Drew Peterson, born in 1954, was a police officer from Bolingbrook, Illinois, whose life became defined by a series of deeply troubling marriages characterized by extreme control, infidelity, and ultimately, murder. Raised by a pampering mother and a strict father, he was a popular high school track athlete who eventually pursued a career in law enforcement. Despite his arrogance and being fired for misconduct and corruption in 1985, he inexplicably managed to get his police job back in 1986.Peterson's romantic relationships followed a dark, repetitive pattern. He married his high school sweetheart, Carol Brown, in 1974. While the relationship initially seemed happy, Drew's constant need to know her whereabouts and his frequent affairs led to their divorce in 1980. He then married Vicki in 1982. As his police career and ego grew, so did his disturbing behaviors, which included planting listening devices in their home to monitor her conversations. Vicki divorced him in 1992 after catching him with another woman and enduring threats from Drew that he could dispose of her and get away with it.The woman he was caught with was Kathleen (Caitlyn) Savio, whom he married in May 1992. Like his previous relationships, this marriage deteriorated due to Drew's infidelity and surveillance. In 2001, Kathleen learned Drew was secretly seeing a 17-year-old girl named Stacy. Their divorce was finalized in October 2003, but a bitter financial settlement regarding their shared assets remained unresolved. On March 1, 2004, just weeks before their scheduled financial hearing, Kathleen was found dead in a dry bathtub with a head injury. Though initially dismissed by police and the coroner's jury as a tragic slipping accident, it was later revealed that Peterson had previously offered a man named Jeff Pasternak $25,000 to murder her to secure an alibi, an offer Drew later rescinded.Peterson's fourth wife was Stacy, the teenager he had been seeing, who was 30 years his junior. By 2007, Stacy was deeply unhappy, feeling stifled by his control over her life and studies, and began expressing a desire to leave the marriage. Crucially, she confided in her pastor that Drew had admitted to killing Kathleen to avoid the financial payout, and she feared for her own life. On October 28, 2007, Stacy vanished. Peterson claimed she ran off with another man, but her family and the police strongly suspected foul play, noting she would never abandon her children. Suspicion grew when Drew's half-brother, Thomas Murphy, confessed to helping Drew move a heavy blue barrel around the time of her disappearance, an object neighbors also witnessed. Furthermore, a fifth woman Peterson was engaged to in 2008, Christina Raines, broke off their relationship and told authorities that Drew had confessed to murdering both of his previous wives.Aware of the tightening investigation, Peterson retired early in 2007 to secure his $6,000 monthly police pension before facing any criminal charges that would revoke it. He was finally arrested in May 2009 with bail set at $20 million. On September 6, 2012, he was found guilty of Kathleen's murder and sentenced to 38 years in prison. In 2016, his time behind bars was extended by an additional 40 years after he was caught on wiretaps attempting to orchestrate a hit on James Glasgow, the prosecutor responsible for his conviction. To this day, Stacy's disappearance remains unsolved, and her body has never been found.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-pieces--6886558/support.