know, it's just that observational piece. You kind of learn it through observation and education. And then, you know, going to the PT side is more of that treatment aspect, getting into the treatment side of it. So back to your question. As far as the athletic training approach, it's really being able to identify it early and get that early intervention that is so, so crucial. You know, and there is a lot of research out there to support that early intervention helps with long term outcomes. And again, I think this is something that we're going to dive into a little bit more during the podcast. But, you [00:15:00] know, that's kind of where I see that athletic training model fitting in to that to the workforce. Early intervention, you know, address it as soon as you can.

    Al Brown: [00:15:11] Yeah. You know, it was funny because I have to laugh. Funny little story. I love football, too, so it's great. Same thing. You sit there, you watch, you observe. You know what we were talking about different types of jobs. And one year at Penn State, it was my job to cover the state final cross-country meet on the golf course, which goes around the perimeter of the golf course. And they said, oh, so you're thinking what could happen here? I had more athletes go down during that event, couldn't observe them, but it was we need an athletic trainer over at mile two we have someone that's down. You know, we got someone down over one mile one. I probably put in as many miles that day, the cross-country athletes. But again, I had to speculate. It was more [00:16:00] hyperventilating. It was those types of things or was an Achilles injury. So I didn't get to observe. But again, in your mind, my first perception was not going to be much going on here. And then it was like, I have a whole new respect for that type of thing. So the athletic training model came in many different shapes, sizes and flavors, as do you know, industries. So you do have to understand your industry, understand what you might anticipate, but then you have to go and collect and see the data and understand it and then you can make an effective change. So, yeah, same thing. Same thing.

    Peter Koch: [00:16:34] That's interesting. I have a similar experience as a ski patroller, so it's one of the mountains that I work at here. We have a big cross-country following and we actually had the Chevy Nationals happen from a cross-country standpoint. And when they come, there's hundreds and hundreds of elite college athletes that are coming and will have a similar piece as a patroller. We have to either respond [00:17:00] to the injury that occurs and it could be a traumatic injury from a fall or it could be a medical issue whether it's hyperventilating or it could be a frostbite piece. Some of the patrollers that I that I work with don't have a cross-country experience. So they're treating them from the perspective of, say, an alpine event or an alpine injury or an injury that might happen from downhill skiing instead of cross-country skiing, where as the cross-country athlete, I've done cross-country myself. I actually had one of the coaches there. And we're looking at the particular individual as we're coming in. They're being treated by another patroller. The patroller is on one tactic and thought process about what the injury is where because I know more and the coach knows a lot about what's happening with that particular athlete, they're able to weave that experience into to understand what's going on with that person a little more naturally and then be able to direct care [00:18:00] a little bit more accurately.

    Peter Koch: [00:18:02] So the value of being either there to observe or to be able to observe prior to the injury happening. So not just watching the worker as they get injured or seeing it happen, but actually watching and gaining data about what's going on in the industry on the shop floor with your workers is a key part to really understanding what's happening, so that's a really connective piece that we want to we want to bring back into our model there. Let's take the injury that happens to the worker or let's actually bring it to the athletic side to start with and then we'll move it over to the worker. So when someone does get injured, they're going to experience some sort of pain and everybody experiences pain differently. But we've had conversations about this, too. And as the provider, whether you're the athletic trainer or the PT or you might even be the [00:19:00] coach at the time when the person gets there, how you approach or how you communicate with that worker or the athlete about pain is a pretty critical part in how the individual might experience their recovery over time. So could you talk a little bit about how that initial conversation and the ongoing conversation with the athlete about their pain levels can help or hinder the actual recovery?

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:19:27] Yes, so an area that I really started to kind of gain some interest in was this whole concept of pain science, which is really a really fascinating topic. And so what I started to learn from that process is that communication piece. You know, when we approach somebody and start asking them about their pain and what they're feeling. There are so many variables that goes into that on an individual basis. It could be their prior experiences. I mean, there is just a wide variety of [00:20:00] things that have impacted their life that could amplify or decrease the amount of pain that they're experiencing. So one thing that that really kind of stands out is how I started to approach asking patients, athletes about their pain experiences, you know, instead of always asking them, you know, we hear the standard rate, your pain on a scale from zero to 10 like that was you know, you ask that pretty much on a daily basis over.

    Peter Koch: [00:20:25] How much does it hurt? Right. Because that's the first question that happens, right? If someone comes to you and they're limping. How much does that hurt or are you in pain? And it starts the conversation. It's almost a conversation starter. So interesting. So keep going. Sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt you.

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:20:38] No, no. I mean, that's exactly it is. But then what happens is, is that is our go to question every time. What's your pain, what's your pain, you know, so if you are continuingly to ask somebody what their pain level is, well, now what you've done is you started to make them just think about it more. And [00:21:00] so what we see and what we know is pain is processed in the brain. Right. So let's take, for example, touching a hot stove. Right. The stimulus is the hot stove. That information goes to the brain. Your brain says it's a threat. So I'm going to produce pain to let you know that you shouldn't do that again. And so what happens is when you start to constantly ask somebody about their pain levels, well, now their pain sort of increases because they're constantly thinking about it and they think that it should maybe hurt more than what they're telling you. And so pain is subjective to the person. Right. But you sort of see I've seen patterns when I was practicing as a therapist where pain levels would slowly kind of creep up for some people.

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:21:51] So it was it was very interesting. So my approach then started to be more asking functional type questions or questions [00:22:00] that would maybe help build them up a little more. For example, I might say something like, hey, well, tell me what something that you could do this week that you weren't able to do last week. So I'm not really directly asking them about their pain. I'm asking them more about function. And so in their head, if they're if they hadn't been thinking about it that way and they can say, oh, well, hey, I was able to do my daily walk for two miles and, you know, a little bit of discomfort, but it was I could do it, you know, automatically that that sets them up for success. That's a victory for them. And so if you can kind of help point them in that direction versus always asking them about pain, you know, I just felt like it was a much better approach to their care. And it seemed to it seemed to really help with recovery process. So it's very interesting.

    Al Brown: [00:22:50] Pain is one of those things that's kind of cool. I mean, it's cool. That's kind of weird sounding. But, you know, going back to the athletic training world, [00:23:00] when you'd have someone that went down and they're writhing in pain out on the field, my approach, the first thing was to just calm them down before I started to assess, just to get them to understand or get them let them explain to me what happened and then try to get them to realize all those other parts of your body aren't hurt. You can kind of let those relax a little bit. Let's just look at the knee, if that's what just got hurt. And once they realized there was a calming effect there, you could move forward. Sort of same thing in the PT world. You know, I'd have folks that would come in that might have an injured shoulder. They would have this fixed hand posture trying to move things around and they wouldn't move their hand. And I go, What's up with your hand? And they go, Why? And I go, you're moving it around like it's injured. And I said, just open and close your fingers. And I go, Oh, I said, Yeah, you can do that. It's kind of an illness posture. And part of that is subconscious. Part of it is unconscious. And [00:24:00] you can get into other problems because they stop moving that.

    Al Brown: [00:24:03] And if we were to focus on pain all the time, you probably would go round and round just like Clayton said. You know, there's situations where it begins to escalate. So function. I'm a real fan of focusing on function in terms of looking at, you know, work related activities. It's great in the in the sports world, it's pretty easy to. Not easy, but there's a logical progression back towards the athletic event in the work world, sometimes we get into this light duty and, you know, on light duty, off light duty. What does that mean? Where I'd like to look at it more because words matter. I like to look at it more as transitional work. And when you take that functional model and you use that word transitional work, it works much better because you are transitioning the person back to that job task. But you do it by looking at function like it, Clayton said. What can you do today that you couldn't do [00:25:00] last week? Oh, I can. You know, it doesn't hurt to hold this tool anymore and. OK, good. Let's you know, and then progress accordingly. And for the employer that works a whole bunch better, too, because light duty on and off is like a light switch. Either you're on it or you're off it.

    Al Brown: [00:25:16] And that can bring psychological issues that if you're about to say to someone, you're off light duty now, they're going to go, oh my God. But I still have you know, I still have issues where if you're transitioning, doesn't matter if you just kind of move along that timeline and back to function. And you might here's my ergo pitch. You might have to modify that job, but that modification might be a permanent improvement to the job, which will probably talk about a little bit later. But so that functional approach is huge and one that was ingrained in our the one thing we didn't I didn't mention earlier, but I worked on site in industry for a number of years, which was more the athletic training model. So I was at the playing field for the for the [00:26:00] workers. Not every company has that luxury, but that was huge to be able to walk out and actually see the job and make the modifications. So 100 percent pro functional approach because it really does address the pain but doesn't you don't get into a direct conversation about it because, you know, like I think I explained to you guys earlier, I could hit all our hands with a hammer. And Clayton might wince a little bit. You might not you go, is that the best you got? I'd probably

    Peter Koch: [00:26:31] I might whine. All right.

    Al Brown: [00:26:32] Yeah, I might cry for the next three days. And it was the same force, but we all perceive the pain differently. So, you know, it is it is truly it's all those past experiences that help determine our pain response.

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:26:47] And I think that that was a great comment you made about the calming effect of what we think of that approach and the communication style. And so something that I saw a lot, too, is, you know, people [00:27:00] bringing imaging studies, x rays, MRIs, you know, and it might say on there you have mild, mild degeneration at X, Y, Z, a certain disk or whatever. And what they would see is, oh, I have degeneration in my back, but they don't see mild, you know, those key terms that, you know, that degenerative processes is a part of the aging process. You know, so sometimes you would just explaining that to them would help to take some of that tension off of them. Right. Because if they're thinking, oh, my gosh, degeneration in my back, oh, I'm going to need surgery and all of a sudden their head, you know, we've all done it with certain things. You know, you just start compounding the oh, my gosh, this is the end of the world kind of thing. But if you have somebody who can at least sort of talk you off the ledge, you know, for lack of a better term, you know, that calming effect of being able to approach somebody like that does, again, huge impact with how we communicate with and it's the same in the [00:28:00] workforce to the athletes. So I think that's a great point.

    Al Brown: [00:28:04] I used to torture those folks sometimes because they come in and they go, I got this degenerate disc disease and, you know, it would be a 50 year old. And I go, well, if you didn't, you'd be a genetic freak, for God's sakes, I'd like to know how the heck you don't have any. I said, welcome to Gravity. We all live in gravity. Eventually things are going to wear out. That's why we end up back as dirt later on. So, of course, you've got some arthritic changes in your body. That's part of the aging process. So I try to diffuse it that way if I can.

    Peter Koch: [00:28:35] I think it's always good to try that and thinking about it from the functional transition or transitioning to one function to another, function to another, or progressing in function is another. I guess a better way to look at that versus pain management is for lack of a better term, much more functional way of dealing with whether it be an injury on the athletic field or to an athlete [00:29:00] on the athletic field or the industrial athlete, because that's the whole intent of it. Right. We want to get people back to what they were doing. And if you're getting paid to play football, you're getting paid to play a particular sport. Doesn't matter what it is, you're going to want to get back to functions somehow and talking about function as what could you do versus what you can't do and what do you want to be able to do. And then moving someone towards that, I think is a is a great way to do it. Instead of saying, OK, we're just going to manage your pain through whatever process we want your pain to be an eight so that you can do this well, it might still be an eight. So we're going to look at how you actually move through that pain or in that pain, and we'll figure out a way for you to rest or work to the point where you can start recovering and getting better. Clayton, in some of our conversations, there were a couple of different things that you had brought up that said principal. [00:30:00] And can you talk a little bit about that and how maybe that works towards that pain management process in the transition back to function?

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:30:08] The human body is pretty incredible, you know, and it is designed to heal itself, you know? So I think that's really important for people to hear and understand. And so what the SAID principle is or stands for really is specific adaptations to impose demands, fancy terminology. But really what that means is that the stresses that we put on our body, our body is going to adapt to that. So I think we had talked about an example of that would be, say, an ankle sprain. You know, what I might do with that person first is we might just have them walk and see if they can tolerate that. Do that for a little while. OK, let's try a little bit of light jogging so we get the jogging doing well right now. We're going to progress to running straight lines. They do well. All right. Now, maybe some cutting and pivoting work start to do well with that. Right now, we're going [00:31:00] to get back into sports specific training or work specific training again to allow that person to ask an athlete or a worker to see their successes and see that they are progressing in the right direction. So but it's important, though, that you understand you have to put stresses on the body. You always hear the RICE principle, right rest ice compression elevation, which to an extent. Can be good, but again, it's very early on in the process. At a very early stage. You need to start to put the body under some tension, you know, in order to make that progress back to the level that they're at. So a principle that I would think about often, you know, especially when I was in the clinic, you know, treating patients so and that you're treating patients from a work perspective. And my athletes, again, it's I looked at them pretty much the same.

    Peter Koch: [00:31:55] Yeah. And that goes, I think Al, to your point before that, that the [00:32:00] idea of light duty as being that kind of that light switch. Right. So I'm on light duty. I'm off light duty doesn't actually provide for that principle to put stresses on the body in a measured time or at through measure time in order to generate healing. And you've talked about this Al in other podcasts before, kind of going towards what Clayton was talking about, about the RICE principle. If the treatment is rest, ice compression elevation and that's all you do, what happens to you? Right. So I'll throw that to you also, if that's what we do, what happens if all we ever do is rest the injury?

    Al Brown: [00:32:39] Yeah, I can draw an analogy or comparison here between the sports world to let's just look at what an athlete goes and participates. They do some, they do different things. They elevate their tolerance level and they do that through strength training, endurance training, flexibility, you know, in the world of strength [00:33:00] training, just to understand the physiology, you go in and you do something to Claytons point that sort of the SAID principle you've got to create. You know, you go in and you lift a certain weight and it'll cause some tearing down of the tissue. And one of two things happens. You either get injured or you your body adapts, but it takes probably about 48 hours, 24 to 48 hours for your body to recover from that if you make an appropriate inroad in on the body physically. So you sort of tear the body down and then it gets stronger. So you need that recovery period. And then you come back maybe on a Monday, on a Wednesday, you come back again and do it again with a lot of workers. They don't do a lot of other things other than their work activities. So that is sort of their tolerance level. So unfortunately, tolerance and work activity are sort of the same line with the athlete. Usually there's a tolerance or a fitness level that's above where their exposure level is. So there is a buffer in there. [00:34:00] So the worker, it's a little trickier in that if they have they work overtime one day or they have extra packages or the poor U.P.S.

    Al Brown: [00:34:09] folks that have been in FedEx have just been shipping more stuff than they ever have. They're going to bump above that activity line. So either if the industry's good and they sort of gradually progress them into that, they may adapt. And again, that fitness line and work line are going to follow each other. This company in Northern California took a more proactive approach and said, let's get that wellness line, fitness line way above the work line and see if that helps. And sure enough, it created a buffer to protect their workers. So it takes a lot of effort to do that. So you can see how if an industry just is sort of a rice type of person will just do first aid kind of and never do anything more than that. You will always have to be cognizant of those moments [00:35:00] where activity goes over and above the overtime that harder work. And it's even down to like accounting, like month ends. Someone sits and puts twelve hours into the day at a desk and all of a sudden there goes my arm first and arm hurt. Well, there it is again. You know, you've exceeded that tolerance level. So when you're looking at things and you're looking at said principle, sometimes if it's a fairly passive company, that line of wellness in that line of work are pretty much the same levels. So.

    Peter Koch: [00:35:37] Let's take a quick break so I can tell you about our E Ergo resource that can be used to help solve ergonomic challenges at your workplace, sometimes contacting, contracting with and scheduling an ergonomics or occupational health nurse for an onsite evaluation doesn't really fit with our Just-In-Time workflows in a competitive economy. Fixing the problem right now is essential, [00:36:00] and improving worker comfort and efficiency are key components to ongoing success. So free to our policyholders. MEMICs E Ergo tool can help you overcome ergonomic challenges. With just five quick photos or a short 30 second video and a brief explanation of what is being shown. You can send us the critical demands and essential functions within the work tasks once received. Our ergonomics team can identify risks and exposures and provide reasonable suggestions for ergonomic improvement within just a few short days. Start the E Ergo process by logging into the MEMIC safety director at www.youtube.com/Workplace Safety. Now let's get back to today's episode.

    And it becomes challenging then, especially if they're in that same level, like you said, to try to increase the stresses, to be able to have that buffer. And that is that's a tricky part. But I think recognizing [00:37:00] that and to the point of towards the athletic training model of being there on the shop floor, being there with the workers to see what's going on, have your finger on the pulse of the activity level or the business levels to see where that might lay, might be able to help stem off some of that stuff.

    Peter Koch: [00:37:21] But even on the injury side, like post injury, like if you never if you never move the injured part, I mean, just think about it. If you've ever been injured in any of our listeners, if you've ever been injured before and you're just coming out of the cast from a broken whatever it is, you know, the first couple of days coming out of that cast is really super challenging. And all you really want to do is sit down and do nothing. But if you sit down and do nothing and just rest it, you're never going to get past the atrophy that has happened from being still in that cast for so long. And then to your point, before Clayton, your body will adapt. So in another [00:38:00] way, your body has adapted to that limb being stationary for a while and it's challenged other parts of your body. It might have challenged your gait. It might have challenged your hip posture. It might have challenged your shoulders. So all those things have to be looked at and adjusted and you can't do that unless you're moving. So I think movement in a in in a healing principle is pretty important. And that goes to looking at your providers that you're going to be engaging with as a workplace so that your occupational health providers need to understand that principle of bringing your individuals back to health through that transitional duty rather than just light duty on off switch like you had set out.

    Al Brown: [00:38:43] And that's part of the vetting process. As an employer, you need to go out and know who your Occ. Med providers are, because the family doc is great for family doctor things. But a lot of times they're approached because they may not be intimate with the job tasks. [00:39:00] And the work test at the bed may be, you know, familiar with my er to the side of conservative and say, go back to rice. And when we rested for a couple of weeks and see how it goes and now we start to create that illness behavior, it's the athlete that doesn't get back into play. You know, we're waiting. We're waiting. It's the MASH Army unit, you know, the mobile army surgical hospital. They did they learned early on that we've got to move that very close to the front lines, get folks healed and back and return them back, you know, as sad as that is. But that's it. Psychologically, it worked much better than to have them go so far back from the line. And then there's a barrier of return. Same thing with work, same thing with athletics. So it's important to kind of take that, you know, very proactive approach. And by your vetting process of looking at your provider, getting to understand, are they functionally focused, do they understand their job tasks? Is their goal to get that person [00:40:00] back to work? You know, so you're right. You're exactly right about that.

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:40:05] And that that communication piece is crucial. You know, I know we've talked and Al, you talked about your experiences about being actually on site, you know, within a company, but certainly understanding that not every business can certainly afford that on site provider to be there, you know, 24/7 or during hours of operation. So, look, you know, using your local community, there are PT clinics, a dime a dozen now, you know, I'm sure. And that's that vetting process. You know, you could even probably go out and find a provider that, you know, might possibly be able to come in and do some analysis with you or something along those lines. So it's important, I think, to also realize that there are providers out there and it is a little bit more of a proactive approach, but can certainly help you in the long run by identifying those key players, you know, that that you want to have on your side.

    Peter Koch: [00:40:58] Yeah, and that's a great lead. [00:41:00] And I think to start talking about the athletic training model for injury prevention as well. So we're starting to kind of merge those two. We've talked quite a bit about when an injury happens, how you talk to the injured worker about their pain, about their function or function versus pain and how we communicate with our providers. And now we're looking at helping or getting our providers to help us assess our workplace, not just from an A maybe an improvement after an injury occurs, but it could even be assessing the workplace to prevent injury in the first place. And I think some of that happened. It's obviously post injury. But with the NorCal study there, Al, that that UPS did made some. Changes using that athletic training model to help reduce injuries overall, so they combined the or used injuries as a I'm missing the word here.

    Al Brown: [00:41:57] So sort of a motivator. You know, kind [00:42:00] of the thing that affected change is they actually that was the motivator to effect change.

    Peter Koch: [00:42:06] So good. Yeah, that's a great point that it is the motivator. So they looked at their losses. They understood that they're in a place where they need to have some change happen. And then they implemented the model and made some. Made some.

    Al Brown: Adjustments

    Peter Koch :to address things as they could, based on that, they said not just the information, but I'm sure they had people come in and assess the workplace. So let's talk some about how we can use that injury or the athletic training model to manage injury prevention, reduce injuries in the first place.

    Al Brown: [00:42:40] I can tell you there's a couple industries that I've worked with that have done that there. You know, I'm sure they won't mind me using their name. L.L. Bean. It was, a very proactive, very much looking at design, talking to the industrial athlete about how can we best make the work environment fit them. As a matter of fact, thirty [00:43:00] eight years, 40 years ago, they actually created the first sit/ stand workstations, you know, which are very commonplace nowadays, probably popular over the last ten years. But they did it way ahead of time because they realized they were seeing more injuries in the phone center. So they actually created sit/stand workstations with the equipment they had at the time. Move fast forward. And you now see many of their checkout stations are fully adjustable. So if a different statured worker comes in, someone might be five one and there was a six two person there prior. They can adjust the workstation down electrically in the packing areas. They realize people are having wrist hand issues. So they actually started a strengthening program through gripping programs and they actually saw a reduction in their injuries. So that's that more said principle, like let's stimulate, but to do it proactively so we can increase that that fitness level or that wellness level above the work level.

    Al Brown: [00:43:59] You go [00:44:00] to a place like the Jackson Labs up in Bar Harbor and they're also in Farmington, Connecticut, and out in Sacramento, they actually have a simulated workplace that if someone is having issues, they actually demonstrate what they do at the workplace to see if biomechanically they're doing something that we can modify just biomechanically and change, like the runner that's got, you know, plantar fasciitis. And we might, through an orthotic or some taping is an industrial athlete, is an athlete, help with the biomechanics. So they look at the biomechanics, but then they also look at the ergonomics that that designed the designs. Really not that good. We need to maybe modify the design, too. So I've worked with different industries that have had that luxury to be at the front lines and have taken different approaches. And again, to Claytons Point, not everybody can afford to have that on site presence. But I have worked with industry where we've gone as MEMIC [00:45:00] onsite to help them to understand some of those nuances and to look at it through that athletic training model.

    Peter Koch: [00:45:08] Clayton, how about you? So how would you bring the athletic training model to bear on some of the maintenance? Maybe it's preventative maintenance or other tactics that the employer can use to help stem off injuries within the workplace?

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:45:21] Yeah, so finding that person who sort of understands the industry and I kind of take it back to that example I gave earlier with sitting on the couch watching a football game, you watch and you watch something happy. You say, oh, I think that's a blunt ACL tear. Well, if you have somebody who understands the business and what types of tests you're doing, that that person can certainly help maybe identify and be proactive in identifying those things like LL Bean. Al, you were saying for, for example, identifying those things that could potentially lead to an injury. Right. Because if [00:46:00] you don't correct the source that injured worker could go get treatment, get all better, 100 percent, come back and they're back into the same positions that they were in before and now you're back to square one. So it's having that proactive approach to be able to identify it. But also there is, I think, some onus on the workforce and the employee, you know, with just even you know, we talk about preventative maintenance type stuff, you know, at the professional level, you know, I was with the Steelers. I mean, those guys would spend a lot of money, you know, to massages, acupuncture. I mean, they would do everything they had plus there to provide treatments and go through rehab protocols and those things. And that's not necessarily within the realm of the traditional workforce. But there are things that you can certainly do outside of work. You know, instead of going home and sitting at the end of the day, you know, maybe you're [00:47:00] doing a walk or you have some type of strength training program or program that that you like to do. So you're trying to do that a couple of days a week to keep your body sort of in shape and in tune with what you want to complete it as far as the workers concerned. So some lifestyle choices, I think, is also a big a big area to focus on.

    Peter Koch: [00:47:25] Yeah. And I think the athletic training model can certainly help that. And as you're talking, what struck me was that we've been talking about the similarities between the worker and the athlete. I think a big difference, and especially when we start to look at injury prevention and what tools you can employ to protect the worker or the athlete. The biggest difference is from the athlete's standpoint, the sport's not going to change. You're not going to go into it thinking, all right, we're going to make football noncontact or we're going to make so you don't have to swing the tennis racket both ways or [00:48:00] you can only do something. The sport's not going to change. So the athlete has to adapt their body. Must adapt their body to the demands of the particular sport. As a worker, the job and we've seen this before in every industry, there are many aspects of the job that can change. And that goes to the maybe a discussion about the hierarchy of controls as we start to look at how do we manage the as you said before, Clayton, the threat to the particular industrial athlete. So the sports athlete, you're not going to change the sport. You've got to change the person or have to harden the athlete to the particular job as the worker. I think the place where we should start first is what you were alluding to before having someone come in. Or maybe you have the expertise right within your own your own business to assess the workspace, to see what changes we can [00:49:00] make. So can you maybe talk a little bit about that from the not so much the athletic training standpoint, but what's the benefit and where does that fit in with the hierarchy of controls and how does that manage injuries within the workplace?

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:49:14] So, you know, I think when we look at that hierarchy of controls, right, we're looking at things like eliminating hazards or coming up with engineering controls. So we're trying to really reduce the stress that the employee is putting on their bodies. Right. Because, again, if we go and we look at the athlete who maybe they have the luxury of taking some rest days after competition, right. Where the workforce doesn't. So that's where it becomes sort of critical to be able to reduce some of that loading in that stress on their bodies, you know, to reduce the risk of developing some type of injury on site. So I [00:50:00] think that is where, you know, we as MEMIC I think, really thrive is being able to help with that process. So. That's kind of the way that I look at it.

    Al Brown: [00:50:11] I'll give you some historical perspective, too. You know, I think I've been around a little longer than Clayton, you know, and that was just birth order. But I just had an interesting thought as he was talking. And it was about and let's just use football, think about the tools of football when football started. Think about did they wear helmets? They don't start with no, and then they said we're probably having some head injury, so we really need to. So then they created these leather things and put those on people's heads and then they said, boy, a lot of smashed noses. Maybe we ought to create a face mask, you know? And then it was the single bar and then it was the multiple bar. [00:51:00] And then people were get poked in the eyes. And now we've got plexiglass over the eyes and, you know, so and just think of just a helmet, not let alone I mean, just all the other pads have changed tremendously. And then you go to the industrial side and you go think of the first pick, something simple screwdriver, you know, and it was this linear thing that you put your hand on. You turned, you know, and you had to make sure you stayed in the slot and forearm pain, all kinds of discomfort. And then we had the inline electric screwdriver. And now we've got a pistol grip, you know. So again, I think function and form sort of change, but it's through reacting and looking at where are we seeing the injuries and how do we sort of prevent those from occurring. So humans have the same physiological limits they always have. You know, we haven't changed. I mean, we're changing a little bit, but actually I think we're getting a little weaker.

    Al Brown: [00:51:58] But for the most part, that physiology [00:52:00] has pretty much stayed the same. And we have gotten smarter. And what we tolerate is much less to I mean, you think about what coal miners used to go through and go, oh, we lost one today, you know, call HR and that was brutal. And now we don't tolerate that kind of stuff. So the laws have kind of pushed us in that direction and the care of human beings. So, you know, our mantra at MEMIC is I want you to I want, you know, when you I want you to go home from work feeling just as good as when you came in. You know, I don't want you to go home feeling pain and discomfort. So, you know, part of that solution process sometimes with industry is to help folks look with a different set of eyes and take that proactive approach and try to find maybe a change to find the exposure and risk and then try to address it might be through education, but it might also be through modification of the job and reengineering in the long run. You know, [00:53:00] you get a person that feels better. They're going to work better, less exhaustion. And at the end of the day, that company's going to have a better product because you don't have a fatigue, sore, achy worker trying to put the last not on the trailer light and does a poor job. And next thing you know, the consumer buys that trailer and the trailer lights falling off and it's well because of the bad ergonomics of the design. So it's a win win win. When you look at that whole that whole system,

    Peter Koch: [00:53:28] It's good to look at your history and look at the injuries and try to prevent it that way. But I think from again, looking at it from the athletic model, I want to be able to maintain my athlete in prime position or prime condition. So I'm going to do things with them and for them that are going to allow them to stay healthy. And I'm also going to then look at the workplace. From a functional design standpoint and [00:54:00] take into consideration the load, the frequency, the mechanics of the lift or the process that they have to go through in order to do that and think about it from a physical standpoint, how do I make this not so much easier, but how do I make this functional for them? Like we talked about function from a transition to function instead of looking at it from a pain standpoint. If I look at a job task from a how does the function of the job task fit in with the general function of a human being, I'm going to be much better suited to prevent injuries across the board than if I just look at it. From how many widgets do I get in the bucket at the end of the day or how many words can I type? I mean, you think about that from the perspective of typing. And when we went from an administrative assistant working, taking notes, handwritten notes to working on the typewriter, [00:55:00] which you had to take a break and move the carriage over to one side or the other, to an electric typewriter, to now a word processor. And we're seeing many, many, many more repetitive motion carpal tunnel type injuries from that perspective because technology changed. But we didn't look at how the function of the technology would affect the function of the human or interact with the function of the human. And I think that's a really key thing to consider as an employer. As I look at my business from an athletic training standpoint or look at my workers as athletes, if I have that perspective, it is like you said, it's a win going forward.

    Al Brown: [00:55:41] When I had the typewriter at least I had to go find the White-Out occasionally, you know, occasionally have to leave the desk. Now you just hit delete, you know, or backspace, so less movement, so different, different sort of problems, you know, set of problems.

    Clayton Cartwright: [00:55:56] And I think that's you know, I think that's a good thing to do, [00:56:00] to say it's a constant process. You know, like you said, as things change, there's going to be a new set of issues that pop up. So I guess the best way to say it would be, you know, you don't want people to think that they get to a spot where they say, yes, we've done it. You know, it's just when they fix one thing, the next issue's going to pop up. So it's that constant, you know, just awareness and observation and, you know, being aware of your injuries, to be able to make those corrections, you know, as they come up.

    Peter Koch: [00:56:31] Now that's great. And again, that fits in with the athletic standpoint of the worker, too, because and you think about it from your PT standpoint or your athletic training experience if someone comes to you either with an injury or a goal. Right. Here's my goal. I want to get from where I am right now to better function where I want to be. They're going to at some point in time, plateau. They're going to reach a point where they're not going to get any better unless you change something in their treatment path. So [00:57:00] that's I see that as a the same way, just as what you said, in that you can't just rest on your laurels and think you've succeeded. You have to have a constant process of reevaluation to see if you're really meeting those goals, because those are some of those injuries, like repetitive motion injuries or overuse injuries will sneak right up on you, like something odd will change in the process. And it might even just be a personality on the line. Like someone within the line or someone within the process will understand the process in a certain way, which will affect people down the road a little bit further. And it will change how they interact with the product or how they interact with the process, which could put them at a greater risk of injury.

    Peter Koch: [00:57:46] So if you don't have a continual analysis program to address issues or injuries or potential problems that come up in the workplace, you're going to miss it and you're going to rest on your laurels. And then you're going to look back some [00:58:00] day and go, wow, how did we get to where we are now? How do we get all these injuries? How did we get there? And so that I think looking at the worker as an athlete is a great way of helping prevent some of that, because it does it doesn't treat both the employer and the employee to have the best conditioned workplace as possible and to be the best worker as possible in order to achieve the goal that we want to have to be successful as an employer and to be successful as an employee. Excellent. All right, so we are getting that was a quick hour, we're we are getting right to the end of our podcast here, unbelievably so. Anything else you guys want to add about how looking at a worker as an industrial athlete can be beneficial to the employer?

    Al Brown: [00:58:48] I might just add, you know, and when we look at athletics, sports have been vetted. You know, I've had people that said I can't believe he's out bowling. Here's an injured worker, [00:59:00] he's out bowling and I'm going bowling exists. And people have learned how to bowl and use good body technique and probably can tolerate bowling because they're using good body mechanics. And if you probably look back at their job, they probably use lousy body mechanics, and that's probably what got him into trouble. So don't you know diss among the fact that they might be out doing something physical, particularly a sport, because a lot of times sports. We have worked the process enough that we've learned, you know, good body technique, it's when we get out of position that we get hurt, it's when we twist and we get hurt. But like skiing, you know, if you're good at skiing, you stay in control. You know, the proper technique so you don't get hurt. Sometimes we don't do that at work. You know, we and if you understand some of the human limits, you know, some of the basics, for example, in manual material handling, don't put it on the floor and don't put it above shoulder, but keep it between your knees [01:00:00] and your shoulder over just below shoulder level and keep it at about 35 pounds. The human limit. Yeah, we can lift hundreds of pounds, 100 pounds. We can deadlift all but the you know, we look at the formulas in the world of ergonomics and math and human physiology. We go 50 pounds. That's everybody should be able to handle 50 pounds.

    Al Brown: [01:00:16] Well, that's not true. It's probably more around thirty five pounds. And that's again, where you tend to put that thing. So, you know, when we look at human beings and we're looking for just general guidelines and we're looking at the you know, as an athlete, where do we kind of start looking and then and then from there design and create. Because again, if those things are exceeding the human limits, that's when we begin to create the injuries. Sports, we tend to know what the you know, the extremes are and what the limits are and what injuries we might anticipate. But in the work industry, we don't think of people as athletes or we don't sometimes think of their physiology [01:01:00] and we expose them to those risks and hazards. So we have to start thinking in more of a sports medicine model, how do we look at that job, make it fit specific capabilities of the human being that's actually there, and then help them with recovery and understanding or how to prepare for the day? Might be warm yourself up to stretch if it's going to be. I know we work with an oil company now in Maine and every one of their workers, when they get out of the truck, they step down and they do three sort of prep stretches to reset their body. Then they deliver the oil and every delivery, same thing, three stretches before they start. So that's forward thinking by an industry and taking those steps to kind of reduce those injuries, taking that sports medicine model.

    Clayton Cartwright: [01:01:48] And, you know, I'll just kind of throw in there as well. You know, we tend to look at a sport, you know, say football. Every athlete, you know, is different. You [01:02:00] know, even though human bodies, you know, we're all very similar. But there are still some structural changes or differences. I would say changes, but there are structural differences that we all have. You know, a big one is in the hip. You know, the hip socket may be positioned a little different for somebody. So from a bending, you know, when they do need to do something, you know, that technique may be different. So it's, again, taking it from a broad perspective, you know, looking at a sport or an industry, but still trying to maintain focus on your work force and or as an athlete, as individuals. You know, you still have to tease out those individual differences. And so, you know that from that athletic training background and perspective, you know, I think that is a point to make. You still would want to make sure that you're looking at each person at their own level.

    Al Brown: [01:02:56] And, you know, it's just real quick. I just thought of this a cool crossover that [01:03:00] I've seen recently, you know, talking about athletes and workers. I have a lot of you know, back when I was at iron works, they handed out only male large gloves no matter what your size. And so if you took someone who was a small person or a female worker, that might be fifth percentile and you give them a male large glove. They've already lost 20 percent of their grip just because of it's a glove. Now, you put on an excessively large glove and they probably lose half, if not three quarters of their ability to grip. And if you look at sports today, soccer, football with their hands, not so much basketball. What are they wearing? Gloves, and you see these gloves, you see these fantastic catches, now they can just grab one handed. Well, there's a lot of application of that with an industry where we're now taking those sports clubs and applying them to jobs in the industry where they need a good grip and [01:04:00] a comfortable grip. And we're finding that there's crossover, which is pretty cool. So you get to see that sort of connection that some of those tools that work for them also works for the industrial athlete.

    Clayton Cartwright: [01:04:12] You know, I think this is a great conversation, too, is sometimes just the awareness piece of it, you know, just having this conversation today, is it? It might be a light bulb for that person, like, oh, I never thought about it that way, you know, but to bring up our experiences and what we have seen and those comparisons, you know, maybe it'll change the viewpoint out there for some of our listeners. So, you know, I just think that awareness piece is also is pretty huge.

    Peter Koch: [01:04:39] Yeah, it is huge. And it really helps us to move. And I think to your point, Clayton, in the light bulb of not seeing the industry as just industry, but seeing that crossover between the person as an athlete and the person as a worker being combined, and some of the tools that you might find are functional [01:05:00] or at least concepts that you find are functional and sports can really be functional within the within the workplace. And going back to your point, Al, thinking about the oil company, they're stretching and warming up. Right. That's been part of athletics for just about ever, that you're going to have some sort of warm up process before physical activity and that's now or has moved into industry. But I think, you know, it waxes and wanes, but there is benefit to if you're going to do it right and if you're going to target correctly the functional parts of the body with the stretch, it's going to be going to be very beneficial. So there's a lot of learning that you could have from seeing your employee as an athlete and taking some learnings from the athletic world. Pretty cool.

    Al Brown: [01:05:52] Yeah, we do a lot of with the stretching program, I sometimes feel get pushed back because they go there's no research that supports that. And I said a lot of [01:06:00] times the research is showing gains in flexibility. And I said a lot of times you're not going to get that because we can't do a really, you know, a really dedicated stretch program. But think of stretching and movement within industry as resetting the body in the world of gravity so that just that might be slightly bulging backwards. And you do some back extensions we're actually resetting the body. We're not necessarily improving it, but we're trying to reset it back where it was or renourishment, you know, bring blood flow back into the neck and shoulders just to change and filter things out. So it's a reset. And once folks get that understanding, they go, oh, and then they can they'll see a reduction in injury simply because they're spending time resetting folks that need that resetting.

    Clayton Cartwright: [01:06:53] And so something that kind of sticks out in my mind and one of my mentors would always tell me was [01:07:00] and I would say this all the time, motion is lotion. You know, the human the human body, the human body is designed to move. The body wants to move. And that's how, again, we nourish our joints and lubricate things and keep movement. So that is something that's always stuck with me. And that's something that I live by, you know, in my own personal life, you know, from a from a health and fitness perspective. So motion is lotion. I think it's that's a crucial thing to understand to in the workforce.

    Peter Koch: [01:07:33] That's awesome. I like it. That has t shirt written all over it. I think that

    Al Brown: [01:07:39] Motion is lotion.

    Peter Koch: [01:07:46] So as we come to a close here, I just want to throw this out to you both and sort of in your in your history, as you as you reflect back on what you've done in your career or different careers and now where you are with MEMIC [01:08:00] and working specifically in an industry, helping workers stay safe and helping employers keep their employees from being injured. What do you know now that you wish you had known when you started out that might have had changed things for you on the way?

    Clayton Cartwright: [01:08:17] So for me, I really think that communication piece, you know, the things that we say very early on, you know, can really help set us up for success or it can set us up for a little bit of a failure if we're not using our words in a manner that's going to help set somebody up. Right. So, you know, I think that piece of communication really stands out to me and something that I really try to focus on when I'm even now at MEMIC, you know, when I'm talking to our policyholders, how are we communicating with them and making helping them to understand just how important some [01:09:00] of these concepts are. So definitely for me, it's the communication piece.

    Peter Koch: [01:09:05] And I definitely took that away today from our conversation that that was an aha moment for me going back. I can see where I could have used that innumerable times, talking with someone from a functional standpoint instead of a pain management standpoint that could really have changed the trajectory, early trajectory of an injury. So for me, I just learned that today. So that was pretty cool. Al, how about you?

    Al Brown: [01:09:29] You know, I speculated about the proactive approach back when I was young and thought it was the right way, and I feel like that's been validated over my years, that, in fact, it was a system that was created probably from that athletic training world. And as I've gone into the physical therapy world, have always stayed on the proactive side, the functional approach, and have found it very valuable. And probably the most recent [01:10:00] lesson I have learned probably over the last 10 years is that I need to be I maybe wasn't as cognizant of it back then, only because I wasn't. But now that I am older, that physiologically we do change and we don't stay forever young. So, you know, in Maine, you know, we have an older workforce. We're actually the oldest workforce in the nation. And if you look at the demographics across the country, we have a shift towards an increase in those baby boomers reaching their 60s and up. And in the work world, workaday world, you know, we're not all we're not all Tom Brady's and can be, you know, at the peak performance at forty three. You know, we have a lot of workers that are in their 60s that we have to be aware of those comorbidities, those aches and pains that are, as Clayton had talked about, the degenerative disease. And as my response to people was, [01:11:00] if you didn't have any, you must be a genetic freak. And we have to be cognizant of that when we look at design. And so I probably was not as aware of that when I was younger simply because I thought, I don't hurt, I'm fine. But now that I've gotten to this age, I do what I feel are all the right things. But I still ache in the morning when I wake up. And that's just part of sort of the natural aging process. And you have to respect it, understand it and keep it in mind when you're dealing with a workforce.

    Peter Koch: [01:11:32] Cool communication progression and motion is lotion, I think those are three key principles we need to take away from today, so that's awesome. All right. So thanks. Thanks for being here, guys. I really appreciate sharing your insight and your expertise with myself and our listeners today. So thanks for being here.

    Clayton Cartwright: [01:11:50] Yeah, great. It was an awesome conversation. I really appreciate the opportunity to come on and talk with you today, both of you.

    Peter Koch: [01:11:56] Right on Clayton. And we'll have you back for sure.

    Al Brown: [01:11:58] He knows it was awesome. Great. [01:12:00] You know, and I and I didn't realize until today that looking at Clayton was like looking into a mirror, you know, but about 10 or 15 years younger. But I didn't realize he had so many common experiences that I've had. So it's pretty cool to kind of, you know, here we are colleagues now and learning those things. But you know what? Every day I hope to learn something. And today I did.

    Peter Koch: [01:12:24] There you go. And it just goes to show like that communication, that shared experience. One last piece, like if you think about it from and you think about the worker as an athlete, the athlete doesn't stand alone. They have a lot of people that work with them in order to help them be successful. And as an industrial athlete, you look at your workers and who are the resources that you can tie into. So can you tie into can you tie into someone from the outside, whether that be MEMIC as your insurance carrier or a provider that you can help bring in to assess your workplace? Or maybe there's some expertise right within your own business, [01:13:00] some colleagues that you have that can bring some insight into a particular engineering challenge that you're having to address, an exposure that your employees are getting to. So great learning that we all had today. And communication progression. Motion is lotion. Love it. That's awesome. So Al and Clay in both. Well, I'll throw this to you, Al, because you might know better. So where can our listeners find out more about the industrial athlete at MEMIC?

    Al Brown: [01:13:28] Yes, as a policyholder you certainly can hit the safety director and you just have to register because we have some references sort of behind the safety director web. And you can access a lot of the information that we've talked about today. If you're a policyholder and you work with a safety consultant. One of our safety consultants, you can reach out to them. You always have access to us. And I say us. It's the ergonomics department with that industrial sports medicine hat that we wear through [01:14:00] E Ergo and which can be a virtual assessment of workstations. So we have a lot of tools and resources that are available. The one thing about MEMIC is I think we really one thing I enjoy about my job, I can't speak for, you know, Clayton and you Pete, but we get to partner with industry all the time. And, you know, I like to think of us as partners when we walk into an industry so, you know, take advantage of those services that we have, because with these kinds of past experiences, a lot of times you can bring a different set of eyes. So look to the safety director, look to your safety consultants, look to us, and we might be able to help you out for sure.

    Peter Koch: [01:14:42] And I can see Clayton shaking his head and I'm shaking my head to that. Yeah, the part of the part of the thing that I know I enjoy and in my conversations with Clayton is, is that partnership. So please, if you're a policyholder, reach out. And if you're not a policyholder and you're looking for some information, then MEMIC has some free resources that you can find [01:15:00] right at MEMIC.com that you can jump right in there under workplace safety and you can find some great resources that you might be able to pull in and use within your workplace. So thanks again, Al and Clayton, for joining us today. And to all of our listeners out there today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, we've been speaking about the industrial athlete with Al Brown and Clayton Cartwright. If you have any questions for Al or Clayton or. We'd like to hear more about a particular topic on our podcast. Email me at podcast@ MEMIC.com. Also, check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/podcast, where you can find additional resources, links to other podcasts and our entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for our Safety Net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates. And if you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it if you took a minute or two to review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whichever podcast service that you found us on. If you've already done that, thanks, because it really [01:16:00] helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing the show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Koch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.

    1 hr 17 min
  • Getting Under the Surface of Slip and Fall Injuries with Patrick Dooley

    In 2019 the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported there were 190,000 slip and fall events that resulted in time away from work. 60% of those were falls on the same surface. Any surface is the interface with our shoes and together they provide stability for our base of support while moving. The surface composition and condition are key to the efficiency of our movements. A stable surface compatible with the work being done is a good place to start when trying to prevent Slip and Fall events.

    On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, I speak with Patrick Dooley, CSP and Senior Environmental Health and Safety Specialist for LL Bean. We are going to get under the surface of slip and fall injuries and discuss how understanding your surfaces can help reduce slip and fall events.

    Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch. I expect many of you listening out there have had the chance to walk on the beach. Well right now I want you to think back. What was it like? Was it Rocky where the rocks big or the little pebbles? Was the sand hard or was it really loose the surface move underneath your feet when you walked when we expected a surface like soft beach sand or the gravel around where the surf breaks can be just what we want. But when that surface changes to something we aren't expecting, it can cause us to stumble or at the very least break stride. Think about it. So when our foot or shoe interacts unexpectedly with the surface, our base of support changes as our foot, knee or hip moves farther to the side or four and a half feet. So when we're walking or working, most of the time our base of support is our feet. So right now, if you can [00:01:00] safely do it, stop and put your feet about shoulder width or maybe just a little wider and then steady yourself and keeping both feet on the ground, shift your weight from one side to the other side and then back again should feel pretty stable, balanced. Even if you shift your weight pretty far to one side, you're still going to feel pretty balanced as long as your feet are going to be on the floor.

    Peter Koch: [00:01:23] When you move side to side, I want you to think about how far your center of gravity and that's right around where your belly button or your belt buckle is, how far that moves from side to side before you might feel like you're going to tip over. So depending on how far apart your feet are, your center of gravity can move quite a bit from that center position. You can move it almost all the way to the outside of that foot, to the side that you're standing on now. And again, only if you can safely do it, move your feet closer together with your toes or your shoes touching or maybe almost touching. Now shift your weight from side [00:02:00] to side again. And do you feel the difference? You should even see the difference in how far your center of gravity moves before you feel unstable, because the closer your feet are, the smaller that base of support is. We fall when our center of gravity moves outside of our base of support. The larger or faster the movement and the smaller our base of support is, the more likely we are to fall. It's just physics. You really can't get around it. And we take for granted the surfaces that we walk on during the day. That's really neither good nor bad. It just is like you're going to walk across the tile floor in the bathroom or you're going to walk across the rug in your home, or you're going to walk across the concrete at work and you take it for granted.

    Peter Koch: [00:02:45] However, the surface is an important piece. It's the interface with our shoes. And together that surface in our shoes provide a platform of stability for our base of support while we walk, move, lift, reach, roll or whatever [00:03:00] motion or ambulation that we're engaged in at the time. That surfaces composition and condition are key to the efficiency of our movement. So it's reasonable to think that a stable surface compatible with the work being done is a good place to start when you're trying to prevent slip and fall events. But how do you know what that surface is? How do you know how stable it is? How do you know how slip resistant it is? And unless you're fortunate enough to have built a custom facility, most of us have inherited the surface that came with the building. And even if you did build a new facility, some of the walking working surfaces may have been specked out by the architect and not the safety engineer. They may look good, but they're not compatible with the work, meaning that they don't have enough inherent friction to keep you from slipping or too much and may cause you to stumble. This is where a thorough surface or floor care and maintenance program really comes into play. So understanding all the components that go into [00:04:00] keeping us upright when we're walking and working around the business.

    Peter Koch: [00:04:04] And there's a lot that goes into one of those programs. And I don't know if you're like me. When I first started out, I was thinking, I don't need one of those. Our floors are just fine. And then if you look back at some of your statistics, it might show a different story. And if you look at it nationally and the Bureau of Labor Statistics has some stats that should make you look down at the floor a little more closely, because in 2019, BLS reported that there were more than 190,000 slip trip fall events that involve days away from work, and 60 percent of those were events that were a fall to the same level. So not a fall from a height, like a ladder or a vehicle, but a slip and fall on the same surface. So gaining insights to where to start and the pitfalls that you might look out for are key no matter what you're doing, if you're just starting out to create your own slip and fall program or if you're really evaluating an existing program [00:05:00] for your company. So that said on the podcast. With me today is Patrick Dooley, CSP, and senior environmental health and safety specialist with L.L. Bean. And we're going to get under the surface of slip and fall events and what steps L.L. Bean has taken to manage the surfaces its staff work on at their facilities. So, Patrick, welcome to the podcast today.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:05:21] Well, thank you very much, Peter. Happy to join.

    Peter Koch: [00:05:24] That's great. And, you know, you and I and a couple of others from MEMIC, we ended up doing a podcast, not a podcast, but a webinar a few weeks back on Slip and Falls and talking a little bit about Libyan's experience managing slip and falls at their store. So I wanted to have you on and just maybe take a little deeper dive into some of the things that you did, what you learned from your experiences, some of the challenges that you ran into and what maybe some actions that you took. So I'm hoping that we can get into some of those conversations today as we move forward.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:05:58] Absolutely.

    Peter Koch: [00:06:00] Before [00:06:00] we jump into the bean's plan or process, tell us a little bit about your background. So what got you started in safety and how long have you been in the field? And maybe how long have you been at L.L. Bean?

    Patrick Dooley: [00:06:12] Well, thank you. So as of right now, I am lucky enough to be in the field of safety for the last 20 years, have a degree in safety studies from Keene State College. And I've been lucky enough to be with L.L. Bean the last 14 years.

    Peter Koch: [00:06:29] That's pretty awesome. And Keene State's got a pretty long history of having of putting out quite a few really good safety professionals with their safety studies programs out there. So were you able to jump right from Keene State to beans, or did you have a couple of places that you stopped in between?

    Patrick Dooley: [00:06:49] So in between the year 2001 and leading up to L.L. Bean, I was able to hold a couple of different positions within safety included lead in asbestos abatement [00:07:00] and consulting, as well as working for a temporary agency and doing safety for all of their temp hires and working with actually MEMIC to help with our lost control. And then I was fortunate enough to land a job with L.L. Bean, and I've been there ever since. And the best part about L.L. Bean is that it's not singularly focused into just the retail division. We have a manufacturing division, we have our fulfillment centers, we have our facilities. So it's a lot more expansive than what people might think of LLB.

    Peter Koch: [00:07:37] Yeah, it's not just a store. And, you know, we were talking before the podcast. Neither you nor I are native to Maine. We're actually both native to Connecticut and then moved to Maine for our wives, which is kind of cool. And, you know, I had known of L.L. Bean while I was there in Connecticut and had come to Maine and actually shopped at the flagship store. But I had no [00:08:00] idea the extensive facilities that L.L. Bean has between, you know, research and design and manufacturing and then shipping storage besides the retail facilities. So that's pretty, interesting. You get but you get to see a lot of interesting things just within the L.L. Bean ecosystem.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:08:21] So the L.L. Bean as a whole, when you look at it with all the different divisions that we have from a safety perspective, you're able to apply all the knowledge you've learned over the years and gain knowledge as you go along. It kind of opens the doors for a lot of folks. It's eye opening. Most folks in our profession get kind of siloed into manufacturing or transportation or construction. And, you know, here at the L.L. Bean, we've been afforded the opportunity as safety professionals to explore all of those avenues. And it's been great.

    Peter Koch: [00:08:58] You even have I mean, even [00:09:00] at the retail store, you even have hospitality. So you have there's a little food outlet there, a restaurant that you have at the flagship store. People wouldn't think of that either. So when you explore L.L. Bean from a safety perspective, it's like almost working in a little city because you have all these different nooks and crannies that have different needs. And then you have the connection with the public. So it's not just workplace safety, as you might have in manufacturing or you might have in an office building or someplace else. But you have a pretty strong connection with the public that you're going to have guests and staff encountering different exposures together. Even so, you're planning on both sides, which from my perspective, I always think that there is a definite overlap between what you might do for guest safety and what you're going to do for workplace safety. There's a definite overlap there.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:09:56] And I would even extend it even further to guests, to [00:10:00] the community, because majority of the. Places where we reside throughout the country right now. We expand our offerings into the community from our outdoors discovery programs, so things are available to folks and it's not just the branding thing, but we want people to be outside and be in the outdoors. They're not just our guests, we are actually the guests to the outdoors. Right. I mean, that's the whole point. But how we do it and how we make people be safe and do things is I mean, that's what we've been very successful in, even through this whole pandemic.

    Peter Koch: [00:10:33] So that's pretty cool. And not just all of the different facilities that you have, that do different things. But you have locations across the country as well, which is something that didn't exist back in the 70s. Right. It's you've expanded across the United States. So you have 54 locations or something like that across the United States.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:10:56] Now we're across 19 different states [00:11:00] and there is roughly 54 locations with soon to be a couple more opening this year. But within this past year, those 54 locations in 19 states offered up many different challenges throughout the pandemic, as anyone could imagine.

    Peter Koch: [00:11:18] So I'm sure they have. And in all those different states, there are you know, there's different like you said before, there's different cultures that you have to work through and within there's different facilities, challenges. There's different perceptions from the public that you might have to manage as you go through there. All of these things kind of fit into that overall safety puzzle. And I would imagine, like one of the common things that you have for exposures across all of the different facilities and no matter what they do is slip and falls or slip and falls. So slip and fall exposures, how different are they across the different facilities and how different are they maybe [00:12:00] in different states or maybe in the different areas that you would have work going on, whether it be a public facing or outdoor center or manufacturing and warehousing?

    Patrick Dooley: [00:12:13] Yeah, I mean, if you look at it from a retail standpoint, I'll start with that is we are in those 19 different states. So what is the environment that we're in? You know, where we're not in sunny Florida where we may get a little bit of rain. We're in Park City, Utah. We're going to go for the big end of town that's known people their ski and we're in the Adirondacks and in New York. Same thing. Hopefully it's snow season and the rain events and everything else that comes along with New England. So a lot of the things that go into planning and engineering and thinking about how we build out our stores, slips trips and falls have to be kind of in the forefront, not just from our customers, not for our employees. It's things [00:13:00] that we need to think about. And those are things that maybe when we're building out these stores 10 years ago, we didn't have so much forward thinking. But now as we're, you know, 10 years later, we're trying to figure it out and say, oh, you know, we need to look at more of what's the impact to not only the customer or the employee, but sustainability to floor care and maintenance programs. What does that all look like?

    Peter Koch: [00:13:30] Yeah, it's all one big puzzle, really. And if you just, I remember in some of my past experiences or other working with clients at MEMIC or working outside of MEMIC before I came to MEMIC thinking about the flooring or the surfaces that you're going to have people walking and working around. It sometimes started with the idea of what's it going to look like? And we never really talked about how are we going to maintain it, what [00:14:00] type of footwear is going to be on it, how much traction is going to be there? Basically, they figured, well, we're going to put it in and then if we have to replace it, we'll replace it in 10 years. But frankly and historically, those products, especially in those high traffic areas, never lasted the time that they expected to because of either increased traffic levels or, you know, I can tell you, you talked about Park City, Utah. I was the question that rolled through my head, when you're saying that was I wonder if you got anybody in ski boots walking through one of those stores. And I think from a slip trip and fall standpoint, ski boot on any surface is one of the most difficult things to try to figure out, because there isn't really anything that's going to be great, because you can find something that works for the ski boot, but then it's near impossible to keep it clean.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:14:52] For sure and one of the things that architecturally what was looked at when stores are being built, not just L.L. Bean, but other places [00:15:00] is. Does it look how does it feel? Is it on Brand in what ended up happening from. And from our standpoint is we were having like four or five different floor textures within one building. So now your floor care and maintenance program becomes a little bit crazy and the costs are a little bit different because you're vacuuming one space, you're mopping in another and you're dry mopping in another. So it just adds to a lot of the confusion. And like you said, it's, you know, depending on the area your in, that may not be the way to go. So 2021, let's revisit that and see how we can make improvements on that. Not only impacts our employees, but the general public that comes in to visit L.L. Bean.

    Peter Koch: [00:15:46] Sure. So we're going to talk about the refurbishment program that you guys went through and specifically about some of the flooring. But I think it's worthwhile talking a little bit about some of the challenges with slip and fall prevention and [00:16:00] kind of how they affect the big picture. I think some of the big ones are in and you alluded to this in our webinar, perception is one of those things. Visibility is another. And then surface traction. I think those three are pretty sizable. And we can address some of those as we go. So let's really start with surface traction and what it is. And why is low traction a problem?

    Patrick Dooley: [00:16:26] I think it is an easy question to answer. But at the same token, it isn't because it's one of these things that people don't see. Right. It's invisible. So problems with these surfaces cause what the majority of the slip trips and falls for the most part, if we see a puddle on the floor or something that looks slick or, you know, gum or leaves or whatever, we can kind of focus on that. Right. But if we're not wearing proper footwear, you're not going to get the right amount of traction. [00:17:00] And the amount of traction depends on what kind of flooring you have. So if you go see not only attraction's really invisible, but it also isn't immediately obvious how to quantify and tell when to do something about it. So how much water makes it so slippery or, you know, is it the snow and ice on the sidewalk? It's slippery or, you know, is it snow melt or calcium chloride that we're putting outside and tracking? And that makes it slippery. So there's so many different environmental factors that can come in that can give you this low traction effect. But then there's this underlying thing of what's our perception of slippery? Your perception is going to be different than mine. You know, a perception of someone at a younger age, a toddler. Their perception is that we're going to be way different than someone who is probably a little bit older. So where [00:18:00] they may walk fast, someone may walk slower. So perception is kind of this undefined thing when it comes to slips trips and falls and how to figure out what it's not slippery and what is slippery.

    Peter Koch: [00:18:12] And I think that's a really good point. And it's perception is one of those things that you really it's hard to control outside of yourself. Like one of the first things that people do to help prevent slip and fall injuries are to put signs up. We're going to put a sign up and help make people aware. You've all seen the yellow wet floor signs or maintenance in progress or something sign. And they're fairly ubiquitous. I can't tell you. Well, before all the travel restrictions happens, you know, you walk through the airport and guaranteed if you're walking through early in the morning, you're going to see a number of those along the walkways. And after a while, you don't even see him anymore. So, like, they're not even they don't even create additional perception. [00:19:00] You just see them as part of the background. You might not even process it. So that's one of the challenges with perception. But the other challenge, too, is like it's all it's different. You said what might be slippery to you or hazardous to you and your perception is going to be different for me, my perception of what the hazard is and then it changes what you do with it for sure.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:19:20] Right? I mean, we all have unique gates. Our strides are all different. Our footwear choices are all different. Now, the type of shoe that you wear that we have an on our footwear all adds into what can be slippery and what isn't slippery because you and I could be wearing the same shoe. But your shoe could be six months older than mine. But I'm sticking to the floor and know you're falling on your behind. It's very different.

    Peter Koch: [00:19:47] So and if I'm taken if I'm taking a six or eight inch longer stride than you are in our legs or the same length. So there's a different amount of force placed on the heel and the sole to generate [00:20:00] friction when it lands. So. It's a there's so many different things that go into that to drive perception, and they're all a lot of them are habits. I mean, we're many of us don't put on shoes in the morning in order to prevent a slip and fall unless, of course, you're going out into a hazardous environment. And then you might put, you know, ice cleats on or micro spikes or something. That is going to be a traction enhancer for a pair of shoes that you're going to have. But typically, when you get up in the morning, go to work, you put on the shoes that either match the outfit or they're going to be comfortable for what you're going to do or required for what you're going to do that day.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:20:40] Right. And I think that from an employee standpoint, because you're in the same workspace day in and day out, you recognize those areas that can be slippery or not slippery. And so you can adjust the footwear that you're going to wear or you're recommended the footwear. So [00:21:00] if I'm a line cook in a restaurant, I know that it's going to be slippery back there. So I'm going to wear footwear that translates to that environment, similar to the fact that if I'm outside shoveling in the middle of winter in ice and snow, I'm going to wear footwear to that effect. But if I'm shopping inside of a store, for the most part, it's fair game. You don't know what people are going to wear and come in and come out from. So from a general liability standpoint, we can't anticipate what their perception is going to be of a floor and whatnot. We can coach our employees. We can do certain things to lower the risk, but the general public is open to us so they can come in and they're at the risk of the environment that they're in. Right.

    Peter Koch: [00:21:46] Flip flops to steel toes, really, I'm sure you've seen it all come through the door.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:21:52] Absolutely.

    Peter Koch: [00:21:53] So perception exacerbates the problem of low friction. If you have a flooring or a surface, whether [00:22:00] it be inside or outside, that could be generally slippery. But your perception and how you see that surface can change how you interact with it. What other factors play into reducing the traction on a floor.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:22:17] So let's think about the kind of the five biggest things that you see for a slip trip and fall events. Right. It's slip resistance on walking surfaces. So we've talked a little bit about that. The walking surface conditions, visibility is another one poor condition of either handrails or guardrails that are in the area. And the accessibility can be a major factor, too. So is it too crowded? There's too many things going on for us to be like fixtures? Let's think about having fixtures in aisles and you're offering up an area where people are aware of their surroundings and can slip trip or fall or something. So [00:23:00] I think those are probably the five biggest things that we would look at in order to kind of reduce the risk of a slip trip fall.

    Peter Koch: [00:23:09] And when we start to look at those different factors, a lot of it's going to come down to what the flooring is at its base. Like what material, what's the composition of that particular floor that you're on? And then what? What are you going to do with it? And that's the fixtures. That's the maintenance. That's the way it's going to be used. The number of people that are going to be on it. All of those things contribute to it. But there's a base slip, resistance or traction that flooring is going to have when it comes from the manufacturer. So if we start there, because again, let's start at the base and let's really get down to the nitty gritty of this whole thing. How do you know how slippery a floor actually is even before [00:24:00] you start putting things on top of it and people on top of it?

    Patrick Dooley: [00:24:03] Right. So fortunately, we're lucky enough, right. There's there is some sort of scientific method that we can apply to looking at the coefficient of friction, which is objective. Now, the standards on coefficient of friction are all over the place for flooring, but there is a threshold that people can use or benchmark against that says that is your floor more slippery or less slippery. So OSHA doesn't define it. The National Flooring Institute, they have their own standard, but you can benchmark it. So when you're buying something off the shelf from, let's say, Home Depot and you're buying tile and you're putting in your bathroom, there is a COF coefficient of friction label on it that says this meets blah blah blah. From our standpoint, we would bring in someone like MEMIC to sample the floor. So we do try Bomaderry. Right. So basically it is science of measuring friction. So we're going to use [00:25:00] a device. And in this particular one, we're using a binary tribometer or output tribometer that measures the coefficient of friction, the floor sideways, frontwards, backwards, wet, dry. And he gives us an idea of where we're at and what risk measures do we need to take to lower the risk of a slip and fall inside the workplace? Or is the flooring in to match the environment we're putting it in? So obviously, if we're putting flooring in Freeport, Maine may be different than what we put in Virginia. Virginia is not going to have snow and they're going to have snow melt. They're not going to have, I should say, that could knock on wood after this year. Anything can happen. But, you know, generally speaking, they're floor conditions. They look different than what we're going to have in Freeport. So let's define that and let's come to a conclusion of what's happening to the environment, basically is what it is.

    Peter Koch: [00:25:56] Yeah. So how do you understand first understanding of the environment [00:26:00] and then getting some information about the floor and how those two things would match up and compare to each other? Because certainly, you know, like you talked about like in a food service standpoint, a hard, hard core tile with a real polished surface isn't going to be great if you're going to get grease on it from your fryolator. Not a great combination. And that same combination wouldn't be great to have, say, in Freeport, where you're going to have outside, where you're going to have snow and sand because it's going to wear really poorly and wet shoes. Wet slick shoes on that surface is going to be crazy slippery.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:26:43] Absolutely. And also, what is the location? What do you where you're at? So it's easy for us because it's our campus. It's our store. But outside of Freeport, you know, we're leasing spaces inside of malls. And, you know, we may be just a pass through. [00:27:00] Into the mall. So, you know that the parking is convenient. So people are walking in and out. So what happens is that they're dragging stuff in and out of the store. So we need now what we didn't know then is to match the flooring to the traffic that's going to happen inside of the store,

    Peter Koch: [00:27:19] Traffic patterns and volume are especially for your situation it was pretty critical as you started to look at what do we use when we start when we get into that refurbishment project? I also think that that's a pretty important thing to think about, no matter where you are. I mean, traffic patterns, whether you're in a doctor's office, hospitality situation, manufacturing, I don't think it really matters. Even a grocery store traffic patterns are a big deal because depending on where they're coming from, like you said, you think about a grocery store, if you're coming from the butcher area or you're coming from the back of the house space where we're [00:28:00] storing things or you're coming from front of the house as people are walking in through the entryway, how much what's the possibility of having a contaminant on the bottom of your shoe that you're dragging in? And how do you treat for that? How do you plan for that? How do you manage that? And there's some definitely some strategies there. Sure.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:28:19] Right. And then the interrogation of the surface. So obviously the middle of your walkways inside of a store or a building or what have you are going to have less traffic than your main entrances. So do you have a specific plan for now resurfacing those?

    Peter Koch: [00:28:37] So I guess this is a good time to sort of jump into the refurbishment project as you started to look at your facilities. It was time to replace some flooring and to refurbish some of those facilities that needed to have needed it. So when you started to do that, I know we had talked about before that you had used tribometry to learn [00:29:00] what the coefficient of friction was about some of those surfaces. Talk to me a little bit about the refurbishment project that you did and then what part sampling the surfaces, either before or after played to you making decisions about flooring.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:29:16] So when we kicked this off, let's say, three years ago, the question came up from our store operations, the facilities, teams that we hate. We're thinking about getting rid of all this different floor textures and going with a singular floor texture inside of our stores. What impact would that have on not only the general public, but on our employees? And that posed a great question for us. How do we gauge that? How do we figure that out? Luckily enough for us, at the time we had this great big expansive space that was getting ready to be refurbished that allowed us to take some concrete and [00:30:00] create sample areas. So the goal was to come up with a concrete surface for the store the goal on top of that was to have our floor care and maintenance program. The cost reduce it would look clean it would be singular. But in order to get to that point, how do we know it's not just safe? Because I don't think safe's a good word to use. But I mean, is it slippery? Does it work? Can we drag fixtures across of it? Does it need to be mopped? Do we need to use a machine so we are able to create this space and use four different textures? And we partner with MEMIC and said, hey, bring your tribometer here, to L.L. Bean, let's do some testing. We're going to wear it on the floor. We're going to make it where we're going to make it dirty.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:30:53] So that way it's not like you're getting a fresh floor when you come in and it gives us a little bit of wear patterns and such. Take the readings and then [00:31:00] from the readings, we will determine what would be the best option to replace in the flooring that we currently have in our stores. And with that, we came to the conclusion, let's use a flooring that has some texture in it, has a urethane finish. It'll look nice. It'll look uniform and has a high coefficient of friction. Little did we know that the environment dictated kind of what would happen in the future for one of our stores. But for the most part, it was the right decision. And if you look at major retailers right now, you look at your Wal-Mart, you look at your Hannaford's, you look at Shaws, and they're all going to this rough surfaced concrete slab. And really, it's because your floor care and maintenance programs are really less than what they would have to be if you had tile. The agent deterioration factors kind of go down. You don't have to have as much floor care repairs than you have now. And aesthetically, it actually looks good, removed four textures from the floor. [00:32:00] You know, for us, you go from a wood floor to a carpet to a court floor to a carpet in our demographics for our customers. Unfortunately, that created more of a hazard than anything else.

    Peter Koch: [00:32:16] Let's take a quick break. Safe for S.A.F.E is an acronym for many different things. But when talking about slip and fall events, Safe represents the four areas that you can focus on at your facility to prevent slips and falls, surface awareness, footwear and environment. Look at the surface as it relates to its composition, condition, changes and contamination. Evaluate how your facility layout and pace of work may affect the awareness of your staff to slip and trip hazards. What is your footwear policy and how is that compatible with the type of work and the surfaces at your facility? And last, how [00:33:00] does the lighting and weather in and around the work environment compound or create slip and trip hazards? If you're interested in learning more about how to prevent slip and fall events at your workplace, check out the resources at www.MEMIC.com/workplace safety. Or if you're a policy holder with MEMIC, you can sign into the MEMIC safety director and find more resources there. Now let's get back to today's episode.

    Yeah, that kind of ticks into that whole perception and visibility, too, like if I'm on one type of surface and it has a lot of traction to it and I'm not really understanding what the next surface is going to bring, I might know that it's not there or it's going to be different, like going from carpet to cork because it's fairly easy to see that difference. But you have no idea how it's going to react under foot. So they might continue their gait the same way and [00:34:00] their feet might still be wet from tracking in from the outside. And all of a sudden it's a slightly different coefficient of friction and down they go at end. Lighting must play some difference in that to being able to see changes in elevation, changes in surface texture that might cause someone with a low gait, more of a shuffling gait to maybe even trip on some of those higher traction surfaces or maybe uneven like cobbled surfaces.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:34:28] So the majority of our refreshes, not only do we look at the flooring, but all the lighting was changed and all of our fixtures were changed. So we eliminated not only a lot of heavy fixtures, but also our stores were a lot more adequately lit than they were in the past. I can't tell you what the foot candles were, but I can tell you that it made the product look a lot better.

    Peter Koch: [00:34:57] It's kind of amazing how something small like that, you know, [00:35:00] you might even change something for a product, get the product to look better, increase the lighting so you can see better. But visibility makes a huge difference and slips and falls. When you can see the surface. It helps you with your perception. It helps you with understanding the exposure, especially in those crowded areas. Some of the things that we talk to our clients about, too, is as you go through your facility, some of the areas that you should pay a lot of attention to are those low-lit areas where your employees are going to be like your trash handling spaces, the back of the house spaces that typically aren't as well-lit as some of the front of the house spaces. Those are always areas. If you go back and look at what your trends are or your injury or your near miss trends, you're going to find that they're going to happen in those spaces just because you can't really see what's on the floor.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:35:51] And those are the areas that we tend to lose focus on, right? They're not selling areas for us. So Backhouse is a good [00:36:00] example. Your employee entrance. No employees enter from the front door, right? It's always the back door. The back door has one little light, usually on top of it. You know, lighting is a is a big factor in what we do.

    Peter Koch: [00:36:12] Yeah, yeah. And you have some complex needs because you are you're not only trying to develop flooring that's going to help you reduce the overall maintenance and replacement costs. But it had to look good. It had to match, I guess, the branding, you could say, for L.L. Bean and had had to draw people into the space and make them feel comfortable. And it needed to be functional not only for traffic walking, but also for moving your fixtures over the floor, too. And I think it's something that we forget. And when you're talking about moving a fixture, what do you, I think I understand what you're talking about. You're moving racks and carts and things across the floor. What else would be considered a fixture [00:37:00] that you might have to plan for

    Patrick Dooley: [00:37:02] Going from back of the house to the front of house or using dollies are used in pallet jacks or, you know, you're moving over stuff, Xerox, anything that would be product movement. And not just that. There's stuff that we sell that, you know, you have one person that needs that kind of move it along in a customer needs to pick it up or do it. So how can we make it easier for them? One is it is the flooring work for them? Is it going to damage the product as they're dragging it across? Is it going to damage the texture as they're dragging it across? So is it going to be agent deterioration factor on that? So I think there's a lot of different things to think about. And you could probably go way down a rabbit hole on that. But, you know, in general, what's going to work best for that environment and how do you how do you figure it out? And I think we've only done a really good spot, because if I look at my employee injuries that have occurred over the last ten years, you [00:38:00] know, there was a significant push pull was a big one.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:38:05] You know, they're moving fixtures around. We did floor set changes monthly, which is crazy, right? I mean, did you force that change? It's massive. So now we've gone to quarterly and that has made a significant difference in how we handle product, how we move product, you know, tag product change, all of it. It just has a little trickledown effect. Our store injuries have. Gone from pretty significant to pretty insignificant over the last. So if we look at I did 13 years, my 14 years over the last three, we've seen a dramatic dip in retail store injuries. And a lot of it has come from our process changes our front of house changes, flooring, fixtures, lighting mannequins, handling mannequins, you know, bringing them upstairs, downstairs, dragging them across floors, [00:39:00] all that stuff. So it's had a huge impact. So people think I'm making a floor change or I'm making a fixture change. It may seem very insignificant, but if you look in the long, broader lens to it, it really does have a huge impact. It has a huge impact on how people play with the landscape of what their store looks like or what their environment is.

    Peter Koch: [00:39:23] And those changes prevent exposures. But it also allows you to do more like when you when you have good flooring, good lighting, good changes, good processes in place. It allows you from a retail perspective to have your associates interacting with your guests, which is going to be a huge part of the experience when they come to L.L. Bean or they come to any retail establishment like you don't want your staff always focused on how am I moving all this stuff around and what's going to happen if it's a complex process or a big deal. You want them interacting and then when they're not interacting, then they can start to move different things. It's just part [00:40:00] of that. So some of these changes can, like you said, have far, far reaching effects. But there is a lot that goes into it. Did you have a team of people that worked together to make these floor changes or decide on the floor changes? Or was it kind of just you and your notebook?

    Patrick Dooley: [00:40:18] No, absolutely no. We had we had to definitely have a team. So in the past, it was more of a facility planning and operations lens on what the store is going to look like and how we're going to interact. And aesthetically, was the approach right. Let's make the store beautiful and have that environment. When you walk in, you're like, oh, wow, this is L.L. Bean. Now, 20 years later, like no we want it to be shoppable. We want it to be yes, we do want it to look nice, but we want our customers to interact. We want our employees to be able to interact. We want to do in a safe manner. And, you know, is it functional? Is it flooring? [00:41:00] Does the fixtures, is it all meet what we're trying to do here and is it on Brand? And I think we have achieved that. And I will say, you know, we're having a store opening here in May and it's probably going to be one of the probably one of the nicest stores that I've seen. And it's going to have all these different components that we're talking about today wrapped up into it, which is going to be great to see.

    Peter Koch: [00:41:23] Yeah, that's really cool to kind of see it all happen in one particular space and then start from scratch and see how they kind of move going forward. That's pretty cool. So when you when you were making these changes going through and I know it's a process of understanding, installing, observing, making some more changes. Was there anything unexpected that you found when you were when you were testing flooring or after you installed some flooring that you hadn't expected?

    Patrick Dooley: [00:41:59] Yeah, [00:42:00] I think, you know, there are unknowns. I mean, you try to do as best you can to replicate situations and environments when you do sample areas inside of what we tried to do. But then when you get it into the actual environment, they're going to be putting it in. There are certain unknowns. They're going to happen. There's obviously external environmental factors that are out of control. A good example is, you know, one of our stores in upstate New York, they're using a different type of snowmelt. So we typically use salt and sand mixtures. They were using a calcium chloride based product that was being trapped in through the store. And this store was a pass through into a mall. So, you know, a lot of our traffic isn't even shopping. They're going into the mall. They're dragging the calcium chloride in. So the further and further they're bringing it in to more slip trips and falls that we were having from not only customers, but from employees. Because now remember, back to the perception thing, employees [00:43:00] already knew where the hot spots were. Right. But as these as this calcium chloride is being tracked to the store, those hotspots changed. And so this particular store, which usually only has a handful of slips trips and falls a year, we had upwards of 50 within two months. And it was something that we didn't plan for. Now, we had the same flooring in some in two other stores earlier in the year, but. You know, winter came and we found out that maybe this flooring wasn't the best, so we had to go back and kind of think about, all right, why is this happening? Do we know what some of the root causes are of it? And what do we do to kind of fix it? And luckily for us, within a short time frame, we're able to come to a lot of big conclusions and pivot to, [00:44:00] you know, getting a new floor care and maintenance program in place because we knew that the machine that was there wasn't working properly.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:44:07] We knew that the landlord was using a different product on the sidewalks that was being tracked into the store. So, you know, we worked with the landlord to change that product. So that way the calcium chloride was, you know, the problem with calcium chloride that sticks to these surfaces. And it's a it's a real pain to clean. And actually, it broke the machine that was supposed to clean the floor. So we asked the landlord to go to a different product for the store. We also found our floor mats are terrible in this particular store. So a water hog mat, which is something that we sell, is wonderful from a household standpoint. But from a commercial standpoint, maybe not the best product to use in a store that has a very large traffic volume. So we changed out our floor mats. This particular store, you would walk in and you would see the yellow floor. What signs up and down the aisles. [00:45:00] Now you walk in the store and you don't see them anymore because we did make those changes.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:45:04] The floor care maintenance program is way more robust. The matting program is now included in that floor maintenance program, which it wasn't in the past. The changes were made to the salting and sanding and calcium chloride outside the stratification inside of the vestibule was turned up. So that way and you're getting it was drying as you're walking in instead of staying white all the time. So those are things that you don't really necessarily think about when you're sitting inside of a box sampling flooring. Right. You have all these wonderful ideas of what you want that's going to be and how you're going to work with it. But then, you know, you don't know what someone's bringing in. You don't know if, you know, that site had recently been paved. So if it had been recently paved and it's wet, you're dragging all those oils into the store, which would cause a similar effect to what calcium chloride had done. So while it may be temporary, you're still going to scratch your head and figure out why am I having all these trips [00:46:00] and falls? So there's a lot of unknowns that happen with this. You can only focus on the things that you can focus on when you're trying to make a decision like this. But, you know, I think is always going to be that little level of uncertainty that you have to have. And that's the risk that you need to be either willing to accept or not accept.

    Peter Koch: [00:46:25] Yeah, I don't think there's any perfect solution for slips, trips and falls, except, you know, maybe carting people everywhere they go, pushing them around. But that, you know, creates other hazards, other places that you bring up some interesting problems that you wouldn't find unless you're doing one or two things, one, paying attention to your injury trends or near miss trends. Right. So what are people reporting? What's going on? And are you seeing clustering happening in a particular location, whether you have one [00:47:00] facility or multiple facilities? And then the other part would be paying attention to the surface in the maintenance process itself? Because, you know, how did you find out that the floor care machine was gummed up and not working as well? How long had it been there in that condition or how long had someone been using it in that condition thinking that they were cleaning the floor when it really wasn't working as well as it should have? Well, it starts smoking on you and blows up in one spot. They're typically gradual, like they're going to work really well. And then over time, it's going to be a reduction in the quality that for the surface that the machine leaves afterwards. And unless you're really paying attention, you're not going to see it. So I think there's a value in checklists and like, what are you paying attention to locally? And then your position kind of globally, overseeing safety for multiple areas is checking in on those spaces and seeing what's really happening [00:48:00] on the ground. And those are always going to be great indications that something's either working or something might not be working for you.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:48:08] Yeah, the biggest thing is really, you know, from an employer standpoint is to really encourage employees to report stuff. So the earlier that you report something, you know, the more data you're going to have. So we talk about what leading and lagging indicators, right. So lagging indicator. Someone's already fallen. Someone's gotten hurt. But the leading indicator as well, someone slipped there yesterday, but they got hurt today, but it wasn't reported yesterday, so we couldn't we didn't have the opportunity to take a look at that and fix it, you know, or what's the trend look like inside of a different store or stores that have similar flooring, similar fixtures. You know, what's the trend look like? How can we match those apples and apples and apples to oranges and figure out, you know, do [00:49:00] we need to pivot and make a change in how each fixture or the flooring in a different store? So, yeah, I think data is just absolutely necessary. Stuff doesn't get lost in data. If you're tracking the right things, you're going to be able to get ahead of a lot of different risks then you would have if you've didn't, because you I think we've all heard it and especially with some of your policyholders and I've seen it in some of our buildings. Well, that spots been slippery for 10, 15 years. Right. Well, why don't you tell me for 10, 15 years ago, I would have fixed it and want to be slippery anymore. But yet over those 10, 15 years, how many different people have crossed that spot and had a little bit of a slip without a fall? But all it takes is that one person to have a catastrophic incident. And everyone says, well, I knew about it 15 years ago so.

    Peter Koch: [00:49:57] And then you scratch your head and why didn't you tell me, why don't you tell [00:50:00] me? And I think that's a whole other podcast. Like, why don't people say something? That's a whole other topic. But it's really important. And that culture of employees being able to have a conversation with the safety guy or gal or the supervisor or the manager about some of those things is really important. Like you said, it's critical and then not forgoing that information, like following up on that information, because I would expect that this is my experience, because I've had that same thing happen to me where you go to someplace, you're investigating a big slip trip and fall injury that happened and you talk to the employees and they say the same thing. Oh, yeah, it's been like that forever. Well, how come you didn't say anything?

    Patrick Dooley: [00:50:45] Absolutely. And the thing is, like as a safety professional, I think one of the biggest misconceptions that people have, especially if you look at people from an employee perspective, a safety professional isn't just a [00:51:00] pocket protector and a clipboard. You know, we're there to really help and do things and have the conversations and learn about your job. And we're excited to learn about your job. Right. So if there's challenges in flooring, if there's challenges in your how you do your work, well, we just want to know about that so that it's not nothing that's negative. It's all positive. And that's kind of the environment we live in now. But 10, 15 years ago, I don't think the safety professionals kind of looked like they were clipboards and pocket protector people and telling people no, whereas now we're like, no, but the risk of doing it is this. And the risk of not doing it is that. So there's a nice conversation that happens. And that's kind of how we landed on, you know, some of the different things that we've done inside of our store reverbs. It was a conversation that just didn't happen. So now those conversations do happen. And I think we all land [00:52:00] in a great spot and we have less things to do. And in the end run,

    Peter Koch: [00:52:03] That's pretty cool. So we're coming towards the end of the podcast here. Do you have any recommendations for companies or maybe a safety person at a company that's looking to do some refurbishment, that's looking to do some floor replacement or maybe even creating their own floor care and maintenance plan? Any recommendations?

    Patrick Dooley: [00:52:26] Yeah, I have a few. I mean, if we're looking at specifically with flooring, so know your environment. Right. So select flooring materials that that match that environment. So when you build and expand remodel facilities, make sure this little resistance meets that environment, know what the out of box stuff is. So if you're purchasing something at a Home Depot, it may not be the best thing you may have to really look at the literature that comes along with it specifications and say, is this the best flooring? Make sure your floor care and maintenance programs are up to speed. Make sure whatever you're using matches [00:53:00] the flooring material that is laid. So even mopping is great, but some flooring and says don't mop with detergents and cleaning products. It could just be water and rinse off and or people think floor care machinery you're cleaning, it's meant to clean. It doesn't need that. Machinery does not need to be cleaned. Right. So there is a preventative maintenance program for that piece of machinery. So make sure that's up to speed. Yeah. You use a dirty old mop, you put in dirty old water back on the dirty old floor, right?

    Peter Koch: [00:53:35] And you know, that's a topic we didn't even get into today and which has its own nuances. The cleaning the floor itself. And you alluded to a little bit with the calcium chloride, but the product that you choose, how you apply the product, how it interacts with the floor, there are some subtleties there that not everybody knows. And, you know that old rule of thumb, that more is better is not always where [00:54:00] you want to go when you're trying to clean your floor.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:54:02] Yeah, right. I mean, a bottle of old English is not going to work on a tile floor, right?

    Peter Koch: [00:54:06] No, not at all.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:54:08] I mean, you really have to match the cleaning product to the flooring and what's coming in. So, you know, the calcium chloride. It's a tough thing to clean. So you want to make sure you're matching the cleaning product to what the environment is, as long as it matches, as long as the manufacturer's recommendations are match as well. The other couple of things would be like make sure your MAP program is part of your floor care maintenance program. So that would include like any of your runners. And I would also expand even further to like if you have rugs in the facility, you take a look at your rugs. Is the age of deterioration of certain areas of your rugs pretty sorry? So do they need to be replaced? Do they need to be repaired? Those are things to think about. And maybe is that the right product for that type of area when you go to replace it? And then, you know, I think we just touched upon it regularly [00:55:00] review your incident reports, you know, what is happening, what are the trends? Are there things that are happening that you can't anticipate? Encourage near miss reporting? Get that leading indicator in there. Make your employees report those near misses. It may seem laborious at first because I think what ends up happening is we encourage all this leading indicator stuff and you get a ton of reports. But they're significant. They're significant to the person reporting it. So let's pay attention to it and chart it and map it and put the data to it. And then finally, from a floor care maintenance program and an employee thing, make sure folks are trained in just cleaning up spills like a from our standpoint, we have a retail store. We don't have a janitorial staff on site all the time. So they're trained in how to clean up spills, make sure that if you do have [00:56:00] a custodial staff that they're trained and respond to spills appropriately. I think those probably would hit the big beats.

    Peter Koch: [00:56:09] Yeah, I think so, too. And that last point is very interesting. You know, you would think that cleaning up a spill is a skill set that everyone should have. I mean, all of us here. And if you're not raising your hand, you're lying. All of us here have spilled something. Doesn't matter if it's a glass of milk, glass of water, whatever, that something has spilled and you've cleaned it up at home. Great. But in the workplace, you might not be dealing with it. Like how many of us have actually spilled something, maybe off the stove that's a little greasy and you're using an off the shelf cleaner to clean that up? And how many of us have gone back to that spot? And it's still a little greasy. It's not as clean as it should be because we might not have used the right cleaner. We hadn't had the skill set or the training. [00:57:00] So making sure that your staff, who aren't your custodial staff, have some understanding of what they should be using to clean up the potential things that they're going to encounter when they're in their workplace. And then your custodial staff needs to have another whole level of training so that they can deal with anything that comes in and understanding the products and understanding the process, understanding the potential risks of using this the wrong way. Understanding limitations, I think is huge.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:57:28] Right. And use and use things like the yellow, floors wet signs everywhere. Right. But if they're not used appropriately, it can actually create a hazard. Right. Because now you have people that are anticipating perceive a slip, trip or fall and there isn't. So they've changed their gait, they change their stride and now they're actually tripping. Because they're their perception is changed. So, you know, making sure that things that you do [00:58:00] are in line with the environment, what they need to be doing it use them appropriately. And I guess that's the key.

    Peter Koch: [00:58:07] One last thing I kind of want to end on here, and you said it as the second to last thing of the recommendations, reporting those near misses and especially for slips and falls. That's huge. So, you know, you've got the ability to map things. Everyone has it. If you're working in a space, you have a facility. And even if you can't draw, you can still draw a box with a couple of places where things are in your facility, so you think about all that data that you have, sorry, do you encourage people to talk about their near misses? And in a month, out of the 10 employees that you have, you have 50 near misses, one that should tell you that there's a problem inherent there. But two, what are you going to do with all that data? Well, you might not have to respond to everyone individually at first, but maybe take that data and at least put those near misses on the map and then see where they cluster. And that can open your eyes [00:59:00] to, hey, maybe we need to look more in that area, because out of those fifty twenty-seven of those reports were in this particular area. So then you can look at what's your floor care process there? What's the flooring there, what does it look like, what's the condition, what's the kind, what are the changes all of those parts for then you as the owner of the business, if you're a small company or if you have a safety person, maybe they can be the person that goes to do a little more investigating so that that mapping process as a hugely powerful tool with those lagging indicators and in even the leading indicators. So you flip it around and start looking at the hazards that are out there in your facilities, inspection and mapping those.

    Patrick Dooley: [00:59:41] And just communicating back to the person that did report it. So you have to because you want to make sure that you encourage the effort to put that in and you want them to do it again. Even if it's insignificant. But that's just a data point that you have and you could utilize [01:00:00] in the future. And, you know, I tell folks all the time, I encourage them to report anything. You know, I'd rather see my email flooded. Then no have one email at all.

    Peter Koch: [01:00:13] Because, you know, if you get one email, it's going to be that email.

    Patrick Dooley: [01:00:18] Right. And, you know, and if someone took the time to report it, it's an important it's important enough to them that I should respond and make sure that they know that we're going to work on we're going to take a look at it, that it's not just a data point. That is something that we encourage. And, you know, it leads into other things in the long run.

    Peter Koch: [01:00:39] Yeah, encouraging that communication,

    Patrick Dooley: [01:00:42] Leading indicators are just huge. And I think, you know, majority of safety professionals and in the environments we work in that we don't see enough of them. They're hard to judge. They're hard to go by. But they play a huge role in how you determine how [01:01:00] we lower risk in certain different areas and different areas of our business. So, yeah,

    Peter Koch: [01:01:05] And it's that one cool thing. You know, if you think about all the rest of the measurements that we have in business and most of the measurements we have in business are lagging indicators. It's the measurement of your income versus outflow for the monetary side of your business. How many employees do you have this month versus last month? Most of those are lagging because you're looking at a report of something that happened historically where the leading indicators are its information right now. It's that dashboard of real time information that it's enormously helpful from a safety standpoint because there's a human factor about it. Like to be able to respond in kind in time with something that's coming from another person is huge for your culture.

    Patrick Dooley: [01:01:56] Yeah. I mean, literally, the lagging indicators are the last thing that a safety person [01:02:00] wants to talk about. The Debbie Downer of a meeting. Right. I mean, you're going into a meeting and you're talking about things that have already happened, the cost to the company. You know, the things that happened to me, G.L standpoint, comp standpoint. I don't want to talk about it. I want to talk about. No, here's the things that we've done that we reported ahead of time. And these are the things that we fixed. So that way we're not injuring someone or we're not having an incident with a vehicle or PPT like this is what's happening because we're able to have these leading indicators. And I'm not standing here and talking about, you know, someone being injured because someone didn't, you know, take the grease off the floor.

    Peter Koch: [01:02:37] So that's cool. And all about kind of understanding the surface. I mean, that's what we started with today is, you know, talking about slips and falls. And there's lots of things that go into the puzzle of preventing slip and fall events. But really, where to start is understanding your service, how people interact with it, what goes on it, how it's cleaned, your maintenance program, all that stuff. Understanding the surface really gives you the best [01:03:00] idea of how to manage the other things that go towards preventing slips and falls. So that's pretty cool. And really, we've now hit the end of the podcast here today. And I really appreciate you spending some time with us, Patrick, and sharing your expertise and your experience with us. So thank you for that.

    Patrick Dooley: [01:03:19] I thank you for having me. And this has been great. And now I look forward to working with MEMIC and some of your policyholder's in the future.

    Peter Koch: [01:03:28] Yeah, I hope so. That'll be great. We will have you on again, and there's you know, like we talked about at the beginning, L.L. Bean is multifaceted when it comes to the different industries or the different safety aspects that are involved with L.L. Bean. So I'm sure we'll have you on again. Maybe we can talk fall protection or we can talk personal protective equipment or something else would be kind of cool to have a chat about.

    Patrick Dooley: [01:03:50] Awesome. I look forward to it, Peter.

    Peter Koch: [01:03:52] Very good. Well, thanks again for joining us. And to all of our listeners out there, appreciate your listening today. Today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, [01:04:00] we've been speaking about slip and fall prevention with Patrick Dooley, CSP and senior environmental health and safety specialist with L.L. Bean. If you have any questions or I'd like to hear more about a particular topic on our podcast, e-mail me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/podcast, where you can find additional resources, links to other podcasts, as well as the entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for our Safety Net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates. And if you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it if you took a minute or two to review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whichever podcast service that you found us on and subscribe. And if you've already done that, well, thanks, because it really helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing this show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Kotch reminding you that listening [01:05:00] to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good but using what you learned here is even better.

    1 hr 6 min
  • Implementing Proper Fall Protection with David Kozlowsky

    Falls in the workplace are one of the leading causes of serious injuries and fatalities. Citations around the OSHA standards for fall protection have made the top 10 most frequently cited OSHA standards for the last decade.

    Fall hazard exposures exist in almost every industry and finding the right fall protection solution for your situation is not always easy. There are many factors that should go into making the right choice.

    On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, I speak with David Kozlowsky, President and Owner of Safe Approach in Poland, Maine about his company and the approach they take with fall protection and prevention.

    Peter Koch: [00:00:04] Hello, listeners, and welcome to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast, I'm your host, Peter Koch, five thousand four hundred and twenty four. According to a February twenty sixth article in Safety and Health, that's the number of violations or citations in 2020 alone for the OSHA Fall Protection General Requirement standard for construction. And that standard sits at the top of the OSHA top 10 most frequently cited standards for the last 10 years, believe it or not. And if you looked at all the other fall protection related citations listed on the OSHA top 10 like scaffolding ladders and the fall protection training citations, you would get nearly 12000 citations related to fall protection alone for the year 2020. And if we look at beyond citations and look at injuries and how they affect people. Falls, even if you exclude falls on [00:01:00] the same level and just falls from one level to another, so falls from a height. That's one of the leading causes for serious injury and fatalities in the workplace. There are fall hazards in almost every industry or business. And personally, whether it's scaffolding, ladders, anchors, personal fall arrest systems, rope access or rescue. Fall protection training and education make up a huge part of what I do with the businesses that I work with. Well, we wanted to bring on an expert in fall protection to the podcast. So on the line with me today is David Kozlowsky, president and owner of Safe Approach in Poland, Maine. So led by David Safe Approache's team designs and builds a fall protection equipment and harnesses, anchors and lifelines, everything from that to safety netting and custom fall protection, worksite solutions. So, David, welcome to the podcast today.

    David Kozlowsky: [00:01:52] Thanks, Peter. Glad to be here.

    Peter Koch: [00:01:54] Yeah, it's fantastic to have you. You know, I've had the pleasure of working with Safe Approach during my time [00:02:00] here at MEMIC. And the team there has always been able to offer some sage advice, as well as design some custom solutions for a number of the policyholders that I've been working with. I think it's an important part of the story to get a little to know, get to know you a little bit more and about the company, because instead of jumping right into, again, right into the fall protection side of things and why it's important, I think it's important to know what your history is. So why don't you tell us a little bit about your background and the company's background and how you got to where you are today?

    David Kozlowsky: [00:02:30] Sure. Thanks, Peter. So the company was founded or conceived anyway? I would say right around 1988 ish, the previous owner, Roger, owned a business called Mobile Maintenance, which was kind of like a mobile mill writing maintenance type thing where he would go around to mills or various places and do work on site things that were difficult, either too large or too difficult to actually send out to be repaired. He would go [00:03:00] and had a truck with a lot of machine type tools and stuff and would just go around. And he was actually at a repair job in the town of Lisbon back around 1988ish. And while they were working around an open wet well either he or one of the guys there almost fell in. And so someone made the comment like, oh man, you know, somebody should put a net in this thing or something because it's 30 feet to the, you know, to the pump. And we all know what's at the bottom of a sewage pump station. So to add insult to injury, I guess so here they're like somebody should make a net for this thing or something. And so that's kind of how it was conceived. Incorporated in 1992, brought on some distributors and kind of launched the company from there. So from its very inception, the whole premise of the company was on innovation [00:04:00] and finding ways to help people work safer. As our logo says, sometimes something off the shelf or out of the box just doesn't cut it. And it's easy to have a catalog of, hey, here's my repertoire of harnesses and lanyards or whatever else I sell. But, you know, there's countless different situations that you run into in business where just something out of the box just doesn't cut it. It's not there. And so the company was conceived on that that principle and that concept. And so we've kind of gone from there since 1992. I came on to the company in 1998. I was young. I was twenty five years old. I really didn't know anything about fall protection or anything else, but spent the last 22 years kind of learning my way through it. And I really feel like I'm kind of a [00:05:00]example that the American Dream is still alive. I started at twenty five, I didn't know anything, but I was willing to learn and willing to work and started out in the shop basically getting dirty, working with my hands, learning how to make stuff, and then kind of from there graduated to turning some wrenches in the field and into sales. And then, you know, ultimately at one point basically being the general manager and kind of running the company. And now here I am. Twenty two years later and I own the business. So it's kind of a neat little story. You know, it's still can happen. People say the American dream isn't alive, but it's there. If you're willing to work hard and you're willing to learn and you're willing to pay your dues. And I think a lot of people don't know the term paying your dues anymore. If you're willing to do it, it's still there. You can do it. So here we are.

    Peter Koch: [00:05:57] Yeah, that's pretty cool because it's a great story when I [00:06:00] kind of think about it, because you back in 88, there weren't a lot of guidelines. I mean, the fall protection standard was there for OSHA and they told you a bunch of stuff. But I think there's a really great connection there where you said not every out-of-the-box solution is going to work every place. And that's a key part that I talked to policyholders all the time about, well, you know, here you're not following the standards for fall protection like you've got a fall protection exposure right there. How come you're not putting something into that? He said, well, the typical harness solution gets in the way or the horizontal lifeline solution that we could get from the Amazon catalog isn't going to work within this particular space or area. And being innovative around those fall protection solutions, I think is a key part. And it's a great way because you really had to understand what your what the exposures were and then what the company [00:07:00] needed. Not safe approach, but the company you're working with, what they needed in order to make the job not only safe but productive. And I mean,

    David Kozlowsky: [00:07:09] I think you're right, Peter. You have to really understand No. One, what OSHA's just telling you about, what are the regulations, No. One that you have to follow. And coming up with solutions within those regulations can still be out of the box without, you know, going through some of the traditional methods. You know, one of the things that we've worked on a lot is safety netting and safety netting is just one of those things that there's not a lot of stuff written on it. And you can be very creative and still follow the standards and the guidelines in the spirit of the law that they're giving you. That's where the original product came from. The Hatch ness, that was the first thing. I mean, it was taking something that was not traditionally considered a fall item and turning it into something, [00:08:00] testing it and certifying it and turning it into something. And that was in its infancy. I mean, harnessess weren't even body belts weren't outlawed until nineteen ninety six. I mean so back in, you know when I started it's like it was still kind of in its infancy regulatory wise. And so we carried that, you know, that desire to to be innovative and creative and help people find solutions to stuff, you know, all the way through to today.

    Peter Koch: [00:08:29] And it is funny how you still find some I don't call it older or maybe it's a traditional understanding about fall protection. Like you said, like body belts weren't outlawed until 1996. But you still find him someplace. You'll go different places and you'll still find people that have that particular tool in their toolbox of solutions that they'll put in place somewhere. And it doesn't really fit. So there's a lack of knowledge in some cases out there. I think OSHA has done a great job at educating [00:09:00] the businesses out there about what is appropriate. But it's a passive type of education that people need to want to get it. And in your case, too, I think I find that when someone approaches you, at least when I've worked with safe approach in the past, there's been an exchange of education. Like you're you're looking for information about what the exposures are, what the workplace looks like, where I'm willing to go. And then you're also taking that and educating me about, well, you know, the solution that you might think is going to work isn't going to work for these reasons. And here is how it fits within the standard. So that education about what's good, what's out there, what's functional, and then why is a big part about what makes safe approach pretty special and then how some of their solutions or some of your solutions work well within the workplace?

    David Kozlowsky: [00:09:55] Well, there's many different levels of education that takes [00:10:00] place when we go on a site visit. You know, as you mentioned, it's not always just, you know, what are the standards and how do I apply them to this situation? You know, and even in today's day and age, there's still a certain amount of education that takes place to get people convinced that they actually need it, that they actually should have it. I mean, I can't tell you how many times I tell people fall protection is like purchasing an insurance policy. It's one of those things that you hope you never need. And you might come to me and say, well, I've worked around this open hatch for 30 years and I've never fallen in. And I would say, well, if I was an auto insurer, you'd be a bad risk because they the numbers show you're going to probably get in an accident at some point. And if you've been here for 30 years and you haven't yet, there's a good chance you're going to. So just educating [00:11:00] people that, you know, you're not necessarily protecting for the everyday mundane tasks you're protecting for that one in a million shot, that one. And, you know, that thing that never could have happened. It just seems like, oh, this was a one in a million chance. But if that's that one time you're around an open hole and you know it's slippery and you get tangled up in a cord and you turn to look at somebody and you're doing three things at once. And next thing you know, you lose your balance and fall in. And you've done it eight thousand times and every time was perfect and you really don't think you need it. But that one time you need it, you want it to be there and educating people that just because you've done it a million times doesn't mean that there's not some value to protecting yourself.

    Peter Koch: [00:11:50] And that is a really hard lesson for some folks to swallow without having the experience of having been the victim of that particular [00:12:00] scenario. It happens both ways on my end. So I'll go into a company initially and I'll identify uncontrolled fall hazards that companies have and then on the other hand, I'll go in post accidents and do an accident analysis and help them figure out why it occurred, because someone fell because an unidentified fall hazard, something that they didn't actually take care of. If I compare those two experiences and I have the one company that hasn't had an incident occur, whether it's an injury or just a near miss, they're the ones that are typically harder to convince that you need to put a solution in place. But the ones that have had it happen and especially the ones where it's been, unfortunately, a tragedy, they're the ones that really desire a solution. But it's truly unfortunate that that is the impetus behind people being gung ho about putting a force protection solution in. And you [00:13:00] I think you describe it very well. It's like an insurance policy. So if you put it in place and you maintain it and you install it and you educate around it, then that exposure that exists because of the job and there's no other way to manage that risk. You put those fall protection tools in place. Now you're helping to prevent the tragedy from happening and that's that insurance policy. So that's a cool way of thinking about it, really is.

    David Kozlowsky: [00:13:27] That's exactly right. I mean, that's what we're trying to educate people, is that don't be the guy that calls me because you had somebody fall off something and you already have an injury. It's like let's , you know, work with this ahead of time. But we've had enough. And you can tell when that happens. I mean, there's been multiple times where in the past during our history, you can tell when you've gotten a call from somebody and you know that they had somebody fall there's an you know, an incident and now they're kind of in a panic [00:14:00] to come and, you know, put something in place. And so we just try to educate people to show them that they need it and in some cases show them that just because you opened up, you know, a catalogue and you see someone's, you know, list of harnesses and whatever, that just because you don't see that doesn't mean that there isn't a solution, that there's sometimes creative ways to come in and fix problems.

    Peter Koch: [00:14:29] Yeah, let's diverge a little bit, I think this would be an interesting time to talk about this particular topic. And let's talk a little bit about the hierarchy of controls and how it can be used to address fall protection, because I think a lot of people and maybe not some of the folks who are listening to this podcast, because, you know, if you're a safety person, if you were in charge of safety for your company, you don't always or you're not going to start at personal protective equipment as the end all be all for your fall [00:15:00] protection solution. But a lot of folks, that's what they jump to. I want a harness. I want a lanyard and I want an anchor. And when I put that in place, I'm good to go. Boom, I've checked the box. I'm safe. And that's not really where we want to start. So let's can you talk a little bit about maybe the hierarchy, like from elimination to engineering and administrative controls to fall protection and how that fits in with your process of coming up with a solution?

    David Kozlowsky: [00:15:27] Sure. I mean, when we go to a facility or go to look at a situation, you know, the hierarchy is to No. One to try to engineer out the fall to begin with. If you have a situation where there is a fall hazard, you want to try to look for solutions that engineer that out. So maybe it's a guardrail or something of that nature to take a situation where there is not an opportunity for a person to fall. So that would be at the most preferred [00:16:00] level. And you go down from there to kind of what is in the middle we call kind of a restraint type model where, OK, we can't really engineer out the fall. This isn't an application where we can, you know, put up a bunch of guardrails or put something to prevent people. But we could set up maybe some type of restraint system where you could use fall protection or PPE type equipment to prevent somebody from being able to get to the edge. And then finally, the honestly, what should be the last on the list. As you mentioned, a lot of people jump to first, but which should be last on the list, should be actual fall arrest. But then within that, once you've gone to a facility where, OK, we've ruled out the other opportunities. So we can't engineer out the fall. We can't prevent somebody from getting to the edge. We've determined that we actually do need [00:17:00] some type of fall arrest system. I would say we spend the most amount of time working within this kind of subcategory and that's educating people, the limitations of fall arrest and what you can and can't do with it and when it's appropriate to have something or not, you know, it happens all the time. I'll give you one example without naming any company names or anything. But a number of years ago, I was asked to come in and look at a situation where they had some concrete tanks that they were working on, those precast concrete tanks. And so the tanks were not overly large. They were only about seven or eight feet tall and they had to get on the top of these tanks to work on them. And they called us in and said, hey, listen, we've got this building and we want to put a cable up here so we can, you know, tie off while we're on these tanks. And after a rather long discussion, I basically [00:18:00] tried to educate them, say, listen, this isn't the right application. No. One, this building is extremely old. It's barely engineered to the snow load. I'm surprised it hasn't collapsed yet, much less attaching fall protection to the roof. But you're lucky to be maintaining the snow load in this region with this old prefab building. And you want to string a cable between them and you're only going to be eight feet off the floor. And by the time somebody falls off and the cable stretches out in the lanyard stretches out and all this happens, the person is going to hit the floor long before my system even catches you or arrest the fall. This isn't the right application. You need to do this. But that wasn't the cheapest alternative. And, you know, it was it was sad to see them go and purchase a couple of beam clamps and a cable and put it up there so that if anybody walked through, they could look up and say, [00:19:00] oh, see, we have our fall protection it's in place. We're doing what I supposed to be. But it doesn't necessarily mean it's working. And I would say, you know, going through the hierarchy is one thing, but spending time on helping people find something that's proper and works like it's supposed to is where I would definitely say we spend the majority of our time.

    Peter Koch: [00:19:25] This is one of the reasons why I liked working with you guys in the past, because. You will spend the time to do the education about a particular propered solution or proffered solution and whether or not the company decides to go with you to purchase the solution that you're recommending for them to put in place, you're still going through the process of educating them and why this is a good spot and not just, hey, here it is. This is this is what's going to work for you. Put it in place or don't put it in place. Whatever you want. You really want to see people succeed. And I think [00:20:00] just from having some conversations with you and knowing the team is there's a real desire within safe approach to not have people hit the ground. I mean, you go back to 1988 and Roger and putting that net in place, I mean, the mentality around many places would have been, well, don't get so close to the edge and you won't fall. Right. Not to think about putting a net in place and and building on that. I think that is a philosophy that kind of flows through safe approach that you really you don't want to see anybody hit the deck. So education's part of that. And determining the right solution is part of that.

    David Kozlowsky: [00:20:39] It's a tough thing to do to walk into a place and not sell somebody something because what they're wanting to do isn't going to work. It's easy to walk in and say, OK, well, I'll take your money. And here, here's a system. And meanwhile, you know, 10 years down the road, somebody [00:21:00] falls and it fails or doesn't work like it's supposed to. I mean, it's a tough thing to do to sometimes go in there and have to tell people that. But the other side of that is that we've been really successful and really good at coming in and helping people find what would work and helping people, you know, come up with solutions that sometimes are a little bit out of the ordinary or out of the box, to use a cliche. But that's you know, we've been really good at that over the years. And I think that's what's helped us succeed, is working with people to come up with those solutions.

    Peter Koch: [00:21:39] Yeah, for sure. Can you talk a little bit about some of the fall protection challenges that you've seen over the years that you talked about the one with the concrete tanks? I'm sure that there are plenty of other examples that you might be able to share with us. But I think it's important for people to see that, you know, some of the fall protection needs [00:22:00] aren't just on the construction site or aren't just in a heavy industry like oil or mills, but it exists in many different places. It could be hospitality, it could be hotels, it could be office buildings, depending on what you're doing. So could you share some of them? Maybe the fall protection challenges that people have come to you with and maybe some of the solutions that you've been able to offer?

    David Kozlowsky: [00:22:25] Sure. That's one of the unique things. You're right, Peter, about fall protection is that it really touches so many different industries. I think a lot of times people associate it with construction. So they you know, they just think, oh, here's an iron worker, you know, erecting steel. Well, obviously, he needs fall protection, but it really touches almost every industry. We have customers that range from semiconductor facilities, that make machines that make semiconductors and people think, oh, electronics, [00:23:00]why do you need full protection for that? But, you know, these are big machines, similar to what the concrete tanks were, seven, eight feet tall. They're up there on the top of them. They're building them and they're constructing them. And they're in a room, a clean room maybe where there's limited opportunities for tie off. Where can you connect to, you know, limited space. And so, you know, that's a unique situation where somebody might not expect that there would be a fall situation. But there there was there was a really unique challenge. You had a very low ceiling, very high machines, a clean room, very tight tolerances for space. These machines were packed in here. It's not like you could just be rolling guardrails around the room and, you know, put them up. So on those type of things, the stuff that we we look at, we did a job a couple of years ago for actually the U.S. Capitol in Washington, DC. They did a dome rehabilitation project and we put in a custom safety [00:24:00] net that was a safety slash work platform that actually that would suspend inside the interstitial space at the dome and allow workers to actually clean the dome. They would actually climb in it and and clean it. So, I mean, there's another example of kind of a unique situation where not many people would think of. Then there was the usual stuff. I mean, even what, you know, maybe we would consider a run of the mill, but not so run of the mill is, you know, even in construction, there's countless times that we run into where we'll have let's take the stanchion, for example, our bridge stanchions sell hundreds of them all over the country with a couple of common dials. One clamps to a steel IBM, one can bolt to concrete. Those are the two most common types of bridge girders, right? Steel and concrete. But, you know, there's we came [00:25:00] up with a solution a number of years ago for we had a contractor that has some kind of oddly shaped box beams that had no flanges on them. They weren't concrete, they were steel, and they had no way to tie off. And honestly, the solution was really something as simple as taking the stanchion that we already had the to connect Lifeline's to, and engineering and building a new kind of base that would have, you know, there would be able to adapt to this type of beam. So it could be anything from a, you know, a unique work situation to even just something as mundane as, hey, we have a different type of connection here. And everything that we've seen on the market doesn't work. And you adapt something that you have to work with this. So those are you know, those are the most common types of things that we run into,

    Peter Koch: [00:25:53] Again, thinking outside the box, but sort of inside the box. Like, you don't have to design something from scratch, but you can look [00:26:00] at a particular situation, modify what you have in order to fit the application, but still managed to fit it within the standards that you have to meet in order for it to be certified for fall protection.

    David Kozlowsky: [00:26:15] Sure. Yeah, right. Exactly.

    Peter Koch: [00:26:18] So that kind of leads to another question here. Like if someone has a fall protection problem like there, listen to this podcast and going, hey, you know, I we've been really lucky over here. And I'll give you an example. We had working with a hospitality organization that had a fairly sizable flat roof space that they had to get up there and shovel all the time here in New England when we when we have snow. So up in northern New England, we still have snow somewhere through the wintertime. And even like this year, snow has been throughout the country. Even Texas had snow this particular year. So the flat roof, they you [00:27:00] know, they didn't really see it as a fall protection hazard because for the most of the time, they were not anywhere near the edge. But the maintenance guys or the people that they hired to help with maintenance were there shoveling the roof off. So they had to be close to that particular edge all the time. And if the company sees an issue like that, they could come to you and say, hey, we need a solution. But I imagine that in your initial conversation with those guys that you need some information that would help you point in a direction for a solution. So if they're listening like, hey, you know, we've got this pretty unique challenge or maybe it's a mundane challenge, we just haven't been able to figure it out. What are some things that you need to know as the solution provider about a situation that would help you get an idea of where you might need to go

    David Kozlowsky: [00:27:56] There's a short answer and a long answer to that question. And, [00:28:00] we'll stick to somewhat the short answer for the purposes of this show. But the short answer to that is, is there when you when you start to get into this, you find that there really is no set of standard questions that you run into because each situation is is different. And, you know, I would take your example of a rooftop situation and then coming up with a solution to that, we would need to know things like, well, how big is the area that we're trying to cover? Probably the most importantly, how, you know, how many people do you want to put on the roof at one time? Because the solution for well, I want to send one guy up there to shovel off this. You know, this little hippogriff or something is different than, you know, here we have a warehouse facility and I need 30 guys up there shoveling the roof. The solutions are different for those two applications. [00:29:00] So, you know, you would want to know how many people you would have working up there. Unfortunately, you need to know how much those people weigh. That's a question nobody likes to ask. But I'm going to tell you, this comes up more often than anything these days is OSHA's limitations of, you know, the three hundred and ten pounds fall protection. And while we do have gear that's ANSI rated for higher than that, that is an important question that on. Unfortunately, we ask a lot how many people how much do they weigh and then what are they doing, how close to the edge or how close to the fall hazard are they getting? What functions are they performing while they're there? Those are types of generic questions that I think apply to most any situation. And we would do we would start there.

    Peter Koch: [00:29:52] Yeah, that's a I think it's a good list because it really does hit on all the hits on all the cylinders to getting you thinking about. All right. [00:30:00] So where what potential solution is there? Is it a restraint device? Is it truly a fall arrest system or is it an engineering solution where you can do all those will tend to lead you to one way or the other. And if you don't ask those questions and you just kind of look at through the catalog and like as the business owner going, well, it looks like this might be the solution you might put a solution in that actually adds more hazards than an appropriate solution would.

    David Kozlowsky: [00:30:32] Yeah, because those questions would lead into other questions once you've established the duties that they're performing and how many people and what they're trying to accomplish, depending on the situation, those questions lead into other questions like, well, how far we've established that, you know, we need some fall protection here. Well, how far could the person fall, you know, talking about the tank situation, if you're [00:31:00] only six feet up, off of a lower level, you know, a horizontal lifeline with a shock absorber lanyard attached to it is probably not the right solution. It might not be the right solution, even if you're 20 feet above a lower level, depending on how you're tying off and what you're doing. So those questions lead into other questions like how far is the fall distance? Are there any hazards below the fall area that we should take into consideration? And then ultimately that leads into which, again, this is way deeper than we probably have time for today. But OK, so they we've engineered a solution and a person fell off. How do we get them down? You have the fall clearance, you have all the gear you need and everything is lined up, except that there's no conceivable way of getting the person down in the amount of time that you have. So you end up saying, OK, we for that reason, we actually [00:32:00] need to engineer out the fall. You can't have someone fall here because you're never going to be able to get them down or get them out, especially in the case of, say, like a confined space entry where there's only one way in and one way out and you don't have the ability for a couple of firefighters to come in with a stretcher and put you on it and carry you out. And so the rescue and retrieval aspect of it is another important thing that we usually would hit on. Again, leading into the basic questions would lead into those depending on the situation.

    Peter Koch: [00:32:38] Let's take a quick break. In 2018, 320 of the 1008 construction related fatalities were attributed to falls. If you're listening to this podcast before May 3rd, of 2021, then you still have a chance to participate. The eighth annual national safety stand down to prevent falls and construction [00:33:00] is happening from May 3rd through the 7th of this year. If you're listening to it after you still have an opportunity, a safety stand down is a voluntary event asking employers to take a break and talk directly with their teams specifically about safety. The stand down around fall protection asks employers to talk specifically about fall hazards their team is exposed to because fall hazards exist in almost every industry. Think about ladders or roof maintenance and scaffolding. MEMIC is asking that all employers take advantage of the resources offered at www.OSHA.gov/stopfallsStanddown and talk to your team about fall hazards. Even if you're not in the construction business. If you're looking for more fall protection resources to help you educate your staff or inspect your workplace, check out the MEMIC safety director at www.MEMIC.com/WorkplaceSafety. Now [00:34:00] let's get back to today's episode.

    Peter Koch: [00:34:04] It's a really, really good point about rescue, and it's I think it's something that does not get discussed enough when we talk about fall protection. I had a client a number of years ago where I went to go to his construction client building residential homes, and they were building a house somewhere like, you know, township six, row 11. So, you know, you don't have emergency facilities really close. Like it's going to be an hour before someone can get to you if you call nine one one, if you have reception on that day, like if you're on the wrong side of the house, you're not going to get reception. So we're looking at like three and a half stories on the Walk-In basement side. And they're planning the roof process. And it's like, well, what do you have for full protection of all? We have the typical you know, they've got a rope grab and a vertical lifeline and a temporary roof anchor and which would work fine for most cases. But if he fell working by [00:35:00] himself and he fell and there was any injury at all, he's not coming down until his wife decides that. Well, it's been a little longer than normal. Maybe I should call the bar first and then I should try to find if he's still at the work site. And so from then, like a fall arrest solution was not the solution that we discussed. It was like, you really should get a piece of machinery in here to do the work that you need to do because, you know, you can get a lift up there. Of course, it's going to probably cost you a little bit more. But if you do fall, the result can be tragic and it's not really where you want to be. So that's a it's a great point. I think people miss that that rescue process because they never think that they're going to fall. They just think most of the time that the fall protection solution is there to check the box. And I'm never going to use it.

    David Kozlowsky: [00:35:48] Yes. This goes back to the insurance thing that we were talking about. Exactly. It's I'm going to check the box. It's here. Yep. I did it. So I'm protected. But you never expect that you're actually going to use it, convincing [00:36:00] people to stop thinking in terms of money, which unfortunately in private industry that I mean, that is a very important topic. You just can't get around that. There's not unlimited budgets for everything. But sometimes the consequences of a fall or a serious injury could be life and death when, you know, maybe spending just a few extra dollars on the right solution or maybe a different solution would possibly prevent that. So you're right.

    Peter Koch: [00:36:29] Yeah. And I think another part to consider, and I'm not sure if this sort of falls within your wheelhouse within Safe Approach, but training for those people who are going to be using the solution, whether it is an engineered solution and understanding the limitations or a restraint solution or a personal fall arrest solution. So training of those people that are using it is pretty key. I know I've had conversations when I go to companies that are using a fall protection solution, regardless of what it is. [00:37:00] And you talk to the employees and there's a certain level of training that OSHA requires. And I like to think that there should be a certain level of understanding for that individual who is using that so that they understand what box they have to work in

    David Kozlowsky: [00:37:15] And they should be. And that's one of the things that we that we talk about quite a bit. So part of the survey process is discussing that very thing. And this comes up very often in rooftop safety, as you were talking about earlier. So sure, we spend we spend a very high percentage of our time these days working on rooftop safety. And the certainly the two most common solutions would be some type of guardrail or some type of roof anchor or lifeline or fall arrest type apparatus. And part of the discussion we invariably have is, OK, so there's two different costs to this project. There's [00:38:00] the upfront costs, the initial costs, the capital expenditure of X amount of dollars for a full guardrail system or a roof anchor or a lifeline system. And quite often, you know, the guardrails get overlooked because it's more costly. The capital expenditure is, you know, just more expensive upfront. And people immediately want to go to. Let me just throw a couple of cans up there and cable and call it good. And part of the discussion invariably has to be the training that you were just talking about and telling the customers, say, listen, if you put the guardrails up there on the roof, they're set and forget you go up, you put them up there. You can have unlimited people. You can move around as much as you wish, and you don't have to inspect them and certify them. And there's really no training involved. Whereas if we put fall arrest up there, you're limited to a certain number of people that however many people are allowed to be on the [00:39:00] engineered into that system. You're limited to the weight of the person, because part of the engineering is the weight and the dynamic forces of the fall, you're looking at training for every person that goes up there, because we wouldn't recommend that you allow people to use an active fall arrest system without, you know, having some training and understand what you're doing. You're looking at an annual inspection every year. You're looking at recertification every five years because we don't want to just leave these up there and then hope they're going to work 10 years down the road every five years. You need some type of recertification. So there's all these things that come after the fact that may or may not make it your best solution, even though the cost may be less upfront and the training that's involved in it may be one of those things that might be a limiting factor for you, training all your users and having roof sign off sheets and just covering [00:40:00] yourself and coming up with a rescue plan.

    Peter Koch: [00:40:03] Yeah, there's a lot more to it, depending on what solution that you have. And you're right, I always look at safety being kind of one of three things that have to get managed within any company. People who have heard this podcast before have heard me talk about it. And it's not nothing new. It's safety, quality and productivity. So you have all three of those things which have to be in balance in order to be a successful company. And I joke all the time. I can make you as safe as you'll never have an injury. You'll never get anything done. Right. So I can put safety first all the time and you'll never have anything else happen because there's you're preventing that person from engaging anywhere near that particular exposure. And the exposure happens to be the job that they need to do. Like, you can't be a sewage technician without going into the hole you can't be a roofer without going up on the roof. So you [00:41:00] have to have a balance in there so that it fits. So you've got to find the solution that fits within that safety, quality and productivity triangle. I think from a different view standpoint is not putting safety at the top of the triangle, like in productivity and quality or at the base. You flip it around and you put that point at the bottom. So safety is the thing that balances productivity and quality. And if you have a good, robust safety program and think about that from the the perspective of the scenario that you just proffered there with the choice of guardrails versus a horizontal lifeline solution that you have for people. Well, the horizontal lifeline solution is good as long as you stay within your productivity demands for what it's designed for, guaranteed you will have productivity, demands that will exceed the design of that system, ike you will need more people up there or you'll have [00:42:00] to have a heavier person that gets up there. Something will exceed the design of it. So if you think about safety as as the base right, the guardrail on that particular piece will balance productivity and quality much better than that horizontal lifeline would. So having that robust safety program really fits within puts you in a better position to have a safe and healthy and productive workplace so.

    David Kozlowsky: [00:42:25] Well, trying to trying to balance risk with productivity and with investment. I keep talking about the money aspect because it seems like it comes up so often is that, you know, people want to spend money on their businesses that do one of things. They either save them time or save the money in productivity and safety. Let just be honest. Very rarely does either of those things very rarely saves you time on your project or labor. And it certainly doesn't save you money unless, you know, there was a potential [00:43:00] incident down the road. We could talk about opportunity cost for a potential accident. We talk about that all day long. But, you know, up front at least, you know, going back to the whole insurance analogy, you're spending money on something that you hope you never use. And if you're creative and use the term you just did robust with your safety program and you spend, you know, time managing it properly, it really doesn't have to have always that big of an impact on what you do. If you're being creative in spending the time to actually analyse the problem and come up with a creative solution, it doesn't always have to cost a ton of money and it doesn't always have to be so obstructive that it's limiting the job that you do and you're not. There's certain times where it does. I mean, you know, there's times where you just can't get around that. [00:44:00] But that doesn't have to be the norm. And that's partly what. We do we try to come in and listen to customers concerns, listen to the, you know, the task that they're doing, as I mentioned before, and find out who's doing what and where and see what we can do to be as seamless as possible to make it so that with as little impact on productivity and bottom line cost, come in and try to make that person safe. I mean, there is a hierarchy. I mean, let's get back to that briefly. I mean, you know, OSHA never says that there is never allowed to be any risk in a job. Certain jobs have risks. And so it's not practical to take every job that's ever out there and say, oh, there's absolutely zero risk of an injury or zero risk of anything. Even OSHA doesn't realize that otherwise there would be no such thing as fall arrest. Because, you know, quite honestly, sometimes the act of falling and getting caught can injure [00:45:00] you. I mean, there's a possibility that you can get hurt during a fall. So I think if you just manage it effectively, try to engineer out the fall whenever you can and then when you can't spend some time to manage it effectively. And I think you would find that not always does it really affect your productivity and your bottom line as much as you maybe think it does.

    Peter Koch: [00:45:24] And I think that's a good place to sort of come to a close here, because that is something that is hugely beneficial to going to an expert like yourself to talk through the different solutions and have an idea or get an idea about how a particular solution might actually affect you positively or possibly negatively, instead of just looking through the file protection catalogue and finding the, you know, fall compliance and a bucket in buying that and putting it out there, it might not be the best solution. But sometimes that's [00:46:00] the only resource that someone thinks they have. But there are other resources out there. And I think safe approach brings a good philosophy to understanding the problem and also to developing a solution. So I want to throw this question at you here as we come to a close. And this kind of goes back to what we were talking about at the beginning in your history of just coming into it cold into the fall protection process and learning and taking chances and understanding and then finally getting to the point where now you're the president and an owner of Safe Approach. So if you go back to when you started, like, what do you know now that you wish you had known when you started out from a fall protection standpoint?

    David Kozlowsky: [00:46:46] That's a really tough question. No one's ever asked me that before. I mean, my brain immediately goes to all of the knowledge that I've gleaned over the years. And I [00:47:00] don't know if I have an immediate answer to that. I would maybe have to think about it some more. But when I first started out, you know, as I went through the learning process, I know I put a lot of pressure on myself to think that I had to be the be all end all to everybody for everything, or they weren't going to call me or they weren't going to trust me with anything. And maybe I guess to answer your question, I think probably one of the biggest things I've learned is that sometimes it's OK to tell somebody, you know, I don't have a solution for that, or at least I don't have the right solution for that. Or maybe I need to go think about it for a while and come back. And just to be honest with people, not that I was ever dishonest, but it was really hard in the beginning to be OK with not knowing everything. And 22 years later, I don't know everything. [00:48:00] And every day I learn something. And it's you know, I think if you ever get to the point where you think you know everything, that you don't know anything. And so it's really just a matter of kind of I wish I could have gone back and told myself, it's OK. It's OK to learn. Yes, fall protection is important. Yes, people's lives are on the line. And yes, you definitely need to take it seriously. But it's OK to not know everything and it's OK to tell people when you don't know. And I feel like people will trust you more if you tell them that you don't know, rather than trying to pretend like you do know everything.

    Peter Koch: [00:48:37] I think that's actually great advice. And especially in the fall protection realm, you know, if you're just starting out in your own business as a contractor or you come into a safety position and you're looking at a particular situation to look at it and be OK with not knowing, but also understanding that there are experts out there that you can rely on or you can go to the help find [00:49:00] the best solution. And it might not just be one expert. It might be. A combination of maybe it's your insurance carrier and they have a safety expert with expertise around the situation that you're looking at, and maybe it's someone like yourself, David, who works for a specialized company that deals with that particular piece. So knowing where your resources are and being comfortable in that tension of yeah, I think I should know, but I don't know. And that's OK as long as I seek out the best solution that's out there.

    David Kozlowsky: [00:49:30] Smart people surround themselves with other smart people because they realize they don't know everything. They can't possibly know everything. So you try to surround yourself with people that fill in the blanks and fill in the gaps of what your skill set is. And even myself, I know my skill sets. I know what I'm good at and what I'm not good at. And I try to surround myself with people that are good at things that I'm not good at. And so, you know, if you're out there and you have a unique [00:50:00] situation or you have, you know, a tough spot that you haven't tackled because you just don't know what to do and maybe you do like I do and procrastinate rather than tackle it, then you know what? Maybe, you know, maybe just reach out to somebody for some help and say, hey, let's I need to tackle this and I don't know what to do and let somebody come in and give you a hand. And we can do that. We can give you a hand. We work with you, too. We're not we're not pushy. And we don't we don't come in and try to sell you a bunch of stuff you don't need. We just try to come in and help. We really do.

    Peter Koch: [00:50:34] That's awesome. And you set me up for this question. So where can our listeners find out more about safe approach if they do have that question?

    David Kozlowsky: [00:50:42] Sure. You can find us on the Web, www.safeapproach.com, but certainly the phone I'm old school. I like to get phone calls. So 800-471-1157. You can give us a call. You're going to go to the website. And if you're listening [00:51:00] to this podcast and you felt compelled to call me, it's probably because you need something that's not on our Web site. So it's a great resource. But if you go there and you look at the same harnesses that you see in everybody else's catalog, certainly pick up the phone, give us a call. You can email me [email protected] and we don't charge anything for we're not consultants. So I don't, you know, charge people to come out and do site surveys. Everything's related to solutions. So, you know, we don't want to come out and, you know, charge you for, you know, a site survey and give you reports and all that stuff. But if you have a genuine solution that you need help with, we don't charge anything. We come out, we'll give you give you an honest look. And if we can come up with a solution, we will present one.

    Peter Koch: [00:51:54] Perfect, thanks. That's awesome. David, I appreciate that. And I imagine you'll get a couple of calls about [00:52:00] that.

    David Kozlowsky: [00:52:01] Thanks for having me.

    Peter Koch: [00:52:01] Yeah, no problem. So that about wraps up this week's Safety Experts podcast. And David, again, I wanted to thank you for sharing your expertise with us. And I'd like to have you back at some point in time, because we've only really scratched the surface over the different types of fall protection and the requirements that are out there. And we haven't even really touched the standards that are out there either. So if you're willing, I'd love to have you back on.

    David Kozlowsky: [00:52:23] I would love to. This is a lot of fun and yes, definitely any time.

    Peter Koch: [00:52:27] Fantastic. So thanks again for joining us. And to all of our listeners out there, thank you. To today on the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast. We've been speaking about fall protection basics with David Kozlowsky, president and owner of Safe Approach in Poland, Maine. And if you have any questions about fall protection or would like to hear more about a particular topic on our podcast, email me at [email protected]. Also, check out our show notes at MEMIC.com/podcast, where you can find additional resources and links to other podcasts, as well as our [00:53:00] entire podcast archive. And while you're there, sign up for our Safety Net blog so you never miss any of our articles or safety news updates. And if you haven't done so already, I'd appreciate it if you took a minute or two to review us on Stitcher, iTunes or whichever podcast service that you found us on. And if you've already done that, thanks, because that really helps us spread the word. Please consider sharing this show with a business associate friend or family member who you think will get something out of it. And as always, thank you for the continued support. And until next time, this is Peter Koch reminding you that listening to the MEMIC Safety Experts podcast is good, but using what you learned here is even better.

    55 min
  • Distracted Driving Prevention - The Excellent Driver Dilemma with Greg LaRochelle

    Most of us want to be excellent drivers. But being one is not as easy or as common as you would think. Stats from 2019 and 2020 show more than a 20% increase in driving related fatalities, the highest it's been in more than 10 years. Many of those fatal accidents are caused by a momentary or possibly habitual lack of attention to the roadway environment. What is driving us to distraction when in the car?

    On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, I speak with Greg Larochelle, Safety Management Consultant here at MEMIC and we are going to travel down the road of the excellent driver dilemma together.

    1 hr 9 min
  • OSHA and Workplace Injury Prevention with Gary Orr

    Workplace injuries have been around as long as humans have been at work. Prior to 1970 and the promulgation of the Occupational Safety and Health Act there had never been a baseline for workplace safety in the United States. Beginning in 1971, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration or OSHA has been a key partner with business and employees for workplace safety. Health and Safety Standards development, inspections, citations, education, and training are all part of how OSHA works to keep American's safe.

    Today's guest on the podcast is Gary Orr, Health Scientist and Ergonomist with the United States Department of Labor, OSHA. Join us as we look at OSHA's history and how it has helped to make the workplace safer through rule making, enforcement, education, and partnerships.

    1 hr 12 min
  • Integrating Safety Programs with Joe Collura and Dave Darnley

    Safety integration is a term tossed around in most industries. But not all companies have it wired. Integrating safety is not just making safety THE priority, but by recognizing it as "a living breathing thing". Something that you need to feed and care for as your business changes, as exposures change, and as your employee team shifts.

    On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, I speak with Dave Darnley, Safety Management Consultant with MEMIC and Joe Collura, the Senior Operations Manager at STI-CO and dig into their story of integrating safety into an already lean manufacturing process.

    1 hr 3 min
  • Safety first? Safety third? Safety all the time, with Randy Klatt and Greg LaRochelle

    When something goes wrong in the workplace, who is responsible for the safety of the worker? Safety should be the priority, right? Whose priority? What level of priority? Should it be a higher priority for the manager or supervisor than the employee?

    Some have the opinion, that safety should not a priority at all, profit is what should drive a business. Many say, safety should be first, it should be the responsibility of the teacher, the manager, or the worker, or somewhere in between. Still others, find that safety is important but would argue who is responsible for it. And that brings us to Mike Rowe and Safety 3rd.

    On this episode of the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast, I speak with Greg Larochelle, Safety Management Consultant and Randy Klatt, Director of Region 2 Loss Control at MEMIC about the priority of safety, and where it lands in the hierarchy. Is safety really first, or is it third?

    1 hr 10 min

About MEMIC Safety Experts

From the publisher's feed

Because safety is more than just a policy, practice, or personal protective equipment, the MEMIC Safety Experts Podcast hosted by Peter Koch will interview industry leaders every two weeks on theโ€ฆ